LCE is supportive 2. Cost efficient in monitoring Proximity to other MPAs

41 Annex 4. Status of MPAS in Bohol Assessed Using MEAT Municipality Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Tubigon Matabao Cabulijan Tinangnan Macaas Centro Batasan Pangapasan Bilangbilangan Ubay Clarin Bonbon Nahawan Majigpit Lajog Tangaran Inabanga Lawis Cagawasan Hambungan Ondol Buenavista West Cabul-an Asinan East Cabul-an Getafe Campao Occidental Pandanon Jandayan Norte Handumon Corte-Baud Banacon Jandayan Sur Jagoliao Tugas Nasingin Tulang Talibon Busalian Bien Unido Bilangbilangan West Ubay Sinandigan 11 Level 1 MPAs 13 Level 2 MPAs 4 Level 3 MPAs 7 Level 4 MPAs Criteria for selection of MPAs to be put under improved management

1. LCE is supportive 2.

With potential community leader -with budget for CRM and law enforcement

3. Cost efficient in monitoring

-with CRM officer

4. Proximity to other MPAs

-believes in PHE integration 5. No other NGOs working in the MPA 2 3 4 5 2 3 4 5 2 3 4 5 2 3 4 5 2 3 4 5 42 Annex 5. Bantay Dagat Evaluation Results Table 1. Batangas Bantay Dagat Evaluation Results ORGANIZATIONAL STATUS OPERATIONAL STATUS MANAGEMENT SUPPORT AND INTERVENTION Lack of support due to political intervention Disorganized operational activities among BD members Full support of PNPPCGLGU and other local and national agencies Weak on logistical support and other enforcement assistance Fund sourcingprovide livelihood program Through municipal ordinance and executive order Inactive in terms of task Insufficient honorarium or incentives Municipal ordinance Table 2. Operational Status of Oriental Mindoro Bantay Dagat Teams Implementation of Plans Municipality Patrolling MPA Area Covered Team Compositio nPNP, BD, Maritime, BFAR rep, Tactical Plan Day Night Use of Informer Puerto Galera Regular Complete San Teodoro Irregular Complete Baco Irregular Complete Calapan City Irregular Complete Pola Regular Complete Naujan Regular Complete Pinamalayan Irregular Complete Gloria Regular Complete Bansud Irregular Complete Bongabong Irregular Complete Roxas Irregular Complete Mansalay Irregular Complete Bulalacao Irregular Complete 43 Management Support and Interventions received from the LGUPrivate Sector to Support BD Groups Municipality Operation Fuel Coordinat ion Honorariu m Livelihood from LGU Monitoring Evaluation Puerto Galera Insufficient X San Teodoro Sufficient X Goats Baco Insufficient X Crablets, Calapan City Sufficient Fishing Gears Pola Sufficient X Naujan Sufficient X Pinamalayan Insufficient X X Gloria Sufficient hog raising, payao,tilapiafi ngerlings Bansud Insufficient X X Bongabong Insufficient X hog dispersal Roxas Insufficient X X Mansalay Insufficient X X Bulalacao Insufficient X X 44 Annex 6. Performance Management and Reporting Plan and Results to Date BALANCED-Philippines Project Indicators, Expected and Actual Results to Date INTERMEDIA TE RESULT INDICATOR Expected Year 1 Results Total Year 1 Results Dec 2010 to Sept 2011 Expecte d Year 2 Results Oct to Dec 2011 Results Jan to Mar 2012 Results Total Year 2 Results Comments IR1: Improved access to family planning reproductive health services in key bioregions 1.1 Number of people counseled in RHFP as a result of USAID assistance USAIDOHcustom indicator 2 22,000 1,526 43,550 1,904 6,593 8,497 Under target There is difficulty in collecting the data on the number of people counseled because RHU midwives in some sites do not conduct regular monitoring and reporting in some sites resulting to incomplete data. Other factors include late submission of reports causing underreporting of accomplishments and inactive PHE APEs not reporting. Collection of reports is ongoing and data that will be collected will be added in the next quarter report. 45 1.2 Contraceptive Prevalence Rate USAIDOH standard indicator 3 NA 31 average of the 5 target Provinces Increasin g 37.88 average of the 5 target Data not collected 37.88 CPR data seems to be very unreliable. Some municipalities are reporting very high increases while other municipalities report very steep declines. Interestingly, target sites with established cost recovery systems report a 19 increase in CPR, while target sites with no cost- recovery systems established reported a 17 increase in CPR. Further, Hilongos, which has no trained PHE CBDs, showed a 14 increase in CPR. There seems to be rampant inaccuracies in data collection for this indicator. Therefore, BALANCED- Philippines staff will check data to determine the reason for large variances in CPR calculations. 1.3 Number of couple years protection USAIDOH standard indicator 3 NA 17,160 79,125 80,816 80,816 PFPI will check these numbers for accuracy as such a high CYP seems unlikely given the few number of people counseled 1.4 Number of people trained in RHFP with USG funds USAIDOH standard indicator 3 713 1,508 204 m; 1,304 f 412 215 42 m; 173 f 205 32 m, 173 f 420 74 m; 346 F Over-target and 4 increase in number of men trained 46 1.5 Number of participants who received BALANCED training andor mentoring that are now providing training or technical assistance to others on PHE BALANCED core indicator 60 36 36 36 24 60 Over-target 1.6 Percent of FP users of modern methods obtaining supplies and services from private sector sources CBDs, etc. Surrogate BALANCED field indicator 15 15 1 1.68 1.68 Under-target Percentage is based on the data collected from 11 municipalities. Collection of data from other municipalities is ongoing as of this period. 1.7 Number of USG-assisted service delivery points providing FP services BALANCED field indicator 495 450 21 233 107 22 99 23 206 On-target 1.8 Number of target organizations incorporating PHE tools, protocols, etc. into their work BALANCED core indicator 15 23 24 20 10 25 4 26 14 On-target 21 26 RHUs + 424 CBDs 22 1 RHU + 106 CBDs 23 1 RHU + 98 CBDs 24 MENRO RHU of Calatagan 2; MAO RHU of Lobo 2; MAO RHU of Mabini 2; MAO RHU of San Juan 2; MAO RHU of Nasugbu 2; MAO RHU of Inabanga 2; RHUs of Batangas City, Bato, Hindang, Matalom, Inopacan, Bien Unido, Getafe, Buenavista, Clarin, Tubigon Ubay 11. These local government organizations have been using the BALANCED training manuals to train PHE adult PEs and PHE CBDs 25 MAO, RHU MSWDO of Abra de Ilog 3; MAO RHU of Lubang 2; MAO RHU of Looc 2; RHUs of Pres. Carlos P. Garcia, Trinidad Hilongos. 26 RHU, MPDO, CRMO of Paluan 3 and RHU of Talibon 1. These local government organizations have been using the BALANCED training manuals to train PHE adult PEs and PHE CBDs 47 IR2: Increased community awareness and support of family planning and conservation as a means to improve health, food security and natural resources 2.1 Number of people who have seen or heard a specific RHFP message USAIDOH standard indicator 2 75,000 2,379 100,000 107,694 20,979 128,673 On-target IR3: Increased policymakers’ commitment to promotesupport FPRH services and integrated approaches 3.1 Amount of in-country public and private financial resources leveraged by USG programs for RHFP USAIDOH standard indicator 1 U15,000 U112,760 U40,000 U10,282 U15,923 US26,205 On-target 3.2 Number of local policy reformsplans with integrated PHE initiated BALANCED field indicator 10 4 10 2 2 Under-target Local policy reformsplans are currently being reviewed and updated. BALANCED- Philippines Project staff continues to advocate for the inclusion of PHE in local plans and agenda . 3.3 Number of Nationalregional Forums where PHE approach highlighted NA 1 MOU with LMP was signed. Coordination with LMP for the schedule of island cluster conferences is ongoing . 48 IR 4: Improved governance capacities of provincial and municipal LGUs in the VIP and Danajon Bank marine ecosystems 4.1 Number of people trained on NRM disaggregated by gender and those involved in FP Standard USAID bio-diversity indicator NA 4.2 Number of hectares of biologically significant marine areas under improved management disaggregated by area of MPAs versus area of municipal waters 1 Standard USAID bio- diversity indicator NA Municipa l waters: 50,000ha . MPAs: 400ha. MPA assessment in Bohol using the MEAT tool is ongoing. MPA assessment in the VIP will commence next quarter. VIP results will be available in July. 4.3 Number of local institutions strengthened on NRM Standard USAID bio-diversity indicator NA 14 MPAs 10, BD 4 IR 5: Increased incentives for coastal and marine conservation among coastal fisher households 5.1 Number of people trained gender disaggregated on conservation-based enterprises 3 NA Target set in Year 1 27 Coordination with LGUs, GOs and private organizations involved in enterprise development is ongoing. Training on conservation based enterprises will happen next quarter. 5.2 Number of people with increased economic benefits derived from sustainable fisheries management NA No target but tracked 28 27 This target will be based on target number of people benefiting from conservation based enterprises and will be a subset of that number see below. 49 5.3 Number of people benefiting from conservation incentive- based enterprises NA Target set in Year 1 29 28 Estimated number of fishers in LIG is 1000 persons. If fishers and municipalities choose to pilot a managed access regime, then the number benefiting will be the number of fishers granted exclusive access rights. If it is for the reef fishery only, the actual number will be less than 1000 as the number of reef fishers has yet not determined, and will be baselined in Year1. 29 In a process oriented livelihoods approach, the number of targeted beneficiaries will be determined as part of the planning conducted with LGUs in Year1. However, given budget considerations, order of magnitude approximation will be in hundreds 100-300, not thousands of households. Number of households benefiting from conservation incentive-based enterprises gender disaggregated and by number of these people also involved in FPRH activities includes those households where a member has participated in diversified livelihood interventions including training, value chain improvements, etc. TBD once livelihood strategies designed w LGUs but estimated at 30 per municipality X 5 = 150 households 1 Building Actors and Leaders for Advancing Community Excellence in Development: The BALANCED - Philippines Project Quarterly Progress Report 6 For Period April 1 to June 30, 2012 Submitted August 14, 2012 USAID Cooperative Agreement No. GPO-A-00-08-00002-00 Population Health Environment Technical Leadership Cooperative Agreement Implemented by: PATH Foundation Philippines, Inc. Conservation International Coastal Resources Center at the University of Rhode Island 2 This document was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development under the terms of Cooperative Agreement No. GPO-A-00-08-00002-00. The Project is managed by the Coastal Resources Center at the University of Rhode Island in collaboration with Path Foundation Philippines, Inc. and Conservation International. For more information contact: Dr. Ronald Quintana, Program Manager Email: rquintanapfpi.org 3 2 ACRONYMS APE Adult Peer Educator BALANCED Building Actors and Leaders for Advancing Community Excellence in Development BD Bantay Dagat BEMO Bohol Environmental Management Office BFAR Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources BHW Barangay Health Worker BnB Botika ng Barangay CBD Community Based Distributor CCEF Coastal Conservation and Education Foundation CHD Center for Health Development CHT Community Health Team CI Conservation International CIP Conservation International Philippines CRC Coastal Resources Center CRM Coastal Resource Management DENR Department of Environment and Natural Resources DOH Department of Health FGD Focus Group Discussion FPRH Family PlanningReproductive Health FSSI Foundation for the Sustainable Society, Inc. ICRM Integrated Coastal Resource Management ICRMP Integrated Coastal Resource Management Project ICV Informed Consent and Volunteerism IEC Information, education, and communication IMAP Integrated Midwives Association of the Philippines IPC Interpersonal Communication IR Intermediate Results LAM Lactational Amenorrhea Method LCE Local Chief Executives LGU Local Government Unit LHAD Local Health Assistance Division LIG Lubang Island Group LMP League of Municipalities of the Philippines MEAT MPA Management Effectiveness Assessment tool MHO Municipal Health Officer MOUA Memorandum of UnderstandingAgreement MPA Marine Protected Area NFWF National Fish and Wildlife Foundation NGO Non-governmental Organization NRM Natural Resource Management OEECC Office of Energy, Environment and Climate Change OH Office of Health PAgO Provincial Agriculture Office 4 PFPI PATH Foundation Philippines, Inc. PHE Population, Health, and Environment PHO Provincial Health Officer PHTL Provincial Health Team Leader PO People’s Organization POPCOM Commission on Population RH Reproductive Health RHM Rural Health Midwife RHU Reproductive Health Unit SAFI Sustainable Alternative Farming Institute SICAD Strategic Intervention and Community-focused Action Towards Development TOT Training of Trainers TWG Technical Working Group URI University of Rhode Island USAID United States Agency for International Development VIP Verde Island Passage VMG Vision, Mission, Goals 5 I. INTRODUCTION The United States Agency for International DevelopmentPhilippines USAIDPhilippines is providing a US1,300,000 Buy-in to the USAID Washington-funded BALANCED Building Actors and Leaders for Advancing Excellence in Community Development Project to support results-oriented population, health and environment PHE field activities in biodiversity-rich bioregions of the Philippines over the period from December 2010 to August 2013. Funding is from two sources from within USAIDPhilippines: The Office of HealthOH 500,000 for family planning and outreach components Intermediate ResultsIRs 1, 2 and 3, and Office of Energy, Environment and Climate ChangeOEECC 800,000 for outreach, fisheries management and livelihood components IRs 4 5 and some contributions to IR3. OH activities commenced in December of 2010 and will run through December 2012, with supplemental funding being considered to extend support to IRs 1 to 3 through August 2013. OEECC-supported activities began in December 2011 and will run through August 2013. The Coastal Resources Center CRC at the University of Rhode Island URI, with PATH Foundation Philippines, Inc. PFPI and Conservation InternationalPhilippines CIP are the implementing agents for BALANCED-Philippines Project. The goal of the BALANCED- Philippines Project is to build the leadership and implementation capacities of national and local governments and stakeholders to respond in an integrated manner to interrelated population, health, and marine environmental issues. This goal is achieved through the following IRs: IR1 - Improved access to family planningreproductive health services in key bioregions OH IR2 - Increased community awareness and support of family planning and conservation as a means to improve health, food security and natural resources OH IR3 - Increased policy makers commitment to FPRH services, CRM and integrated policies OH OEECC IR4 - Improved governance capacities of provincial and municipal LGUs in the VIP and Danajon Bank marine ecosystems OEECC IR5. - Increased incentives for coastal and marine conservation among coastal fisher households OEECC The BALANCED-Philippines Project goal and intermediate results contribute to USAIDPhilippines priority goal of “Investing in People to Reduce Poverty” and also to the USAIDOH Strategic Objective of sustainably achieving improved family health and the Family PlanningReproductive Health FPRH Objective of achieving desired family size. The Project is also in line with the current U.S. Country Assistance Strategy with respect to assistance directed at reducing threats to biodiversity. The BALANCED-Philippines Project will also contribute to achieving Intermediate Result 1, “Natural Resources and Environmental Services Improved” under Objective 1, “Broad Based and Inclusive Growth Sustained” of the proposed results framework for the planned USAIDPhilippines Mission’s Country Development Cooperation Strategy. With support from USAIDOH, family planning activities are being implemented in Verde Island Passage VIP sites where ongoing coastalfisheries management activities have yet to be integrated with FPRH herein called “new” sites, and Danajon Bank bioregions to improve and 6 maintain PHE initiatives that were implemented by PFPI under previous PHE projects herein referred to as “maintenance” sites. Through additional support from USAIDOEECC, the Project incorporated coastal resources management CRM activities in select BALANCED- Philippines sites. This report summarizes the activities completed by BALANCED-Philippines during the reporting period April 1 to June 30, 2012 as per terms and conditions as approved in the Year 2 work plan and Cooperative Agreement No. GPO-A-00-08-00002-00.

II. PROJECT RESULTS From April 1 to June 30 2012, BALANCED-Philippines continued working with local