Schema theory in reading class

SCHEMA THEORY IN READING CLASS
Fahriany
([email protected])
UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta
ABSTRACT
Comprehension is making a sense out of text. It is a process of using
reader’s existing knowledge (schemata) to interpret texts in order to
construct meaning. Many reading experts agree that the schema theory
is one of the reasonable theories of human information processing.
Schemata, the plural of schema, are believed to be the building blocks
of cognition. This paper discusses the role of readers’ preexisting
knowledge on linguistics code as well as readers’ knowledge of the
world (schema), which for the case of reading has similar importance
of the printed words in the text. It is argued that the more non visual
information the reader posses, the less visual information is needed.
For teaching and learning, teachers are expected to use different
strategies in order to deal with different students’ preexisting
knowledge and schema to maximize students’ learning.
Key Words: schema theory, reading class

INTRODUCTION


knowledge itself, these packets of

Schema theory is a theory

knowledge embedded information

about knowledge. It is a theory

about how this knowledge is to be

about

is

used. Therefore, schemata are used

represented and about how the

by readers to make sense of text;


representation facilitates the use of

the

the knowledge in particular ways.

reader’s experiences, as well as past

According to the schema theory, all

and potential relationships.

how

knowledge

knowledge is packed into units,
called schemata. In addition to


printed

A

work

schema

evokes

has

the

some

characteristics (Rummelhart, 1980,

Fahriany


P.25). First, it has variables. These

Such

variables can be associated with

instantiated schema. It is believed

different environment instantiatio-

that

ns of schema. In a schema theory,

schemata serve as the basis of

variable

recollections.


constraints

serve

two

a

schema

the

is

irises

of

called


an

instantiated

important functions. They help the

Third, a schema is not a

identification of various aspects of

complete specification of every

situations with the variable of the

detail of situations. A schema

schema. They also help by serving

allows


as

variation

“default

values”

or

initial

room

for

irrelevant

and


creative

guesses for variable whose values

interpretation. A schema is not so

he/she has not yet observed. For

rigidly applied that no variation is

example, if he/she observes a

allowed. The schema only provides

transaction to be one of buying but

the skeleton around which the

does not notice the money, he/she


situations is interpreted.

can infer that there is money. In

Fourth, a schema is much more

this way, the schema can help

abstract than the real situation. The

making

buy schema is much more abstract

inferences

about

unobserved aspects of a situation.
Second, a schema needs to be

instantiated.

A

schema

is

an

that the actual buying event, and is
applicable to any case of buying. A
schema

should

be

viewed


as

instantiated whenever a particular

consisting of a configuration of

configuration of values is to a

sub-schema corresponding to the

bound to a particular moment in

constituents of the concept being

time. Interpreting a situation to be

represented.

an

instance

of

some

Fifth,

concepts

schemata

are

like

involves that instantiation of an

theories. Schemata contain theories

appropriate schema by associating

about the nature of reality that exist

various variables of the schema

in

with various aspects of situation.

supposed

18| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014

mind.

These
to

theories

serve

in

are
the

Schema Theory in Reading Class

construction of the interpretation of

schemata is a kind of parsing

situation during the process of

process that works with conceptual

comprehending, which is viewed

elements finding constituents and

as hypothesis testing. In reading,

sub-constituents among the data

the reader constantly evaluates

being the processed.

hypothesis about the most possible
interpretation of texts.
Sixth,

schemata

processes.

are

Schemata

are

active
like

procedures. A schema should be
viewed as a procedure the function
of which is to determine whether
and to what degree it accounts for
the pattern of observation. This is
because

schemata

underlies

concepts, and hence a schema
theory is both a prototype and
procedural

theory

of

meaning.

Finally, schemata are like parser. A
parser is a device that determines
whether a sequence of symbols
forms the legal sentence, according
to the rule of grammars, and if it
does, determines the constituent
structure of sentence. This means
the

parser

symbols

determines
in

the

THE SCHEMA THEORY IN READING CLASS

which
sequence

correspond to which constituents
of the sentence. The process of
finding and verifying appropriate

Most teaching as we know
takes place in a classroom with
thirty to forty or even more
students.

They

have

different

abilities, interests, attitudes, and
socio economic conditions. It adds
up to the so called “background,”
and “the background that each
student brings to school constitutes
a

hidden

student’s

curriculum
person,

of

the

personal

experience, and spirit” (Harris &
Sipay, 1984, p.25). All these are not
superficial differences, as every
teacher knows. In conjunction with
the students’ differences, teachers
when teaching English reading are
not trying to determine how to
teach a student one-by-one. Rather,
they look for the most effective
approach and strategies to use to
meet the needs of students in
IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014 |19

Fahriany

majority and create activities that

print stand for the familiar oral

can make the students become

symbols of speech and that these

active-participant in the classroom.

sounds, in term, represent objects,

Reading

is

a

complex

act

persons, or events about which he

requiring certain skills. Several

knows. She must learn to make

recognizable stages must be met

many associations between these

and mastered along the way from

two sets of language symbols.

the level of pre-reading to the level

Some words are made up of

of purposeful reading. The learner

letter, which represent consistently

must have many opportunities to

the sounds of the learner’s. Many

pay attention, to listen, to perceive

words in many languages do not

and

have

discriminate

forms

and

a

regular

sound-symbol

sounds, to understand directions,

correspondence. These words are

to move her eyes and her hands in

usually called the sight words of a

a left-to-right direction, to add to

language because they are best

her spoken vocabulary, and to

learned through the memorizing of

experience success in the pre-

their

reading activities, before a formal

words are learned because the

introduction to print (Thonis, 1990).

students are able to put two or

These basic skills must be revised

more smaller words together to

and maintained in order to provide

make the new word. This practice

foundation for the building of the

calls attention to the structures of

basic reading skills. The basic

words.

visual

appearance.

Some

reading skills include the skill of

Developing vocabularies is also

developing vocabulary and the

built through the use of meaning

skill of comprehending what is

clues which may be applied to

read.

unknown words and which may

Developing vocabulary begins

help pupils discover a word in a

when the students are aware that

specific context. Pictures may give

the unfamiliar written symbols of

students clues to the discovery of

20| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014

Schema Theory in Reading Class

new words. One of the most useful

must also recognize the details of

techniques for recognizing words is

persons, places, events, and time of

the application of phonics skills. In

what he reads. He/she enriches his

theory, phonics skills help students

reading by becoming aware of the

sound out and pronounce words

general feeling, mood, or emotional

which are known to them in

tone of stories. He/she must learn

speech, but unknown or unfamiliar

to appreciate motives and traits of

in print. Each learner should be

people, to see the relationships

encouraged

his/her

between circumstances and actions,

reading vocabulary by applying

and gain greater insight into people

the techniques, which work best for

and events. He/she must think

him./her

about what he reads in order to

to

build

Comprehension or understanding in every reading activity is an

interpret meaning as well as to get
the factual information.

skill

In reading activity, it is not

additional

always necessary to read every

must

be

word of a passage. Too much time

added to the abilities to organize

spent on individual words or

and to gain meaning from words or

corpuses

group of words if the reader is to

understanding of a passage. The

grasp fully the significance of what

purpose for reading sometimes

a paragraph consisting of many

determines how closely we should

sentences and select the one main

read. According to Grellet (1990),

idea to which all the sentences

the reading techniques includes,

refer.

skimming, scanning, intensive and

important

part

learning.

However,

comprehension

of
skills

each

can

destroy

ones’

After the reader is able to

extensive reading. Skimming is a

comprehend the most important

specific reading technique which is

thought is that he/she needs to be

necessary for quick and efficient

able to identify the details which

reading. Once we know what our

support the main idea. He/she

purpose is, skimming is a valuable
IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014 |21

Fahriany

procedure. Skimming through a

not quickly read the passage again

passage involves reading very fast

to look for the information you

in order to recognize main ideas

need and (7) read the answer to the

and supporting details. Although

question you have asked (Wise,

skimming should never replace

1984).

careful reading, it can save time in

Skimming which is aimed to

deciding what or what not to read,

find a specific piece of information

in getting the general content of a

such as a number or the answer of

passage,

and

the

a question is called scanning. When

authors’

main

without

scanning, we only try to locate

in

finding

point

specific information and often we

having to deal with details.
Skimming is therefore a more

do not even follow the linearity of

through activity which requires an

the passage to do so. We simply let

overall view of the text and implies

our eyes wonder over the text until

a definite

competence.

we find what we are looking for,

Some strategies to skim include:

whether it is a name, a data, or less

(1) making sure that you know

specific

what information you are looking

Scanning only means retrieving

for. Ask yourself a question and

what information is relevant to our

look for a key word; (2) moving

purpose.

reading

piece

of

information.

your eyes quickly from line to line

In reading shorter texts to

and from sentence to sentence;

extract specific information, the

(3) when you think you have found

technique of intensive reading is

what you are looking for, stop;

needed. Intensive reading usually

(4) read slowly the part of the line

involves approaching a certain text

or sentence that tells you what you

under the guidance of the teacher,

want to know; (5) think about the

or under the guidance of a task

question

to

which forces the student to pay

answer; (6) does the information

great attention to the text. The aim

you find answer the question? If

of this reading technique is to

you

were

22| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014

trying

Schema Theory in Reading Class

arrive at a profound and detailed

appealing, easy, short and varied.

understanding of the text not only

Extensive reading can be provided

of what it means, but also of how

to students who have not acquired

the

the

meaning

is

produced.

reading

habit

and

often

(1985),

daunted by books. Moreover, as

intensive reading should be done

there is no absolute divide between

in the classroom. The text should

intensive and extensive reading,

be placed in front of the students

the same text can usefully be

and teacher assigns tasks that will

employed for training in both, key

help the students to understand the

passage from it being used for

text, and then stand out of the way

intensive

while the students get to grip with

illuminating the book as a whole.

According

to

Nutall

study

and

in

turn

In line with the perspective on

the text.
Extensive reading is reading

the teaching, in this case, the

longer texts, usually for ones’ own

teaching of English reading as

pleasure. This is a fluency activity,

mastering sets of skills or as

mainly

global

involving students in a holistic

understanding. Extensive reading

process, it can be traced to the

is needed to activate reading out of

theories

class. Nuttall (1985) also stated that

discussed above. The view of

extensive reading is an out of

learning to read by mastering and

school work. Class time is always

integrating

a

in short supply and the amount of

recognition

and

reading needed to achieve fluency

sub skills is based on the bottom up

and efficiency is very great, much

belief. On the other hand, the view

greater than most students will

of teaching reading as creating

undertake it left to them.

opportunities for the students to be

In

involving

addition,

Nuttall

(models)

of

series

reading

of

word

comprehension

(1985)

involved in whole language is

considered that the materials for

based on the top-down and strong

extensive

interactive beliefs that students

reading

should

be

IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014 |23

Fahriany

learn to read through meaningful

approach

activities.

implementing the teaching and

and

strategies

in

Dealing with the beliefs about

learning activities in the classroom.

reading and the theory of reading,

Rumelhart, Mc Neil, Nuttal,

the trend of teaching language,

and Vacca

especially of teaching English in

strategies are

our country is compatible with top-

teaching of reading; they are the

down and interactive models of

hour-by-hour, day-by-day evidence

reading.

brings

of what is really happening in the

about the great impact on the

classroom. This statement implies

application of the approach in the

that

classroom, the so-called Commun-

important role in the teaching and

icative Approach. This approach

learning

stresses

the

of

teachers should master a variety of

students

in

and

strategies and techniques that they

learning activities. To activate the

will adapt to fit the needs of their

students,

create

students. Strategies and techniques

suitable circumstances and apply

are essential for every reading

strategies that can contribute the

teacher

students to actively get involved in

reading. The mastery of strategies

the activities. Thus, the use of

and techniques on the part of the

suitable approach and strategies

teacher will make them easier

will facilitate students in learning

conduct their instruction that in

to read in the classroom.

turn it will facilitate the students in

This

condition

involvement
the

teacher

teaching
must

The heart of the instructional
programs is the quality of the

(1987) indicates the
the key

strategies

play

process.

to

a

The

especially

of

the

very

effective

English

learning to read.
The teachers’ knowledge of

teaching. This implies that the

strategies

success of instructional programs

reflect

may much depend on the teachers’

teaching of reading. The teachers’

ability to master and use suitable

beliefs

24| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014

and

their
will

techniques

beliefs

about

influence

may
the
their

Schema Theory in Reading Class

strategies and activities in the

strategies is started “from the

classroom.

It

Rumelhart,

is

et

line

with

simple to the complex”. In the

(1987)

who

other

in

al.

words,

the

teaching

of

indicate that “beliefs about the

reading by applying bottom-up

teaching of reading are reflected in

strategies triggers from identifying

teachers’ strategies and actions in

and decoding features of letters to

the classroom” (p.19). If teachers

comprehending the whole text.

advocate students to talk as an

Furthermore,

the

top-down

important aspect of comprehensi -

strategies can also be applied as the

on, because it brings the students’

basis of strategies to the teaching of

background into what they are

reading. In using these strategies,

reading, his teaching activities will

teachers

then

students the story and asking them

reflect

the

top-down

or

interactive theory of reading.
of

telling

the

later learn to deal with individual

reading,

words. Sub-skills are not taught

teachers can apply the bottom-up

because they are considered to

strategies as the basis of teaching

fragmenting

strategies to beginning learners. In

making learning to read more

the case, teachers can begin by

abstract and difficult (Goodman,

showing and introducing students

1992, P.13).

the names and shapes of the letter

down strategies as the underlying

of the alphabets. Then, the students

strategy

are introduced the combination of

appears in the teaching which

the

applying

letters

English

by

to memorize the whole story and

In the teaching of reading,
especially

start

in

syllables

and

the

process

and

The use of the top-

for

teaching

pre-reading

reading
activities,

continued to words, phrases, and

during/whilst reading activities,

sentences. In teaching reading as

and post-reading activities. In the

such, the students are taught the

case, teachers start by activating the

sub-kills of reading in stages. The

students’ schemata and moving to

teaching

see the words to check and confirm

of

reading

by

these

IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014 |25

Fahriany

their prediction and hypothesis

classroom. In teaching of reading

made before.

the teachers’ beliefs about reading

In the teaching of reading

are very essential. The mastery of

nowadays, especially of English

strategies

reading, it is much more influenced

facilitate teachers to implement

by

In

their programs. In executing the

teaching reading, teachers teach

teaching in the classroom, teachers

skills directly, especially in the

can apply bottom-up, top-down

beginning, but they do not over do

and interactive strategies in order

it.

that the students can understand

interactive

In

strategies.

the

teaching-learning

activities, teachers provide plenty
of opportunities for the students to
experience the holistic nature of
reading activities by having them
read whole books. Giving more
chances to the learners in reading
activities is based on the principle
of teaching reading that indicates
reading should be thought in a way
that allows each learner to the
experience success. In other words,
the success of teaching reading the
learners

must

opportunities

be
to

given

more

participate

in

reading activities.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the success of
instructional programs depends on
the teaching-learning process in the
26| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014

and

techniques

will

the text read.
REFERENCES
Beer, T. 1997. Schema- Theoretic
Models
of
Reading:
Humanizing The Machine,
Reading Research Quarterly, 22
(3): 36-37.
Bolinger, Dwigth. 1992. Aspect of
Language. Englewood Cliffs:
Prentice Hall.
Coady, James dan Barkman, B.
1999.
Reading in a second
Languages. Rowlet: Newsbury
House.
Goodman, K.S. 1967. Reading: A
Psycholinguistic Guessing Games, Journal of the Reading
Specialist.
Grellet, F. 1990. Developing Reading
Skills: A Practical Guide to
Reading Comprehension Exerc -

Schema Theory in Reading Class

ise. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Harris, A.J., and Sipay. 1984. E.R.
How to Increase Reading Ability,
New York: Longman.
McNeil, John D. 1992. Reading
Comprehension (3rd ed). New
York:
Harpen
Collins
rd
Publishers 3 Edition.
Nuttall, Christine. 1985. Teaching
Reading
Skill
a
Foreign
Language. London: Heinemann
Educational
Books
Limited.

Thonis, E.W. 1990. Teaching Reading
to
Non-English
Speakers.
London: Macmillan.
Rumelhart, D.E., Mc Neil, John D.,
Nuttal, C., Vacca, Jo Anne L.
et al. 1987. Reading and
Learning to Read, Illinois: Scolt.
Foresman and Company.
Wise, J.H. 1984. Meaning in reading.
New York : Harcout Brace
and Co.

Rummelhart, D.E. 1980. Schemata:
The
Building
Block
of
Cognition. Spiro. In. R. J.,
Bruce, B.C. and Bsewer,
B.F.(Eds). Technical Issues in
Reading Comprehension, Perspective
from
Cognitive
Psychology,
Linguistics,
Artificials
Intelegence,
and
Education. Hillsdale, New
Jersey : Lowrence Erlbaum
Associates Publisher.

IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014 |27

Fahriany

28| IJEE, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2014