competencies german language teachers indonesia and vietnam based common european framework referenc
p-ISSN 1,412- 2595 (Cetak)
a-ISSN 2460 - 8139 (Daring)
VOTUME 15, NOMOR 1, APRIL 2016
JURNAL PENELITIAN BAHASA, SASTRA, DAN PENGAJARANNYA
peftama kali bhun 2OO2, dua lcali dahun edisi Januari dan Juli.
Selak tahun 2OO8 penode teftitan diutuh meqiadi edisi April dan
Terbit
Oktober
Penerbrt'
Fakultas 6ahas dan Seni Uniwsftas l,legett
Susunan Redaksi
l(etua
Prof Dr Burhan Nugfuntoro.
/.4.Pd.
Or Amnr Efendi. M.Si.
Prcf. Or Endang Nurharatr, tU'l.Hum.
Prof. Dr Pntomo Widodo, /n.Pd.
Dr Wiyatml lVl.Hum.
Sekrdans
Anggota
Penyunting
Yogp*ata
&ahasa :
Jolla[qns n>lpllrad
uuaqory an1fig
alarupq
edre; Ialou-laloN urplep rapuaD uespJa>la) euaruoued
Iaals
unlatusnx uv
raJsuPrl
rParx
ANn Ip
-
66 -
lg
"' nTelrrad
rurul1adg s4nv TeuV rsualratr{ tuepp rdural useqeg Ieprnl ue8uequra8ua4
8ua8ng Suaqwag
sasar{J alenpe.rS.rapun ,sluapn}S uI ase) e
:a8en8uel u8rarog e syqsq8ug Jo asn aq1 ul srorJg IerlleturuerD uounuo3
4n8ng
{.
uumaqas 4n&a7
urElep Brsauoprrl eseqPg Jrsasod r$Inrlsuo)
*
EJPqruad
ee
euvref
Z9
- 19
0g -
g0
+EJeg
rp eseqeg-uoN ue.re[e1a4
ZI - I
EletrAtr
nrnD TruapDIV sqnuanl uenduretua;
b1{naTpbutlyv
qsrvrolue{
uqre141 ed,re) mu1 uawa I afiu4ntun>l taqry lazrop urelep {r1rlocl rseurfeqaU
t
ouo rtta g o4o { O uep p nmo e' os o qua g 3 uauy' urutfi 1
(1fl) praqrl tuelsl ue8urre{ ueeure8eay EuETEM lrp1ep €o1oap1 r$fru]suo;
*
*
{.
.............r,'*!.Y.y.?.y.y.!1..i!!!.7..::..'.i.:.:.:.:..w*.y..':ffitr:ffi
eser{Bg uere[elad
ET
lerns )rrqnu
*
.........!.(.':!.?.?..'!.:'*'!>,
tt,_oz
ZZ-
*
IETuIV epleureg e{rey aqaxqa[ Ia^oN ruplep e>lr]atsg
wtuqaflHuly4ag frnyg
Ersauopul ur Eurprng
JnoI uI saJueJal+n uEruJaD Jo sura*€d aql Jo uo4ecqdurl IeJnllnf,-ssoJJ
98-91
sL_
*
pas,srrrpr4ar^pueErsauopqr:rrsraqreala'"*#;r#fr:?r:::i?fiZriln *
00I
0II
*
urerSor4 VcIIg uprefe1aqrua4 rrrelep 1o13uor1 ElvrSTsEqeI I upqTIId Tdol
uv laoH aTLrep ''5 ryn|una nElv'opopltAouowtd
""" (UggC) sa8en8uul ro, aJuaraJa5 Jo >Iromatuer{ ueadorng uowruoJ uo
tzl - 0zI
6II - lll
*
ofrSuqng UV'cL
{ruor+]alg UsIqaS n>Ing ruepp s€o1ory treseprare)
ryndng
lereg nrEC espqeg urEIEp Eqre1 uped seryerodrual
ruttafi4sa7 lpluag uep qo$snw unwotwl
respq qplo>las EMSrS {nlun rspralr"I rsualaduro;tr {ru}suox
el€trAtr
9I0Z UrdV'1,roruo11'91 arunlon
sluueru [u8uad uup'urlsu g'useqeg uullllauad
purnf
YUHJLTT
{.
3
t?.
SHPETENCIES OF GERMAN LANGUAGE TEACHERS IN INDONESIA AND
YTETNAM BASED ON COMMON EUROPEAN FRAMEWORK OF REFERENCE
FOR LANGUAGES (CEFR)
Tratorno'N ]\, AkbarK. S) dan\-e]loa\ ArF
l)Yogyakarta State University dan 2)Vietnam National University of Hanoi
email: [email protected]
Abstract
This study aims to (1) identify and compare the language competencies of German
Ianguage teachers in Lrdonesia and Vietnam, and (2) identify the factors attributable to
their competency levels. This was a qualitative descriptive study. The data were collected
by means of questionnaires. The study shows that, based on the CEF& the competencies of
German language teachers inVietnam are inthe 82level, while those of Germanlanguage
teachers in Indonesia are in the Bi[ level. The low competencies of German language
teachers in Indonesia are caused by the language attrition and the lack of opportunities
to receive language training.
Keywords: German language competencies, teachers, language training
KOMPETENSI BAHASA IERMAN GURU BAHASA IERMAN DI INDONESIA
DAN VIETNAM BERDASARKAN KERANGKA BERSAMA EROPA UNTUK
BAHASA (CEFR)
Abstrak
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk (1) mengidentifikasi dan membandingkan kompetensi
bahasa Jerman guru bahasa Jerman di Indonesia dan Vietnam, dan (2) mengidentifikasi
faktor-faktor yang mempengaruhi tingkat kompetensi tersebut. Metode yang digunakan
dalam penelitan ini adalah deskriptif kualitatif. Data diperoleh dengan kuesioner. Hasil
penelitian menunjukkan bahwa, berdasarkan CEF& guru bahasa Jerman di Vietnam
berada pada tingkatanB2, sedang guru bahasa Jerman L:rdonesia berada pada tingkat 81Penyebab rendahnya kompetensi guru bahasa Jerman Indonesia disebabkan antara lain
oleh atrisi bahasa dan kurangnya kesempatan untuk mendapatkan pelatihan/penataran
bahasa.
Kata kunci: kompetensi guru bahasa ]ermary guru, pelatihan bahasa
INTRODUCTION
At present, German is learned by
by the country itself. That is why, the
leaming conditions in each country are not
known to one another. For the success of a
better leaming process, it is necessary to
have close cooperation and collaboration
among universities in various ASEAN
member countries.
In order to support the program,
the Faculty of. Languages ind Arts,
Yogyakarta State University is conducting
approximately 50 million people in various
countries. The Southeast Asia is one area
that gives great attention to learning the
German language. In many Southeast
Asian countries, German language is
generally studied in secondary schools. So
far, the advancement of learning German
in Southeast Asia tends to be determined
128
7"*
.''rueular^
prrE Ersauopul ur sJaqJeal aSenSup-I uEuuaD
Jo sarJualadruo)
'(a{nqspunlg) Ia^al rrspq .a.l /slalal
alqprlldde llsnorlerd arD qlrm a)uppro)Jp
uI ills arp pue 'J pue ,g ,y:sarcuapduroc
;o dnor8 0 otul papl^Ip sI UgD
:sMoIIO'
sp papr^rp sr dcuanr;ord a8Bn8uel Jo
pJepuels ar{} 'IeJauaB u1 'uosrreduroc ro;
alqrssod lr a{eru o} pup ,}uaussasse s}r
sE Ilarvr se aBenBuEI ueuraD Surureal
pue Surqrpal JoJ ErJalrJJ ruJolrun pue
lenba alelrlr)e, ol palearJ tualsds u sr
U:ID'(U1ID) uawr4anuaalay nrpsrudomX
fiuusunuag paIIEr sI Udgf, ,afen8uel
ueruraD ,o lxaluoJ aql uI .dcuarcryord
a8en8uel aql alep{e^ ol papuaturuoJar
uaaq seq U{gf, ,1997 raqtualoN ruorJ
Suqrelg 'a3en8ue1ueuraD ro sratrJeal aqt
Surpnpur'sarllunol ueadorng aq1 puodaq
sJauJeal a8en8trel roJ uoqezrJepuels a{eru
o] ado.rng Jo IrJuno) aql ,o luaruaar8e
ue aruoJaq spr{ dcrlod a^oqu aql
',,lxaluo) ueadorng e tn sllls a8en8uel
u8raro; Jo luaussasse pue uorl€JrJrsselJ
Jo Ia^al aql roJ srseq aql se palrelard seq
UCA) aql teql puJ al4 Jo ruarl ur relncqred
ur luelrodrm sr srr{L, :pres o:q.lv. ,(ZIOZ)
Jourprr) dq palroddns osle sur* uortndo
srql 'uorlEJrlqJal urelqo ol suorlnlqsur
Ipuo4e)npa pue'sradolatap runlnJrJJnJ
'sraqreal 'sraureal at4 dlaq ol ,pJrql pue
la8en8uel Surd;rpnb aql ol doutu4rtal
azrr8 ro aleprlul ol ,puoJas :plrom aq]
ralo 11e suoqnll]sur Ieuor+eJnpa Suorue
uorleradooJ a+elrlrJpJ o1 lsru ,are gggS
;o qeo8 aq+ leql salels (ZOOZ) urruD
('JS:e1OOZ adornX ;o pcuno3)
/suo;Ja Jrar{} aleulpJo-oJ pue a1uryls lrel aq/s lut{}
]IaI luapuodsar aql 'sueatu rlJlt{zvr '1arra1
IVI€ saruq 7 sraMsue uTauarreB 9 raqlunu
luapuodsar ua^['lalal IV ro salJuapduroc
aqt Surdynads sluarual€ls ueual arp ol
ulau stawsue ane8 or{m s}uapuodsar 91
ara/r araql lEr{} paPa^ar Jaqun} sl }I
'1y '1arra1 JISeq lsou aql JoJ lelJaleru
aql Suualseru ]ou sraqJeal aruos flqs aJa^rvl
araql dqrvr rapuo^ sn apeu ru]s rI (arocs
099 Ielol ar{+ }o lno gI 'a'1 %9'Z)'lunotue
aql ileurs 1v\oq Jal+Ptu oN 'sluatualels aql
ur pagnads dlgrqe aq+ palrel daq+ lIaJ
quapuodsal ar{} }PrD suearu qtt'tltvt'utau
z€,r
t'a
"' ,uer4ar^ puE Ersauopul ur sJar,IJpaJ aSEnSup-I uEurJaD
runlnJrJJn) uersauopul aLIl ol Surp.rocce)
Jo sarJualadruo)
B uazrr8 il'(%g.td sramsue ylctu
{tam
18 pue '(%g'Og) sre..rsue a{Wt dpo are
araLLL
'\r61il
IlI.a.l,s1uaura1els tsoru ot
sramstrp uyau Surprtrord dq sarcualadtuoa
sropeJ atuos dq pasnec aq ueJ (1arra1
19)
parJrlenbraptrn dpo are (fsqsluapuodsar
aq] Jo JIer{ uEq} aroru }Eq} peJ aqI
'(at^g'Ot) aldoad
9I are
(1azra1 13) prepuers
ANn ar{+ ralo alarqrp
uer ot{zvr asoq} alrqm ,("t"Z.ge) aldoad 91
dpo sr (1azra179) prepuels ANn ar{+ laatu
oq/vr sluapuodsar;o raqrunu aL r .ANn dq
las pJepuels parrnbar aq1 raptm dEuaJJnJ
are sluapuodsar;o dlrroferu aql /lalal
Zg
'a'I ANn uor+eJnpf, aBen8uel ueruJaD
,o ]uauuedaq aql dq ]as sprepuels
dcualaduro) ar{l q}rm palelalJoJ sr Jaqrunu
s1n rI 'Ia^aI Ig ol luapzrrnba suo4erqqenb
aql a^eq '(%gq) sluapuodsar 00 Jo
Ielol e
'a'r 'sluapuodsar;o dlrrofeur aq]
leql prcs
aq ueJ tI ,IIe ul 11V .sla^al raq8rq ar{}
Jo
sanualaduroJ aql aaeq dpressaJau lou op
sanualadtuoJ IV aler{ oqm sluapuodsar
ar{l /pueq raq}o aql uo .sla^al ra^rol ar{l
1e aeuapdtuor aler{ os1e Ilrzvr Ia^aI If, aql
le sarJualadtuor aler{ orIM sluapuodsar
aql Surneq lou sallastuaql paraprsuoJ
sluapuodsaJ lsoru ,1a.rra1 IJ lV
'la^al zg al{}le
azre8 daqt sramsue ylctu y1fiam
W1,r (auII
ur) alqelrns aJe sra.Msue asar{l .Ia^aI IJ
ro; arualadruoJ ou llal sluapuodsar asagl
'sI teql 'stuarualels (US/) g Jo tno 9 ol
sra.l sue utaupapttord sluapuodsar aures
aql '(ff,) Ia^aI lxau alp roJ ,uorleururexa
raqlrnJ uodn 'la^al Zg le saoualaduor
11e ol ]ue]rsaq ]lal s]uapuodsar oml aq]
leql paprdralur aq ueJ lI .stawsue utau
to al ou sr aJaq] lsarcualadruoJ Ia al Zg
Srryuasardal sluaruale+s aloqm of sJa,.r sup
ltlc?u dtam ate? oqlrt sluapuodsar orrLl
aJE araq] 'd18u4saraluJ .sluarualuls arp ur
pagrcads sE sarJualaduoc aq1 peq daqr
raqlaqm tenop ur ara^r (ZZi y" l.r1$eal
le pue Zg Ia^aI acualaduroJ aql a^Eq
lou plp sallasuaql paraprsuot (%rc)
quapuodsar ;o d1r.rofetu aq] leql supaur
slttl 'ggl snsral 6IV .a,I,sJarhsup o[ aql
papaaJxa reJ sra.{,rsuu ulaup\N ltlclu{1am
,o raqrunu 1elol aql ,alualaduroJ Jo lelal
parrnbar aql sI qrrr{^r
,1aaa1
Zg
ly
'paal uotllsua4 e se pazrroSalec aq
UEJ IaAaI
Ig sgl'deur
azvt;1
.sarcuapduor
aql 8uqce1 sallasuaqt parelJap oqm asotp
aleq sluapuodsa.r aql,o 11e ]sorup ro ]soru
]eql puarl alqeuosear E sr ararn lpql panSle
paJaqunulno sluapuodsar qJns puv
aq rrEJ lr 'azr.oqe uorssnJsrp arD uo pasBg
aq] peq daql 1ou ro raqlaq.&\ luapquoJ
d1ry rou aram Jo luplrsarl llal sluapuodsar
aqt /slIIS qns aruos ro; leql palardralur
aq upJ lT slr{} dg .sramsue utau ol upql
arotu sr Ig la^al sII{l le sJa.Msue ilplu
,sr SuHr Suqsaralur
2ltam p raqrunu at11
raqlouv'Ig Ialal arualaduroc aq1 Surrrutl
lou sallasruaql paJaprsuoJ sluapuodsar
asoql ler{l sueaur T lb pue ,e€ ,9I ,gI
'1 ou quapuodsa.r are daql .sluaualels
Surpuodsalror aql ol sra.Msue al ueql
.sluawalels aql
ur pa1;nads sarcuapduoc due alpq lou
pp daqt lerll arns dlalnlosqe arauvr daql
teq] sueau q)lqm Jaaal srql;o sluarualels
Jo sulall IIe o] sJaMSue UtaU paprtrotd
dltlrlldxa or{^.r s}uapuodsar g ar, ,rrql
!ce; u1 'uoqelrseq ur aJaM Jo sarcualaduror
ou peq daqr leql \al %Ollnoqe lsar aqa
'la^al If, slq] uI acualadtuoJ aql a^uq ol
sallasruaql palraJrad sluapuodsar ;o
%00lnoqe dpo leql papnlruor aq uE) tr
'sra*rsue { ayl dpo Suqel dq auu prrls
€€r
'sluarualels aql
sralvrsue
rtrtu
aruos 'la+a1
u-r
paqrcads saroualadruoc
dtam arcanaae8 quapuodsar
Ig sFIl 1e ,uorlrppe u1
t"r
gl0z
prp daql lerD arns ara1vl sluapuodsar at{+
lPt{+ suearu qrf{1v\ u!.au paJa,^{SuE or{/V\
sluapuodsar er{} aas a1r g alqeJ uI
'sla^al raqSr-q Jo saDualaduoc
aql aAPq dlrressarau lou op salJualaduroJ
Qsarvrof IV a^pr{ oqm asoq} 'dlasrarruo3
'sla^al Ja^rol aq]ro sarJuaFdruoJ aq+ aAPq
asrnor 1o (lsaq8rq) fC lo acualadruoo
raq8rq aq+ a^eLI or{zvr asoq} ler{l sueau
srql 'la^al raq8rq aql ot Ia^al ramol e
uorl SursearJap sr sarJualaduror aql
a^eq o+ Sururelc sluapuodsal Jo raqunu
aql qJrq^.vr u1 '11arvt sE puaJ] rre; e alrhb
alerrpur elep ar{I 'PtOg1il aldoad 9'g
Ia^al IJ ro dlqrqe lsaq8rq aq+'(%Og'29)
aldoad 9la^al Zg'(%t6) aldoad I Ia^al Ig
'P/"g6) aldoad g'l :la^al ZVJo arualadruor
aler{ ol paurelD quapuodar Jaqunu arp
dq uaqt parvrollo{ 'Ia^al IV acualaduoc
aql a^er{ daq+ leu+ patets (.t,oot)
sluapuodsar 8 IIe 'aloqe 7 alqel uI
%LE
%lZ
%09',9
%06'0 0
0
lElor
ZY IV
nEaArN
9'Z Z'Z V'0 I'0
IJ
Zg
IS
aseluDrad
,,4\)tu d!'M,,
paJalAsue oqm alreuuorlsan[
uotlanluaalsqPs uo paseq
luarussassv-Jlas luapuodsa5'galqel
%€Z %Ol
%1gl %06'0 g
6't 8'0 I'0
I)
Zg
IB
r'0
a8eluacra4
0
IPlor
CV IV
nEa^IN
,u!4N,,
paJalrsue oqm alreuuorlsanQ
uollonlaaalsqps uo paseq
]uarussassV-JIaS luapuodsa5'g aIqEI
y"1e.gl "/"09.29 y"e6 "/og6 %00I
a5eluarrad
9'€9t9'18
ZS. I8 ZY
,,a [,,
ploJ,
IV
pata*tsJe oq a aJrBtruoqsan$
uot+anlaaalsqps uo pasPq
lualussassV-JIaS luapuodsa5'f alqpl
llrdv'1 rouroS'91 aumlon vuEIII]
'tueulal^ uI
dpnrs aqlJo sllnsar atp are araH'ersauopul
ur sluapuodsar aq1 ol palJnpuoJ sezvr
leq.rlr a{{'(arreuuo4sanb aql) lualunrlsul
uarrt8 aJaM sluapuodsar 11y 'suor8ar
1q31a aql ro r{Jea ruorJ ua{u} luapuodsar
auo dluo sem araql asneJaq sr srql 'ue1d
aql .Molaq re} sr qrrqM 'aldoad g dpo sr
rueular1 ur dpnls sql ul Suqedrcllred
sluapuodsar Io raqurnu aql
urBulal^ uI sJaqJual
aSunEuul uuuuaC Io salJualadruo3 'g
'sasrnoJ Surper8dn
3uqel ro Suturerl a8en8uel Sururof
aq1
ur sluapuodsar 1o uoqudrcqred rvrol aqt
/quno{ 'udllf, aq} q}I,vr aruepror)e uI
q11s aSen8uel paaordrul ol pal lou aler{
sluapuodsal ar{l pamolloJ aJE q)rqm
sasrnoJ Surper8dn dueu 'pJItII
'sPasra^o puE elsauopul uI tDoq s)Id-l
Jaqlo qlIM sprepuels asar{l areduror o1
d.ressacau os1e $ 1r 'ranazvroll 'U{ilf, Jo
Ia^aI Zg ol srarar qJIqM acualadruoc 1o
spJepuels aql aJrolular o1 dressa)au $ 1r
(>fal uoqp)npg raqreal roJ uol+nl4sul
auo se ANn Jo salenpur8 aql Jo dlrlenb
aql arnsua oI 'la^al zg leq] Molaq flqs
aram lsed aql q salenpe.r8 leql dla{Il
alrnb sr lI 'salenper8 slr ro; arualaduoc
Jo pJepuels urntururtu e las lad lou peq
luau4redaq uollernpg a8enSuel uetuJaD
aql dlsnornard pue 'o8e atuq 3uo1e alrnb
lou paqsrlqelsa uaaq lsn[ seq UiIgf, /
uED aql ler{} Sulraplsuor 'puocaS
'paqsrururp ro lsol uaq+ fl dlUqe
aq1 'au1l 3uo1 e alrnb ro; lr Surcrloerd
lou ol anp :uorlrrl+E JaIJns 1ana1 raq8rq
aql te saoualaduroJ Jlaql dqrvt sr }eq1
'zv puP IV Jo sla^al aql uI are srar{real
aql dq pasn dlapwr lsoru qyls a8ne8uel
aql 's[r{s a8en8uel ueuraD Jraql asn o}
dpreur pue dolarrap ol sraqrEal aql JoJ
saqrunl,roddo pue aceds q8noua aprrrord
lou saop osle +uawuoJrlua depdrazra
rlaql'(WrU>ruS/VhtS ro slooqJs q31q ro1
ntl
f".*
"' ruEular^ puE Ersauopu[ rr sJaqJEaI aSenSuP'l uPurJaD
se^lastualil passardxa oq,rv\ ueula.r^ ulory
s+uapuodsat %oE gt ol PerEdruoJ /la^al
sFil uI erarv\ daql lPql pelp+s sluapuodser
uersauopq %z'8e /IJ Ia^al lv
'elsauopt{
ruor, sJaqJea+ ueIuJaD arll u€ql IoAeI
zg sltll le are weulal^ tuoJJ sJar{JPal
.a8en8uel uerura9 aroru leql salPJIpuI
osIE lr'uosrreduroJ ur /ueBV'Ia al sTtll uI
aq ol paureP ureular^ urorJ sluapuodsaJ
%og'zg seararur '1ana1 srql uI araM dar{l
lEql palPls oq.&l. sluapuodsar uersauopul
aql Io %g'0€, are araq] 'zg Ia^aI
lv
'ersauopr{ ruor} asoql ueq}
Ia^al Ig sItI] lE ar€ tueular^ urorJ sJar{JEal
a8un8uel ueruJaD aJoru let{l a}PJrplJI osp
Elep asarD 'dFepu[S 'Ia^al srql uI aq 01
patels ruEularn wor, sluapuodsar %€5
sEarar{M 'la^al sql uI aq ol patuEp ot{,ryI
ersauopul ruorJ sluapuodsal %9'99 aJu
alarp /Ig IaAaT 'a'r 'lanal lxau aql +V
'ersauopul ruory asoql uEql
Ia^al sql le aJE rueular^ tuoJJ sJaqJEal
a8en8uey ueruraD aroru leql aleJlpul
PlEp asaql 'os Palels otllv\ ueular^
ruoJ; sluapuods ar "/o86 o1 pareduroc
'1azra1 snll uI aq ol parrrelJ Ersauopul
urorJ stuapuodsar %qvg '7y lazral lv
'Ia^al
sItD uI aq ol arns lou aralA ersauopul tuoJ}
sr 1r snql'lalal
sHl passed a^er{ ol palels sluapuodsaJ
srarpeal aruos ]ErD alqrssod
uersauopr.{ 1o "1o9' 96 AluoasneJaq uoqrsod
Japaq E ur aJE ruelqar1 ruoJJ sluapuodsar
arll /ersauopr{ Iuory elep qlr/lt pareduro]
'la^al sltll lP aq ol paurelf, sluapuodsor
Jo %00I leql elep aql dq palerlsuouap
sI s1r{I 'la^al dcualaduo) sg{} passed
aleq ol dlluapuuot drarr pa1e1s ru€u+al1
tuorl sluapuodsar 11V 'slIITs a8en8uel
u€uraD ur Ia^aI lsamol aql $ IV Ia^a'l
Jo
sarJualadruo)
"/"S116 "/"2'Ae %9,99
"/"g'tg y.g'96
aUpluarrad
6gn
AruanDard
9I
nrt
88r
t8
IEIOI
tv
nEa^IN
,al,pate//rslJe
oq/vr sluapuodsar uErsauopul Jo PIECI
'Ersauopul tII q)JEasar aql
Jo sllnsar ar{t II}I1VI paJedruoJ atup atuus
aql lu puP Ia^al r{JEa uo pasEq passmslp
aq IIIM paurelqo Elep ar{l 'acualadtuoc
FuorssaloJd rraq] Jo, ruerqar1 uI sJarpeal
a8en8uel ueruraD 1o uoqdacrad aq1 ;o
arn+crd rarealr e aprrrord o1 'Qsaq31q aq1)
Zf, pue 'I) 'Zg'Iy'ZY o1 '(1sarvro1 aql)
IV uroJ1 's1ala1 xIS Io slsrsuoJ a8en8uel
ro1 Ui1ilf, o1Surprocce a8en8uel ueruraD
ur dcuarcrlord 1o Ialal Jo luaruaJnseatu
aql 'azroqe pauoquaru uaaq seq sV
EIsauoPuI PUE
rar{JEaI
uI
salJuafaduro3
uruulal1
atunSuul ueruraD yo uospuduo3 'J
'arreuuoEsanb
aql uI sluaua+els aq] puelsJapun lou
plp ro ]uellsaq ara^t otlrvr sluapuodsar;o
raqrunu aq1 ralearS aql'(If,) arualaduroc
leql saleJrpul elep
arfl'(%I€) aldoad 9'Z Ia^al I) pue '(%lZ)
aldoad Z'Z p^al Zg,'(%Og'g) uosrad 7'6
Ia^aI Ig '(%O'd uosrad I'0Ia aI ZY'(%O)
uosrad 0 Ia^al IV :s/'rolloJ se are slrelap
ar{I 'alrerruorlsanb aql uI s}uaura}Els aql
pue+sJapun 1ou lq8nu Jo InI+qnop ara^\
daql sueau qrrq..v\ 'ltplu dyam paletu,sue
oqm Euapuodsar aql smot{s 9 aIqPI
'luaualPls aql uI
Jo sla^al aql raq8rq aq+
payrcads sarcualadtuoJ q?ns Surrreq
lou;o
%o€'gn %0q29 %€,6 %86 %00I a;eluaf,rad
9'L
9'€
nll
tfl
50I
08
zY
IV
i{ruanbarg
,?r, paJaMsue
or{rvr s}uapuodsar asarueu}al1 Jo EI€CI
9€r
uosrad I'0 Ia^aI W' (%6 duosrad I'0 Ia^aI
Zv'(%O) uosrad 0la^al IV:smo[o] sP arp
qr-epp aql 'aneuuoqsanb aqlul luaualels
arp uI pagrcads lcualadruoJ aql aAErI +ou
*"t
gl0z Ilrdv'1 rouoS'91 aurnlon
fl e ua zua p dwolrya ilS
awllpunw 'zl0z 'E>lirn 'tunr3
n 8 u4c u tdsqr
s
a
'ral4al I 'g'{ SeFan
:UEBtlnlS'l.psflapqtamuaga)' 166l
'rauraM 3ue311o1,4'ranes
28
lnurlaH
tcntc
^'HdVUCOIIflg
'roueH ro dlrsJa^run IPuorlBN ruet4ar^
qll^r r{Jruasar aAqeJoqEIIoJ srl{l Sulpun,
ro, ANn suv pue saSenSuel ro d+ImEc
ar{l ol apn1rler8 aJaJurs rraql ssardxa o}
a{rl plno.&r sJatpJeasal ar{l 'aJoJaJaqI
'(,trud dlrsrarrrun alels EtroledSol'slry
pue sa8en8ueT ro dlpceg aL{} dq papunJ
qJJeasaJ aArleJoqelloJ Ieuorleuralur
ue ,o llnsar aql sl dpnls srql
SINIII IIID OIIIMONXJV
'sarcualadruo) 1en+Je
q}Ilvr
ar{}
aJuepJoJJe ur aJe dcuarcrlord
pqdarrad rraql lou ro Jaqlaq.rvr tuJIJuoJ ol
rapJo ur ]sa1 dcuarcrlord a8en8uel uEuJaD
aql Jo ruJoI aql ur r{Dreasar raqun, e
aler{ ol ra+laq aq ppolvr lI'sarJuaFduoc
a8en8uel uerrrraD Jraql Sururaluol
sluapuodsa.r dq uarrr8 uorldarrad ;o
urro, arp ur 1sn[ ara.M e]ep paraqlu8 aq1
'dlluanbasuo3 ']uarunJlsur lsal e lou
'alreuuorlsanb uaprrrvr e Jo uJoJ aql ur lsnf
sem aJaq pasn poqlaur darrrns aql dlaru€u
'suorlelrturl aruos suq dpnls srql
'rueu+ar^ puE ersauopr{ urory
sJar{JEa} a8en8uel uEruJaD ro1 Surlaaru
1euoqeuJalur luro[ e azrue8ro o1 d.ressacau
sI lI 'prlt{I 'sJaqJEa} a8en8uel ueruJaD
roJ U{ilf, ar{} o} ra1ar +eq} s8ururerl
a8en8uel alrsualur aprnord ol spaau
luaruuJalo8 aq1 'puorag 'dlrsramun alels
elre>1ed3o1 ur pue roueH;o dlrsrarrrull
IeuorleN tueular1 ur ssarord Surureal
a8en8uel ueurJaD aql Sururacuoc dpnls
aur.qeredtuo) e spaau ll lsrlC :dpn+s sIU+
Jo sllnsar arp ruory suoqsaSSns awos
'peoJqe se flam se Prsauopul
s)Id'l
rarDo rllr1vl spJEpuels asaql
areduror ol dressarau os1e sI lI /JaAaMoH
ssorJE
'Zg Ia^aI 'a'I 'UCg) aql ol sralar q)Iqrvr
acualaduroJ Jo spJepuels aql aJJofurcr o+
dressacau
v[glll
q lI ()Id-l) uo4ecnpg rar{real
alntqsul aLIl Jo salenper8 aql Jo d11pnb
aql aJnsua oI 'Ia^al parrnbar luaJal aql
anarqre lou plp lsed aql ur salenper8 reql
alqrssod sr 1r 'acualadtuoo Jo pJepue+s
runurruru e 1as dllplldxa 1ou peq ANn
luarulredaq uoqpJnpf, a8en8uel ueuJaD
aqt dlsnomard pue paqs{qe}sa uaaq }sn[
seq (UCiIf,) aruara;a5 ,o {rorratuerd
ueadorng uoruruoJ aql aJurs'd1p4.ll
'paqsltrlurp
ro lsol uaq] sr ru)s ar{} ailperd Jo {rel aql
ol anp leq] Sulueaur 'uorlrrpe paraJJns
ll a^oqe IaAaI aql le arualadruor dqrvr sr
leqJ 'zv pue IV sla^al aql le asoql arE
sJaq)eal dq pasn dlaprrvr lsoru are leql
s11DIs ar{I 'passassod dlpnlce anuq daql
q11s a8en8uel raq8rq ar{} asn lseal le ro
dolarrap ol srar{)ea} aql ro, sa4runlroddo
puu a8ualleqc qSnoua aprzrord lou saoP
ralunoJua daql luauuorrlua dpep aq1
.(VW/XftS/VftS
Jo runlnrrrrnr aql ol
Surprorre) ZV pue IV sla aI 1u a8en8uel
trururagrpeal dpo dleraua8 qooqcs q8rq
ur qJeal oqm sluapuodsar aql asneJaq
Jo
u SuuJmJo
qnoua
np $fiUaA)
luazuaqadwo44ca ilg uaua
uoqrrlle a8enBuel sr ararp 'dlpuocag
.a.I
.Ig
Ia^aI lE
'raltol Ialal auo sI Elsauopul uI sJaqJeal
a8en8uel ueruraDro leql alq^\ Zgla^al lE
sr rrrul4ar1 ur s.raqrual a8en8uel ueuuag ;o
sarcuapduroJ Jo Ia al aql 'd1+srl{ :dpnls sp1l
tuory wv\eJp aq IreJ suorsnlJuoJ IeJaAas
'Ersauopr{ ut sraqJual ueurrag
NOISNl)NOJ
'Ig,o
Ia^aI aql lE are elsauopt{
ruo4 sluapuodsa.r agqm Ia^al Zg le aJE
urpular1 uoJJ sluapuodsar 1eq1 Surrvroqs
elep aql tuory uneJp sr uorsnlJuoJ sIqJ
'ersauopul ur sJaq)ea1 a8en8uul upruJaD
lerll sarruataduror a8en8uel ur ratISIq Ia al
auo are rueular1 ur sJaqJpal a8en8uel
upruJaD leql des ueJ alr'a8elazre ug
'Ersauopul tuorJ sJaqJeal
aq+
ueql
uEuJaD
Ia^al sr-ql +E aq ol paunep
tueular1 ruoJJ sJaqJual a8en8uel ueruJaD
arou terD s^ror{s osle lI 'Ia^al slq} uI aq ol
9€r
"' rueular1 prrp plsauoprrl rr sJalpeal a8en8uel uEuJaD 1o sarcualadr'uo3
E' ol;.' lautno [-t{l' puut pslnacl
ut aln#+sul-atfiaog fip uastmp4cuilS
uap m suauqafiuan{aA uaqtsrudomX
uauosunua) sap ryppptpotnx. tap
'
'uge1ed3otr rra8aN
s€lrsra^rul.I leuas e{nqral lEdpu
eped rusag nrnD r.reqmln8ua4 olepTd
'uuun[ ustqag nm) suflpuorsalot4
uap
)p+sflau./7,g'll0z'oruolErd'opoplM
IBuorsEN rrolrprpuad rualsrs Suelual
€002 unqel 0Z roIrIoN Suepun-Suepun
g:ppunorrE L0E9Et LLlz
/rvrarmop/urol lsanbord'qcreas//: d$q
palarrta5' O6L- tgl G,)69'8urycoa7
a?an?ua7'1redu1 pue uorldacaS
'ulStrO'asodrn4 !ua1uo3 :sa8un8uel
7Z€ I
roI aJuaralau Jo {Jo/l^auPJd
ueadorng uoruruo3 aq1-,'9002'q'allll'l
L€I
ZOOZI
Sunzqaswn'ZOOZ'pru8appll'rauqc4;1
6900606090 6r lgzosI tl0r' 0 l/8rc
'rop'xp/i:dnq :IoP'€9-I9' 57'sct\sm&urT
palddy lo mana>J pnuuv' $aC rrlt PUV
'&utuna7' luawssassv fict1o 4 aEtnSwT
uaadomX'6002 'N 'alpleg rt ''N 'sauo{
'ornf,
:
08'?9'uallas zlE' 0-90a29-l€9-€-816
N8SI'(9r'lqclrra unuatPerdsPuard
urnrnbollo;) 8ue1 :lE la 'W'u
un1{uerd' fl #ua8 onqaqs8uqsra7
tnz sllapouzualadwoa sauta
Sunl4nmquX'uaqcxlSuX saq n,un7
a-ISSN 2460 - 8139 (Daring)
VOTUME 15, NOMOR 1, APRIL 2016
JURNAL PENELITIAN BAHASA, SASTRA, DAN PENGAJARANNYA
peftama kali bhun 2OO2, dua lcali dahun edisi Januari dan Juli.
Selak tahun 2OO8 penode teftitan diutuh meqiadi edisi April dan
Terbit
Oktober
Penerbrt'
Fakultas 6ahas dan Seni Uniwsftas l,legett
Susunan Redaksi
l(etua
Prof Dr Burhan Nugfuntoro.
/.4.Pd.
Or Amnr Efendi. M.Si.
Prcf. Or Endang Nurharatr, tU'l.Hum.
Prof. Dr Pntomo Widodo, /n.Pd.
Dr Wiyatml lVl.Hum.
Sekrdans
Anggota
Penyunting
Yogp*ata
&ahasa :
Jolla[qns n>lpllrad
uuaqory an1fig
alarupq
edre; Ialou-laloN urplep rapuaD uespJa>la) euaruoued
Iaals
unlatusnx uv
raJsuPrl
rParx
ANn Ip
-
66 -
lg
"' nTelrrad
rurul1adg s4nv TeuV rsualratr{ tuepp rdural useqeg Ieprnl ue8uequra8ua4
8ua8ng Suaqwag
sasar{J alenpe.rS.rapun ,sluapn}S uI ase) e
:a8en8uel u8rarog e syqsq8ug Jo asn aq1 ul srorJg IerlleturuerD uounuo3
4n8ng
{.
uumaqas 4n&a7
urElep Brsauoprrl eseqPg Jrsasod r$Inrlsuo)
*
EJPqruad
ee
euvref
Z9
- 19
0g -
g0
+EJeg
rp eseqeg-uoN ue.re[e1a4
ZI - I
EletrAtr
nrnD TruapDIV sqnuanl uenduretua;
b1{naTpbutlyv
qsrvrolue{
uqre141 ed,re) mu1 uawa I afiu4ntun>l taqry lazrop urelep {r1rlocl rseurfeqaU
t
ouo rtta g o4o { O uep p nmo e' os o qua g 3 uauy' urutfi 1
(1fl) praqrl tuelsl ue8urre{ ueeure8eay EuETEM lrp1ep €o1oap1 r$fru]suo;
*
*
{.
.............r,'*!.Y.y.?.y.y.!1..i!!!.7..::..'.i.:.:.:.:..w*.y..':ffitr:ffi
eser{Bg uere[elad
ET
lerns )rrqnu
*
.........!.(.':!.?.?..'!.:'*'!>,
tt,_oz
ZZ-
*
IETuIV epleureg e{rey aqaxqa[ Ia^oN ruplep e>lr]atsg
wtuqaflHuly4ag frnyg
Ersauopul ur Eurprng
JnoI uI saJueJal+n uEruJaD Jo sura*€d aql Jo uo4ecqdurl IeJnllnf,-ssoJJ
98-91
sL_
*
pas,srrrpr4ar^pueErsauopqr:rrsraqreala'"*#;r#fr:?r:::i?fiZriln *
00I
0II
*
urerSor4 VcIIg uprefe1aqrua4 rrrelep 1o13uor1 ElvrSTsEqeI I upqTIId Tdol
uv laoH aTLrep ''5 ryn|una nElv'opopltAouowtd
""" (UggC) sa8en8uul ro, aJuaraJa5 Jo >Iromatuer{ ueadorng uowruoJ uo
tzl - 0zI
6II - lll
*
ofrSuqng UV'cL
{ruor+]alg UsIqaS n>Ing ruepp s€o1ory treseprare)
ryndng
lereg nrEC espqeg urEIEp Eqre1 uped seryerodrual
ruttafi4sa7 lpluag uep qo$snw unwotwl
respq qplo>las EMSrS {nlun rspralr"I rsualaduro;tr {ru}suox
el€trAtr
9I0Z UrdV'1,roruo11'91 arunlon
sluueru [u8uad uup'urlsu g'useqeg uullllauad
purnf
YUHJLTT
{.
3
t?.
SHPETENCIES OF GERMAN LANGUAGE TEACHERS IN INDONESIA AND
YTETNAM BASED ON COMMON EUROPEAN FRAMEWORK OF REFERENCE
FOR LANGUAGES (CEFR)
Tratorno'N ]\, AkbarK. S) dan\-e]loa\ ArF
l)Yogyakarta State University dan 2)Vietnam National University of Hanoi
email: [email protected]
Abstract
This study aims to (1) identify and compare the language competencies of German
Ianguage teachers in Lrdonesia and Vietnam, and (2) identify the factors attributable to
their competency levels. This was a qualitative descriptive study. The data were collected
by means of questionnaires. The study shows that, based on the CEF& the competencies of
German language teachers inVietnam are inthe 82level, while those of Germanlanguage
teachers in Indonesia are in the Bi[ level. The low competencies of German language
teachers in Indonesia are caused by the language attrition and the lack of opportunities
to receive language training.
Keywords: German language competencies, teachers, language training
KOMPETENSI BAHASA IERMAN GURU BAHASA IERMAN DI INDONESIA
DAN VIETNAM BERDASARKAN KERANGKA BERSAMA EROPA UNTUK
BAHASA (CEFR)
Abstrak
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk (1) mengidentifikasi dan membandingkan kompetensi
bahasa Jerman guru bahasa Jerman di Indonesia dan Vietnam, dan (2) mengidentifikasi
faktor-faktor yang mempengaruhi tingkat kompetensi tersebut. Metode yang digunakan
dalam penelitan ini adalah deskriptif kualitatif. Data diperoleh dengan kuesioner. Hasil
penelitian menunjukkan bahwa, berdasarkan CEF& guru bahasa Jerman di Vietnam
berada pada tingkatanB2, sedang guru bahasa Jerman L:rdonesia berada pada tingkat 81Penyebab rendahnya kompetensi guru bahasa Jerman Indonesia disebabkan antara lain
oleh atrisi bahasa dan kurangnya kesempatan untuk mendapatkan pelatihan/penataran
bahasa.
Kata kunci: kompetensi guru bahasa ]ermary guru, pelatihan bahasa
INTRODUCTION
At present, German is learned by
by the country itself. That is why, the
leaming conditions in each country are not
known to one another. For the success of a
better leaming process, it is necessary to
have close cooperation and collaboration
among universities in various ASEAN
member countries.
In order to support the program,
the Faculty of. Languages ind Arts,
Yogyakarta State University is conducting
approximately 50 million people in various
countries. The Southeast Asia is one area
that gives great attention to learning the
German language. In many Southeast
Asian countries, German language is
generally studied in secondary schools. So
far, the advancement of learning German
in Southeast Asia tends to be determined
128
7"*
.''rueular^
prrE Ersauopul ur sJaqJeal aSenSup-I uEuuaD
Jo sarJualadruo)
'(a{nqspunlg) Ia^al rrspq .a.l /slalal
alqprlldde llsnorlerd arD qlrm a)uppro)Jp
uI ills arp pue 'J pue ,g ,y:sarcuapduroc
;o dnor8 0 otul papl^Ip sI UgD
:sMoIIO'
sp papr^rp sr dcuanr;ord a8Bn8uel Jo
pJepuels ar{} 'IeJauaB u1 'uosrreduroc ro;
alqrssod lr a{eru o} pup ,}uaussasse s}r
sE Ilarvr se aBenBuEI ueuraD Surureal
pue Surqrpal JoJ ErJalrJJ ruJolrun pue
lenba alelrlr)e, ol palearJ tualsds u sr
U:ID'(U1ID) uawr4anuaalay nrpsrudomX
fiuusunuag paIIEr sI Udgf, ,afen8uel
ueruraD ,o lxaluoJ aql uI .dcuarcryord
a8en8uel aql alep{e^ ol papuaturuoJar
uaaq seq U{gf, ,1997 raqtualoN ruorJ
Suqrelg 'a3en8ue1ueuraD ro sratrJeal aqt
Surpnpur'sarllunol ueadorng aq1 puodaq
sJauJeal a8en8trel roJ uoqezrJepuels a{eru
o] ado.rng Jo IrJuno) aql ,o luaruaar8e
ue aruoJaq spr{ dcrlod a^oqu aql
',,lxaluo) ueadorng e tn sllls a8en8uel
u8raro; Jo luaussasse pue uorl€JrJrsselJ
Jo Ia^al aql roJ srseq aql se palrelard seq
UCA) aql teql puJ al4 Jo ruarl ur relncqred
ur luelrodrm sr srr{L, :pres o:q.lv. ,(ZIOZ)
Jourprr) dq palroddns osle sur* uortndo
srql 'uorlEJrlqJal urelqo ol suorlnlqsur
Ipuo4e)npa pue'sradolatap runlnJrJJnJ
'sraqreal 'sraureal at4 dlaq ol ,pJrql pue
la8en8uel Surd;rpnb aql ol doutu4rtal
azrr8 ro aleprlul ol ,puoJas :plrom aq]
ralo 11e suoqnll]sur Ieuor+eJnpa Suorue
uorleradooJ a+elrlrJpJ o1 lsru ,are gggS
;o qeo8 aq+ leql salels (ZOOZ) urruD
('JS:e1OOZ adornX ;o pcuno3)
/suo;Ja Jrar{} aleulpJo-oJ pue a1uryls lrel aq/s lut{}
]IaI luapuodsar aql 'sueatu rlJlt{zvr '1arra1
IVI€ saruq 7 sraMsue uTauarreB 9 raqlunu
luapuodsar ua^['lalal IV ro salJuapduroc
aqt Surdynads sluarual€ls ueual arp ol
ulau stawsue ane8 or{m s}uapuodsar 91
ara/r araql lEr{} paPa^ar Jaqun} sl }I
'1y '1arra1 JISeq lsou aql JoJ lelJaleru
aql Suualseru ]ou sraqJeal aruos flqs aJa^rvl
araql dqrvr rapuo^ sn apeu ru]s rI (arocs
099 Ielol ar{+ }o lno gI 'a'1 %9'Z)'lunotue
aql ileurs 1v\oq Jal+Ptu oN 'sluatualels aql
ur pagnads dlgrqe aq+ palrel daq+ lIaJ
quapuodsal ar{} }PrD suearu qtt'tltvt'utau
z€,r
t'a
"' ,uer4ar^ puE Ersauopul ur sJar,IJpaJ aSEnSup-I uEurJaD
runlnJrJJn) uersauopul aLIl ol Surp.rocce)
Jo sarJualadruo)
B uazrr8 il'(%g.td sramsue ylctu
{tam
18 pue '(%g'Og) sre..rsue a{Wt dpo are
araLLL
'\r61il
IlI.a.l,s1uaura1els tsoru ot
sramstrp uyau Surprtrord dq sarcualadtuoa
sropeJ atuos dq pasnec aq ueJ (1arra1
19)
parJrlenbraptrn dpo are (fsqsluapuodsar
aq] Jo JIer{ uEq} aroru }Eq} peJ aqI
'(at^g'Ot) aldoad
9I are
(1azra1 13) prepuers
ANn ar{+ ralo alarqrp
uer ot{zvr asoq} alrqm ,("t"Z.ge) aldoad 91
dpo sr (1azra179) prepuels ANn ar{+ laatu
oq/vr sluapuodsar;o raqrunu aL r .ANn dq
las pJepuels parrnbar aq1 raptm dEuaJJnJ
are sluapuodsar;o dlrroferu aql /lalal
Zg
'a'I ANn uor+eJnpf, aBen8uel ueruJaD
,o ]uauuedaq aql dq ]as sprepuels
dcualaduro) ar{l q}rm palelalJoJ sr Jaqrunu
s1n rI 'Ia^aI Ig ol luapzrrnba suo4erqqenb
aql a^eq '(%gq) sluapuodsar 00 Jo
Ielol e
'a'r 'sluapuodsar;o dlrrofeur aq]
leql prcs
aq ueJ tI ,IIe ul 11V .sla^al raq8rq ar{}
Jo
sanualaduroJ aql aaeq dpressaJau lou op
sanualadtuoJ IV aler{ oqm sluapuodsar
ar{l /pueq raq}o aql uo .sla^al ra^rol ar{l
1e aeuapdtuor aler{ os1e Ilrzvr Ia^aI If, aql
le sarJualadtuor aler{ orIM sluapuodsar
aql Surneq lou sallastuaql paraprsuoJ
sluapuodsaJ lsoru ,1a.rra1 IJ lV
'la^al zg al{}le
azre8 daqt sramsue ylctu y1fiam
W1,r (auII
ur) alqelrns aJe sra.Msue asar{l .Ia^aI IJ
ro; arualadruoJ ou llal sluapuodsar asagl
'sI teql 'stuarualels (US/) g Jo tno 9 ol
sra.l sue utaupapttord sluapuodsar aures
aql '(ff,) Ia^aI lxau alp roJ ,uorleururexa
raqlrnJ uodn 'la^al Zg le saoualaduor
11e ol ]ue]rsaq ]lal s]uapuodsar oml aq]
leql paprdralur aq ueJ lI .stawsue utau
to al ou sr aJaq] lsarcualadruoJ Ia al Zg
Srryuasardal sluaruale+s aloqm of sJa,.r sup
ltlc?u dtam ate? oqlrt sluapuodsar orrLl
aJE araq] 'd18u4saraluJ .sluarualuls arp ur
pagrcads sE sarJualaduoc aq1 peq daqr
raqlaqm tenop ur ara^r (ZZi y" l.r1$eal
le pue Zg Ia^aI acualaduroJ aql a^Eq
lou plp sallasuaql paraprsuot (%rc)
quapuodsar ;o d1r.rofetu aq] leql supaur
slttl 'ggl snsral 6IV .a,I,sJarhsup o[ aql
papaaJxa reJ sra.{,rsuu ulaup\N ltlclu{1am
,o raqrunu 1elol aql ,alualaduroJ Jo lelal
parrnbar aql sI qrrr{^r
,1aaa1
Zg
ly
'paal uotllsua4 e se pazrroSalec aq
UEJ IaAaI
Ig sgl'deur
azvt;1
.sarcuapduor
aql 8uqce1 sallasuaqt parelJap oqm asotp
aleq sluapuodsa.r aql,o 11e ]sorup ro ]soru
]eql puarl alqeuosear E sr ararn lpql panSle
paJaqunulno sluapuodsar qJns puv
aq rrEJ lr 'azr.oqe uorssnJsrp arD uo pasBg
aq] peq daql 1ou ro raqlaq.&\ luapquoJ
d1ry rou aram Jo luplrsarl llal sluapuodsar
aqt /slIIS qns aruos ro; leql palardralur
aq upJ lT slr{} dg .sramsue utau ol upql
arotu sr Ig la^al sII{l le sJa.Msue ilplu
,sr SuHr Suqsaralur
2ltam p raqrunu at11
raqlouv'Ig Ialal arualaduroc aq1 Surrrutl
lou sallasruaql paJaprsuoJ sluapuodsar
asoql ler{l sueaur T lb pue ,e€ ,9I ,gI
'1 ou quapuodsa.r are daql .sluaualels
Surpuodsalror aql ol sra.Msue al ueql
.sluawalels aql
ur pa1;nads sarcuapduoc due alpq lou
pp daqt lerll arns dlalnlosqe arauvr daql
teq] sueau q)lqm Jaaal srql;o sluarualels
Jo sulall IIe o] sJaMSue UtaU paprtrotd
dltlrlldxa or{^.r s}uapuodsar g ar, ,rrql
!ce; u1 'uoqelrseq ur aJaM Jo sarcualaduror
ou peq daqr leql \al %Ollnoqe lsar aqa
'la^al If, slq] uI acualadtuoJ aql a^uq ol
sallasruaql palraJrad sluapuodsar ;o
%00lnoqe dpo leql papnlruor aq uE) tr
'sra*rsue { ayl dpo Suqel dq auu prrls
€€r
'sluarualels aql
sralvrsue
rtrtu
aruos 'la+a1
u-r
paqrcads saroualadruoc
dtam arcanaae8 quapuodsar
Ig sFIl 1e ,uorlrppe u1
t"r
gl0z
prp daql lerD arns ara1vl sluapuodsar at{+
lPt{+ suearu qrf{1v\ u!.au paJa,^{SuE or{/V\
sluapuodsar er{} aas a1r g alqeJ uI
'sla^al raqSr-q Jo saDualaduoc
aql aAPq dlrressarau lou op salJualaduroJ
Qsarvrof IV a^pr{ oqm asoq} 'dlasrarruo3
'sla^al Ja^rol aq]ro sarJuaFdruoJ aq+ aAPq
asrnor 1o (lsaq8rq) fC lo acualadruoo
raq8rq aq+ a^eLI or{zvr asoq} ler{l sueau
srql 'la^al raq8rq aql ot Ia^al ramol e
uorl SursearJap sr sarJualaduror aql
a^eq o+ Sururelc sluapuodsal Jo raqunu
aql qJrq^.vr u1 '11arvt sE puaJ] rre; e alrhb
alerrpur elep ar{I 'PtOg1il aldoad 9'g
Ia^al IJ ro dlqrqe lsaq8rq aq+'(%Og'29)
aldoad 9la^al Zg'(%t6) aldoad I Ia^al Ig
'P/"g6) aldoad g'l :la^al ZVJo arualadruor
aler{ ol paurelD quapuodar Jaqunu arp
dq uaqt parvrollo{ 'Ia^al IV acualaduoc
aql a^er{ daq+ leu+ patets (.t,oot)
sluapuodsar 8 IIe 'aloqe 7 alqel uI
%LE
%lZ
%09',9
%06'0 0
0
lElor
ZY IV
nEaArN
9'Z Z'Z V'0 I'0
IJ
Zg
IS
aseluDrad
,,4\)tu d!'M,,
paJalAsue oqm alreuuorlsan[
uotlanluaalsqPs uo paseq
luarussassv-Jlas luapuodsa5'galqel
%€Z %Ol
%1gl %06'0 g
6't 8'0 I'0
I)
Zg
IB
r'0
a8eluacra4
0
IPlor
CV IV
nEa^IN
,u!4N,,
paJalrsue oqm alreuuorlsanQ
uollonlaaalsqps uo paseq
]uarussassV-JIaS luapuodsa5'g aIqEI
y"1e.gl "/"09.29 y"e6 "/og6 %00I
a5eluarrad
9'€9t9'18
ZS. I8 ZY
,,a [,,
ploJ,
IV
pata*tsJe oq a aJrBtruoqsan$
uot+anlaaalsqps uo pasPq
lualussassV-JIaS luapuodsa5'f alqpl
llrdv'1 rouroS'91 aumlon vuEIII]
'tueulal^ uI
dpnrs aqlJo sllnsar atp are araH'ersauopul
ur sluapuodsar aq1 ol palJnpuoJ sezvr
leq.rlr a{{'(arreuuo4sanb aql) lualunrlsul
uarrt8 aJaM sluapuodsar 11y 'suor8ar
1q31a aql ro r{Jea ruorJ ua{u} luapuodsar
auo dluo sem araql asneJaq sr srql 'ue1d
aql .Molaq re} sr qrrqM 'aldoad g dpo sr
rueular1 ur dpnls sql ul Suqedrcllred
sluapuodsar Io raqurnu aql
urBulal^ uI sJaqJual
aSunEuul uuuuaC Io salJualadruo3 'g
'sasrnoJ Surper8dn
3uqel ro Suturerl a8en8uel Sururof
aq1
ur sluapuodsar 1o uoqudrcqred rvrol aqt
/quno{ 'udllf, aq} q}I,vr aruepror)e uI
q11s aSen8uel paaordrul ol pal lou aler{
sluapuodsal ar{l pamolloJ aJE q)rqm
sasrnoJ Surper8dn dueu 'pJItII
'sPasra^o puE elsauopul uI tDoq s)Id-l
Jaqlo qlIM sprepuels asar{l areduror o1
d.ressacau os1e $ 1r 'ranazvroll 'U{ilf, Jo
Ia^aI Zg ol srarar qJIqM acualadruoc 1o
spJepuels aql aJrolular o1 dressa)au $ 1r
(>fal uoqp)npg raqreal roJ uol+nl4sul
auo se ANn Jo salenpur8 aql Jo dlrlenb
aql arnsua oI 'la^al zg leq] Molaq flqs
aram lsed aql q salenpe.r8 leql dla{Il
alrnb sr lI 'salenper8 slr ro; arualaduoc
Jo pJepuels urntururtu e las lad lou peq
luau4redaq uollernpg a8enSuel uetuJaD
aql dlsnornard pue 'o8e atuq 3uo1e alrnb
lou paqsrlqelsa uaaq lsn[ seq UiIgf, /
uED aql ler{} Sulraplsuor 'puocaS
'paqsrururp ro lsol uaq+ fl dlUqe
aq1 'au1l 3uo1 e alrnb ro; lr Surcrloerd
lou ol anp :uorlrrl+E JaIJns 1ana1 raq8rq
aql te saoualaduroJ Jlaql dqrvt sr }eq1
'zv puP IV Jo sla^al aql uI are srar{real
aql dq pasn dlapwr lsoru qyls a8ne8uel
aql 's[r{s a8en8uel ueuraD Jraql asn o}
dpreur pue dolarrap ol sraqrEal aql JoJ
saqrunl,roddo pue aceds q8noua aprrrord
lou saop osle +uawuoJrlua depdrazra
rlaql'(WrU>ruS/VhtS ro slooqJs q31q ro1
ntl
f".*
"' ruEular^ puE Ersauopu[ rr sJaqJEaI aSenSuP'l uPurJaD
se^lastualil passardxa oq,rv\ ueula.r^ ulory
s+uapuodsat %oE gt ol PerEdruoJ /la^al
sFil uI erarv\ daql lPql pelp+s sluapuodser
uersauopq %z'8e /IJ Ia^al lv
'elsauopt{
ruor, sJaqJea+ ueIuJaD arll u€ql IoAeI
zg sltll le are weulal^ tuoJJ sJar{JPal
.a8en8uel uerura9 aroru leql salPJIpuI
osIE lr'uosrreduroJ ur /ueBV'Ia al sTtll uI
aq ol paureP ureular^ urorJ sluapuodsaJ
%og'zg seararur '1ana1 srql uI araM dar{l
lEql palPls oq.&l. sluapuodsar uersauopul
aql Io %g'0€, are araq] 'zg Ia^aI
lv
'ersauopr{ ruor} asoql ueq}
Ia^al Ig sItI] lE ar€ tueular^ urorJ sJar{JEal
a8un8uel ueruJaD aJoru let{l a}PJrplJI osp
Elep asarD 'dFepu[S 'Ia^al srql uI aq 01
patels ruEularn wor, sluapuodsar %€5
sEarar{M 'la^al sql uI aq ol patuEp ot{,ryI
ersauopul ruorJ sluapuodsal %9'99 aJu
alarp /Ig IaAaT 'a'r 'lanal lxau aql +V
'ersauopul ruory asoql uEql
Ia^al sql le aJE rueular^ tuoJJ sJaqJEal
a8en8uey ueruraD aroru leql aleJlpul
PlEp asaql 'os Palels otllv\ ueular^
ruoJ; sluapuods ar "/o86 o1 pareduroc
'1azra1 snll uI aq ol parrrelJ Ersauopul
urorJ stuapuodsar %qvg '7y lazral lv
'Ia^al
sItD uI aq ol arns lou aralA ersauopul tuoJ}
sr 1r snql'lalal
sHl passed a^er{ ol palels sluapuodsaJ
srarpeal aruos ]ErD alqrssod
uersauopr.{ 1o "1o9' 96 AluoasneJaq uoqrsod
Japaq E ur aJE ruelqar1 ruoJJ sluapuodsar
arll /ersauopr{ Iuory elep qlr/lt pareduro]
'la^al sltll lP aq ol paurelf, sluapuodsor
Jo %00I leql elep aql dq palerlsuouap
sI s1r{I 'la^al dcualaduo) sg{} passed
aleq ol dlluapuuot drarr pa1e1s ru€u+al1
tuorl sluapuodsar 11V 'slIITs a8en8uel
u€uraD ur Ia^aI lsamol aql $ IV Ia^a'l
Jo
sarJualadruo)
"/"S116 "/"2'Ae %9,99
"/"g'tg y.g'96
aUpluarrad
6gn
AruanDard
9I
nrt
88r
t8
IEIOI
tv
nEa^IN
,al,pate//rslJe
oq/vr sluapuodsar uErsauopul Jo PIECI
'Ersauopul tII q)JEasar aql
Jo sllnsar ar{t II}I1VI paJedruoJ atup atuus
aql lu puP Ia^al r{JEa uo pasEq passmslp
aq IIIM paurelqo Elep ar{l 'acualadtuoc
FuorssaloJd rraq] Jo, ruerqar1 uI sJarpeal
a8en8uel ueruraD 1o uoqdacrad aq1 ;o
arn+crd rarealr e aprrrord o1 'Qsaq31q aq1)
Zf, pue 'I) 'Zg'Iy'ZY o1 '(1sarvro1 aql)
IV uroJ1 's1ala1 xIS Io slsrsuoJ a8en8uel
ro1 Ui1ilf, o1Surprocce a8en8uel ueruraD
ur dcuarcrlord 1o Ialal Jo luaruaJnseatu
aql 'azroqe pauoquaru uaaq seq sV
EIsauoPuI PUE
rar{JEaI
uI
salJuafaduro3
uruulal1
atunSuul ueruraD yo uospuduo3 'J
'arreuuoEsanb
aql uI sluaua+els aq] puelsJapun lou
plp ro ]uellsaq ara^t otlrvr sluapuodsar;o
raqrunu aq1 ralearS aql'(If,) arualaduroc
leql saleJrpul elep
arfl'(%I€) aldoad 9'Z Ia^al I) pue '(%lZ)
aldoad Z'Z p^al Zg,'(%Og'g) uosrad 7'6
Ia^aI Ig '(%O'd uosrad I'0Ia aI ZY'(%O)
uosrad 0 Ia^al IV :s/'rolloJ se are slrelap
ar{I 'alrerruorlsanb aql uI s}uaura}Els aql
pue+sJapun 1ou lq8nu Jo InI+qnop ara^\
daql sueau qrrq..v\ 'ltplu dyam paletu,sue
oqm Euapuodsar aql smot{s 9 aIqPI
'luaualPls aql uI
Jo sla^al aql raq8rq aq+
payrcads sarcualadtuoJ q?ns Surrreq
lou;o
%o€'gn %0q29 %€,6 %86 %00I a;eluaf,rad
9'L
9'€
nll
tfl
50I
08
zY
IV
i{ruanbarg
,?r, paJaMsue
or{rvr s}uapuodsar asarueu}al1 Jo EI€CI
9€r
uosrad I'0 Ia^aI W' (%6 duosrad I'0 Ia^aI
Zv'(%O) uosrad 0la^al IV:smo[o] sP arp
qr-epp aql 'aneuuoqsanb aqlul luaualels
arp uI pagrcads lcualadruoJ aql aAErI +ou
*"t
gl0z Ilrdv'1 rouoS'91 aurnlon
fl e ua zua p dwolrya ilS
awllpunw 'zl0z 'E>lirn 'tunr3
n 8 u4c u tdsqr
s
a
'ral4al I 'g'{ SeFan
:UEBtlnlS'l.psflapqtamuaga)' 166l
'rauraM 3ue311o1,4'ranes
28
lnurlaH
tcntc
^'HdVUCOIIflg
'roueH ro dlrsJa^run IPuorlBN ruet4ar^
qll^r r{Jruasar aAqeJoqEIIoJ srl{l Sulpun,
ro, ANn suv pue saSenSuel ro d+ImEc
ar{l ol apn1rler8 aJaJurs rraql ssardxa o}
a{rl plno.&r sJatpJeasal ar{l 'aJoJaJaqI
'(,trud dlrsrarrrun alels EtroledSol'slry
pue sa8en8ueT ro dlpceg aL{} dq papunJ
qJJeasaJ aArleJoqelloJ Ieuorleuralur
ue ,o llnsar aql sl dpnls srql
SINIII IIID OIIIMONXJV
'sarcualadruo) 1en+Je
q}Ilvr
ar{}
aJuepJoJJe ur aJe dcuarcrlord
pqdarrad rraql lou ro Jaqlaq.rvr tuJIJuoJ ol
rapJo ur ]sa1 dcuarcrlord a8en8uel uEuJaD
aql Jo ruJoI aql ur r{Dreasar raqun, e
aler{ ol ra+laq aq ppolvr lI'sarJuaFduoc
a8en8uel uerrrraD Jraql Sururaluol
sluapuodsa.r dq uarrr8 uorldarrad ;o
urro, arp ur 1sn[ ara.M e]ep paraqlu8 aq1
'dlluanbasuo3 ']uarunJlsur lsal e lou
'alreuuorlsanb uaprrrvr e Jo uJoJ aql ur lsnf
sem aJaq pasn poqlaur darrrns aql dlaru€u
'suorlelrturl aruos suq dpnls srql
'rueu+ar^ puE ersauopr{ urory
sJar{JEa} a8en8uel uEruJaD ro1 Surlaaru
1euoqeuJalur luro[ e azrue8ro o1 d.ressacau
sI lI 'prlt{I 'sJaqJEa} a8en8uel ueruJaD
roJ U{ilf, ar{} o} ra1ar +eq} s8ururerl
a8en8uel alrsualur aprnord ol spaau
luaruuJalo8 aq1 'puorag 'dlrsramun alels
elre>1ed3o1 ur pue roueH;o dlrsrarrrull
IeuorleN tueular1 ur ssarord Surureal
a8en8uel ueurJaD aql Sururacuoc dpnls
aur.qeredtuo) e spaau ll lsrlC :dpn+s sIU+
Jo sllnsar arp ruory suoqsaSSns awos
'peoJqe se flam se Prsauopul
s)Id'l
rarDo rllr1vl spJEpuels asaql
areduror ol dressarau os1e sI lI /JaAaMoH
ssorJE
'Zg Ia^aI 'a'I 'UCg) aql ol sralar q)Iqrvr
acualaduroJ Jo spJepuels aql aJJofurcr o+
dressacau
v[glll
q lI ()Id-l) uo4ecnpg rar{real
alntqsul aLIl Jo salenper8 aql Jo d11pnb
aql aJnsua oI 'Ia^al parrnbar luaJal aql
anarqre lou plp lsed aql ur salenper8 reql
alqrssod sr 1r 'acualadtuoo Jo pJepue+s
runurruru e 1as dllplldxa 1ou peq ANn
luarulredaq uoqpJnpf, a8en8uel ueuJaD
aqt dlsnomard pue paqs{qe}sa uaaq }sn[
seq (UCiIf,) aruara;a5 ,o {rorratuerd
ueadorng uoruruoJ aql aJurs'd1p4.ll
'paqsltrlurp
ro lsol uaq] sr ru)s ar{} ailperd Jo {rel aql
ol anp leq] Sulueaur 'uorlrrpe paraJJns
ll a^oqe IaAaI aql le arualadruor dqrvr sr
leqJ 'zv pue IV sla^al aql le asoql arE
sJaq)eal dq pasn dlaprrvr lsoru are leql
s11DIs ar{I 'passassod dlpnlce anuq daql
q11s a8en8uel raq8rq ar{} asn lseal le ro
dolarrap ol srar{)ea} aql ro, sa4runlroddo
puu a8ualleqc qSnoua aprzrord lou saoP
ralunoJua daql luauuorrlua dpep aq1
.(VW/XftS/VftS
Jo runlnrrrrnr aql ol
Surprorre) ZV pue IV sla aI 1u a8en8uel
trururagrpeal dpo dleraua8 qooqcs q8rq
ur qJeal oqm sluapuodsar aql asneJaq
Jo
u SuuJmJo
qnoua
np $fiUaA)
luazuaqadwo44ca ilg uaua
uoqrrlle a8enBuel sr ararp 'dlpuocag
.a.I
.Ig
Ia^aI lE
'raltol Ialal auo sI Elsauopul uI sJaqJeal
a8en8uel ueruraDro leql alq^\ Zgla^al lE
sr rrrul4ar1 ur s.raqrual a8en8uel ueuuag ;o
sarcuapduroJ Jo Ia al aql 'd1+srl{ :dpnls sp1l
tuory wv\eJp aq IreJ suorsnlJuoJ IeJaAas
'Ersauopr{ ut sraqJual ueurrag
NOISNl)NOJ
'Ig,o
Ia^aI aql lE are elsauopt{
ruo4 sluapuodsa.r agqm Ia^al Zg le aJE
urpular1 uoJJ sluapuodsar 1eq1 Surrvroqs
elep aql tuory uneJp sr uorsnlJuoJ sIqJ
'ersauopul ur sJaq)ea1 a8en8uul upruJaD
lerll sarruataduror a8en8uel ur ratISIq Ia al
auo are rueular1 ur sJaqJpal a8en8uel
upruJaD leql des ueJ alr'a8elazre ug
'Ersauopul tuorJ sJaqJeal
aq+
ueql
uEuJaD
Ia^al sr-ql +E aq ol paunep
tueular1 ruoJJ sJaqJual a8en8uel ueruJaD
arou terD s^ror{s osle lI 'Ia^al slq} uI aq ol
9€r
"' rueular1 prrp plsauoprrl rr sJalpeal a8en8uel uEuJaD 1o sarcualadr'uo3
E' ol;.' lautno [-t{l' puut pslnacl
ut aln#+sul-atfiaog fip uastmp4cuilS
uap m suauqafiuan{aA uaqtsrudomX
uauosunua) sap ryppptpotnx. tap
'
'uge1ed3otr rra8aN
s€lrsra^rul.I leuas e{nqral lEdpu
eped rusag nrnD r.reqmln8ua4 olepTd
'uuun[ ustqag nm) suflpuorsalot4
uap
)p+sflau./7,g'll0z'oruolErd'opoplM
IBuorsEN rrolrprpuad rualsrs Suelual
€002 unqel 0Z roIrIoN Suepun-Suepun
g:ppunorrE L0E9Et LLlz
/rvrarmop/urol lsanbord'qcreas//: d$q
palarrta5' O6L- tgl G,)69'8urycoa7
a?an?ua7'1redu1 pue uorldacaS
'ulStrO'asodrn4 !ua1uo3 :sa8un8uel
7Z€ I
roI aJuaralau Jo {Jo/l^auPJd
ueadorng uoruruo3 aq1-,'9002'q'allll'l
L€I
ZOOZI
Sunzqaswn'ZOOZ'pru8appll'rauqc4;1
6900606090 6r lgzosI tl0r' 0 l/8rc
'rop'xp/i:dnq :IoP'€9-I9' 57'sct\sm&urT
palddy lo mana>J pnuuv' $aC rrlt PUV
'&utuna7' luawssassv fict1o 4 aEtnSwT
uaadomX'6002 'N 'alpleg rt ''N 'sauo{
'ornf,
:
08'?9'uallas zlE' 0-90a29-l€9-€-816
N8SI'(9r'lqclrra unuatPerdsPuard
urnrnbollo;) 8ue1 :lE la 'W'u
un1{uerd' fl #ua8 onqaqs8uqsra7
tnz sllapouzualadwoa sauta
Sunl4nmquX'uaqcxlSuX saq n,un7