The Effect of Using Slow Beat English Songs on the Eight Year Students’ Listening Comprehension Achievement at SMPN 3 Jember in The 2011/2012 Academic Year
i
The Effect of Using Slow Beat English Songs on the Eight Year Students
Listening Comprehension Achievement at SMPN 3 Jember in The 2011/2012
Academic Year
Thesis
Composed as One of The Requirements to Obtain S1 Degree at The English
Education Study Program of Language and Arts Education Department of
Teacher Training and Education Faculty of Jember University
By:
FIFING ESPRADINA
070210401113
ENGLISH LANGUAGE EDUCATION STUDY PROGRAM
LANGUAGE AND ARTS EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
TEACHING TRAINING AND EDUCATION FACULTY
JEMBER UNIVERSITY
(2)
iii
DEDICATION
This thesis is honorably dedicated to:
1. My beloved parents; my father Mat Heri and my mother Poni Rahayu,
thanks for your endless love,
2. The only my adorable sister, Wulan Pangestu, thanks for giving me
annoying and beautiful days,
3. My sweetheart, Eko Riswanto, thanks for standing next to me in all
weather,
4. My extended family in Jember, Banyuwangi, Bondowoso and Bali for
everything all of you have given to me,
(3)
v
CONSULTANTS APPROVAL
The Effect of Using Slow Beat English Songs on the Eight Year Students
Listening Comprehension Achievement at SMPN 3 Jember in The 2011/2012
Academic Year
Thesis
Composed as One of The Requirements to Obtain S1 Degree at The English
Education Program of Language and Arts Education Department of Teacher
Training and Education Faculty of Jember University
Name
: Fifing Espradina
Place/Date of Birth
: Jember, 19 Juni 1990
NIM
: 070210401113
Program
: English Education
Department
: Language and Arts Education
Faculty
: Teacher Training and Education
Approved by
Consultant I
Consultant II
Drs. Sudarsono M.Pd.
Drs. Annur Rofiq, M.A., M.Sc.
(4)
vii
ACKNOLEDGMENT
First and foremost, I have to say thank you so much to the Only Greatest
God that give me unbreakable days and everything I need and want and guide me
through everything smells good, so I can have and finish this thesis.
In relation to the writing and finishing of this thesis, I would like to
express my great appreciation and sincerest gratitude to the following people:
1. The Dean of Faculty of Teacher Training and Education.
2. The Head of Language and Arts Education Department
3. The Head of English Education Program.
4. My Consultants, Drs. Sudarsono M.Pd. and Drs. Annur Rofiq, M.A.,
M.Sc. I do really thank for your time, guidance, valuable advice, patience,
and motivation that had led me compile and finish my thesis.
5. The Examination Committee and the Lecturers of the English Education
Program.
6. The Head Master, the English Teacher, the Students of VIII A, VIII B,
VIII D of SMPN 3 Jember that give me permission and help me in
conducting this research
Finally, I do hope that this thesis will be a useful contribution for the sake
of the improvement of English teaching, especially the teaching of listening. Any
criticism and valuable suggestion would be appreciated.
Jember, Oktober 2011
The Writer
(5)
ix
2.12 Research Hypothesis
...
15
III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Research Design
...
16
3.2 Area Determination Method
...
17
3.3 Respondent Determination Method
...
18
3.4 Data Collection Method
...
18
3.4.1 Test...
18
3.4.2 Documentation ...
25
3.4.3 Interview ...
25
3.5 Data Analysis Method
...
25
IV. RESEARCH RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 The Description of Treatment
...
27
4.2 The Result of Supporting Data
...
28
4.2.1 The Result of Interview
..
28
4.2.2 The Result of Documentation
.. 28
4.3 Homogeneity Analysis of English Score
From The English Teacher
...
29
4.4 The Analysis of the Try Out
...
31
4.4.1 The Analysis of Reliability Coefficient ...
31
4.4.2 The Analysis of Difficulty Index ...
33
4.5 The Result of Post Test
...
36
4.6 Hypothesis Verification
...
37
4.7 DRE (Degree of Relativeness)
...
37
4.8 Discussion
...
38
V. CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
5.1 Conclusion
...
41
5.2 Suggestions
...
41
(6)
xi
II. THE LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX A. Research Matrix
APPENDIX B. Research Instrument
APPENDIX C. Lesson Plan Meeting I
APPENDIX D. Lesson Plan Meeting II
APPENDIX E. Lesson Plan Meeting III
APPENDIX F. Pilot Test
APPENDIX G. Post Test
APPENDIX H. The Teacher Score
APPENDIX I. The Names of Research Respondent
APPENDIX J. The Distribution of Odd and Even Numbers
APPENDIX K. The Division of Odd and Even Numbers
APPENDIX L. t-test analysis with SPSS 11.5 for windows
APPENDIX M. t-test table with 5% significant level
APPENDIX N. Research Permission Letter from the Dean of Faculty of Teacher
Training and Education of Jember University
APPENDIX O. Research Permission Letter from the Head Master of SMPN 3
Jember
(7)
xiii
SUMMARY
The Effect of Using Slow Beat English Songs on the Eighth Grade Students
Listening Comprehension Achievement at SMPN 3 Jember in The 2011/2012
Academic Year;
Fifing Espradina, 070210401113; 2011:46; English Education
Program, Language and Arts Department, Faculty of Teacher Training and
Education, Jember University
Listening is one of the language skills that should be mastered by the
students in Junior High School. Unfortunately, EFL students still have difficulties
in listening comprehension. Further, it makes difficult for them to gain better
score for other language skills and components. When a teacher gives listening
test to the students, they still make some mistakes mostly in catching what the
speaker says. It is caused by unfamiliar English words they have.
One solution to solve this problem is using interesting media appropriate
for students named slow beat English songs. Supporting this solution, Davies
(2000) suggests that we can use songs to capture students interest or to reinforce
content. Besides through music, children can keep information permanently
because normally, children s mind is good in catching information through songs.
Further, an experimental research on listening skill by using songs had
been done by Saputri (2003) at SMU PGRI 1 Lumajang in the 2002/2003
academic year. Based on the calculation, the result showed that the value of t-test
of the post test was 4,148 while the critical value of t-test with the significant level
of 5% and the degree of freedom 88 was 1,980. Since 4.148 was higher than
1.980, therefore the major hypothesis of the research was accepted.
Based on the interview with the English teacher at SMPN 3 Jember it was
known that she rarely gave listening practice to the students. Although the school
had already had good facilities as it is an RSBI school, but still she rarely used it.
It was because she thought that bring them to multimedia room was wasting time.
However, when she teaches listening, she speaks orally to the students. So the
English teacher had never used slow beat English songs in teaching listening.
(8)
xv
contrast, the alternative hypothesis (Ha) that there was a significant effect of slow
beat English songs on the eight year students listening comprehension
achievement at SMPN 3 Jember in the 2011/2012 academic year was accepted.
Besides, the degree of effectiveness was 7.72%. It meant that the degree of
relative effectiveness of using slow beat English songs in teaching listening
comprehension applied to the experimental was 7.72% more effective than
teaching listening without using slow beat English songs applied to the control
group.
(9)
!
" #
!
$ %
&# #
'
!
:
())*$
#
+
, #
- '. / 01+ ( 23 4
" 5
6(67 5
89
88
()7 6(67()7 3
'/ : - ; " #
<
1"+ '
2 2 +
(10)
>? @A ?>BCDE @>A FDA DGH> IJ KHJL DH >AJ >? F>AH @LJBD E@ >AH E > FB JD EJ H>CJ G @HEJA @AM NDOH @A @ CPB >Q@AM H EKL JA EHR G@H EJA @AM F>CPB JS JAH @ >AT
IUVS JWE KL JA EH
VS J BJHKGE >? ES J B JHJDBFS S >PJ?KG GO FDA C >E@QD E J H E KL JA EHR L JH@B J DAL N@GG @AMAJH H @A GJDBA @AM XAMG@HST VS J H EKL JA EH FDA D GH > EBD @A ES JCHJGQJH @A G @HEJA @AM ESB>KMS HG >N IJD E XAMG @H S H >AMH E > CDYJES JC?DC @G @DBN@ ESXAMG @H SN>BLH T
FUVS JZES JB[JHJDB FS JBH
VS J BJHKGE >? ES J B JHJD BFS S >PJ?KG GO FDA IJ KH JL DH D C JDA @AM?KG B J?JBJA F J D AL @A ?>BCD E@ >A ?>B >ESJB BJH JDB FSJBH E > F>AL KFEH@C @GDBB JH JDB FS T
\]^_` abcadefg hi ejk alg ig fghim
VS J >PJB D E@ >AD G L J?@A @E @>A M@QJH ES J HD CJ KAL JBHEDAL @AM E > ES J BJDLJBH D I>KE ES J CJDA @AM >? QDB@D IGJH @A ES @H HEKLOT nA ES @H BJH JDB FS ES JBJ D B J EN> QDB@D IGJH o ES JO DBJ H G >N IJD E XAMG@HS H>AMH DAL H E KL JA EH G@H EJA @AM F>CPB JS JAH@ >ADFS @ JQJCJA ET
DU WG >NpJD EXAMG @H SH>AMH
WG >N IJD EXAMG @H S H>AMH DBJXAMG @H S H>AMHESDE S DQJ H G>NBSOES CT nAES @HHEKLOo>A J>?ES JHG >NIJD EXAMG@HSH >AMHESD EKH JLNDHDH >AM?B >C q@FSD JGrD FYH >AstJD GVS Ju>B GLvTVS JB JHJD BFSJBKH JHH G >NIJD EXAMG @H S H>AMH@A>BL JBE >CDYJH EKL JA EH JDH @ JB E>FDE FSXAMG@HSN>BLH@A ES >H JEN> H>AMH T
IU WE KL JA EHRw@HE JA @AMx >CPB JS JAH @ >Ay FS @JQJC JA E
w@H E JA @AMF>CPB JS JAH @ >AD FS @JQJCJA ECJDAHDADFE @QJPB >F JH HESD E ?KGGO HKFFJH H JH NSJA ES J G @HE JA JB FDA B J FJ@QJ ES J CJH HDMJo F>AH EB KF E CJDA @AMo M@QJ B JHP>AHJH >B A >A QJB ID G H@MA D G E> HS >No KAL JBH EDA L Q>FD IKGDBO DAL MBD CC D E@ FDG HEB KFEKB JH o FD EFS HEBJH H DAL @A E>AD E @>Ao PBDFE @FJ DAL BJPBJHJA E ES J CJH H DMJT uS @ GJ @A ES @H B JH JDBFSo H EKL JA EHR
(11)
{ {|} ~ ~{ ~} } ~} ~ {~
¡ ¡
¢|£¤ ¥ ¦§¨ ¤¨©ª«¬ ®§¯§¨ ¥ ¤«¨
° ¡ ± ² ¡¡ ± ± ³ ´° µ ¶··¸µzz¹º ¡ ³ ± ² ± » ± ± ² ¡ ± ± ¼ ½ ¡
¾ ´¶··¿µ¶ Àz³¶ À· ¹ ¡ ¡ ¡ ² ¡ ¡ ² ±
¢|¢¤¥¦§¨ ¤¨ ©ª «¬ ®§¯§¨ ¥¤ «¨Á¯ ¤§Â §¬ §¨¦
¾ ´¶··¿µ ¶ À· ¹
(12)
Ä ÅÅÆÇÈÉÊ Ë ÌÆ ÍÎÏ ÐÇ ÑÒÓ ÓÔÕÖ Ì×ÐÇÐ ØÇ Ð Ì ×ÇÐÐ Ù Ì ØËÐÙ ÉÊ ØÚÚÛÜÉÊ Ë ÛÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊË ØÅÌ ÉÝÉ ÌÉÐÙÞ
ÒÞ ß ÇÐàÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊ Ë
á×ÉÙ ØÅÌÉÝÉÌÜ ÐÙ Ì ØâÛ ÉÙ ×ÐÙ Ì×Ð ÚÎÇÚÆÙÐÆãÌ ×Ð Û ÉÙÌÐÊ ÉÊËØÅÌÉÝÉÌÜØÊ È ØÅÌ ÉÝØÌÐÙ ÆÇ âÎ ÉÛ ÈÙ ÙÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙÖÚÇ ÉÆÇ äÊÆåÛ Ð ÈËÐÞæÌ ÉÙ ÉçÚÆÇÌ ØÊ Ì ãÆÇ Ì×Ð Ù ÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙ ÌÆ âÐ ØâÛÐ ÌÆ ÅÆÊÊ Ð ÅÌ å ×ØÌ Ì ×ÐÜ × ØÝÐ ØÛÇÐØÈÜäÊÆå Ê ÌÆ Ì ×Ð Ù ÚÐØäÐÇèÙ çÐÙ Ù ØËÐÞ ß ÇÐ àÉÙÌÐÊ ÉÊË Ø ÅÌ ÉÝÉ Ì Ü ç ØäÐÙ ÙÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙ âÐ ËÉÊ ÌÆ ËÎÐÙÙ å×ØÌ Ì ×ÐÜ Ú ÇÆâØâÛÜ ×Ð ØÇ ØÊ È ç ØäÐØÅÆÊÊÐÅÌÉÆÊå É Ì× Ì×Ð ÉÇ ÚÇÉÆÇäÊÆå ÛÐ ÈËÐ ÖØÊ È ÉÊ ÅÇÐØÙ Ð Ì×Ð ÉÇ ÆåÊäÊÆå ÛÐ ÈËÐÞ
é Þ ê×ÉÛ Ù ÌàÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊË
á×ÉÙÙÌ ØËÐÇ ÐÛ ØÌ ÐÙÈÉÇ Ð ÅÌÛÜÌÆÐÊ ËØËÐ çÐÊ Ìå É Ì×Ì×ÐÌÐëÌÖØÊ ÈÙ ÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙ ÈÆÌ ×Ð çØÉÊ ØÅÌÉÝÉÌ ÉÐÙ ÈÎÇ ÉÊË Ì×ÐÜ ØÇÐ Û ÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊËÞ æÊ Ì×Ð çØÉÊ ÛÉÙÌÐÊ ÉÊË ØÅÌÉÝÉÌ ÉÐÙ Ö Ù ÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙ å ÉÛÛ ãÉÊ È Ì×ÐÊå ×ÐÌ ×ÐÇ Ì ×Ð ÉÇÚÇÐ ÈÉ ÅÌ ÉÆÊ ÉÙÅÆÇÇÐ ÅÌÆÇ åÇÆÊ ËÞæÊÌ ×Ð çØÉÊ ØÅÌÉÝÉÌÜÖ ÌÐØÅ×Ð Ç ØÚÚÛÉÐ È Ø ËØÚ ãÉÛÛÉÊ Ë ÌÐÙ ÌÞ á×ÐÊ å×ÐÊ Ì× Ð Ù ÌÎ ÈÐÊ Ì Ù ãÉÊ ÉÙ×Ð È Ì×Ð ÉÇåÆÇä ÖÌ ×ÐÌ Ð ØÅ×ÐÇå ÉÛ ÛÙ å É ÌÅ×Ù ÌÎ ÈÐ Ê ÌÙèÙ×ÐÐÌ ØÊ È ÈÉÙ ÅÎÙ ÙÌ ×Ð ØÊÙå ÐÇå É Ì×Ì ×Ðå ×ÆÛÐÅÛØÙ ÙÞ
ìÞ ß ÆÙÌàÉÙÌÐÊ ÉÊ Ë
æÌ ÉÙ Ø ä ÉÊ È Æã ãÆÛÛ ÆåíÎ Ú ØÅÌÉÝÉÌÉÐÙÞ æÌ å ÉÛÛ âÐ ÝÐÇÜ ÐããÐ ÅÌ ÉÝÐ å ×ÐÊ ÉÌ ÉÙ ÉçÚÛÐ çÐÊ ÌÐ È Éç çÐ ÈÉ ØÌÐÛ Ü ØãÌÐÇ Ì×Ð ç ØÉÊ ÛÉÙÌÐÊ ÉÊË Ø ÅÌ ÉÝÉ ÌÜÞ ß ÆÙ Ì Û ÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊË ØÅÌ ÉÝÉ ÌÉÐÙ ×ÐÛÚ ÙÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙ ÌÆ ÅÆÊÊÐ ÅÌ å ×ØÌ Ì ×ÐÜ × ØÝÐ ×Ð ØÇÈ ÌÆ Ì ×Ð ÉÇ ÆåÊ Ð ëÚÐÇ ÉÐÊ ÅÐÙ ØÊ È ÐÊ ÅÆÎÇ ØËÐ ÇÐãÛ Ð ÅÌÉÝÐ Ì×ÉÊ Ëä ÉÊ ËÞ îÎÇ Ì×ÐÇ Ö Í ÎÏÐÇ ÑÒÓÓÔÕ Ù Ì ØÌÐÙ Ì×ØÌ ÚÆÙ Ì Û ÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊË ØÅÌÉÝÉÌ ÉÐÙ ÚÇÆÝÉ ÈÐ ÆÚÚÆÇÌÎÊ ÉÌ ÉÐÙ ØÊ È ÅÛØÇÉãÜ ÎÊ ÈÐÇÙÌØÊ ÈÉÊ ËÞ á×ÉÙ ÙÌØËÐ ØÛÙ Æ ËÉÝÐÙ ÌÐ ØÅ×ÐÇ Å× ØÊ ÅÐ ÌÆ ØÅÅÐÙ Ù Ù ÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙè ÅÆ çÚÇÐ×ÐÊÙÉÆÊ ÖÅ×Ð ÅäØÊÈÅÛ ØÇ ÉãÜÙ ÌÎ ÈÐÊ ÌÙèÎÊ ÈÐ ÇÙÌØÊ ÈÉÊËÞ
Ä ÅÅÆÇÈÉÊ ËÌÆïÆ ×ÑÒÓÓÔð éÒíéìÕ ÖÌ ×ÐÇÐØÇÐÌåÐÊ Ì ÜãØÅÌÆÇÙå ×ÉÅ×ÉÊãÛÎÐÊÅÐ Û ÉÙ ÌÐÊ ÉÊËÅÆ çÚÇÐ ×ÐÊÙ ÉÆÊØÅ×ÉÐÝÐç ÐÊ ÌÌ×ØÌØÇÐÅØÌÐ ËÆÇ ÉÏ Ð ÈÌÆñçØÉÊÅØÌ Ð ËÆÇ ÉÐÙð
ÒÞ áÐ ë ÌÖÌ ×ÐÜØÇ ÐðØÞß×ÆÊÆÛÆËÉ ÅØÛçÆ ÈÉãÉ ÅØÌ ÉÆÊÙ â ÞòÆ ÅØâÎÛ ØÇÜ
ÅÞóÚÐÐ Å×ÇØÌÐ ÈÞáÜÚÐÆãÉÊÚÎ Ì
(13)
ö÷ øùùúûü
ýü þúÿúþ ü üú þúü ù ú úþú û úû úüúþ ü þ ü ø úþ ùûø üþ ûþüúþ ÷
÷ úúùþüú
ýü þúüúüüú úúþ ûú ÿúù þ úû÷ÿÿúþúûüûú úÿÿúþúûüûþþ üú ÷ ú ùùüúþú ûþ þ ü ú ûû ùû ú ùüúþú üú ÿ ü û ú ÿþ ýûûú û ü úûü ü ü úþûü û ÷ úûúüÿù ü ü üüú úü ÿÿù üú ûùüù ûüúúûû÷
÷ þ þû úú÷
ýü ü ü úûü ùþûû úúÿ üúü ù ú ù ú ÷ýü þüûüü û ùû úúüùûûúù üüúþ
þ þ
ûÿþü û üüú ûú ûú÷
øü üú ü úùúþ ú
û þú ü û
ü úûü ü úûû ùþúúû û ù úúúûü ü ü üúþú þú
û
ü ú
üú þ ú þ ü ú ü ü ûú üú ÷ ú ü úùúþ ÿû û þ ú
ü úûü üúûü úþú üûüúþ û úüúú ûü ù þ ùûü û û þ üúüúùúûúÿ ÿúùüúü úù û ü úûû üþ üúú ÷
!"#$%&'( ) * +, !( )+
û úù ú ÿ ù ü þ ü ü û -. þû/001 2÷ ú þ û û þúù ú þ ù ÷3 ù úû ú ûùû üþù üú ùû ú ü ú úÿÿúù ü û ù úþûû û ú üú û û - 4 û /0052÷
4 û - /0052 úû ü ü ù û þüûü û úüþúú úÿ ü û üú ú úþû û ü úû ü úþ üú ÿ üþ û úþ ÿ þú þùú÷ 6þüúþþú ú ú û ü ü ü úûû üþ ù ùû ú ûú üþ û ü ûúþ üû ü û ûü úþþúü ü û ÿÿúþúûü 7 û û û üüúü ÷3 ùû û ùûúûùþú úüú ú üúûû ûÿûþú ú ûûúþ÷ ø ú ù ùþúüú û úûþûúûüü ü ùû ùúü úþûûû
(14)
;< = >? >@AB CD= EBA;F ?>= ?GHI>;AJ C D?B K L=G CDK
ML>N> ;N> KGO> @NB A >NB; BC K>? >@ AB C D K EB A ;F ?> K? GH F >;A JC D?BKL KG C DK< P@GNQBC D AG R >> D;C S TUUVWX A L> @NB A >NB; G Y K>? >@ AB CD KG C DK YGN A>;@ LB CD ?B K A >CBCD@GOZN>L >CKBG C;@ LB >[>O>CA;N>;KYG ? ?G HK\
T< ML>KG CDKOEK AL;[>;@?>;N?]NB @ K
^< ML>N>@GNQB C DGYAL>KG C DKK LG E?QF >DGG Q;CQ@ ? >;N _ < ML>KBCD>NGYAL>KG C DKKLG E? QL;[>CB @ >@? >;N[GB@ >
`< ML> ?;C DE; D> G Y A L> KG C DK OEKA F > K EB A ;F ? > H BA L A L> ? >[>? GY AL> K AEQ>CAK
aGN>G[>NX A L>N> ;N> A LN>> ZNB C@BZ;? KG CD K>? >@ A BG C @NB A >NB; ;@@GNQB CD AG b]C@L S^ccdW\
T< eK> KG CDK AL;A ;N> ZGZE? ;N HBAL AL> K AEQ>CAK H L>C>[>N ZG K KB F ?>< eCYGNAEC;A >?]X K AEQ>CA K YN>f E>CA ?] K >?>@ A KG CDK Y GN @? ;KKNGGO EK > HLB@ L ;N> GFg>@ABG C;F ? >B CKGO>H ; ]O;hBC DAL>KG C DECEK ;F ?><
^< =G CDKOEK AL;[>@ ?>;N; CQECQ>NK A;C;F ? >?]NB@ K <iG ALBCDBKHGNKAA L ;C;K G CD ;?OG K A CGFG Q ]@ ;CECQ >NKA ;CQ<jYAL >K A EQ>CA K L;[>ANG EF ? > ECQ >NK A ;CQBC DAL> ?]NB @ KF]?B K A>CBC DXA L>C; CG AL>NKG CDC >>QKAGF >K >? >@A >Q<
_ < =G CDK K LG E?Q L;[> ;ZZNGZNB ;A> A L>O>< ML>N>kK > CG EDL F ;Q C>HKX C>D;AB[BA ] ;CQ [B G ?>C@ > B C A L> HGN?Q ;?N>;Q]< =G CDK H B A L ;C ] A]Z> GY C> D;AB[> AL>O> K LG E? QF >;[GB Q>Q<ML>N>;N>Z? >CA]GY ZG KBAB[>XEZF >;A >[>C LEOGNG EK KG CDK ;[;B ? ;F ?><
F < PZZ? ]BC D= ?GHI>;AJC D?BK L=G CDK
ML>ZNG @ >QEN>KGYA > ;@LBCD?B K A>CBCD@GOZN>L >CKB G CEK >QAL;AB KQ>K @NB F >QF] lGGS^cc^WXAL>];N>\
T< mN>nbBKA>CB CD\
;W ;K ; H ;NOnEZ GN K @ L>O; F EB ? QB CD ;@ AB[B A]X ;Kh KA EQ>CAK H L;A AL>] hCGH ;FG EA PO>NB @ ;C ZGZ @E? AEN>< ML> N>K > ;N@ L >N OBDLA ;?KG H ;CA AGFNBCDKGO>ZB @ AEN>KGNo pkKGYAL>KG C DAL;AHB? ?F >Z?; ]> Q< F W m;K K G EA A L> @ ?Gq> ;@ AB[B A] L;CQG EA X ;CQ L;[> A L > K AEQ>CAK N>;Q AL >
(15)
tu v wxy z{y |}
v ~ z ~ }~ ~ w|yz y y~ y | ~w|yw~ y~ y} }|~ wu| ~ { xy ~wyzu| yz|y~y~ xy z |zu | w ~ || y|y y wy |~ ~|{|~ ~ y| ||y~yy|}u|y~ ~ w~||x {~} ~| y |yw~|yy|{ y| |yy~ {~ ~yy~~~y x u w ~ w ~|{|~ y~| ~ z |} y |y |y~ || ~z |} y~ {~ ~ x{ | |} y{~ |y~u
u yyy |}
| { |y ~
~ z y~ |
{ y ~y~| u | ~ ~yzyy | y{ | ~|{|~ x} yz| | }y
| ~z~u } y~|yz | ~ w ~ z~ ~|{|~ y | ~y~|
~ w|yz~{ ~
|y~y| u u y~ y| }
v~
w
z{z{~~ z~
{y~wz{ wxyz~u |w~ y| ww |yz~ | {|{~ y ~ y |{ yzy{~xyu xyy|y~ {y~ x {~ { wxyz~ wwy||~ |yz~u
u }{ ~~
|} | ~yyzyz z{zy~|xyy| } |{y |}| }y| y | | |~| y|~ ~|y y |}u|{|~ x~ y | |~ | y | | z{z |} |y |~yz |}y | ~zu|w~||~z~ | } zy |{y|} | | ~|{|~ | | z{z x{ | ~ | }y|y|u
u ¡ |y¢z{z
z~ zy ~ ~ | |y |}~ ~ z{z {~ u y wy {~ y~ y | | w w |x | { { |yy| y ~{| | y | y~ | w | ~ } | | ~ ~ x ~~y xyy|}u | w~ || ~z~ y y | | |
(16)
¥¥ ¥ ¦§ ¨© ¨ª§ «¬¨®¬ ¯° ©
±²³´ µ²¶·¸ ¹º · º¹´¹»¸´ ¸ ²¹ º¹´¹ ¶ºµ² ¼ ¹¸²½¾½¿½À Á ¸ ²¶¸  ¶´ ¶··¿³¹¾ ³» ¸ ²³´ º¹´¹¶ ºµ²Ã ĸ µ½»´³´¸¹¾ ½Å º¹´¹¶ ºµ² ¾ ¹´³ À»Æ ¶º¹ ¶ ¾ ¹¸¹º¼ ³» ¶¸³½» ¼¹¸ ²½¾Æ º ¹´· ½»¾ ¹»¸ ¾ ¹¸ ¹º¼ ³» ¶¸³½»¼¹¸ ²½¾Æ¾ ¶¸ ¶µ½¿ ¿ ¹µ¸ ³½»¼ ¹¸ ²½¾¶» ¾¾ ¶¸ ¶¶» ¶¿Á´ ³´¼¹¸²½¾Ã
Ǧ ȧ ÉÊ ÉËÌ Íΰ ÉÊÏÐÑ
±²¹´ ¸Ò¾Á ¶´¾½» ¹ÓÁÒ´³» ÀÔÕ· ¹º³¼ ¹»¸¶¿Ö¹´¹¶ ºµ²×¹´ ³À»Ã±²¹¶³¼½Å ¸ ²¹ ´¸Ò¾Á ¶´ ¸½ ³» ع´ ¸ ³ À¶¸¹ ²¹¸²¹ º ½ º »½¸ ¸²¹º ¹ ³´ ¶ ´ ³À» ³Å³µ¶»¸ ¹ÅŹ µ¸ ½Å Ù ¿½  ڹ¶¸ Ô»À¿³´² Ù½» À´ ½» ¸²¹ Ô³ À²¸² Û¹¶º Ù¸Ò¾ ¹»¸´Ü ݳ´ ¸ ¹» ³»À Þ½¼ · º¹ ²¹»´ ³½» ßµ²³ ¹Ø¹¼¹»¸ ¶¸ Ù àá â ã ä¹¼Ó¹º ³» ± ²¹ å棣ç åæ£å ßµ¶¾ ¹¼³µ Û¹¶ºÃ ±²¹ º¹´¹¶ ºµ²¹ ºµ²½½´¹á½´ ¸è± ¹´ ¸½»¿ÁÞ½»¸º½¿×¹´ ³ À»½Å¹Õ· ¹º³¼¹»¸¶¿º¹´ ¹¶ºµ² ¾ ¹´ ³À»Ã ±²¹ ¾ ¹´³ À» ³¿ ¿ » ¹¹¾ ¸Â½ Àº½Ò·´ ½ º µ¿¶´ ´¹´ ź½¼ ¸ ²¹  ²½¿ ¹ ¶Ø¶³¿¶Ó¿ ¹ µ¿¶´ ´ ¹´ éáҺ ¶»¸ ½¶»¾ÙÒ¿ ³´¸Á¶  ¶¸ ³ÆåææêëìíîÃ
±²¹ ųº´ ¸ µ¿¶´´ ¶´ ¸ ²¹ ¹Õ· ¹º³¼¹»¸ ¶¿ Àº½Ò·Æ ²³¿¹ ¸²¹ ´¹µ½»¾ µ¿¶´´  ¶´ ¸ ²¹ µ½»¸º½¿ Àº½Ò·Ã±²¹ ¹Õ· ¹º³¼ ¹»¸ ¶¿ Àº½Ò· º¹ µ¹³ Ø ¹ ¾ ¸º¹ ¶¸ ¼ ¹»¸ÓÁÒ´ ³»À´ ¿½ ÂÓ¹¶¸ Ô» À¿ ³´² ´ ½» À´ éïî ¶´ ¸ ²¹ ¼¶¸ ¹º³¶¿ ³» ¸¹¶µ²³»À ¿³´ ¸ ¹» ³» À µ½¼· º ¹²¹»´ ³½»Æ  ²³¿ ¹¸ ²¹ µ½»¸ º½¿ Àº½Ò·  ¶´ ¸¶ÒÀ²¸ ÓÁ Ò´³» À ¸ ¹ ¶µ²¹º´Ü ´ ½Ò»¾ º¹µ½ º¾¹ºÃ ±²¹» ¶Å¸¹º ¸¹¶µ²³»À ¸ ²º¹¹¸³¼¹´¸½ ¹ ¶µ²Àº½Ò·Æ¸ ²¹·½´¸è¸¹´¸Â¶´À³Ø¹»¸½ Ó½¸ ²½Å¸²¹¹Õ· ¹º³¼¹»¸¶¿¶»¾ µ½»¸ º½¿Àº½Ò·¸½Å³»¾½Ò¸¸ ²¹¼¹¶»¾ ³ÅŹ º¹» µ ¹Ó¹¸Â¹¹»¸² ½´¹¸Â½ Àº½Ò·´Ã±²¹¾ ¶¸ ¶ ¶´ ¶»¶¿Á
z
¹¾ ÓÁ µ½¼ ·¶ º³» À ¸ ²¹ ·½´¸è¸¹´¸ ´µ½ º¹´ ½Å Ó½ ¸² Àº½Ò·´ ÓÁ Ò´ ³»À ¸è¸¹´ ¸ Ž º¼Ò¿ ¶³»Ùá Ù Ùµ½¼·Ò¸³» À´Á´ ¸¹¼Ãá½´ ¸è¸ ¹´ ¸½»¿Áµ½»¸ º½¿¾ ¹´ ³ À»µ ¶»Ó¹¾ ¹´ µº³Ó¹¾ ¶´Å½¿ ¿½ ´ë⽸¹´ë
֣뱲¹£´ ¸Àº½Ò·µ²½´¹»º¶»¾½¼¿Á Öåë±²¹å»¾Àº½Ò·µ²½´¹»º¶»¾½¼¿Á ï뱺¹¶¸ ¼ ¹»¸
ð£ëá½´ ¸è¸¹´ ¸´ µ½ º¹½Å¸² ¹£´ ¸Àº½Ò·¶Å¸¹ ºÀ³Ø³» À¸ º ¹¶¸¼¹»¸
Ö£ ï ð£
(17)
óô õö ó÷ ø ùóô÷úûøüý õú óô÷ þ õö ø üø÷øý üùöøü ÿ üÿó÷ú ø ùö óó÷ø ø øü õó ù óôû ù õõö øøÿøüúøôõý üø÷ øýüùö
ö øÿóÿ ý õú óôó õö ú÷üø÷øý üùö ! ý÷ ý õö øøú"ö õöøýü÷ õ ûøôõ÷ú ô ø øüö øüø ! øüø
#
ù ý÷ ÷ø÷ ó õö ø øú"ö õö øýü úô øøü$ õöø!øüø % &&& ' þ %&&& ( þ %&&& ) þ %&&& * þ% &&& + þ % &&& , ýôû % &&& - &ô õö ú÷ ü ø÷ øý üùö þ õö ø üø÷øýüùö ø ü ÷øû õö ø ÿóÿ ý õ úóô ó % &&& ' ôõ ú %&&& ,þ øùý ÷ø %&&& - ú÷ ý ô ýùù ø øüý õú óô ù ý÷ ÷ ö ø ô øü ó ÷õ ûøôõ÷ úô õö ó÷ø ÷øøô ù ý÷ ÷ ø÷ !ý÷ ./0 ÷õ ûøôõ÷
ö ø üø÷øý üùö !ý÷ øÿøüúøôõý üø÷øý üùö õöý õ ôøøû÷ õ!ó ù ý÷ ÷ ø÷ ý÷ øÿøüú øôõý ù ý÷ ÷ ý ôû ùóôõüó ù ý÷ ÷ ü!ý ôõ ó ýôû ú÷ õ ý !ý õú 1200#3 4# 5 ÷ õýõ ø õöý õ ù ÷õøü üý ôûó ÷ ý ÿ úô" ú÷ ý 6 úôû ó ÷ ý ÿ úô" õ øùö ôú7 ø ú ô õö ø ý÷ ú÷ ó ù ÷õøü÷ ý ôû ôóõ úôûú úû ý üø÷ ÿóôûøôõ õý6 øô üý ôû ó ö ø üø ó üøþ õöø ü ø÷ øý üùöøü ÷øûù ÷õ øüüý ôûó÷ ýÿ úô"õ øùö ôú 7 ø õý6 ú ô"õ! óù ý÷ ÷ø÷ý óô"õö øøú÷ õ úô" ÷úùý÷÷ø÷ý÷õö øüø÷ øýüù öüø÷ÿóôûøôõ
8 9 : :;
*ýõý ùó øù õú óô øõö óû !ý÷ ÷÷õøý õ úù ÷ õý ôûýüû ÿüóùøû ü ø÷ õó " øõ õö ø ûýõý ôøøûøûö ø üø ýüø õ !ó 6úôû÷ ó ûý õý õöý õ ! ú ø ù ó øùõ øû óü õö ú÷ üø÷ øý üù ö$ õö ø ý üø ÿüúý ü ûý õý ý ôû ÷ ÿÿóüõ úô" ûýõýüú ý ü ûý õý !ý÷ ù ó øù õ øû üó ÷ ù óüø÷ ó õö øõ ø÷ õ!ö ú ø÷ ÿÿóüõ úô"ûý õý!ý÷ù ó øù õøû üóúôõ øüú ø!ý ôûûóù øôõý õúóô 4.ø÷õ
ø÷õ !ý÷ ÷øû õ ó ùó øùõ ÿüú ý ü ûýõý &ô õö ú÷ ü ø÷øý üùö þ õö øü ø !ø üø õö üø ø 6 úôû÷ ó õø÷õ õöý õ ! ú ø ý ÿÿúøû õó ù ó øù õ õö ø ûýõý þ õö ø ! ø üø ö ó ó"øô øúõ õø÷ õþ õüó õ1ÿú óõõø÷õ5ý ôûÿó÷õõ ø÷õ(ø ó!!ý÷õö øúü üúø øÿý ôýõ úóô
(18)
>? @ A BC DE?FCBGH I DFJ GA KJLKBM KGGN OP ?N GQ @A?CK? C @RN ?GH C K?A?B?@ AMK JFEJM @CGAB@FEC K??S@T UN?GHCK?C ?BCJC ?TBV
W?B ?@AM KXFEJM @CGAB Y @TUN ?GHC?BCJC?TB ZO YCDE?FC B @A? @RN? CG HJFE CK?
?SUNJM JC JFHGAT@C J GF GH C K? TGFGN GLD?C ?SCC K?>K ?@A E
XO[J BC ?F C G CK? C ?SC UN@>?E\ @FECK?FE?M JE?Q KJM KQGAE J F CK? R A@M]?C C K@C JB CA DN> BUG]?F^
_`aRN J FEJFLbRN? ?EJ FLcHN@BK C K@CE?BCAG>? E@R?@DCJHDN
FJLKC@FE@R GTRC K@C aR DAFbR DAFCcR DJN EJ FLBB DM K @BTGBdD?B\aKGT?BbKGU?Bc @FEBM KGGN BQK?A ?JCH@NN EGQFJ B@E@JN >B JCD@CJGFJF
e @
z
@\f @N?BCJF? OgXXO hJNNC K?RN@F]BU@M ?BGHCK? C?SC R ?NGQ R @B ?E GF CK? TGFGN GLD? C?SC >GD K?@AE^
_ iA? @TJ B@R JLE ?@NGHNJH?OXC J BFGCGFN>B GT?CKJFLC K@C MGT?BZOjjjjjjjjjjjjj jj GDAFJM ?BN??UR DC@N B G@BUJ AJC GHN J H?OiA? @TBQ K?F ?k?AJCJB @R @EEA? @T \Q ?M @FBC JNNC @]? JC@BGDATGCJk@CJGFCGT@]?
(19)
nop q rstpoup tp vw x y v sz v{ |pq} s ~ so vxq zowz v o v v s z tpv o ty sv x pz o qxv sr soqz xy sozrpq n vsz v rstpoup tp vw{ r vsr s s topqz vo v v s z tpv o t y sv x pz uozs xqvsrp q}p t s vo v py oq o}}r o vs sozrpq n p qzvrsqv sr s urxsq p qv x vx so t or vz v s sozrssqvz xu v op qs p v xqs o r v xt } xrr sz xq s o} vtw vx v xzs xu vop qs p v v s xv sr{ o vsr v s rstp oup tp v w xy v s xt s p t xv vszvr sztvoz}o t}to vsuwzpq nvp zyxr to
xv sz r
r stp ouptpv w} xsyyp }psqv
v sv xvo tqu srzxyx p v szo qssqpvsz v sv xvo txyxpvsz
v sv xvo tqu srxyss qp v sz v squ srxyr sz xqsqvz
| p xqx sqv s rstpoup tp vwxyso}v sz v rsztvoz o qotw
z
suwz p qn| soro q r xqxrtoozr szs qv su st xr
xv sz r
r stp ouptpv w} xsyyp }psqvy xrv s xt spvsz
(20)
¡¢£¤¥
¦ ¥£§¤¨ ©ª¤«¢¬ª¨ ¬¬¨ ®¯£°¢¬¤±§¨£¤²
³ ¥£§¤©® ²´¤ µ¢¬¶ £® ª¤©£ ¶·§¢± ©¶·¤ µ£§¤¸®¤ ¶ £¨¢©¶¢µµ¤£¯° ¡ ¥£§¤©® ²´¤ µ¢¬¶ £® ª¤©£ ¶·§¢ª¢£§¤£ ¤ ¶£
¹§¤µ¨£¤ µ¨ ±¢¬¨ ©ª¤«¢¬ª¨ ¬¬¨ ®¯£°±µ¤¥ º»ºº¼º»½ º ¥ª¨¬¬¨ ®¯£
º»½¾¼º»¿º ¥¬±¨µ º»¿ ¾¼¾»ºº ¥¤±¶°
ÀÁµ¨ ® ©£ ¢ÃĺºÅ¥Ä¾ºÆ Ç ¢²¤£¤ ¶£¨£¤²¶·¤µ¤£¢¢¤±¶°
± ©ª
£¢ ¢ª¨ ¬¬¨ ®¯£Ã ± © ª
£§¤©£§¤µ¤¶ ¤±µ§¤µ µ¤È¨¶¤ª £§¤ ¨£¤²¶ »¹§¤ µ¤È¨¶¨¢©¨£¶¤¯ ¬ ·±¶ ´±¶¨ µ¤È¨¶¨¢©¶ ¬¢µ¤«± ²É¯¤ £¤ ¶ £ ¨£¤²µ¤È¨¶¨¢©
± ©ª
£¤ ¶ £¨£¤²¶ª¤¯¤ £¨¢©£§±£·¤ µ¤©¢£¸®±¯¨¬¨¤ª»¹§¤ µ¤¬¢µ¤Ã£§¤ ¨£¤²¶ £¤ ¶ £ ¢¬ ɨ¯¢£ £¤¶ £ ²®¶ £ ´¤ ²¢µ¤ £§± © £§¢¶¤
¨©
É¢¶ £ £¤ ¶ £ ÀÊ Ë¨·±©ª¢©¢Ã ¾ÌÌÅ¥¾ÍÆ»
» ΢¶ £¹¤ ¶ £
ϮЧ¤ ¶ À¾ÌÌÅ¥¾Ä¼¾½Æ ¶£±£¤ ¶ £§±£ ± §¨¤È¤²¤©£ £¤ ¶ £ ¨¶ ®¶¤ª £¢ ²¤±¶®µ¤ ± ¶£® ª¤©£Ñ¶ ²±¶£¤ µ° ¢¬ ·§±£ §±¶ ´¤ ¤© £± ®Ð§£» ¹§¤ É¢¶£¼£¤ ¶ £ ·±¶ ¢©¶£ µ®£¤ª ±¶ ± © ±§¨¤È¤²¤©£ £¤ ¶ £ £§±£ ²¤±¶®µ¤ £§¤ ¶ £® ª¤©£¶Ñ ¯¨¶£¤©¨ ©Ð ¢²Éµ¤§¤©¶¨¢© ±§¨¤È¤²¤©£ » ¦£ ·±¶ ±µµ± ©Ð¤ª ´±¶¤ª ¢© £§¤ £¤ ¶ £ ¨£¤²¶ ¢¬ ɨ¯¢£ £¤ ¶ £ £§±£ ·±¶ ɵ¢É¤ µ ¬¢µ £§¤ ¶ £® ª¤©£ ¶ » ¹§¤ £¤¶ £ ¢©¶¨¶ £¤ª ¢¬ ÄÒ ¨£¤²¶ » ¹§¤ £¤ ¶£ ¢È¤ µ¤ª £§¤ £°É¤ ¶ ¢¬ ¸®¤ ¶£¨¢©¶Ã £µ®¤ ¼¬±¯¶ ¤ ¤«¤µ¨¶¤ ± ©ª ¬¨ ¯¯¨©Ð £§¤ б ɶ £ ¢ ¶¤±µ§ ¨²É¯ ¨¨£ ±©ª ¤« ɯ¨ ¨£ ¨ ©¬¢µ²±£¨¢©©¤¤ª¤ª» ¦© µ¤¯±£¨¢© £¢ £§¤ ¶¢µ¨©Ðà £§¤ £ ¢£±¯ ¶¢µ¤ ·±¶ ¾ºº ¨¬ ¶ £® ª¤©£ ¶ ± ©¶·¤ µ¤ª ±¯ ¯ £§¤ £¤ ¶ £ ¨£¤²¶ ¢µµ¤£¯°»¹§¤£¨ ²¤±¯ ¯¢ ±£¨¢©¬¢µ£§¤É¢¶ ££¤ ¶ £·±¶ÓÒ²¨©®£¤ ¶ »
(21)
Ö×ØÙÚÛÜ ØÝÞÚØßàÛáâ áãä
z
ØÝáàáåØ ÚØæáç èâ à ØÚéâê à ×Ø Ýá àá Ûë à×Ø ØìÙØÚéíØâ àáã áâ Ý ÜÛâ àÚÛã Üãáß ß àÛ î ï î î ðØÚç ññçòÝá àáØÝéàÛ Úó
ôç èìáí éâéâêà×ØÝá à áÝéëëØ ÚØâÜ ØÛë ôÛ à ×Ýá à áôäÞßéâêõâáãä
z
Øö÷ÛíÙá ÚØ øØáâßöùâ Ý ØÙØâ ÝØâ àîáíÙã ØàöàØßàóÜç õã ã Ýáàá éâ à×Ø î ïî î
ÙÚÛêÚáí åáß ÚØá Ý áß â ÞíôØÚú à×Þß ÝØë éâéâê à×Ø êÚÛ ÞÙß éâ àÛ â Þí ôØÚß ó êÚÛ ÞÙ ñ ëÛ Ú à ×Ø ØìÙØÚéíØâàáã Üã áß ß áâ Ý êÚÛ ÞÙ û ëÛ Úà ×ØÜÛâ à ÚÛãÜã áß ß ó
Ýç üØà ØÚí éâéâêà × Øý òþ÷ÛâëéÝØâÜ Øùâ àØÚðáãÛëà×ØüéëëØÚØâÜ Øó
Øç Ö×Ø ëéÚß à Û ÞàÙÞà ß×ÛåØÝ à ×Ø ÿÚÛ ÞÙ îàá àéß àéÜß å ×éÜ × Þß ØÝ àÛ éâ à ØÚÙÚØà íØáâß ÜÛ ÚØáâ Ýßàáâ ÝáÚÝÝØðéáàéÛâÛëØá Ü×êÚÛ ÞÙÛÚÜã áßß ó
ëç Ö×Ø ßØÜÛâ Ý Û Þà ÙÞà ß ×ÛåØÝ ùâ Ý ØÙØâ ÝØâ à îáíÙã Øß ÖØß à àÛ éâ àØ ÚÙÚØà à×Ø ðáã ÞØÛëàúÝØêÚØØÛëëÚØØ ÝÛí Ýëáâ Ýßéêâéë éÜ áâ àã ØðØã ÙÚÛôáôéãéàéØß ûö àáéã ØÝ Ûë à× Ø Ýáàáç ä ÜÛíÙá Úéâê à ×Ø ßé êâéëéÜ á â à ã ØðØã ÙÚÛôáôéãéàéØß
îéêúà×ØÝ ØÜéßéÛâÛë×äÙÛ à×ØßéßÜáâôØàáØâ æ
ùëÙ ÚÛôáôéãéàéØß îéêòþúà×Ø× äÙÛ à×ØßéßéßáÜÜ Ø ÙàØÝáâ Ýà×Ø ÚØß ÞãàÛëà ×ØÚØßØá ÚÜ ×éßßéêâéë éÜ áâ à
ùëÙÚÛôáôéãéàéØß îéê òþúà×Ø × äÙÛ à× Øßéß éßÚØØÜà ØÝáâ Ý à ×Ø ÚØß ÞãàÛëà ×ØÚØßØá ÚÜ ×éßâÛ àßéêâéëéÜáâ àç
(22)
28
! " # $ % #&
.
'()*+ ,-,./ 0 1.234/5 52617 8 9: ; 1;
< =
!< #
.
'()(>*+ ,-,./ 0 123? 81,6@7 ,A
< $ B #
9
C D
,
2011
E FG H3
I.
J = =$ #
.
K $
,
2006
EL
(
M<EG).
,
# # = #
,
.
= =
,
## = ! $ =
,
# !E =# # $!< N
;
= =& #
.
B =,
$ $ = # !
'()()*+ ,-,./ 0 123O2P/Q,8 1;172 8
<
(23)
30
RSTUVW X RTS U Y Z Y Y [\T
11.5.
] ^\ T\_VW ` S R abc da e Xf g\ _\\f h f `^\ `XgW\ g \WSi:
Table 2. The ANOVA Analysis of the Homogenity Analysis
jk lmno
plq rst u vt wlq bxyax
z { |}~
.
|} ~
.
95%
~ | ~ |~ |} { |}~ { ~ {} | ~ | ~
1
28
84.36
4.778
.903
82.50
86.21
74
90
2
28
83.93
4.127
.780
82.33
85.53
74
90
3
29
85.59
3.397
.631
84.29
86.88
80
90
4
29
83.86
6.781
1.259
81.28
86.44
56
90
5
29
88.83
4.124
.766
87.26
90.40
80
96
6
29
85.38
5.858
1.088
83.15
87.61
72
96
}
172
85.34
5.200
.397
84.55
86.12
56
96
lq v l kltvo nstnkrlq bxyax
y\[ \f\Y `X`h _ `h e R
1
R2
Yh .
1.453
5
166
.208
j bxyax
¡¢ £¤¥
¡¦¢ §¨©ª «¥ ¬©§¡¦¢ §¨© ® ¡¯°
.
±©²³©©´¨ ¤¢µª
(
¶¤ £·¯© «)
500.708
5
100.142
4.031
.002
¸¯©§¨¹©¨£ º³©¯°»²» © «
133.170
1
133.170
5.361
.022
¼©¯°»²» © «133.059
1
133.059
5.356
.022
½© ¾¯§²¯¤367.649
4
91.912
3.700
.007
¼¯²»¯´¨ ¤¢µª
4123.734
166
24.842
(24)
32
À
À
À
À
À
0.42
ÁÂÃÄÅ ÆÇ È É
ÊÇÄË ÌÍÎÌË ÌÃÏÐÂÄÑÑ Ì ÐÌÄÒÃ
Ó Ô ÊÃÕÄà ÂÃÍËÒÖ×ÎÄÇÅÂÑÂØ ØÌÃÄ×ÅÍÒØÄÙÄÒÌÃÄ× Å Ó ÊÃÕÄà ÂÃÍËÂÑÂØØÌÃÄ× Å
Ô ÊÃÕÄà ÂÃÍËÒÖ×ÎÄÇÂÑÄ ÙÄÒÌÃÄ×Å Á ÊÃÕÄÒÖ×ÎÄÇÂÑÇÄÅÚÂÒØ ÄÒÃÅ
(
ÛÖØÌÜÂÒÂÝÞßßàÆ216)
áÂÂÎÃÍ ÌÒÃÕÄÙÍËÖÄÂÑÇ
11,
ÃÕÄÄÅ ÃÌ×ÍÃÌÂÒÖÅÄØÛÚÄÍ Ç×ÍÒ-
âÇÂãÒÑÂÇ×ÖË ÍÍÅ ÚÇÄÅ ÄÒÃÄØÎÄËÂã:
Ç
11
=
=
=
(25)
34
Table 3. Difficulty Index of Test Items
äåæçè éêçëæì
é ë äéíæî ïìäåæìäð
1
28
28
1
æðè ñ2
28
19
0.68
òðäì3
28
26
0.93
æðè ñ4
28
28
1
æðè ñ5
28
27
0.96
æðè ñ6
28
20
0.71
æðè ñ7
28
27
0.96
æðè ñ8
28
4
0.14
íäò òäïêóå9
28
27
0.96
æðè ñ10
28
0
0
íäò òäïêóå11
28
11
0.39
òðäì12
28
20
0.71
æðè ñ13
28
28
1
æðè ñ14
28
7
0.25
íäò òäïêóå15
28
25
0.89
æðè ñ16
28
9
0.32
òðäì17
28
20
0.71
æðè ñ18
28
27
0.96
æðè ñ19
28
11
0.39
òðäì20
28
28
1
æðè ñ21
28
17
0.61
òðäì22
28
28
1
æðè ñ23
28
26
0.93
æðè ñ24
28
24
0.86
æðè ñ25
28
20
0.71
æðè ñ26
28
28
1
æðè ñ27
28
23
0.82
æðè ñ28
28
22
0.78
æðè ñ29
28
24
0.86
æðè ñ(26)
36
ôõö÷ø ùúùûü ý þÿ ÿûþ÷ùû þ
20
2011
21
2011.
:
Table 4. Listening Score of Post Test
.
!"# $ %&' ! ( ) $ !&'! (1
72
80
2
76
50
3
74
70
4
74
60
5
72
56
6
80
80
7
72
72
8
72
84
9
64
64
10
76
56
11
80
68
12
78
72
13
65
64
14
68
76
15
76
68
16
68
64
17
78
68
18
80
52
19
68
56
20
74
75
21
72
60
22
76
60
23
80
84
24
60
64
25
68
56
26
68
72
27
60
72
28
64
64
29
68
*( #
2083
1872
(27)
38
+,-./ 0
123
:
45.1.67..,82.9:-; <.3 88.=-; <.>.// ?::
?.:>@=,7.,8-5.3A B.7;C.>-:9D7,EB ?F:
?.:>@=,7.,8-5.G,>-7,9D7,EBH7,C -5. =:9 =E9 :-;,> :F,<.
,
;- I :/ 8,E>J -5 :- -5. J.67.. ,8 7.9:-; <. .88.=-;<.>./ / ,8 -5. E/ . ,8 /9,I F.:- 3> 69;/5 /,>6/ ,> 9 ;/-.>; > 6 =,CB7.5.>/;,> :=5;.<. C.>- I:/7.72%.
K- C.:>- -5 :- -5. J.67.. ,8 7.9:-; <. .88.=-;<.>./ / ,8 -5. E/ .,8/9,IF.:-3> 69;/5/,>6/;>-.: =5;>69 ;/-.>; > 6=,CB7.5.>/;,>:BB9 ;.J- ,-5. . A B.7;C.>-:967,EBI:/7.72%
C,7..88.=-;<.-5 :>-.:=5.7 L/<,;=.7.=,7J.7:/-5. C.J;:;>-5.=,>-7,967,EBMK-;>J;=:-.J-5 :--5./ - EJ.>-/; >-5.. A B.7;C.>-:967,EB 5 :JF. --.7/=,7.-5 :>-5,/./- EJ.>-/; >-5.=,>-7,967,EBMNOPQRS TUS SRVW
45;/ 7./ .:7=5 I :/ ;>-.>J.J - , X>,I I 5. -5.7 ,7 >,- -5.7. I:/ : /;6>; 8;=:>-.88.=-,8/9,IF.:-3> 69;/5/,>6/,>-5..;65-5 Y.:7/ - EJ.>-/L9;/ -.>;>6 =,CB7.5.>/;,> : =5;.<.C.>-
.
45;/ 7./ .:7 =5 / -:7- .J I;-5 =,>JE=-;>6 :> ; >-.7<;.I I;-5 -5. 3>69;/5 -.:=5.7.
Z:/ .J ,> -5. ; >-.7 <;.I I ;-5 -5. 3>69 ;/5 -.:=5.7 ;- I:/ X>,I>-5 :- /5.7 :7.9Y6 : <.9;/-.>;>6 B7 :=-; =.-,-5./-EJ.>-/M[9-5,E65-5./=5,,9 5 :J :97.:JY 5 :J 6,,J 8:=;9 ;-;./\ FE- /-;9 9 /5. 7 :7.9Y E/ .J ;-.
K- I:/ F.= :E/. /5. -5,E65- -5 :- F 7;> 6; >6 -5. C - , ?E9-;C.J;: 7,,C I :/ I :/5;> 6 -;C..
],I.<.7,
I5.>/5.-:E65-9;/ -.>;>6,
/5./B,X.,7:99Y-,-5./-EJ.>-/ M@,-5.3>69;/5-.:=5.7 >.<.7E/ .J/9,IF.:-3 > 69;/5/,>6/; >
-.:=5;> 69 ;/-.>; >6
.
Z:/ .J ,> -5. 7./E9- ,8 J,=EC.>-:-;,> ,8 @?^+
3
_. CF.7,
;- I:/ 8,E>J -5 :--5.7.:7./.<.> =9 :/ / ./ ,8.; 65-5 Y.:7 > :C.9Y`KKK[,
`KKKZ,
`KKKG,
`KKK1,
`KKK3\ `KKK
H :>J
`KKK D
.
45. 7./.:7 =5.7 J; J>,- E/ . `KKK D F.=:E/ . -5 ;/ =9 :// I :/ : ==.9.7 :-;,> =9 :/ /M H,7- E> :-.9Y
,
-5.7. ;/ ,>9Y ,>. -.: =5.7 -.:=5; > 6 ;> `KKK [ E>-; 9 `KKKH ,8@?^+3
_. CF.7.
@,;-I :/ .:/;.7 8,7 -5.7./ .:7 =5.7 - , =5, ,/ .-5. . A B.7;C.>-:9:>J=,>-7,9=9 :/ /F.= :E/.-5.Y:7.-:E65-FY-5./:C.-.:=5.7.
1E7;>6 6;<;>6 -5. -7.:-C.>- -, -5. / - EJ.>-/\ -5. 7./ .:7=5.7 -:E65-9;/-.>;>6- ,-5./ - EJ.>-/F,-5;>.A B.7;C.>-:9:>J=,>-7,967,EBM45.. A B.7;C.>-:9
(28)
40
abcdef df g h eijkljmnjl e i bophi mf lejgf gh eo lo k j l o ghl q rl b jl p me
,
e ijfb mf l ejgf gh do kabjijgl f o gcdifjnjkjgedop mscml otjfkabo n jsqubo k e ijcto n j sfldpl lf o gvf e liop ms tj do gdmpsjs eic e eijbjl p me ow eif l bjljcbdi lioxjs eic e e i j c aamfdcefo g ow lmox tjc e yghmfli lo ghl cwwjde js e ij lepsjgelz mf l e jgf gh do ka bjijgl f o g cdifjn jk jge
.
{ij lec eflefdcm ncmpj abonjs e ice eijbj xcl c l fhgf wfdc ge jww j de ow plfgh l mox tjce yghmfli lo ghl kc ej bfc m o g e ij |jcbjfhie ilepsjgel zmfl e jgf ghdo kabjijgl f o gcdifjnjk jgec e} ~ 3
jktjb.
(29)
,
,
.
¡ ¢£ ¤ ¥¢¦
§ ¨ ¨ ¨ © ©
,
© ª« ¨ ,
.
¬ ¢ ®¯ ¦ °®± ®
§ ² ³ ¨ ¨ ³ ³
,
,
¨ .
(30)
44
´µ
nch, larry
¶·2008.
¸¹ º»¼ ½¾¿ÀÁÂà ľ»¼¹t
¾ ÅÆ ¿Ã ¾ÇÈ É Â»¼ À¼ È É ºst
È» º»¼Ê¾Æ ¿Ã ÈËÈ»¹º¾» Ä̺ÁÁ¹Í Î
vailable
at
http://esl4free.blogspot.com/2008/02/can-music-improve-your-students.html
. [
Ïovember, 24th 2010]
¶Ð
ley,
Î
lan. 1987.
½¾È
try
Â»Ñ Ä¾»¼ ¹ Ò Ó ÓÈÔt
ºv
È É Â»¼ À¼ È-
Á ÈÂû º»¼ ÕÔt
º
v
ºt
ºÈs
Í Önteractive
´anguage
×Øaching.
Ùambridge:
Ùambridge
Úniversity
Ûress.
Ü
lson,
Ýristian
Þavid. 1996.
ßËÈ Ò ÓÓÈÔts
¾Ó àÀ¹ ºÔ ¾»t
ËÈàº»Ñ á Èy
¾»Ñ Ä ¾¾t
˺»¼t
ËÈ Ä Ç¼ È á ȹâ
.
Îvailable
at
http://www.reversespins.com/effectsofmusic.html
. [
Ïovember, 24th 2010]
Û
aulston,
Ùhristina
ãratt
ä ãruder,
¶Ðrry
Ïewton. 1976.
ß ÈÂÔ˺»¼ Ò»¼ Áº¹Ë ¹ ÄÈÔ¾»Ñ É Â»¼ À¼ È:
ß ÈÔË» ºåÀÈs
Â»Ñ ½Ã ¾ÔÈÑÀÃÈ¹Í Ùambridge:
æinthrop
Ûublisher,
ÖÏÙ.
Û
urwanto,
ç·Î.
ä èulistyani,
Þ.
é. 2007.
àÈt
¾ÑÈ ½È» ÈÁ ºt
ºÂ» êÀ»âºt
ÂâºÓ ¸»âÀÌ ÕÑÆ º» ºst
ÃÂâºÓ ½ÀëÁºÌ Ñ» ๠ÁÂË-
๠ÁÂË Ä¾¹ºÂ ÁÍ ìogyakarta:
íaya
¶Ødia.
è
aukah,
Îli et al. 1997.
ÒÇ ÁÀ¹º î¹ º Á ½È»¼ÂïÂû áÂ˹  Ż¼¼Ã ºs
.
ðÐkarta:
Úniversitas
× Ørbuka
è
udijono,
Înas. 1996.
½È»¼Â»âÂÃÒÇ ÁÀ¹º½È»ÑºÑºÌ».
ðakarta:
Û ×éaja
írafindo
Ûersada
è
udjana,
Ïana. 1990.
½ È» º Á ºÂ» î¹ º Á ½Ã¾¹ Ès
á ÈÁ ïÂà àÈ»¼Â ïÂÃ.
ãandung:
Û × éemeja
éosdakarya
æ
oodall,
´ ä ñiembroski. 2004.
½Ã ¾Æ ¾âº»¼ Áºt
ÈÃ ÂÔy t
ËþÀ¼Ë Æ À¹ ºÔ, [online]
available:
http://www.songsforteaching.com
. [
ðuly, 19th 2011]
www.staffaband.com
ì
oo,
Ösaiah
æon
òo. 2002.
ó¾ÔÀ¹ ÈÑ Éºst
È» º»¼w
ºt
Ë Ä¾»¼¹Í ×ôØ Önternet
× çè´ ðournal.
Î
vailable
at
http://iteslj.org/
×Ø
chniques/
ìoo-è
ongs.html
.
(31)
(32)
÷ø ø ùú û üýþ ÿ ø øú þ üüü ù û ! ÷ "ÿ#
$%
&' $ $ $ $
$ !$ $
% û
&'& $ $ $ $
( $ $ $
$ !$ '
ü$
' )$ * $ $ $ '
&' )$ * $ $
$ '
÷ !
ù þ þ þ
ú ' ÷ ! ú' ÷!
'
+, -. /.0
'1 $
'&ü$
' 2 !
ÿ3 '
+,-. / .0
'1 $
'&ü$
' 2 !
ÿ3
&'
45/ .6 78/9/8/ -: ;<=>?- @A/:8-. /.0
÷ $$ B
#3
&'
45/.678/9/8/-: ;<=>?- @A /:8-. / . 0
÷ $$B
(33)
CD D EF G HIJ KL
MNOPQR NSTU V WSX QQN YEZ [\]^_ \`aJbcdd e
fgfhi ij klmknkojpqhrs t giu gt vl
Cwb^ `x^`yzbcd{| z}{^ a\b^y{a Y~\cx ~^ ae[a{\d | \]c ca|`^y{a
D\|[b\] ``^`yz|]|\]
`|a `|}^`yY}{\a{\] }\c a{\] ea{\]\x\cx|]c b^ \
{\c_ \}^a{a{\^]Ya{c `d ac `d ec `xa{\^][bc`\d }^a{]ccy^ `yYzc ^]z^\]ezbc_\d
c `x`|a{^ `y] \_ c^ `d
dac|^\Y]^d ^ `y]c ^d^ `ye[^`a{\d _|{c \
Y{|]d e \}^ bb`|ay|x|}` ^ `
a{\`^y{a}^ a{|a c
z^y{a |c `Yw] `w|] `e[|]_|d \d c `x|]Y{|[\d {|_ \dec`x|]d{||bd
a |]
d[^] ^a }^ bb
`\ \] x^\ }\}^ bb`|ay|x|}`
H` c c
a|`^y{a
|_ \`c `x{^bx]\`Yc b^ \cb ^ \e
]x\] \xc`x_ cdd c]\x`^y{aY| \] cza \]e`^y{a {^b \a{\d|cb b\xb \cx\]d| z|`a]^ \dYczc]czzc ^ ]e
G\wc a\x|`}{|d}]|`y|]] ^y{a
aa{\^][|}\]b \d dY} |]xd}|] bxde}\]\^`c ^ ` c `xa{\w|_wdYz\\b z\bbex|}`b ^ \c^x]c ^`
(34)
¡¢ £ ¤ ¥ ¦§¨© ª§ ««¬ ®
¯°±²³´°µ¶ · ¸²³¶
¹º»¬©¼§ ½ º»ª» §¾ ¬ «» ©¿¨» ¨§À¿ ¾Á« « §¾ ¼§Âú¬Ä » ©º¬© ŧ¼» ¾ª§¼ Ƭ » §¾ ÆÁ¨ ¬¨ Ç È§¼È ©º¬© ¦¾¬« «É¾§§ «® ǧÀ¨ ¬ «¼§ © »Ê»ªÃǬÃË ¹º » Ƭ » ¦«¿©É«»¬ Ç® Á½ ©º» Âà §Ê»ª ̬ «»©¿¨» Ǭà ¬© ¨¿Æº©Ë Ê»ªÃǬà ©º» ª¬»«¿ ŧ¼» À ¿©º ©º»¿ª ¦©º¬¨ÂÉ © ¬¨Â® ¬¨ Ç ½«¬¨» Ç»©ª§Ã¿¨Æ ¼§ ÍÁ»Î ¦º§¼ »Éº§½ »®Î ź§§ « ¬¨ Ç §¾¾ ¿Å» Àº¿«» ©º» ȧ¼È ¦ÈÁª¨É ȧ ª¨® »Ê»ªÃ©º¿¨ Æ ©º»Ã¾¬ « « ǧÀ¨ ©§Ë Ï Á¨ Ǫ»Ç §¾ Æ»¨»ª¬©¿§¨ §¾ ¬ «»©¿¨¿¬¨ ź¿«Çª»¨ «¿Ê» ¿¨ ¾Á« «Ã ¼¬ ¬Åª»Ç ¿©Á¬©¿§¨ ¨¿Æº© ¦§Ê»ªÉ ¬¾©»ª® ¨¿Æº© Ë ¹º»Ã ¨»Ê»ª ¨§À ¦À »¬©º»ªÉÀº »©º»ª® ¿¨ ©º» ¨»Ð© Ǭà ©º » à ¬ ª» ©¿«« ¬ «¿Ê» § ª Ç»¬ ÇË «¿¨» §¾ ¦È«§§ ÇÉ È§ « Ç® ©º¬© ¾«§À ¨»Ð© ©§ ª§¬Ç ¿ ¬ ¦Å§¼ ¼§¨ Éŧ¼¼Á¨»® ©º¿¨ Æ À » Ŭ¨ ¾ ¿¨ Ç ¿¨ ¬«»©¿¨»Ë¬ «»©¿¨¿¬¨ º¬ ©ª¿»Ç© § »¨ Ç ©º»¿ª ¦À§ ªÇÉÀ§ ª«Ç® ¬ ȧÁ© ÑÁ©¿Å»© § ©º» ÒË ÓÁ© ©¿« « ¿©¨»Ê»ªÅ§¼ » §Á©©º»ª»¬ « ¦§ «Á©¿§¨É½§ ««Á©¿§¨®Ë Ô©º»ª ¦Å§Á¨©ª¿»ÉŧÁ¨©«» ® »Ê»¨ Ŭ¨ ǧ ¨§©º¿¨ Æ ©§ ¼¬Â » ¿© È»©©»ªË Ò¨©¿« ¨§ÀΠçÁ Ŭ¨ ©¿«« ¦º»¬ ªÉº»¬ ªÇ® ©º»¿ª ¦ª¿¿¨ ÆÉ ª¬¿¿¨ Æ® Ū»¬¼ ¬© ©º» ¼ ¿Ç¨¿Æº© ËÕ§¼ »©º¿¨ Æ©º¬©À ¿««¨»Ê»ªÇ¿»¿©º»§¨ «Ã©º»¿ª¦½ ¿ª¿© É ½ª»¬ Ç®§¾«¿¾»Ë
(35)
Ö× × ØÙ Ú ÛÜÝ Þß
àáââãäåá æãâ ãçâçè äéèêëâãçì í îïïðñòó áôôõèêëâ ãçöè÷ê øå áùèêéâ ÷ó ó
(
ú ûüýñ ãçäç õâ ãèâþå÷ùçâãä åá æãâãçéÿå øãèçàèù â åì Ýãåä áéõ
÷êâãçê ÷æãâ÷ âãåáâèô÷æãâ ç÷óóê åâæåë åê
(36)
55
:
3
:
!/1
" #:
$
:
% &'(%)
:
'*%) %: 1
+40
",- '
:
2.
$ , $ (" , ',$ ,"$, '*,"""$ $ , $" $
- '
:
2.2
' $ & ,' , ', $ ,$"
,
, ""$ $ , $" $ , $"$, '*, ".
, .
1.
/, )' ( & ( ' ) ",0
2.
/, (1 , $'0'(% *.
)'
0 * % 0 * %
1.
23 45 6571.1
8 ",1.2
,"1.3
9 # *4
:1.
2345 6 57
1.1
8 ",1.2
,"1.3
9# *4
:2.
;<6 5= >?6@6?6 4A BCDEF4 GH6A?45 657
1 ",(
10
:2.
;<65=>?6@6?64A BCDEF4 GH 6A?45 6 5 7
$ ", ,I"(37)
JK K LM N OPN
57
QRSTUV RWXY Z [W\ UUR
(
L]^_`ab _cd efghh)
ij k klm nopq rs pr ntuvlm nruvow uxm npyt z
{j r mjvo|v}~lpynw uv n
dg`
2
P Ob ah ac 2
Pcghdg`
.
[
e`h]
Obah ac cgh dg `
.
ff _` _g` _.
Obah a c cg
1.
.
f f g da db_g ch
.
JcObah a c cd _
2.
dg dOh _ _.
Ob ah ac cd _3.
`_g ff` _gb.
JcOb
ah ac cdb ``
4.
c__`b_h JcOb
ah ac cd _d _`d ach _ c__`
c _
.
[
_`h_:]
Oc __`
5.
Oh__ d _dab _ _cf_.
g`g g`b
6.
.
g`g g`bb _.
hdd acgf fd _
7.
dg d _h ^_cd.
Ohdg c df_d`bb_,
_ _`_b _g cd.
(38)
59
¡¢£¤¥ ¡¦§¨ © ª¦« ¤¤¡
(
¬®¯ ° ±¬ ±²³ ³)
´µ ¶ ¶·¸ ¹º»¼ ½¾ »½ ¹¿ÀÁ·¸ ¹·¹Â·Ã Àĸ ¹»Å ¿Æ
ÇÈ É Ê
ËÌ°ÍγÏγ̰аѲҳӲ®Ð̰аѲҳ²°ÑÌ°ÍγÏÔÕÖ××××××××××××× Î³ ³ÒѯÏή Ø ¯Ï²¯ Ò¯ÎÙ²¯Ñ³ ̳ ¯ ¯°Ú ϲ °ÐÑ° ¯ Øѯ ί
.
Û ÒÑ ÜÑ Ü±Ñ ØÎÙÑ ³ÎÒαβ ° ÒѲ®Î® Ø ²Ò®Ø ÝÖ×××× ×××××××××××,
ÍÎ³Ï ²®Ð °Ñ³ ±Ì¯Î®Ô ÞÎ³Ï Î³ ß°® à°Ò аѲҲ®ÐßÑáÒѰѳ ±Ì¯Î®Í ÏÑ®ÍѰѲ ±±Ú¯ °Ú¯Ò²âÑÌ°ÍγÏѳßÑáÒѰѲ±.
ÞÑ ³Ñ®Ð Ì° ÍÎ³Ï Í ÏÑ® ÍÑ ã Ö ×××××××××××× ××××× Ì° ßΰ¯ÏÐ²Ú Ü²°¯Ú ή ¯ÏÑ ³Ñá¯Î®àäÒ²âѲÍγÏå¯Ï²¯ÍÑÐÍÏÑ®Í Ñß±ÍÌܯÏÑᲮбѳÔæ®à°¯Ì®²¯Ñ± Ú,
®¯² ± ± àÌ° ÍγÏѳ Íα±ßѰѲ± ßÑá²Ì³Ñ ÏÍϲ °ÐÍѯ°Ú¯ÏÑ ÐÑáγή γ߲á⯠¯ÏÑ çÐÔ èÖ ××××××××× ×××××× áÒÒ® ± Ú Ï²ÙÑ ³ Ò²®Ú ÍγÏѳ ¯Ï²¯ Ò¯ÎÙ²¯Ñ ¯ÏÑ Ò ¯ áÒÑ ¯ ¯ÏÑ Ø°Ñ²¯Ñ° ±ÎàÑ.
³¯ÌÐÑ®¯³ ÍÎ³Ï ¯ Øѯ ² ØÐ ³ á °Ñ ¯ áÒÑ ¯ ¯ÏÑ ®Ñé ¯ Ø°²ÐÑ,
² áÌÜ±Ñ ¯Ï²¯ ÍÎ³Ï ¯ êÖ ×××××××××××× Ò²°°ÎÑ Ð ³® ²®Ð ϲ ³ ² ®Ñ Íë Ö×××××××××××××× ×,
²
ರÒÑ°¯Ï²¯² ±Í²Ú³Í²Î¯à ° ìÖ××××××××××××íѯ á² °Ñ ³ÒÑ à ÒÒÑ®¯ ³ ¯Ï²¯ ²°Ñ ÍγÏÑ Ð áÒ Ò® ±Ú ßÚ ¯Ï ³Ñ ÜÑ Ü±Ñ
.
îÏÌØÏÓ ÜÑ Ü±Ñ Ï²ÙÑ ¯ÏÑΰ Í® ÍγÏѳ ² ®Ð Ò²âÑ ïÖ ×××××××××× ××× ßÑáÒÑ Ò °Ñ áÒÜѯίÎÙÑ,
ß̯³¯Î± ±ÍγϳÏ̱ÐßѰѲáÏÑ ÐÍίÏϮѳ¯Í²Ú³Ô(39)
ðñ ñ òó ô õöô
61
õ÷øùú
8.
ûü ýþÿ ÿú,
ÿúù øÿ ÿ(
ÿ-
ÿ-
ÿ-
ÿ-
)
[
úÿ÷] 2
öõ úú ø ø ú ú
9.
ú.
õ úú ø ø ú ÿ øÿú øøÿú øùú.
ð÷úøùúú øÿ10.
û,
ÿù.
ùú ÷ú úø ÿúøùú
.
ùú øùúÿ÷úú.
[
ù ÿ]
! ÿ ÷ øùú øÿ""
.
# ýþ ÷ øÿÿ$ ! ÿ÷ÿ÷øùú ÿ ÿ÷,
ÿ÷ÿ ÿ$[
ú:]
, 12.
% &û 'þú.
(ú ø ú)õ ÿ.
(ú ø úø ÿúøùú, 13.
* & þ ü+, -.óúú
.
/ùúÿú úùú
14.
þ þ ý ú ÿ / úúø15.
0ü#+ ÿ ù ÷ÿ÷ ø.
(40)
12 2 34 5 673 89
: ;<=>?@ @ A;2 BC ;
D EFAAB GDH24?I?J<9K?L M?J N BC@ @ OD?L?@ = ?J
G P 666OQ D R MS?E= G3;IB <@F DT <B B G><@ = ?;<;I U VW?AXU?Y=
G
5 ?@E J<W=<Z?U?Y= U<L?1BB AEC= <A; G[\]^L< ;R= ?@
D= C;_CJ` ALW?=?;@ <G
[aH?LCFCL<LCT ;C _C BCL=?T@ B<@ C ;XR;I@< A;CB _C ;LA;AB AI W?;_?T@ ?_ ?JFC ;C M?JM?;=RT_?@E J<W=<Z?_C;J?EAR;=R;=RTM?J< ;= ?JC T@ <_?;IC ;B <;ITR;IC ;@?T <= CJ
` ALW?= ?;@<5C@ CJG
[a[ H?J?@WA; LCT ;C VC ;I =?J_CWC= _C B CL LA;ABAI W?;_ ?T @ ?_ ?JFC ;C @ ?ECJC CTR JC= b BC ;E?J _C ; M?J=?J<LC R;=RT M?J<;= ?JCT@ < _?;IC; B <;ITR;IC ; @ ?T <= CJ _C BCL = ?T@M?JM?;=RT_?@E J<W=<Z?_C ;J?EAR;=a
6;_<EC= AJ@G
Qa c<;_< ;I?YWB <E<=C ;_<LWB<E<=< ;XAJLC=<A;MVC ;@ d?J< ;IUOc?Y?JE<@?@a [a c<;_ <;I?YWB <E<=C ;_<LWB<E<=< ;XAJLC=<A;MVC ;@ d?J< ;IeR?@ = < A;@a
D=?WAXU?CE F<;I>?CJ;< ;I1E= <Z<=<?@G
3YW?J<L?;=N BC@ @ NA;=JABNBC@ @
4 Aa 1E= <Z<=<?@ U<L? 4 Aa 1E= <Z<=<?@ U<L? Qa
f g hiji k
lJ??= < ;I=F? @ =R_?;=@
6;=JA_RE=<A;
D= C=<;Im MS?E= <Z?@no Qa
f g hiji k
lJ??= < ;I=F?@=R_?;=@
6;=JA_RE=<A;
D= C=<;Im MS?E= <Z?@no
[a pqjir stjujtj hv wxyz{ h|}jv thiji k
DFAd <;I@ =R_?;=@ @AL?W<E=R J?@AX=F?Qno
[a pqjir stjujtj hv wxyz{ h|}jv thi ji k
1@T < ;I@=R_?;=@@ AL? B ?C _< ;IeR?@ =<A;@(41)
~
¡¢£
¤
¢ ¡ ¥
¦ ¥¢ ¡ § ¡¥¢ ¨ © ¡¥¢ ¨¢ ¡¨ ¡
~ ¥ ª « ¡¢ £ ¤ ~«« ¡ ¡¬¥¥ ¨ ¦ ¡
§ ¢« ®¨
© ¯¥¥ ¥«¥ ¨ ¡
(42)
°± ± ²³ ´ µ¶² ·¸
¹º»°¼½ ¾º ¿ À²Á º¿Ãĺ¼ÅÆÇ È½ ½É
µÊ ˿à ź Ì ÃÍ Åκ ½ÅÈźĺ¼Åý Ì¿ Ϻ ȼ Ð Ñ ÃÍ Åκ ½Å Èźĺ¼Å ý ÑÈǽ º ÒȽº Ð Ó¼ Åκ Íÿ½ÅźÁ Å»Ó Ïκȿ ÐÔ
ÕÊ Ìκ »È¿ ºÅÓ ÖºÅκ¿¼Ó¾ÊÑ
×Ê ³ÓÓ¼ºÅºÇ ǽÎÃľλ½ÎºÎȽÅÓÖÓÊÑ ØÊ Ìκ½Ã¼ Öº¿ÈǾȻ½ÅÎü Ù½Ó ÍÅκÇÓ½ÅÇÓÚºÊ Ì ÛÊ Ìκ½Ã¼ Öº¿Ã½ÍȿȾȻͿ ÓÄÎýÇÓںǻÊÌ ÜÊ Ìκ½Ã¼ Öº¿¼ºÚ º¿Äý ½ º½ÅκÖÿÇÊÑ
µµÊ °¼½ ¾º¿ÅÎºÝ Ïº½Å ÃÓ¼½ÒȽº ÐÓ¼Åκ½ºÞÓ¼ нӼֻÓÏκȿ ÐÔ
ÕÊ °ÞÞÓ¿ÐÃ¼Ö ÅÓ Åκ ½Ã¼ Öº ¿ßÎÓ¾ ý Åκ ¾ Ó¿ÇÐ ÅÎÈÅ ÍÏÇÇ Ó Í ÇÓÚºà Ì Îº¾Ó¿ÇÐ ÞȼҺÄÏÞ ÎÒ ¿ÃÖÎź¿ÅÎȼҺÍÓ¿ºÊ
×Ê Ë ÎÈÅ ÐÓº½ Åκ½Ã¼ Öº¿ÍººÇ àÌ Îº½Ã¼ Öº¿ ͺ ºÇ½ ÅÎÈÅÅκ¾Ó¿ÇоÃÇÇÒºÄÓ¿ º ÒºÈÏÅ ÃÍÏǾÃÅÎÓ ÏÅȼ »ÚÃÓǺ¼ÞºÊ
ØÊ Ë Î »ÞȼáÅÇÓÚºÐúàâºÞÈϽ ºÇÓںý½Å¿Ó¼Ö
ÛÊ ãÓ¾ ¾ÃÇ Ç Åκ ¾Ó ¿ÇÐ Ó¼Þº ¾º ÒºÇ ÃºÚºà Ìκ ¾ Ó¿ÇÐ ¾ÃÇÇ ½ Îüº ÈÖÈü ü Ö¿ÈÞºÊ
ÜÊ Ë ÎÈÅýÅκ½Ó¼ ÖźÇÇϽÈÒÓ ÏÅ àÌκ½Ó¼ ÖźÇǽϽÈÒÓ ÏÅÅκ¾ Ó¿ÇÐÅÎÈÅý ֺŠÅÃ¼Ö ¾Ó¿½ º ȼ о º Ƚ ÎÏÄȼ Ç ÃÚü Ö ½ ÎÓ ÏÇÐ ÄÈٺà ŠÈÒºÅź¿ ÂÇÈÞº ÅÓ Ç ÃÚºÊ
(43)
äå å æç è éêæ ëì
í äåæ î ïðéåí ñæò óôõö÷ ôøùïú ûü üý
þÿ
äøùôõûûüø ôé÷ü ùöúúûú úûúøô úùö ü ôõôøùôõ ô öù
÷ ô øôôõüûö ôî ÷ ôøôùôú ú÷ ô
èöûôù äøúôûô÷õúüú
æ ôõûéü öùûøûü÷üôú öú ôüú ö óûû î ÷ôùö øöü óôõüöø÷ô ûõûøüûü
í ûùûõôøùûúøô!õéû÷ôõôöù í õô ûõûûéû÷ôõôùüù û
ûõ ôøùûúø ôéû÷ôõôö ù í ôõ ô ûõûóûõùõôûú ûüö ø÷ôûõ ù
ûõ ôøùûúø ô
äúúûúøô"
#ü ùùôùôõøöùéùùéô ûõõ äü ö ø÷ôù÷ ôäøúöø÷ûõ÷ü é
ûø
ô ûõõó õûôõüõ õôøüé
öúú ôûõ $ù öõ ü ùéøô ôõûøî õ ôôõ ûøôö ø
æ ôõûé ü öù
ûø ûü
÷üôú öú ô üú ö ó
ûû í ôøü÷ ôùö øö üóôõüöø÷ôûõûøü ûü í ûùûõôøùûúøô!õéû÷ôõôöù
í õô ûõûûéû÷ôõôùü ùû !õûõ ôøùûúøôéû÷ôõô öù í ôõ ô ûõûóûõùõôûú ûüö ø÷ôûõ ù
(44)
%& & '( ) *+'
,-./01 2345206 7 89:;32 4< 13= 8>4?
@ABC BDEFGHFI BJKLMN CA BFCO PFKQ*RKMSO AFOJOJEHM TB %KQO AJEGHFI BIMN HQUBVNI AUC JWAO BCO AFKO MVM CCMS %KQJXLMNC BF H HLO CLPLMNDHHXJKQO ABCB DEKMK BBQO MICL
*KO AJEGHFIBLMNDHHX BBH POABC B DEKMANCOMCE M CCMS
@ABC BFC BS FLEOMWBOOABCB *XLMNIF C BBKMNWAXMCO A BH JTJKW YFR BFH JO O HBEGFIBPVFR BFUBO O BCGHF I B
Z[BF HOABSM C HQVFR BJOFUBOOBCGHFI B \MCLMNFKQXMCVBFKQOABBK O JC BANVFKCFIB
ZZ@ABCBFC BGBM GH BQLJKWJXLMNI FC BBKMNWAXM CO ABH JTJKW YFR BFUBO O BCGHFIBXMCLMNFKQXMCVB
*XLMNS FKOO MRKMSS ALPOABCB DEFHM TBOAFOIFKKM OH JB ]M TBJEEO CMKWPJOMK HLIF C BEXMC^MLXN HWJTJKWJXSBO C L _BEAFH HEBBJKOAJEUHJEE PSBIFKKMOX BBHXBFCM CQCBFQ
_BEO M GB`JEO JKWFKQE O FC OH JTJKW
@ABKJOX BBHEO AFOF HS FLEHM TBDEBKMNWAXMCNEWCM S JKW aMVFR BFUBOOBCS M CHQ PVFR BFUBOOBCSMC HQ
bcBGBFO Z
P ZZd
%KQOABQC BFVSBSBCBIMKI BJTBQ*KS JH HC BTBFHF^MLXN HXFI B %KQO ABSMC HQS BMK I BUBH JBTBQJKSJH HEAJK BFWF JKJKWCF I B @ABKS ALQMSBRBBGE OC FKWHJKWH JX BSMNKQOAJEBFCOAICN I JXL *O EEMN HO AMNWAJO DEGHFJKOME BBO AJES MCHQJEABF TBK H LUBeMQDEWHMS
(45)
fg g hi j klh mn
ohlop qr kg o sqtuv wt xqxyz z {
|} ~ ~
w uz z yu uv wxyvtuz w uz z t t wvyx yu wx y wuz w wz vu v uz t tv wuz xu
y wuz z wt yzyx wuz xu wuz z v yz v wuzz ww zxzxtz w z t yu w uz yz wzz pt v yxu yu xz vuu xz w uz z wuzz ww yxv yu xt y xv wt wuz yuvu yu t wuz z z wyx wuzz yuutv uxv u tu tu tuvyv z y wwzv t w uz z w uz z v xx qtux v z v wz t x t w w uz z v t tuvu v w uz z y u tv x yzv w uz zyuxtz t wv yu yu wyyx xpt wuz zuywv x vu wz t xtuxvo t wzvutwuz zzyutut wtv wuzowzzyxxyuvv xtz ztw uz wuzzyzx xyzyxx tv wwx yvtuz zz vyx vzt zv x vzvt w wuzy z t ywtwv yu t wwxyvtuz vv u tv yzt tuvkt vu tyw u yuxyvv wyw uyv xtwt wwx yvv y y ywv vt ywvtuwzyvtuvv vtyt v wtxzwtxyww
¡ ¡ ¢} ¡£ ¡ oyu yotwy¤yz
y
x y tyy¥ u
uyv wyx
yvo wywwtvzy w wtz¤zvvwt v wvwuw xzyuv wy wvv wwttzt v v wyvtu yxt zzytut wz vzty ttv wzqt xt wxuwyxwtuz v xtt z yw y w t tux y yu wyy wz y w
y
v t vy
y xtt yvoyu yot wy¤y yzv z uvwz vu u yv wyuv z yvyxx tu v t zvt wz ¦tt wt yz yu ywt wv yu zvyuy w tvxz y tu v ot wy¤y xyuz vt zvt wzwt ywtuv t wxit vztutv tz v txyw z vu yvtuzu t w t uvw wt v wtuyx yvyx v yyzzyw z xtyv u v xt xyuz v vyz v t wz yw v t wy ryuvyt y tt x z ¥
(46)
§¨ ¨ ©ª « ¬®
75
¨ ¬¯°±± © ²± ³± ´µ°¶± ²·¨ª©¸© ´¬
3
¹©·º©´ ²»¼½ ¾¿À Á© ÂÃÄÅ Æ Ç ¸ÈÉʾ/
² ¾Ë¾ÆÀ ¾È Á̬¬¬/1
²ÍÅ Ä Ä Á¯ÅÆÀ ¾ÂÅ à ±ÎϾРÑ
À ¾ÒÀ Á« ¾Æ¿ÈÅÏÀ ÅÓ¾± ¾ÒÀ ±Å˾§ÄÄпÉÀÅРÁ
60
ËŠ»À ¾Æ¬
.
«ÅÑѾȾÂÀ ÅÉÀ¾ÀǾÔÐ ÈÊÆÅ ÂÀ Ǿ¼Èɿ;ÀÀ ÇÉÀÀÈ» ÄÎÆÏ ÐÍ ¾Â¼ÉÆ ¾ÊÐÂÀ ǾÀ ¾ÒÀ ÎлǾÉÈÊÕ§Ö§´¬ª¨ §¯© ²±¬ª©
§
(
¼ ÄÅ ÂÊÅÂÃ/
¼ ľ¾ÊÅ Ã)
ÑÄÉÆ Ç ÀÇÉÀ ʾÆÀÈÐÎ¾Ê É ¼ ¾É»ÀÅÑ» Ä ÂÅ ÃÇÀ ÉÂÊ É ¼Ð˼ À ÇÉÀ(
¼»È³¼»ÈÂÀ)
¼»ÅÄÊÅ ÂÃÆ Æ»¿ Ç ÉÆ ËÐÆ×» ¾ÆØ(
ÇÐ˾Ƴ ÇÐϾÆ)
ÉÂÊ Æ¿ÇÐ ÐÄ Æ Ô Ç¾È¾ Å À ÑÉÄÄ ÊÐÔ Â Å Æ É ÊÉÅ ÄÎ ÆÅÀ »ÉÀ ÅРŸÉÙÉ
,
¨ÉľÆÀÅ Â ¾.
°Ó¾È50
Î¾É ÈÆ ¸ ÉÙÉ ¼ ¾¿Ð˾ Æ É ¿ ¾ÂÀÈÉÄ ¿ÐÂÑÄÅ ¿À ¼ ¾À Ô ¾¾Â¬ÆÈɾÄÅÉÂʨÉÄ ¾ÆÀ ÅÂÅÉÂÚÖ¾¿ÉÂÑÅ ÂÊÀÇÉÀ ÔÐË É ÉÂÊ¿ÇÅÄÊȾÂ(
È»Â³È»Ë Ï)
¾Ó¾È ÎÔ Ç ¾È¾ÀÐÆÉ Ñ¾À ǾÅÈÄÅѾ.
±Ç¾ÎÄÅӾŠÂÀ Ǿ¿Ð»ÂÀÈ ÎÔ ÅÀÇË»ÈÊ¾È¾Ê ÉÂÊ Ë ÉÆ ÆÉ¿È¾Ê À ÇÉÀ ¿Ð˾ ÂÅÃÇÀ
(
ÐÓ¾È/
ÉÑÀ ¾È)
ÂÅ ÃÇÀ.
ÖǾ ÊÉ ÎÆ ¿Ð˾,
ÀǾ ¬ÆÈɾÄÅÆ ÀÉÂÍ Æ ÉÂÊ ÏÄÉ ¾Æ ¿Ð˾ ¿È¾ÉÀ Å Ã(
ÑÉÅÈ Î/
ÑÅ¾È Î)
ÑÄÉ˾ÆÚ §ÄÀÇл ÃÇ ÀǾ ÆÅÀ»ÉÀ ÅРÅÆ ÆÐ ¼É ÊØ ¼»À ÆÀ Å Ä Ä À ǾȾ ÉȾÂÛÀ ÉÂÎ(
¿Ð»ÂÀ Ä ¾ÆƳ¿Ð»ÂÀÈžÆ)
ÔÉÂÀÀÐǾÄϨÉÄ ¾ÆÀ Å ¾.
¬¬
.
®Å Ä ÄÀǾ¼ ÄÉÂÍÆÏÉ¿ ¾ÆÅÂÀǾÀ ¾ÒÀ¼ ¾ÄÐÔ¼ÉÆ ¾ÊÐÂÔÇÉÀÎÐ»Ç ¾É ÈÊÕ «´© §·«È¾ÉË Å Æ É ¼Å à ʾÉÄ ÐÑ ÄÅѾ
.
¬À ÅÆ ÂÐÀ РÄÎ ÆÐ˾À ÇÅ Âà À ÇÉÀ ¿Ð˾Æ1.
ÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜ
Ð»È ÂÅ ¿ ¾ Æ Ä¾ ¾Ï ¼»À ÉÄÆÐ É
ÆÏÅÈÅÀ ÐÑ
ÄÅѾ
.
«È¾ÉËÆ Ô Ç¾Â¾Ó¾È ÀÇ¾Î É È¾ ¼É Ê ÊȾÉËÆ,
Ô¾ ¿É ÆÀ Å Ä Ä ÀÉÍ ¾ ÅÀ ÉÆ Ð»È Ë ÐÀ ÅÓÉÀ ÅÐÂÀÐËÉÍ ¾» ÆËÐȾ2.
ÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÚ²Ð˾À Å˾ÆÅ ÂлÈÊÉÅÄÎ ÄÅѾ,
ϾÐÏľ ÐÑÀ¾Â ÃÅÓ¾ É ¿ ¾ÈÀÉŠ ˾ÉÂÅÂà ¼ÉÆ ¾Ê РлÈ3.
ÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÚ § ÃÐÐÊ ÊȾÉË ÅÆ ÆÐ˾ÀÇÅÂà ÀÇÉÀ Ô ¾ ÔÉÅÀ ÑÐÈ(47)
ÝÞ Þ ßà á âãä
77
åâæ çßàâàäçßæ ç æèÞàß äßéâ
3
êßèëßé æ ìíî ïðñ:
ß òóôõ ö ÷ äøùúï/
æïûïöñ ïø:
üâââ/1
æ ýõ ô ô:
åõöñ ïòõò ó çþÿï
ñ ïñ
:
á ïöðøõÿñ õïç ïñ çõûïÝôô ðùñõ ò: 45
ûõ òìñ ïöâ
.
áõïøïòñ õùñïñ÷ï øúöõ òñ ÷ïíøùðýïññ ÷ùññøì ôþöÿ ý ïòíùö ïú òñ ÷ïñ ïñ þ ì÷ïùøúÝÝéâàÞ Ýåßæ çâà ß
Ý
1. (
í ôõ òúõòó/
í ô ïïúõ ò ó)
ôùö ÷ñ÷ùñúïöñø þïúùí ïùìñõì ôòõ ó÷ñ ùòú ù í ûí ñ÷ùñ2. (
íìøòíìøòñ)
íìõôúõ òóö öìð ÷ ùö û öì ïö3.
(
÷ ûïö ÷ ÿïö)
ùòú öð÷ ô ö ÷ïøï õ ñ ùôô ú ò õ ö ù úùõ ôþ öõñ ìùñ õ ò õòäùù
,
Þùôïöñõ ò ï.
ïø50
þïù øö äùù í ïð ûï ö ù ðïòñøùô ð òôõ ðñ í ïñ ïïòâöøùïôõùòúÞùô ïöñ õòõùòïðùòõ òúñ÷ùñ û ùò ùòúð÷õôúøïò4. (
øìòøìûÿ)
ïïø þ÷ ïøï ñ öù ï ñ ÷ïõø ôõï.
ç ÷ïþ ôõï õ ò ñ ÷ï ð ìòñøþõñ÷ ûìøúïøïú ùòúû ùö öùðøïú ñ ÷ùñ ð ûïòõó÷ñ ù ñïø òõó÷ñ
.
÷ïòúù þö ð ûï,
ñ÷ï âöøùïôõö5. (
ñ÷ùòý ö ñùòý ö)
ùòú ÿôùò ïö ð ûï ðøïùñõ ò ó6.
(
ùõø þ/
õ ïø þ)
ôùûïö Ýôñ÷ ìó÷ ñ ÷ï öõ ñìùñ õ ò õö ö íù ú íìñ öñõôô ñ ÷ïøïù øïòñùòþ
7. (
ð ìòñôïö ö ð ìòñøõ ïö)
ùòññ ÷ïôÿÞùôïöñõ ò ï.
ââ
.
õ ô ôñ÷ïí ôùòýöÿùð ïöõòñ÷ïñ ïñí ïô íùö ïú ò÷ùñ þì÷ ïù øú áéß Ýè
áøïùû õ ö ù íõ ó úïùô ôõï
.
âñ õ ö ò ñ ò ôþ ö ûïñ÷õòó ñ÷ùñ ð ûïö8.
ìø òõð ï öô ï ïÿ íìñ ùô öù öÿõøõ ñ
ôõï
.
áøïùûö ÷ïòïïø ñ ÷ïþ ù øï íù ú úøïùûö ï ðùò öñõôô ñùý ï õ ñ ùö ìø û ñ õùñ õ òñ ûùý ïì öû øï9.
æ ûïñ õûïöõ ò ìøúùõôþ ôõï,
ÿï ÿôï ñïò óõï ù ð ïøñùõ ò ûïùòõòó íùöïú ò ìø10.
Ý ó ú úøïùû õ ö ö ûïñ÷õòó ñ÷ùñ ï ùõñ ø(48)
79
! "#!"$ % &' ( ) (&) #*' ) +, -* # & *&.)! %. "!$ () & "# & , / )(&) . +" .! #! "$' ' .0( &' /,'1. *'2 (, / *' & "# '0(,, ' 3(*+* ! ) %& #,3" !' & #&! -' !) .&) !, " ! " & 4&
,
& *')!"*.
5 *+50
-*&+' &4& *0, / *' & 0*") +& 0, "% !0) *)3**" '+&* ! &"# & *' )!"!& "6 * 0& " %! "# )(&) 3, /& " & "# 0(! #+*" +. " *5 *+-3(*+*) ,' &% *) (*! + ! 5 *'.
(* - ! 5 *!")(*0, . ")+-3!)(/. +#*+&"#/&' ' &0+ * ) (&)0, / *'"!$() &%) *+"!$().
(*"#&-'0, /*,
) (*' +& * !')& "7'&"# 8 &"*'0, / * 0+*&)!"$ %! * + - % & /*'6 )(,.$( ) (* ' !) .&)! , " !' ' , & #2 .) ' )! ) (*+* & +* "9) &"-0,. ") +! *'3& ")),(* 8& *') ! "*.
:
+*& / !' & ! $ #*& , % !%*
.
) ! ' ",) , " - ' , /*) (!"$ )(&) 0, / *' )(+,. $( ,. +"!0*' **8.)& ', &'8!+! ) ,% !% *.
+ *&/'3( *"*5 *+ ) (* -&+*& # #+ *&/'23* 0& "' )! )&7*! )&',. +/,) !5&)! , ") ,/&7*.'/, +*0& +*%..
, /*)!/*'!",. +#&! ! % *,
3* ,%)*" $! 5 * & 0* +)&! " /*& "! "$ &' *# , " )(*!+ * !*%'6 $,, # # +*& / !' ' , /*) (!"$)(&)3*3&!)%, +*5 *+ -"! $().
(&)!'3(-3( *"3*& +*$,!"$),$,*#2 3*3(! '8*+ (&5 *& "!0*#+*& /;) ,,. +'* 5*', +8*,8 *3* ,5 *' ,/.0(6$,, # #+*& / 0&" * ,. + /,) !5&) !, " ) , +*&0( ,. + +! $()*+ %.) . +* & "# #, ' , /*)(! "$ )(&) 3* ) (!"7 3* 0& " 9).
+ *&/' 0& " ,8*" 8*,8 * 9' *-*' & "# /!"# )(&) ,.+ 3, + # ! ' *&.)! %..
* '(,. # ) +- & "# )+- ), /&7* ,. + #+*& /' 0, /* ) +. *.
(* /, +* , +* #+*& /'3*(&5*,
) (*/, + *'8! +!) ')(&)3*0&"$ *)% , +,. + !% *.
+ *& /! "$%, +&$,, # '0, +*,
&*))*+ ! %*,
&*& .)! %. 3*##!"$8& +)-,
&0(**+%. %& /! -, +& ". "+*&7& * % +!*"#'(!8 & + * ) (* *<&/8 *' ,% #+*& /' )(&) /&7*' ,. + ! %* %. ,% +&!",3,
(,8*' & "# ,5 *'6(49)
=> > ?@ A BCD
81
EFGGH I J FGGHKLMN EOG FPQKLEHRNQQGR ERK FSN LMTN UT MG
(
VW2),
X OTR OT HKYF G GLON ZH G YKH IJONHGK F GH N[GE OT LYHR K ZH GYQN SKQXK F[T LYE OK EX GHON ZQ MK\NTMMNT LY.
(1)
ÝÞ Þ ßà á âãä
77
åâæ çßàâàäçßæ ç
æèÞàß äßéâ
3
êßèëßé æ ìíî ïðñ:
ß òóôõ ö ÷ äøùúï/
æïûïöñ ïø:
üâââ/1
æ ýõ ô ô:
åõöñ ïòõò ó çþÿï
ñ ïñ
:
á ïöðøõÿñ õïç ïñ çõûïÝôô ðùñõ ò: 45
ûõ òìñ ïöâ
.
áõïøïòñ õùñïñ÷ï øúöõ òñ ÷ïíøùðýïññ ÷ùññøì ôþöÿ ý ïòíùö ïú òñ ÷ïñ ïñ þ ì÷ïùøúÝÝéâàÞ Ýåßæ çâà ß
Ý
1. (
í ôõ òúõòó/
í ô ïïúõ ò ó)
ôùö ÷ñ÷ùñúïöñø þïúùí ïùìñõì ôòõ ó÷ñ ùòú ù í ûí ñ÷ùñ2. (
íìøòíìøòñ)
íìõôúõ òóö öìð ÷ ùö û öì ïö3.
(
÷ ûïö ÷ ÿïö)
ùòú öð÷ ô ö ÷ïøï õ ñ ùôô ú ò õ ö ù úùõ ôþ öõñ ìùñ õ ò õòäùù
,
Þùôïöñõ ò ï.
ïø50
þïù øö äùù í ïð ûï ö ù ðïòñøùô ð òôõ ðñ í ïñ ïïòâöøùïôõùòúÞùô ïöñ õòõùòïðùòõ òúñ÷ùñ û ùò ùòúð÷õôúøïò4. (
øìòøìûÿ)
ïïø þ÷ ïøï ñ öù ï ñ ÷ïõø ôõï.
ç ÷ïþ ôõï õ ò ñ ÷ï ð ìòñøþõñ÷ ûìøúïøïú ùòúû ùö öùðøïú ñ ÷ùñ ð ûïòõó÷ñ ù ñïø òõó÷ñ
.
÷ïòúù þö ð ûï,
ñ÷ï âöøùïôõö5. (
ñ÷ùòý ö ñùòý ö)
ùòú ÿôùò ïö ð ûï ðøïùñõ ò ó6.
(
ùõø þ/
õ ïø þ)
ôùûïö Ýôñ÷ ìó÷ ñ ÷ï öõ ñìùñ õ ò õö ö íù ú íìñ öñõôô ñ ÷ïøïù øïòñùòþ
7. (
ð ìòñôïö ö ð ìòñøõ ïö)
ùòññ ÷ïôÿÞùôïöñõ ò ï.
ââ
.
õ ô ôñ÷ïí ôùòýöÿùð ïöõòñ÷ïñ ïñí ïô íùö ïú ò÷ùñ þì÷ ïù øú
áéß Ýè
áøïùû õ ö ù íõ ó úïùô ôõï
.
âñ õ ö ò ñ ò ôþ ö ûïñ÷õòó ñ÷ùñð ûïö
8.
ìø òõð ï öô ï ïÿ íìñ ùô öù öÿõøõ ñ
ôõï
.
áøïùûö ÷ïòïïø ñ ÷ïþ ù øï íù ú úøïùûö ï ðùò öñõôô ñùý ï õ ñ ùö ìøû ñ õùñ õ òñ ûùý ïì öû øï
9.
æ ûïñ õûïöõ ò ìøúùõôþ ôõï,
ÿï ÿôï ñïò óõï ù ð ïøñùõ ò ûïùòõòó íùöïú ò ìø10.
Ý ó ú úøïùû õ ö ö ûïñ÷õòó ñ÷ùñ ï ùõñ ø(2)
79
! "#!"$ % &' ( ) (&) #*' ) +, -* # & *&.)! %. "!$ () & "# & , / )(&) . +"
.! #! "$' ' .0( &' /,'1. *'2 (, / *' & "# '0(,, ' 3(*+* ! ) %& #,3" !' & #&!
-' !) .&) !, " ! " & 4&
,
& *')!"*.
5 *+50
-*&+' &4& *0, / *' & 0*") +& 0, "% !0) *)3**" '+&* ! &"# & *' )!"!& "6 * 0& " %! "# )(&) 3, /& " & "# 0(! #+*" +. "*5 *+-3(*+*) ,' &% *) (*! + ! 5 *'
.
(* - ! 5 *!")(*0, . ")+-3!)(/. +#*+&"#/&' ' &0+ * ) (&)0, / *'"!$() &%) *+"!$().
(*"#&-'0, /*,
) (*' +& * !')& "7'&"# 8 &"*'0, / * 0+*&)!"$ %! * + - % & /*'6 )(,.$( ) (* ' !) .&)! , " !' ' , & #2 .) ' )! ) (*+* & +* "9)&"-0,. ") +! *'3& ")),(* 8& *') ! "*
.
:
+*& / !' & ! $ #*& , % !%*
.
) ! ' ",) , " - ' , /*) (!"$ )(&) 0, / *' )(+,. $( ,. +"!0*' **8.)& ', &'8!+! ) ,% !% *.
+ *&/'3( *"*5 *+ ) (* -&+*& # #+ *&/'23* 0& "' )! )&7*! )&',. +/,) !5&)! , ") ,/&7*.'/, +*0& +*%..
, /*)!/*'!",. +#&! ! % *,
3* ,%)*" $! 5 * & 0* +)&! " /*& "! "$ &' *# , " )(*!+ * !*%'6 $,, # # +*& / !' ' , /*) (!"$)(&)3*3&!)%, +*5 *+ -"! $().
(&)!'3(-3( *"3*& +*$,!"$),$,*#2 3*3(! '8*+ (&5 *& "!0*#+*& /;) ,,. +'* 5*', +8*,8 *3* ,5 *' ,/.0(6$,, ##+*& / 0&" * ,. + /,) !5&) !, " ) , +*&0( ,. + +! $()*+ %.) . +* & "# #, ' , /*)(! "$ )(&)
3* ) (!"7 3* 0& " 9)
.
+ *&/' 0& " ,8*" 8*,8 * 9' *-*' & "# /!"# )(&) ,.+ 3, + # ! ' *&.)! %..
* '(,. # ) +- & "# )+- ), /&7* ,. + #+*& /' 0, /* ) +. *.
(* /, +* , +* #+*& /'3*(&5*,
) (*/, + *'8! +!) ')(&)3*0&"$ *)% , +,. + !% *.
+ *& /! "$%, +&$,, # '0, +*,
&*))*+ ! %*,
&*& .)! %. 3*##!"$8& +)-,
&0(**+%. %& /! -, +& ". "+*&7& * % +!*"#'(!8 & + * ) (* *<&/8 *' ,% #+*& /' )(&) /&7*' ,. + ! %* %. ,% +&!",3,
(,8*'(3)
=> > ?@ A BCD
81
EFGGH I J FGGHKLMN EOG FPQKLEHRNQQGR ERK FSN LMTN UT MG
(
VW2),
X OTR OT HKYF G GLON ZH G YKH IJONHGK F GH N[GE OT LYHR K ZH GYQN SKQXK F[T LYE OK EX GHON ZQ MK\NTMMNT LY.
(4)
] ^ ^ _`abcb de
fg hijkhlmno hlhj pq gohlr ms ths u
`v
wx wy
_c ^ _xbz_`y]{| {]} } |v`yxv{| {] } }
~ ]aby] wxb}y ]]`]{b{_v
]xx }_x` ]`a ]]|x_]`
]b]`w]`]`a_ {]
]b}]]yb]bxa]w}b
e ]{b]``wxab]`}]
]{ab]w ] ``wxx]|z]`
]{bb]x] |z]]yb
]{av] |x wab`]xx v b
] }b]x]|z]_ ] } ]xb
]` ]`a ]^w yxba_`b]
]yb]bx] z]a] `b
] `]`y]z]w{]` ]zw}yb ]
a]` ]`]y|wxx]|z]`
]wab]x ]`^x] vv
d a _by]^w}^by] } ]xb
]{b_}y^wyxb} ]}v`v
ab` a]|]`axb{]}z b] }]
_`b`aby]]xyb]} ]xb
~ ab]yz]^]x]z by]
|]` ax]^x]]yby]
~~ _]]{ bb]
ab`a ]]yb ]} ]xb
~ _ bxb`x wz]]xa ]`b
xba]]wzw}} ]]a ]
~e _} ]} ]ybz]_`ax]}^zb
] b b{{]^wyx]{vv z]] `
~
] |x ] } ]xb
]xby}] zz] `]{]} ]x
~ byxb w{ b]`]
{ b`by]|] _} ]x} ] } z by]
~ x]` }b}]yb]x]aby]
za ] bab]w{]
~ b{] z`]x_` ax]^wyx]
z bx]}wx ]^x] }yb ]] z] a
~d b ]yw``b}]bxa]w}b
`]ab]] } ]{b]]y bz]
~ {_`y_x]`wx] `b}_yx]
`wxb_]w}byxb]`b
{w w{w]a]{]yv`b
x] `]bzyb` ] `
~ z]xb]]xaby]z ]] w^x]z_}yb
xb}z]]ybyxb ]{]}vx v]yb
z]]b` a ]zw{] `b
xb bxz] ` }]
e x] |z] a] w`]]}vxv
xb ]]xaby]x v} ]{b`]
x_ b`]{ab]`]` a]^wyx]
x vb`]yv`b
} ] bx]z]bx{]`]]ab
x v}b] `]`a]|] _} ]xz]x]
}v b]x]z]]yb
} ] b{{]] ` ]` a ]^wyxb
}]x w{bz]w{ba ab`
}vb]`b`x wz
d y vxb] | yb]x
] w`wx{]b{b
(5)
(6)
¡ ¢ £¤¥ ¦§
¨
-
¨©ª¨«¬ ® ¯ª °ª ±°¨²³´ ³³µ µ.
¶·¸ ¹º° ¬ »¸±ª ¼½¾² ©´ ¸ª ¨¾©ª¨¿ÀÁÂÃÄ ÅÆÅÇ È ÅÇ É È
Ê¥ Ä Ä ¡ ËÌÆÍ
Ä ÅÎÏ
¢Ì ÐÇÆ ÅÇ ÁÍ
Ä ÅÎÏ ÀÀÁÀ
ËÌÆÍ
¡ £¥£ Ñ ÒÓ ÔÑÏ¦Õ ÖϦ§¦ ÑÏ× Ó×
Ò Ò¦ §§Ï§¦ ÓÏÕØ Ó ÑÏÔ§Ô
Ù Ú Û ÜÝ ÜÚÛ Ü Ú ÞßàáÝ âÜãäÜãÞ
¥Ì ÐÌ ÍÌåÈ
æÌÈ ÅçÁÀ
è ÂÆéÇÅ êÁç
ëÆÀÇÆÍÉÌÈ Å
-
ÅÌÈ ÅçÁÀ è ÂÆé Ç ÅêÁçËÌÆÍÈì ÄÇí
.
Å ÎçÄÇí
.
îÒ -ÅÆÇéÌ Îï ËÌÆ Í ¢Ç ççÌ ÀÌ ÍÉÌ Ä ÅÎÏ ÀÀÁÀ ¢Ç ççÌ ÀÌ ÍÉÌ ÓÖð ÊÁÍçÇÎÌ ÍÉÌ £ÍÅÌÀÐÆéÁç ÅñÌ ¢ÇççÌÀÌ ÍÉÌ ¥Áò ÌÀ ó Ãà ÌÀ ¡£¥ £ è ÂÆé ÐÆÀÇÆÍÉÌÈÆÈ È ÂôÌ Î
§ÏÖÖ
Ñ
.
× ÑÕ ÒÏÖ×× ÖÖ.
× ÑÖ ÖÏÑÖÒÏ× § × ÑÏ× Ò Ñ ÓÏÒÔ Ô è ÂÆé ÐÆÀÇÆÍÉÌÈ ÍÁÅ
ÆÈ È ÂôÌ Î
ÒÏØ ¦× ØÖÏÑØ Ô
.
× ÑÔ ÖÏÑÖÒÏ× Ô
§