Performance Analysis Of Wireless Optical Broadband Access Network (WOBAN).

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF WIRELESS OPTICAL BROADBAND
ACCESS NETWORK (WOBAN)

NOR SYAZWANI BT MOHD SAID

UNIVERSITI TEKNIKAL MALAYSIA MELAKA

i

PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF WIRELESS OPTICAL BROADBAND
ACCESS NETWORK (WOBAN)

NOR SYAZWANI BT MOHD SAID

This Report Is Submitted In Partial Fulfilment Of Requirement For The Bachelor
Degree of Electronic Engineering (Wireless Communication) With Honours

Fakulti Kejuruteraan Elektronik dan Kejuruteraan Komputer
Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka

June 2012


ii

iii

iv

v

To my beloved mother, Rohaizah bt Hj Mohd Kassim, my siblings,
and all my lovely friends

vi

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

First of all, my undivided gratitude to Allah S.W.T that has given me blessing
and strength to complete this project entitled “Performance Analysis of Wireless Optical
Broadband Access Network” successfully. The writing of this thesis is one of the most
significant academic challenges that I have ever face. I would like to thank my

supervisor, Pn Nurmala Irdawaty Hassan for giving me support and motivation during
completing this thesis. I am also thankful to my friend and my classmate for their
encouragement and advices. Finally, I thank my parents for supporting me throughout
all my studies in Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka.

vii

ABSTRACT

This paper presents the study of performance analysis of wireless optical
broadband access network. The length of the optical fiber will give an effect to the
performance of WOBAN and hence, the investigation of the optimum length is done.
WOBAN is the most effective access network because it provide high bandwidth and
good scalability with cost effectives. Optiwave Optisystem software tool is used to
accomplish the design and performance analysis of WOBAN. The performance analysis
is analysed in terms of Power Received, Q factor, Eye Diagram and eye height, and Bit
Error Rate (BER).

viii


ABSTRAK

Kertas kerja ini membentangkan kajian analysis mengenai prestasi rangkaian
wayales jalur lebar optik (WOBAN). Panjang gentian optik akan divariasikan untuk
melihat kesan kepada prestasi rangkaian wayales jalur lebar optic (WOBAN) dan oleh itu
penyisasatan optimum akan dilakukan terhadap system WOBAN. WOBAN adalah
rangkaian akses yang paling berteknologi kerana ia menyediakan jalur lebar yang tinggi,
skala yang tinggi dan kos yang berkesan. Perisian Optiwave Optisystem akan digunakan
untuk mereka litar WOBAN dan menganalisis prestasi WOBAN. WOBAN akan dianalisis
dalam bentuk Power Received, Q factor, Eye Diagram dan eye height, dan Bit Error
Rate (BER).

ix

TABLE OF CONTENTS

CHAPTER

I


TITLE

PAGES

PROJECT TITLE

i

STATUS REPORT FORM

ii

STUDENT DECLARATION

iii

SUPERVISOR DECLARATION

iv


DEDICATION

v

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

vi

ABSTRACT

vii

ABSTRAK

viii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ix


LIST OF TABLES

xiii

LIST OF FIGURES

xiv

LIST OF ACRONYMS

xvi

LIST OF APPENDICES

xviii

INTRODUCTION

1


1.1

2

Objectives

x

II

1.2

Problem Statement

3

1.3

Scope of Work


3

1.4

Thesis Outline

4

LITERATURE REVIEW

6

2.1

Optical Access Network Overview

6

2.2


Wireless Access Network Overview

10

2.3

Wireless Optical Broadband Access Network

11

2.4

WOBAN Architecture

12

2.5

Compelling Solution


14

2.6

Optical Fiber

15

2.6.1

Single Mode Optical Fiber

17

2.6.2

Multi Mode Optical Fiber

18


2.6.3

Comparison between Single Mode and

19

Multimode Optical Fiber
2.6.4

2.7

2.8

Fiber Dispersion

19

2.6.4.1

Modal dispersion

21

2.6.4.1

Chromatic dispersion

22

Performance Parameter

23

2.7.1

Eye Diagram

23

2.7.2

Bit Error Rate

25

2.7.3

Power Spectrum

26

2.7.4

Q Factor

26

2.7.5

Signal Noise Ratio

27

Advantages of Optical Fiber over Copper Wire

27

xi

III

1V

METHODOLOGY

30

3.1

Flowcharts of the project

31

3.2

Flowcharts of simulation circuit

32

3.3

K Map of Project

33

3.4

Proposed Block Diagram of WOBAN

34

3.5

Expected Result

35

3.6

Simulation Process

36

3.6.1

Starting Optisystem

36

3.6.2

Setting and Changing the Bit Rates

37

3.6.3

Adding the Component

38

3.6.4

Connecting Component

38

3.6.5

Setting Component Parameter

39

3.6.6

Setting the Parameter Sweep

42

3.6.7

Running the Simulation

46

3.6.8

Viewing the Results

47

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

48

4.1

Power Received Results

50

4.2

Q-factor Results

52

4.3

Bit Error Rate (BER) Performance

53

4.4

Eye Diagram and Eye Height Results

54

4.5

RF Spectrum Analyzer

56

4.6

Best Combination Results

57

xii

V

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION

58

5.1

Conclusion

58

5.2

Recommendation

59

REFERENCES

61

APPENDIX A

64

APPENDIX B

65

xiii

LIST OF TABLES

NO

TITLE
PAGE

2.1

The Advantages of WOBAN

14

2.2

Comparison between Single Mode and Multimode

19

2.3

Advantages of Optical Fiber

27

3.1

Typical Parameters of WOBAN

35

3.2

Starting Optisystem

36

3.3

Setting and Changing the Bit Rates

37

3.4

Adding the Component

38

3.5

Connecting Component

38

3.6

Setting Component Parameter

39

3.7

Setting Component Parameter

42

3.8

Running the Simulation

46

3.9

Viewing the Results

47

4.1

Power received results

50

4.2

Q-factor results

52

4.3

BER results

53

4.4

Eye Diagram and Eye Height results

54

4.5

Best Combination Results

57

xiv

LIST OF FIGURES

NO

TITLE

PAGE

2.1

Basic diagram of Passive Optical Network (PON)

8

2.2

The simple WDM PON architecture

8

2.3

Evolution of optical access network

9

2.4

WOBANs upstream and downstream protocols

13

2.5

WOBAN Architecture

13

2.6

Basic structure of optical fiber

16

2.7

Basic fiber optic communication system

16

2.8

Single Mode optical fiber

17

2.9

Multi Mode Optical fiber

18

2.10

Broaden Pulse

19

2.11

Intersymbol Interference

20

2.12

Output signal with dispersion

20

2.13

Mode propagation in multimode optical fiber

22

2.14

Mode propagation with material and waveguide dispersion

23

2.15

The Formation of eye diagram

24

2.16

Basic information contain in eye diagram

25

3.1

Methodology flowchart

31

3.2

Simulation flowchart

32

3.3

WOBAN system by using K chart

33

xv

3.4

Block diagram of Wireless Optical Broadband Access Network

34

3.5

Optisystem Graphical User Interface

36

3.6

Layout parameter dialog box

37

3.7

Connecting components symbol

38

3.8

Connecting ports

38

3.9

Connecting Component

38

3.10

WDM Transmitter properties dialog box

39

3.11

Bidirectional Optical Fiber dialog box

40

3.12

1xN Splitter Bidirectional dialog box

40

3.13

WOBAN Simulation Circuit

41

3.14

Bidirectional Optical Fiber dialog box

43

3.15

Set total sweep iteration

43

3.16

Total parameter sweep iteration dialog box

44

3.17

Set total parameter sweeps

44

3.18

Parameter sweep dialog box

44

3.19

Parameter sweep dialog box 2

45

3.20

Parameter iteration spread dialog box

45

3.21

Parameter sweeps dialog box 3

45

3.22

Calculation dialog box 1

46

3.23

Calculation dialog box 2

46

3.24

BER Analyzer Monitor

47

4.1

Transmitted Optical Spectrum

51

4.2

RF Spectrum at ONU 1

56

4.3

Optical Spectrum at ONU 1

56

xvi

LIST OF ACRONYMS

3G

-

Third-generation

AWG

-

Array Wave Guide

BER

-

Bit Error Rate

BS

-

Base Station

BPON

-

Broadband Passive Optical Network

CO

-

Central Office

DAM

-

Dual Arm Modulator

DFB

-

Distributed Feedback Laser

EPON

-

Ethernet Passive Optical Network

FTTH

-

Fiber To The Home

FTTC

-

Fiber To The Curb

FTTB

-

Fiber To The Building

Gbps

-

Gigabits per Second

GFP-PON

-

Generic Framing Procedure Passive Optical Network

GPON

-

Gigabit Passive Optical Network

HSPA

-

High Speed Packet Access

IEEE

-

Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineering

ISI

-

Intersymbol Interference

LED

-

Light Emitting Diode

LOS

-

Line of Sight

MAN

-

Metropolitan Area Network

Mbps

-

Megabits per Second

xvii

MMF

-

Multi Mode Fiber

NLOS

-

Non Line of Sight

NRZ

-

Non Return to Zero

OFDM

-

Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing

OLT

-

Optical Line Terminal

ONU

-

Optical Network Unit

IL

-

Optical Interleaver

Ps

-

picosecond

PS/C

-

Passive splitters / combiner

PON

-

Passive Optical Network

RZ

-

Return Zero

RF

-

Radio Frequency

RN

-

Remote Node

SMF

-

Single Mode Fiber

SNR

-

Signal to Noise Ratio

TDM PON

-

Time Division Multiplexing Passive Optical Network

WDM PON

-

Wavelength Division Multiplexing Passive Optical Network

WiFi

-

Wireless Fidelity

WiMAX

-

Wordwide Interoperability for Microwave Access

WMN

-

Wireless Mesh Network

WOBAN

-

Wireless Optical Broadband Access Network

xviii

LIST OF APPENDICES

NO

TITLE

PAGE

A

Gantt Chart and Milestone (∆)

64

B

Component Library

65

1

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

The emerging demand for multimedia communication such as voice, data
pictures, video services and internet streaming require for the realization of broadband
distribution system. During the past decade, the use of optical fiber as a transmission
line experience an enormous growth due to the wide bandwidth it can provide. Wireless
Optical Broadband Access Network, (WOBAN) is one of the broadband access
networks that use optical fiber as a transmission line from the optical backhaul to the
wireless mesh network. The basic purpose of WOBAN is to eliminate wired dropped at
every wireless router at end user and the used of fiber optic which give an advantages
because it does not need to penetrate to the end user. Moreover, the architecture of
WOBAN is a combining of wireless and optical where at the back end is a wired optical
network and at the front end is manage by wireless connectivity.

At the back end of the network, optical line terminal (OLT) resides in the central
office (CO) and is connected via optical fiber to multiple optical network units (ONU)

2

[1]. Remote node (RN) will distributed data to the ONU via optical links. At the front
end, a set of wireless nodes (routers) forms a wireless mesh network (WMN) [1]. End
users are connected to the network through these nodes where the locations are fixed in a
wireless mesh network (WMN). A number of selected routers are connected to the ONU
which is also mean connected to the optical backhaul. End users send packets to a
nearby wireless node and travel through the wireless mesh and reach the OLT via the
gateways.

Before WOBAN is developed, the recent trends of the optical access network are
a Passive Optical Network (PON). PON is a point to multipoint optical network. In this
configuration, it used a different wavelength of channel for upstream and downstream
from the central office (Optical Line Terminal) to the Optical Network Unit (ONU). A
traditional PON also known as TDM PON which indicate a time division multiplexed
where the number of ONU‟s is limited by the splitting loss and by the bit rate of the
transceiver in the OLT‟s and ONU‟s. Next is WDM PON which is developed by the
high demand of end users as the bandwidth can be very low because it is share by all end
users. WDM PON provides excellent stability and may not suffer power splitting loss. In
comparison to the traditional PON, WDM PON used multiple wavelengths that can
support both upstream and downstream direction. WDM PON creates a point to point
link between OLT and each ONU.

1.1

Objectives
The purpose of this paper is to construct WOBAN circuit by using Optiwave

OptiSystem. The next objective is to analyze the performance of the Wireless Optical
Broadband Access Network by developing a WOBAN circuit by using Optiwave
OptiSystem software. To compare between different fiber length as a transmission line
between the front end and back end of the network. Finally, the performance of the
WOBAN with the best fiber length will be discussed.

3

1.2

Problem Statement

Due to the high demand from the customers or end users, they are asking for more cost
effective communication system that can support anytime, anywhere and any media they want.
Moreover, the users of wireless communications are demanding more capacity and

therefore higher frequencies. Other than that, since WOBAN is a combining of optical
and wireless communications, it presents a compelling solution that optimizes the best of
both worlds.

In addition, running optical fiber to every end user may be costly due to the
expensive installation cost. Moreover, providing wireless access from CO to every end
user may not be possible because of limited spectrum [2]. The users of wireless
communications are demanding more capacity, bandwidth and high frequencies [2].
Therefore, the investigation on the effect of optimum optical fiber length towards a
better performance in wireless mesh network is required.

1.3

Work Scope

The work scope of this research is to study the architecture of the block diagram
of WOBAN. Next, the parameters of the optical backhaul and wireless front end of the
network are examined. Moreover, this research concentrates on the performance analysis
of wireless optical broadband access network by varying the fiber length of the
transmission line of the network. Lastly, the results are analysed based on Power
Received, Q factor, Eye Diagram and eye height and Bit Error Rate (BER).

4

1.4

Thesis Outline

There are five chapters consist in this thesis; Introduction, Literature Review,
Methodology, Result and Discussion and Conclusion and Recommendation. Chapter 1
briefly explains the introduction of Wireless Optical Broadband Access Network
(WOBAN) and also the objectives of the project that need to be achieved at the end of
this project. Problem statement and work scope are also included in this chapter which
help the overflow of simulation and thesis writing.

Chapter 2 defines WOBAN for the optical wireless network and Wireless access
network. This chapter also explores WOBAN architecture which includes Optical Link
Terminal (OLT), Remote Node (RN) and Optical Network Unit (ONU). Other than that,
the advantages of WOBAN over the wireline optical are summarized in this chapter.
Fiber optic also discussed in this chapter which involves the type of fiber and its
comparison, dispersion effect, optical length effect and the advantages of using optical
fiber over copper wire. All the information in this chapter is gathered from related
journals and fiber optic books with citation.

Chapter 3 focused on methodology of the project. Flowchart and K-Map of the
project help the flow of the simulation design and also which parameter needs to be
focused. The proposed scheme is introduced in this chapter which define the bit rate
used for backhaul and wireless part. Optical fiber length is varied to analyze the
performance of WOBAN. In addition, the simulation process of developing WOBAN
circuit is included in this chapter. The process involved are by starting OptiSystem,
setting the layout, adding component, connecting component, setting the component
parameter, setting the parameter sweep, running the simulation and lastly viewing the
result.

5

Chapter 4 explores the result and discussion obtained from the simulation circuit.
The results are observed for 15km, 20km and 25km fiber length in term of power
received, Q factor, eye diagram and eye height and bit error rate (BER).In this session,
the results gained are analysed by referring to the parameter set earlier in the circuit.

Chapter 5 conclude the overall thesis. The best length with the least bit error rate
and the best data rate at both optical backhaul and wireless network are explained in this
chapter. Recommendations for this circuit are also included.