Summary of the Nine Layer Model An Alternative Perspective to the Nine Layer Model

Feature Collections seem to need important interfaces in order to support the needs of Catalogs and Catalog Services. These interfaces seem to be tightly coupled with Feature Collection Metadata. Formal definition of feature identifier scope is required, and every scope implicitly has an association with the collection of features whose identifiers it can resolve.

2.11. Summary of the Nine Layer Model

As a summary of the preceding sections, and as a reformulation of Figure 2-2, we present Figure 2-23. name pith select embed measure fit codify localize survey locate assemble extent geo-value Epistemic Interface GIS Discipline Interface Local Metric Interface Community Interface Spatial Reference Interface Geometric Structure Interface Feature Structure Interface Project Structure Interface member include decompose Real World; Essential Language Conceptual World; Natural Language OGIS Points; Coordinate Geometry OGIS Geometry World; OGIS WKTs OGIS Feature World; OGIS Features Project World World View; Information Community Dimensional World; Metric Language Geospatial World; GIS Language Mathematical and Symbolic Models of the World Conceptual and Literal Models of the World encl ose instance attribu te Attribute Schema Interface Geometry Schema Interface Project Schema Interface represent re ali ze skel eton OGIS Feature Collection World OGIS Feature Collection Figure 2-23 Nine Layers of Abstraction with Additional Interfaces The OpenGIS ® Abstract Specification Page 23 Volume 5: Topic 5: Features Using the notation of [1], we present Figure 2-23. GIS World Real World OGIS Feature World OGIS Geometry World OGIS Point World Project World or World View Dimensional World Conceptual World name pith model embed measure fit codify localize survey locate assemble geo-value decompose extent skeletonize enclose attribute instance Attribute Schema Spatial Reference System Geometry Schema OGIS Feature Collection World realize represent Project Schema include member Attribute Reference System Attribute Figure 2-24 The Object Types of the Nine Layer Model

2.12. An Alternative Perspective to the Nine Layer Model

Figure 2-25 presents an alternative view of the various ways of defining multiple worlds, but from a language perspective. This view is equally valid but different. In particular, the nine-layer model implies that the essence of all features is tied up in their spatial extents they are all drawn from a ‘Project World’ which is a ‘codification’ of the ‘Dimensional World’. However, we define features to be able to have many spatial extents - or none - and where the spatial extent of the feature may be of less importance than its relationships to other features see Topic 8. The OpenGIS ® Abstract Specification Page 24 Volume 5: Topic 5: Features Figure 2-25 Conceptual Model of the ‘Real World’ modelling process

2.13. Persistent Feature Identifiers