Conference paper
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
!
'
*
*
"
&
& .' /
"
&
#
+
&.'
*
"(
&
& '"
"
'+&
"
"
*
"
"
&
+
"
"
5
"
' "
& (
'
* "
&
"
"
&&'
"
"
& &
++ &
&
+
"
+
*
" +
"&
&
+&
#
"
$+
"&
"
"
&
' * "&
4 " $
"
& "
&
3 ' "
"
"
+ ' " 78
&
+&
"
&
"
&
"
!
"
"
" (1 '
' "
"
"
+
"
+ &
'+& &
"
&
&
"
*
" #:'
")
!
&
&
"
'
+
+
& "
#)
& "
+
" ++
+
' " -78 #
&
" ++
&
&
& +
+
" ++
"
'
+
& '"
"
*
&
&
&
+
+ '
"
'
+
& '"
+
&
*
"'&
&
"
"
"
'
3
"
.'
&
" (
&
.'
&
+&
& .'
'
"
"
)
"
#5
&
+
*
"
"
"
>77?$
+&
&
"
*
+
"
&
+
+
"'&
"'&
&&'
&
+&
&
" #
&
!
&
'
!
' "+
"
+
&
'
+&
&
+
<
'
&
"
1 ! 1 @ ' *
"&
&
+&
-
+&
&
&
&
"
6
+
&
"
"
"
"
"&
!
&
+&
"'& "
"
$
&
"
"
%
"
" & '
+
&
>
!
&
" ++
"
+
& .'
'&
+
" <
>77> " ++
"
& &
++ &
(
+ ' "
<
*
"
"'&
"&
+
4
+ #
>77>$
"
"
+
"'
&&'
*
'"
"
" /,
' "
+
!
& '" "
"
999$ !
*
+
"
" 779$ !
"
"
+
""
' " ++ &
"&
&
$ &
+
+
" &&'
"
" # !10 1$
&
+& &
"
' "+
"&
&
+&
&
' "
*
$
++ & "
+
' "
&
& +
2 & '+& !
++ &
" '
"
'
+
+&
&
&
"
&
+*
(
& .'
' "
&
+
+
(
"
"
*
&
(
" ++
&
+
" &
+
!
"
&
+&
+
& '" "
"
&
+ "
!
"
+ "
"
"'& " '
&
'
3 $
&
"
" &
+&
'"
&
'
" &
5'
'
+
&
6
" ++
" &
&
&
#
$ "
!
'
' &
&
" '
"
&
# * $ &.'
'+& '
& "
+
&
*
"
"
#)
999$ !
" + *
"
+
&
" &
*
&
& # '&
'+&
$ +' &
& &
&
"
&
*
99;$
+
-
$%
#*
'+&
&
*
"
'"
"
-
#
&
,
"0
"
& &
+&
&
*
"
)
"
&
!
@ & "
&'
'
+
'
& +
&
+
"&
+&
.'
' " +
"
"&
+
!
& "
'
#1* $
&
&
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
79
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
& "'&
'
"
"
&
" &
#
+&
$
+
"
"
#1* $
+ "
&
'
" 6 '
" +
" +
!
@
(
& +
&
"
& .'
"'&
' + & 1 " # 1$ +
!
"
1
&
+ " '
" &
+&
"&
&
'
"
!
" " "
&
&
"'&
"
&
A
(
"
" &
"
& " &
"
" ' "
'
+
@
& & '" "
'
+
'"
& '"
!
+
&
+
&
&
-
&
" +'
"
&
!
' "
+
&
&
+
& "
"# $ %#&
&
&
" &
&
&
+
+&
+&
"
+
&
"
+
'
<
"
& '"
+
+ *
'
"
!
!
!
&
"
+
"
"
"
&
.'
=
+
' "
+
&
!
&
"@
+
&
*
"
"
.'
"
+<
"
"
+
"
! 1 @ ' *
"
' " &
+
"
+ "
'
&
!
'
+
&
+&
& "'& " '
& +'
@
&
'
"
' "
& .'
&
+
"&
'
$ # &'( #
"# $ %#&
LiDAR Point Clouds
!
"
'
"
+
&
+
*
"
Point Data Interpolation
(Raster Conversion)
Digital Surface Model
(DSM)
"
+
" !
& '"
"
&
(
-
>
& "'
+
6 ' > !
& "' &
++
+
"
&
&
!
"
&
&
+
+
+
&
+
"
"
&
+ "
"
&
" "
'
& "
!
"
&
+ "
" + " "
& (
"
& &"
"
&
"
"
' &
+ " (
+ '
' &
+ "
"
"
"
' " &
'
+
& .'
" + "+
!
&&' &
&
+&
'
' "
'
Elevation points
Intensity Image
(Intensity)
&
& " )* #
" &
"
&
Data Separation
Intensity points
$
"
Layers Combination
Multi-layer images
Classification Process
Classified Images
6 ' > *
Accuracy Assessment
6 '
!
6
*
'
"
+
+
*
6
" "
& '" ! +
+&
(( +
&
@
+
+
!
=
"(
&
&
&
"
&
"
.'
& 6
&
1 @ '
+&
& .'
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
+&
+ "
@
= +
+&
+
*
"
$
' " &
,
'" 6
&
"
+
+
+
+
"
#'
"
"
80
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
"
'
'
"&
!
2
"
+ "
"
"
&
&
+
&
+ "
&
"
&
"
& "
"
"
!
&
' &
+ "
"
& &" "
"
& ' &
+ " "
'"
"
2
&
+
' ' "
' +
!
& "'& "
&
!
&
"
' &
+ "
"2 &
&
+ "
!
&
&
' "'
#' &
+ "
$ ! +
'
+
&
+&
'
& +'
@
&
' "
"
+
&
' "
+
& +
&
'
"
&
+
+
!
&)*, ('#
'"
&
!
'"
5'
5
6 ' #"- $ !
'&
F77
+
+
" @ -C7
+
'"
!
& "
6 ' - "$
#
' "
# '&
!
*
G'
"
; >779
5
&
1&
'
&.' "
&.' " "'
& "'& "
A3CC * & * C7
(
'
+ !&
#5(!$
'
& *" 5
"
" "
*
"
! *
"
@ " ++
! +
+
*
' " CA7 !
* C7
7 -"
"
&
" ?- :=
+ .' & !
"
+
&.' "
' "AC
0 > !
'"
+
" ++
+
'
7FA H
'
*
"
&
" '
& &'
&
!
& "
&
+&
'
" &
" # >>BC9D) A9B CD $
&
"
'
"&
" ""
&
& & " "&
"
(( , (I J ;> / E(
2 & !
&&' & +
@
" = & "
+
*
& '"
9 &
+
2 &
"
"
&
& & "
&
+
+
&.' " "
& ' "
+
*
!
& + " "' " & &
' " ' +
&
+&
'
+
+
'"
&"
+
" ++
"
' " ! "
' "&
&
"
' &'
"
&
"
""
'"
&
! +
'"
#
$&
&
'&
&
"
"
*
&
"
'
!
+
'
+
& &'
#$
Area2
Area1
@
C77 +
&
+&
+'
' !
+
*
# $
-
6 ' - ! * &
/
1 # $ "
'"
+
'"
&
#"$
+
E
#&$
'"
'"
'"
> #"$
' " -F7
" @ ?C
&
+&
&
#6 '
"&
@ "&
&
" ++
+
+ '+&
" " ++
+ ' "
"
" &
& "
' )"&
+
# $
'
'
"
3!
"
#
"
"
"
& "
"
"
$
"&
' " F7 777
#
>$
$ # &'(
&
&
"
>&
"
=
& "
+
&
&
+
> !
+&
& & "
' " "'
( #&
+
'
"
6 '
1 @ ' *
6 ' F !
AA8 +
5' "
&
" ?C7
' "
+
&
+
"
"
+
"
'
'
'
" ""
" &
"
'
+
@
&
' " ' +
& + "
"# $ %#&
!
#&$
&
"
A " C !
"&
+ +
"
&&' & +
" C78 +
>
"
&
+&
&
'
+&
"
&
"
- &$ !
=
' "
+
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
81
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
Buildings
Grass
Roads
Soil
Trees
6 ' A (
'+&
>
+
!
>
'"
6 ' ;
+&
'
+
,
6
>
6 ' C
1 +
!
'"
>
6 ' ?
+&
'
6
!
#
+
6'
&
&&' &
+&
"
& :
+
,
/
6
+
"'
& "&
+&
&
" $
&
+&
+
+
@ & "
&
" +
+
&
+&
'
' "
&&' & +
+ ,
+
&
+&
.
*
>
6 ' F
-
+&
"# $ %#&
! &
+&
1 @ ' *
'
&
?
+
+
&
& "
'
'
' )"&
'
"&
'
+&
&
C-8 +
' "
!
"
@
"
' "+ * "
+&
!
&
+&
&
" "
'
&
" ! &
&
+&
+
"
&
"
"
&
"
&
+ "
"
&
" "
'
"
&
+ "
&
"
+
"0
"
!
"
"
&
"
&
!
"
& &"
+
"
&
"&
2
&
+
.'
@
= !
"
"
&
"
2
+
"2 &
'
6
'
" &
& & '" "
"
& &
' " '&& +'
&
+&
'
+*
"
" &&' &
&
+&
'
' " 78 6'
&
' "
+'
&
+&
&&' &
&
+
$
6
&
+
( #&
*
+
"
'
"
6 '
+
& '" '
;
&
&&' &
" FC8 +
"
6 '
+
"?
"
"
+&
+
!
&
>
'
+&
+
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
82
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
!
&
'
"
&
/
+
'
& &
"
&
' & +
" #
$ "
/ E(
"
+
@&
&
&(
(
# (($
2 & (( ,
(I J ;> !
'
'"
1&
'
& *" 5
" +
"
*
"
"
5
/
6
K * /
>77?
+ !1 +
"
( 3
5 2
:'
!
-> ,
* L M
: : N 5
+&
+ *
,
*
:
"(
I
" )
& E 2 &
99;
(
-OA)>
& 1
*
5
"
"
5-
&
" ("
+
*
( 3
I
9O>F
"77>
*
/ =
(
'
,5
>C9++
)
( "'&
" *
"E
999
*
&
P
CA3F?O?>
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
83
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
!
'
*
*
"
&
& .' /
"
&
#
+
&.'
*
"(
&
& '"
"
'+&
"
"
*
"
"
&
+
"
"
5
"
' "
& (
'
* "
&
"
"
&&'
"
"
& &
++ &
&
+
"
+
*
" +
"&
&
+&
#
"
$+
"&
"
"
&
' * "&
4 " $
"
& "
&
3 ' "
"
"
+ ' " 78
&
+&
"
&
"
&
"
!
"
"
" (1 '
' "
"
"
+
"
+ &
'+& &
"
&
&
"
*
" #:'
")
!
&
&
"
'
+
+
& "
#)
& "
+
" ++
+
' " -78 #
&
" ++
&
&
& +
+
" ++
"
'
+
& '"
"
*
&
&
&
+
+ '
"
'
+
& '"
+
&
*
"'&
&
"
"
"
'
3
"
.'
&
" (
&
.'
&
+&
& .'
'
"
"
)
"
#5
&
+
*
"
"
"
>77?$
+&
&
"
*
+
"
&
+
+
"'&
"'&
&&'
&
+&
&
" #
&
!
&
'
!
' "+
"
+
&
'
+&
&
+
<
'
&
"
1 ! 1 @ ' *
"&
&
+&
-
+&
&
&
&
"
6
+
&
"
"
"
"
"&
!
&
+&
"'& "
"
$
&
"
"
%
"
" & '
+
&
>
!
&
" ++
"
+
& .'
'&
+
" <
>77> " ++
"
& &
++ &
(
+ ' "
<
*
"
"'&
"&
+
4
+ #
>77>$
"
"
+
"'
&&'
*
'"
"
" /,
' "
+
!
& '" "
"
999$ !
*
+
"
" 779$ !
"
"
+
""
' " ++ &
"&
&
$ &
+
+
" &&'
"
" # !10 1$
&
+& &
"
' "+
"&
&
+&
&
' "
*
$
++ & "
+
' "
&
& +
2 & '+& !
++ &
" '
"
'
+
+&
&
&
"
&
+*
(
& .'
' "
&
+
+
(
"
"
*
&
(
" ++
&
+
" &
+
!
"
&
+&
+
& '" "
"
&
+ "
!
"
+ "
"
"'& " '
&
'
3 $
&
"
" &
+&
'"
&
'
" &
5'
'
+
&
6
" ++
" &
&
&
#
$ "
!
'
' &
&
" '
"
&
# * $ &.'
'+& '
& "
+
&
*
"
"
#)
999$ !
" + *
"
+
&
" &
*
&
& # '&
'+&
$ +' &
& &
&
"
&
*
99;$
+
-
$%
#*
'+&
&
*
"
'"
"
-
#
&
,
"0
"
& &
+&
&
*
"
)
"
&
!
@ & "
&'
'
+
'
& +
&
+
"&
+&
.'
' " +
"
"&
+
!
& "
'
#1* $
&
&
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
79
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
& "'&
'
"
"
&
" &
#
+&
$
+
"
"
#1* $
+ "
&
'
" 6 '
" +
" +
!
@
(
& +
&
"
& .'
"'&
' + & 1 " # 1$ +
!
"
1
&
+ " '
" &
+&
"&
&
'
"
!
" " "
&
&
"'&
"
&
A
(
"
" &
"
& " &
"
" ' "
'
+
@
& & '" "
'
+
'"
& '"
!
+
&
+
&
&
-
&
" +'
"
&
!
' "
+
&
&
+
& "
"# $ %#&
&
&
" &
&
&
+
+&
+&
"
+
&
"
+
'
<
"
& '"
+
+ *
'
"
!
!
!
&
"
+
"
"
"
&
.'
=
+
' "
+
&
!
&
"@
+
&
*
"
"
.'
"
+<
"
"
+
"
! 1 @ ' *
"
' " &
+
"
+ "
'
&
!
'
+
&
+&
& "'& " '
& +'
@
&
'
"
' "
& .'
&
+
"&
'
$ # &'( #
"# $ %#&
LiDAR Point Clouds
!
"
'
"
+
&
+
*
"
Point Data Interpolation
(Raster Conversion)
Digital Surface Model
(DSM)
"
+
" !
& '"
"
&
(
-
>
& "'
+
6 ' > !
& "' &
++
+
"
&
&
!
"
&
&
+
+
+
&
+
"
"
&
+ "
"
&
" "
'
& "
!
"
&
+ "
" + " "
& (
"
& &"
"
&
"
"
' &
+ " (
+ '
' &
+ "
"
"
"
' " &
'
+
& .'
" + "+
!
&&' &
&
+&
'
' "
'
Elevation points
Intensity Image
(Intensity)
&
& " )* #
" &
"
&
Data Separation
Intensity points
$
"
Layers Combination
Multi-layer images
Classification Process
Classified Images
6 ' > *
Accuracy Assessment
6 '
!
6
*
'
"
+
+
*
6
" "
& '" ! +
+&
(( +
&
@
+
+
!
=
"(
&
&
&
"
&
"
.'
& 6
&
1 @ '
+&
& .'
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
+&
+ "
@
= +
+&
+
*
"
$
' " &
,
'" 6
&
"
+
+
+
+
"
#'
"
"
80
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
"
'
'
"&
!
2
"
+ "
"
"
&
&
+
&
+ "
&
"
&
"
& "
"
"
!
&
' &
+ "
"
& &" "
"
& ' &
+ " "
'"
"
2
&
+
' ' "
' +
!
& "'& "
&
!
&
"
' &
+ "
"2 &
&
+ "
!
&
&
' "'
#' &
+ "
$ ! +
'
+
&
+&
'
& +'
@
&
' "
"
+
&
' "
+
& +
&
'
"
&
+
+
!
&)*, ('#
'"
&
!
'"
5'
5
6 ' #"- $ !
'&
F77
+
+
" @ -C7
+
'"
!
& "
6 ' - "$
#
' "
# '&
!
*
G'
"
; >779
5
&
1&
'
&.' "
&.' " "'
& "'& "
A3CC * & * C7
(
'
+ !&
#5(!$
'
& *" 5
"
" "
*
"
! *
"
@ " ++
! +
+
*
' " CA7 !
* C7
7 -"
"
&
" ?- :=
+ .' & !
"
+
&.' "
' "AC
0 > !
'"
+
" ++
+
'
7FA H
'
*
"
&
" '
& &'
&
!
& "
&
+&
'
" &
" # >>BC9D) A9B CD $
&
"
'
"&
" ""
&
& & " "&
"
(( , (I J ;> / E(
2 & !
&&' & +
@
" = & "
+
*
& '"
9 &
+
2 &
"
"
&
& & "
&
+
+
&.' " "
& ' "
+
*
!
& + " "' " & &
' " ' +
&
+&
'
+
+
'"
&"
+
" ++
"
' " ! "
' "&
&
"
' &'
"
&
"
""
'"
&
! +
'"
#
$&
&
'&
&
"
"
*
&
"
'
!
+
'
+
& &'
#$
Area2
Area1
@
C77 +
&
+&
+'
' !
+
*
# $
-
6 ' - ! * &
/
1 # $ "
'"
+
'"
&
#"$
+
E
#&$
'"
'"
'"
> #"$
' " -F7
" @ ?C
&
+&
&
#6 '
"&
@ "&
&
" ++
+
+ '+&
" " ++
+ ' "
"
" &
& "
' )"&
+
# $
'
'
"
3!
"
#
"
"
"
& "
"
"
$
"&
' " F7 777
#
>$
$ # &'(
&
&
"
>&
"
=
& "
+
&
&
+
> !
+&
& & "
' " "'
( #&
+
'
"
6 '
1 @ ' *
6 ' F !
AA8 +
5' "
&
" ?C7
' "
+
&
+
"
"
+
"
'
'
'
" ""
" &
"
'
+
@
&
' " ' +
& + "
"# $ %#&
!
#&$
&
"
A " C !
"&
+ +
"
&&' & +
" C78 +
>
"
&
+&
&
'
+&
"
&
"
- &$ !
=
' "
+
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
81
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
Buildings
Grass
Roads
Soil
Trees
6 ' A (
'+&
>
+
!
>
'"
6 ' ;
+&
'
+
,
6
>
6 ' C
1 +
!
'"
>
6 ' ?
+&
'
6
!
#
+
6'
&
&&' &
+&
"
& :
+
,
/
6
+
"'
& "&
+&
&
" $
&
+&
+
+
@ & "
&
" +
+
&
+&
'
' "
&&' & +
+ ,
+
&
+&
.
*
>
6 ' F
-
+&
"# $ %#&
! &
+&
1 @ ' *
'
&
?
+
+
&
& "
'
'
' )"&
'
"&
'
+&
&
C-8 +
' "
!
"
@
"
' "+ * "
+&
!
&
+&
&
" "
'
&
" ! &
&
+&
+
"
&
"
"
&
"
&
+ "
"
&
" "
'
"
&
+ "
&
"
+
"0
"
!
"
"
&
"
&
!
"
& &"
+
"
&
"&
2
&
+
.'
@
= !
"
"
&
"
2
+
"2 &
'
6
'
" &
& & '" "
"
& &
' " '&& +'
&
+&
'
+*
"
" &&' &
&
+&
'
' " 78 6'
&
' "
+'
&
+&
&&' &
&
+
$
6
&
+
( #&
*
+
"
'
"
6 '
+
& '" '
;
&
&&' &
" FC8 +
"
6 '
+
"?
"
"
+&
+
!
&
>
'
+&
+
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
82
The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XL-7, 2014
ISPRS Technical Commission VII Symposium, 29 September – 2 October 2014, Istanbul, Turkey
!
&
'
"
&
/
+
'
& &
"
&
' & +
" #
$ "
/ E(
"
+
@&
&
&(
(
# (($
2 & (( ,
(I J ;> !
'
'"
1&
'
& *" 5
" +
"
*
"
"
5
/
6
K * /
>77?
+ !1 +
"
( 3
5 2
:'
!
-> ,
* L M
: : N 5
+&
+ *
,
*
:
"(
I
" )
& E 2 &
99;
(
-OA)>
& 1
*
5
"
"
5-
&
" ("
+
*
( 3
I
9O>F
"77>
*
/ =
(
'
,5
>C9++
)
( "'&
" *
"E
999
*
&
P
CA3F?O?>
This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-7-79-2014
83