REDD+, Governance, and Community Forestry | RECOFTC Recoft FGLG 149
REDD+,
andand
Community
Forestry
REDD+,Governance
Governance,
Community
Forestry
,ŝŐŚůŝŐŚƚƐĨƌŽŵƚŚĞ&ŽƌĞƐƚ'ŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞ>ĞĂƌŶŝŶŐ'ƌŽƵƉƐŝĂ džƉĞƌƚƐ͛DĞĞƟŶŐ
,ŝŐŚůŝŐŚƚƐĨƌŽŵƚŚĞ&ŽƌĞƐƚ'ŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞ>ĞĂƌŶŝŶŐ'ƌŽƵƉƐŝĂ džƉĞƌƚƐ͛DĞĞƟŶŐ
July 2011
The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily
!
"
"#$
#"
"
"
" "
%# # "&"'
"
"
&"
" &%&
!
%
$()"# "*+"& "&,"
$"&-./00(
%" "
%1"" %"
##"%
"
% "23" %" 3"
#"
" # $"&
'"
%
"
%$ * 3&! %" "
%1""
##" %
"
"1" 3" %
" 3"#"
" $"& !
% 4" 4 ,"
% "& "
3 *!
"
%#
"1""$
%
% "%#
1&
"&
""
% 4" 4 ,"
%
!
Introduction
,
#"
# %"& #"
"
#
"
&" 5
67 ' '
"" "
%1 " '
"
"
%
" 3
# ##%"$
$ #"& 1 " % "
' #! 8" "
& 3"& &"" ##%"$
$
& " "1% " "
9 "
##""
3
"
#"&
#%
1 %9 %
!
9#" "
" 13 ##%"$
$
6
'
"& % 57 3"
% # "
"%
'" # ' #
5
7
"# ' # 3& 3 * 5 7
"$
:%""& ;
6
"'" 0. 9
# "
" """
! >
!)"# "* ! '"" "3 *" &"2"&
#"&"
$
"2"&9
@"%
""
%1"" !
Key questions
Q1
8"
" ##%"$
$ "1%
6A
Q2
B 3 ##%"$
$
&1C
##%""
%
6A
Q3
6 #
&
##%"$
$A
Q4
6
"
*
##%"$
$A
Q5
B 3"&
"
##%""
""& %
1
%" 9
6A
Q6
8""
$9"
##%"$' "1%
6"##" A
8""
#%
11%"A
Q7
B 3
61%"%
& '
#
##%"$
$A
Q8
8*$
#
##%"$
$ 1
##%""&"
6A
Q9
8& '#&"
%
6"##"
1C
##%""
A
The experts
! #
4
&" "
4" "
'" # &##
Thailand
: B%$
%$ %$ ,&"%%D
$
#
%
D
'" #
>&#
$ &%$4"'
"$
!>>%2
"
8 #@
"""'
) "$%%
'" #58)
7!
"""
>! &%$ %#
""& "
"$:%""&
6
&# .
$
# " "
' #
"'"&
6 1 "
##%""
!
" "$
""
#&# ' "
"&$
" # #
1
# "
3""#1%
3
&
##%"$ 1
# !
, ##%"$
$ "$ '
"$
" "# ' ""
!
#$ %"
# "2" &"
"
& # &%"
%&$ ##%"$
$ %C "
#"
"'"& 1C
##%""
!
#3 %$ $""""'
%
6!
.
F> 3
" 1 # ##%"$
$ "
#"& %
"& '#
"
&"2"
%!
Q3
Can REDD+ promote and strengthen community forestry?
, %&
6"
#"1$#%""
*
" #
& ##%"$
$! " "
' "##
""
"%
"'"&
1
"#$ "# '#%"
*
""" &&# #&""2 & %
"
#&#!)"C$""
" #
" " 1$ " #$ &"2
"%$ ""& %
'" 1%
#3 *
%"& """
$ %1""$!
“The role of FGLG
Indonesia is to look
at community forestry
where it is working
and show that it can
contribute to the
objectives of REDD+.”
Budhita Kismadi
B 3' 9
#"9 '"3
"1 "#
6 ' '
#&#!
6
"2"
#$1%""& 9"
"&
##%"$
$ "
"%"
! & '
%%
3 % 1
%
& 1$ "
#&# %"
"& &
'%
&&# 3" "" "
" #*"&
6! ' #
6
"
1 % "2" ! "$ & # %
%"&
#$ 3 % ""'
"
"' '# "
#&#!
" '" #
&%
6
"% "
,9 % ,&# "1% ##%"$
$
1$
%"& "&
##%""
! , "& ,&#
" & '#
#%
"% #"
#
# " "&
"&
"
3" &"&
&%
! ;%" 3"
%" ##%""
""&
&%
3 * 3
"&"& "&
!
Q4
Does REDD+ pose risks to community forestry?
3"
$
"& "##
6#"
# 3" 1*
&"
##%"$
$!
6#$$2 "
"
"$13 ##%""
& '#!8 %
"&
&% "
##%""
"'$&&"
6" & '#
#$ 1 #
" ' '" %
$ ' '
! , # "$ &"' "#""
"
3 % '
##%""
@ "&
"'"
"
"
"2"
#&# %&
6 3 % %#"
'"1""$ I6@3 "
6 1$ #&""2"&
*
3 $%" ""
%
!
#"
6 "
" "! %
"&
"#
" $ #
&
% "
* "
"& '$
"#"
" 9"
! , "% "
* ""C 1$ 9
"
"
" #
"
'" 1
*
!
'"
" #&# #%
1 1 3" %
""
@
%
%
" ""
1 "
%
%"$
" ;%
"!
"
#1"&%"$ %
1 "
6
##%""
" & '#
*
%
"
"
* "! %$ " "
3 %
6 "
# 1
&# #$ 1"& "
1 "
""'"%
3"""""& ##%""
!
“REDD+ is an opportunity,
but also it could be
a trap if we do not do
it correctly.”
Nguyen Quang Tan
“If we convey this
REDD+ concept unclearly,
then we are heading
communities.”
Bambang Supriyanto
"' "
% % " #9""
* "$
% %"&
6 "
$
%"
"&!
% "
" "
%#"
%;%
" " 9"
#"
%
"&
&%"
9"$! "
'" # 1
$ 1 "
##%""
% ' "
%
"#
%%
6!
"$
""2 * 3& "
*"
%
"
*
%#""&
*
3 ' $
#&
!
3
%
"&"
6
%
"1#&#
'" #
1
*
!
Q5
How can the rights and interests of local communities and
indigenous peoples be ensured in the context of REDD+?
“One way to ensure that
local communities are
part of the planning and
execution of REDD+
is the creation of a
multi-stakeholder council.”
##%""
""& %
& %
#%
1 3 " #
"'$ && %& % "& "##" # " "&
6! "
1"
# #%"
*
'
"& #
%
3" 1 %"! "
3"
% "1""$
$"
6
&%&"
"19%
"
#&""2& %
!
Marlea Munez
6
%"
#%
"% 3 # $ % & %
3
1
"'
# & *$
*
!8" %
" #
'%1
*
"
& "& & " "
%" "
#$ ' "
"1 " "
%
%
6 #9"#"2=%"$ "'
!
""
#%
1
"
%"& "&
"
##%""
=%$%!$
' $ "&" '"3
%
% '%! >3" #$
##%""
$
" "'"
! %"$
'"&
" "&
6 ""'
" & "
"
&" !
“We have learned
that local people can
manage the forests
very well.”
Bao Huy
“Community forestry is
not a silver bullet, there
are numerous examples
of successes, but also
of failure, we must
learn from all of these.”
Thomas Enters
Q9
What can government agencies do to ensure that REDD+
LPSOHPHQWDWLRQEHQHÀWVORFDOFRPPXQLWLHV"
“Arbitrary policy
changes as well as
complicated bureaucratic
procedures lead to
insecurity.”
Thomas Enters
9
""C 3 #"
& '# "
6
"##" (
"
"" ! ,
" "
' "
" &%
% "
# & &"
! "*3"
" #%
%& #%"
* " &%
13 " '
"# '
%"
!"
3"1"%$
""
#""&"&
"1"""
'" %
"
$ "2"&" 3
!
,
"" & '#
% "" $ # ' 1"
"' '# " ' # "
6 &#
! "
"
% %& """ %&
* "$ 1%""&
%"& ##%""
"&
" #" '""&
& &% $ #3 *! #%
'" %
#"
#"""
%"& "'& '
"& % 3! $ 3"
6 1 1 *
"
%
%
%"
3
*
$
%1""$!
Recommendations
N
% "&
"
%
6!#$ %"
% #3"1
$
% ##%""
' "&
M
!
N
6
"%
" "' """
##%""
!, "&$ "$ #*
#%
# %
% ##%"$"' '#!
N "$ 1%""& &#
#%
* " % ##%""
@
9"
"&
*"
1 # "'! "
" 3"
%
*
3" '
*"
* 3& =%" 9"
" "&
%C "
"1"""
#9"#"21 "
%
6!
N
61%" %"
##%"$
$!8
##%"$
$9"
"$ #*
#%
"&"##"
6 3" ##%"$
$ ""
1C
3"
'$1#
!
N ,#1"&%"$ ""
" ""
"
& '#
"
"%"
"&
##%""
!
"" # & & '# &"
# "2"
#""& &"
" %"!
N ,
"
" #*"&
#
"& "##"
# " "& "
%#
%
6!
#%
%"
'%1 ##%""
%$
"!
N , $ C #"
#
1C
1 '"$
"2 $#%
1"##!
"' '#%
1
"
%1 "=%"1#!
N %
" &"& 1C
6 %"
"#
"
##%""
"
&
"&"&
"##"&# " "&
6#"
#
!
: 90000
C
:&* *0/K/O"
(6PP5/7.KQ/RS//
333! ! &
"
"%
'" # ' #5
7
Q
"&)
80B/
4" "& #
(6QQ5/7./SOLL.00S
333!""! &
andand
Community
Forestry
REDD+,Governance
Governance,
Community
Forestry
,ŝŐŚůŝŐŚƚƐĨƌŽŵƚŚĞ&ŽƌĞƐƚ'ŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞ>ĞĂƌŶŝŶŐ'ƌŽƵƉƐŝĂ džƉĞƌƚƐ͛DĞĞƟŶŐ
,ŝŐŚůŝŐŚƚƐĨƌŽŵƚŚĞ&ŽƌĞƐƚ'ŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞ>ĞĂƌŶŝŶŐ'ƌŽƵƉƐŝĂ džƉĞƌƚƐ͛DĞĞƟŶŐ
July 2011
The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily
!
"
"#$
#"
"
"
" "
%# # "&"'
"
"
&"
" &%&
!
%
$()"# "*+"& "&,"
$"&-./00(
%" "
%1"" %"
##"%
"
% "23" %" 3"
#"
" # $"&
'"
%
"
%$ * 3&! %" "
%1""
##" %
"
"1" 3" %
" 3"#"
" $"& !
% 4" 4 ,"
% "& "
3 *!
"
%#
"1""$
%
% "%#
1&
"&
""
% 4" 4 ,"
%
!
Introduction
,
#"
# %"& #"
"
#
"
&" 5
67 ' '
"" "
%1 " '
"
"
%
" 3
# ##%"$
$ #"& 1 " % "
' #! 8" "
& 3"& &"" ##%"$
$
& " "1% " "
9 "
##""
3
"
#"&
#%
1 %9 %
!
9#" "
" 13 ##%"$
$
6
'
"& % 57 3"
% # "
"%
'" # ' #
5
7
"# ' # 3& 3 * 5 7
"$
:%""& ;
6
"'" 0. 9
# "
" """
! >
!)"# "* ! '"" "3 *" &"2"&
#"&"
$
"2"&9
@"%
""
%1"" !
Key questions
Q1
8"
" ##%"$
$ "1%
6A
Q2
B 3 ##%"$
$
&1C
##%""
%
6A
Q3
6 #
&
##%"$
$A
Q4
6
"
*
##%"$
$A
Q5
B 3"&
"
##%""
""& %
1
%" 9
6A
Q6
8""
$9"
##%"$' "1%
6"##" A
8""
#%
11%"A
Q7
B 3
61%"%
& '
#
##%"$
$A
Q8
8*$
#
##%"$
$ 1
##%""&"
6A
Q9
8& '#&"
%
6"##"
1C
##%""
A
The experts
! #
4
&" "
4" "
'" # &##
Thailand
: B%$
%$ %$ ,&"%%D
$
#
%
D
'" #
>&#
$ &%$4"'
"$
!>>%2
"
8 #@
"""'
) "$%%
'" #58)
7!
"""
>! &%$ %#
""& "
"$:%""&
6
&# .
$
# " "
' #
"'"&
6 1 "
##%""
!
" "$
""
#&# ' "
"&$
" # #
1
# "
3""#1%
3
&
##%"$ 1
# !
, ##%"$
$ "$ '
"$
" "# ' ""
!
#$ %"
# "2" &"
"
& # &%"
%&$ ##%"$
$ %C "
#"
"'"& 1C
##%""
!
#3 %$ $""""'
%
6!
.
F> 3
" 1 # ##%"$
$ "
#"& %
"& '#
"
&"2"
%!
Q3
Can REDD+ promote and strengthen community forestry?
, %&
6"
#"1$#%""
*
" #
& ##%"$
$! " "
' "##
""
"%
"'"&
1
"#$ "# '#%"
*
""" &&# #&""2 & %
"
#&#!)"C$""
" #
" " 1$ " #$ &"2
"%$ ""& %
'" 1%
#3 *
%"& """
$ %1""$!
“The role of FGLG
Indonesia is to look
at community forestry
where it is working
and show that it can
contribute to the
objectives of REDD+.”
Budhita Kismadi
B 3' 9
#"9 '"3
"1 "#
6 ' '
#&#!
6
"2"
#$1%""& 9"
"&
##%"$
$ "
"%"
! & '
%%
3 % 1
%
& 1$ "
#&# %"
"& &
'%
&&# 3" "" "
" #*"&
6! ' #
6
"
1 % "2" ! "$ & # %
%"&
#$ 3 % ""'
"
"' '# "
#&#!
" '" #
&%
6
"% "
,9 % ,&# "1% ##%"$
$
1$
%"& "&
##%""
! , "& ,&#
" & '#
#%
"% #"
#
# " "&
"&
"
3" &"&
&%
! ;%" 3"
%" ##%""
""&
&%
3 * 3
"&"& "&
!
Q4
Does REDD+ pose risks to community forestry?
3"
$
"& "##
6#"
# 3" 1*
&"
##%"$
$!
6#$$2 "
"
"$13 ##%""
& '#!8 %
"&
&% "
##%""
"'$&&"
6" & '#
#$ 1 #
" ' '" %
$ ' '
! , # "$ &"' "#""
"
3 % '
##%""
@ "&
"'"
"
"
"2"
#&# %&
6 3 % %#"
'"1""$ I6@3 "
6 1$ #&""2"&
*
3 $%" ""
%
!
#"
6 "
" "! %
"&
"#
" $ #
&
% "
* "
"& '$
"#"
" 9"
! , "% "
* ""C 1$ 9
"
"
" #
"
'" 1
*
!
'"
" #&# #%
1 1 3" %
""
@
%
%
" ""
1 "
%
%"$
" ;%
"!
"
#1"&%"$ %
1 "
6
##%""
" & '#
*
%
"
"
* "! %$ " "
3 %
6 "
# 1
&# #$ 1"& "
1 "
""'"%
3"""""& ##%""
!
“REDD+ is an opportunity,
but also it could be
a trap if we do not do
it correctly.”
Nguyen Quang Tan
“If we convey this
REDD+ concept unclearly,
then we are heading
communities.”
Bambang Supriyanto
"' "
% % " #9""
* "$
% %"&
6 "
$
%"
"&!
% "
" "
%#"
%;%
" " 9"
#"
%
"&
&%"
9"$! "
'" # 1
$ 1 "
##%""
% ' "
%
"#
%%
6!
"$
""2 * 3& "
*"
%
"
*
%#""&
*
3 ' $
#&
!
3
%
"&"
6
%
"1#&#
'" #
1
*
!
Q5
How can the rights and interests of local communities and
indigenous peoples be ensured in the context of REDD+?
“One way to ensure that
local communities are
part of the planning and
execution of REDD+
is the creation of a
multi-stakeholder council.”
##%""
""& %
& %
#%
1 3 " #
"'$ && %& % "& "##" # " "&
6! "
1"
# #%"
*
'
"& #
%
3" 1 %"! "
3"
% "1""$
$"
6
&%&"
"19%
"
#&""2& %
!
Marlea Munez
6
%"
#%
"% 3 # $ % & %
3
1
"'
# & *$
*
!8" %
" #
'%1
*
"
& "& & " "
%" "
#$ ' "
"1 " "
%
%
6 #9"#"2=%"$ "'
!
""
#%
1
"
%"& "&
"
##%""
=%$%!$
' $ "&" '"3
%
% '%! >3" #$
##%""
$
" "'"
! %"$
'"&
" "&
6 ""'
" & "
"
&" !
“We have learned
that local people can
manage the forests
very well.”
Bao Huy
“Community forestry is
not a silver bullet, there
are numerous examples
of successes, but also
of failure, we must
learn from all of these.”
Thomas Enters
Q9
What can government agencies do to ensure that REDD+
LPSOHPHQWDWLRQEHQHÀWVORFDOFRPPXQLWLHV"
“Arbitrary policy
changes as well as
complicated bureaucratic
procedures lead to
insecurity.”
Thomas Enters
9
""C 3 #"
& '# "
6
"##" (
"
"" ! ,
" "
' "
" &%
% "
# & &"
! "*3"
" #%
%& #%"
* " &%
13 " '
"# '
%"
!"
3"1"%$
""
#""&"&
"1"""
'" %
"
$ "2"&" 3
!
,
"" & '#
% "" $ # ' 1"
"' '# " ' # "
6 &#
! "
"
% %& """ %&
* "$ 1%""&
%"& ##%""
"&
" #" '""&
& &% $ #3 *! #%
'" %
#"
#"""
%"& "'& '
"& % 3! $ 3"
6 1 1 *
"
%
%
%"
3
*
$
%1""$!
Recommendations
N
% "&
"
%
6!#$ %"
% #3"1
$
% ##%""
' "&
M
!
N
6
"%
" "' """
##%""
!, "&$ "$ #*
#%
# %
% ##%"$"' '#!
N "$ 1%""& &#
#%
* " % ##%""
@
9"
"&
*"
1 # "'! "
" 3"
%
*
3" '
*"
* 3& =%" 9"
" "&
%C "
"1"""
#9"#"21 "
%
6!
N
61%" %"
##%"$
$!8
##%"$
$9"
"$ #*
#%
"&"##"
6 3" ##%"$
$ ""
1C
3"
'$1#
!
N ,#1"&%"$ ""
" ""
"
& '#
"
"%"
"&
##%""
!
"" # & & '# &"
# "2"
#""& &"
" %"!
N ,
"
" #*"&
#
"& "##"
# " "& "
%#
%
6!
#%
%"
'%1 ##%""
%$
"!
N , $ C #"
#
1C
1 '"$
"2 $#%
1"##!
"' '#%
1
"
%1 "=%"1#!
N %
" &"& 1C
6 %"
"#
"
##%""
"
&
"&"&
"##"&# " "&
6#"
#
!
: 90000
C
:&* *0/K/O"
(6PP5/7.KQ/RS//
333! ! &
"
"%
'" # ' #5
7
Q
"&)
80B/
4" "& #
(6QQ5/7./SOLL.00S
333!""! &