Analisis Perbandingan Protokol Better Approach To Mobile Ad Hoc Network (BATMAN) Dengan Protokol Babel Untuk Layanan Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP) Pada Mobile Ad Hoc Network (MANET)

  

LAMPIRAN

LAMPIRAN 1 Data Pengujian Bandwidth B.A.T.M.A.N-adv Skenario Full Connected

  1 Sesi

  2 Sesi Detik ke Down

0 Sesi

  (bps) Up

  (bps) Down

  (bps) Up

  (bps) Down

  (bps) Up

  (bps)

  1 5.628 754 3.719 638 4.106 696 2 3.585 666 3.946 724 5.893 580 3 4.196 638 4.382 696 6.968 580 4 4.771 754 5.733 638 4.930 696 5 4.143 580 4.896 696 3.746 696 6 4.856 696 4.536 638 3.400 638 7 9.289 3.785 6.497 696 4.462 724 8 5.358 580 3.916 664 3.838 724 9 7.565 3.263 6.018 696 5.913 638 10 5.992 638 5.793 638 4.404 580

  11 4.280 754 4.764 782 6.006 580 12 10.567 3.442 7.850 696 7.850 898 13 6.004 638 4.961 638 4.064 724 14 8.380 3.523 5.057 696 8.399 1.079 15 6.853 638 6.371 580 7.462 1.077 16 4.297 580 6.165 696 6.444 638 17 6.456 638 3.651 580 6.343 580 18 7.517 754 4.383 696 3.266 580 19 4.562 580 4.639 696 4.906 812 20 4.000 638 7.606 1.376 4.304 696 21 4.610 754 5.358 638 7.164 1.165 22 4.503 696 5.161 638 4.210 638 23 3.450 752 5.055 638 7.388 1.077 24 4.576 638 5.154 580 3.320 580 25 5.137 754 7.046 810 6.202 666 26 6.322 580 5.493 638 6.898 812 27 7.169 580 5.428 812 4.385 780 28 4.922 782 5.913 638 5.496 638 29 5.914 812 6.491 638 8.606 990 30 4.183 580 5.304 580 5.845 871 31 5.737 580 4.464 696 8.356 1.047

  32 7.222 696 3.985 638 5.728 580 33 5.176 696 3.720 638 5.298 812 34 3.719 580 4.889 724 6.509 638 35 4.235 638 4.383 754 6.862 638 36 4.663 754 4.668 638 4.053 696 37 3.919 638 4.656 580 3.760 638 38 4.337 580 4.683 724 4.023 580 39 4.022 580 6.561 638 4.049 608 40 6.013 812 3.850 722 4.877 956 41 5.633 580 5.926 638 5.315 638 42 4.976 580 6.114 696 4.790 638 43 4.982 896 5.240 782 6.190 580 44 6.259 696 6.445 782 7.208 782 45 5.897 580 5.993 638 4.510 580 46 4.669 752 4.270 522 7.356 1.021 47 7.174 754 5.835 696 10.017 1.251 48 5.677 638 7.419 638 6.902 638 49 5.459 580 4.583 638 4.736 638 50 7.052 638 4.172 754 4.373 754 51 5.417 812 4.120 696 3.823 580 52 3.716 522 4.302 666 4.250 638 53 3.876 580 5.026 724 4.557 898 54 4.331 638 5.068 638 4.550 638 55 4.252 696 5.149 696 3.600 638 56 4.257 580 6.578 696 5.011 638 57 5.931 638 7.141 782 5.174 782 58 5.921 870 5.120 638 5.566 580 59 7.427 580 4.789 638 3.426 664 60 4.309 752 5.714 638 6.805 754

  Rata-rata (bps) 5.422,38 856,38 5.269,15 685,30 5.464,87 732,60 Rata-rata (Kbps) 5,30 0,84 5,15 0,67 5,34 0,72 Rata-rata (KBps) 0,66 0,10 0,64 0,08 0,67 0,09

  LAMPIRAN 2 Data Pengujian Bandwidth B.A.T.M.A.N-adv Skenario Partial Connected

  1 Sesi

  2 Sesi Detik ke Down

0 Sesi

  (bps) Up

  (bps)

Down

  

(bps)

Up (bps) Down

  (bps) Up (bps)

  1 683 258 21.310 23.024 35.992 32.928 2 550 290 22.345 24.563 32.714 55.968 3 602 290 20.731 22.797 33.589 33.155 4 857 406 20.819 22.809 38.321 40.894 5 869 464 22.181 24.258 44.164 45.029 6 626 290 28.673 31.132 35.876 33.037 7 506 290 15.686 17.554 30.163 60.134 8 506 290 22.605 24.659 24.118 56.752 9 1.080 290 18.316 20.223 25.169 26.848 10 666 406 21.893 23.904 32.547 40.840

  11 696 406 20.308 22.486 30.838 34.491 12 576 348 20.482 22.620 37.861 40.191 13 789 374 21.523 23.368 34.701 39.119 14 443 232 21.366 23.321 42.626 47.393 15 466 290 20.738 22.736 32.498 46.295 16 492 318 20.017 21.971 37.508 66.213 17 873 464 20.467 22.541 30.849 45.135 18 871 406 26.799 28.991 30.334 66.261 19 492 290 15.715 17.433 37.304 32.827 20 442 290 20.380 22.416 27.408 47.865 21 576 290 21.231 23.239 30.205 41.327 22 723 290 22.079 23.882 39.586 40.623 23 789 348 20.936 22.861 33.430 31.513 24 706 406 19.546 21.532 24.484 28.779 25 666 406 20.866 22.934 37.941 44.881 26 1.914 731 21.141 22.876 25.313 33.319 27 1.599 639 20.799 22.474 36.282 45.102 28 466 290 21.043 23.291 28.168 36.460 29 616 290 20.093 22.291 26.897 35.536 30 694 492 21.262 23.432 28.880 49.534 31 1.032 464 20.807 22.595 44.076 38.031 32 532 290 20.752 22.794 39.082 32.327 33 518 374 20.531 22.605 41.037 33.770 34 466 290 20.755 22.977 32.260 26.111 35 769 290 21.572 23.301 44.521 39.279 36 629 258 20.751 22.678 29.947 25.817 37 678 348 21.401 23.491 37.230 41.804

  38 778 406 21.411 23.699 25.990 28.826 39 652 406 21.372 23.295 24.928 22.594 40 846 290 20.649 22.620 29.085 33.072 41 532 258 20.937 23.151 46.027 38.957 42 452 377 19.864 21.904 34.451 32.837 43 518 344 21.452 23.237 31.972 35.548 44 1.944 699 21.063 22.986 41.659 39.427 45 1.041 432 20.701 22.669 35.116 35.912 46 1.461 723 21.978 24.150 30.381 30.019 47 552 258 21.860 24.174 28.136 36.496 48 563 232 19.043 20.723 40.507 31.624 49 735 342 21.059 23.347 42.092 33.225 50 452 258 19.975 22.093 32.708 34.784 51 650 316 21.118 23.190 28.346 80.640 52 758 458 20.589 22.338 36.043 31.129 53 1.026 258 24.360 26.523 38.940 55.211 54 504 258 17.277 19.219 56.489 25.515 55 562 290 22.119 24.141 40.663 32.624 56 456 232 19.060 20.813 35.807 26.112 57 643 376 20.423 22.442 40.507 31.624 58 909 464 20.811 22.889 38.241 37.552 59 572 374 25.629 28.139 47.250 34.910 60 426 290 21.509 23.504 44.630 23.214

  Rata-rata (bps) 724,83 358,82 21.036,30 23.055,08 35.064,78 38.790,67 Rata-rata (Kbps) 90,60 44,85 2.629,54 2.881,89 4.383,10 4.848,83 Rata-rata (KBps) 11,33 5,61 328,69 360,24 547,89 606,10

  LAMPIRAN 3 Data Pengujian Bandwidth Babel Skenario Full Connected

  1 Sesi

  2 Sesi Detik ke Down

0 Sesi

  (bps) Down

  25 74 380 1.338

  62 1.680 62 2.538 298 35 1.898 62 3.868 236 2.686 36 1.420 92 5.649 1.792 37 2.028 2.296 2.334

  92 32 1.366 236 1.514 124 292 33 1.770 2.588 1.628 34 1.318

  62 31 218 99 2.530 124 2.362

  74 92 2.354 154 29 780 1.568 1.312 30 696 181 180 1.814

  28

  62 27 440 1.408 170 726 108

  90 26 620 90 1.904

  62 558 124 1.976 108 17 1.828 526 728 18 802 308 308 19 4.228 108 760 244 20 2.498 218 562 108 21 1.288 1.304 124 218 22 670 236 376 292 23 798 798 1.204 236 24 218 132 586 988 372

  (bps) Up

  11 6.690 668 108 1.579 124 12 3.731 2.348 608 524 13 1.370 4.252 524 1.902 14 2.962 1.022 3.094 15 1.787 108 324 2.216 16 334

  (bps) Up

  62 5 116 170 3.837 956 62 6 1.350 2.638 3.092 60 7 3.344

  1 74 1.030 62 390 236 2 1.206 236 2.334 1.262 3 1.728 2.924 3.082 232 4 2.268 5.048 296 2.524

  (bps)

  (bps) Up

  (bps) Down

  62 3.035 218 5.412 8 2.552 108 1.920 108 4.295 108 9 1.030 62 1.544 124 2.833 10 2.194 2.130 2.255

  38 1.420 62 3.253 6.048 140 39 1.966 380 2.186 396 5.099 40 2.654 898 124 1.222 41 2.798

  62 2.246 2.962 444 42 4.904 296 670 1.645 62 43 3.943 2.474 108 1.574 62 44 1.918 4.342 1.918

  45 2.557 276 90 236 46 2.628 92 308 4.256 47 174 124 868 236 1.982 124

  48 2.408 1.192 292 49 942 180 888 50 4.662 92 292 436 51 2.334 658 380 436 52 600 378 670 108 53 396 236 580 218 54 90 164 92 580 55 728 774

  62 696 56 308 988 580 524 57 74 380 74 236 308 58 1.090 2.580 684 59 324 2.380 62 1.280 60 452 1.030 154

  74 108

  Rata-rata 1.618,97 79,13 1.587,00 80,67 1.593,17 77,70 (bps) Rata-rata 1,58 0,08 1,55 0,08 1,56 0,08 (Kbps) Rata-rata 0,20 0,01 0,19 0,01 0,19 0,01 (KBps)

  LAMPIRAN 4 Data Pengujian Bandwidth Babel Skenario Partial Connected

  1 Sesi

  2 Sesi Detik ke Down

0 Sesi

  (bps) Up

  (bps)

Down

  

(bps)

Up (bps) Down

  (bps) Up (bps)

  1 238 17.545 19.907

  33.338 37.257

  2 90 17.406 19.452 31.997 35.679 3 108 17.100 18.960 29.927 36.293 4 90 17.430 19.680 24.929 30.477 5 106 144 16.983 19.113 23.662 44.962 6 74 17.317 19.089 26.358 32.142 7 122 16.602 18.998 28.720 34.456 8 148 288 17.632 19.854 26.112 33.384 9 254 18.002 20.066 30.497 18.169

  10 74 17.350 19.568 35.949 43.546 11 614 788 17.591 19.767 27.857 33.657 12 106 17.512 19.428 29.698 35.644 13 254 17.641 19.817 29.396 35.716 14 374 657 17.030 19.194 34.169 41.285 15 122 17.290 19.428 34.492 41.892 16 90 17.199 19.383 27.360 33.240 17 90 140 17.830 19.938 33.272 39.642 18 90 17.110 18.984 30.793 37.201 19 90 256 18.062 20.378 21.135 26.049 20 90 17.380 19.716 30.647 37.003 21 108 17.658 19.664 33.309 40.235 22 122 17.611 19.743 31.231 37.203 23 270 17.578 19.786 30.026 26.442 24 254 140 17.675 19.791 33.868 13.508 25 180 17.025 19.065 33.854 12.342 26 108 17.204 19.494 41.916 21.222 27 142 17.318 19.428 40.868 21.494 28 90 256 17.184 18.984 26.655 6.325 29 122 17.678 20.012 25.247 2.805 30 344 17.898 20.048 26.212 35.701 31 254 140 17.284 19.194 24.258 7.273 32 180 17.245 19.385 26.825 8.552 33 108 17.774 20.184 27.956 9.756 34 180 17.563 19.571 22.596 53.169 35 122 17.185 19.195 24.088 7.263

  36 108 18.448 20.784 32.060 22.103 37 122 17.453 19.559 31.452 24.465 38 90 17.534 19.428 26.217 30.263 39 74 140 17.850 20.162 27.503 33.167 40 90 17.558 19.654 27.153 33.139 41 90 256 17.076 19.334 33.169 40.131 42 508 17.088 18.750 29.374 35.576 43 108 17.806 20.048 28.705 34.677 44 212 140 17.247 19.447 30.944 37.306 45 74 17.207 19.299 30.564 37.006 46 90 17.116 19.490 27.437 33.447 47 90 108 18.072 20.170 27.270 33.096 48 90 17.030 19.194 29.042 34.794 49 256 17.963 20.141 29.090 35.144 50 508 17.725 19.767 27.851 33.795 51 222 104 17.286 19.488 29.999 35.973 52 208 17.278 19.494 27.376 33.098 53 74 140 18.084 20.106 31.077 37.587 54 212 16.810 18.750 32.857 39.467 55 108 17.718 20.020 29.873 36.311 56 180 17.432 19.346 30.721 37.041 57 90 17.318 19.428 31.149 37.415 58 256 17.203 19.323 31.577 38.413 59 212 16.856 19.272 27.257 33.363 60 140 17.685 19.709 25.611 30.767

  Rata-rata (bps) 140,07 88,55 17.445,58 19.573,78 29.575,75 31.142,13 Rata-rata (Kbps) 17,51 11,07 2.180,70 2.446,72 3.696,97 3.892,77 Rata-rata (KBps) 2,19 1,38 272,59 305,84 462,12 486,60