Taboos and misconceptions about food during pregnancy among rural population of Pondicherry
Calicut Medical Journal 2010;8(2):e4 Page number not for indexing purposes
Original article
Taboos and misconceptions about food during pregnancy
among rural population of Pondicherry
A cross sectional study was planned to study the misconceptions about food during pregnancy among adult rural population.A pre-tested semi-structured questionnaire was used. Before interview, subjects were informed about the purpose of the study and consent was taken. The study was conducted in the field area of Rural Health and Training Centre, Manapet, of department of Community
All people, whether rural or urban, have their own beliefs and practices. Some are based on centuries of trial and error and have positive values while others may be useless or harmful. (1) This is true for food also. Some food items are considered good and some bad at different ages of life. Food taboos are known from virtually all human societies. Probably food taboos (as unwritten social rules) exist in one form or another in every society on Earth, for it is a fact that perhaps nowhere in the world, a people, a tribe, or an ethnic group, makes use of the full potential of edible items in its surroundings.(2,3) It is the regular avoidance of a food that turns into a tradition which ends up eventually as a food taboo.(2) Pregnancy imposes the need for considerable extra calorie and nutrient requirements. A balanced and adequate diet is therefore, of utmost importance during pregnancy and lactation to meet the increased needs of the mother, and to prevent “nutritional stress”.(4)In various studies it was seen that pregnant women in various parts of the world are forced to abstain from nutritious foods as a part of their traditional food habits.(5,6,7) We could not find any study related to food taboos and beliefs in South India so we planned the study. This paper tries to explore some food taboos and their reasons among rural population of Pondicherry.
Keywords: food taboo, misconception, health, food, pregnancy
Maximum misconceptions about nutrition revolve around pregnancy; affecting a vital period in human lifecycle. The aim of the present study was to explore food taboos during pregnancy among the rural population of Pondicherry. A cross sectional study was conducted in a village under Rural Health Centre of Community Medicine Department of AV Medical College at Pondicherry. Total 339 adults were interviewed from the village. Statistical analysis was done using proportions (%) and Chi-square test. 62.8% participants believed that consumption of saffron by pregnant woman results in a fairer skin child. Most common reason for restriction of specified fruit/vegetable was abortion (86.1%). Overall more than half of the participants lack awareness; they still believe in old unscientific tales. Illiteracy is an important factor responsible for this.
2 A.V. Medical College, Pondicherry
1 Geetanjali Medical College,Udaipur,Rajasthan
2 Department of Community Medicine
1 , M.Raghavia
2 ,M Iqbal Khan
2 , Vedapriya DR
1 ,Anuj Mittal
Rajkumar Patil
Summary
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Calicut Medical Journal 2010;8(2):e4
Most of the females were housewives (58.7%), while 50.4% of males were farmers; others were laborers & semi skilled workers. Nearly half of the participants were in Socio-Economic Class V (based on Modified Prasad’s classification), with only 1.8% in Class I. Of 339, 216 (63.7%) told that some vegetables/fruits should be avoided during pregnancy. There was no significant difference regarding this misconception between literates and illiterates. (Table1). Most of the illiterates (91.3%) told that papaya should not be eaten during pregnancy in comparison to 83.9% of literates (Table 2).Most common reason for restriction of specified fruits/vegetables was abortion (Table 3).
There were 4 villages under the field area of RHTC Manapet. One village was selected randomly and door to door survey was conducted. Population of the selected village was 1435. All families (except door locked/no consent) in the village were covered. Only adult population was selected for the study. One person (preferably head of the family or any elder member present) from each family was interviewed After proper training and orientation about the location and people living there, Interns conducted the survey in the village (1st January 08-15th February 08). The data collected were entered and analyzed in MS- Excel software. Simple proportions (%) and Chi square test were used to analyze the data.
Results and Discussion
Our study population was 339 adults; most of the participants belonged to age group 25-32 yr (24.5%) followed by old age group (>65 years) (16.5%).Regarding literacy, 203 were literates & 136 were illiterates. Majority of the participants were females (64.3%).
23.5
7.9 (Chi Square value:2.27; p-value:0.3214; Not significant)
31.0
61.1
16
63
8.8 124
67.6
In a hospital based Pakistani study(8)of women’s beliefs about food in pregnancy, 12% believed in restricting some food item during pregnancy, this was different from our study finding (63.7%) as we carried out the study among men as well women and in a community setting. But there was no significant difference among education levels, similar to our study finding.
12
As literacy is an important determinant for health and disease we compared the various food taboos and their reasons between illiterates and literates in our study.
92
No. % No. % Yes (216) No (95) Don’t Know (28)
Illiterates (203)
Avoidance of any food/fruit Literates (136)
____________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1: Avoidance of any food/fruit during pregnancy
32
Page number not for indexing purposes Medicine,A V Medical College,Pondicherry
Calicut Medical Journal 2010;8(2):e4 Table 2: Avoidance of fruits/vegetables during pregnancy*
Illiterates Literates Total Avoided
(92) (124) (216) fruit/vegetable No. % No. % No. %
Papaya
84 91.3 104 83.9 188
87.0 Mango
10
10.9
23
18.6
33
15.3 Jack fruit
9
9.8
10
8.1
19
8.8 Pineapple
9
9.8
8
6.5
17
7.9 Banana
4
4.3
7
5.6
11
5.1 Grape
4
4.3
6
4.8
10
4.6 Others**
6
6.5
13
10.5
19
8.8 (*Multiple answers; ** guava, green leafy vegetables)
Table 3: Reasons for not consuming fruits during pregnancy*
Illiterates Literates Total (92) (124) (216)
Reasons No. % No. % No. %
Abortion
84 91.3 102 82.3 186
86.1 Cold food
13
14.1
20
16.1
33
15.3 Others**
4
4.3
9
7.3
13
6.0 (*Multiple answers; ** hot food, cold food, rigors, overweight, seizures, difficult labor)
Table 4: Misconception about saffron consumption during pregnancy
Illiterates (136) Literates (203) No No
Misconception Agree Disagree Agree Disagree Comments Comments
No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % No. % Consumption of saffron results in a fairer skin 104
76.2
23
16.9
9 6.6 109
53.7
73
35.9
21
10.3 child (Chi Square value:18.44 ; p value: <0.0001 , Highly significant)
Page number not for indexing purposes Calicut Medical Journal 2010;8(2):e4 Page number not for indexing purposes
One of the strong beliefs is that papaya can cause abortion. In a study done by Puri S and Kapoor S (9) it was reported that 16.5% of the adolescent girls believe that papaya can cause abortion. A study among 1200 women from all districts of Tamil Nadu in India showed that 82 % of women avoided papaya during pregnancy.(10) Similarly in our study among adults; more than 80% people believe that papaya should not be consumed.
Papaya is considered to be a fruit which is ‘hot’. Conventionally ‘hot’ food items are avoided during pregnancy as it is thought that it will cause abortion. Similarly ‘cold’ foods are avoided during lactation as it might affect the quality and quantity of milk production.(11) The main constituents of papaya latex are papain and chymopapain,(12) which are potent uterine- stimulants.(13) A fully ripe papaya contains very little or a negligible quantity of the latex which will not provoke uterine contractions, so it can be eaten. On the other hand, the unripe or semiripe papaya (which contains high concentration of the latex that produces marked uterine contractions) may have an adverse effect during pregnancy and should be avoided.(13) Most common misconception was “consumption of saffron by pregnant woman results in a fairer skin child” (Table 4). There was a significant difference regarding this misconception between literates and illiterates but the difference was not significant regarding misconception about avoidance of any food/fruit in pregnancy.
From our study we concluded that still a large proportion of population believes in old unscientific tales, though with increase in literacy the proportion of people has reduced to a certain extent. There is a need of nutrition education and awareness generation among all stratas of population. There are very less number of studies on food misconceptions about food in pregnancy, as India is a country with diverse cultural backgrounds, there is a need for more research.
Acknowledgement
We would like to thank all the participants who had participated in our study. We would also like to thank all other villagers for their kind support.
___________________________________________________________________________
References
1. Park K. Park’s Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine. Jabalpur: M/S Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers, 19th edition, 2007:504.
2. Harris M, Ross EB. Food and evolution – Toward a theory of human food habits. Philadelphia, Temple University Press; 1987.
3.Mintz SW, Du Bois CM. The anthropology of food and eating. Annu Rev Anthropol. 2002;31:99–119. doi: 10.1146/annurev.anthro.32.032702.131011.
4. Park K. Park’s Textbook of Preventive and Social Medicine.Jabalpur: M/S Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers, 18th edition, 2007:387.
5. Manderson L, Mathews M. Vietnamese attitudes towards maternal and infant health. Med J Aust 1981;1:69-72.
6. Trigo M, Roncada MJ, Stewien GT, Pereira IM.Food taboos in the northern region of Brazil. Rev Saude Publica 1989;23:455-64.
7. Jo Mitchell and Dorothy Mackerras,The traditional humoral food habits of pregnant Vietnamese–Australian women and their effect on birth weight.Australian Journal of Public Health.Vol 19 (6) 2010. 629-633.
8. Ali NS, Azam SI, Noor R.Womens' beliefs and practices regarding food restrictions during pregnancy and lactation: a hospital based study.J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2004 Jul- Sep;16(3):29-31.
9. Puri S, Kapoor S.Taboos and myths associated with women’s health among rural and urban adolescent girls in Punjab. Indian Journal of Community Medicine.2006 Oct-Dec; 31(4): 168-170.
Calicut Medical Journal 2010;8(2):e4 10. Ferro-Luzzi EG .Food avoidance of pregnant investigation on some enzymes of papaya latex.
women in Tamil Nadu. In Food, Ecology and Journal of Chromatography.1985; 326, 103-111. Culture: Readings in the Anthropology of Dietary Practices,1980;101– 108.
13. Adebowale Adebiyi, P. Ganesan Adaikan, R. N. V. Prasad. Papaya (Carica papaya)
11. Mukhi S. Problems in Adolescent’s consumption is unsafe in pregnancy: fact or Sexuality: Family Planning Prespective: 1990; fable? Scientific evaluation of a common belief 21:52-64. in some parts of Asia using a rat model. British Journal of Nutrition. 2002; 88, 199–203 .
12. Calam DH, Davidson J & Harris R .High performance liquid chromatographic
____________________________________________________________________________
Corresponding author: Dr.Rajkumar Patil Associate Professor, Department of Community Medicine, Mahatama Gandhi Medical College and Research Institute Pillaiyarkuppam,Pondicherry 607402 E-mail:drraj49@gmail.com Mobile No. 09894428081Page number not for indexing purposes