pc3abtr kropotkin the state
Pëtr Kropotkin
1896
1
Halaman 2
Pëtr Kropotkin
!"
#
$
% &
'
#
,
1'
'
'
!)* !"
'%
-.
(
(
(
+
/
0 '(
(
'
2
'
(
3
(
% /
(
(
(
'
4
(
(
% /
((
$
3 '
%5
1
% .
6
7
(
(
,
,
0
#
0 (
(
6
% 1
(
,
(
(
(
+
8)))
2
9)))
(
(
%
(
7
:;
(%
+
(,
<
=
(
'
'
>% 1
( '
( %
%
(
!)? @
(
+
(
(
'
@
#
(
(
Halaman 3
Pëtr Kropotkin
>
4
%
-
(
>
' (
(
+
A=
( B%
(
(&
=/
'
C
,
(
(
B
(
(
(
(
-=D
-1
=/
/
(
' (
%
> /
>%
2
#
/
'
(
(
'>
>%
2
% =E
-.
,
A
(
(
'
'
((
%E
>
'
+
(B
/
;
(
% 7
7 %
'
-1
% .
>
( '$ =.
>%
'
-=.
'
/ (
/
'
'
/
(
% .
(
@
%>
> /
'
'
% =2
>%
'
/
%5
>
(
(
# (
(
=
'
( <
:
(
% 1
(
(
(
>
'
:
Halaman 4
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
<
>
(
'
(
%
(
2 (
(
(
'
(
4
'
'
(
% ,
(
(
'
'
'
'
%
'
(
$ -.
!"!
!"!
+
(
(
2
<
F
(
2
(
' (
=
(
(
F
(
G/
+
>
:
(
6'
A'
B
6'
'
:
' =
(
>
:
>
>
(
:&
A;
F
(
'
/
' (
!" B
=;
(
> !"
(
6 ' >
%5
!"
6 '
6'
>
@
(.
(
=
2
(
0
=2
@
'
'
((
H
,
'
-
(
(
>
2
'
+
><
(
'
+
'
(
(%
! "
(
5
(
(
(
(
(
<
'
(
(
.
' 4
Halaman 5
Pëtr Kropotkin
-
'5
#
,
% I
! C
!J8K
(
3%
>
#
1
(
$
'
2
(
#
(
(
'
(
'
' (
(
'
(
'
'
(
%
/
#
(
(
+
'
( "
$
(
&
%
$
%
+
+
%
/
(
>
(
(
% .
(
(
:
A (
# '' '
'
(
3+
4
'
'
(
>
&' &
F
")
'
GB% 1
2
3+
'
+
(
(
(
0
=2
:(
>%
>
%%%
$-
G5%
;
D
LLLLL
'
0 '
%
(
6
! "
Halaman 6
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
2
/ (
+ (
/
( $
#
'
(
'
2
'
(
%
/
4
2
%.
(
( '
+
(
'
(
+
( '
%
.
'
2
'
(
+
'
%1
2
(
'
('
'
4
(
'
2
( '% .
( %
/
%/
(
'
(
'
%1
'
2
(
@
@
((
#
((
2
(
'
''
0
2
( '
(
%
LLL
F
'
(=
2
>%
4
' %
Halaman 7
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
(
% .
'
(
'
(
(
,
0 2
2
<
'
'
>
(
'
'
=
>%
'
'
(
(
<
2
2
'
'
<
3
@
'
2
'
+
(
<
>
'
((
2
'
((
.
(
%
2
(
%
(
(
(
M
I
'
'
2
% 2
(
2
(
'
(
(
(
(
%
(
4
(
2
% . 2
'
(
(
'
(
(
(
'
%/
+
$
(
(
$ &
$
$
$
( (
2
(
+
'
(
#
.
( '
$
(
% /
% 1
'
(
(
'
%
('
'
2
%
Halaman 8
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
2
(
%
.
6 (
3(
(
2
' >
(
'
6 ( $
(
' %, (6 (
%.
% /
% 3
(
(
3(
( '
'
.
@
3(
% 3
(
2
(
'
(
6 (
'
'
6 (
(
'
' '
'
%1
(
0
"(
'
3(
(
%
3
'
(
3(
(
&
<
'
'
'
+
(
(
0
%
(
'
<
(
(
(
3(
@
(
0
%
2
0
4
(
'
0
'
'
(
6 (
1 +
3 %
(
/
'
6 (
(
2
2
3(
'
'
3(
0
'
'
2
%
(
Halaman 9
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
1
'
(
%
(
'
'
(
(
(
(
% &
'
0 % 1
''
(
'
/
M@
'
%1
@
(
(
0 '
(
( '
(
':
(
'
(
(
0
.
(
(
M
'
'
(
3
>
(
' % 7
=
'
<
'
6
(
(
%
.
(
+
(
( ' +
' '
%/
(
% /
''
'
(
'
(
(
%
'
<
+
%
@
'
' @
(
%.
(
'
( (
( %
% (
@
@
'
(
(
(
'
(
( (
Halaman 10
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
(
'
'
(
(
+
( (( % 1
'
<
(
+
(
(
' '
(
'
'
( '
(
+
(
(
% I
(
'
(
(
'
((
:'
'
'
%
'
' '
'
'
(
(
0
%.
(
'
(
'
'
.
%
(
'
( (
% .
3 '
=
0
>
(
($
(
>
(
>
(
(
'
%
,
( +
'
(
(
@
(
*
'
@
(
4
(
%
(
2
(
(
4
(
& <
(
% .
''
,
1
'
%.
(
(
(
(
'
'
(
(
1'
%
&
'
/
3
1
"
(
(
')
@
'
@
+
(
%
&
'
'
('
(
% .
'
(
' (
%/
(
3% 7
Halaman 11
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
( /
F
' (
% ,
'
'
% 7
(
'% 1
(
(
(
%
(
' $
< 4
+
(
, (
'
%E
'
<
%
'
( (
(
(
( (
%
.
:
$ -&
(
(% /
G1
'
5@
'
@
#
%%%
=
(
>
%
/
A
(
B
(
(
'
/
(
% 1
(
(
'
%.
(
(
.
(
%.
' @
(
:(
'
(
( (
(
%
(
@
(
(
' % 2(
0
'
(
%1
'
:
>
(
(
%/ (
'
(
:
:
%1
(
=
(
> ( (
((
%1
'
'
'
:
'
'
Halaman 12
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
(
(
=(
(
(
>
(
(
%1
' (
/ '
%
'
'
(
'
(
'('
=
>A
B
(
''
%&
(
(
'
3
( %
7
(
6 (
3(
#
( ' '
'
'
( %
/
('
7
1
(
'
(
%
(
(
0
1
@
(
3
+C K @
'
'
(
%
/
('
'
+
'
'
( '
( '
+
'
(
(
' (
'
(
(
(
'
3
((
((
%.
((
'' (
<
(
'
('
(
(
'
:
@
(
(
(
M
.
A
(
B
'
% 1
'
$
((
'' (
@
%C?K
Halaman 13
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
.
(
((
@
(
(
'
@
(
'%
'<
'
'
'
'' (
'
'
% F
(
(
((
'
(
3
%.
1
@2
6 (
'
@
0
%1
1
(
(
%
'
((
'
%
(
'
0
%
F
%
.
'
((
(
%&
(( % .
(
(
(
(
3
/
2
(
@
(
'
(
%
'
%/
(
'
2
2
.
3
(
6
(
%
(
'
((
%2
A
(
B
'
'
((
'
0
&
2
3(
'
+
1
#
%
I
'
'
'
(
'
@
@
((
( %
'
%
((
Halaman 14
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
'
% 1
@
'
'
'
(
@
((
#
(
((
&
=
'
'
(
> @
(
'
'
'
(
( @
'
(
(
%.
2
(
%
'
'
(
'
%
/
'
(
%
(
((
(
#
' %F
(
(
'
#
'
'
(
(
'
(
'
((
(
>
(
((
'
=
$
(
#
'
/
%
'
/
% / (
%2
(
2
0
+
(
(
(
B
#
'
(
'
'
(
=
'
>
%6 (
.
'
'
% 2
'
((
'
'
(
%
.
'
((
#
:
'
'
'
'
'
( '
A
(
'
((
'
((
(
(
%
((
<
Halaman 15
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
#
'
'
(
(
'%
&
$
% 7
(
'
(
(
'
%I
(
(
'
#
(
'
<
(
'
% 1
<
(
=
%
#
>
'
'
(
(
(
(
2
6 (
.
(
&
#
(
(
& 0
%2 (
I
(
#
'
(
#
(
(
%
'
/
%
%
>% 1
>
'
+
% .
,
'
=
@
=
% H
(
(
(
+ (
( ' (
'
((
$
((
((
(
(
'
'
'
(
(
(
%
>
3
#
<
(
%
(
+
(
'
4
(
(
(
M
('
M/
(
<
'
(
>
(
+
=
%
>% 1
(
Halaman 16
Pëtr Kropotkin
&
(
(
'
' '
'
+
(% ,
<
%
(
'
(
'
'
<
(
(
'
>
<
% &
' (
(
(
'
'
(
(
'
% .
% .
(
'
@#
1'
% 1
( <
'
<
$
$
+
+
%.
( (
$@
>
@
>
=
'
((
> =
><
(
>
> >(
'
%
'
%
3
(
%H
#
(
$
"
%
(
( ( (
=
'
>
+
(
'
''
<
+
<
(
='
'
<
'
><
3
+
6 (
2
(
'
((
@
% /
(
(
(
'
'
.
((
2
#
(
%
+
(
(
(
'
<
( %I
Halaman 17
Pëtr Kropotkin
& 0
+ ((
A
6 (
B
'
(
%
.
(
'
4
(
'
(
(
%
/
((
'
((
6 (
@
@
'
2
3
(
(
(
% .
0
<
(
4
'
'
(
'
/
(
%
'
(
+
%/
'
(
'
(
4
''
(
B
'
(
'
%6
A
'
'
+
(
:
''
(
'
''
%
1
(
@
'
(
(
'
'
'
(
$
@
'
(
%
1
'
'
'
'
:
Halaman 18
Pëtr Kropotkin
((
'
% .
(
% 1
(
3
'
.
:,
'
@
(
(
'
%
'
(
0
% I
@
(
#
%
6 (
3
(
'
%
,
(
'
(
#
(
4
(
% N
(
'% ,
'
(
('
(
'
('
(
' '
'
' '
@
( ' ( #
%1
'
<
(
@
(
'
'
'
A
(
+
B
'
(
(
%
(
'
%
1
(
'
=
(
'
( (
>
(
(
( #
%/
'
'
'
(
(
( (
'
% D '
((
(
% 1
(
'
'
'
(
#
(
(
'
'
(
(
%
Halaman 19
Pëtr Kropotkin
' (
(
(
(
/
(
(
(
(
(
>
(
'
=
(
(
(
%
=
'
1
'
/
'
@
((
'
#
%
'
%1
(
#
<
(
(
4
>
(
' (
(
(
(
(
@
''
%
(
@
(
(
<
( @
(
%
.
(
(
'
'
'
(
( '
(
(
%, (
(
%
LLL
/
#
(
'
(
(
(
<
'
'
'
'
'
'
'(
'
(
<
''
<
'
'
(
' %
/
'
(
3
'
(
1
( I
<
% .
(
(
'
Halaman 20
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
(
'
(
,
%
=
(
2
>
@ 2
@
2 +
'
(
'
'
'
'
(
@
% .
'
'
(
(
'
'
(
% .
(
'
'
1
(
%
((
'
((
(
(
'
'
(
@
@ +
'
((
/
3
%/
%
.
'
(
(
3
% /
(
'
(
(
0
('
(
0
(
$
/
6 (
&
((
(
'
6 (
(
(
(
(
.
1
'
((
+
%
(
'
(
'
'
(
'
0 '6 (
+
#
%/
%
% 7
%
Halaman 21
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
(
'
' ' #
((
(
'
%.
(
1 '
.
2 (
(
F
@
,
(
'
'
%/
((
(
(
3 '
.
@
+
'
((
' %
1'
((
'
'
'
( '
% 1
(
%
/ (
3
'
@
(
'
'
% 1
'
(
(
=
'(
#
>% .
(
'
'
('
# '
(
% /
'
(
'
:
'
(
'
' ( %/
'
#
7
(
1
((
'
(
(
'
'
'
' %
(
(
#
( %
@
3
'
'
(
(
'
%/
(
'
%
(
' (
Halaman 22
Pëtr Kropotkin
((
((
A
B
%.
#
'
((
(
(
(
' 0
@
#
I
'@
'
(
='
(
'
$
( %
>
@
% .
'
# '
'
'
(
((
(
(
(
<
%&
(
(
((
'
%
/
(
(
(
'
(
@
2
(
3
' 2
/
(
@
,
F
%1
6
(
'
0
(
((
'
=
6 (
'
(
, (
7
((
,
(
0
1
'
(
(
'
G
(
2
@
3
(
1(
'
D
'
(
''
'
>%
D '
(
'
( '
7 (
'
7
'
'
(
4
(
%
1
'
(
'
((
%
+
'
'
((
((
(
% &
(
( % .
'
((
A
B
'
6
& '
'
D
(
(
2
'
7
,
,
Halaman 23
Pëtr Kropotkin
+
(
<
,
% .
(
'
'
((
%.
'
( %
'
'
'
'
'
4
@
+
(
(
%3
(
'
@
=
'
((
(
=
>
>@
%
.
'
(
% 3
(
'
(
% .
'
(
%
.
(
'
(
%.
# ' %/
% /
#
+
(
(
#
(
(
@
% /
( '
'
'
'
A
.
'
B
%
(
#
'
(
'
% /
(
'
'
(
'
%.
;
,
<
(
:2
6
7
4
;
'
% /
+
(
Halaman 24
Pëtr Kropotkin
2
/
%, (
(
F
(
#
#
(
2
I
(
>
=
(
(
=
>
'
'
'
#
%
G
@
' >
@
(
((
'
G
.
% .
((
'
%1
>
+
(
'
'
(
'
'
'
'
F
'
'
( '
(
<
%
''
'
'
(
((
=(
>@
(
'
(
#
% ,
(
<
%
I
(
(
'
(
(
/
F
6
#
@
(
(
%.
%.
(
6
'
+
'
'
(
F
(
@
I'
'
(
3 '
F
%
.
(
1'
% .
/
#
(
/
: :
(
#
%
((
'
@
@
Halaman 25
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
(
'
'
"
(
(
2
% ,
(
(
+
%,
((
(
%/
>
(
A
(
2
'
B% .
'
(
( 2
(
% /
(
(
(
:
+
'
1' % .
+
%
(
(
@
'
+
+
0
'
(
.
(
A'
B
'
0
@
(
1'
+
(
:
'
%
I
(
(
(
(
@ 6 '
(
(
3 '
@
:
(
(
'
(
I+
(
% .
A
( 3 '
(
(
'
'
'
B
'
2
%
/
(
(
#
(
@
'
H
'
@
(
Halaman 26
Pëtr Kropotkin
( <
(
( '
(
'
,
'
(
%
(
:
'
(
((
' :
'
@
@
(
'
:
(
'
<
'
(
(
'
(
'
(
'
(
((
%
'
@
(
(
%
'
4
'
@
(
'
M
1 #
( #
(
(
(
( '
=
#
4
(
' >%
LLL
/
4
'
0
(
'
%
1
(
(
(
% /
(
4
%1
6
@
'
F
'
'
'
D
;
F
6
(
'
Halaman 27
Pëtr Kropotkin
,
( O
@
D
'
-
5A
B@
,
D
7
'
& (
(
'
$
' %
;
'
(
(
(
7 (
<
&
+
M.
(
(
(
:'
'
0
2
D
'
.
<
7
<
'
;
6
<
F
G
%1
+
@
'
@
(
'
(
'
' '
(
(
(
<
%7
'
:
7
E
'
'
'
0
(
'
(
'M &
0
(
((
@
(
(
(
(
(
+
%
% 1
(
'
(
'
'
'
'
'
(
(
6 '
@
0
(
(
/
&
'
((
M
/
/ (
(
'
'
''
((
'
=
''
>
%
'
> '
'
=
Halaman 28
Pëtr Kropotkin
7
/
'
(
(
'% &
@
/
/
F
2 (
'
@
,
''
%/
(
1
&
'
''
'
'(
''
'
'
'
<
:
'
@ F
0
&
/ (
(
@
#
4
%
(
%/
(
$ -1 ((
(
'
(
%
%5
(
&
$
'
@
(
E
2
'
((
' '
'
'' %
/
-(
(
#
'
'
'
(
'
(
(
%
/
((
(
(
-
'
( 2
(
(
5 @
'
'
''
(
(
<
2
/
@
((
(
%
0
''
'
#
4
<
2
>
(
'
(
2
' #
'
@
%
.
%.
% 1
(
%
''
Halaman 29
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
+
(
0
1' % .
'
'
'
%.
(
( (
'
.
(
((
(
(
' (
% .
'
%.
(
(
(
2
'
%.
(
#
'
2
((
'
%
#
+
''
#
<
(
(
%
(
1
M/
2
$
.
6 ( #
(
@
'
(
((
1
'
(
@
(
(
@
%
LLL
I
(
((
'
M
4
M
/
' %
((
1
@
1'
(
(
/
(
((
(
(
(
%
(
@
(
( '
(
(
(
(
(
@
'
%
Halaman 30
Pëtr Kropotkin
,
(
' '
(
/
2
(
'
% ,
'
% .
(
(
(
(
(%
&
%
4
:
%.
'
%/ /
'
((
'
(
((
(
=
(
(
(
%3
%1
'
'
>
(
'
''
(
'
(
((
(
:
'
'
.
'
'
#
%
(
0
((
'
'%
(
% 1
(
((
' %
'
(
'
'
%
'
(
(
1
(
'
'
'
(
'
(
#
'
%
(%
/
(
((
(
/
(
+
(
'
'
(
@
(
1 '
(
.
(
%
(
( <
-
(
@
>
' A
Halaman 31
Pëtr Kropotkin
B
A (
'
2
(
'
B
-
5
''
'
'
(
'
-
(
(
(% 1
'
'
5
5%
'
$
% .
( '%
(
'
+
% &
'
.
(
6
<
'
(
1
6
%
'
(
'
'
F
@
'' (
'
<
'
C
K
7
'
'
7
.
(
(
F
'
2 0
( ' F
%
<
(
D
,
(
(
@
@
'
(
((
<
((
@
%.
(
@
(
%/
(
(
(
%/
7
/( '
D '
/
0
(
'
( (
(
'
(
(
'
(
(
'
/
:
%
(
'
'
+
; (
% 1
'
%
Halaman 32
Pëtr Kropotkin
:
'
'
'
'
'
(
(
6 (
(
'
'
'
(
& 0
(
@
$
'
'
(
@
%
/
+
'
%1
'
(
'
(
%
LLL
&
+
'
%
&
'
'
'
4
'
(
(
%
/
'
(
(
=
A (
(
(
'
((
(
(
%.
%/
% 1
(
(
'
=(
=
(
'
>
(
+
(
(
'
( (
'
(
% /
'
(
I
#
'
((
>
=
'
(
><
'
((
% I
(
(
%
'
(
'
'
(
% .
'
(
''
4
'
'
' 0
%
Halaman 33
Pëtr Kropotkin
1
%&
(
'
A
"
+
@
,
B
#
(
'
'
1
%
'
+
=
# '
( (
G
6 (
1
#
>
% .
'
(
>
'%
.
3
(
%1
(
'
'
'
(
%
'
% .
6 (
(%
&
@
+
(
(
<
6 (
'
(
#
@
(
(
(
%
'
'
'
'
(
%/
((
((
'
'
(
(
+
<
(
%1
'
'
''
(
(
'
(
(
I
%
%
(
'
'
(
M
Halaman 34
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
6
M;
(
=
0
'
M1
'
(
(
(
'
'
'
M ,
'
(
%7 (
@
('
(
@
$
'
( %
'
>
'
'
1
#
6 (
((
'
(
(
'
'
'
0
%&
%
1
<
(
(
(
'
(
'
(
'
=
(
>
'
'
@
(
'
.
'
(
(%
3
(
(
3
'
%
.
'
4
3
3
(
6
% .
(
.
(
.
(
D
(
'
3
'
2
3
+ (
2
'
% 1
&
+
(
(
(
%
'
'
Halaman 35
Pëtr Kropotkin
1 '
@
/ 4
6 (
%
.
3
@
(
2
%
((
(
( ' (
2
'
%
.
2
((
(
1'
%.
(
1
%
(
4
(
( '
(
@
'
(
+
((
@
3
1
A
3 '
B
(
(
P9
,
(
(
'
%
P
'% .
4
.
% &
'
'
% .
4
(
(
(
'
(
'
7
3
(
3
3
% H
(
(
(
2
(
'
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
@
' '
,
%
(
1
(
'
(
+
&
'
3 '
,
(
2
0
'
'
%CPK
(
2
'
'
%
.
(
((
(
((
(
'
F
F
@
6 (
Halaman 36
Pëtr Kropotkin
'% 1
2
+
(
'
(
'
(
(
F
(
F
6
(
(
(
((
(
% 1
'
(
%
(
<
(
'
'
(
$
'
(
2
'
((
<
(
F
(
'
((
2
<
%.
(
(
1
'
((
(
(
4
;
' 0
&
$
'
(% 1
(
(
((
4
(
# '
$
&
'
(
@
' (
(
@
>
=
'
'
( '
' (
(@
'
'M
&
.
(
(
%
+ '
(
'
'
( '
(
#
'
'
'
(
'
((
(
1
(
%
'
(
@F
6
' '
(
(
(
@
'
2
F
6
%
(
'
2
(
(
1
(
Halaman 37
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
'% .
((
(
(
'
'
=
&
'
>
2
.
(
'
(
(
((
+
2
('
(
'
3
%
(
6
A
(
B
((
'
2
%
2
+
%.
#
#
%
(
(
2
/
2
G
(
(
2
'
'
(
M
(
%
'
'
'
1
(
'
'
%
,
7
F (
(
/
% I
.
A
&
3
(
(
+
2
% 1
2
6
(
(
,
2
6
%.
(
' '
4
0
'
((
(
&
;
2
6
B
'
%
'
G .
((
A
'
' ME
(
(
B #
F
0
% 1
'
:
'
'
(
Halaman 38
Pëtr Kropotkin
' '
' :
((
'
+
'
%
&
2
$
>% .
'
2
'
2
' 0
' 0
(
<
'
( %
4
2
#
= 2
: (
%. 2
"(
'
(
0
% / (
% ,
(
(
%2
2
1
2
+
@
((
4
'
(
@
2
''
'
%
% .
'
(
(
%
.
2
4
/
% 1
$
+
3
(
(
'
<
(
(
'
(
9) )))
,
B
((
%
M.
)) )))
'
'
A
(
'
(
% .
2
'
% 3
( (
2
(
%/
> (
<
%
'
((
(
Halaman 39
Pëtr Kropotkin
2
(
(
%
3
'
2
%
'
(
2
'
(
GI
2
+
+
MI
.
(
(
3 '
Q/D @
=6
2
F
"8
2
>@
(
(
,
(
/
%
(
+
'
'
+
% /
(
(
'
<
( '
'
%/ 6
2
6 (
(
'
%
&
'
'
(
2
((
'
(
'
#
M
.
2
+
<
'
'
<
(
+
((
<
(
'
#
((
(
@
(
(
'
'
'
%
<
(
+
'
Halaman 40
Pëtr Kropotkin
I
(
'
%I
'
2
'
'
((
'
((
(
'
'
2
((
@
(
'
'
'
%
'
(
(
@
'
=
(
>% .
'
'
(
'
(
<
(
(
%
(
%1
(
@
(
;
((
'
'
#
,
0@
2
$
<
(
2
2
/
,
%
'
+
'
, ( "9!
'
'
'
2
'
F
((
% -3
'
((
Q/D
=
(
%%%
(
>
/
'
((
>
'
(
5
'
(
'
((
(
+
A
' %2
(
'
(
'
2
+
""J
'
%%%
((
%
%%%
=6
2
>
(
'
%
((
% 1
J J% .
'
(
(
(
@
#
(
-
&
#
B% . '
:
Halaman 41
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
>
=
'
(
(
'
2
':
'
' % 1
0
( ( '
J J
6
(
((
%.
(
'
.
;
1
(
(
%
(
J !
((
( '
'
((
(% /
(
,
%.
(
4
J!P
3
#
1
(
'
@
((
"
%
/
(
$
%.
&
' 0 '
(
'
((
0
>@
=
'
(
((
""!
(
(% /
4
(
'
(
'
'
=
(
%
J!P
( '
0
@ '
((
'
+
%
=
((
'
>
'% 2
0
((
7
'
(
(
'
'
.
>
4
(
(
'
%&
(
'
'
%
%
;
(
((
M
1 '
?8 J!8
( #
%. 2
(
'
(
Halaman 42
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
?
%&
'
E
(
D
((
2
(
)
% .
((
(
'
<
(
(
P" )))
6
((
G 1
P)
% 1
J !
(
(
2
'
+
%
"%
((
((
P
(
;
M7
((
( P)
.
(
G3
'(
(
'
(
@
7
$
((
'
'
/// @
%
PJ
( '
(
2
(
(
'
% 7
7
0
///
'
'
(
(
%
2
=
=
(
% 1
>
'
'
(
>% I
1
@
'
((
('
(
G
7
3 '
+
,
(
2
%C8K
&
'
3
%I
3 '
'
3
(
' '
(
'
(
(
((
%.
<
1
(
'
& ' (
3
@
4
'
@
((
Halaman 43
Pëtr Kropotkin
':
% 1
((
(
(
'
(
'
'
'
3 '
(
(
'
'
(
A
' B
(
3 '
+
+
/ & ' (
(
0
(
(
2
(
(
(
(G
/
2
(
((
9) % I
%
3
.
,
((
(
%1
'
((
C9K
((
'
(
(
# '
(
((
=2
>
(
'
+
(
'
(
' %
LLL
&
2
'
'
((
% ,
M I
0 '
'
'
(
(
0
(
2
%.
2
(
(
<
.
(
(
(
2
2
'
#
<
(
2
%
+
'
+
' %
0
(
( @
(
4
(
(
(
@
'
'
+
':
'
' <
'
'
3 '
4
Halaman 44
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
( %
.
%F
0
(
(
6 (
(
%.
%
<
/
* "
(
@
,
((
((
'
'(
1'
@
(
'
(
((
>
% .
7
' 0
& 0
(
' 6 (
%
/
'
,
'
((
@
(
(
/
,
$$
(
((
.
%
(
(
(
.
.
.
.
%
A1
(
!PB%
'
(
/ (
'( >
%&
6
=
(
+
(
2
(%
1
?) )))
' %1(
&
G /
(
(
=
(
(
>
'(
'%
'
((
$
'
(
'
' (
%.
G
Halaman 45
Pëtr Kropotkin
% .
(
' %&
#
'
(
2
G1
'
2
'
(
#
'
' @
(
%1
'
2
.
P
(
'
G
,
(
'
0
P*
:
'
6
"
(
'
'
'
%
1
2
(
#
'
'
'
'
#
4
@
(
1' %
=
(
(
'
(
2
G
-/
'
((
(%
2
'
'
C
@
>% .
'
2
(
#
(
% /
(
(
'
'
%5 .
(
K
'
3
(
+
%
1
///
'
'
'
C K(
&
'
3
3 '
(
'
(
(
(
(
5%
'
2
@'
@
C
%
'
(% .
(
3 '
K
C
K
2
(
'
(
Halaman 46
Pëtr Kropotkin
%/
4
(
<
D///
#
'
(
2
'
'
'
%1
'
% .
(
'
/
+
(
%
'
.
6 '
'
(
=
=
>G
(
/
:
'
>
2
'
(
/
'
=2
&
(
2
$
6
>G .
3 '
'
(
2
,
+
%1
(
(
'
'
'
M
(
(
(
(
(
'
(
'
(
%
.
2
&
(%
2
'
'
(
#
(
% /
'
%.
2
%
/
1'
'
'
'
(
(
'
' (
% .
(
(
(
(
%
1
'
2
'
%, (
# ' % 1
(
'
Halaman 47
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
(
(
(
%. 3 '
(
4
(
(
4
@
% 1
@ (
(
'
#
(
$
'
$
'
+ (
(
4
( G
&
% /
2
%, (
'
+
+
4
'
(
%/
'
(
(
''
(
%1
'
'
((
4
%
&
2
F
% .
'
4
'
'
(
'
(
(
%
LLL
E
'
%H
'%
'
(
' M /
'
(
( M
&
>
(
(
+
'
(
(
2
'
M
2
G 1
+
& '
(
%
(
'
Halaman 48
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
(
'
3
'
(
(
+4
(
M
(
'
7
(
(
1'
'
M.
(
'
(
(
(
'
#
'
(
%
4
(
%
2
2
%1
'
'
(
C(
( K
(%
'
1
(
(
'
'
: +
(
'
'
(
1' %
(
'
,
6
&
(
'
'
(
(
2
%
6
2
;
%
( (
@
(
.
2
&
'
2
@
M
$ -.
0
%
' 2
( '
%2 @
G5
/
'
6
(
2
% &
'
(
2
#
M;
(
'
G/
%1
(
(
'
(
(
(
6
+
J!PM M.
'
(
'
(
'
@7
G5 /
" %
;
;
Pëtr Kropotkin
Halaman 49
+
(
'
(
'
'
M
M
/
((
2
'
(%
/
6
(
'
% /
(
(
5%
(
2
3 '
(
$ -1
(
(
,
'
''
''
(
: +
+
'
'
(
( <
% 1
(
(
")B
&
A
'
(
'
>
@
(
'
(
'
2
(
%
''
G1
(
(
G
1
'
@
'
( (
(
'
(
@
(
2
%
&
(
F
M
(
' '
((
''
2
'
'
@
'
2
'
'
%
(
.
''
'
2
H
'
G.
1
(
''
'
@
(
'
''
2
'
#
'
G3
G7
Halaman 50
Pëtr Kropotkin
#
'
@
(
(
>
@
'
''
(
(
4
(
I
I
+
2
(
+
@
@
G
'
'
(
2
'
3
(
1(
(
(
( #
%
.
2
(
(
(
<
(
( (
'
@
(
2
(
@
'
2
% .
#
'
4
'
(
(
%1
,
%
1
#
(
(
2
(
(
'
'
%
/
'
(
'
@#
('
(
2
%1
(
%.
(
#
'
2
%
F
6 (
:
'
'
2
(
'
'
'
(
'
(
'
%
'
%7
$
:2
%
Halaman 51
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
(
#
#
'
' % ,
(
'
(
2
$ -7
(
'
'
2
5
6 (
(
'
1
#
1
'
<
'
'
% -.
@
'
(
'
(
(% E
(
'
2
' 4
(
%5
'
2
'
'
.
(
%
%2
%1
%
(
/
,
2
(
2
'(
(
'
(
(
(
(
( 2
G
'
/
@
'
@
2
'
'
'
(
@
/
2
%
/
(
(
(
'(
(
%
Halaman 52
Pëtr Kropotkin
+
'
#
(
( '@
%
(
1
'
'
'
%
.
' (
' MI
(
=.
' (
2
0
'
$
+
:(
%
'
@ '
%/
+
M/
<
'
1
2
(
(
(<
>
R
( @
' (
'
'
(
>
(%
M>
4
(
(
'
' (
'
(
1
G,
>
2
(
'
((
%
.
1
.
+ (
'
6
(
,
%
(
'
(
(
'
'
(
%
0
,
@/ (
'
'
(
(
@
(
%,
0
?9
3
(
(
'
(
'% .
Halaman 53
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
(
(
/
(
(M
(
,
(
+
'
' %.
' (
:
(
0
' 0
6 (
'
'
(
'
,
+
2
'
0
+
'
2
(
% 1
+
'
'
@
(
'
(
' % .
2
0
(
(
'
(
'
<
0
(
(
(
% F
'
'
%
.
@
/ (
'
@
=
2
>
'
0
'
0
6
%
' 0
(
((
'
'
+
( '
@
>% 1
@
( (
'
'
0
'
'
(
= '
+
0
'
(
@
@
%
1
'
' '
(
(
(
&
+
%
(
(
4
G.
(
(
+
'
'
(
Halaman 54
Pëtr Kropotkin
4
(
'
2
G@
0
(
'
(
( '
(
(
@
(
$
' (
(
'
(
4
(
(
4
(
(
(
G
'
.
(
(
G
'
(
(
'
(
(
(
% /
' ' (
=
(
(
#
(
4
><
(
'
:(
%/
+
(
'
(
'
'
'
(
'
4
+
'
(
'
0
@
'
%
1
(
( (
' 0
'
(
'
((
(
(
%
1
2
2
'
+
+
'
((
'
+
'
0
2
>
(
(
(
(
(
(
+
(
(
G .
'
4
(
(
@
((
%.
( #
%%%
G
Halaman 55
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
'
0
'
$
<
(
%1
6 (
<
(
%
&
(
'
@
'
(
'
(
(
@
%
'
(
(
'
%1
'
4
6 (
(
(
%
LLL
(
'
( '
% 1'
(
(
% 3'
7
3
3
(
( $
'
'
%&
(
'
((
<
2
%
/ 3'
(
0
'
'
(
%/
((
2
<
%
;
(
2
(
:
1
%/
$
'
2
0
%%%
G
(
%1
'
((
0
%2
0
%&
%/
((
3
(%
((
4
'
3(
Halaman 56
Pëtr Kropotkin
1 +
% .
2
%%%
6 (
'
0
'
0
G
(
'
6 (
2
(
I
6 (
2
0
(
%I
(
% 1
%&
'
%
((
'
3(
3(
%%%
(
2
(
% 2
'
(
'
'
((
( '
%/
'
(
(
'
(
;
ME $
.
2
%%%&
G
@
( '
'
(
(
%%%
'
' '
''
(
%%%
!
G
2
'
.
2
'
'
(
'
%
G
[1]
The reasons which lead me to this hypothesis are put forward in a paper, Dessication of Eur-Asia, compiled
for the Research Department of the Geographical Society of London, and published in its Geographical
Journal for June 1904.
[2]
Readers interested in this subject as well as in that of the communal phases and of the free cities, will find
more detailed information and source references in my book Mutual Aid.
[3]
The time of troubles in Russia at the beginning of the seventeenth century, represent a similar movement,
directed against serfdom and the State but without a religious basis.
[4]
It is already being done in Russia, the government having authorized the pillaging of communal lands under
the law of 1906 and favored this pillage by its own functionaries.
[5]
See Dr. Gilbert Slater ‘The Inclosure of Common Fields’ in the Geographical Journal of the Geographical
Society of London, with plans and maps, January 1907. Later published in volume form.
Pëtr Kropotkin
Halaman 57
Note for the marxists.org Archive edition: When downloaded from Endpage.com
certain passages of the text were found to be corrupted. Attempts were made to
compare this version with those in other archives but all those we found were
similarly corrupted, an indication that all versions stem from the same scanning
process. Most of the errors were obvious but in a few cases it was necessary to
reconstruct the text consulting the French version available at kropot.free.fr —
these phrases are enclosed in square brackets.
1896
1
Halaman 2
Pëtr Kropotkin
!"
#
$
% &
'
#
,
1'
'
'
!)* !"
'%
-.
(
(
(
+
/
0 '(
(
'
2
'
(
3
(
% /
(
(
(
'
4
(
(
% /
((
$
3 '
%5
1
% .
6
7
(
(
,
,
0
#
0 (
(
6
% 1
(
,
(
(
(
+
8)))
2
9)))
(
(
%
(
7
:;
(%
+
(,
<
=
(
'
'
>% 1
( '
( %
%
(
!)? @
(
+
(
(
'
@
#
(
(
Halaman 3
Pëtr Kropotkin
>
4
%
-
(
>
' (
(
+
A=
( B%
(
(&
=/
'
C
,
(
(
B
(
(
(
(
-=D
-1
=/
/
(
' (
%
> /
>%
2
#
/
'
(
(
'>
>%
2
% =E
-.
,
A
(
(
'
'
((
%E
>
'
+
(B
/
;
(
% 7
7 %
'
-1
% .
>
( '$ =.
>%
'
-=.
'
/ (
/
'
'
/
(
% .
(
@
%>
> /
'
'
% =2
>%
'
/
%5
>
(
(
# (
(
=
'
( <
:
(
% 1
(
(
(
>
'
:
Halaman 4
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
<
>
(
'
(
%
(
2 (
(
(
'
(
4
'
'
(
% ,
(
(
'
'
'
'
%
'
(
$ -.
!"!
!"!
+
(
(
2
<
F
(
2
(
' (
=
(
(
F
(
G/
+
>
:
(
6'
A'
B
6'
'
:
' =
(
>
:
>
>
(
:&
A;
F
(
'
/
' (
!" B
=;
(
> !"
(
6 ' >
%5
!"
6 '
6'
>
@
(.
(
=
2
(
0
=2
@
'
'
((
H
,
'
-
(
(
>
2
'
+
><
(
'
+
'
(
(%
! "
(
5
(
(
(
(
(
<
'
(
(
.
' 4
Halaman 5
Pëtr Kropotkin
-
'5
#
,
% I
! C
!J8K
(
3%
>
#
1
(
$
'
2
(
#
(
(
'
(
'
' (
(
'
(
'
'
(
%
/
#
(
(
+
'
( "
$
(
&
%
$
%
+
+
%
/
(
>
(
(
% .
(
(
:
A (
# '' '
'
(
3+
4
'
'
(
>
&' &
F
")
'
GB% 1
2
3+
'
+
(
(
(
0
=2
:(
>%
>
%%%
$-
G5%
;
D
LLLLL
'
0 '
%
(
6
! "
Halaman 6
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
2
/ (
+ (
/
( $
#
'
(
'
2
'
(
%
/
4
2
%.
(
( '
+
(
'
(
+
( '
%
.
'
2
'
(
+
'
%1
2
(
'
('
'
4
(
'
2
( '% .
( %
/
%/
(
'
(
'
%1
'
2
(
@
@
((
#
((
2
(
'
''
0
2
( '
(
%
LLL
F
'
(=
2
>%
4
' %
Halaman 7
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
(
% .
'
(
'
(
(
,
0 2
2
<
'
'
>
(
'
'
=
>%
'
'
(
(
<
2
2
'
'
<
3
@
'
2
'
+
(
<
>
'
((
2
'
((
.
(
%
2
(
%
(
(
(
M
I
'
'
2
% 2
(
2
(
'
(
(
(
(
%
(
4
(
2
% . 2
'
(
(
'
(
(
(
'
%/
+
$
(
(
$ &
$
$
$
( (
2
(
+
'
(
#
.
( '
$
(
% /
% 1
'
(
(
'
%
('
'
2
%
Halaman 8
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
2
(
%
.
6 (
3(
(
2
' >
(
'
6 ( $
(
' %, (6 (
%.
% /
% 3
(
(
3(
( '
'
.
@
3(
% 3
(
2
(
'
(
6 (
'
'
6 (
(
'
' '
'
%1
(
0
"(
'
3(
(
%
3
'
(
3(
(
&
<
'
'
'
+
(
(
0
%
(
'
<
(
(
(
3(
@
(
0
%
2
0
4
(
'
0
'
'
(
6 (
1 +
3 %
(
/
'
6 (
(
2
2
3(
'
'
3(
0
'
'
2
%
(
Halaman 9
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
1
'
(
%
(
'
'
(
(
(
(
% &
'
0 % 1
''
(
'
/
M@
'
%1
@
(
(
0 '
(
( '
(
':
(
'
(
(
0
.
(
(
M
'
'
(
3
>
(
' % 7
=
'
<
'
6
(
(
%
.
(
+
(
( ' +
' '
%/
(
% /
''
'
(
'
(
(
%
'
<
+
%
@
'
' @
(
%.
(
'
( (
( %
% (
@
@
'
(
(
(
'
(
( (
Halaman 10
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
(
'
'
(
(
+
( (( % 1
'
<
(
+
(
(
' '
(
'
'
( '
(
+
(
(
% I
(
'
(
(
'
((
:'
'
'
%
'
' '
'
'
(
(
0
%.
(
'
(
'
'
.
%
(
'
( (
% .
3 '
=
0
>
(
($
(
>
(
>
(
(
'
%
,
( +
'
(
(
@
(
*
'
@
(
4
(
%
(
2
(
(
4
(
& <
(
% .
''
,
1
'
%.
(
(
(
(
'
'
(
(
1'
%
&
'
/
3
1
"
(
(
')
@
'
@
+
(
%
&
'
'
('
(
% .
'
(
' (
%/
(
3% 7
Halaman 11
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
( /
F
' (
% ,
'
'
% 7
(
'% 1
(
(
(
%
(
' $
< 4
+
(
, (
'
%E
'
<
%
'
( (
(
(
( (
%
.
:
$ -&
(
(% /
G1
'
5@
'
@
#
%%%
=
(
>
%
/
A
(
B
(
(
'
/
(
% 1
(
(
'
%.
(
(
.
(
%.
' @
(
:(
'
(
( (
(
%
(
@
(
(
' % 2(
0
'
(
%1
'
:
>
(
(
%/ (
'
(
:
:
%1
(
=
(
> ( (
((
%1
'
'
'
:
'
'
Halaman 12
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
(
(
=(
(
(
>
(
(
%1
' (
/ '
%
'
'
(
'
(
'('
=
>A
B
(
''
%&
(
(
'
3
( %
7
(
6 (
3(
#
( ' '
'
'
( %
/
('
7
1
(
'
(
%
(
(
0
1
@
(
3
+C K @
'
'
(
%
/
('
'
+
'
'
( '
( '
+
'
(
(
' (
'
(
(
(
'
3
((
((
%.
((
'' (
<
(
'
('
(
(
'
:
@
(
(
(
M
.
A
(
B
'
% 1
'
$
((
'' (
@
%C?K
Halaman 13
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
.
(
((
@
(
(
'
@
(
'%
'<
'
'
'
'' (
'
'
% F
(
(
((
'
(
3
%.
1
@2
6 (
'
@
0
%1
1
(
(
%
'
((
'
%
(
'
0
%
F
%
.
'
((
(
%&
(( % .
(
(
(
(
3
/
2
(
@
(
'
(
%
'
%/
(
'
2
2
.
3
(
6
(
%
(
'
((
%2
A
(
B
'
'
((
'
0
&
2
3(
'
+
1
#
%
I
'
'
'
(
'
@
@
((
( %
'
%
((
Halaman 14
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
'
% 1
@
'
'
'
(
@
((
#
(
((
&
=
'
'
(
> @
(
'
'
'
(
( @
'
(
(
%.
2
(
%
'
'
(
'
%
/
'
(
%
(
((
(
#
' %F
(
(
'
#
'
'
(
(
'
(
'
((
(
>
(
((
'
=
$
(
#
'
/
%
'
/
% / (
%2
(
2
0
+
(
(
(
B
#
'
(
'
'
(
=
'
>
%6 (
.
'
'
% 2
'
((
'
'
(
%
.
'
((
#
:
'
'
'
'
'
( '
A
(
'
((
'
((
(
(
%
((
<
Halaman 15
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
#
'
'
(
(
'%
&
$
% 7
(
'
(
(
'
%I
(
(
'
#
(
'
<
(
'
% 1
<
(
=
%
#
>
'
'
(
(
(
(
2
6 (
.
(
&
#
(
(
& 0
%2 (
I
(
#
'
(
#
(
(
%
'
/
%
%
>% 1
>
'
+
% .
,
'
=
@
=
% H
(
(
(
+ (
( ' (
'
((
$
((
((
(
(
'
'
'
(
(
(
%
>
3
#
<
(
%
(
+
(
'
4
(
(
(
M
('
M/
(
<
'
(
>
(
+
=
%
>% 1
(
Halaman 16
Pëtr Kropotkin
&
(
(
'
' '
'
+
(% ,
<
%
(
'
(
'
'
<
(
(
'
>
<
% &
' (
(
(
'
'
(
(
'
% .
% .
(
'
@#
1'
% 1
( <
'
<
$
$
+
+
%.
( (
$@
>
@
>
=
'
((
> =
><
(
>
> >(
'
%
'
%
3
(
%H
#
(
$
"
%
(
( ( (
=
'
>
+
(
'
''
<
+
<
(
='
'
<
'
><
3
+
6 (
2
(
'
((
@
% /
(
(
(
'
'
.
((
2
#
(
%
+
(
(
(
'
<
( %I
Halaman 17
Pëtr Kropotkin
& 0
+ ((
A
6 (
B
'
(
%
.
(
'
4
(
'
(
(
%
/
((
'
((
6 (
@
@
'
2
3
(
(
(
% .
0
<
(
4
'
'
(
'
/
(
%
'
(
+
%/
'
(
'
(
4
''
(
B
'
(
'
%6
A
'
'
+
(
:
''
(
'
''
%
1
(
@
'
(
(
'
'
'
(
$
@
'
(
%
1
'
'
'
'
:
Halaman 18
Pëtr Kropotkin
((
'
% .
(
% 1
(
3
'
.
:,
'
@
(
(
'
%
'
(
0
% I
@
(
#
%
6 (
3
(
'
%
,
(
'
(
#
(
4
(
% N
(
'% ,
'
(
('
(
'
('
(
' '
'
' '
@
( ' ( #
%1
'
<
(
@
(
'
'
'
A
(
+
B
'
(
(
%
(
'
%
1
(
'
=
(
'
( (
>
(
(
( #
%/
'
'
'
(
(
( (
'
% D '
((
(
% 1
(
'
'
'
(
#
(
(
'
'
(
(
%
Halaman 19
Pëtr Kropotkin
' (
(
(
(
/
(
(
(
(
(
>
(
'
=
(
(
(
%
=
'
1
'
/
'
@
((
'
#
%
'
%1
(
#
<
(
(
4
>
(
' (
(
(
(
(
@
''
%
(
@
(
(
<
( @
(
%
.
(
(
'
'
'
(
( '
(
(
%, (
(
%
LLL
/
#
(
'
(
(
(
<
'
'
'
'
'
'
'(
'
(
<
''
<
'
'
(
' %
/
'
(
3
'
(
1
( I
<
% .
(
(
'
Halaman 20
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
(
'
(
,
%
=
(
2
>
@ 2
@
2 +
'
(
'
'
'
'
(
@
% .
'
'
(
(
'
'
(
% .
(
'
'
1
(
%
((
'
((
(
(
'
'
(
@
@ +
'
((
/
3
%/
%
.
'
(
(
3
% /
(
'
(
(
0
('
(
0
(
$
/
6 (
&
((
(
'
6 (
(
(
(
(
.
1
'
((
+
%
(
'
(
'
'
(
'
0 '6 (
+
#
%/
%
% 7
%
Halaman 21
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
(
'
' ' #
((
(
'
%.
(
1 '
.
2 (
(
F
@
,
(
'
'
%/
((
(
(
3 '
.
@
+
'
((
' %
1'
((
'
'
'
( '
% 1
(
%
/ (
3
'
@
(
'
'
% 1
'
(
(
=
'(
#
>% .
(
'
'
('
# '
(
% /
'
(
'
:
'
(
'
' ( %/
'
#
7
(
1
((
'
(
(
'
'
'
' %
(
(
#
( %
@
3
'
'
(
(
'
%/
(
'
%
(
' (
Halaman 22
Pëtr Kropotkin
((
((
A
B
%.
#
'
((
(
(
(
' 0
@
#
I
'@
'
(
='
(
'
$
( %
>
@
% .
'
# '
'
'
(
((
(
(
(
<
%&
(
(
((
'
%
/
(
(
(
'
(
@
2
(
3
' 2
/
(
@
,
F
%1
6
(
'
0
(
((
'
=
6 (
'
(
, (
7
((
,
(
0
1
'
(
(
'
G
(
2
@
3
(
1(
'
D
'
(
''
'
>%
D '
(
'
( '
7 (
'
7
'
'
(
4
(
%
1
'
(
'
((
%
+
'
'
((
((
(
% &
(
( % .
'
((
A
B
'
6
& '
'
D
(
(
2
'
7
,
,
Halaman 23
Pëtr Kropotkin
+
(
<
,
% .
(
'
'
((
%.
'
( %
'
'
'
'
'
4
@
+
(
(
%3
(
'
@
=
'
((
(
=
>
>@
%
.
'
(
% 3
(
'
(
% .
'
(
%
.
(
'
(
%.
# ' %/
% /
#
+
(
(
#
(
(
@
% /
( '
'
'
'
A
.
'
B
%
(
#
'
(
'
% /
(
'
'
(
'
%.
;
,
<
(
:2
6
7
4
;
'
% /
+
(
Halaman 24
Pëtr Kropotkin
2
/
%, (
(
F
(
#
#
(
2
I
(
>
=
(
(
=
>
'
'
'
#
%
G
@
' >
@
(
((
'
G
.
% .
((
'
%1
>
+
(
'
'
(
'
'
'
'
F
'
'
( '
(
<
%
''
'
'
(
((
=(
>@
(
'
(
#
% ,
(
<
%
I
(
(
'
(
(
/
F
6
#
@
(
(
%.
%.
(
6
'
+
'
'
(
F
(
@
I'
'
(
3 '
F
%
.
(
1'
% .
/
#
(
/
: :
(
#
%
((
'
@
@
Halaman 25
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
'
(
'
'
"
(
(
2
% ,
(
(
+
%,
((
(
%/
>
(
A
(
2
'
B% .
'
(
( 2
(
% /
(
(
(
:
+
'
1' % .
+
%
(
(
@
'
+
+
0
'
(
.
(
A'
B
'
0
@
(
1'
+
(
:
'
%
I
(
(
(
(
@ 6 '
(
(
3 '
@
:
(
(
'
(
I+
(
% .
A
( 3 '
(
(
'
'
'
B
'
2
%
/
(
(
#
(
@
'
H
'
@
(
Halaman 26
Pëtr Kropotkin
( <
(
( '
(
'
,
'
(
%
(
:
'
(
((
' :
'
@
@
(
'
:
(
'
<
'
(
(
'
(
'
(
'
(
((
%
'
@
(
(
%
'
4
'
@
(
'
M
1 #
( #
(
(
(
( '
=
#
4
(
' >%
LLL
/
4
'
0
(
'
%
1
(
(
(
% /
(
4
%1
6
@
'
F
'
'
'
D
;
F
6
(
'
Halaman 27
Pëtr Kropotkin
,
( O
@
D
'
-
5A
B@
,
D
7
'
& (
(
'
$
' %
;
'
(
(
(
7 (
<
&
+
M.
(
(
(
:'
'
0
2
D
'
.
<
7
<
'
;
6
<
F
G
%1
+
@
'
@
(
'
(
'
' '
(
(
(
<
%7
'
:
7
E
'
'
'
0
(
'
(
'M &
0
(
((
@
(
(
(
(
(
+
%
% 1
(
'
(
'
'
'
'
'
(
(
6 '
@
0
(
(
/
&
'
((
M
/
/ (
(
'
'
''
((
'
=
''
>
%
'
> '
'
=
Halaman 28
Pëtr Kropotkin
7
/
'
(
(
'% &
@
/
/
F
2 (
'
@
,
''
%/
(
1
&
'
''
'
'(
''
'
'
'
<
:
'
@ F
0
&
/ (
(
@
#
4
%
(
%/
(
$ -1 ((
(
'
(
%
%5
(
&
$
'
@
(
E
2
'
((
' '
'
'' %
/
-(
(
#
'
'
'
(
'
(
(
%
/
((
(
(
-
'
( 2
(
(
5 @
'
'
''
(
(
<
2
/
@
((
(
%
0
''
'
#
4
<
2
>
(
'
(
2
' #
'
@
%
.
%.
% 1
(
%
''
Halaman 29
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
+
(
0
1' % .
'
'
'
%.
(
( (
'
.
(
((
(
(
' (
% .
'
%.
(
(
(
2
'
%.
(
#
'
2
((
'
%
#
+
''
#
<
(
(
%
(
1
M/
2
$
.
6 ( #
(
@
'
(
((
1
'
(
@
(
(
@
%
LLL
I
(
((
'
M
4
M
/
' %
((
1
@
1'
(
(
/
(
((
(
(
(
%
(
@
(
( '
(
(
(
(
(
@
'
%
Halaman 30
Pëtr Kropotkin
,
(
' '
(
/
2
(
'
% ,
'
% .
(
(
(
(
(%
&
%
4
:
%.
'
%/ /
'
((
'
(
((
(
=
(
(
(
%3
%1
'
'
>
(
'
''
(
'
(
((
(
:
'
'
.
'
'
#
%
(
0
((
'
'%
(
% 1
(
((
' %
'
(
'
'
%
'
(
(
1
(
'
'
'
(
'
(
#
'
%
(%
/
(
((
(
/
(
+
(
'
'
(
@
(
1 '
(
.
(
%
(
( <
-
(
@
>
' A
Halaman 31
Pëtr Kropotkin
B
A (
'
2
(
'
B
-
5
''
'
'
(
'
-
(
(
(% 1
'
'
5
5%
'
$
% .
( '%
(
'
+
% &
'
.
(
6
<
'
(
1
6
%
'
(
'
'
F
@
'' (
'
<
'
C
K
7
'
'
7
.
(
(
F
'
2 0
( ' F
%
<
(
D
,
(
(
@
@
'
(
((
<
((
@
%.
(
@
(
%/
(
(
(
%/
7
/( '
D '
/
0
(
'
( (
(
'
(
(
'
(
(
'
/
:
%
(
'
'
+
; (
% 1
'
%
Halaman 32
Pëtr Kropotkin
:
'
'
'
'
'
(
(
6 (
(
'
'
'
(
& 0
(
@
$
'
'
(
@
%
/
+
'
%1
'
(
'
(
%
LLL
&
+
'
%
&
'
'
'
4
'
(
(
%
/
'
(
(
=
A (
(
(
'
((
(
(
%.
%/
% 1
(
(
'
=(
=
(
'
>
(
+
(
(
'
( (
'
(
% /
'
(
I
#
'
((
>
=
'
(
><
'
((
% I
(
(
%
'
(
'
'
(
% .
'
(
''
4
'
'
' 0
%
Halaman 33
Pëtr Kropotkin
1
%&
(
'
A
"
+
@
,
B
#
(
'
'
1
%
'
+
=
# '
( (
G
6 (
1
#
>
% .
'
(
>
'%
.
3
(
%1
(
'
'
'
(
%
'
% .
6 (
(%
&
@
+
(
(
<
6 (
'
(
#
@
(
(
(
%
'
'
'
'
(
%/
((
((
'
'
(
(
+
<
(
%1
'
'
''
(
(
'
(
(
I
%
%
(
'
'
(
M
Halaman 34
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
6
M;
(
=
0
'
M1
'
(
(
(
'
'
'
M ,
'
(
%7 (
@
('
(
@
$
'
( %
'
>
'
'
1
#
6 (
((
'
(
(
'
'
'
0
%&
%
1
<
(
(
(
'
(
'
(
'
=
(
>
'
'
@
(
'
.
'
(
(%
3
(
(
3
'
%
.
'
4
3
3
(
6
% .
(
.
(
.
(
D
(
'
3
'
2
3
+ (
2
'
% 1
&
+
(
(
(
%
'
'
Halaman 35
Pëtr Kropotkin
1 '
@
/ 4
6 (
%
.
3
@
(
2
%
((
(
( ' (
2
'
%
.
2
((
(
1'
%.
(
1
%
(
4
(
( '
(
@
'
(
+
((
@
3
1
A
3 '
B
(
(
P9
,
(
(
'
%
P
'% .
4
.
% &
'
'
% .
4
(
(
(
'
(
'
7
3
(
3
3
% H
(
(
(
2
(
'
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
@
' '
,
%
(
1
(
'
(
+
&
'
3 '
,
(
2
0
'
'
%CPK
(
2
'
'
%
.
(
((
(
((
(
'
F
F
@
6 (
Halaman 36
Pëtr Kropotkin
'% 1
2
+
(
'
(
'
(
(
F
(
F
6
(
(
(
((
(
% 1
'
(
%
(
<
(
'
'
(
$
'
(
2
'
((
<
(
F
(
'
((
2
<
%.
(
(
1
'
((
(
(
4
;
' 0
&
$
'
(% 1
(
(
((
4
(
# '
$
&
'
(
@
' (
(
@
>
=
'
'
( '
' (
(@
'
'M
&
.
(
(
%
+ '
(
'
'
( '
(
#
'
'
'
(
'
((
(
1
(
%
'
(
@F
6
' '
(
(
(
@
'
2
F
6
%
(
'
2
(
(
1
(
Halaman 37
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
'% .
((
(
(
'
'
=
&
'
>
2
.
(
'
(
(
((
+
2
('
(
'
3
%
(
6
A
(
B
((
'
2
%
2
+
%.
#
#
%
(
(
2
/
2
G
(
(
2
'
'
(
M
(
%
'
'
'
1
(
'
'
%
,
7
F (
(
/
% I
.
A
&
3
(
(
+
2
% 1
2
6
(
(
,
2
6
%.
(
' '
4
0
'
((
(
&
;
2
6
B
'
%
'
G .
((
A
'
' ME
(
(
B #
F
0
% 1
'
:
'
'
(
Halaman 38
Pëtr Kropotkin
' '
' :
((
'
+
'
%
&
2
$
>% .
'
2
'
2
' 0
' 0
(
<
'
( %
4
2
#
= 2
: (
%. 2
"(
'
(
0
% / (
% ,
(
(
%2
2
1
2
+
@
((
4
'
(
@
2
''
'
%
% .
'
(
(
%
.
2
4
/
% 1
$
+
3
(
(
'
<
(
(
'
(
9) )))
,
B
((
%
M.
)) )))
'
'
A
(
'
(
% .
2
'
% 3
( (
2
(
%/
> (
<
%
'
((
(
Halaman 39
Pëtr Kropotkin
2
(
(
%
3
'
2
%
'
(
2
'
(
GI
2
+
+
MI
.
(
(
3 '
Q/D @
=6
2
F
"8
2
>@
(
(
,
(
/
%
(
+
'
'
+
% /
(
(
'
<
( '
'
%/ 6
2
6 (
(
'
%
&
'
'
(
2
((
'
(
'
#
M
.
2
+
<
'
'
<
(
+
((
<
(
'
#
((
(
@
(
(
'
'
'
%
<
(
+
'
Halaman 40
Pëtr Kropotkin
I
(
'
%I
'
2
'
'
((
'
((
(
'
'
2
((
@
(
'
'
'
%
'
(
(
@
'
=
(
>% .
'
'
(
'
(
<
(
(
%
(
%1
(
@
(
;
((
'
'
#
,
0@
2
$
<
(
2
2
/
,
%
'
+
'
, ( "9!
'
'
'
2
'
F
((
% -3
'
((
Q/D
=
(
%%%
(
>
/
'
((
>
'
(
5
'
(
'
((
(
+
A
' %2
(
'
(
'
2
+
""J
'
%%%
((
%
%%%
=6
2
>
(
'
%
((
% 1
J J% .
'
(
(
(
@
#
(
-
&
#
B% . '
:
Halaman 41
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
>
=
'
(
(
'
2
':
'
' % 1
0
( ( '
J J
6
(
((
%.
(
'
.
;
1
(
(
%
(
J !
((
( '
'
((
(% /
(
,
%.
(
4
J!P
3
#
1
(
'
@
((
"
%
/
(
$
%.
&
' 0 '
(
'
((
0
>@
=
'
(
((
""!
(
(% /
4
(
'
(
'
'
=
(
%
J!P
( '
0
@ '
((
'
+
%
=
((
'
>
'% 2
0
((
7
'
(
(
'
'
.
>
4
(
(
'
%&
(
'
'
%
%
;
(
((
M
1 '
?8 J!8
( #
%. 2
(
'
(
Halaman 42
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
?
%&
'
E
(
D
((
2
(
)
% .
((
(
'
<
(
(
P" )))
6
((
G 1
P)
% 1
J !
(
(
2
'
+
%
"%
((
((
P
(
;
M7
((
( P)
.
(
G3
'(
(
'
(
@
7
$
((
'
'
/// @
%
PJ
( '
(
2
(
(
'
% 7
7
0
///
'
'
(
(
%
2
=
=
(
% 1
>
'
'
(
>% I
1
@
'
((
('
(
G
7
3 '
+
,
(
2
%C8K
&
'
3
%I
3 '
'
3
(
' '
(
'
(
(
((
%.
<
1
(
'
& ' (
3
@
4
'
@
((
Halaman 43
Pëtr Kropotkin
':
% 1
((
(
(
'
(
'
'
'
3 '
(
(
'
'
(
A
' B
(
3 '
+
+
/ & ' (
(
0
(
(
2
(
(
(
(G
/
2
(
((
9) % I
%
3
.
,
((
(
%1
'
((
C9K
((
'
(
(
# '
(
((
=2
>
(
'
+
(
'
(
' %
LLL
&
2
'
'
((
% ,
M I
0 '
'
'
(
(
0
(
2
%.
2
(
(
<
.
(
(
(
2
2
'
#
<
(
2
%
+
'
+
' %
0
(
( @
(
4
(
(
(
@
'
'
+
':
'
' <
'
'
3 '
4
Halaman 44
Pëtr Kropotkin
'
( %
.
%F
0
(
(
6 (
(
%.
%
<
/
* "
(
@
,
((
((
'
'(
1'
@
(
'
(
((
>
% .
7
' 0
& 0
(
' 6 (
%
/
'
,
'
((
@
(
(
/
,
$$
(
((
.
%
(
(
(
.
.
.
.
%
A1
(
!PB%
'
(
/ (
'( >
%&
6
=
(
+
(
2
(%
1
?) )))
' %1(
&
G /
(
(
=
(
(
>
'(
'%
'
((
$
'
(
'
' (
%.
G
Halaman 45
Pëtr Kropotkin
% .
(
' %&
#
'
(
2
G1
'
2
'
(
#
'
' @
(
%1
'
2
.
P
(
'
G
,
(
'
0
P*
:
'
6
"
(
'
'
'
%
1
2
(
#
'
'
'
'
#
4
@
(
1' %
=
(
(
'
(
2
G
-/
'
((
(%
2
'
'
C
@
>% .
'
2
(
#
(
% /
(
(
'
'
%5 .
(
K
'
3
(
+
%
1
///
'
'
'
C K(
&
'
3
3 '
(
'
(
(
(
(
5%
'
2
@'
@
C
%
'
(% .
(
3 '
K
C
K
2
(
'
(
Halaman 46
Pëtr Kropotkin
%/
4
(
<
D///
#
'
(
2
'
'
'
%1
'
% .
(
'
/
+
(
%
'
.
6 '
'
(
=
=
>G
(
/
:
'
>
2
'
(
/
'
=2
&
(
2
$
6
>G .
3 '
'
(
2
,
+
%1
(
(
'
'
'
M
(
(
(
(
(
'
(
'
(
%
.
2
&
(%
2
'
'
(
#
(
% /
'
%.
2
%
/
1'
'
'
'
(
(
'
' (
% .
(
(
(
(
%
1
'
2
'
%, (
# ' % 1
(
'
Halaman 47
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
(
(
(
%. 3 '
(
4
(
(
4
@
% 1
@ (
(
'
#
(
$
'
$
'
+ (
(
4
( G
&
% /
2
%, (
'
+
+
4
'
(
%/
'
(
(
''
(
%1
'
'
((
4
%
&
2
F
% .
'
4
'
'
(
'
(
(
%
LLL
E
'
%H
'%
'
(
' M /
'
(
( M
&
>
(
(
+
'
(
(
2
'
M
2
G 1
+
& '
(
%
(
'
Halaman 48
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
(
(
'
3
'
(
(
+4
(
M
(
'
7
(
(
1'
'
M.
(
'
(
(
(
'
#
'
(
%
4
(
%
2
2
%1
'
'
(
C(
( K
(%
'
1
(
(
'
'
: +
(
'
'
(
1' %
(
'
,
6
&
(
'
'
(
(
2
%
6
2
;
%
( (
@
(
.
2
&
'
2
@
M
$ -.
0
%
' 2
( '
%2 @
G5
/
'
6
(
2
% &
'
(
2
#
M;
(
'
G/
%1
(
(
'
(
(
(
6
+
J!PM M.
'
(
'
(
'
@7
G5 /
" %
;
;
Pëtr Kropotkin
Halaman 49
+
(
'
(
'
'
M
M
/
((
2
'
(%
/
6
(
'
% /
(
(
5%
(
2
3 '
(
$ -1
(
(
,
'
''
''
(
: +
+
'
'
(
( <
% 1
(
(
")B
&
A
'
(
'
>
@
(
'
(
'
2
(
%
''
G1
(
(
G
1
'
@
'
( (
(
'
(
@
(
2
%
&
(
F
M
(
' '
((
''
2
'
'
@
'
2
'
'
%
(
.
''
'
2
H
'
G.
1
(
''
'
@
(
'
''
2
'
#
'
G3
G7
Halaman 50
Pëtr Kropotkin
#
'
@
(
(
>
@
'
''
(
(
4
(
I
I
+
2
(
+
@
@
G
'
'
(
2
'
3
(
1(
(
(
( #
%
.
2
(
(
(
<
(
( (
'
@
(
2
(
@
'
2
% .
#
'
4
'
(
(
%1
,
%
1
#
(
(
2
(
(
'
'
%
/
'
(
'
@#
('
(
2
%1
(
%.
(
#
'
2
%
F
6 (
:
'
'
2
(
'
'
'
(
'
(
'
%
'
%7
$
:2
%
Halaman 51
Pëtr Kropotkin
/
'
(
#
#
'
' % ,
(
'
(
2
$ -7
(
'
'
2
5
6 (
(
'
1
#
1
'
<
'
'
% -.
@
'
(
'
(
(% E
(
'
2
' 4
(
%5
'
2
'
'
.
(
%
%2
%1
%
(
/
,
2
(
2
'(
(
'
(
(
(
(
( 2
G
'
/
@
'
@
2
'
'
'
(
@
/
2
%
/
(
(
(
'(
(
%
Halaman 52
Pëtr Kropotkin
+
'
#
(
( '@
%
(
1
'
'
'
%
.
' (
' MI
(
=.
' (
2
0
'
$
+
:(
%
'
@ '
%/
+
M/
<
'
1
2
(
(
(<
>
R
( @
' (
'
'
(
>
(%
M>
4
(
(
'
' (
'
(
1
G,
>
2
(
'
((
%
.
1
.
+ (
'
6
(
,
%
(
'
(
(
'
'
(
%
0
,
@/ (
'
'
(
(
@
(
%,
0
?9
3
(
(
'
(
'% .
Halaman 53
Pëtr Kropotkin
(
'
(
(
/
(
(M
(
,
(
+
'
' %.
' (
:
(
0
' 0
6 (
'
'
(
'
,
+
2
'
0
+
'
2
(
% 1
+
'
'
@
(
'
(
' % .
2
0
(
(
'
(
'
<
0
(
(
(
% F
'
'
%
.
@
/ (
'
@
=
2
>
'
0
'
0
6
%
' 0
(
((
'
'
+
( '
@
>% 1
@
( (
'
'
0
'
'
(
= '
+
0
'
(
@
@
%
1
'
' '
(
(
(
&
+
%
(
(
4
G.
(
(
+
'
'
(
Halaman 54
Pëtr Kropotkin
4
(
'
2
G@
0
(
'
(
( '
(
(
@
(
$
' (
(
'
(
4
(
(
4
(
(
(
G
'
.
(
(
G
'
(
(
'
(
(
(
% /
' ' (
=
(
(
#
(
4
><
(
'
:(
%/
+
(
'
(
'
'
'
(
'
4
+
'
(
'
0
@
'
%
1
(
( (
' 0
'
(
'
((
(
(
%
1
2
2
'
+
+
'
((
'
+
'
0
2
>
(
(
(
(
(
(
+
(
(
G .
'
4
(
(
@
((
%.
( #
%%%
G
Halaman 55
Pëtr Kropotkin
.
'
0
'
$
<
(
%1
6 (
<
(
%
&
(
'
@
'
(
'
(
(
@
%
'
(
(
'
%1
'
4
6 (
(
(
%
LLL
(
'
( '
% 1'
(
(
% 3'
7
3
3
(
( $
'
'
%&
(
'
((
<
2
%
/ 3'
(
0
'
'
(
%/
((
2
<
%
;
(
2
(
:
1
%/
$
'
2
0
%%%
G
(
%1
'
((
0
%2
0
%&
%/
((
3
(%
((
4
'
3(
Halaman 56
Pëtr Kropotkin
1 +
% .
2
%%%
6 (
'
0
'
0
G
(
'
6 (
2
(
I
6 (
2
0
(
%I
(
% 1
%&
'
%
((
'
3(
3(
%%%
(
2
(
% 2
'
(
'
'
((
( '
%/
'
(
(
'
(
;
ME $
.
2
%%%&
G
@
( '
'
(
(
%%%
'
' '
''
(
%%%
!
G
2
'
.
2
'
'
(
'
%
G
[1]
The reasons which lead me to this hypothesis are put forward in a paper, Dessication of Eur-Asia, compiled
for the Research Department of the Geographical Society of London, and published in its Geographical
Journal for June 1904.
[2]
Readers interested in this subject as well as in that of the communal phases and of the free cities, will find
more detailed information and source references in my book Mutual Aid.
[3]
The time of troubles in Russia at the beginning of the seventeenth century, represent a similar movement,
directed against serfdom and the State but without a religious basis.
[4]
It is already being done in Russia, the government having authorized the pillaging of communal lands under
the law of 1906 and favored this pillage by its own functionaries.
[5]
See Dr. Gilbert Slater ‘The Inclosure of Common Fields’ in the Geographical Journal of the Geographical
Society of London, with plans and maps, January 1907. Later published in volume form.
Pëtr Kropotkin
Halaman 57
Note for the marxists.org Archive edition: When downloaded from Endpage.com
certain passages of the text were found to be corrupted. Attempts were made to
compare this version with those in other archives but all those we found were
similarly corrupted, an indication that all versions stem from the same scanning
process. Most of the errors were obvious but in a few cases it was necessary to
reconstruct the text consulting the French version available at kropot.free.fr —
these phrases are enclosed in square brackets.