Directory UMM :Data Elmu:jurnal:A:Agricultural Water Management:Vol45.Issue3.Aug2000:
Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Characterisation of hydrogen isotope pro®les in an
agroforestry system: implications for tracing
water sources of trees
Stephen S.O. Burgessa,*, Mark A. Adamsa,
Neil C. Turnerb, Brett Wardc
a
Department of Botany, University of Western Australia, Nedlands, WA 6907, Australia
b
CSIRO Plant Industry, Private Bag, Wembley, WA 6014, Australia
c
Water and Rivers Commission, 5 Bevan Street, Albany 6330, Australia
Accepted 26 April 2000
Abstract
Tracing sources of water utilised by plants is important to understand species interactions in
intercropping/agroforestry systems, particularly where species vary greatly in life-form. Isotopic
techniques are an increasingly common means to trace water sources. The distribution of stable
isotopes of water within the soil±plant±atmosphere continuum is indicative of a range of hydrologic
processes and plant functions. Before we can infer plant or other biological effects on the
distribution of isotopes we require a thorough characterisation of the environmental isotope
distribution as well as an understanding of the physical processes that determine this distribution.
Unless distinct features are recognisable in the isotopic `landscape' surrounding a plant, links
cannot be made between plant function and environment. As a means to trace water acquisition by
four Eucalyptus species in an agroforestry planting, we tested a simple `end member' approach and
a more extensive characterisation of hydrogen and deuterium distribution pro®les within an
agricultural soil in south-western Australia. Hydrogen isotope distribution within the soil was
highly uniform; an apparent result of climatic factors, soil physical properties and the ability of tree
roots to redistribute soil water. Such ®ndings have important implications for measurement
strategies and experimental design when attempting to quantify plant use of water from differing
soil sources. In the absence of large isotopic discrimination among water sources, simple `end
member' models are likely to be misleading and isotopic labelling techniques may be more
appropriate in some environments. # 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Stable isotopes; Agroforestry; Water use; Resource partitioning
*
Corresponding author. Present address: Department of Integrative Biology, University of California,
Berkeley, CA 94720, USA. Tel.: 1-510-642-1054; fax: 1-510-643-6264.
E-mail address: sburgess@socrates.berkeley.edu (S.S.O. Burgess)
0378-3774/00/$ ± see front matter # 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 3 7 8 - 3 7 7 4 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 1 0 5 - 0
230
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
1. Introduction
The practice of combining functionally distinct plant types on agricultural land has
been the subject of considerable research over the past two decades (Akinnifesi et al.,
1998). Termed `agroforestry' and generally based around a combination of woody
perennials (trees and shrubs) with herbaceous annuals (crops and pasture), such
agricultural systems are increasingly being adopted to optimise resource utilisation by
cultivated plants.
Both agronomic and ecological principles have been employed to investigate whether
agroforestry systems might be more productive and sustainable than monocultures as a
result of closer coupling between the use and availability of resources (Sanchez, 1995).
The role of water is of key importance. In terms of sustainability, Sadler and Turner
(1994) argued that if amounts of rainfall, irrigation and water stored in soil exceed that
used by plants, surplus water will lead to land degradation by erosion, waterlogging and
salinisation. A clear example can be seen in regions of southern Australia, where the
replacement of functionally complex native vegetation with agricultural crops has
increased waterlogging (Cox and McFarlane, 1995) and groundwater recharge with
resultant salinisation of soils and waterways (Walker et al., 1993). If plants are able to
utilise a larger fraction of available water, particularly in environments where water is
limited, greater yield and less recharge should result (McIntyre et al., 1997; Wallace et al.,
1999).
The role of agroforestry in increasing the amount of water used for plant growth and
reducing environmentally damaging, surplus water, hinges on a central concept that
functionally distinct plant types differ in their resource requirements. If resource
requirements among plant types are complementary, the set of resources used in a
functionally complex agricultural system will be greater than that used by a monocrop
(Cannell et al., 1996; Narain et al., 1998). There is evidence that resource use is increased
under agroforestry systems (Vandermeer et al., 1998), however more research on the
basic biophysical processes that dictate resource partitioning among, and acquisition by,
different plant types is needed (Rao et al., 1997). For this, both the availability of water
resources and the ability of plants to acquire them need to be measured.
One way to identify different water resources and investigate their availability to plants
is to measure the variation in the relative abundance of the stable isotopic species that
comprise water (hydrogen, deuterium 16O and 18O) (Smith et al., 1997). The distribution
of these isotopes in soil is influenced by the numerous physical and chemical processes
that govern the hydrologic cycle. Temperature, altitude and distance from the ocean/site
of evaporation alter the isotopic composition of rainfall (Dawson, 1993b). Rainfall
reaching land surfaces is subject to immediate evaporation and the remaining water
percolates through bulk soil in response to gravity, where soil texture influences the rates
of diffusion and convection of the water and its constituent isotopes (Barnes and Allison,
1984). Evaporation of soil water enriches the remaining water in heavier isotopic forms
since light fractions evaporate most readily. The influence of evaporation is greatest close
to the soil surface, thus creating a profile of declining enrichment with depth. However,
migration of water vapour (depleted in heavy isotopes) through the soil atmosphere via
diffusion partially offsets the enrichment caused by evaporation and may actually deplete
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
231
water of heavy isotopes at the soil surface. The net result of these opposing processes is
that the maximum enrichment of water with heavy isotopes may be some distance below
the evaporation front (Barnes and Allison, 1984). In contrast to the physical processes
governing the distribution of isotopes of water within soil, mechanisms of water uptake
by plants are non-fractionating (see Turner et al. (1987) and references therein). Hence,
uptake of water by plant roots will alter the amount, but not the isotopic composition, of
remaining water in the soil. As a result of these processes, spatial and temporal variations
in isotope abundance are common throughout most soil profiles. Once characterised,
these variations can be used to infer the contribution of particular water sources to plant
hydrology (Dawson et al., 1998).
We explored the utility of isotope (H/D) analyses to indirectly determine if tree roots
reached groundwater or exploited only soil water. Since trees at our site exhibited
`hydraulic redistribution' of soil water (Burgess et al., 1998), we also aimed to test
whether this process influenced the isotopic composition of water in surface layers, thus
indicating the lateral extent of tree roots into the cropping zone.
2. Methods
2.1. Site description
The site was located 11 km west of Katanning, 280 km south east of Perth in southwestern Australia (338450 S, 1178270 E, see Fig. 1). The area has a Mediterranean-type
climate characterised by cool wet winters and hot dry summers. Annual rainfall is
485 mm (116 days of rain), whilst class A pan evaporation is 1826 mm. Seasonal rainfall
distribution at Katanning is shown in Fig. 2. Amount-weight isotopic composition (dD) of
rainfall for three sites in south-western Australia (marked in Fig. 1) is shown in Table 1.
The soil profile at Katanning is duplex (Typic Palexerult, USDA Soil Taxonomy) with
an A horizon of loamy medium sand to clayey coarse sand (generally to 50 cm) underlain
by a B horizon of medium to light clay with 10 to 20% smooth faced lateritic gravel at
depth. The textural/permeability contrast between upper and lower soil horizons causes
discontinuous hydraulic properties that can lead to transient waterlogging. Water tends to
pond at the base of the sandy A horizon, since the clay B horizon has extremely low
permeability that restricts water entry (Tennant et al., 1992; Cox and McFarlane, 1995).
In an attempt to reduce episodic waterlogging as well as groundwater recharge, mixed
8 m wide belts of Eucalyptus trees (Eucalyptus saligna Smith, Eucalyptus camaldulensis
Table 1
Summary of isotopic data collected for rainfall at three sites (see Fig. 1) in south-western Australia
Sample
dD (%)
Amount weighted monthly rainfall (Perth 1983±1995) (J. Turner, personal communication, 1999)
Amount-weighted rainfall (Salmon catchment, Collie WA, 1985, Turner et al., 1987)
Amount weighted rainfall (Susannah Brook catchment, Gidgegannup WA, 1987)
(Turner and Macpherson, 1990)
ÿ18.1
ÿ19.5
ÿ24.5
232
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Fig. 1. The location of the research site in relation to sites for which the isotopic composition of rainfall has
been measured.
Dehnh., Eucalyptus leucoxylon F. Muell and Eucalyptus platypus Hook) were planted in
1986. Tree belts were planted immediately downslope from interceptor drains spaced
100±200 m along contour lines to intercept subsurface water flow. The trees had an
average height of 5.5 m in September 1997 (White et al., 2000). Between tree belts,
Fig. 2. The pattern of rainfall distribution of Katanning.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
233
canola and cereals were cropped in rotation with lucerne (Medicago sativa L.) and
subterranean clover (Trifolium subterranean L.) pastures.
2.2. Sample collection
2.2.1. `End member' study
The first study was performed in November 1997, when the predawn leaf water
potentials in E. camaldulensis, E. leucoxylon and E. platypus were ÿ0.7, ÿ1.6 and
ÿ2.2 MPa, respectively (White et al., 2000). Under the `end member' model (Dawson,
1993a), groundwater and either rainwater or shallow soil water are considered as two
potential and discrete `end member' sources of which a plant may use as a mixture. If the
isotopic signature (dD) of the water sources differ, the contribution of each source to the
dD of plant xylem sap can be calculated. This approach has been used successfully in a
number of studies, mainly in North America (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1991; Ehleringer
et al., 1991; Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson, 1998; Dodd et al., 1998). Samples
of groundwater (at approximately 5±7 m depth) were taken from dip-wells beneath
trees at four positions along a tree belt. Dip-well positions were 20 m apart along the
contour line on which the tree belt was planted. Perched water (at 0.5 m depth)
was collected at two positions from shallow piezometers adjacent to the dip-wells.
Topsoil (0±20 cm depth) was collected directly beneath trees at positions coinciding with
the dip-wells. A 30 g soil sub-sample was sealed in an airtight vial. The dD of water in
topsoil was presumed to represent the integrated dD signals of recent rain events
(modified partly by evaporation) and the source of water available to fine roots in the
topsoil.
At four positions coinciding with dip-wells, xylem sap was extracted from suberised
stems (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1993) of two specimens of each of the four Eucalyptus
species. Stems were harvested with pruning shears and the cut end of each stem placed in
the open mouth of a plastic vial. A hypodermic needle attached to a vacuum hose was
also placed into the vial. Mouldable putty was used to seal the stem and needle around the
mouth of the vial. A hand vacuum was used to create a mild vacuum in the vial. To aid
displacement of sap by vacuum, the length of the stem section was progressively pruned
to reduce capillary tension in the xylem (Bollard, 1960).
Root bases of the lucerne plants were also harvested to provide an indication of topsoil
water dD in the field adjacent to the tree belt.
2.2.2. Detailed soil analysis
A second study involving more detailed soil analysis was then performed in February
1998, when the predawn leaf water potentials in E. camaldulensis, E. leucoxylon and E.
platypus were ÿ0.9, ÿ2.8 and ÿ4.1 MPa, respectively (White et al., 2000). Vertical
profiles were sampled at the positions beneath the belt of trees using a rotary, air-blast
drilling rig. A third profile was sampled approximately 50 m distant to the tree belt in the
adjacent pasture. Heavy clay sub-soils prevented the use of other means of soil sampling.
Care was taken to immediately collect samples from within clumps of spoil. Soil was
collected at depth intervals of 20 cm from 0±200 cm and at 50 cm intervals from thereon
until groundwater was reached.
234
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Soil was also collected from three horizontal transects at a depth of 20 cm using a hand
auger. Samples were taken every 30 cm along each transect to a distance of 3 m from the
tree belt. From thereon, soil was sampled every 60 cm to a distance of 9 m
(approximately 1(1/2) tree heights).
Care was taken with all samples to avoid isotopic fractionation by evaporation during
collection and all samples were stored frozen.
2.3. Extraction of water from soil samples
Soil water was extracted from soil by cryogenic vacuum distillation (Ehleringer and
Osmond, 1989). Two Vycor glass tubes were attached to a vacuum pump in Y-shape
configuration. Approximately 15 g of soil was placed in one tube and frozen by
submerging the tube in liquid nitrogen. Both tubes were evacuated and then isolated from
the vacuum line to create a closed U-shape configuration. The tube containing the sample
was placed in boiling water, whilst the second tube was placed in liquid nitrogen to `trap'
water evaporating from the heated sample. After 1 h, the collection tube was removed and
sealed. After thawing, the collected water was decanted into an airtight vessel.
2.4. Preparation of samples for mass spectrometry
Water samples were reduced to hydrogen gas for analysis using a gas phase mass
spectrometer (VG Isogas SIRA 10). Granulated zinc reactant (0.4 g) was dried by heating
under vacuum and placed in a Vycor reaction tube back-filled with nitrogen gas. A 0.2 ml
aliquot of sample was added and then frozen with the catalyst by immersing the tube in
liquid nitrogen. The nitrogen gas was then evacuated from the reaction tube and the tube
sealed before heating at 5008C for 1 h.
Hydrogen/deuterium ratios (dD) were expressed according to standard notation in parts
per thousand relative to the VSMOW (Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water) standard.
D=Hsample
ÿ 1 1000
dD
D=Hstandard
3. Results
3.1. `End member' study
Comparison of the dD values of water from topsoil beneath the trees and those of
groundwater indicated that water from topsoil was enriched in deuterium relative to
groundwater by 8% (Table 2). Perched groundwater dD was intermediate to that of soil
water or deeper groundwater (see Table 2). Water extracted from the root base of lucerne
plants showed greater enrichment in deuterium than that of topsoil collected beneath the
trees by 10% (Table 3).
At the time of the study (November 1997), the trees were moderately short of water
(White et al., 2000). The dD of xylem sap of E. camaldulensis, E. saligna, E. leucoxylon
235
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Table 2
The dD (standard error) of different water sources at different depths within a duplex soil pro®le at Katanning,
November 1997
Sample
n
Depth of source (m)
dD (%)
Topsoil water
Perched water
Groundwater
4
2
7
0.2
1
3.5±7.6
ÿ21.111.00
ÿ24.262.19
ÿ29.530.53
Fig. 3. The dD of water from soil collected at different depths in the soil pro®le beneath either a belt of eucalypt
trees (A and B) or lucerne pasture (C) during February 1998. Grey bars indicated the range of groundwater dD
values measured during November 1997.
236
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Table 3
Average (standard error) dD values of xylem sap extracted from stems of four Eucalypt species and roots of
lucerne (M. sativa) at Katanning, November 1997
Specimen
Sample
n
dD (%)
E. camaldulensis
E. saligna
E. leucoxylon
E. platypus
M. sativa
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Root xylem sap
6
7
8
7
2
ÿ23.081.92
ÿ23.891.26
ÿ22.911.94
ÿ20.271.82
ÿ11.451.11
Fig. 4. The dD of water from soil collected at 20 cm depth along three transects (A±C) perpendicular to a belt of
eucalypt trees during February 1998.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
237
and E. platypus ranged from ÿ20 to ÿ24% (Table 3). These values were significantly
different (p0.05) from dD of topsoil water (ÿ21.11%) or perched water
(ÿ24.26%).
3.2. Detailed soil analysis
At the time of the detailed soil analysis, the predawn water potentials in leaves of the
trees at the site were at their lowest in 3 years of study (White et al., 2000). Thus the soils
were extremely dry. Data from the two vertical profiles beneath the belt of trees and one
profile beneath pasture are shown in Fig. 3A±C. The dD profiles showed little trend with
depth, centering on a value of approximately ÿ30%, with the exception of the surface
(20 cm) values, which had a value of approximately ÿ50%. The three horizontal profiles
(Fig. 4A±C) showed no clear trend with distance from the tree belt and there was
considerable spatial variation (e.g. see especially Fig. 4B).
4. Discussion
4.1. `End member' study
In isolation from the data collected during the detailed soil analysis, the initial `end
member' data suggested that groundwater and soil water had a different isotopic
composition. In addition, water from topsoil collected beneath trees showed greater
similarity to groundwater than did topsoil water under pasture as indicated by lucerne
xylem sap (Table 3). These data were consistent with the hypothesis that some water in
the surface soil under the trees had been `lifted' by the trees. Dawson (1993a) drew such a
conclusion on the basis of similar measurements of topsoil under Acer saccharum. During
the dry conditions of November, tree hydration appeared to be at least partly due to
sources of water other than groundwater. However, Brunel et al. (1995) state that the error
for dD techniques (including sample extraction, analysis, etc.) is 5%, hence an attempt
to distinguish between `end members' that differ less than 10% may be beyond the
sensitivity of the technique.
4.2. Detailed soil analysis
The uniformity of dD values for water from soil at different depths within the profile
was not expected, either from the results of the first study or from theoretical predictions.
For example, the predicted enrichment of deuterium in water near the soil surface (Barnes
and Allison, 1984) was not observed. Our chosen sample interval (every 20 cm to a depth
of 2 m) may have been too coarse to elucidate the enrichment profile. However, Turner
et al. (1987) sampled at less frequent intervals than in our study and demonstrated the
predicted surface enrichment. Our results, however, indicate a depletion maximum (as
predicted by Barnes and Allison (1984)) near the soil surface (see Fig. 3A and C) in
contrast to the results of Turner et al. (1987). A feature common to our data and that of
238
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Turner et al. (1987) was the nearly uniform dD values of the unsaturated zone at depth.
These values were also similar to those of groundwater, making inferences regarding the
source of water used by plants difficult.
At sites where there are large variations in the dD values (in some cases, >100%) of
potential sources of water (including snowmelt and fog water as well as rainfall, soil
water and groundwater), researchers have been able to apportion the water taken up by
plants among the various sources (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1991; Ehleringer et al., 1991;
Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson, 1998). Comparable studies in southern
Australia have typically found much smaller ranges of dD (Thorburn and Walker, 1994;
Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson and Pate, 1996; Bleby et al., 1997) reducing the
scope within which to discriminate differing water sources. Turner et al. (1987), for
example, found the average dD of shallow groundwater in the Salmon catchment (Collie,
see Fig. 1) showed little variation at ÿ21.01.0 (n70). Furthermore, at a number of
sites in south-western Australia, dD values of soil water are uniform throughout the soil
profile and differ little from groundwater (Turner et al., 1987; Farrington et al., 1996).
Turner et al. (1987) suggested that the isotopically uniform profiles of lateritic soils in
south-western Australia result from good mixing of isotopically variable rainfall during
recharge. In view of the findings of Burgess et al. (1998) that root systems of trees
transfer water between soil layers in response to gradients in water potential, we suggest
that plant roots contribute to the mixing of water within the profile by redistributing
water. For example, measurements of soil moisture at Katanning demonstrated that water
redistributed from shallow soil layers to deeper layers (1.8±2.6 m) by tree roots increased
soil moisture content by up to 2.8%, 1 month after break of season in 1998 (Burgess et al.,
2000). On a v/v basis, up to 14% of the water contained in deep soil layers was water
from the topsoil transferred by plants. Lucerne roots would probably also redistribute
water to some extent since previous studies have shown that this species also exhibits
hydraulic lift (Caldwell et al., 1998). Clearly, extant dD discrimination between subsoil
and surface soil water would have been reduced by up to 14%, by mixing resulting from
water transfer by plant roots.
Much of the annual rainfall at Katanning would probably have a dD similar to the
mean weighted values recorded at other sites in south-western Australia (Table 1), but
perhaps further depleted due to the inland position of Katanning (Dawson, 1993b). The
importance of large winter rain events (see Fig. 2) to soil recharge probably contributed to
the uniformity of soil water dD within the profile. Mixing due to the action of root
systems would further homogenise the dD values of water in the soil profile. Exchange
among water sources by hydraulic redistribution should have most impact where sources
within the soil profile have markedly different water potentials. The strongly seasonal
rainfall distribution of Katanning's Mediterranean-type climate favours the establishment
of strong gradients in water potential between water sources. A further possibility is that
the hydraulic discontinuity between the A horizon (sand) and subsequent horizons (clay)
isolates these parts of the soil profile (>50 cm deep) from the fractionating process of
evaporation, but not to extraction of water by plants (which is non-fractionating).
Horizontal transects showed no apparent trend in dD of topsoil water with distance
from trees. dD of topsoil water were both more enriched and more depleted in deuterium
than groundwater. This finding is not surprising given that both maximum and minimum
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
239
enrichment may be found in the upper few centimetres of the soil profile (Barnes and
Allison, 1984). Spatial heterogeneity of soil characteristics and microclimate add to this
complexity (Le Roux et al., 1995). Duplex soils have a characteristically variable
subsurface relief, leading to significant spatial variation in the depth boundaries between
horizons (Tennant et al., 1992). Such variability will increase the difficulty of measuring
the influence of `hydraulic lift' on soil water dD. The dD of topsoil water collected during
the November study (Table 2) was more uniform than that collected in February, probably
as a result of rainfall (5 mm) in November, and suggests that further drying serves to
increase heterogeneity in topsoil dD.
Unlike the results of Dawson (1993a), which clearly demonstrated that water exudation
from roots of Acer saccharum modified the dD of topsoil water as a function of distance
from tree (and decreasing root length density), our data were inconclusive. The absence
of a clear dD discrimination among water sources, coupled with variable dD of topsoil
water in the sand horizon of the duplex soils at our site, prevented the tracing of the
acquisition and redistribution of water sources by the trees.
5. Conclusions
Non-destructive methods for assessing potential complementarity in patterns of water
extraction among species are limited. Isotopic techniques have the potential to indirectly
assess resource access by plant roots. However, we conclude that these techniques are
difficult to apply at sites where uniformity of dD with soil depth, heterogeneity at the
surface level or limited range of dD among differing water sources exist. Measurements
of `end member' water sources alone provide insufficient information regarding the
spatial variability of dD in the soil profile and are potentially misleading. Robust
characterisation of spatial variation in the natural abundance of stable isotopes must be
undertaken when using environmental isotope techniques. In environments where
insufficient isotopic discrimination exists among water sources, labelling techniques such
the application of deuterium enriched water either by irrigation or direct injection into
plant tissues may be more appropriate.
Clearly, much research effort will be required to characterise the belowground
functioning of woody perennials so as to predict their effects on the productivity and
sustainability of agroforestry systems. Until new methods are developed, it is likely that
root excavations and measurements of soil moisture will remain the basic tools to
investigate the belowground resource acquisition by different plant functional types.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Australian Centre for International Agricultural
Research. Support for S.S.O.B. was provided by the Western Australian Department of
Conservation and Land Management. We thank Drs Jeff Turner and Don White (CSIRO)
for reviewing an earlier version of this paper and suggesting improvements. We are
grateful to Todd Dawson for advice and assistance with sample collection and analysis
240
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
and Lidia Bednarek performed the mass spectrometry. Frank Dunin, Phil Ward, Shane
Micin and Gerald Watson assisted with sample collection. The Grains Research and
Development Corporation and Agriculture Western Australia contributed to site
establishment and maintenance.
References
Akinnifesi, F.K., Kang, B.T., Ladipo, D.O., 1998. Structural root form and ®ne root distribution of some woody
species evaluated for agroforestry systems. Agrofor. Syst. 42, 121±138.
Barnes, C.J., Allison, G.B., 1984. The distribution of deuterium and oxygen-18 in dry soils. 3. Theory for nonisothermal water movement. J. Hydrol. 74, 119±136.
Bleby, T.M., Aucote, M., Kennettsmith, A.K., Walker, G.R., Schachtman, D.P., 1997. Seasonal water use
characteristics of tall wheatgrass [Agropyron elongatum (Host) Beauv.] in a saline environment. Plant Cell
Environ. 20, 1361±1371.
Bollard, E.G., 1960. Transport in the xylem. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 11, 141±166.
Brunel, J.P., Walker, G.R., Kennett Smith, A.K., 1995. Field validation of isotopic procedures for determining
sources of water used by plants in a semi-arid environment. J. Hydrol. 167, 351±368.
Burgess, S.S.O., Adams, M.A., Turner, N.C., Ong, C.K., 1998. The redistribution of soil water by tree root
systems. Oecologia 115, 306±311.
Burgess, S.S.O., Turner, N.C., Adams, M.A., White, D.A., Ong, C.K., 2000. Tree roots, conduits for deep
recharge of soil water. Oecologia, in press.
Caldwell, M.M., Dawson, T.E., Richards, J.H., 1998. Hydraulic lift Ð consequences of water ef¯ux from the
roots of plants. Oecologia 113, 151±161.
Cannell, M.G.R., Vannoordwijk, M., Ong, C.K., 1996. The central agroforestry hypothesis Ð the trees must
acquire resources that the crop would not otherwise acquire. Agrofor. Syst. 34, 27±31.
Cox, J.W., McFarlane, D.J., 1995. The causes of waterlogging in shallow soils and their drainage in
southwestern Australia. J. Hydrol. 167, 175±194.
Dawson, T.E., 1993a. Hydraulic lift and water use by plants: implications for water balance, performance and
plant±plant interactions. Oecologia 95, 565±574.
Dawson, T.E., 1993b. Water sources of plants as determined from xylem-water isotopic composition:
perspectives on plant competition, distribution and water relations. In: Ehleringer, J.R., Hall, A.E., Farquhar,
G.D. (Eds.), Stable Isotopes and Plant Carbon/Water Relations. Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 465±496.
Dawson, T.E., 1998. Fog in the California redwood forest: ecosystem inputs and use by plants. Oecologia 117,
476±485.
Dawson, T.E., Ehleringer, J.R., 1991. Streamside trees that do not use stream water. Nature 350, 335±337.
Dawson, T.E., Ehleringer, J.R., 1993. Isotopic enrichment of water in the woody tissues of plants Ð implications
for plant water source, water uptake, and other studies which use the stable isotopic composition of cellulose.
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 57, 3487±3492.
Dawson, T.E., Pate, J.S., 1996. Seasonal water uptake and movement in root systems of Australian
phraeatophytic plants of dimorphic root morphology: a stable isotope investigation. Oecologia 107, 13±20.
Dawson, T.E., Pausch, R.C., Parker, H.M., 1998. The role of hydrogen and oxygen stable isotopes in
understanding water movement along the soil±plant±atmosphere continuum. In: Grif®ths, H. (Ed.), Stable
Isotopes: Integration of Biological, Ecological and Geochemical Processes. BIOS Scienti®c Publishers,
Oxford, pp. 169±183.
Dodd, M.B., Lauenroth, W.K., Welker, J.M., 1998. Differential water resource use by herbaceous and woody
plant life-forms in a shortgrass steppe community. Oecologia 117, 504±512.
Ehleringer, J.R., Osmond, C.B., 1989. Stable isotopes. In: Pearcy, R.W., Ehleringer, J.R., Mooney, H.A.,
Rundell, P.W. (Eds.), Plant Physiological Ecology: Field Methods and Instrumentation. Chapman & Hall,
London, pp. 281±300.
Ehleringer, J.R., Phillips, S.L., Schuster, W.S.F., Sandquist, D.R., 1991. Differential utilization of summer rains
by desert plants. Oecologia 88, 430±434.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
241
Farrington, P., Turner, J.V., Gailitis, V., 1996. Tracing water uptake by jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata) trees using
natural abundances of deuterium. Trees 11, 9±15.
Le Roux, X., Bariac, T., Mariotti, A., 1995. Spatial partitioning of the soil water resource between grass and
shrub components in a West African humid savanna. Oecologia 104, 147±155.
McIntyre, B.D., Riha, S.J., Ong, C.K., 1997. Competition for water in a hedge±intercrop system. Field Crops
Res. 52, 151±160.
Narain, P., Singh, R.K., Sindhwal, N.S., Joshie, P., 1998. Water balance and water use ef®ciency of different land
uses in western Himalayan valley region. Agric. Water Manage. 37, 225±240.
Rao, M.R., Nair, P.K.R., Ong, C.K., 1997. Biophysical interactions in tropical agroforestry systems. Agrofor.
Syst. 38, 3±50.
Sadler, E.J., Turner, N.C., 1994. Water relationships in a sustainable agricultural system. In: Hat®eld, J.L.,
Karlen, D.L. (Eds.), Sustainable Agriculture Systems. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, pp. 21±45.
Sanchez, P.A., 1995. Science in agroforestry. Agrofor. Syst. 30, 5±55.
Smith, D.M., Jarvis, P.G., Odongo, J.C.W., 1997. Sources of water used by trees and millet in Sahelian
windbreak systems. J. Hydrol. 198, 140±153.
Tennant, D., Scholz, G., Dixon, J., Purdie, B., 1992. Physical and chemical characteristics of duplex soils and
their distribution in the south-west of Western Australia. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. 32, 827±843.
Thorburn, P.J., Ehleringer, J.R., 1995. Root water uptake of ®eld-growing plants indicated by measurements of
natural-abundance deuterium. Plant Soil 177, 225±233.
Thorburn, P.J., Walker, G.R., 1994. Variation in stream water uptake by Eucalyptus camaldulensis with differing
access to stream water. Oecologia 100, 293±301.
Turner, J.V., Macpherson, D.K., 1990. Mechanisms affecting stream¯ow and streamwater quality: an approach
via stable isotope, hydrogeochemical and time series analysis. Water Resources Res. 26, 3005±3019.
Turner, J.V., Arad, A., Johnston, C.D., 1987. Environmental isotope hydrology of salinized experimental
catchments. J. Hydrol. 94, 89±108.
Vandermeer, J., Vannoordwijk, M., Anderson, J., Ong, C., Perfecto, I., 1998. Global change and multi-species
agroecosystems Ð concepts and issues. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 67, 1±22.
Walker, J., Bullen, F., Williams, B.G., 1993. Ecohydrological changes in the Murray-Darling basin. I. The
number of trees cleared over two centuries. J. Appl. Ecol. 30, 265±273.
Wallace, J.S., Jackson, N.A., Ong, C.K., 1999. Modelling soil evaporation in an agroforestry system in Kenya.
Agric. For. Meteorol. 94, 189±202.
White, D.A., Turner, N.C., Galbraith, J.H., 2000. Shoot water relations and stomatal behaviour of four allopatric
Eucalyptus species planted in Mediterranean south-western Australia: implications for water use models,
Aust. J. Plant Physiol., in press.
Characterisation of hydrogen isotope pro®les in an
agroforestry system: implications for tracing
water sources of trees
Stephen S.O. Burgessa,*, Mark A. Adamsa,
Neil C. Turnerb, Brett Wardc
a
Department of Botany, University of Western Australia, Nedlands, WA 6907, Australia
b
CSIRO Plant Industry, Private Bag, Wembley, WA 6014, Australia
c
Water and Rivers Commission, 5 Bevan Street, Albany 6330, Australia
Accepted 26 April 2000
Abstract
Tracing sources of water utilised by plants is important to understand species interactions in
intercropping/agroforestry systems, particularly where species vary greatly in life-form. Isotopic
techniques are an increasingly common means to trace water sources. The distribution of stable
isotopes of water within the soil±plant±atmosphere continuum is indicative of a range of hydrologic
processes and plant functions. Before we can infer plant or other biological effects on the
distribution of isotopes we require a thorough characterisation of the environmental isotope
distribution as well as an understanding of the physical processes that determine this distribution.
Unless distinct features are recognisable in the isotopic `landscape' surrounding a plant, links
cannot be made between plant function and environment. As a means to trace water acquisition by
four Eucalyptus species in an agroforestry planting, we tested a simple `end member' approach and
a more extensive characterisation of hydrogen and deuterium distribution pro®les within an
agricultural soil in south-western Australia. Hydrogen isotope distribution within the soil was
highly uniform; an apparent result of climatic factors, soil physical properties and the ability of tree
roots to redistribute soil water. Such ®ndings have important implications for measurement
strategies and experimental design when attempting to quantify plant use of water from differing
soil sources. In the absence of large isotopic discrimination among water sources, simple `end
member' models are likely to be misleading and isotopic labelling techniques may be more
appropriate in some environments. # 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Stable isotopes; Agroforestry; Water use; Resource partitioning
*
Corresponding author. Present address: Department of Integrative Biology, University of California,
Berkeley, CA 94720, USA. Tel.: 1-510-642-1054; fax: 1-510-643-6264.
E-mail address: sburgess@socrates.berkeley.edu (S.S.O. Burgess)
0378-3774/00/$ ± see front matter # 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 3 7 8 - 3 7 7 4 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 1 0 5 - 0
230
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
1. Introduction
The practice of combining functionally distinct plant types on agricultural land has
been the subject of considerable research over the past two decades (Akinnifesi et al.,
1998). Termed `agroforestry' and generally based around a combination of woody
perennials (trees and shrubs) with herbaceous annuals (crops and pasture), such
agricultural systems are increasingly being adopted to optimise resource utilisation by
cultivated plants.
Both agronomic and ecological principles have been employed to investigate whether
agroforestry systems might be more productive and sustainable than monocultures as a
result of closer coupling between the use and availability of resources (Sanchez, 1995).
The role of water is of key importance. In terms of sustainability, Sadler and Turner
(1994) argued that if amounts of rainfall, irrigation and water stored in soil exceed that
used by plants, surplus water will lead to land degradation by erosion, waterlogging and
salinisation. A clear example can be seen in regions of southern Australia, where the
replacement of functionally complex native vegetation with agricultural crops has
increased waterlogging (Cox and McFarlane, 1995) and groundwater recharge with
resultant salinisation of soils and waterways (Walker et al., 1993). If plants are able to
utilise a larger fraction of available water, particularly in environments where water is
limited, greater yield and less recharge should result (McIntyre et al., 1997; Wallace et al.,
1999).
The role of agroforestry in increasing the amount of water used for plant growth and
reducing environmentally damaging, surplus water, hinges on a central concept that
functionally distinct plant types differ in their resource requirements. If resource
requirements among plant types are complementary, the set of resources used in a
functionally complex agricultural system will be greater than that used by a monocrop
(Cannell et al., 1996; Narain et al., 1998). There is evidence that resource use is increased
under agroforestry systems (Vandermeer et al., 1998), however more research on the
basic biophysical processes that dictate resource partitioning among, and acquisition by,
different plant types is needed (Rao et al., 1997). For this, both the availability of water
resources and the ability of plants to acquire them need to be measured.
One way to identify different water resources and investigate their availability to plants
is to measure the variation in the relative abundance of the stable isotopic species that
comprise water (hydrogen, deuterium 16O and 18O) (Smith et al., 1997). The distribution
of these isotopes in soil is influenced by the numerous physical and chemical processes
that govern the hydrologic cycle. Temperature, altitude and distance from the ocean/site
of evaporation alter the isotopic composition of rainfall (Dawson, 1993b). Rainfall
reaching land surfaces is subject to immediate evaporation and the remaining water
percolates through bulk soil in response to gravity, where soil texture influences the rates
of diffusion and convection of the water and its constituent isotopes (Barnes and Allison,
1984). Evaporation of soil water enriches the remaining water in heavier isotopic forms
since light fractions evaporate most readily. The influence of evaporation is greatest close
to the soil surface, thus creating a profile of declining enrichment with depth. However,
migration of water vapour (depleted in heavy isotopes) through the soil atmosphere via
diffusion partially offsets the enrichment caused by evaporation and may actually deplete
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
231
water of heavy isotopes at the soil surface. The net result of these opposing processes is
that the maximum enrichment of water with heavy isotopes may be some distance below
the evaporation front (Barnes and Allison, 1984). In contrast to the physical processes
governing the distribution of isotopes of water within soil, mechanisms of water uptake
by plants are non-fractionating (see Turner et al. (1987) and references therein). Hence,
uptake of water by plant roots will alter the amount, but not the isotopic composition, of
remaining water in the soil. As a result of these processes, spatial and temporal variations
in isotope abundance are common throughout most soil profiles. Once characterised,
these variations can be used to infer the contribution of particular water sources to plant
hydrology (Dawson et al., 1998).
We explored the utility of isotope (H/D) analyses to indirectly determine if tree roots
reached groundwater or exploited only soil water. Since trees at our site exhibited
`hydraulic redistribution' of soil water (Burgess et al., 1998), we also aimed to test
whether this process influenced the isotopic composition of water in surface layers, thus
indicating the lateral extent of tree roots into the cropping zone.
2. Methods
2.1. Site description
The site was located 11 km west of Katanning, 280 km south east of Perth in southwestern Australia (338450 S, 1178270 E, see Fig. 1). The area has a Mediterranean-type
climate characterised by cool wet winters and hot dry summers. Annual rainfall is
485 mm (116 days of rain), whilst class A pan evaporation is 1826 mm. Seasonal rainfall
distribution at Katanning is shown in Fig. 2. Amount-weight isotopic composition (dD) of
rainfall for three sites in south-western Australia (marked in Fig. 1) is shown in Table 1.
The soil profile at Katanning is duplex (Typic Palexerult, USDA Soil Taxonomy) with
an A horizon of loamy medium sand to clayey coarse sand (generally to 50 cm) underlain
by a B horizon of medium to light clay with 10 to 20% smooth faced lateritic gravel at
depth. The textural/permeability contrast between upper and lower soil horizons causes
discontinuous hydraulic properties that can lead to transient waterlogging. Water tends to
pond at the base of the sandy A horizon, since the clay B horizon has extremely low
permeability that restricts water entry (Tennant et al., 1992; Cox and McFarlane, 1995).
In an attempt to reduce episodic waterlogging as well as groundwater recharge, mixed
8 m wide belts of Eucalyptus trees (Eucalyptus saligna Smith, Eucalyptus camaldulensis
Table 1
Summary of isotopic data collected for rainfall at three sites (see Fig. 1) in south-western Australia
Sample
dD (%)
Amount weighted monthly rainfall (Perth 1983±1995) (J. Turner, personal communication, 1999)
Amount-weighted rainfall (Salmon catchment, Collie WA, 1985, Turner et al., 1987)
Amount weighted rainfall (Susannah Brook catchment, Gidgegannup WA, 1987)
(Turner and Macpherson, 1990)
ÿ18.1
ÿ19.5
ÿ24.5
232
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Fig. 1. The location of the research site in relation to sites for which the isotopic composition of rainfall has
been measured.
Dehnh., Eucalyptus leucoxylon F. Muell and Eucalyptus platypus Hook) were planted in
1986. Tree belts were planted immediately downslope from interceptor drains spaced
100±200 m along contour lines to intercept subsurface water flow. The trees had an
average height of 5.5 m in September 1997 (White et al., 2000). Between tree belts,
Fig. 2. The pattern of rainfall distribution of Katanning.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
233
canola and cereals were cropped in rotation with lucerne (Medicago sativa L.) and
subterranean clover (Trifolium subterranean L.) pastures.
2.2. Sample collection
2.2.1. `End member' study
The first study was performed in November 1997, when the predawn leaf water
potentials in E. camaldulensis, E. leucoxylon and E. platypus were ÿ0.7, ÿ1.6 and
ÿ2.2 MPa, respectively (White et al., 2000). Under the `end member' model (Dawson,
1993a), groundwater and either rainwater or shallow soil water are considered as two
potential and discrete `end member' sources of which a plant may use as a mixture. If the
isotopic signature (dD) of the water sources differ, the contribution of each source to the
dD of plant xylem sap can be calculated. This approach has been used successfully in a
number of studies, mainly in North America (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1991; Ehleringer
et al., 1991; Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson, 1998; Dodd et al., 1998). Samples
of groundwater (at approximately 5±7 m depth) were taken from dip-wells beneath
trees at four positions along a tree belt. Dip-well positions were 20 m apart along the
contour line on which the tree belt was planted. Perched water (at 0.5 m depth)
was collected at two positions from shallow piezometers adjacent to the dip-wells.
Topsoil (0±20 cm depth) was collected directly beneath trees at positions coinciding with
the dip-wells. A 30 g soil sub-sample was sealed in an airtight vial. The dD of water in
topsoil was presumed to represent the integrated dD signals of recent rain events
(modified partly by evaporation) and the source of water available to fine roots in the
topsoil.
At four positions coinciding with dip-wells, xylem sap was extracted from suberised
stems (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1993) of two specimens of each of the four Eucalyptus
species. Stems were harvested with pruning shears and the cut end of each stem placed in
the open mouth of a plastic vial. A hypodermic needle attached to a vacuum hose was
also placed into the vial. Mouldable putty was used to seal the stem and needle around the
mouth of the vial. A hand vacuum was used to create a mild vacuum in the vial. To aid
displacement of sap by vacuum, the length of the stem section was progressively pruned
to reduce capillary tension in the xylem (Bollard, 1960).
Root bases of the lucerne plants were also harvested to provide an indication of topsoil
water dD in the field adjacent to the tree belt.
2.2.2. Detailed soil analysis
A second study involving more detailed soil analysis was then performed in February
1998, when the predawn leaf water potentials in E. camaldulensis, E. leucoxylon and E.
platypus were ÿ0.9, ÿ2.8 and ÿ4.1 MPa, respectively (White et al., 2000). Vertical
profiles were sampled at the positions beneath the belt of trees using a rotary, air-blast
drilling rig. A third profile was sampled approximately 50 m distant to the tree belt in the
adjacent pasture. Heavy clay sub-soils prevented the use of other means of soil sampling.
Care was taken to immediately collect samples from within clumps of spoil. Soil was
collected at depth intervals of 20 cm from 0±200 cm and at 50 cm intervals from thereon
until groundwater was reached.
234
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Soil was also collected from three horizontal transects at a depth of 20 cm using a hand
auger. Samples were taken every 30 cm along each transect to a distance of 3 m from the
tree belt. From thereon, soil was sampled every 60 cm to a distance of 9 m
(approximately 1(1/2) tree heights).
Care was taken with all samples to avoid isotopic fractionation by evaporation during
collection and all samples were stored frozen.
2.3. Extraction of water from soil samples
Soil water was extracted from soil by cryogenic vacuum distillation (Ehleringer and
Osmond, 1989). Two Vycor glass tubes were attached to a vacuum pump in Y-shape
configuration. Approximately 15 g of soil was placed in one tube and frozen by
submerging the tube in liquid nitrogen. Both tubes were evacuated and then isolated from
the vacuum line to create a closed U-shape configuration. The tube containing the sample
was placed in boiling water, whilst the second tube was placed in liquid nitrogen to `trap'
water evaporating from the heated sample. After 1 h, the collection tube was removed and
sealed. After thawing, the collected water was decanted into an airtight vessel.
2.4. Preparation of samples for mass spectrometry
Water samples were reduced to hydrogen gas for analysis using a gas phase mass
spectrometer (VG Isogas SIRA 10). Granulated zinc reactant (0.4 g) was dried by heating
under vacuum and placed in a Vycor reaction tube back-filled with nitrogen gas. A 0.2 ml
aliquot of sample was added and then frozen with the catalyst by immersing the tube in
liquid nitrogen. The nitrogen gas was then evacuated from the reaction tube and the tube
sealed before heating at 5008C for 1 h.
Hydrogen/deuterium ratios (dD) were expressed according to standard notation in parts
per thousand relative to the VSMOW (Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water) standard.
D=Hsample
ÿ 1 1000
dD
D=Hstandard
3. Results
3.1. `End member' study
Comparison of the dD values of water from topsoil beneath the trees and those of
groundwater indicated that water from topsoil was enriched in deuterium relative to
groundwater by 8% (Table 2). Perched groundwater dD was intermediate to that of soil
water or deeper groundwater (see Table 2). Water extracted from the root base of lucerne
plants showed greater enrichment in deuterium than that of topsoil collected beneath the
trees by 10% (Table 3).
At the time of the study (November 1997), the trees were moderately short of water
(White et al., 2000). The dD of xylem sap of E. camaldulensis, E. saligna, E. leucoxylon
235
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Table 2
The dD (standard error) of different water sources at different depths within a duplex soil pro®le at Katanning,
November 1997
Sample
n
Depth of source (m)
dD (%)
Topsoil water
Perched water
Groundwater
4
2
7
0.2
1
3.5±7.6
ÿ21.111.00
ÿ24.262.19
ÿ29.530.53
Fig. 3. The dD of water from soil collected at different depths in the soil pro®le beneath either a belt of eucalypt
trees (A and B) or lucerne pasture (C) during February 1998. Grey bars indicated the range of groundwater dD
values measured during November 1997.
236
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Table 3
Average (standard error) dD values of xylem sap extracted from stems of four Eucalypt species and roots of
lucerne (M. sativa) at Katanning, November 1997
Specimen
Sample
n
dD (%)
E. camaldulensis
E. saligna
E. leucoxylon
E. platypus
M. sativa
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Stem xylem sap
Root xylem sap
6
7
8
7
2
ÿ23.081.92
ÿ23.891.26
ÿ22.911.94
ÿ20.271.82
ÿ11.451.11
Fig. 4. The dD of water from soil collected at 20 cm depth along three transects (A±C) perpendicular to a belt of
eucalypt trees during February 1998.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
237
and E. platypus ranged from ÿ20 to ÿ24% (Table 3). These values were significantly
different (p0.05) from dD of topsoil water (ÿ21.11%) or perched water
(ÿ24.26%).
3.2. Detailed soil analysis
At the time of the detailed soil analysis, the predawn water potentials in leaves of the
trees at the site were at their lowest in 3 years of study (White et al., 2000). Thus the soils
were extremely dry. Data from the two vertical profiles beneath the belt of trees and one
profile beneath pasture are shown in Fig. 3A±C. The dD profiles showed little trend with
depth, centering on a value of approximately ÿ30%, with the exception of the surface
(20 cm) values, which had a value of approximately ÿ50%. The three horizontal profiles
(Fig. 4A±C) showed no clear trend with distance from the tree belt and there was
considerable spatial variation (e.g. see especially Fig. 4B).
4. Discussion
4.1. `End member' study
In isolation from the data collected during the detailed soil analysis, the initial `end
member' data suggested that groundwater and soil water had a different isotopic
composition. In addition, water from topsoil collected beneath trees showed greater
similarity to groundwater than did topsoil water under pasture as indicated by lucerne
xylem sap (Table 3). These data were consistent with the hypothesis that some water in
the surface soil under the trees had been `lifted' by the trees. Dawson (1993a) drew such a
conclusion on the basis of similar measurements of topsoil under Acer saccharum. During
the dry conditions of November, tree hydration appeared to be at least partly due to
sources of water other than groundwater. However, Brunel et al. (1995) state that the error
for dD techniques (including sample extraction, analysis, etc.) is 5%, hence an attempt
to distinguish between `end members' that differ less than 10% may be beyond the
sensitivity of the technique.
4.2. Detailed soil analysis
The uniformity of dD values for water from soil at different depths within the profile
was not expected, either from the results of the first study or from theoretical predictions.
For example, the predicted enrichment of deuterium in water near the soil surface (Barnes
and Allison, 1984) was not observed. Our chosen sample interval (every 20 cm to a depth
of 2 m) may have been too coarse to elucidate the enrichment profile. However, Turner
et al. (1987) sampled at less frequent intervals than in our study and demonstrated the
predicted surface enrichment. Our results, however, indicate a depletion maximum (as
predicted by Barnes and Allison (1984)) near the soil surface (see Fig. 3A and C) in
contrast to the results of Turner et al. (1987). A feature common to our data and that of
238
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
Turner et al. (1987) was the nearly uniform dD values of the unsaturated zone at depth.
These values were also similar to those of groundwater, making inferences regarding the
source of water used by plants difficult.
At sites where there are large variations in the dD values (in some cases, >100%) of
potential sources of water (including snowmelt and fog water as well as rainfall, soil
water and groundwater), researchers have been able to apportion the water taken up by
plants among the various sources (Dawson and Ehleringer, 1991; Ehleringer et al., 1991;
Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson, 1998). Comparable studies in southern
Australia have typically found much smaller ranges of dD (Thorburn and Walker, 1994;
Thorburn and Ehleringer, 1995; Dawson and Pate, 1996; Bleby et al., 1997) reducing the
scope within which to discriminate differing water sources. Turner et al. (1987), for
example, found the average dD of shallow groundwater in the Salmon catchment (Collie,
see Fig. 1) showed little variation at ÿ21.01.0 (n70). Furthermore, at a number of
sites in south-western Australia, dD values of soil water are uniform throughout the soil
profile and differ little from groundwater (Turner et al., 1987; Farrington et al., 1996).
Turner et al. (1987) suggested that the isotopically uniform profiles of lateritic soils in
south-western Australia result from good mixing of isotopically variable rainfall during
recharge. In view of the findings of Burgess et al. (1998) that root systems of trees
transfer water between soil layers in response to gradients in water potential, we suggest
that plant roots contribute to the mixing of water within the profile by redistributing
water. For example, measurements of soil moisture at Katanning demonstrated that water
redistributed from shallow soil layers to deeper layers (1.8±2.6 m) by tree roots increased
soil moisture content by up to 2.8%, 1 month after break of season in 1998 (Burgess et al.,
2000). On a v/v basis, up to 14% of the water contained in deep soil layers was water
from the topsoil transferred by plants. Lucerne roots would probably also redistribute
water to some extent since previous studies have shown that this species also exhibits
hydraulic lift (Caldwell et al., 1998). Clearly, extant dD discrimination between subsoil
and surface soil water would have been reduced by up to 14%, by mixing resulting from
water transfer by plant roots.
Much of the annual rainfall at Katanning would probably have a dD similar to the
mean weighted values recorded at other sites in south-western Australia (Table 1), but
perhaps further depleted due to the inland position of Katanning (Dawson, 1993b). The
importance of large winter rain events (see Fig. 2) to soil recharge probably contributed to
the uniformity of soil water dD within the profile. Mixing due to the action of root
systems would further homogenise the dD values of water in the soil profile. Exchange
among water sources by hydraulic redistribution should have most impact where sources
within the soil profile have markedly different water potentials. The strongly seasonal
rainfall distribution of Katanning's Mediterranean-type climate favours the establishment
of strong gradients in water potential between water sources. A further possibility is that
the hydraulic discontinuity between the A horizon (sand) and subsequent horizons (clay)
isolates these parts of the soil profile (>50 cm deep) from the fractionating process of
evaporation, but not to extraction of water by plants (which is non-fractionating).
Horizontal transects showed no apparent trend in dD of topsoil water with distance
from trees. dD of topsoil water were both more enriched and more depleted in deuterium
than groundwater. This finding is not surprising given that both maximum and minimum
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
239
enrichment may be found in the upper few centimetres of the soil profile (Barnes and
Allison, 1984). Spatial heterogeneity of soil characteristics and microclimate add to this
complexity (Le Roux et al., 1995). Duplex soils have a characteristically variable
subsurface relief, leading to significant spatial variation in the depth boundaries between
horizons (Tennant et al., 1992). Such variability will increase the difficulty of measuring
the influence of `hydraulic lift' on soil water dD. The dD of topsoil water collected during
the November study (Table 2) was more uniform than that collected in February, probably
as a result of rainfall (5 mm) in November, and suggests that further drying serves to
increase heterogeneity in topsoil dD.
Unlike the results of Dawson (1993a), which clearly demonstrated that water exudation
from roots of Acer saccharum modified the dD of topsoil water as a function of distance
from tree (and decreasing root length density), our data were inconclusive. The absence
of a clear dD discrimination among water sources, coupled with variable dD of topsoil
water in the sand horizon of the duplex soils at our site, prevented the tracing of the
acquisition and redistribution of water sources by the trees.
5. Conclusions
Non-destructive methods for assessing potential complementarity in patterns of water
extraction among species are limited. Isotopic techniques have the potential to indirectly
assess resource access by plant roots. However, we conclude that these techniques are
difficult to apply at sites where uniformity of dD with soil depth, heterogeneity at the
surface level or limited range of dD among differing water sources exist. Measurements
of `end member' water sources alone provide insufficient information regarding the
spatial variability of dD in the soil profile and are potentially misleading. Robust
characterisation of spatial variation in the natural abundance of stable isotopes must be
undertaken when using environmental isotope techniques. In environments where
insufficient isotopic discrimination exists among water sources, labelling techniques such
the application of deuterium enriched water either by irrigation or direct injection into
plant tissues may be more appropriate.
Clearly, much research effort will be required to characterise the belowground
functioning of woody perennials so as to predict their effects on the productivity and
sustainability of agroforestry systems. Until new methods are developed, it is likely that
root excavations and measurements of soil moisture will remain the basic tools to
investigate the belowground resource acquisition by different plant functional types.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the Australian Centre for International Agricultural
Research. Support for S.S.O.B. was provided by the Western Australian Department of
Conservation and Land Management. We thank Drs Jeff Turner and Don White (CSIRO)
for reviewing an earlier version of this paper and suggesting improvements. We are
grateful to Todd Dawson for advice and assistance with sample collection and analysis
240
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
and Lidia Bednarek performed the mass spectrometry. Frank Dunin, Phil Ward, Shane
Micin and Gerald Watson assisted with sample collection. The Grains Research and
Development Corporation and Agriculture Western Australia contributed to site
establishment and maintenance.
References
Akinnifesi, F.K., Kang, B.T., Ladipo, D.O., 1998. Structural root form and ®ne root distribution of some woody
species evaluated for agroforestry systems. Agrofor. Syst. 42, 121±138.
Barnes, C.J., Allison, G.B., 1984. The distribution of deuterium and oxygen-18 in dry soils. 3. Theory for nonisothermal water movement. J. Hydrol. 74, 119±136.
Bleby, T.M., Aucote, M., Kennettsmith, A.K., Walker, G.R., Schachtman, D.P., 1997. Seasonal water use
characteristics of tall wheatgrass [Agropyron elongatum (Host) Beauv.] in a saline environment. Plant Cell
Environ. 20, 1361±1371.
Bollard, E.G., 1960. Transport in the xylem. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 11, 141±166.
Brunel, J.P., Walker, G.R., Kennett Smith, A.K., 1995. Field validation of isotopic procedures for determining
sources of water used by plants in a semi-arid environment. J. Hydrol. 167, 351±368.
Burgess, S.S.O., Adams, M.A., Turner, N.C., Ong, C.K., 1998. The redistribution of soil water by tree root
systems. Oecologia 115, 306±311.
Burgess, S.S.O., Turner, N.C., Adams, M.A., White, D.A., Ong, C.K., 2000. Tree roots, conduits for deep
recharge of soil water. Oecologia, in press.
Caldwell, M.M., Dawson, T.E., Richards, J.H., 1998. Hydraulic lift Ð consequences of water ef¯ux from the
roots of plants. Oecologia 113, 151±161.
Cannell, M.G.R., Vannoordwijk, M., Ong, C.K., 1996. The central agroforestry hypothesis Ð the trees must
acquire resources that the crop would not otherwise acquire. Agrofor. Syst. 34, 27±31.
Cox, J.W., McFarlane, D.J., 1995. The causes of waterlogging in shallow soils and their drainage in
southwestern Australia. J. Hydrol. 167, 175±194.
Dawson, T.E., 1993a. Hydraulic lift and water use by plants: implications for water balance, performance and
plant±plant interactions. Oecologia 95, 565±574.
Dawson, T.E., 1993b. Water sources of plants as determined from xylem-water isotopic composition:
perspectives on plant competition, distribution and water relations. In: Ehleringer, J.R., Hall, A.E., Farquhar,
G.D. (Eds.), Stable Isotopes and Plant Carbon/Water Relations. Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 465±496.
Dawson, T.E., 1998. Fog in the California redwood forest: ecosystem inputs and use by plants. Oecologia 117,
476±485.
Dawson, T.E., Ehleringer, J.R., 1991. Streamside trees that do not use stream water. Nature 350, 335±337.
Dawson, T.E., Ehleringer, J.R., 1993. Isotopic enrichment of water in the woody tissues of plants Ð implications
for plant water source, water uptake, and other studies which use the stable isotopic composition of cellulose.
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 57, 3487±3492.
Dawson, T.E., Pate, J.S., 1996. Seasonal water uptake and movement in root systems of Australian
phraeatophytic plants of dimorphic root morphology: a stable isotope investigation. Oecologia 107, 13±20.
Dawson, T.E., Pausch, R.C., Parker, H.M., 1998. The role of hydrogen and oxygen stable isotopes in
understanding water movement along the soil±plant±atmosphere continuum. In: Grif®ths, H. (Ed.), Stable
Isotopes: Integration of Biological, Ecological and Geochemical Processes. BIOS Scienti®c Publishers,
Oxford, pp. 169±183.
Dodd, M.B., Lauenroth, W.K., Welker, J.M., 1998. Differential water resource use by herbaceous and woody
plant life-forms in a shortgrass steppe community. Oecologia 117, 504±512.
Ehleringer, J.R., Osmond, C.B., 1989. Stable isotopes. In: Pearcy, R.W., Ehleringer, J.R., Mooney, H.A.,
Rundell, P.W. (Eds.), Plant Physiological Ecology: Field Methods and Instrumentation. Chapman & Hall,
London, pp. 281±300.
Ehleringer, J.R., Phillips, S.L., Schuster, W.S.F., Sandquist, D.R., 1991. Differential utilization of summer rains
by desert plants. Oecologia 88, 430±434.
S.S.O. Burgess et al. / Agricultural Water Management 45 (2000) 229±241
241
Farrington, P., Turner, J.V., Gailitis, V., 1996. Tracing water uptake by jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata) trees using
natural abundances of deuterium. Trees 11, 9±15.
Le Roux, X., Bariac, T., Mariotti, A., 1995. Spatial partitioning of the soil water resource between grass and
shrub components in a West African humid savanna. Oecologia 104, 147±155.
McIntyre, B.D., Riha, S.J., Ong, C.K., 1997. Competition for water in a hedge±intercrop system. Field Crops
Res. 52, 151±160.
Narain, P., Singh, R.K., Sindhwal, N.S., Joshie, P., 1998. Water balance and water use ef®ciency of different land
uses in western Himalayan valley region. Agric. Water Manage. 37, 225±240.
Rao, M.R., Nair, P.K.R., Ong, C.K., 1997. Biophysical interactions in tropical agroforestry systems. Agrofor.
Syst. 38, 3±50.
Sadler, E.J., Turner, N.C., 1994. Water relationships in a sustainable agricultural system. In: Hat®eld, J.L.,
Karlen, D.L. (Eds.), Sustainable Agriculture Systems. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, pp. 21±45.
Sanchez, P.A., 1995. Science in agroforestry. Agrofor. Syst. 30, 5±55.
Smith, D.M., Jarvis, P.G., Odongo, J.C.W., 1997. Sources of water used by trees and millet in Sahelian
windbreak systems. J. Hydrol. 198, 140±153.
Tennant, D., Scholz, G., Dixon, J., Purdie, B., 1992. Physical and chemical characteristics of duplex soils and
their distribution in the south-west of Western Australia. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. 32, 827±843.
Thorburn, P.J., Ehleringer, J.R., 1995. Root water uptake of ®eld-growing plants indicated by measurements of
natural-abundance deuterium. Plant Soil 177, 225±233.
Thorburn, P.J., Walker, G.R., 1994. Variation in stream water uptake by Eucalyptus camaldulensis with differing
access to stream water. Oecologia 100, 293±301.
Turner, J.V., Macpherson, D.K., 1990. Mechanisms affecting stream¯ow and streamwater quality: an approach
via stable isotope, hydrogeochemical and time series analysis. Water Resources Res. 26, 3005±3019.
Turner, J.V., Arad, A., Johnston, C.D., 1987. Environmental isotope hydrology of salinized experimental
catchments. J. Hydrol. 94, 89±108.
Vandermeer, J., Vannoordwijk, M., Anderson, J., Ong, C., Perfecto, I., 1998. Global change and multi-species
agroecosystems Ð concepts and issues. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 67, 1±22.
Walker, J., Bullen, F., Williams, B.G., 1993. Ecohydrological changes in the Murray-Darling basin. I. The
number of trees cleared over two centuries. J. Appl. Ecol. 30, 265±273.
Wallace, J.S., Jackson, N.A., Ong, C.K., 1999. Modelling soil evaporation in an agroforestry system in Kenya.
Agric. For. Meteorol. 94, 189±202.
White, D.A., Turner, N.C., Galbraith, J.H., 2000. Shoot water relations and stomatal behaviour of four allopatric
Eucalyptus species planted in Mediterranean south-western Australia: implications for water use models,
Aust. J. Plant Physiol., in press.