A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE PLOTS OFWILLIAM SHAKESPEARE’S OTHELLO AND PAULO COELHO’S THE ZAHIR
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
ht
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
.id/
/
rary
://lib
http
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
/l
://l
tp:// THE PLOTS OF WILLIAM
ttp:/
http
AhCOMPARATIVE
STUDYhtON
SHAKESPEARE’S OTHELLO AND PAULO
/
/
/
COELHO’S
THE ZAHIR ac.id/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
libr
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
rary
lib
tp://
u
rary
ry.u
ry.u
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
tp://
.id
j.ac
/
c.id
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
://
http
.id/
ac
nej.
h
2013
une
ry.
libra
h
.id/
ry.u
/
une
ry.
libra
rary
h
/
j.a
.une
://lib
http
/
/
c.id
c.id
ENGLISH
DEPARTMENT
a
a
.
.
j
j
.une
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
r
FACULTY OF/LETTERS
://lib
:/ lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h UNIVERSITY
JEMBER
.id
j.ac
/
c.id
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ac
nej.
ry
Sujud Winarno
050110191011
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
j.a
.une
Written//by:
libra
.id/
ht
c.id
:
http
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
c.id
://lib
http
y.u
://li
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
http
c.id
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
THESISbrary.
ht
j.a
.une
.id/
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
ra
THESIS
://lib
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
http
h
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
h
h
/
id/ WILLIAM
.id/ A COMPARATIVE
.id/
ON THE PLOTS
cSTUDY
c.OF
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
SHAKESPEARE’S
OTHELLO AND
PAULO
COELHO’S ary.une
.une
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
r
r
THEttZAHIR
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
id/
/
rary
lib
tp://
rary
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
c.id
j.a
.une
://lib
http
ac
nej.
id/
.
.
.
A Thesis Presented
j.acto the English Department,neFaculty
j.ac of Letters,
j.ac
e
e
n
n
u
u
u
.
to Get
ary. University as One of the
ary.
rJember
rRequirements
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
/
/
/
the Award of Sarjana
:/
:/ Sastra Degree in
:/
http
http Study
http
English
c.id
j.a
.une
id/
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
Written
p://by:
htt
h
h
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
Sujud Winarno
/
id/ 050110191011
.
c
c.id
a
a
.
.
j
j
e
e
y.un
y.un
r
r
a
a
r
r
://lib
://lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
/
/
c.id
c.id
a
a
.
.
j
j
.une ENGLISH DEPARTMENT
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
FACULTY OF
libr
://lib
://LETTERS
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
JEMBERh UNIVERSITY
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
2013
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
DEDICATION
PAGE
ht
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
ac.i
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
This thesis is profoundly
y.un dedicated to:
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
ib
://lib parents, Moch Da’im and
://lib
1. my tdearest
p://l
h tp
httpMudjiati (the late) who have
httpassionately
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
supported and given me new inspiration all the time. Eventually, I understand the
.id/
ac
nej.
.u
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
tp
/ realize the idea of
id/ respect you have given toacme
meaning of responsibility
.and
.idto
j.ac
j.
ne
/lib
ttp:/
ry.u
my
h sisters, Eka and Fitri who havehsupported me to finish this thesis;
h
3.
my Alma Mater, Faculty of Letters, Jember University.
id/
.ac.
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ii
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
a
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
j.a
.une
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
h
.id/
y.u
.id/
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/lib
ttp:/
2.
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ne
.u
.u
having an educated
rary son. Thank you for the encouragement;
rary
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
/
c.id
ary
/libr
y.u
.un
ary
/libr
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
iii
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
.id
ac
nej.
y.u
/
h
.id
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
c.id
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ht
a
nej.
ac
nej.
Nelson mandela. 2010. IN THE WORDS OF NELSON MANDELA. South Africa: Penguin
Books[South Africa][Pty] Ltd.
/
/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
1
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
rary
.id/
ac
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
://lib
http
:/
http
.id/
ry.u
h
d/
.un
.id/
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ht
d/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
y.u
c.i
c.i their bodies”.1
“Women have the right
j.awith
ej.a to decide what they want toedo
:/
http
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
MOTTO
ht
ary
/libr
tp:/
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ary
/libr
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
DECLARATION
ht
ht
d/
h
d/
.un
/
c.id
.i
c.i
I hereby declare e
that
j.acthe thesis entitled: A Comparative
ej.a Study on The Plots of
j.a
.une
.un
ttp:/
ttp:/
ttp:/
h described in this thesis have
h never been
I statehthat the analysis and the research
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
submitted for any other degree or/any publication.
/
/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e of my knowledge that .uallnesources used and any help.une
I certify to the
best
y.un
y
r
a
r
raracknowledged.
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
received in
the
preparation
of
this
thesis
have
been
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
y.u
/
ht
c.id
rary
/
rary
://lib
http
.id/
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
iv
/
c.id
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
y.u
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
h
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
rary
ry.u
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
j.a
.une
://lib
http
h
.id/
/
c.id
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
h
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
lib
tp://
ht
.id/
id/
y.u
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
The Writer,
.
Sujud
j.acWinarno
e
n
u
.
rary 050110191011
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
th
d/
Jember,
ac.iJanuary 15 2013
ac
nej.
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
id/
.ac.
nej
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ary Othello and Paulo Coelho’s
ary
ary
William Shakespeare’s
/libr
/libr The Zahir is an original writing.
/libr
tp:/
lib
tp://
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
APPROVAL
SHEET
ht
ht
h
/
/
/
d/
c.idApproved and received by
c.idExamination committee of
c.id Department, the
athe
aEnglish
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
Faculty of Letters,
Jember
y.un University on:
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
lib
lib
lib
tp://
tp://
tp://
t
t
t
h
h
h
Day
: Tuesday
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
Date
: January, 15 2013
: Faculty of Letters,
.id/ Jember University
/
c.idPlace
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
ry.uChairman,
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ry.u
/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
(……………………………….)
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
rary
/
rary
.id/
rary
ry.u
a
r
b
i
l
by
tp://
tApproved
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
v
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
.id/
.id/
y.u
h
h
Dr. Hairus
Salikin, M.Ed.
NIP 196310151989021001
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
The Dean,
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
h
h
c.id
j.a
.une
ib Cahyawati, S.S., M.Hum.://lib
lib
3.
://lErna
tp://
t
http NIP 197308371999032004
http
h
(……………………………….)
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
(……………………………….)
j.
.une
ry.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
h
ht
2. Dra. Supiastutik, M.Pd.
NIP 196605141998032001
.id/
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
d/
ac.i
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
/
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id S.S., MEIL.
Hari Supriono,
j.ac
e
n
u 197903152006041001
ry.NIP
1. Dra. Hj. Meilia Adiana,
.id/ M.Pd.
c
a
.
j
NIP 195105211981032002
ne
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
h
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h The Members:
.id/
Secretary,
h
.id
Drs. Syamsul
j.acanam M.A.
e
n
NIP 195909181988021001
ry.u
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
th
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
SUMMARY
ht
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
c.idA Comparative Study onj.The
ac.i Plots on William Shakespeare’s
ac.i Othello and Paulo ej.ac.i
.
j
e
e
Coelho’s The Zahir;
y.unSujud Winarno; 050110191011;
y.un 2005: 57 pages; English
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
lib
Department,
of Letters, Jember University.
://Faculty
://lib
://lib
http
http
http
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
Novel and play are the results of the author’s creative process. This thesis will
/
/
/
d/ Zahir. There are
about the play called
.iddiscuss
c.idOthello and a novel entitled
c.iThe
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
.unplay
y.unthe woman, in particularraasrya.un
interesting plotsra
inrythe
and the novel whichradepict
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
wife (especially).
Othello
describes
a
man
who
leaves
his
wife
because
of
the war
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
with the Turk. He has a good wife who gives him support and advice, or becomes a
/
/
id/ her husband. The play is
.id/ popular until now
c.idgood friend to share opinion
c.with
cvery
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r value still exists in real life.
r
r the
because the moral
Esther
is faithful. She is loyal./liOn
libr
://lib
://lib
:/ b
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h The Zahir has an interestingh plot that it portrays a new thing.
h It conveys a
other hand,
h
woman
as a wife who leaves her/ house to do her job as a war journalist.
Jorge is a
/
/
d
d/
i
i
.
.
c
c
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
husband who works .as
unaewriter at home and his wife .isunaewar journalist who works in.une
.id
j.ac
une
ry.
libra
ary
ary
ary
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
/
/
/
dangerous
The plot in the Zahir
to
/
:places.
:is/ simple but the story is interesting
:/
http
http
http
tp://
h
discuss.
/
/
A comparative study is.id
suitable
to find the similarities.iand
d/ the differences of
d/
ac
ac
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n more attention or concern
n
.un Studying the plot meansryto
.ugive
the plots of the tworystories.
ry.u
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
a
a
/libr
a
/libr
/libr
:/
:/ Othello and in the novelttpThe
:/ Zahir.
with the
ttpplay
httpmain sequence of events in hthe
h
Therefore, structural approach is used to focus only on the intrinsic aspects,
h
/
/
/
/
c.idespecially the plots. Furthermore,
c.id the method used in this jthesis
c.idis inductive method.
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
.une starts from the specific
y.un
yanalysis
y.unconcept moving to general
y.un
r
r
r
r
It
means
that
the
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
r
lib
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h in this thesis by library research
h and some
conclusion.
The data collection is used
printed materials, such as, dictionaries, books, articles and cybernetic sites.
id/
.ac.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
.id/
c
.ac
The results of the
show that there are nsimilarities
and differences of nej.ac
ejresearch
ej.a
n
u
u
.
.
ry
ry
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
the plots shown
in
both
the
play
and
the
novel.
Othello
serves
a
complex
plot
in
i
i
i
://l
://l
://l
nej
http
http
http
h
dramatic plot and The Zahir offers a simple plot that involves flashback plot.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
vi
/
c.id
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ht
ht
d/
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
h
d/
d/
.i Almighty and the most Merciful
All praises are due
to
acthe
ac.i Allah, without His ej.ac.i
.
.
j
j
e
e
y.unI would never be able torafinish
y.unmy study. I also thank Allah
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
r
r
guidance and/liblessing,
b
/lib
/lib
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
:/
:/
:/
ttp like to
httpme health, strength and knowledge
http in finishing this thesis. Ihwould
for giving
express my sincere gratitude to: /
.id
id/
.ac.
nej
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
.u
.u
1. Dr. Hairus Salikin,
ry.u
rary M.Ed., the Dean of Faculty
raryof Letters, Jember Universityraand
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p Head of English Department
Drs.
Tallapessy, M.A. Ph.D.,
httAlbert
httthe
http who have
.id/
h
given me a chance to start writing this thesis;
/
/
/
c 2. Dra. Meilia Adiana, M.Pd.,
c.idas my first advisor and Dra.j.aSupiastutik,
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
M.Pd.,
as
my
.
.
.
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r who have given me direct/liadvice
r
r
second advisor
and spent much time correcting
libr
://lib
:/ b
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
thish thesis;
3./ All of the Examination Committee
who have given me the opportunity
to present
/
/
.id
j.ac
une
ry.
libra
.id
my thesis;
.id/
.id
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
/li
4. All oftpthe
://li lecturers of Faculty of Letters,
://liJember University who have
:/delivered
ht
http
http
tp://
h
h
their knowledge during my study in this faculty;
/
/
/
ofdLetters
and Central Library who
been very kind
dhave
d/
c.id5. The librarians of Faculty
ac.i
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
un
in giving their rservice
some references for this
y.un and opportunity to merato
y.borrow
y.un
r
r
a
a
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
thesis;
http
http
http
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
6. The staffs of English Department who have helped me to complete the
/
/
/
.id/ administration for the thesis
c.idexamination.
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
ne
une
y.ubless
y.assistance
y.un
r
r
r
Finally may
Allah
them
all
for
their
sincere
and
endow
them
with
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h to the study
properhvirtue. At least, I do hope this thesis
will be a useful contribution
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
of literature.
id/
.ac.
nej
u
ry.
a
r
b
i
://l
.id/
u
Jember, 15th January
ary.2013
/libr
ttp:/
tp
ry.u
y.u
vii
/
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
/libr
:/
http
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
u
SUJUD WINARNO
ary.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
a
nej.
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
rary
lib
tp://
TABLE OF CONTENTS
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
/
rary
://lib
http
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
Page
i
DECLARATION PAGE...........................................................................
iv
id
.ac.
h
c.id
j.a
.une
FRONTIESPIECE ....................................................................................
/
/
id/
.ac.
id
.ac.
.id/
c
ej
ej
ej.a
DEDICATION PAGE...............................................................................
ii
n
n
n
u
u
u
.
.
.
rary
rary
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
MOTTOp.....................................................................................................
iii
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
htt
http
http
h
/
/
/
/
SHEET ................................................................................
v
.idAPPROVAL
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
SUMMARY ...............................................................................................
vi
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT........................................................................
vii
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
h
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
d/
ac.i
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
TABLE OF CONTENTS.......................................................................... viii
/
/
/
/
x
c.idLIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
CHAPTER
1.
INTRODUCTION
............................................................
1
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
libr
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h 1
1.1 The Rationale...............................................................
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
ry
libra
tp://
1.2 The Problems to Discuss.............................................
6
1.3 ThenGoals
ej. of the Study.................................................
nej.
6
1.5 The Approach to Use ..................................................
7
d/
ac.i
d/
ac.i
u
y.u
ry
arThe
ary.
r
r
b
b
1.4
Research
Method
.................................................
7/libra
i
i
l
l
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
h
2. THEORETICAL
9
/
/
dCHAPTER
id/ FRAMEWORK..................................
id/
.
.
c
c
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
2.1 The
9
y.unPrevious Researches ............................................
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
11
://lib2.2 Plot................................................................................
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
.un
tp
2.3 Comparative Literature..............................................
h
13
/
/ STUDY ON THE PLOTS
/
/
3. A COMPARATIVE
.idCHAPTER
c.id
c.id OF
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
.une SHAKESPARE’S aOTHELLO
.une AND
.une
WILLIAM
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
r
r
br
://lib PAULO COELHO’S tTHE
://liZAHIR..............................
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
16
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
d/
ac.i
ej.
.un
rary
lib
tp://
/
c.id
j.a
.une
c.i
ej.a
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
3.1 The Plot on Othello .....................................................
17
/
/
d/
c.iBeginning
c.id ........... 18
c.id
3.1.1 jThe
in Shakespare’s Othello
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
une
.
y
r
a
libr
id/
.ac.
nej
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
3.1.2 The Middle h
int Shakespare’s Othello ................
ht 22
a. Rising Action ............................................................
h
23
d/
d/
.id/
b. Climax
29
ac......................................................................
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n
y.uFalling
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
c.
Action
...........................................................
31
lib
lib
://lib
tp://
tp://
t
t
http
h
h
3.1.3 The Ending in Shakespare’s Othello ................... 33
h
3.2 The Plot on The
33
/ Zahir ................................................
/
/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
eThe Beginning in Coelho’s .The
eZahir................ 34
e
3.2.1
y.un
y un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib 3.2.2 The Middle in Coelho’s
://lib The Zahir.....................ttp37
://lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
h
.id/
y.u
tp://
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
a. Rising Action ............................................................
37
b. Climax ......................................................................
.id/
.id/
39
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
40
y.uFalling Action ...........................................................
rc.
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
/l The Zahir..................... tp41
://l
://l
3.2.3 The Ending inhCoelho’s
ttp:/
http
ht
h
3.3 The Analysis of the Similarities and the Differences
d/
ac.i
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
nej
ry
libra
tp://
53
BIBLIOGRAPHY .....................................................................................
nej.
nej.
55
ry.u
d/
.un
tp
:
http
.id/
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
h
xi
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
c.id
rary
/
c.i
c.i
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
C. The
xviii
une
y.unBiography of Paulo Coelho
y.................................
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
xxii
://lib D. The Synopsis of ThettZahir
://lib.........................................ttp
://lib
p
p
t
t
h
h
h
ry.u
a
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
//lib
:xi
http
A. The Biography of William Shakespeare...................
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
d/
ac.i
h
B. The Synopsis
xv
d/of Othello..............................................
d/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
d/
ac.i
ra
ra
APPENDICES
//lib ...........................................................................................
//lib
c.i
ej.a
.id/
ac
nej.
43
CHAPTER 4. CONCLUSION .................................................................
:
http
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
/
nej
u
u
y.u The Similarities of the Plots
r3.3.1
ry.................................
43 brary.
a
a
r
r
b
b
/li
://li
://li
p:/the
http
httof
http48
3.3.2 The Differences
Plots ................................
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
/
id
id
of the Plots
.ac. ...................................................................
.ac.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
LIST OF
ht FIGURES
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
c.id2.1 The diagram of a Dramatic
12
ac.iplot ............................................................
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n
yan.uEpisodic
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
2.2 The diagram
of
plot
...........................................................
13
lib
lib
lib
tp://
tp://
tp://
t
t
t
h
h
h
2.3 The diagram of a Flashback plot........................................................... 13
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
ry.u
32
big plots................................................................................................
51
id
.ac.
id
.ac.
.id/
c
ej
ej
ej.a
3.2 The diagram of a u
Flashback
plot...........................................................
42
n
n
n
u
u
.
.
.
ary
rary following the similarities
rand
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
3.3 The plot
of
Othello
the
differences
of
the
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
h
/ The plot of The Zahir following
/ the similarities and the differences
/
/
of
.id3.4
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
the big plots ...........................................................................................
52
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
h
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
3.1 The diagram of a Dramatic plot
/ ............................................................
/
id/
.ac.
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
/
rary
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht x
a
nej.
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
j.a
.une
lib
tp://
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
ht
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
.id/
/
rary
://lib
http
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
/l
://l
tp:// THE PLOTS OF WILLIAM
ttp:/
http
AhCOMPARATIVE
STUDYhtON
SHAKESPEARE’S OTHELLO AND PAULO
/
/
/
COELHO’S
THE ZAHIR ac.id/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
libr
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
rary
lib
tp://
u
rary
ry.u
ry.u
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
tp://
.id
j.ac
/
c.id
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
://
http
.id/
ac
nej.
h
2013
une
ry.
libra
h
.id/
ry.u
/
une
ry.
libra
rary
h
/
j.a
.une
://lib
http
/
/
c.id
c.id
ENGLISH
DEPARTMENT
a
a
.
.
j
j
.une
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
r
FACULTY OF/LETTERS
://lib
:/ lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h UNIVERSITY
JEMBER
.id
j.ac
/
c.id
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ac
nej.
ry
Sujud Winarno
050110191011
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
j.a
.une
Written//by:
libra
.id/
ht
c.id
:
http
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
c.id
://lib
http
y.u
://li
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
http
c.id
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
THESISbrary.
ht
j.a
.une
.id/
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
ra
THESIS
://lib
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
http
h
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
h
h
/
id/ WILLIAM
.id/ A COMPARATIVE
.id/
ON THE PLOTS
cSTUDY
c.OF
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
SHAKESPEARE’S
OTHELLO AND
PAULO
COELHO’S ary.une
.une
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
r
r
THEttZAHIR
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
id/
/
rary
lib
tp://
rary
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
c.id
j.a
.une
://lib
http
ac
nej.
id/
.
.
.
A Thesis Presented
j.acto the English Department,neFaculty
j.ac of Letters,
j.ac
e
e
n
n
u
u
u
.
to Get
ary. University as One of the
ary.
rJember
rRequirements
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
/
/
/
the Award of Sarjana
:/
:/ Sastra Degree in
:/
http
http Study
http
English
c.id
j.a
.une
id/
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
Written
p://by:
htt
h
h
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
Sujud Winarno
/
id/ 050110191011
.
c
c.id
a
a
.
.
j
j
e
e
y.un
y.un
r
r
a
a
r
r
://lib
://lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
/
/
c.id
c.id
a
a
.
.
j
j
.une ENGLISH DEPARTMENT
.une
y
y
r
r
a
a
r
FACULTY OF
libr
://lib
://LETTERS
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
JEMBERh UNIVERSITY
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
2013
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
DEDICATION
PAGE
ht
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
ac.i
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
This thesis is profoundly
y.un dedicated to:
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
ib
://lib parents, Moch Da’im and
://lib
1. my tdearest
p://l
h tp
httpMudjiati (the late) who have
httpassionately
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
supported and given me new inspiration all the time. Eventually, I understand the
.id/
ac
nej.
.u
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
tp
/ realize the idea of
id/ respect you have given toacme
meaning of responsibility
.and
.idto
j.ac
j.
ne
/lib
ttp:/
ry.u
my
h sisters, Eka and Fitri who havehsupported me to finish this thesis;
h
3.
my Alma Mater, Faculty of Letters, Jember University.
id/
.ac.
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ii
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
a
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
j.a
.une
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
h
.id/
y.u
.id/
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/lib
ttp:/
2.
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ne
.u
.u
having an educated
rary son. Thank you for the encouragement;
rary
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
/
c.id
ary
/libr
y.u
.un
ary
/libr
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
/
rary
lib
tp://
y.u
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
iii
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
.id
ac
nej.
y.u
/
h
.id
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
c.id
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ht
a
nej.
ac
nej.
Nelson mandela. 2010. IN THE WORDS OF NELSON MANDELA. South Africa: Penguin
Books[South Africa][Pty] Ltd.
/
/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
1
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
rary
.id/
ac
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
://lib
http
:/
http
.id/
ry.u
h
d/
.un
.id/
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ht
d/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
y.u
c.i
c.i their bodies”.1
“Women have the right
j.awith
ej.a to decide what they want toedo
:/
http
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
MOTTO
ht
ary
/libr
tp:/
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
ary
/libr
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
DECLARATION
ht
ht
d/
h
d/
.un
/
c.id
.i
c.i
I hereby declare e
that
j.acthe thesis entitled: A Comparative
ej.a Study on The Plots of
j.a
.une
.un
ttp:/
ttp:/
ttp:/
h described in this thesis have
h never been
I statehthat the analysis and the research
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
submitted for any other degree or/any publication.
/
/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e of my knowledge that .uallnesources used and any help.une
I certify to the
best
y.un
y
r
a
r
raracknowledged.
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
received in
the
preparation
of
this
thesis
have
been
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
y.u
/
ht
c.id
rary
/
rary
://lib
http
.id/
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
iv
/
c.id
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
y.u
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
h
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
rary
ry.u
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
j.a
.une
://lib
http
h
.id/
/
c.id
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
h
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
lib
tp://
ht
.id/
id/
y.u
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
The Writer,
.
Sujud
j.acWinarno
e
n
u
.
rary 050110191011
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.a
.une
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
th
d/
Jember,
ac.iJanuary 15 2013
ac
nej.
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
id/
.ac.
nej
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ary Othello and Paulo Coelho’s
ary
ary
William Shakespeare’s
/libr
/libr The Zahir is an original writing.
/libr
tp:/
lib
tp://
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
j.a
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
APPROVAL
SHEET
ht
ht
h
/
/
/
d/
c.idApproved and received by
c.idExamination committee of
c.id Department, the
athe
aEnglish
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
Faculty of Letters,
Jember
y.un University on:
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
lib
lib
lib
tp://
tp://
tp://
t
t
t
h
h
h
Day
: Tuesday
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
Date
: January, 15 2013
: Faculty of Letters,
.id/ Jember University
/
c.idPlace
a
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
ry.uChairman,
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ry.u
/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
(……………………………….)
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
.id/
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
rary
/
rary
.id/
rary
ry.u
a
r
b
i
l
by
tp://
tApproved
h
.id/
ry.u
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
v
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
h
.id/
.id/
y.u
h
h
Dr. Hairus
Salikin, M.Ed.
NIP 196310151989021001
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
The Dean,
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
h
h
c.id
j.a
.une
ib Cahyawati, S.S., M.Hum.://lib
lib
3.
://lErna
tp://
t
http NIP 197308371999032004
http
h
(……………………………….)
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
(……………………………….)
j.
.une
ry.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
h
ht
2. Dra. Supiastutik, M.Pd.
NIP 196605141998032001
.id/
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
d/
ac.i
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
/
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id S.S., MEIL.
Hari Supriono,
j.ac
e
n
u 197903152006041001
ry.NIP
1. Dra. Hj. Meilia Adiana,
.id/ M.Pd.
c
a
.
j
NIP 195105211981032002
ne
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
h
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h The Members:
.id/
Secretary,
h
.id
Drs. Syamsul
j.acanam M.A.
e
n
NIP 195909181988021001
ry.u
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
th
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
SUMMARY
ht
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
c.idA Comparative Study onj.The
ac.i Plots on William Shakespeare’s
ac.i Othello and Paulo ej.ac.i
.
j
e
e
Coelho’s The Zahir;
y.unSujud Winarno; 050110191011;
y.un 2005: 57 pages; English
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
lib
Department,
of Letters, Jember University.
://Faculty
://lib
://lib
http
http
http
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
Novel and play are the results of the author’s creative process. This thesis will
/
/
/
d/ Zahir. There are
about the play called
.iddiscuss
c.idOthello and a novel entitled
c.iThe
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
.unplay
y.unthe woman, in particularraasrya.un
interesting plotsra
inrythe
and the novel whichradepict
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
wife (especially).
Othello
describes
a
man
who
leaves
his
wife
because
of
the war
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
with the Turk. He has a good wife who gives him support and advice, or becomes a
/
/
id/ her husband. The play is
.id/ popular until now
c.idgood friend to share opinion
c.with
cvery
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r value still exists in real life.
r
r the
because the moral
Esther
is faithful. She is loyal./liOn
libr
://lib
://lib
:/ b
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h The Zahir has an interestingh plot that it portrays a new thing.
h It conveys a
other hand,
h
woman
as a wife who leaves her/ house to do her job as a war journalist.
Jorge is a
/
/
d
d/
i
i
.
.
c
c
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
husband who works .as
unaewriter at home and his wife .isunaewar journalist who works in.une
.id
j.ac
une
ry.
libra
ary
ary
ary
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
/
/
/
dangerous
The plot in the Zahir
to
/
:places.
:is/ simple but the story is interesting
:/
http
http
http
tp://
h
discuss.
/
/
A comparative study is.id
suitable
to find the similarities.iand
d/ the differences of
d/
ac
ac
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n more attention or concern
n
.un Studying the plot meansryto
.ugive
the plots of the tworystories.
ry.u
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
a
a
/libr
a
/libr
/libr
:/
:/ Othello and in the novelttpThe
:/ Zahir.
with the
ttpplay
httpmain sequence of events in hthe
h
Therefore, structural approach is used to focus only on the intrinsic aspects,
h
/
/
/
/
c.idespecially the plots. Furthermore,
c.id the method used in this jthesis
c.idis inductive method.
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
.une starts from the specific
y.un
yanalysis
y.unconcept moving to general
y.un
r
r
r
r
It
means
that
the
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
r
lib
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h in this thesis by library research
h and some
conclusion.
The data collection is used
printed materials, such as, dictionaries, books, articles and cybernetic sites.
id/
.ac.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
.id/
c
.ac
The results of the
show that there are nsimilarities
and differences of nej.ac
ejresearch
ej.a
n
u
u
.
.
ry
ry
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
the plots shown
in
both
the
play
and
the
novel.
Othello
serves
a
complex
plot
in
i
i
i
://l
://l
://l
nej
http
http
http
h
dramatic plot and The Zahir offers a simple plot that involves flashback plot.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
vi
/
c.id
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ht
ht
d/
c.id
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
h
d/
d/
.i Almighty and the most Merciful
All praises are due
to
acthe
ac.i Allah, without His ej.ac.i
.
.
j
j
e
e
y.unI would never be able torafinish
y.unmy study. I also thank Allah
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
r
r
guidance and/liblessing,
b
/lib
/lib
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
:/
:/
:/
ttp like to
httpme health, strength and knowledge
http in finishing this thesis. Ihwould
for giving
express my sincere gratitude to: /
.id
id/
.ac.
nej
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
.u
.u
1. Dr. Hairus Salikin,
ry.u
rary M.Ed., the Dean of Faculty
raryof Letters, Jember Universityraand
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p Head of English Department
Drs.
Tallapessy, M.A. Ph.D.,
httAlbert
httthe
http who have
.id/
h
given me a chance to start writing this thesis;
/
/
/
c 2. Dra. Meilia Adiana, M.Pd.,
c.idas my first advisor and Dra.j.aSupiastutik,
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
M.Pd.,
as
my
.
.
.
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
a
a
a
a
r who have given me direct/liadvice
r
r
second advisor
and spent much time correcting
libr
://lib
:/ b
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
thish thesis;
3./ All of the Examination Committee
who have given me the opportunity
to present
/
/
.id
j.ac
une
ry.
libra
.id
my thesis;
.id/
.id
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
/li
4. All oftpthe
://li lecturers of Faculty of Letters,
://liJember University who have
:/delivered
ht
http
http
tp://
h
h
their knowledge during my study in this faculty;
/
/
/
ofdLetters
and Central Library who
been very kind
dhave
d/
c.id5. The librarians of Faculty
ac.i
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
un
in giving their rservice
some references for this
y.un and opportunity to merato
y.borrow
y.un
r
r
a
a
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
thesis;
http
http
http
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
h
6. The staffs of English Department who have helped me to complete the
/
/
/
.id/ administration for the thesis
c.idexamination.
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
ne
une
y.ubless
y.assistance
y.un
r
r
r
Finally may
Allah
them
all
for
their
sincere
and
endow
them
with
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h to the study
properhvirtue. At least, I do hope this thesis
will be a useful contribution
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
of literature.
id/
.ac.
nej
u
ry.
a
r
b
i
://l
.id/
u
Jember, 15th January
ary.2013
/libr
ttp:/
tp
ry.u
y.u
vii
/
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
/libr
:/
http
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
u
SUJUD WINARNO
ary.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
a
nej.
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
y.u
y.u
rary
lib
tp://
TABLE OF CONTENTS
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
/
rary
://lib
http
/
c.id
j.a
.une
rary
://lib
http
h
Page
i
DECLARATION PAGE...........................................................................
iv
id
.ac.
h
c.id
j.a
.une
FRONTIESPIECE ....................................................................................
/
/
id/
.ac.
id
.ac.
.id/
c
ej
ej
ej.a
DEDICATION PAGE...............................................................................
ii
n
n
n
u
u
u
.
.
.
rary
rary
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
MOTTOp.....................................................................................................
iii
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
htt
http
http
h
/
/
/
/
SHEET ................................................................................
v
.idAPPROVAL
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
SUMMARY ...............................................................................................
vi
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT........................................................................
vii
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
h
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
d/
ac.i
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
j.
.une
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
TABLE OF CONTENTS.......................................................................... viii
/
/
/
/
x
c.idLIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
a
.
.
.
.
j
j
j
j
.une
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
y
r
r
r
r
CHAPTER
1.
INTRODUCTION
............................................................
1
a
a
a
a
r
r
r
libr
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
tp://
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h 1
1.1 The Rationale...............................................................
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
ry
libra
tp://
1.2 The Problems to Discuss.............................................
6
1.3 ThenGoals
ej. of the Study.................................................
nej.
6
1.5 The Approach to Use ..................................................
7
d/
ac.i
d/
ac.i
u
y.u
ry
arThe
ary.
r
r
b
b
1.4
Research
Method
.................................................
7/libra
i
i
l
l
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
h
2. THEORETICAL
9
/
/
dCHAPTER
id/ FRAMEWORK..................................
id/
.
.
c
c
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
2.1 The
9
y.unPrevious Researches ............................................
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
11
://lib2.2 Plot................................................................................
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
.un
tp
2.3 Comparative Literature..............................................
h
13
/
/ STUDY ON THE PLOTS
/
/
3. A COMPARATIVE
.idCHAPTER
c.id
c.id OF
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
.une SHAKESPARE’S aOTHELLO
.une AND
.une
WILLIAM
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
r
r
br
://lib PAULO COELHO’S tTHE
://liZAHIR..............................
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
16
h
h
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
d/
ac.i
ej.
.un
rary
lib
tp://
/
c.id
j.a
.une
c.i
ej.a
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
3.1 The Plot on Othello .....................................................
17
/
/
d/
c.iBeginning
c.id ........... 18
c.id
3.1.1 jThe
in Shakespare’s Othello
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
y.u
ht
d/
ac.i
j.
une
.
y
r
a
libr
id/
.ac.
nej
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
3.1.2 The Middle h
int Shakespare’s Othello ................
ht 22
a. Rising Action ............................................................
h
23
d/
d/
.id/
b. Climax
29
ac......................................................................
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n
y.uFalling
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
c.
Action
...........................................................
31
lib
lib
://lib
tp://
tp://
t
t
http
h
h
3.1.3 The Ending in Shakespare’s Othello ................... 33
h
3.2 The Plot on The
33
/ Zahir ................................................
/
/
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
eThe Beginning in Coelho’s .The
eZahir................ 34
e
3.2.1
y.un
y un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib 3.2.2 The Middle in Coelho’s
://lib The Zahir.....................ttp37
://lib
p
p
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
h
.id/
y.u
tp://
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
a. Rising Action ............................................................
37
b. Climax ......................................................................
.id/
.id/
39
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
40
y.uFalling Action ...........................................................
rc.
ry.u
ry.u
a
a
a
r
r
r
b
b
b
i
i
i
/l The Zahir..................... tp41
://l
://l
3.2.3 The Ending inhCoelho’s
ttp:/
http
ht
h
3.3 The Analysis of the Similarities and the Differences
d/
ac.i
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
nej
ry
libra
tp://
53
BIBLIOGRAPHY .....................................................................................
nej.
nej.
55
ry.u
d/
.un
tp
:
http
.id/
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
/
h
xi
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
c.id
rary
/
c.i
c.i
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
C. The
xviii
une
y.unBiography of Paulo Coelho
y.................................
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
xxii
://lib D. The Synopsis of ThettZahir
://lib.........................................ttp
://lib
p
p
t
t
h
h
h
ry.u
a
nej.
/
c.id
j.a
.une
//lib
:xi
http
A. The Biography of William Shakespeare...................
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ry.u
d/
ac.i
h
B. The Synopsis
xv
d/of Othello..............................................
d/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
d/
ac.i
ra
ra
APPENDICES
//lib ...........................................................................................
//lib
c.i
ej.a
.id/
ac
nej.
43
CHAPTER 4. CONCLUSION .................................................................
:
http
rary
b
i
l
/
/
:
/
nej
u
u
y.u The Similarities of the Plots
r3.3.1
ry.................................
43 brary.
a
a
r
r
b
b
/li
://li
://li
p:/the
http
httof
http48
3.3.2 The Differences
Plots ................................
d/
ac.i
j.
.une
/
id
id
of the Plots
.ac. ...................................................................
.ac.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ry.u
ry.u
h
.id/
y.u
y.u
ht
h
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
.id/
ac
nej.
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
LIST OF
ht FIGURES
ht
h
/
d/
d/
d/
c.id2.1 The diagram of a Dramatic
12
ac.iplot ............................................................
ac.i
ac.i
.
.
.
j
j
j
e
e
e
n
yan.uEpisodic
y.un
y.un
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
2.2 The diagram
of
plot
...........................................................
13
lib
lib
lib
tp://
tp://
tp://
t
t
t
h
h
h
2.3 The diagram of a Flashback plot........................................................... 13
j.a
.une
rary
lib
tp://
ry.u
32
big plots................................................................................................
51
id
.ac.
id
.ac.
.id/
c
ej
ej
ej.a
3.2 The diagram of a u
Flashback
plot...........................................................
42
n
n
n
u
u
.
.
.
ary
rary following the similarities
rand
rary
b
b
b
i
i
i
l
l
l
3.3 The plot
of
Othello
the
differences
of
the
/
/
/
/
/
/
:
:
:
http
http
http
h
/ The plot of The Zahir following
/ the similarities and the differences
/
/
of
.id3.4
c.id
c.id
c.id
a
a
a
.
.
.
j
j
j
the big plots ...........................................................................................
52
.une
.une
.une
y
y
y
r
r
r
a
a
a
r
r
r
://lib
://lib
://lib
p
p
p
t
t
t
t
t
t
h
h
h
h
nej
libra
/
/
:
p
t
3.1 The diagram of a Dramatic plot
/ ............................................................
/
id/
.ac.
h
ac
nej.
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
/
rary
.id/
ry.u
rary
://lib
http
ry.u
ry.u
ry.u
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
/
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
y.u
/
c.id
ac
nej.
y.u
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht x
a
nej.
h
.id/
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
a
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ac
nej.
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
h
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
ac
nej.
ry.u
h
.id/
ry.u
libra
/
/
:
p
t
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
h
.id/
h
.id/
ry.u
h
ac
nej.
rary
://lib
http
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
tt
/
h
c.id
j.a
.une
.id/
ac
nej.
libra
/
/
:
p
t
/
rary
://lib
http
y.u
ht
c.id
j.a
.une
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
c.id
.id/
ac
nej.
r
ibra
l
/
/
:
tp
ht
j.a
.une
lib
tp://
.id/
ac
nej.
ht
/
c.id
a
nej.
h
/
c.id
a
nej.