Journal of Home Affairs Governance
Jurnal Bina Praja
Journal of Home Affairs Governance
VOLUME 8 | ISSUE 1 | MAY 2016
Aim and Scope Imprint Indexing Jurnal Bina Praja (JBP) is a journal JBP is published by Research and Indexed in Google Scholar.that provides scientific information Development Agency, Ministry of resources aimed at researchers, Home Affairs and managed to be research institutions, government issued twice in every volume. The
Accreditation
agencies, and stakeholders. The first issue should be in May and the JBP has been certified as an journal publishes original research second issue is in November.
Indonesian Scientific Journal by manuscripts, review articles,
ISSN print: 2085-4323
Indonesian Institute of Sciences studies, and case studies that focus
ISSN electronic: 2503-3360 (LIPI) by 24 April 2016.
on: Electronic edition is available at:
Accreditation Number: www.binaprajajournal.com
735/AU2/P2MI-LIPI/04/2016
1. Local Autonomy and Bureau-
Valid thru: 24 April 2019
cracy
2. Politics and Public Adminis- Article Management tration
Every article submitted to JBP shall
Postal Address
3. Territorial Administration
use reference management software Research and Development Agency
and Rural Governance e.g.
EndNote™ or Mendeley.
Ministry of Home Affairs
4. Population and Civil Registra-
Accepted article to be published Jl. Kramat Raya No. 132, Central
tion
in JBP will be proofed using ® Jakarta, Indonesia
5. Regional Election and Region- checker software. Grammarly al Innovation
Phone/Fax: +62 21 392 7857
6. Regional Fiscal Policy and De-
Email: jurnal binapraja@yahoo.com
velopment Article Processing
7. Other Issues in Public Admin- istration Charges
Every article submitted to JBP will not have any Article Processing Charges. This includes peer- reviewing, editing, publishing, maintaining and archiving, and allows immediate access to the full text version of the articles. Jurnal Bina Praja
Journal of Home Affairs Governance
VOLUME 8 | ISSUE 1 | M`AY 2016
Editor-in-Chief AsroriIda Hayu
Graphic Designer Elpino Windy
elpinowindy@gmail.com
Acknowledgement for Reviewer Augustina Situmorang
Demography augustinasitumorang@gmail.com
Dwi Purwoko
Religion and Religious Tradition d_purwoko2003@yahoo.com
Administrative Sciences ida2hade@gmail.com
Language Editor Al-Amri Arif Sandy
Meidi Kosandi
Political Sciences mkosandi@yahoo.com
Muchlis Hamdi
Public Policy muchlis.hamdi03@gmail.com
Rachma Fitriati
Administrative Sciences rachmafi@yahoo.com
Sudarsono Hardjosoekarto
alamriarifsandy1112@gmail.com
Human Resources Management sornipaskah@yahoo.com
Public Policy asrori2011@yahoo.com
niyannurin@gmail.com
Managing Editor Moh. Ilham A. Hamudy
Politics and Governance ilhamhamudy80@gmail.com
Yuddy Kuswanto
yuddykuswanto@gmail.com
Frisca Natalia Hutabarat
frisca212@gmail.com
Niyan Nurin Ridha Putri
Elpino Windy
Sorni Paskah Daeli
elpinowindy@gmail.com
Associate Editors Ajib Rakhmawanto
Public Management ajib.bkn@gmail.com
Imam Radianto ASP
Public Administration imamradianto@gmail.com
Sitti Aminah
Public Policy sittiaminah.kemendagri@gmail. com
Sociology sudarsono@dpd.go.id Jurnal Bina Praja
Journal of Home Affairs Governance
VOLUME 8 | ISSUE 1 | MAY 2016
Foreword from Editor-in Chief
Praise be to God Almighty, Bina Praja Journal (JBP) can be present again before the reader. In this edition, JBP is different.Starting in 2016, JBP is published only twice a year, which before was published four times a year. This option is deliberately taken to maintain the quality and consistency of JBP. Nevertheless, in every publication, JBP does not reduce the quantity of articles. Within a year, JBP still publishes 28 articles, just like when JBP is published four times a year. Another different look is from the layout. The cover, which was usually filled with the title of the published articles, this time is changed into the logo of the Ministry of Home Affairs (MoHA). As for the language used, starting from this edition, JBP is published with English version. The goal is none other than to make the articles written by researchers, lecturers, and other observers of government accessible to the reader more broadly.
In this publication, JBP still raises themes related to the main duties and functions of the MoHA. Initially, JBP received 68 articles, but due to space limitation, JBP could only publish 14 articles. These fourteen writers who participated in this edition come from various backgrounds, mostly lecturers at various universities and researchers at the Research and Development Agency of the MoHA.
Hopefully this May 2016 edition of JBP will be acceptable and useful for the readers. Happy reading! Jakarta, May 2016
Editor-in-Chief
Jurnal Bina Praja
Journal of Home Affairs Governance
VOLUME 8 | ISSUE 1 | M`AY 2016
List of Contents
Strengthening Regional Economic Policy for Investment Attraction: Case in Banten Province
Abdul Halik ..................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1-11
Increasing the Scope of Birth and Death Registration: Issues and Challenges
Hari Prasetyo, Moh. Ilham A. Hamudy ............................................................................................................................................... 13-26
Factors Affecting Traditional Market Competitiveness Hotnier Sipahutar .....................................................................................................................................................................................
27-38
Implementation of Computer Assisted Test Selection System in Local Governments Abdul Aziz .....................................................................................................................................................................................................
39-48
Value-added in Public Service Innovation: The Practice at Integrated Service Units in Pontianak Municipality and Tanah Bumbu District Andi Wahyudi ..............................................................................................................................................................................................
49-58
Managing the Impact of Smoke Haze Disaster: Response of Civil Society Groups Towards Jambi Provincial Government Performance Arfan ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................
59-68
Participation and Neutrality of State Civil Apparatus in Direct Regional Election: Surabaya City Case Catur Wibowo Budi Santoso ..................................................................................................................................................................
69-81
Evaluation of Joint Regulation of the Minister of Religion and Minister of Home Affairs No. 9 and 8 of 2006: Study on Main- tenance of Religious Harmony Policy
Herman Ya’arozatulo Harefa ................................................................................................................................................................
83-95
The Development of e-Government System in Indonesia Mi’rojul Huda, Novy Setia Yunas .........................................................................................................................................................
97-108
Solving Local Violence by Cosmopolitan Democracy Approach Muhammad Luthfil Hakim, Nasrun Annahar .............................................................................................................................
109-119
Intergovermental Cooperation Initiative on Sustainable Transportation Management in Jabodetabek
Hidayat Chusnul Chotimah ............................................................................................................................................................... 121-133
The Application of Participatory Communication in the Implementation of Small Farmers Empowerment Program
Sitti Aminah ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 135-148
The Relation Between Multi Actors and Local Reform in Solo City During Joko Widodo’s Leadership Era (2005-2012)
Wahidah R. Bulan ................................................................................................................................................................................. 149-161
The Role of Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) in Advocating the National Security Bill
Yusa Djuyandi ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 163-173
Jurnal Bina Praja
Journal of Home Affairs Governance
VOLUME 8 | ISSUE 1 | MAY 2016
Abstracts Sheet
e-ISSN: 2503-3360 p-ISSN: 2085-4323 Date of Issue: 31 May 2016 The descriptions given are free terms. This abstracts sheet may be reproduced without permission or change.
Abdul Halik
1
(
1 Research and Development Agency,
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 1-11, 1 ill, 0 tab, 22 ref.
(Author) Keywords: civil registration, birth certificate, death certificate.
Nowadays, traditional market is increasingly squeezed by
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 27-38, 2 ill, 0 tab, 27 ref.
Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) Factors Affecting Traditional Markets Competitiveness
1 Research and Development Agency,
(
1
Hotnier Sipahutar
This study found that birth and death registration are still referring to the Presidential Decree No 25 of 2008 which implementation is still adapting the “convenience” of the Law No 24 of 2013. The implementation of birth and death registration still experiences many obstacles, such as: the lack of death reporting by the head of neighborhood (RT); applicants still experience tiered bureaucracy that leads to a lengthy process of completing the document, limited access in the district area, and time service mismatch; human resources in the sub-district/village that are not adequately supportive to the civil registration services; and documentation process in the implementing agencies still relies on manual systems.
The purpose of the study is to analyze the condition of economic potential and economic structure of the region, local investment conditions, as well as to propose a policy in order to strengthen regional economic attraction of investment. The study utilizes qualitative method with descriptive explanation. The result of this study is the attraction of foreign investors and domestic investors to invest in Banten Province is still low, despite the adequately supportive (good enough) economic potential and economic structure in the region. Therefore, it is still necessary to strengthen more appropriate regional economic policies to increase the attraction of investment in Banten province, especially the policy of increasing people’s purchasing power (not in the consumptive context).
Despite being regulated by the Presidential Decree No 25 of 2008, which then was simplified by the Law No 24 of 2013, the registration of birth and death in Indonesia does not automatically promote the scope of birth and death certificate in Indonesia. Local governments are with their respective innovations on these issue, yet these inovations tend to add more bureaucracy and create new problems. The purpose of this study is to examine how the real practice of birth and death registration, as well as to identify the problems, implications, and the causes of the registration implementation. This study was conducted in 2015 in two districts and two municipalities in Banten and West Java Provinces using descriptive research method and descriptive-qualitative analysis.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 13-26, 4 ill, 4 tab, 33 ref.
(Research and Development, Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) Increasing the Scope of Birth and Death Registration: Issues and Challenges
Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) Strengthening Regional Economic Policy for Investment Attraction: Case in Banten Province
, Moh. Ilham A. Hamudy
1
Hari Prasetyo
(Author) Keywords: economic potential, economic structure, investment.
2 the emergence of modern market that develops rapidly. The dominance shift in national retail is apparent when globalization can no longer be contained, let alone be banned. Middle class and small class (traditional market) business retail seem to be in increasingly difficult condition to compete with upscale retail business (modern market). The purpose of this study is to analyze the factors influencing the competitiveness of traditional market and to develop policies to improve the competitiveness of traditional market. This study utilizes research strategy of case study in Bandung City, Serang City, and Surabaya City with qualitative descriptive approach. The study shows that the factors inhibiting the competitiveness of traditional market with modern stores are (1) Traditional market’s bad image, and (2) Traditional market’s sellers and managers are unprofessional. To improve the competitiveness of traditional market, this study recommends: (1) routine and regular maintenance of buildings and infrastructure of traditional market, (2) professionalism improvement of traditional market’s sellers and managers, and (3) the partiality of local government in traditional markets.
(Author) Keywords: competitiveness, traditional markets, modern markets, public policy.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 49-58, 1 ill, 1 tab, 28 ref.
Smoke haze from forest and land fires in Jambi in 2015 had led to various reactions. The low response from the provincial government led by an Acting Governor received various criticism and protests from civil society groups. This study examines the impact of 2015’ haze in Jambi and describes civil society groups’ responses toward the government “transition” of Jambi province performances regarding 2015 smoke haze. Through observation of
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 59-68, 0 ill, 0 tab, 32 ref.
Managing the Impact of Smoke Haze Disaster: Response of Civil Society Groups Towards Jambi Provincial Government Performance
1 IAIN Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi)
(
1
Arfan
(Author) Keywords: value-added, innovation, public service.
The rise of innovations in the public sector creates something new in delivering public services. This study aims to analyze value-added in the practices of service innovation in the public sector. Drawing on desk research method, this study uses secondary data from literature sources. Innovation becomes a way to create value-added in public service sphere. This study concludes that some innovations created in the integrated service units in Pontianak Municipality and Tanah Bumbu District are included in innovation process which delivers efficiency and easiness values for the users of SITU, SIUP and TDP services. The innovation in the two service agencies has succeeded to reduce service delivery duration and minimized the occurrence of opportunity lost among citizens so that the innovation creates public value. Furthermore, those innovation practices demonstrate that there is an adjustment of network community governance in the process of public service administration.
Research and Government Official Training III National Institute of Public Administration (PKP2A III LAN) Samarinda) Value-added in Public Service Innovation: The Practice at Integrated Service Units in Pontianak Municipality and Tanah Bumbu District
Abdul Aziz
1 Center for Public Administration
(
1
(Author) Keywords: CAT system, local governments, civil servants Andi Wahyudi
As an evaluative way of selection of civil servant system in all government areas, Computer Assisted Test selection system was started to apply in 2013. In phase of implementation for first time in all areas in 2014, this system selection had trouble in several areas, such as registration procedure and passing grade. The main objective of this essay was to describe implementation of new selection system for civil servants in the local governments and to seek level of effectiveness of this selection system. This essay used combination of study literature and field survey which data collection was made by interviews, observations, and documentations from various sources, and to analyze the collected data, this essay used reduction, display data and verification for made the conclusion. The result of this essay showed, despite there a few parts that be problem of this system such as in the registration phase but almost all phases of implementation of CAT selection system in local government areas can be said was working clearly likes in preparation, implementation and result processing phase. And also this system was fulfilled two of three criterias of effectiveness for selection system, they were accuracy and trusty. Therefore, this selection system can be said as an effective way to select new civil servant. As suggestion, local governments have to make prime preparation in all phases of test and make a good feedback as evaluation mechanism and together with central government to seek, fix and improve infrastructures as supporting tool and competency of local residents.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 39-48, 1 ill, 1 tab, 29 ref.
Halmahera Regency) Implementation of Computer Assisted Test Selection System in Local Governments
(
1
1 Regional Employment Board (BKD) of East
the relation and activities of the two sides: government and civil society, and open-ended interview with a representative of civil society groups, the results showed that the barrier is the absence of a national disaster status. Acting Governor and Regional Working Unit (SKPD) have a limitation in funding, equipment, and human resources to conduct fire fighting and are unresponsive in treating the haze victims. The persistence of civil society groups which work independently to help victims and encourage the government to be more responsive led to the issuance of Local Regulation on Forest and Land Fires. Finally, this study recommends the government of the Republic of Indonesia to formulate task and function certainty of the central government and Acting Governor in the handling of smoke haze under the condition without national disaster status.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 83-95, 0 ill, 0 tab, 27 ref.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 97-108, 6 ill, 1 tab, 19 ref.
Universitas Darul Ulum Jombang) The Development of e-Government System in Indonesia
2 FISIP
Program of FISIP Universitas Brawijaya Malang,
1 Political Study
(
2
, Novy Setia Yunas
1
Mi’rojul Huda
(Author) Keywords: protection, religious harmony, regulation socialization.
This study aims to evaluate the implementation of the regulation in the province of East Java. The method used in this study is naturalistic or qualitative with a descriptive explanation. The study result shows that in general, the implementation of the regulation in the province of East Java has not been effective. Factors that affect, among others, are the lack of commitment of in implementing the regulation, weak socialization of the regulation, weak law enforcement, and the lack of multicultural education to the community. The policy that needs to be implemented is mainly of the regulation needs to be improved to become a Law. The approval of the existing Draft Law on the Protection of Religious Community needs to be accelerated.
Development Agency, Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) Evaluation of Joint Regulation of the Minister of Religion and Minister of Home Affairs No. 9 and 8 of 2006: Study on Maintenance of Religious Harmony Policy
(Author) Keywords: smoke haze disaster management, Jambi Government, civil society groups.
1 Research and
(
1
Herman Ya’arozatulo Harefa
(Author) Keywords: bureaucracy, participation, neutrality.
In relation to the existence of State Civil Apparatus, at least there are two issues that must be observed in the implementation of Regional elections, namely the issues of participation and neutrality of State Civil Apparatus. The phenomenon that occurs during this time is the involvement of the State Civil Apparatus in attendance is still minimum (low). Moreover, it is believed that there are many Civil Apparatus State who is not neutral in the organization of Regional Elections. In this regard, this study aims to analyze the participation and neutrality of State Civil Apparatus. The method utilized in this study is qualitative. The result of the study shows that in general the participation of State Civil Apparatus in Surabaya is adequately good, but the neutrality of State Civil Apparatus has not implemented well enough. There are at least three (3) main factors influencing the participation of Civil State Apparatus, namely the factors of leadership exemplary, commitment to employees, and employee development. As for the neutrality of the State Civil Apparatus, among others, is influenced by the factors of the ambition of employee, primordialism, and working environment of employees.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 69-81, 1 ill, 3 tab, 23 ref.
Development Agency, Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) Participation and Neutrality of State Civil Apparatus in Direct Regional Election: Surabaya City Case
1 Research and
(
1
Catur Wibowo Budi Santoso
The purpose of this study is to provide an overview of the system of electronic-based government or e-government in Indonesia. The development of e-government system in Indonesia is very important to answer the demands of globalization and modernization that are growing rapidly. E-government system is intended so that the governance is easier, faster, transparent, and effective. However, in its development, the implementation of e-government in Indonesia still needs various improvements. Information in this study is obtained from a variety of publications and documents related to the purposes of the study. The results of the study, among others, show that for technology resources, should the current government to allocate funds sufficient to meet the various devices related to the development of e-government. As for human resources, starting now, the government should have a commitment to provide informal education in the field of ICT in the state apparatus and society. To synchronize both strategies, it is necessary to build digital communities (digital society) throughout the region in Indonesia. The existence of digital society is considered not only able to develop better e-government system but also has an impact on economic acceleration. Other than those two things, the most important thing also requires commitment and strong leadership in developing e-government.
(Author) Keywords: information technology, e-government, public service, effective government.
Affairs Gadjah Mada University (UGM)) Intergovermental Cooperation Initiative on Sustainable Transportation Management in Jabodetabek
(Author) Keywords: participatory communication, empowerment, small farmers.
An agricultural development approach that is centralized, top down, and applied linear communication (transfer of technology) puts farmers as a tool to achieve national’s goals (rice self-sufficiency) and makes them dependant to the outsiders. This study aims to analyze the level of participatory communication implementation in the implementation of Small Farmers Empowerment Program. The data are collected using some methods: observation, interview and focus group discussion. The data are analyzed using descriptive statistic. The study result shows that the implementation of participatory communication is in a low category. The recommendations of this study are to enhance the ability of small farmers through increasing the intensity of dialogue between the small farmers and the stakeholders (insiders and outsiders). Exchange of information and knowledge through ideal dialogue as the medium of exchange of information and knowledge to cope with problems of farming.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 135-148, 2 ill, 3 tab, 32 ref.
Ministry of Home Affairs (BPP Kemendagri)) The Application of Participatory Communication in the Implementation of Small Farmers Empowerment Program
1 Research and Development Agency,
(
1
Sitti Aminah
(Author) Keywords: intergovernmental cooperation, transportation, sustainable transportation, interactive planning.
The main issues in Jabodetabek concerning the management of transportation are related to the increased use of private vehicles and the decreased use of public transportation, overcrowding daily traffic in Jabodetabek, the high congestion followed by insecurity in traffic, environmental pollution, uncontrolled growth of and underdeveloped infrastructure, and irregularities in land use. To overcome these problems, sustainable transportation management becomes very important in which the government should be able to cope with environmental, economic and social factors under the decision making related to transportation in Jabodetabek. Therefore, through interactive planning, this study will examine intergovernmental cooperation initiatives on sustainable transportation management in Jabodetabek. This study uses qualitative and descriptive method through literature study and existing statistics as the resources to apply the interactive planning approach. The result shows that there are found a number of problems and gaps in the management of transportation in Jabodetabek that needs to be reduced because it has the same scope of other gaps. From these problems can be made further action programs and policies in accordance with the resources owned, and then, the design of implementation made and controlled whether in accordance with the purpose or not. Thus, sustainable transportation management in the Jabodetabek needs to be done jointly in an institutional or policy framework involving governments Jabodetabekpunjur, BKSP Jabodetabekpunjur, and the private sector.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 121-133, 1 ill, 1 tab, 30 ref.
(
Muhammad Luthfil Hakim
1
Hidayat Chusnul Chotimah
(Author) Keywords: cosmopolitan democracy, violence, local government.
The implementation of democracy intensified since the fall of the new order era has some failures. One of the factors is violence phenomena still continue in the region. This study aims to discuss the violence in the region by presenting cosmopolitan democracy as a new design of more humane democracy. In addition, this research method uses library research, because library research can understand the problem in-depth to find the pattern and recommendation from the violence problems which happens in Indonesia. This study uses Hannah Arendt observations on the phenomenon of violence. In addition, the concept of cosmopolitan democracy is referred from Daniele Archibugi, David Held, and Ulrich Beck is presented as a draft of new democracy direction which is more inclusive and humane. The result of this study discloses that the occurrence of incidence is triggered by failed implementation of the democratic system in Indonesia.
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 109-119, 0 ill, 1 tab, 27 ref.
Solving Local Violence by Cosmopolitan Democracy Approach
2 Avemedia Research)
1 Pesantren Study Center of Universitas Brawijaya,
(
2
, Nasrun Annahar
1
1 Postgraduate International
particularly through the advocacy of the National Security
1
1 Wahidah R. Bulan ( Department of Communication Bill. The method used in this study is a qualitative method.
Studies, Universitas Pembangunan Nasional “Veteran” The result shows that NGOs, which are members of the Jakarta)
KMSRK, have been running the multiple roles, such as: popularly involved in policy making, providing political The Relation Between Multi Actors and Local Reform in education to the community, promoting or encouraging Solo City During Joko Widodo’s Leadership Era (2005- reform, and promoting the interests of the community. 2012)
The study also suggests the existence of new findings of the role of NGOs, which is forming a coherent unity of
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 149-161, 6 ill, interests.
0 tab, 69 ref.
(Author) This study explored power relation of Jokowi as mayor of Solo City and his efforts to create inclusive populist Keywords: NGO, national security, advocacy. policies in the case of street vendors’ arrangement and resettlement of people on the banks of Solo River.
Specifically, this study explores how Jokowi build his relations with many actors, namely, how the relations can be established, who were they, how were the relationships between Jokowi and CSO (Civil Society Organization) and CSA (Civil Society Activist) as the agencies with serious interest in pursuing reform, and how these relations contribute to achieving local reform agenda. By using qualitative approach with case study strategy as the methodology, this study was conducted from December 2010 to early 2012 and obtained some results as follows: there are some strong enough relations between Jokowi with state and non-state actors, which exist as the attempt to overcome the structural constraints (limited human resources) and because of the similar agendas between Jokowi and those actors (especially with CSO and CSA), and that the relations (with CSO and CSA) are proven effective in helping to achieve local reform agenda progressively. The study also refines Tilly’s theory (1978) on several aspects, namely: the variant of member and challenger, the radical challenger, and neutral, and that the positions of challenger or member are not permanent (depend on the issues).
(Author) Keywords: local reform, power relation, the regional heads, civil society activist (NSA), member; challenger.
1
1 Yusa Djuyandi ( Department of Political Science
Universitas Padjadjaran) The Role of Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) in Advocating the National Security Bill
Jurnal Bina Praja, May 2016, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 163-173, 0 ill, 0 tab, 35 ref.
The role run by a coalition of NGOs in advocating the National Security Bill aimed at encouraging the birth of national security policy to appropriate to the purpose of reform. However, until now the role of NGOs in advocating National Security Bill has not been able to encourage the authorities to reconstruct the draft of national security policy that is consistent with the objectives of security sector reform. This study is conducted to analyze the role of NGOs in the security sector reform in Indonesia,
This page is left blank