Ann'il Sour Easf Asfar

!SSN;,3302-786X
r., :"r
l

a
jJ
i

1i

-d

!. t \,.

t&

THE FOURTH ANNUAL fOUTH E&$T A$IAN
INTERNATIONAL IE]fiHAR (AIAI$.,.;.1
.:,-

2Ol5


*i!,._

jg

'11 1 ,, =

i3

fTATE POLYTECHNIC 0F

IAIffiRTA

*:i,

1

i:lr :l]

' t


't' 't'

Ann'i*l Sour& Easf Asfar

fnfernqflonql Seminsr
'i

w

13

{
-'i

I IilUNTI

€S

I

I t'e..
- i.r "*

ISSN 2302-786X

ASAIS 2015 COMMITTEE
Executive Board
Director of PNJ
Head of P3M PNJ
General Chairs
Iis Mariam
Vice Chairs
Budi Damianto

Managing Commitee
Agus Edi Pamono
Putera Agung Maha Agung
Belyamin
Dianta
Anis Rosyidatr

Nining Latianingsih
Dessy Isralryanti

Nuiul Vellayeti
Dennis W Putro
Ade Sukma Mulya
Gun Gun Ramdlan Gunadi
Sri Danaryani

Publication
Yogi Widiawati
Bayu Pratama Putra
MaharAzhari

Administration Staf
Nurmalisna
Sugianto

Contact Address
Pusat Penelitian dan Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat (p3M)


Gedung Q, Lantai 2,

PoliteknikNegeri Jakarta, Kampus Baru UI Depok,

I 7270036 ext 236,
www.asais-pnj,ore; [email protected]
Tlp. 02

Proceedingrof,;:i{nnual South East,Asian Internatibnal Seminar

(ASAI$ 2015

m

ISSN 2302_786X

TITLES OF'COMMERCE AND HUMANITIES
PAPER
Kode

csH-O1

Titels

ueslgn utrategy and

Researcher

its

Interface with Manufacturing
and Marketing: A Conceptua-i

Page

Ali Masjono

I

Framework

CSH.O2

The Empowerment of peopleis Arkas Viddy, Andi
Syarifuddin,
Priority Economy by Clustering and Zuhriah

Economic Sectors

in

u

East

Kalimantan Province (The Case
of 6 Regencies/Districts in East
Kalimantan)
CSH.O3

The Influence of Underpricing Amt Utamaningsih

IPO Aftermarket

2t

to

Performance:

between Fixed

Comparison

price

Bookbuilding System

on

and


the

Indonesia Stock Exchange

csH-04

Indicator of Financial Distress
Prediction on Banks That Listed
in Indonesia Stock Exchange

CSH-05

The Development of Creativitll Lenny Brida
Innovation and Invention of
Indonesian Higher Education
Students' Technopreneurship in
KMI-EXPO 2015

CSH-06


The

Application

Enhepreneurship
Model Based on

Achievement

in

27

37

of laohammad Maskan, Ahmad

Learning
Learning
Management System to Increasi

Leaming

Objective

Endang Afriyeni, Jumyefti

49

Fauzi, Ludfi Djajanto

politeknil

Negeri Malang
CSH.O7

of The Influence of
Professional Ethics and
Independence on
The
Performance of Auditors
Analysis

Novr Damayanti

57

(Empirical Studies on The
Accountan Public Firms in
Surabaya)
CSH.O8

Development of Indonisian Nur Hasylm, Ade Sukma
Mulya,
Learning Model Based On Sri Wahyono

7t

Stengthening of Rasionality and
Soft Skill for Slow Learner

vi

Proceeding of Arurual south,East Asian International
seminar (ASAIS) 2015

P'

rssN 2302-786X

Kode

Titels

Researcher

Page

Students
CSH.O9

Family Background and Social Primadona,Emrizal
Capital in The Entrepreneurial
Process in Minang Ethnic

CSH-10

The Analysis of Mice (Meeting,

Incentive, Conference

and

Exhibition ) Potency: Case
Study in Padang City West

77

Rini Ekasari, Sarmiadi, Yudhytia
Wimeina

83

Sarmiadi

93

Sri Wahyuni

99

Sumatera Indonesia

CSH-I I

Identification of Special Interest
Tourism in South Solok
Regency West Sumatera

CSH-I2

Employment Growth of Micro,

Small and Middle Business
Sector (UMKM) In Reducing

the Open Unemployment

Rate

in Indonesia

CSH-I3

The Significance of Marketing Sylvia Rozza
Business Award on Corporate

Reputation

111

and

Marketing
Brand Holder

Performance of
Company in Indonesia

CSH.I4

Islamic Work Ethics is Needed

for

Developing

Core

Competence of The Firm An
Attempt to Integrate Work Ethic
Strategic Human
Resources Management

Willson Gustiawan, Shang-Ping
Lin

t27

With

csH-I5

Analyze of Economic Sectors Yosi Suryani, Rudy Rinaldy
Priority in Port Area of Bungus

141

Padang

CSH.16

Analyze of Economic Sectors
Priority in Port Area of Bungus

Yosi Suryani, Rudy Rinaldy

153

Zaenal Abidin Eko Putro, Nurul

r59

The Study of Soft Skills to Titi Suhartati, Yenni Nuraeni,
Develop Learning Model of Nedsal Sixpria

169

Padang

CSH-I7

Reaffirming

Cultural

Understanding: The pNJ Intan Pratiwi
Partnership with Kaimana
District of West Papua

csH-l8

Soft Skills That Integrated With
Accounting Subjects

Proceeding ofAnnual South East Asian Internafinncl Scrninor

/Asars\ ?nl<

rrii

ISSN 2302-756X

Researcher

Implemenffi

csH-19

Principle

of Know your

IdaNurhayatilndianikA;inah-

Employee as Fraud prevention
Measures
on Indonesia Banking

rooi%

The Use of nigitat
to Learn' in Indonesian EFL
Classroom: Working With

Yogi Widiawati

Essays

The Language U"tt ,ndTE Ninggarwati,
Ina S;ka";h
Development of Theme nfr"r"
in The Feature Articles in

CSH.21

English and in Bahasa Indonesia

Roleofrrre@
and National Zakat Agency in
Efforts to Alleviat. fo""rty io

Darna, na"hmt

l6htiliU

Indonesia

Analysis of

CSH-23

perfonnance

reur@

Measurement System Using *F":.
Wardhana, Rika novyanti
Competency-Based Balancei

(A Study i,

Scorecard

Banjarmasin State polytechnics)

Destination

-

ffiiopn

Strategy Based

Competence of Mice
Characteri sti c s,

on

ent
Core

E epE;;a
of Female

Preference

EttyKongratffi
Fatimah and aminatr

Consumers Towards UKM

Fashion Products

Opportunity

!_*d*g
The

-Gi-

unA
of Tuty Herawati anaEtly
Fashion SMEs Facing

dngrat

Era of Asean Economil
Community (AEC)
CSH-27

Research

Triple

U.tix

Con@t

-i, tistvtariam@

Coflaboration
Between Industry, Government
Tq Polytechnic Through
Collaborative
Knowledie
Creation Approach

_

_ profile
uemograpic

of

E-

Commerce Customers in Jakarta

viii

Eva ZulfaNailufar"

I.B'H*@

Rodiana Listiawati

Proceeding of Annual South East Asian lnternational
Seminar (ASAIS) 20
I5

ISSN 2302-786X

Kode

CSH.29

Titels

Researcher

Comparing The Effectiveness of Rene Muhammad, Tshin Lip
Writing Assessment and

Page

Vui

26t

Scientific Articles Science and Hapsa lJsman, Alfred Tandirura,
Technology
for Ramzy G.G.L. Sayonira

28s

Practical Effectiveness for
Hearing Impaired Students
CSH-30

Entrepreneurship (bK)
Polytechnic Kupang

At State

Proceeding of Annual South East Asian Intemational Seminar (ASAIS) 2015

ISSN 2302-786X

Analyze of Economic Sectors Priority in Port Area of Bungus
Padang
Yosi Suryanir, Rudy Rinaldy2
tBusiness Administration, Polytechnic State of Padang

Komplek Griya Elok Blok Gl/18 Arai Pinang, Lubuk Begalung Padang

e-maili@

2Economic Faculty, Andalas University and Department of Transportation Padang
Mata Air Street Padang

Absffacl
Tb implement dewlopment with limited resources as a consequence have to be focused on the
development of somi sectors that have an effect multiplier signiJicantly to other sectors or the
economy as a whole. This article describes the area of Port Bungus Padang, not only as a pioneer
tro^pirt locations, but can also be developed on priority economic sectors in accordance with the
character of the areo and the region, so as to support the main sectors, namely transport in Port
area of Buigus. The goal of article writing is to determine the priority sectors of the economy that
can bZ deviloped in-the Port Area of Bungus. The analysis used is quantitative metho.d of AHP
(Analytical Hiemrchy Process). The results illustrate that the sector of the economy that can be
developed in this area on a priority basis is the transport and communications sector,
services, trade, services and restaurants, electricity, gas and water supply,
^orrrp"t*ing,
consiructionind agriculture, liyestock lhith these results we can conclude that in addition to the
development ofthe Port Area of Bungus ofthefreight transport pioneer, there are some sectors ofthe
economy that can be developed as a source ofrevenuefor Padang City-

Key Words: Econpmic sector AHE Port Bungus

1. INTRODUCTION

'Development of a region is defined as
the efforts made to create growth in a
equitable
region characterized
development in all sectors and in all
parts of the region. Economic growth
can not occur simultaneously in all
places and all sectors of the economy,

by

but only at certain Points and in
certain sectors as well. Prioritized
investments in key sectors that can
increase revenue potential and the
region in a relatively short period of
time. An area that has the potential to
grow bigger will grow more raPidlY,

then the area will stimulate the

of

surrounding areas.
For those sectors that have the
potential to grow bigger tends to
development

develop early and later bY the

i
ir

t*i
il

,l:

f,

il
[i!

f"

fl
d.

!i

f,
R

development of other sectors with less
potential.

Economic development of a region to
build an economic aclivity that is able
to grow rapidlY and has a high

exposure to other sectors so as to
form forward and backward linkarge.
The rapid growth of the sector will
encourage the polarization potential
of other economic units, which inturn

indirectly other sectors

of

the

economy experiehced growth.

Under these conditions, the Port Area
of Bungus Padang has economic
potential that can be developed and
have the opportunity to serve as . a
sector that can provide opporfunities
for other sectors to flourish. The
purpose of this study was to analyze
the priority economic sectors that
could be developed in the Port area
Bungus Padang. While the
contribution of the research is the

development of science to the
economics of the sectors that provide
opportunities to be developed on an

af,ea as well as well as
recommendations for the Padang
Local Government on economic

proceeding ofAnnual South EastAsian International Seminar (ASAIS)

2015 153

ISSN 2302-786X

sectors that can provide local revenue
source for the city of Padang.

change, (d)

2. TIIEORY

modemity

2.1

DEVELOPMENT

AND

REGIONAL EXPAI\SION
Development is based on a regional
approach is intended as a Planning
and development activities associated
between one region to the other so

that the direction

of

develoPment
across the country in a region that
needs the higher reservoir. There
should be inter-regional cooperation
in carrying out development activities
the area, basically have the
social
potential economic

in

and

characteristics are almost the same
even mutually reinforcing. This
cooperation is intended for regional

development

can be

oPtimized
on
of
synergies
through the creation
the use of the economic potential that
exists. For the current development in
the region based on nafural resources

and human resources in the area.
Utilizatiort of both these potentials
that need cooperation so as to create

an outcome or a greater benefit when
compared to working alone (Miraza,
2oos).

According

to Tarigan (2005), the

potential of the region in the form of
gifts of nature and man's work in the
past are assets that should be used for
the greatest prosperity of the people in
the long term and lasting. To achieve
this, the utilization of the asset must

be

thoroughly planned carefullY.
There needs to be plaruring to give
overall direction of land use that as a
guide for other'planning (sectoral) are
partial. There are some ideas very
important point, namely: (a) that the

development is an ongoing Process
canied out in order to imProve the
welfare of the community, (b) that the
development is an important endeavor
undertaken, (c) that the development
implemented plans to growth and

lS4

that lead to

the

development of modernity, (e) that

is achieved through the
development covers all aspects of
society, the nation and

the

state,

of political,
economic, social, culfural, defense

including aspects

and security and administration.

Widodo (1999) asserted that the
purpose of development of the region
the
achieved
only
the
activities
concerning
components
regional
utilization
planning,
social
resources, spatial
change and economic growth, active,
dynamic growth and development.
measured using
benchmarks as follows: (a) the growth
Gross Domestic Product, (b)
income per capita and income
distribution, (c) poverty level, (d)
public service
consumption

will'

if

be

of

or the

This can be

of

of

facilities, and (e) the quality

of q"

environment. To assess the success of
the division of a country's economy is
based on four criteria, namely: (a) the
labor, (b) poverty
utilization
reduction, (c) policy for distribution
of income, and (d) an increase in
labor productivity.

of

2.2 ECONOMIC GROWTIIAREAS
Economic growth in the region is
people's income overall increase
occurring in the region, which is the

entire value added that

occurs

(Sjafrizal, 2009). Revenues region
illustrates the remuneration for the
factors of production are operating in
the area, which roughly describe the
prosperity of the area. The same
sources say that economic growth is
the increase in output per capita
preformance long term. That growth
must be sourced from the intemal
processes of the economy.

This provision is of particular interest
in the economic tenitory, because it
could be an area of growth, but the
growth was created because of the

Proceeding of Annual South East Asian International Seminar (ASAIS) 2015

ISSN 2302-786X

many aid / injection of funds from the
central government and the growth
was halted when the cash injection is
stopped. Thus, to support the growth
of a necessary consequence of the
high region between communities as
the economy by the
actors
government as a policy stakeholders
in development.

district is 6,274 inhabitants. While

3.

According

in

METHODOLOGY
The research was conducted at the
Port Area of Bungus with an area of

2.2ha. The location lies in the area of
the Dishict Bungus sackcloth Padang.
This study is a combination of the use
of secondary data and primary data.
The use of secondary data is more
focused on statistical data from the
Central Bureau of Statistics and
Bappeda Padang. While the primary

data derived from interviews are
structured in the form of a
questionnaire to the public (which
consists of ' the general public,

stakeholders and community leaders)
ire located on the object of research
with economic potential, namely trade
and services and industry (large
. industry, medium and small), hotels
and restaurants, tourism, fisheries,
and so on. The assumption of the
sector as a labor-intensive process of
developing local resources and
economic
optimization
potential of the region. Observations
or observation conducted to obtain
preliminary data that can support the
study, so the complete informatipn to
deliver answers to the Problems of
research can be obtained.

of the

Total population

in this studY is

derived from the number of residents
in the sackcloth of District. Bungus
Bay object of studY chosen Place.
Based on data from the District In
Figures sackcloth of Dishict Bungus
Bay of tho Year 2013, the location of

Bungus

ate at

KelurahanWest

Bungus. The total population in this

sampling study conducted by random
sampling on the people residing in the
area around the object. Sampling is

determined by quotas which are
considered to represent the answer to
each question in the form of a
questionnaire that witl be given to the
respondent.

Theorem

to the Central Limit
in Cooper and Schinder

(2006), said that in order to determine
the sample size, the sampling

distribution

will be normal if

sufficient number

of

samples. The
number of samples in question is a
minimum of 30 (n : 30), where the
greater number of samples, sampling
food distribution approaches a normal
distribution. In other words, if the
population is not normally distributed,
the mean of samples would be normal
if the sample size is greater than or
equal to 30 (n 2 30). Thus, the
number of samples in this study were
30 respondents.

To answer the research objectives of
the priority sectors of the economy
that can be developed in Bungus Port
area of Padang, the analysis method
Analytical Hierarchy Process. This
method is used to test the hypothesis
priority economic potential by sector
are assumed to be able to thrive in the
Port area ofBungus Padang based on
an initial survey that has been done.

The steps

in the method of AHP
(l) Define the problem

analysis are:

and specifr the desired problemsolving, (2) Creating a hierarchical
structure and overall management
perspective, (3) Prepare comparative

matrix pairs. This matrix starts from
the top, (4) Consistency Logical, (5)
Formula Mathematically, (6) Perform
the synthesis of a priority to do the
weighting vectors priority, (7)
Processing matrix opinion consists of

two ,stages, namely processing

Proceeding of Annual South East Asian International Seminar (ASAIS)

2015 155

ISSN 2302-786X

horizontal and vertical, and (8)
Evaluate inconsistency for the entire
hierarchy.

4.

ANALYSIS

Determine of Benefits economic
sector priority, which is able to
provide an indication of the national
and regional economy. Economic
sector priority certainly have a greater
potential for more rapid.growth than
other sectors of the region, especially
their role in contributing factor to
these priority economic sectors,
namely the accumulation of capital,
the growth of labor absorPtion and
technological advances. The creation
of investment opporfunities can also

be done by empowering Potential

leading sectors are owned bY their

respective regions.

From the initial survey has been
conducted and the results of
observation of the region, the
economic potenti'al that can be
recommended to thrive is Trade,
hotels and restaurants, manufacturing
industry (Sub Sector Non Oil),
Transportation and Communications
(Sub sectors of Transportation) in this
case is transport River Lake
Crossing), Sector Offices (Included in

Sub Private Sector),

Entertainment Services

the
and

Recreation) or Tourism, Agriculture,
Livestock, Forestry and Fisheries, in

this case Sub Fisheries Sector,

Electricity Sector, Gas and Water, in
this case Sub Sector Electricity and
Water, and Construction Sector.

The emergence on the economic
sectors of potential that can be
developed in the area of the Port
Crossing Gulf Bungus Padang city is

based

on

several indicators of

(l)

Of Project
assessment, namelY:
absorbed
be
can
that
labor
of
(amount
and reduce unemPloYment, (2)
Competitiveness (Output produced
the same qualitY with the outPut

sector of the economy but at a low
cost, rate of economic growth in each
sector, the productivity level of each

sector), (3) technologY (tYPe of
technology used, the level of
effrciency that can be generated), (4)
Investnnent Opportunities (Power drag
each business sector,. investment
local
oppor-tunities

from the

community, opportunities of
from outside- investors
(domestic and foreign), (5)
Availability of Land (area of vacant

investment

land,, use

of existing land, intensity of

building), (6) Physical

land
(topography of the land, the type and
the soil), (7)
characteristics
accessibility (distance location to
arterial roads, Total access to sites,
Barriers to the location).

of

The process of the

AnalYtical
provides
a
(AHP)
Hierarchy Process
framework that makes it possible to
make an effective decision or
complex issues by simplifuing and
accelerating the decision support
process, which in this case the
decision of the selection of priority
sectors of the economy that can be
developed in the Port area of the Gulf
Crossing Bungus Padang. Based on
the analysis by using AHR then in
Table I can be seen in detail the
priority sectors of the economy that
can be developed in the area of the
Port Bungus Padang.
Tabel

l. Economic

Sector Priority in Port

Area of Bungus Padang
nicoriogipi$"E ffiI'iil

Transport

&

354,72

sector

352,78

Communications

Manufacturing

(non-oil sub-sector)

Services (entertainment,
recreation and Tourism)

326,78

Trade, services

and

317,61

and

256,68

restawants

Electricity,

gas

water suoolv
Construction Sector

Asriculture.

Animal

24s.00
187.75
t;

;;

156

proceeding of Annual South EastAsian Intemational Seminar (ASAIS) 2015

:

l
3
.E

ISSN 2302-786X

around the region and for investors
who are interested to invest in this
Transport and communications sector
is an economic sector that is most
likely to be developed in Port Area of
Bungus, with a total value of 354.72.
This is because the transport and
communications sector in particular
sub-sector is the main sector that has
been running until the present time

and have good prospects for
development for the people and
of

Padang. This sector
can be a higger for the growth of
other sectors in the region, such as the
Manufacturing sector, which is an
economic sector that has the total
value of which is under the Transport
and Communications sector. This is
because the raw materials processing
industry can be found around the port
area and in an easy way as well as the
facilities already available in advance
to obtain the raw material.
government

While'the services sector, in this case
of tourism, is a prospect that has

economic potential that can be
developed after the Processing

Industry sector (Fish). Tourism, which
includes entertainment and recreation
being targeted economic potential that
can be developed in the Port area of
Bungus, because in principle there is
a major supporting factor that can be
sold, such as the view of the sea and
the beach is clean. This situation is a

factor that can attract local and
foreign investors (domestic' and
foreign) to invest in this sector in

order to provide a significant impact
to the surrounding community and the
government of Padang.

Likewise, trade, services and
restaurants. This sector has good

prospects to be developed because of
trade, services and restaurants can
provide
Positive imPact on

a

improving the welfare

of

sector. With these imPacts will
indirectly benefit the City
Government

of Padang to obtain

of revenue through fees paid
from activities in the sectors of trade,

sources

services and the restaurant. While the
three sectors that have a value of the
bottom three is an economic sector
that can be considered more to be
developed because it takes a long time
and have a big enough challenge to be
developed in Port Area of Bungus
Padang, such as accessibility, physical
condition of the land is less support
and social impact can be caused by
the development of the sector.

5.

CONCLUSION

Based on the analysis that has been
done, it can be concluded that the
priority economic sectors in an area
can be obtained by using AHP. The
economic sector priorities are
obtained using such methods and
generating the highest total value in
the Port area of Bugus in order are:
transport
communications,
manufacturing industry (sub-sectors
of the non-oil), Offices (Leisure,
Recreation and. Tourism, Trade,
Services and Restaurant, Sector

and

Electricity, Gas and

'Vy'ater,

Construction Sector and Agriculture,

Animal Husbandry (Sub

Sector

Fisheries).

Recommendations can be given are:
the ttree sectors that have a score

is the smallest sector of
electricity, gas and water supply,

value

construction and agriculfure, livestock
(fisheries sub-sector), because each
sector is considered as not meeting
criteria based on selected indicators.
However, these sectors are likely to
be developed for the future (longterm), but not a top priority for the
short term.

PeoPIe

Proceeding of Annual South East Asian Intemational Seminar (ASAIS)

2015

157

;1

ISSN 2302-756X

j

!i,1
II
"J
1

I

6.

BIBLIOGRAPIIY

tu Adisasmita, R
Pengambangan Wilayah

:

(2009)
Konsep

t7l Saaty, TL (2003) Decision Making
Wittt The AHP: Why is The
Principle Eigenvector Necessary.
European Joumal of Operational

dan Teori. Yogyakarta: Graha llmu.

Kota Padang (2013)
Padang Dalam Angka. niro'purui
Statistik.
Cooper,
D and Scinder p (2006)
t3l
Business Research Method, 9 th
Edition. McGraw-Hill International
Edition.
Kuncoro,
Mudrajad (2004) Otonomi
14)
Daerah dan Pembangunan Daerah :
Reformasi, Perencanaan, Strategi
dan Peluang. Jakarta. Erlangga
121

Bappeda

t5] Mangun, Nadiatulhuda e007)

Analisis Potensi Ekonomi
Kabupaten dan Kota di provinsi

Sulawesi Tengah. Tesis. Universitas
Diponegoro. Semarang.

Research.

t8l

:

Program Magister Teknik Sipil
Universitas Udayana.

Teori dan Aplikasi.
Baduose Media

praktis

Penyusunan Rencana pembangunan

Daerah. Padang : Baduose Media

[0] Tdrigan, Robinson

Perencanaan

(2005)

pembangunan

Wilayah. Jakarta : Bumi Aksara

I l] Widodo, Tri (1999) perencanaan
[2]

[3]

Pembangunan : Aplikasi Komputer.
Yogyakarta : UPp STIM yKpN

Taslicali and Ercan (2006) The

Analitical Hierarchy & The Analytic
Network Procsses in Multicriteria
Decision Making: A Comarative
Study. Journal of Aeronantics and
Space Technologi es Z(4), 55-65
Tuban, E and Aronson, J.E (2005)

Decision Support Systems and
Intelligent Systems. 5 th Edition,'
Canada : Prentice Hall International,
Inc.

158

:

padang:

t9l Sjafrizal (2009) Teknik

16] Putri, I Dewa Ayu Ngurah Alit
(2011) Penentuan Skala prioritas
Penanganan Jalan Kabupaten di
Kabupaten Bangli. Tesis. Denpasar

Sjafrizal (2008) Ekonomi Regionat

Proceeding ofAnnual South EastAsian International Seminar (ASAIS)
20 I 5

il

a

a-f

*

2 Jr5-.
^,

'"

\\

*

\\ !li
'"'
-*1--*''
!-{ t
t
'=_
*
--*-

t
qr

a

,.. *"e"

u*tif*o

't''
F

4;

No.3217IPL3/D 1t2015

tot
I

Annual South EastAsian

Intemtotiottal
Semittar x#xs
fiiv*n t*

:

YOSI SURYANI
As:

PRESENTER
Ther:n*

:

*DeveRop*Nxg

amd trnxewvating the Seiemee &ased clt
Teehsxw5lrcmeur for C*mpetitiqe H.esearehes
amd Sepe**&y Serviee"

t *,

:=.

12th,2O1S
Floor

State Polytechnic of Jakarta, Novem ber

Directorate Building,3td

Head

ofthe

-ri"

'ti ,, ,'.-^
Center ia*

Research and'

a

,,',,,Abdillati;5.E., M.si
NlP. 1 9s903091 9891 01 001

Dr.

Drs.A.I
NIP.I

Alamsyah. ST, MT
1986031001

o*

LEMBAR
HASIL PEMLAIAII SEJAWAT SEBIDANG ATAU PEERREWEV

KARYA ILMIATI Z PROSIDING',

Aralyze of Economic Sectors Priority in Port Area of Bungus

Judul Makalah

Padang

Jumlah Penulis

2orung

Status Pengusul

penulis

Identitas Makalah

a. Judul Prosiding

pertama/

si
Proceedings

**

of The Fourth Annual

South East Asian Intemational Seminar
(ASATS) 201s
b. ISSN
c. Tahun Terbit
d. Tempat Pelaksanaan
e. Penerbit

2302-786X
2015

Politeknik Negeri Jakarta
Politeknik Negeri Jakarta
f. Alamat Repository/web prosiding : repo.polinpdg .ac.idl563 I

Kategori Publikasi Makalah
(beri E padakategori yang tePat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Reviant

fl f rosidrngForum Ilmiah lntemasional
I Prosiding Forum IlmiahNasional

:

Nilai Maksim al Prosiding
Komponen Yang Dinilai

a.
b.

Kelenskapan unsur isi paper (10%)
Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan
B0o/o\

c. f"Cutupan

dan kemutahiran data/informasi dan

metodolosi (30%)

d. Kelengkapan

unsur dan kualitas
terbitan/prosidine G A%\

Total :

Internasional

M

x

tol

ft' y

)ol

y't

tl

Nasional

foxx/
ir Y )rl

(I|diD"/"\

Nilai Akhir
Yang
Diperoleh

7

ztr
lh
I

zfrr
7o

Catatan Peni}aian paper oleh Reviewer

{-*< $rJ. ,hru-a,/yy' u"4*( @

flfr* ln41-h'|r4Ll**'ru

Padang, ...

NIP. 19461 I 1171973031001
Unit Kerja: Fakultas Ekonomi Universitas Andalas
* dinilai oleh dua Reviewer secara terpisah

**

coret yang tidak perlu

LEMBAR
HASIL PEI\IILAIAN SEJAWAT SEBIDA}IG ATAU PEER REWEW
KARYA ILMIAH I PROSIDING*
Analyzn of Economic Sectors Priority in Port Area

Judul Makalah

of

Bungus

Padang

Jumlah Penulis

2 orang

Status Pengusul

penulis

Identitas Makalah

a. Judul Prosiding

pertama/

i
Proceedings

t*

of The Fourth Annual

South East Asian International Seminar
(ASATS) 2015
b. ISSN
c. Tahun Terbit
d. Tempat Pelaksanaan
e. Penerbit

2302-786X
2015
Politeknik Negeri Jakarta
Politeknik Negeri Jakarta
f. Alamat Repository/web prosiding : repo.polinpdg .ac.idl563 I

Kategori Publikasi Makalah
(beri F.pada kategori yang tepat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Review

S
n

fros AngForum Ilmiah Internasional
ProsidingEorum llmiahNasional

:

Nilai Maksim
Komponen Yang Dinilai

a.
b.

Kelenskaoan unsur isi oaper (10%)
Ruang lingkup dan kedalaman pembahasan

c.

Kecukupan dan kemutahiran datalinformasi dan

B0%l
metodolosi (30olo)

d.

Kelengkapan unsur dan kualitas

terbitan/orosidins

Total :

(lMla/"\

I

0o/o)

Catatan Penilaian ppper oleh

W

g

Internasional

9b

Prosiding

tI

Nasional

l5l,

Yang
Diperoleh
1

Qtxef,

v)

8o X 307

?+

qs

EA

Y

$f,

Reviewer

n

W*lrl^^ Sirra^f 6r*.ru1*r4 -)ar^ h6%
h4rkh fauottho-sttt6a+

Dr. Primadona. S.E. M.Si
NIP. 19750107 200312 2 002
Unit Kerja: Jurusan Adm. Niaga Politeknik Negeri Padang
* dinilai oleh dua Reviewer secara terpisah
coret yang tidak perlu

NilaiAkhir

UO

tl;^y\Mf%f""

**

Y

il

W^t
?rz16

tcartcvt*rc

slv^'r b

LEMBARREKAPITULASI

REWEW
HASIL PENILAIAN DUA SEJAWAT SEBIDAI\IG ATAU DUAPEER
KARYA ILMIAH 2 PROSIDING*

Analyze of Economic Sectors Priority in Port Area of Bungus

Judul Makalah

Padang

Jumlah Penulis

2 orang

Status Pengusul

penulis pertama/penr*is*e4lpenulis{oacspoadenei

Identitas Makalah

a. Judul Prosiding

Proceedings

*

*

of The Fourth Annual

South East Asian lnternational Seminar
(ASAIS) 2015

b. ISSN

2302-786){

c. Tahtrn Terbit
d. Tempat Pelaksanaan
e. Penerbit

Politeknik Negeri Jakarta
Politeknik Negeri Jakarta

2015

f.AlamatRepository/webprosiding:repo'polinpdg'ac'idl563l
Kategori Publikasi Makalah
@eri F.pada kategori Yang tePat)
Hasil Penilaian Peer Review

R

""g

rE
)

ProsidingForum llmiah Internasional

Prosid@Forum IlmiahNasional

:

nnsur isi oaper (l0Yo
f*gt"rp dan kedalaman pembahasan

@iran
A fercngkapan

datalinformasi dan
unsur dan kualitas

Catata" Penilaian paper oleh Reviewer

Review$2

il,J,

NIP.

19461 1 I 17197303 1001
JabatanFungsional : Guru Besar/Profesor
Unit Kerja: Fakultas Ekonomi
Universitas Andalas

Dr. Pririradona. S.E. M.Si
NIP. 19750 107 200312 2 002
Jabatan Fungsional : Lektor KePala

Unit Kerja: Jur Adm. Niaga
Politeknik Negeri Padang