Perbandingan Kinerja Jaringan Standar IEEE 802.11 Terhadap Perubahan Packet Generation Rate

LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1 Langkah – Langkah Dalam Melakukan Simulasi Perbandingan
Kinerja Jaringan Standar IEEE 802.11 Terhadap Perubahan
Packet Generation Rate
Dalam melakukan simulasi perbandingan kinerja jaringan standar IEEE
802.11 terhadap perubahan packet generation rate, ada beberapa langkah yang
perlu dilakukan, yaitu :
1.
Instalasi simulator Pamvotis 1.1 pada Personal Computer (Laptop)
Langkah awal yang dilakukan yaitu melakukan instalasi terhadap
simulatorPamvotis 1.1 pada Personal Computer (Laptop). Simulasi Pamvotis 1.1
terintegrasi dengan program Java sehingga harus melakukan instalasi software
berbasis Java seperti Java Platform SE Binary.
2.
Menentukan parameter – parameter yang dibutuhkan
Setelah melakukan instalasi simulator Pamvotis 1.1, maka akan muncul
tampilan awal Pamvotis 1.1 WLAN Simulator seperti yang ditunjukkan Gambar
1.

Gambar 1 Tampilan Awal Pamvotis 1.1 WLAN Simulator
Setelah muncul tampilan Pamvotis 1.1 WLAN Simulator, maka langkah

selanjutnya yang harus dilakukan yang perencanaan parameter yang dibutuhkan
untuk mendapatkan hasil yang diinginkan. Parameter – parameter tersebut ada
yang merupakan parameter tetap yang sifatnya tidak perlu diubah – ubah untuk
melakukan simulasi ini karena bukan parameter tersebut yang ingin diteliti dan
ada juga parameter yang sifatnya harus dilakukan perubahan – perubahan untuk
mendapatkan hasil seperti yang diharapkan seperti yang ditunjukkan oleh Gambar
2(a) dan Gambar 2(b)
Parameter – parameter tetap dalam simulasi ini yaitu :seed, simulation time,
number of values per statistic, packet length distribution, packet generation rate
distribution dan RTS threshold. Pada Gambar 2 terlihat bahwa parameter seed,
simulation time, number of values per statistic, dan RTS threshold didapatkan
pada tampilan awal simulator tetapi parameter packet length distribution dan
packet generation rate distribution didapatkan pada kotak dialog simulation

Universitas Sumatera Utara

configuration ketika kita memilih configure pada node configuration. Parameter –
parameter pilihan dalam simulasi ini yaitu :physical layer, data rate, access
mechanism, number of node, packet length mean, dan packet generation rate
mean. Pada Gambar 2 terlihat bahwa parameter seed, simulation time, number of

values per statistic,RTS threshold dan access mechanism didapatkan pada
tampilan awal simulator seperti yang ditunjukkan pada Gambar 2 (a) tetapi
parameter packet length distribution, packet generation rate distribution,
physical layer, data rate, number of node, packet length mean, dan packet
generation rate mean didapatkan pada kotak dialog simulation configuration
ketika kita memilih configure pada node configuration seperti yang ditunjukkan
pada Gambar 2 (b).

Gambar 2 (a) Parameter simulasi pada kotak dialog Pamvotis 1.1 WLAN
Simulator

Gambar 2 (b) Parameter simulasi pada kotak dialog Simulation Configuration
3.
Menentukan hasil output
Setelah ditetapkan parameter – parameter yang dibutuhkan, maka tahap
selanjutnya yaitu memilih hasil output yang diinginkan dan media
penyimpanannya. Pada bagian choose statistics, kita klik dan selanjutnya kita
pilih kinerja jaringan yang akan diteliti, seperti throughput, utilization, media
access delay, queuing delay, total packet delay, dan jitter. Tetapi, jika hanya ingin
2

Universitas Sumatera Utara

melihat nilai rata – rata untuk tiap kinerja terhadap jumlah node, cukup dengan
memilih mean value seperti yang ditunjukkan pada Gambar 3.

Gambar 3 Statistics Configuration
Pada bagian directory to save result, kita dapat memilih tempat
penyimpanan folder hasil simulasi yang akan kita lakukan seperti yang
ditunjukkan oleh Gambar 4. Setelah kita pilih hasil output beserta tempat
penyimpanannya, maka kita siap untuk melakukan running simulasi. Setelah
melakukan running, maka kita harus menunggu selama beberapa saat sampai
simulasi selesai selama beberapa menit.

Gambar 3 Kotak dialog Save
4.
Running simulation
Setelah running simulasi selesai, maka hasil output akan muncul pada media
penyimpanan yang telah kita pilih dalam bentuk notepad. Simulasi yang
dilakukan dalam hal ini harus dilakukan dalam perulangan. Misalkan kita telah
melakukan simulasi untuk standar IEEE 802.11a pada teknologi basic access

untuk packet generation rate berjumlah 25 paket / detik saat jumlah node adalah 1
node, maka kita akan melakukan tahapan simulasi seperti yang telah dijelaskan
tadi untuk standar fisik, teknologi multiple access, dan packet generation rate
yang sama tetapi dengan jumlah node yang berbeda.Setelah itu dilakukan proses
simulasi yang berulang pula untuk standar fisik, teknologi multiple access, dan
packet generation rate yang berbeda pula.
5.
Analisa data
Setelah selesai melakukan semua simulasi yang dibutuhkan, maka
selanjutnya hasil output berupa notepad tadi di-copy atau disalin ke dalam
microsoft excel untuk dijadikan tabel – tabel perbandingan untuk tiap – tiap

3
Universitas Sumatera Utara

standar fisik dan teknologi multiple accessterhadap packet generation rate.
Setelah itu, selanjutnya diubah tabel – tabel tersebut ke dalam bentuk grafik
sehingga perbedaan yang diinginkan akan jelas kelihatan.
Lampiran 2 Perbandingan Throughput(kbps) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic Access.

Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38

39
40

25 paket /
detik
816
1551
2383
3134
4042
4481
4367
4319
4145
4112
4105
4061
3943
3978
3813

3814
3753
3683
3681
3632
3613
3578
3546
3555
3486
3392
3472
3469
3414
3395
3307
3357
3290
3254
3258

3268
3220
3249
3204
3210

50 paket /
detik
782
1586
2379
3157
3985
4413
4297
4173
4069
4039
3975
3887

3844
3814
3782
3728
3635
3647
3584
3626
3548
3517
3505
3450
3439
3368
3367
3292
3353
3348
3256
3263

3233
3190
3192
3181
3176
3132
3186
3143

100 paket /
detik
768
1565
2419
3232
4047
4144
4036
3968
3877
3822
3783
3733
3654
3625
3597
3568
3544
3498
3428
3397
3348
3402
3345
3309
3278
3275
3228
3202
3223
3138
3152
3143
3103
3102
3072
3073
3078
3028
3016
3019

200 paket /
detik
792
1593
2395
3189
3890
3773
3659
3591
3548
3468
3435
3403
3345
3328
3280
3252
3222
3173
3163
3143
3121
3085
3071
3044
3004
3010
2979
2980
2939
2947
2908
2866
2868
2831
2844
2825
2791
2799
2775
2772

400 paket /
detik
798
1601
2396
3203
3254
3165
3103
3063
3017
2979
2943
2903
2876
2847
2817
2785
2762
2736
2706
2686
2673
2656
2625
2614
2608
2577
2575
2557
2539
2525
2514
2498
2487
2480
2461
2458
2442
2427
2417
2405

4
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 3 Perbandingan

Utilization

Terhadap

Packet

Generation

Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,1361
0,2585
0,3971
0,5223
0,6738
0,7467
0,7278
0,7197
0,691
0,6853
0,6843
0,6771
0,657
0,663
0,6354
0,6359
0,6252
0,6144
0,6132
0,6053
0,602
0,5966
0,5914
0,5923
0,5812
0,5657
0,5787
0,5782
0,5691
0,5658
0,5516
0,5594
0,5479
0,5417
0,5429
0,5446
0,537
0,5418
0,5344
0,5349

50 paket /
detik
0,1303
0,2644
0,3966
0,5263
0,6641
0,7354
0,7158
0,6956
0,6783
0,6732
0,6624
0,6475
0,6408
0,6353
0,63
0,6214
0,6062
0,6077
0,5974
0,6045
0,5916
0,5862
0,5844
0,575
0,5735
0,5613
0,5608
0,5483
0,5586
0,5583
0,5424
0,5435
0,5386
0,5313
0,5325
0,5302
0,529
0,5214
0,5315
0,5231

100 paket /
detik
0,128
0,2609
0,4032
0,5386
0,6774
0,6908
0,673
0,6612
0,6459
0,637
0,6306
0,622
0,6091
0,6042
0,5995
0,5947
0,5902
0,5827
0,5716
0,5663
0,5581
0,5671
0,5572
0,5513
0,5467
0,5456
0,5383
0,5339
0,5369
0,5234
0,5254
0,5241
0,517
0,5166
0,5126
0,5118
0,5131
0,5043
0,5023
0,5038

200 paket /
detik
0,132
0,2655
0,3991
0,5316
0,6484
0,6287
0,6098
0,5985
0,5913
0,5781
0,5724
0,5672
0,5575
0,5547
0,5466
0,5421
0,5368
0,5291
0,5275
0,5238
0,5202
0,5143
0,5118
0,507
0,5007
0,5017
0,4965
0,4967
0,4898
0,4908
0,4847
0,4783
0,4779
0,4715
0,4738
0,4704
0,4648
0,4667
0,4629
0,4616

400 paket /
detik
0,133
0,2669
0,3994
0,5338
0,5421
0,5275
0,5172
0,5105
0,5028
0,4965
0,4904
0,4837
0,4791
0,4741
0,4691
0,4643
0,4605
0,4563
0,4515
0,447
0,4457
0,4429
0,4375
0,4361
0,4344
0,4296
0,4293
0,4258
0,4231
0,4208
0,419
0,4163
0,414
0,4141
0,4108
0,4095
0,4071
0,4043
0,4036
0,4009

5
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 4 Perbandingan Media Access Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
5,49
6,395
8,18
11,355
18,168
39,61166667
50,24857143
60,1725
70,12
77,225
86,54272727
98,705
106,2884615
115,6857143
128,2306667
137,6525
154,3188235
159,2483333
176,0594737
182,0365
185,5180952
198,3795455
219,4017391
213,85125
248,0148
261,6123077
254,3240741
267,8371429
281,6358621
287,238
314,9970968
313,2115625
340,1481818
371,6317647
383,5785714
382,1147222
381,1421622
390,9402632
417,1258947
402,5385

50 paket /
detik
2,82
3,225
4,26
5,9525
9,336
20,70666667
26,27428571
30,8025
35,16111111
39,899
44,36272727
50,36416667
54,42769231
59,01
64,86266667
69,02
76,40647059
79,89277778
87,53263158
89,4915
97,02761905
99,90318182
107,3404348
114,6945833
121,47
127,4557692
131,7414815
142,4439286
143,6944828
145,7463333
154,0058065
158,860625
166,3109091
175,1605882
182,0791429
185,2816667
191,1248649
201,8307895
198,2410256
209,546

100 paket /
detik
1,46
1,715
2,32
3,3675
5,872
11,41
13,78428571
16,0675
18,44666667
20,579
23,08272727
25,8075
28,39230769
30,89142857
33,44333333
36,10125
38,64529412
41,00888889
43,89421053
47,5575
50,60857143
52,41818182
54,57347826
59,47708333
60,5228
64,65807692
67,38703704
70,63321429
73,95758621
76,546
79,48903226
82,0234375
86,03393939
88,74941176
91,26171429
94,93555556
97,97756757
101,6981579
105,3058974
107,002

200 paket /
detik
0,83
0,96
1,34
2,015
4,834
6,383333333
7,658571429
8,915
10,17555556
11,47
12,85090909
14,09
15,51923077
16,86357143
18,33866667
19,585625
20,84764706
22,78888889
24,05421053
25,518
26,9347619
28,34954545
30,10521739
31,62708333
33,576
34,73923077
36,27814815
37,675
39,51517241
41,18633333
42,13419355
44,5925
46,31606061
47,87294118
49,75885714
51,16222222
53,41891892
54,71815789
55,8128205
57,99525

400 paket /
detik
0,5
0,6
0,883333333
1,64
3,09
3,776666667
4,514285714
5,26125
5,982222222
6,751
7,496363636
8,314166667
9,069230769
9,848571429
10,71666667
11,45875
12,39235294
13,19666667
14,10315789
14,8635
15,80190476
16,64045455
17,50608696
18,34208333
19,122
20,19423077
21,12296296
22,00214286
22,98448276
23,73033333
24,60580645
25,8065625
26,60575758
27,50823529
28,64657143
29,335
30,59837838
31,23342105
32,55102564
33,41625

6
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 5 Perbandingan

Queuing

Delay

(msec)

Terhadap

Packet

Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,88
1,37
2,516666667
6,525
23,55
1388,036667
5469,584286
8474,035
10655,61
11558,679
13391,68
14770,99
15730,56154
16180,30786
16729,69467
17830,025
18224,48471
19108,11278
19002,60474
19528,6385
19634,67143
20306,19318
20454,6887
20208,17083
21359,5524
21001,765
21061,45926
20829,08321
21762,16931
21589,05
22621,90161
21645,5
21909,86939
22237,38294
22044,474
22609,80278
22211,50865
21958,27553
22897,21026
22965,4225

50 paket /
detik
0,42
0,57
1,496666667
3,505
16,15
1825,443333
5634,134286
8889,66125
10630,77667
12190,136
13528,37
14606,02083
15733,23923
16440,31929
17195,56467
17493,475
18562,33588
18619,01833
19204,26579
19046,0605
19363,11238
19488,79182
20298,93826
20687,13375
20934,6832
21301,86154
21034,02
21309,96857
21618,86552
21415,14233
21840,81484
21880,30063
22228,36333
22091,91265
22072,49829
22175,44389
23012,94
22251,23868
22654,07436
22580,6665

100 paket /
detik
0,22
0,345
0,81
2,515
21,226
3452,188333
6982,871429
9860,095
11592,56
13090,276
14256,55182
15116,89917
16404,29385
16978,38
17254,39067
18052,485
18683,37118
19122,80778
19369,53895
19750,2415
20062,8419
20250,14227
20618,48391
20723,55875
21069,0204
21033,22577
21265,42
21424,6175
21637,69172
21600,59333
21726,33452
22065,53344
22115,60515
22190,78941
22230,33743
22282,09583
22521,0473
22639,64079
22491,13179
22676,281

200 paket /
detik
0,13
0,195
0,643333333
2,06
548,57
5347,828333
8626,221429
10723,21
13015,34
14049,285
15361,62273
16008,88917
16894,68077
17702,07286
18113,15467
18540,78875
19232,77588
19496,925
19725,86526
19945,1
20438,49476
20715,49455
20880,66043
20991,98292
21327,4252
21504,44769
21594,55148
21824,12179
21781,81448
22060,34033
21983,2829
22233,26375
22423,33848
22528,55265
22560,36371
22470,75528
22721,03297
22853,28447
22811,63487
22715,4625

400 paket /
detik
0,09
0,165
0,593333333
6,355
4851,088
8341,275
11070,95429
13026,29
14524,81778
15572,101
16636,54909
17418,25833
18047,37154
18524,42429
19217,08667
19583,49688
19890,43
20213,17778
20533,64789
20831,938
21029,1581
21100,56773
21350,92522
21610,33208
21702,9884
21971,56808
21986,13037
22052,88643
22274,99379
22291,76133
22461,0071
22481,87375
22654,35121
22621,21353
22762,21743
22900,99806
22967,34432
22922,885
22981,99949
23185,36275

7
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 6 Perbandingan Total Packet Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
6,37
7,765
10,69666667
17,8775
41,718
1427,643333
5519,831429
8534,20625
10725,73111
11635,905
13478,22364
14869,6925
15836,85077
16295,99214
16857,92667
17967,67688
18378,80294
19267,67688
19178,66421
19710,674
19820,18905
20504,57409
20674,09217
20422,02208
21607,568
21263,37692
21315,78556
21096,92036
22043,80483
21876,28933
22936,89774
21958,71219
22250,01636
22609,01353
22428,05314
22991,91722
22592,65108
22349,21447
23314,33641
23367,9605

50 paket /
detik
3,24
3,795
5,753333333
9,4575
25,488
1846,148333
5660,41
8920,46375
10665,93889
12230,033
13572,73455
14656,38417
15787,66615
16499,32714
17260,428
17562,49375
18638,74235
18698,90889
19291,79842
19135,5525
19460,14143
19588,69545
20406,27957
20801,82833
21056,1532
21429,31692
21165,76222
21452,41286
21762,55793
21560,88833
21994,82161
22039,16125
22394,67394
22267,07294
22254,57686
22360,72611
23204,06405
22453,07
22852,31538
22790,2135

100 paket /
detik
1,68
2,06
3,126666667
5,8725
27,096
3463,598333
6996,654286
9876,16125
11611,00556
13110,856
14279,63273
15142,70583
16432,68538
17009,25357
17287,832
18088,58688
18722,01882
19163,81667
19413,43316
19797,7985
20113,45143
20302,56
20673,0587
20783,03458
21129,5436
21097,885
21332,80593
21495,24929
21711,64897
21677,13833
21805,82452
22147,5575
22201,63939
22279,53971
22321,60029
22377,03222
22619,02459
22741,33868
22597,43718
22783,28425

200 paket /
detik
0,96
1,16
1,983333333
4,075
553,406
5354,213333
8633,878571
10732,125
13025,51556
14060,753
15374,47364
16022,9775
16910,19923
17718,93571
18131,49467
18560,37375
19253,62353
19519,71556
19749,92
19970,616
20465,43095
20743,84545
20910,76739
21023,60917
21361,0016
21539,18654
21630,82778
21861,7975
21821,33103
22101,52633
22025,41839
22277,8575
22469,65576
22576,42529
22610,122
22521,91639
22774,45162
22908,00105
22867,51615
22773,45825

400 paket /
detik
0,59
0,765
1,476666667
7,995
4854,176
8345,053333
11075,46714
13031,55
14530,80222
15578,854
16644,04727
17426,57167
18056,43769
18534,27357
19227,804
19594,95625
19902,82353
20226,37389
20547,75105
20846,8025
21044,95905
21117,20636
21368,4313
21628,67333
21722,1116
21991,76308
22007,2537
22074,88857
22297,97931
22315,49267
22485,61355
22507,68031
22680,95576
22648,72235
22790,866
22930,33194
22997,9427
22954,11842
23014,55231
23218,781

8
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 7 Perbandingan Jitter (msec) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi Basic Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
8,87
11,33
16,82333333
30,8625
67,63
368,0983333
393,3442857
399,44375
400,1477778
398,787
394,5790909
390,8466667
388,9646154
384,2807143
383,9333333
380,423125
378,3017647
375,7494444
376,3352632
373,256
372,8947619
370,1477273
367,103913
370,985
359,3148
365,455
365,4166667
365,9353571
361,3551724
363,7623333
355,8993548
362,7615625
361,7939394
359,4208824
358,7357143
358,2761111
359,102973
360,0902632
354,7648718
356,113

50 paket /
detik
4,45
5,315
9,34
15,785
47,068
368,23
399,4328571
403,0425
399,7311111
397,617
395,55
392,0241667
387,7153846
386,5271429
383,334
383,1925
379,4905882
378,5161111
375,9194737
376,8935
375,02
375,1781818
371,3778261
369,495
367,7152
367,3073077
368,3040741
367,0996429
365,0203448
366,0263333
364,3996774
363,730625
361,6757576
362,4573529
362,354
362,3302778
358,0994595
361,9155263
359,8364103
359,4915

100 paket /
detik
2,28
2,91
4,936666667
9,9025
52,202
400,69
405,7142857
404,7075
400,6033333
396,984
393,2336364
391,6866667
388,0207692
385,55
384,3953333
381,755625
379,1388235
377,3433333
376,2042105
375,2125
373,3790476
373,025
371,3086957
370,7745833
369,074
368,6892308
368,0640741
367,1928571
366,2855172
366,547
365,9967742
363,90875
363,6384848
363,2882353
363,0888571
363,2547222
362,0691892
361,2394737
361,7535897
361,18075

200 paket /
detik
1,25
1,56
3,223333333
6,94
300,824
406,0733333
405,3671429
402,30625
397,9255556
394,442
391,0327273
389,0433333
386,4515385
383,6078571
381,8086667
380,2925
377,6170588
376,32
375,5057895
374,585
372,4833333
371,0968182
370,153913
369,7383333
368,1176
367,1626923
366,7518519
366,0457143
366,1768966
364,8873333
365,0519355
363,7721875
362,8036364
362,335
362,0417143
362,7880556
361,4778378
360,7210526
360,904359
361,479

400 paket /
detik
0,73
1,03
2,356666667
14,1475
408,102
406,2433333
401,6657143
397,565
393,9144444
390,685
387,1090909
384,39
382,0592308
380,34
377,5446667
376,235
374,7329412
373,6127778
372,0315789
370,834
369,9433333
369,2240909
368,383913
366,9445833
366,554
365,3953846
365,3807407
364,9410714
363,8596552
363,7753333
362,7429032
363,040625
362,0887879
362,2352941
361,3288571
360,69
360,402973
360,3805263
360,3623077
359,42275

9
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 8 Perbandingan Throughput (kbps) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS / CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
833
1535
2472
3280
3907
4856
5518
5667
5657
5664
5660
5661
5655
5662
5653
5659
5659
5646
5654
5653
5652
5652
5649
5645
5651
5643
5641
5643
5643
5651
5639
5636
5638
5643
5635
5642
5642
5625
5629
5634

50 paket /
detik
773
1642
2349
3171
3983
4780
5365
5373
5357
5364
5354
5352
5361
5349
5352
5345
5349
5349
5349
5339
5336
5334
5340
5326
5333
5329
5332
5331
5320
5322
5324
5314
5329
5321
5315
5318
5314
5314
5305
5308

100 paket /
detik
768
1578
2391
3261
4051
4797
4865
4850
4842
4845
4833
4830
4842
4838
4827
4819
4819
4814
4810
4802
4806
4792
4799
4792
4789
4795
4792
4795
4777
4778
4782
4782
4767
4770
4771
4763
4768
4765
4767
4755

200 paket /
detik
774
1601
2387
3236
3998
4094
4081
4081
4079
4067
4060
4053
4053
4043
4048
4033
4032
4023
4017
4014
4020
4004
3999
3989
4002
3992
3998
3979
3980
3982
3978
3966
3968
3964
3965
3963
3955
3946
3957
3944

400 paket /
detik
801
1614
2395
3118
3112
3098
3091
3086
3086
3072
3072
3058
3061
3044
3046
3050
3033
3030
3026
3014
3009
3014
3009
3000
2996
2993
2983
2981
2984
2977
2965
2967
2966
2963
2968
2961
2963
2959
2945
2948

10
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 9 Perbandingan

Utilization

Terhadap

Packet

Generation

Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS / CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,1386
0,256
0,4121
0,5467
0,6513
0,8904
0,9197
0,9444
0,9427
0,9441
0,9431
0,9436
0,9427
0,9438
0,9423
0,9431
0,9425
0,941
0,9426
0,9418
0,9418
0,9421
0,9412
0,9407
0,9412
0,9402
0,9402
0,9399
0,9405
0,942
0,9394
0,9396
0,9396
0,9405
0,9396
0,9407
0,9405
0,9382
0,9381
0,9387

50 paket /
detik
0,1289
0,2737
0,3916
0,5283
0,6639
0,7967
0,8941
0,8955
0,8927
0,8941
0,8922
0,892
0,8935
0,8915
0,8919
0,8906
0,8914
0,8913
0,8915
0,89
0,8896
0,8893
0,8898
0,888
0,8892
0,8882
0,8886
0,8887
0,8868
0,8865
0,8873
0,8864
0,8883
0,8865
0,8862
0,8857
0,8854
0,8859
0,8844
0,8849

100 paket /
detik
0,1279
0,263
0,3985
0,5434
0,6752
0,7994
0,8109
0,8083
0,8071
0,8075
0,8057
0,8052
0,807
0,806
0,8042
0,8033
0,8033
0,8024
0,8018
0,7999
0,8007
0,7987
0,7996
0,7982
0,7984
0,799
0,7984
0,799
0,7966
0,797
0,7966
0,7967
0,7946
0,7952
0,7951
0,7939
0,7948
0,7939
0,7943
0,7929

200 paket /
detik
0,129
0,2668
0,3979
0,5394
0,6662
0,6823
0,6802
0,6802
0,6798
0,6776
0,6768
0,6756
0,6756
0,6736
0,6744
0,6723
0,672
0,6704
0,6697
0,6688
0,6698
0,6676
0,6668
0,665
0,6671
0,6657
0,666
0,6634
0,664
0,6637
0,6627
0,6607
0,6616
0,6606
0,6606
0,66
0,6591
0,6575
0,6595
0,6573

400 paket /
detik
0,1335
0,269
0,3993
0,5197
0,5185
0,5163
0,5152
0,5144
0,5145
0,5122
0,5123
0,5098
0,5101
0,5076
0,5074
0,5086
0,5057
0,5051
0,5042
0,502
0,5013
0,5022
0,5015
0,5005
0,4995
0,4992
0,4974
0,4966
0,4975
0,4967
0,4943
0,4947
0,4948
0,4938
0,4951
0,4936
0,4932
0,4932
0,491
0,4914

11
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 10 Perbandingan Media Access Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS /
CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
5,72
6,29
7,893333333
9,6325
11,712
16,55833333
29,36285714
43,35375
50,96888889
53,317
61,87727273
69,21166667
74,83615385
81,35857143
83,40533333
93,015
102,1794118
101,1727778
108,0836842
113,903
120,6804762
126,8813636
130,68
137,6154167
140,2984
147,41
156,3996296
161,2032143
166,8010345
180,1766667
173,4648387
184,618125
190,1184848
204,75
206,4394286
215,6827778
214,6381081
215,7781579
223,2384615
238,165

50 paket /
detik
2,92
3,45
4,043333333
4,9825
6,622
9,31
19,37142857
23,8125
26,51555556
29,757
32,82545455
35,57583333
39,27769231
41,99857143
45,05333333
47,80875
51,53883253
54,06111111
57,44315789
60,9775
62,87809524
67,39863636
69,80086957
72,58791667
76,856
78,60961538
84,0362963
85,68821429
87,84448276
91,26266667
94,49096774
97,5715625
103,7890909
103,4620588
106,2825714
109,8358333
112,7945946
115,3444737
117,5948718
121,261

100 paket /
detik
1,58
1,845
2,273333333
2,9625
4,108
7,378333333
11,33714286
13,00625
14,77222222
16,39
18,04636364
19,81666667
21,60615385
23,345
24,68333333
26,646875
28,03823529
30,22111111
31,55368421
33,2425
34,89952381
36,64772727
38,28086957
40,17333333
41,4952
43,41769231
45,38777778
46,89107143
48,33758621
50,12066667
52,23258065
53,638125
54,84606061
56,93470588
58,73657143
60,83138889
62,44459459
64,19394737
65,67692308
67,30775

200 paket /
detik
0,93
1,11
1,393333333
1,985
3,518
5,846666667
6,831428571
7,86125
8,891111111
9,882
10,85636364
11,85916667
12,88846154
13,85642857
14,94066667
15,903125
16,94941176
17,98944444
18,89052632
19,9105
21,00761905
22,01090909
23,07347826
23,96375
25,3072
26,09423077
27,27740741
28,015
29,17896552
30,32633333
31,32064516
32,3728125
33,31878788
34,37
35,22857143
36,50472222
37,35567588
38,38210526
39,79615385
40,7435

400 paket /
detik
0,61
0,755
1,08
2,465
3,21
3,86
4,517142857
5,1825
5,851111111
6,501
7,202727273
7,860833333
8,561538462
9,166428571
9,886666667
10,595625
11,23470588
11,89944444
12,63684211
13,2735
13,93
14,70818182
15,38304348
16,0425
16,7128
17,39653846
18,08259259
18,77214286
19,55931034
20,185
20,89709677
21,6196875
22,39969697
22,96970585
23,81257143
24,43722222
25,10756757
25,99526316
26,56769231
27,38425

12
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 11 Perbandingan

Queuing

Delay

(msec)

Terhadap

Packet

Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS /
CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,93
1,115
2,29
3,2475
5,914
16,54833333
518,7757143
3436,88375
5331,574444
7245,691
9019,903636
10490,605
11570,63154
13043,44571
12813,93467
13542,23938
14254,16647
14616,35667
15949,53947
16081,0475
16385,9619
16908,69818
17608,62435
17467,8725
17908,1056
17600,49269
18418,96185
17942,47893
18775,78414
19399,82933
19213,26452
19396,38906
19283,82606
19964,89647
19862,912
19806,64278
20039,48405
20448,17132
20199,22128
20373,17525

50 paket /
detik
0,44
0,755
1,003333333
1,795
3,882
11,94666667
1176,098571
4300,13
6405,402222
8621,906
9606,578182
10754,94917
12222,47846
12853,52929
14023,296
14516,3075
15153,35706
15686,08722
16413,92895
16556,8105
16940,54714
17400,86727
17962,72217
17873,93292
18092,4972
18512,33423
18910,1763
18945,15357
19397,51
19718,774
19982,73194
19854,08969
20072,34091
19942,65206
20280,99857
20381,97194
20407,94703
20608,51395
20583,23718
20642,4545

100 paket /
detik
0,26
0,37
0,663333333
1,4
4,06
64,24833333
3363,742857
5863,23
8046,206667
10017,313
11120,53545
12254,445
13478,18615
14415,24429
14961,66467
15546,27813
16183,48059
16541,39556
17059,62263
17349,8195
17978,57048
17966,32955
18570,46696
18793,10208
18960,2344
19347,18692
19390,93741
19744,93071
19749,74207
19985,01233
20304,55903
20355,78219
20482,98242
20553,19147
20868,79886
20791,25583
21066,37351
21132,27
21276,09744
21269,5535

200 paket /
detik
0,16
0,255
0,506666667
1,59
20,114
3719,218333
6780,211429
8973,11
10956,51889
12253,682
13461,48545
14401,60417
15429,95769
16020,13429
16573,51467
17024,53875
17618,05588
18003,83778
18334,57789
18658,341
19072,22619
19259,80091
19468,37435
19781,7025
20100,108
20290,52962
20425,28705
20421,16643
20727,30759
20837,106
21044,37194
21137,10813
21171,74061
21307,50235
21428,24229
21517,12
21669,26946
21703,32342
21921,67538
21923,7905

400 paket /
detik
0,13
0,26
0,836666667
407,3925
5425,818
8856,285
11202,03714
12844,0325
14379,24
15353,708
16291,79909
17020,025
17711,73
18127,46
18681,92267
19089,68063
19418,61294
19640,73611
20048,93316
20240,7845
20453,03857
20700,49045
20867,22304
21075,60958
21201,5484
21404,08038
21567,38
21669,39679
21729,16448
21874,98533
22002,88613
22032,21438
22188,63152
22317,03118
22323,61943
22406,75556
22511,75784
22605,62421
22642,05487
22690,154

13
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 12 Perbandingan Total Packet Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS /
CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
6,65
7,4
10,18666667
12,8775
17,626
33,10666667
548,14
3480,2375
5382,543333
7301,006
9081,78
10559,81667
11645,46923
13124,80429
12897,342
13635,2575
14356,34529
14717,53
16057,62316
16194,951
16506,64286
17035,58
17739,30609
17605,48792
18048,4048
17747,90346
18575,36111
18103,68214
18942,58379
19580,00733
19386,72871
19581,00719
19473,94455
20169,64706
20069,35029
20022,32556
20254,12027
20663,95
20422,45872
20611,34

50 paket /
detik
3,37
4,205
5,046666667
6,78
10,498
21,26
1195,468571
4323,94125
6431,922222
8651,66
9639,402727
10790,525
12261,75538
12895,52857
14068,348
14564,115
15204,89706
15740,14722
16471,37263
16617,788
17003,42381
17468,26455
18032,52043
17946,52167
18169,3536
18590,94423
18994,21111
19030,84286
19485,35483
19810,03767
20077,22161
19951,66
20176,13
20046,11324
20387,28086
20491,80778
20520,74216
20723,85868
20700,83205
20763,715

100 paket /
detik
1,84
2,22
2,936666667
4,3675
8,168
71,62833333
3375,08
5876,23625
8060,976667
10033,701
11138,58091
12274,26167
13499,79385
14438,58857
14986,34667
15572,92438
16211,51882
16571,61611
17091,17789
17383,062
18013,46857
18002,97727
18608,7487
18833,275
19001,7292
19390,60538
19436,3263
19791,82214
19798,07828
20035,13267
20356,79194
20409,42094
20537,82909
20610,12559
20927,534
20852,08833
21128,81838
21196,46447
21341,77308
21336,861

200 paket /
detik
1,08
1,365
1,903333333
3,575
23,63
3725,065
6787,042857
8980,97
10965,40889
12263,565
13472,34091
14413,46583
15442,84385
16033,99
16588,45467
17040,44188
17635,00529
18021,82667
18353,46579
18678,2525
19093,23238
19281,81182
19491,44739
19805,66833
20125,4148
20316,62577
20452,56333
20449,18143
20756,48517
20867,433
21075,69194
21169,48125
21205,05909
21341,87176
21463,47114
21553,62444
21706,62568
21741,70553
21961,47205
21964,5335

400 paket /
detik
0,74
1,02
1,916666667
409,8575
5429,024
8860,147
11206,55143
12849,215
14385,09222
15360,207
16299,00364
17027,88583
17720,29154
18136,62929
18691,80667
19100,275
19429,84647
19652,63389
20061,56947
20254,0575
20466,96762
20715,19909
20882,60609
21091,65125
21218,2612
21421,47692
21585,46111
21688,16821
21748,72414
21895,16967
22023,7829
22053,83594
22211,03061
22340
22347,43171
22431,19306
22536,86595
22631,61947
22668,62333
22717,538

14
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 13 Perbandingan Jitter (msec) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11a dengan Teknologi RTS / CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
9,15
10,27
15,21666667
19,5775
27,358
55,33666667
242,5042857
378,31875
383,0366667
396,234
400,6545455
394,9125
395,2453846
395,3678571
394,9246667
394,39
391,2123529
390,0133333
386,4410526
383,2385
384,6166667
382,4877273
380,2743478
382,1033333
380,3892
379,6376923
378,0822222
379,3925
375,1868966
373,4016667
374,956129
374,2159375
373,8569697
369,9955882
370,928
371,3677778
371,2872973
368,7005263
369,5466667
368,55075

50 paket /
detik
4,58
5,855
7,32
10,235
16,438
35,18
356,4771429
402,9425
402,79
401,172
401,9818182
399,7041667
396,9461538
396,5142857
392,8426667
392,8575
390,0858824
388,7816667
386,71
385,6205
384,7780952
383,3381818
380,7391304
381,43
380,3292
379,0657692
377,6714815
376,9989286
375,1265517
373,154
372,3054839
372,5475
372,4860606
373,2514706
371,1782857
370,4416667
369,9916216
369,1242105
369,4807692
370,0835

100 paket /
detik
2,47
2,975
4,263333333
6,605
13,252
116,615
383,0271429
404,90875
405,7622222
400,921
401,3318182
397,1691667
395,6476923
393,4107143
391,6086667
389,99125
387,9635294
386,7577778
384,9068421
383,366
381,8904762
381,7327273
379,2586957
378,4704167
377,0756
376,31
376,3066667
374,3857143
374,7858621
373,433
372,0941935
372,0190625
371,4751515
371,1805882
369,79
370,1869444
368,187027
368,5278947
367,7371795
367,70825

200 paket /
detik
1,35
1,785
2,693333333
5,77
42,664
402,37
406,1114286
403,54875
401,44
398,753
395,8690909
393,7775
390,4153846
388,7528571
387,146
385,584375
383,2435294
381,7833333
380,7647368
379,5365
377,8452381
376,8368182
376,4617391
374,8833333
373,7004
372,5430769
372,1862963
372,0071429
371,0317241
370,1196667
369,3941935
369,1178125
368,9718182
368,2441176
367,5982857
367,2452778
366,3340541
366,3907895
365,3541026
365,33175

400 paket /
detik
0,88
1,33
2,863333333
286,95
407,396
404,7183333
401,6371429
397,56875
393,89
391,432
388,5018182
385,9975
383,5230769
381,7185714
379,7213333
378,11
376,6829412
375,8233333
374,1378947
373,2645
372,4471429
371,2790909
370,6291304
369,49875
368,8832
368,1730769
367,2851852
366,8478571
366,5637931
365,746
365,1722581
364,96
364,2487879
363,5229412
363,62
363,2675
362,7697297
362,1821053
361,9041026
361,791

15
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 14 Perbandingan Throughput(kbps) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
827
1618
2294
3212
4032
4376
4256
4131
4085
4000
4012
3881
3843
3805
3796
3668
3674
3608
3536
3525
3527
3514
3495
3447
3409
3360
3398
3370
3320
3289
3247
3244
3251
3172
3212
3195
3185
3156
3095
3112

50 paket /
detik
764
1606
2342
3202
3926
4095
4026
3969
3861
3829
3735
3681
3624
3623
3552
3531
3501
3452
3421
3421
3376
3330
3320
3306
3289
3247
3220
3206
3167
3191
3145
3099
3101
3045
3052
3023
3003
3007
2999
2988

100 paket /
detik
773
1579
2362
3214
3748
3670
3602
3534
3493
3446
3398
3333
3319
3294
3243
3222
3177
3141
3129
3093
3080
3074
3038
3008
2990
2988
2941
2926
2896
2899
2878
2836
2859
2821
2787
2801
2778
2782
2739
2738

200 paket /
detik
776
1598
2373
3107
3070
3033
2990
2958
2914
2885
2844
2810
2782
2756
2726
2714
2690
2689
2637
2630
2618
2590
2568
2550
2536
2533
2512
2503
2485
2472
2458
2440
2458
2410
2389
2403
2367
2374
2364
2342

400 paket /
detik
803
1584
2272
2283
2273
2256
2245
2217
2203
2169
2157
2132
2112
2104
2103
2080
2061
2037
2027
2009
2006
1996
1981
1977
1953
1946
1938
1927
1925
1914
1916
1892
1872
1882
1892
1864
1853
1855
1836
1836

16
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 15 Perbandingan

Utilization

Terhadap

Packet

Generation

Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,1504
0,2941
0,4172
0,5841
0,733
0,7959
0,7739
0,7512
0,7427
0,7273
0,7296
0,7054
0,6989
0,6913
0,6903
0,667
0,6681
0,6562
0,6428
0,6407
0,6411
0,6394
0,6357
0,6268
0,6199
0,6108
0,6179
0,6119
0,6039
0,5978
0,5903
0,5899
0,5916
0,5761
0,5839
0,5809
0,5792
0,5745
0,5628
0,5651

50 paket /
detik
0,1388
0,292
0,4258
0,5823
0,7138
0,7445
0,732
0,7216
0,7019
0,6963
0,6789
0,6694
0,6595
0,6588
0,646
0,6417
0,6371
0,6275
0,6219
0,6221
0,6138
0,6058
0,6038
0,6012
0,5979
0,591
0,5852
0,5827
0,5757
0,5802
0,572
0,5638
0,5639
0,5539
0,5548
0,5497
0,5459
0,5466
0,5458
0,5432

100 paket /
detik
0,1405
0,2872
0,4295
0,5845
0,6815
0,6674
0,6551
0,6422
0,6353
0,6263
0,6179
0,606
0,6031
0,5985
0,5898
0,5856
0,5779
0,5709
0,5685
0,5625
0,56
0,559
0,5525
0,5469
0,5436
0,5432
0,5346
0,5327
0,5266
0,5269
0,5226
0,5153
0,5198
0,5129
0,5072
0,5097
0,5053
0,5057
0,4977
0,4977

200 paket /
detik
0,1411
0,2906
0,4316
0,565
0,5583
0,5516
0,5434
0,5377
0,5295
0,5246
0,517
0,5109
0,5057
0,5012
0,4958
0,4936
0,4893
0,4886
0,4788
0,4784
0,4759
0,4707
0,4671
0,4634
0,4609
0,4605
0,457
0,4554
0,4513
0,4495
0,4469
0,4437
0,447
0,4383
0,4342
0,4373
0,4303
0,4319
0,4299
0,4261

400 paket /
detik
0,146
0,288
0,4133
0,4151
0,4132
0,4103
0,4084
0,4032
0,4003
0,3943
0,3923
0,388
0,3836
0,3824
0,3826
0,378
0,3744
0,3706
0,3686
0,3657
0,3653
0,3628
0,3601
0,3591
0,3557
0,3539
0,3522
0,3508
0,35
0,348
0,3487
0,3438
0,3405
0,3425
0,3436
0,3391
0,337
0,3375
0,3343
0,3333

17
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 16 Perbandingan Media Access Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
6,11
7,45
9,346666667
13,825
23,416
43,03333333
51,60428571
61,50875
70,26222222
79,652
87,22454545
100,6483333
106,2223077
116,6385714
127,284
138,7175
150,2688235
161,3055556
171,6057895
188,318
187,32
210,0804545
221,9586957
222,1716667
239,316
254,9388462
269,1055556
285,0664286
287,0193103
297,5586667
319,1193548
327,8653125
342,2869697
357,1961765
358,4062857
376,0425
384,1778378
398,9081579
421,8748718
409,27225

50 paket /
detik
3,26
3,935
5,12
7,975
12,722
23,44833333
27,87428571
32,5725
37,32222222
41,917
47,51727273
52,10583333
57,89538462
62,40785714
67,82266667
72,7575
77,88647059
83,81555556
89,15473684
94,6575
100,73
105,855
112,1886957
117,89375
122,9292
128,0138462
137,0622222
143,61
147,3503448
150,5516667
162,5951613
166,72375
174,2727273
181,8070588
187,6711429
197,0738889
203,0927027
204,7157895
212,375641
213,71925

100 paket /
detik
1,83
2,195
3,04
4,98
10,61
13,09666667
15,46857143
17,9925
20,54
23,312
25,76909091
28,92333333
31,47307692
34,17571429
37,19066667
40,1425
43,31235294
46,12277778
48,95631579
51,54
54,42
57,83954545
61,0526087
64,85291667
66,91
70,13769231
73,38888889
76,93535714
81,49551724
82,63866667
86,69290323
90,08875
93,56090909
97,47970588
102,12
104,2813889
106,5513514
111,4984211
114,7917949
118,52775

200 paket /
detik
1,12
1,425
2,193333333
5,01
6,48
7,883333333
9,305714286
10,86375
12,41111111
13,879
15,54
17,12166667
18,56461538
20,28785714
22,04866667
23,54125
25,12176471
26,76277778
28,48631579
30,45
32,14666667
33,81636364
35,69086957
37,7375
39,3492
41,32153846
43,22925926
44,91571429
46,32344828
48,41233333
50,71225806
52,564375
54,45424242
56,35941176
58,56685714
59,98138889
62,64567568
63,84842105
66,02102564
68,45

400 paket /
detik
0,81
1,135
2,62
3,505
4,388
5,321666667
6,26
7,22875
8,201111111
9,185
10,20636364
11,25666667
12,27615385
13,325
14,34533333
15,449375
16,49294118
17,57444444
18,55631579
19,865
20,86666667
22,08818182
23,06130435
24,47916667
25,4744
26,41692308
27,92444444
29,02607143
30,16413793
31,552
32,55709677
33,8028125
34,95818182
36,04823529
37,14028571
38,91916667
39,86594595
41,05289474
42,39615385
43,52075

18
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 17 Perbandingan

Queuing

Delay

(msec)

Terhadap

Packet

Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
1
1,87
3,303333333
11,52
60,584
2391,835
5084,872857
9054,59375
10782,36111
11738,241
13510,65273
14998,2125
15425,69308
16103,53357
17487,29867
17408,68938
17972,31353
18788,97944
18843,69
19703,6005
19651,97571
20007,24045
20444,46609
19983,13875
20662,524
21024,88192
20804,74333
21453,53393
21418,70862
21582,716
21176,26903
22380,32375
21880,64152
22461,30235
22328,06371
22133,35
22660,5573
22727,34658
22551,62564
23010,7915

50 paket /
detik
0,54
1,075
1,99
7,945
34,696
3728,376667
6958,191429
9374,14625
11195,04667
12866,001
14526,28091
15131,3825
16444,45923
16863,48571
17496,072
17981,81125
18546,97059
19023,76
19229,88895
19404,878
20160,08524
20238,47227
20430,95435
20962,70458
20502,844
20987,43077
21008,0663
21269,53071
21668,55448
22017,02533
21941,84194
22065,05719
22194,39818
21755,86412
22324,30286
22242,35861
22373,75757
22206,43289
22948,68769
22490,29575

100 paket /
detik
0,35
0,58
1,49
6,7125
1750,228
6128,31
9002,445714
11296,055
12789,89333
14171,608
15192,72364
16312,50417
17010,85769
17680,64286
18369,002
19027,39688
19405,44353
19648,01056
20196,46842
20191,436
20507,71905
20667,65682
20978,10087
21295,505
21176,6256
21328,9
21660,1163
21680,01286
21941,24655
21814,71367
22152,54
22307,73031
22180,57818
22297,28412
22684,13286
22458,81722
22627,12189
22620,58289
22875,58692
22921,10475

200 paket /
detik
0,25
0,49
2,136666667
567,5225
5797,202
9032,61
11561,53429
13547,065
15034,12556
16062,994
16828,24364
17733,265
18215,04308
18928,315
19440,3
19703,89063
20064,62529
20355,50611
20733,94526
20911,349
21103,07143
21386,62591
21492,34435
21678,88333
21814,3124
22196,23846
22192,78148
22322,43464
22407,19724
22559,811
22470,05387
22682,65281
22663,90273
22860,06235
22969,99429
22964,62389
23099,79757
23070,16553
23134,44846
23156,1655

400 paket /
detik
0,28
0,875
1027,34
7149,865
10586,146
13331,12167
14952,08143
16272,57875
17389,91222
18184,772
18876,02182
19499,53583
19868,85385
20359,72143
20626,06267
20921,19625
21165,74706
21415,965
21527,06316
21888,161
21927,16095
22076,95727
22250,35
22429,20625
22542,3804
22638,77808
22788,01185
22863,51393
22976,44621
23027,998
23063,45613
23200,89813
23312,14697
23247,77412
23321,29486
23320,80083
23420,23459
23461,49421
23442,59026
23620,3335

19
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 18 Perbandingan Total Packet Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic
Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
7,11
9,32
12,64666667
25,3425
84,002
2434,868333
5136,477143
9116,1
10852,62222
11817,891
13597,87545
15098,86
15531,91462
16220,17357
17614,58333
17547,40625
18122,58529
18950,28444
19015,29789
19891,9185
19839,29667
20217,32045
20666,42391
20205,30833
20901,842
21279,82115
21073,84926
21738,60107
21705,72759
21880,275
21495,38839
22708,18844
22222,92818
22818,49765
22686,47114
22509,39278
23044,73595
23126,25447
22973,50026
23420,06325

50 paket /
detik
3,8
5,015
7,113333333
15,9175
47,42
3751,823333
6986,064286
9406,7175
11232,36667
12907,917
14573,79727
15183,4875
16502,35462
16925,89571
17563,89467
18054,56938
18624,85706
19107,575
19319,04421
19499,538
20260,81571
20344,32864
20543,14435
21080,59833
20625,7752
21115,44346
21145,12815
21413,14071
21815,90552
22167,577
22104,43935
22231,78156
22368,67091
21937,67088
22511,97343
22439,43222
22576,85189
22411,14763
23161,06205
22704,01575

100 paket /
detik
2,18
2,77
4,53
11,69
1760,836
6141,41
9017,912857
11314,0475
12810,43556
14194,922
15218,49091
16341,43
17042,33077
17714,81714
18406,192
19067,54
19448,75647
19694,13333
20245,42526
20242,976
20562,13857
20752,495
21039,15435
21360,35833
21243,5356
21339,03769
21733,50556
21756,94893
22022,74172
21897,35167
22239,23194
22397,81781
22274,13818
22394,76324
22786,25314
22563,09889
22733,67324
22732,08
22990,37923
23039,63225

200 paket /
detik
1,37
1,915
4,33
572,5325
5803,684
9040,49
11570,84143
13557,93
15046,53667
16076,873
16843,78364
17750,38667
18233,60923
18948,60286
19462,34933
19727,43313
20089,74765
20382,26778
20762,43053
20941,8015
21135,21857
21420,44182
21528,03348
21716,62167
21853,6604
22237,55962
22236,01148
22367,35
22453,52138
22608,22233
22520,76581
22735,2175
22718,35727
22916,42147
23028,562
23024,60667
23162,44324
23134,01447
23200,46923
23224,61375

400 paket /
detik
1,09
2,005
1029,96
7153,37
10590,532
13336,445
14958,34286
16279,80625
17398,11556
18193,956
18886,23091
19510,79333
19881,12923
20373,04929
20640,40733
20936,64563
21182,23882
21433,53667
21545,61895
21908,0265
21948,02714
22099,04636
22273,41043
22453,68708
22567,854
22665,195
22815,9363
22892,54036
23006,61103
23059,551
23096,01452
23234,7
23347,10515
23283,82235
23358,43629
23359,72111
23460,1
23502,54658
23484,98615
23663,8545

20
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 19 Perbandingan Jitter (msec) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi Basic Access.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
9,75
13,25
19,39333333
43,58
142,342
853,52
872,9814286
884,95
884,7577778
875,597
865,44
865,3241667
858,8946154
853,4621429
847,13
847,78
838,7782353
833,255
832,7673684
826,382
825,017619
820,4363636
817,4982609
822,54125
815,3652
811,0111538
814,4962963
804,6471429
805,7462069
806,6163333
808,4116129
793,3059375
798,1187879
797,4744118
793,1194286
799,0505556
792,2802703
789,7826316
794,9092308
786,6395

50 paket /
detik
5,15
7,425
10,82333333
25,93
75,942
864,68
885,99
891,215
882,3088889
873,548
868,5627273
864,5416667
856,1423077
851,9578571
847,0026667
841,148125
838,3576471
835,1405556
831,3347368
831,296
822,6780952
823,7613636
821,7652174
814,0491667
819,7728
814,1646154
815,7018519
811,8839286
805,1972414
805,155
804,4329032
803,2921875
801,9175758
807,6382353
800,1574286
801,2377778
799,0505405
801,4334211
792,945641
798,10775

100 paket /
detik
2,9
3,845
6,916666667
18,6
845,112
895,88
890,4528571
884,635
876,8366667
871,519
863,4245455
856,5341667
850,6938462
847,7214286
841,8213333
836,771875
832,8288235
830,3783333
824,4442105
823,9495
822,072381
820,2418182
817,8421739
813,93375
815,4908
813,7165385
810,2585185
810,5735714
807,0003448
808,062
804,3867742
801,716875
805,22
802,215
797,4348571
801,0391667
800,0140541
799,5192105
796,1630769
795,83075

200 paket /
detik
1,72
2,63
6,94
620,01
895,036
893,32
884,1257143
874,83875
865,8633333
859,356
854,3609091
847,1883333
843,0253846
836,8557143
832,6526667
830,331875
827,0311765
823,9877778
820,7652632
818,686
816,8647619
813,6459091
812,423913
810,4445833
809,178
805,7280769
805,587037
803,5042857
803,027931
801,347
802,4067742
799,725625
798,8409091
796,82
795,8905714
796,1313889
794,8224324
795,6797368
794,0607692
794,04525

400 paket /
detik
1,34
2,885
782,9333333
893,73
888,068
876,5516667
866,6114286
858,08625
850,0422222
843,477
837,7518182
832,4541667
829,2761538
823,8785714
821,5533333
818,998125
816,5194118
814,32
812,4668421
809,02
808,3461905
806,8818182
805,3173913
803,2175
801,8476
800,3692308
799,177037
798,3860714
797,1224138
796,3376667
795,7464516
794,5278125
793,0693939
794,005
792,7822857
792,6363889
791,7937838
791,2584211
791,484359
789,15975

21
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 20 Perbandingan Throughput (kbps) Terhadap Packet Generation
Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi RTS / CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
828
1550
2427
3216
4124
4817
4830
4829
4837
4821
4818
4809
4801
4799
4785
4787
4800
4790
4784
4782
4781
4793
4779
4762
4780
4778
4758
4764
4773
4751
4760
4752
4751
4732
4748
4749
4750
4741
4754
4743

50 paket /
detik
780
1561
2419
3184
4066
4308
4299
4293
4288
4294
4283
4288
4284
4266
4256
4272
4255
4252
4236
4256
4226
4229
4222
4212
4209
4224
4209
4203
4214
4203
4206
4185
4183
4187
4179
4179
4149
4171
4165
4158

100 paket /
detik
764
1605
2410
3244
3529
3526
3525
3508
3503
3511
3490
3481
3494
3473
3474
3449
3457
3463
3454
3445
3429
3408
3436
3414
3402
3398
3406
3401
3389
3396
3390
3372
3386
3353
3379
3369
3360
3352
3337
3347

200 paket /
detik
792
1608
2383
2600
2608
2605
2605
2582
2584
2579
2557
2556
2543
2549
2539
2530
2530
2517
2506
2492
2499
2496
2487
2470
2475
2464
2460
2462
2453
2455
2437
2431
2424
2422
2421
2426
2416
2404
2400
2394

400 paket /
detik
802
1594
1697
1712
1715
1710
1705
1702
1688
1683
1677
1673
1652
1665
1647
1641
1637
1619
1624
1623
1617
1608
1595
1589
1592
1593
1593
1589
1579
1567
1572
1562
1563
1558
1548
1554
1548
1543
1537
1525

22
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 21 Perbandingan

Utilization

Terhadap

Packet

Generation

Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi RTS / CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
0,1505
0,2818
0,4411
0,5848
0,75
0,8757
0,8783
0,878
0,8796
0,8764
0,8758
0,8747
0,873
0,8726
0,8699
0,8703
0,8726
0,8713
0,8701
0,8696
0,8697
0,8711
0,8692
0,8659
0,869
0,8686
0,8645
0,8659
0,8671
0,8639
0,8659
0,8642
0,8639
0,8604
0,8631
0,8631
0,8633
0,862
0,8642
0,8624

50 paket /
detik
0,1418
0,2839
0,4398
0,5792
0,739
0,7834
0,7817
0,7807
0,7798
0,7806
0,7788
0,7796
0,779
0,7757
0,7739
0,7765
0,7734
0,7732
0,77
0,7744
0,768
0,7689
0,7681
0,7659
0,7648
0,7679
0,7651
0,7646
0,7658
0,7645
0,7645
0,7611
0,761
0,7608
0,7597
0,7606
0,7546
0,7586
0,7574
0,7563

100 paket /
detik
0,1389
0,2919
0,4381
0,59
0,6416
0,6412
0,6409
0,6378
0,6368
0,6381
0,6344
0,6329
0,6354
0,6312
0,6316
0,6275
0,6283
0,6296
0,6277
0,626
0,624
0,6201
0,6244
0,6205
0,6185
0,6181
0,6193
0,6176
0,6155
0,6173
0,6165
0,6137
0,6158
0,6103
0,6144
0,612
0,6108
0,6095
0,6076
0,6081

200 paket /
detik
0,1439
0,2923
0,4333
0,4726
0,4744
0,4735
0,4731
0,4693
0,4699
0,4688
0,4649
0,4652
0,4623
0,464
0,4615
0,4599
0,4596
0,4574
0,4553
0,4535
0,4545
0,4538
0,452
0,4492
0,4507
0,448
0,4468
0,448
0,446
0,4465
0,4432
0,4417
0,4412
0,4405
0,4396
0,4414
0,439
0,4375
0,4354
0,4351

400 paket /
detik
0,1458
0,2898
0,3085
0,3111
0,3118
0,311
0,3101
0,3095
0,3071
0,3061
0,3045
0,304
0,3003
0,3026
0,2995
0,2979
0,2973
0,2946
0,2952
0,2947
0,2943
0,2923
0,29
0,289
0,2899
0,2896
0,2895
0,2886
0,2871
0,2856
0,2856
0,284
0,2834
0,2834
0,2814
0,2826
0,281
0,28
0,28
0,2779

23
Universitas Sumatera Utara

Lampiran 22 Perbandingan Media Access Delay (msec) Terhadap Packet
Generation Ratepada IEEE 802.11b dengan Teknologi RTS /
CTS.
Jumlah
User
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

25 paket /
detik
6,48
7,7
9,296666667
12,0025
17,908
36,34666667
45,69857143
53,21875
60,02777778
66,729
73,10454545
79,59916667
86,60538462
93,01571429
98,692
104,884375
114,0011765
123,5311111
127,1042105
135,324
143,1261905
153,5240909
156,0869565
160,9829167
170,1924
175,1623077
181,9111111
197,1814286
199,7265517
207,679
215,2445161
219,4828125
225,1287879
229,4805882
243,926
251,0733333
252,2551351
257,0431579
277,6753846
278,505

50 paket /
detik
3,61
4,25
5,553333333
7,365
12,492
22,09
25,81571429
29,755
33,38333333
37,603
41,41454545
45,4025
49,37538462
52,705
56,722
61,17
64,31294118
68,48944444
71,93315789
76,8285
80,1947619
83,22681818
87,26956522
91,01166667
94,6548
100,8688462
103,4974074
107,3296429
112,1962069
116,1566667
119,3306452
121,914375
127,7912121
132,1694118
134,4097143
140,3119444
141,0343243
147,5226316
152,0746154
153,92275

100 paket /
detik
2,13
2,63
3,576666667
6,1425
11,154
13,47166667
15,78571429
17,9975
20,30222222
22,785
24,97
27,25916667
29,90538462
32,05
34,41866667
36,668125
39,26588235
42,29722222
44,37578947
46,8945
48,84571429
50,93772727
53,86391304
55,72833333
58,3884
60,94269231
63,61703704
66,01678571
68,29517241
71,12766667
74,10483871
75,750625
78,96848485
80,66147059
83,84485714
86,70327778
88,74
91,11947368
93,11461538
96,214

200 paket /
detik
1,46
1,955
3,346666667
6,12
7,644
9,225
10,76142857
12,27875
13,92555556
15,537
17,11909091
18,65083333
20,28153846
22,10142857
23,638
25,218125
27,16176471
28,60277778
30,28473684
31,8195
33,59714286
35,44636364
36,99
38,61166667
40,5592
42,12769231
43,83148148
45,48142857
47,38310345
49,18966667
50,83516129
52,3675
54,25878788
55,82676471
57,82542857
59,57416667
61,19378378
62,78947368
64,71153846
66,625

400 paket /
detik
1,16
2,12
3,533333333
4,675
5,844
7,035
8,211428571
9,45125
10,64888889
11,888
13,09545455
14,3825
15,62538462
16,98428571
18,19933333
19,5025
20,75882353
22,05777778
23,28157895
24,621
26,02714286
27,47318182
28,60913043
29,94375
31,3604
32,75807692
34,09148148
35,50285714
36,70689655
38,156
39,64709677
40,8184375
42,18939394
43,686764