Young People’ Perception of the Determining Factors of Environmental Quality, Case Study of Surabaya- Indonesia - Scientific Repository
glosgo\/
p
Experience in ihe Noturol ond Buili Environmenl:
for Reseorch, Policy, ond Proclice
2 CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS
NTER NATIO
NAL ASSOC IATIO N
UNIVERSITY OF THE
,n,u.o,,ror@
Strathctyde
Glasgow
!vlll"il_Q9ll!
TJ\MS
I
IlI[}ffiuum
22. IAPS
CONFERENCE
Human Experience in the Naturaland Built Environment:
lmplications for Research policy & practice
Patron Karen Anderson, Architecture + Design Scotland
24 lune- 29 tune 2012
Strathclyde University
Glasgow, Scotland
Editors
Ombretta Romice
Edward Edgerton
Kevin Thwaites
ISBN: 978-0-94-764988-3
rM a3ue.raluoc eql jo slue^e lerceds Joqlo ]xeluoc estlce.ld pl-roM-lE3] e oi e:q ss::::
esrl..redxe qcJeosal Ourleru ,iq saLueq] eJoc slr loagar o] alqe ueoq seq ecue.retlc3 3-Mor,l jo eldurexe luellecxe ue sr
EelE eq]]o uorle.teue6at e:nin, eql ssncstp ol ,^,ac0se 3
ut (lrunLruoc uo]leC pue se.ueE leool eq] ]o sraqLuau.r qlrm raq1a6o1 osruedxo g6y1 0u:rc
Llcrqm IJoMleu uorleluesardey pue i{6o1oqdroy1 ueqJn or.l}}o OurleaLl lerceds e 6urpnlou
=
srqj oj elnquiuoc osle slue^e roqlo $rdol lo e6uer aql ssoJce ecrlcerd pue ,(cr1od qore3:=e6puq o1 Lxle o3uereluoo aql 6urlcellor,illecrlrcads uorlnquluoc 1o fuoOelec Mau
sra.:l
,(pn1s esec
'uorlrppe ur 'luasaJd ol peseald
oJe s.rasrue6ro oouaJaluoc.u_
'suotlelueserd reded 6re rerro 6ur.renrlep suorsses
^llercedso
Jeded B, pue srelsod 69 'ersodu,(s ,:Durpnlcur qlpeeJq pue,ilrlenb leuo6decxa,to eurure:Bord crlrluarcs e sluese.Ld srql ,ilan1ca :3
srtll
*
e
gt
'seprseq ojom qcnL! pue 'sluelr.ruo.Jl^ua crlenbe pue c-z
enlen lercos :slelrqel1 lernleu pue a1rlplrM qyM suorleloJ uelrnq luorle^rosuoo I6roua ::
lue^ele.r senssr lelueuuor^ue :luouJdole^ap 3rLlouoca pue uorleraueoer ueq.rn ol sesuoas3leluer.jJuoJr^ue pue lercos:e]n]3nrlserlur pue lueuraoeueu] leuolesue6ro uorlepocisuer) a:
seqceo:dde elqeurelsns :lueLudola^ep leluotuuolr^ue pue ecos ]c sa.ss -l ,crea -^*'-la
Jo alor eql :o] 6urtela: esoq] Ourpnlcur sauroq] eoue.reyo', t- --...= - :,. - -.','
L.uoJJ
acr1celdpuee6ueqcxee0pe|Moul't-]3leeSeJ1oa6uelepiME}ca|,e-i-*=-.-eq] ur suorsses llv burpuelsrepun 1eq1 ;o uorlecr;dde eq1 pue sppoM liric .-. ?--".eq1 ur ecuauedxa ueLrnq ]o aJnieu eq1 1o 6urpueislepun releerO 6utdolenep,Lo e:-:-::oql ur lsaJolur jo snsuesuoc 1eqo16 e 6urlerlsuouap 'palcerle a^eq seueq] a3usjaj-3:
pue
'ssauqci.l eq1 sesse.idxe slce4sqv Jo loo€ s -i
eLll q3il..u,^ lroar 10
^lrlenb
^lts.lo^tp
'u6tsep pue lueueoeueu-L 'lueLudo e^:a
pue elloe.ri
qlua pe6e6ue asoq] pue sreqc.reeser ueemlaq eOueqcxa 6ur1e1r1rce1 iq
^crlodpuE eoEil trrr'
ecue^pe ol slaas pue seoJe eseql urr]lrM r]oleosa.r ur luaLudole^ep pJoc€]
eouaroluoc aql 'sixeluoc plrom Ourdolenep pue podolo^ap Llloq ur suorlecrldLr.r JraL.l] Jelncrt-lec
ur 6u4cege: 'sueour srq] Ag 'luawabeuew pue uolleJuaaaldu pue :uo7eryeAo pue ubtse:
'6uuue1d\xoluoc pue lqdeLboe5:sea:E ureui oelL.l] uo sncoJ o] polr^ur oroM suorlnqrlL::
'luorxuor^Ue ]lrnq pue lernieu oql ur acuer]odxa uEu]nq ]o ouroql lle.la^o oq] L -:
"'
ecrlceld pue ,(crlod 'qcreesar ueamloq e6ueqcxe e6pelmoul Jo] uorjepuno] e se aln]oeltqs-.
adE"Jspuel pue uDrsap ueqrn '^6oloqclsd 1o lrorueure.r; {:eutldtcstptalut ue sassalcx:
pue slcegor srr-{j .(sa1remq1 urnay 16) plellJoqs 1o ,{lrsranruq pue (uolo6pf prempf
'(ectuog euarqurg rg) ep,{1eq1e4g 1o Altsta,rtL;11
rg) puellocg io iseM eL.ll jo
pasrue6ro Illurof ]ue^e^]rsra^run
eql
elrle.roqellqJ e sr ecueroluoc SdVl leuorleu:elul
oql
",ZZ
^q
']cedul lelueluuol^ue pue alersos
esrurldo o1 ,{olod pue ecrlce:d'qcJeosor 6urDprLq'e6ueqcxa pue uor}EcrunurL.uo3 oA}caga
6ur1e1r;rcel ur acuei:odlrr palelleredun seq ]r ocuonbosuoc ul suorleler ]uoL.lruoJrlue-ueL!n!
o1 6ur1e1er seere jo un.rlcads peo.rq e ssorce 6ur1urq1 ieotu. pue q3reosa.r snourouor.E
slr txorj seolnose: peluepece:dun pedolenep seq Ilrunururoc SdVl otl] sree^ I!rLl] JoAo -::
'plolJ or.ll ur asrpedxe pue uorlsJrldde
Jo seo]P olur alelsuer] ol seLxo3]no slr Jo+ pue suorl?-: -:
puoM-leoJ Jo sorlrunlJoddo pue suelqord xaldLum oql o] puodse.r puE ]ce[or o],{lr,:::
qSteeso] serrnbeJ JaAe ueLl] elour sorpnls .rnor^eqoq-lueLUUo.r,^ua jo ]rloueq lelercos e!:
6ursrwrxeyl pouJolur ;;e,r.,i;;en1nu aq o1 6ur1eu uorsrcep ,(cr1od pue actlcerd "to1 elqtsuodsa,
asoql pue saBrunL!ujoc qcJeeser roj ]ueirodu.r oJor.! uoeq lo^au seq ]r ]eq] suea',
seouallelp leluauruoJr^ue pue lercos polercosse slr puB ppoM 6utOueqc ,(lptder s,{epc_g
'qcreaseJ
lol
aJrlcerd pue i{crlod
suorlecrldu.r :luauuoJrAuf llrnE pue leJnleN aql ur ecueuedx3 ueurn;1
oroMrEol
J-
include a sustainability science Group meeting and an initial discussion
on
project on the therapeutic role of construction proiects
in communities.
a
research
we.would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has contributed
to what we are
confident will be a memorabre- and varuabre conference, and in particurar
to thant< ano pay
tribute to the contributions of our three distinguished keynote speakers, professors
ran
Bentley, Nabeel Hamdi and,,Gary Evans. rai Benfley wiil cross
scientific and design
traditions to address the idea that we shourd appry ecorogi'cat thinking
to tne oesig; ot human
settlemenis in an attempt to better understand how to mJke human hlabitats
that"have blnign
ecological impacts. Nabeer Hamdi dears with the changing nature of practrce
in the context
of some of the big issues impacting on people in thelnformal setflements ot
citi* in tne
south' including: the changing scope and purpose of practice; the rife and
organisation of
place; and the nature of professional interventions and the
changing roles and relationships
of practitroners to peopre and Frace. Gary Evans wiil focus on evid''enie revearing
tnai poverty
in childhood leads to physical and psychological difficulties throughout rite, irruitraiind
some
of the negative impacts of chirdhood poverty and their reratioriship to psychosociai ano
physical risk factors low-income children must confront.
lVe are delighted to wercome air participants to this conference at the University of
Stralhclyde, Glasgow, UK and we hope that the content of this book wiliLrr."trr
iriing tn"
conference and as
interests together.
a reference toor for research interests, bringing oeregates *iir-,
Ombretta Romice, Edward Edgerton and Kevin Thwaites
"nLr"o
!cc-cl
jo iool13S
uaen6
BUlllnes eua|f ro
ep,(1cq1e4g 1o Alrs:anru61
aclrrou Euejquo ro
)]eM * loueH
oou Auuef rO
,(ueLueg oqnrsl.re) 'r(6o1ouqcel 1o eln]tlsul eqnJSlre)
/'/\oqLUeU JaIIIU JO
^ltderOcaC
',{1rs.:e,riu1-g ,(.ley1
ftrs:enru61
ep,i1cq1er15 1o,(lrstenrup
epo4 orfuag
go.16
,{1rs:eirrupl Llllor{}co}S
u.roJlspJoN eue,.{
lo
seouorcs ay1 1o firs:earup uer6e,aarop
qploN EueloH
lo
ep^pqleJlS lo Itrsre^run
uoprcg
lo lrcunoC
4$eqen peqqn
1o [lrsrenru61
s-H{eltr€.Mlo
Li-rsrueqJn ueado.rn3
plegleqS
,{e.uny1
MesreM Jo ,{1rsJenrul ',i6o1oqc,(s3 1o ,(11nce3
e)p|n\al e-u€y{ro
se?uor3S lernllncuOy 1o ,{1rs.renru1 qsrpoms
6reqre-1 qeyr,;3o.16
,(lrsrenrul ellsecmaN
uelle) raled
-ro
,(ueu:eg'6rnqapOe6 lelrsre^run o)puanC-uoA-ollo
lesrE) ueuolJ Jord
qcreosou leluau_ruor]^US jo ejluaS
q3srqey unr6rs lord
zln-
e]eosr
Llr
rf
1o r{1rs.renrul lsenn
serpnlg leuor6eg '9 ueqrn roj arlueC ',(lrsrenrul
oley
ep,ilcq1er1g 1o,{1rs,lanr
u
61
uredg 'eunto3 ep apeprsranrun
puellocs Jo ]seM Jo ,t1rsra,rru6
epeue3
,i1r3
coqeno '^]rsro^run le^el
yn ueeproqv'elnlrlsul
uounH seurer eq1
,{1rs.renru61
loodra^'l
ulll Puuo3
rlleroH Esill
lo
uosraile pr^Eo ro
eirl^ el3ree oprecru
JoJd
uouo6p= slpp=
rc
serdse6 aloreC lo.rd
6rer3 r(uo116
uor.{c
rsj ro
erf eLloE elrslo^run
snrec addasnro 16
eLuo6'[1rs"renru6 ezuardeg
oinreuog ouriEr! JoJd
[1rsrenru61 ueMleH 'sUV eurg 1o [11nce3
rpeHlapqv elslv snlueur= ]ord
,(1e11
sqF.4f q.'I EI
lord
-pereqs
qlrm soleoalep burfur.rq
oLl] ourJnp lnlosn
aq
1o Alrs:enrup eL{}
llr,$
'qsa.r4ii trreEe. -cl F
)poq sqq lo }rEt-rc
a: E E &
le ouae+r@ srr[ c: s Ecol.FF I
a-E+"€:siL;-
-41
gr
pue leoosoqc^sd ol drtlsnoqepJ .rlEr.E f-€ ft-str
orJros OuqeJlsnllr 'e1r; poqBnorq sagpElup e6m-fl
Ipenod 1eq 6ur;eerre: aJuapha uo srEol pr s-er;
pLE srog
sdrLlsuorleleJ pue selor Bur6ueqtc
]o uorlesrueoro pue alrl eL$ :eJ[ced Jo
trg'
aF r t
&"rt! F-aq] ur sarllc ]o sluauialuos leuroJur s(1n u *ffi
Ef
]xeluoc oLll ur o9[oe]d Jo eJn]eu 6u6uap a.E :,,8, sE
a{
uorueq e,req ]eql slelrqeq uEurnLl aleur ol
frrr o.e&Eru
ru.6r
ueunLl ]o uOrsep eq1 og 6ur1urq1 1eo6qm
{-Et E-E
uorsep pue c!,uluorcs ssoJc llr,r IeBusA ^&
uel s.rosseloJd 'sre)eeds eloui{e1 peqsm6tr4sg :"8'f
Ied pue )iueL{} o} relnctped ut pue 'auelaJrrc
ore oM leqi ol peinquluoc sell oqr euol€,\€) )r-s: r I
i
.
t
--r
sur8rArrA
rrrlrntAoS llJlrNrfs ro rsll
'selllunululoJ
Llcteeser
e uo
u!
slc€h.l(t €rnt?Ed
uorssncsrp lEilur ue pue
o:gaa- :ro4
Co nte
Prof Petra Schweizer-Ries
University of Magdeburg
Dr lan Simkins
Experiential Landscape
Prof Chris Spencer
University of Sheffield
Mari Sundli-Tveit
The Norwegian University of Life Sciences
Dr Kevin Thwa tes
University of Sheffield
Dr Clare Twigger-Ross
Collingwood Environmental Planning Ltd
Prof David Uzzell
University of Surrey
Prof Catharine Ward-Thompson
Edinburgh College of Art
Patrick Devine Wright
University of Essex
nts
Contents
Practice in the lnformal Cities of Everyshere
Hamdi, N.,..-.................--...-...
Th€ Environment of Childh@d
Pffirty
Human Settlements as Natural Habitats:A
3:ntie,rMemorial Lecture-.
-_:::neJr lesearche: :. l::_,.: :: :- :':-:
--
Uzell, D..............-.-.---
],_.:::
:- ii:ricpologi, :ihncgr.ph, a
q.rrrL W-; Causen, C'.......-
Eya*Eti#
52. Case Studis of Post O€csFEDcy
52.1 Summer, Passiye Housing and
(eu.AG
i::-:--:
Se-cdl udJMlaq )d' >. :
ls,r.llrll
_oS
pue Bu
'
to,3
.
5.
. ?l-t : :'
:,
T9
95
suottestueSlo ut saSueql Surlerlrul .95
'uosslle) :zl^ 'uossueqof
'" ,'
19"
Surluilq
I
-
19:
l3,p.ro}a1ri1t
pareqs ut AStaua 3ur^eS
..
09"
"
"
"
U9
lrv'll^ll
oi
"
sa^loM pue sJeaq lo rea, ueunq ut sasuodsoJ lejnot^eqaq pue lelrSolotslqd 9.SS
"
",V
89
'11411
6s sla8euaal-ard
lrl^ 'uossueqol lrf'uosslre)l
qllaAlraqlpuror? :'.. :1: ::-:r -. :. :.
I
sa^loM pue sreaq lo real ueunq Bur8euen s ss
"
89
"
"
89 "
" "
l9
99
gS
tsJ:i
" """"
pue )leqpaal to alol aqf E 95
Uqeq e - sauttnot lltep Sur8ueql Aq lSiaua 8ur^es Z
" "
pue Surlq8rl uo rnor^eqaq pup sapnlrlle lenpt^.put ]o
19
89 "
...suotleztue8to ut slnot^eqaq
]uaDula-^8Jaue elouord
69
89 "
aq] ul ASlaua 3ut^es y
1'salqllen
IL "
ueunq alqeJeuln^ ur uolled!trqJed Fre u@=-..M
'e8an lu 'ell! l-ell'e9
rf'uosra]l uen irv'euafeH l.hlv'ls:oq1o1 1iH'sleels
Surllas leuollezrueSro ue ur rnorneqaq Surnes,{3taua uo
IL
01
1d
"
€V'l)Ill
"" ""
1rl'uasrapad 1zf'uosslJe) lrt^ 'uossueqof
]lom pue reaq uMorq ]o real ur llatqo paree, aql flSS
"
85'
"29'uossrrllr]'uoJlspues
8S
uapaas ui Apnls asel e a8ut8ueqt sa^loM spreMot sapntrtle arv E SS
"
|c"""
rd'sarqal lzff'e)sen l-hl'sqolef
"""',
--"""
: :. :
q'S e-Pf.
,.
ls
anle^ alrlplrM 01 Uau letlualod a^rprpald a^eq altlpltM pleao] suotltsodstp leuorloua oC
Mol ur qlleaH uo
Z
ES
slualu
of
u8rsaO 3ur^rl
a^rtrv pu.
-::.4 -: ::
:
:
Contents
59. Methodological lnnovations in Restoration Research (1): New insights jn restorative mechanisms and
59.lAttentionalrecovery:anoverviewofcognitivemeasures..........
Jahncke, H1; Hartig,
T2.........................
59.2 Human eeg responses to exact and statistical fractal
Hegerhell,
C1;
...........................76
............................76
patterns.........
Laike, T'; Tay or, R3; Kriller, M'z; Marcheschi,
E'z;
.....................7j
Boydston, C3...........................77
59.3 Does need for restoration direct us to nature? Testing vaewing patterns after emotional and cognittve
de Kort, YAWj Beute,
F....,..........
.....................................78
59.4 Green space and wellbeing: relationships between gender, patterns of salivary cortisol, self-reported
stress and levels ofgreen space in deprived urban communities in Scot1and..................................t....
.... .79
Roe, J1; Ward Thompson, C2; Asplnall, PA1; Brewer, Mr; Duff, 83; Mitchell, Ro; Clow, 45; Miller,
D6........................
................................7g
s9.5 No artificial ingredients added: Naturalness and the replenishment of ego-depletion by bright and
Beute, Fj de Kort,
YAW.......
................79
59.6 Virtual reality, restoration and aversive experiencesi distraction, relaxation and perceived control..80
Tanja-Dijkstra, K; Pahl, S; White, M; Andrade, I j May,
i.......,...
..,................80
510. Methodological Innovations in Restoration Research (2): New insights in restorative preferences and
S10.1 Links between enclosure and potential for restoration...........
Nordh,
H1;
Higerhdll,
.........
C'z..,....
510.2 A conjoint methodology
reldlionships wrth Breen spa(
for
.................81
...,...,......81
exploring place and activity preferences for stress regulation and
e............
............82
Roe, J1; Zuin, A'z; Ward Thompson, C']; Aspinall, PA1
......................
....,,..,....,82
510.3 Nearby outdoor recreation in Swiss peri-urban areas: Restorative needs and behaviours of dlfferent
Degenhardt, B1; Kienast,
F2;
lrngartinger,
C2;
Buchecker, M2..................................................,83
510.4 Creating a restorative staff room in an emergency department; the problems of a windowless
Payne, S1; Cain, Rr; Marsha , P1; Smith,
.12;
Squire, R2...................................................,..,,..,.,..83
S10.5 Community Gardening serving restoration and empowerment processes ........................................84
Martens/D..........................
................84
S11. New ways of lighting the streets at night: implications for practice and research ...................................85
13
EI
NI
olelsl
t6
e uo
llrunuuol
t6
"
1o osuas
""
" " '
€6
arou e spremol
luauqtrelle oleld
:sdrqsuorlelar atreld-aldoad
(Z)
""""
26"""""
....
.....
16
aal^ palellualailrp
88
"
""""""".'"'
€8
"
"""""
pue luauqleDe arPld
t
ETs
zll^ 'oSleplH :rl',zinu lrg'zapugulaH
:
pue uorleln8al
sluaudola^ap arnlnl auos pue
16
puP
06 "" " ,'
luauqrelle areld lo luauarnseau oqI
luauuoJr^ua lroM ujapou aqtr ur aleld lo alor oql :aleldlroM Jo asuas
.
(T)
" "
" " ""
"
""""
'
88"
'Al![qou ueq]n ueunq
g8
:€iA
'llluod
ur
1,U
€IS
:
"
"
-
ur
alroqr rolgp ]o olor aql
€ ZIS
"
S€urlsog1fd'^or]luau
.
61."" " "" " "'
6L
pdlrodJ,
aL
ZTS
....,.,,..,............,,.1 ,)n/usftu ue^ jV.suEEH
suraDed aze8 pue Atarxue:uortuaue ueutsapad uo lq8rl Surppaqs E TIS
1rU'aqll.n :E --:
...""
,la lo.ruo)
""
"
fuel le.
-
., .: :.:
pu?tr:s-:::- - :
,o ..:l-. I .
:
: :
:
-
a^rlruSol pue leuorloua raue sutatled
LL
lu r: :- :::
rl'uolsplo8:l - . ...
"suraljal :l::-
LL
"
:l
V'sueeH ll'>l/ss[lu ue^
'
.s8urlaal l+ales paJje SurtqBrl saop moH :slq8ll tuellluq pue slq8tu ]uetllug Z TIS
"
"
"
sarlp,osorlrleuosradaqlSurddenTzIS
seluenbasuo] pue'susrueqlal^ 'sasnel :lrl luauuor^ul-uosrad
""
6Z
61 "
- -:'
'
'.talltl,\1sV'moll
sura]]ed lesra^run :saqD lueu ]o ale] V Z ZTS
"
9g "
s8 " "
:.
08
puP lq8uq Aq uorlaldop-o8a
'auotquel lis 'olella)S lrv 'selnoN
""""
"
88
........................
98
S8 "" "
I
lrluapt areld pue luauqletrlv areld €1S
llrlenb-re uo sttralla Surllnsal aql pue suo!]oua Surleln8ar
rl 'ololser\
98
€IS
r'lu'lsJol :rl'Surllec 1z)l'sl^e]I lrCS'3ullso9 1il'l'uleqPJo
88
88' "
:
'
08 lolluo)pa'la)l-d--'
""
63
Z
M9'sue^llot^'qluarl
68
68
- : . .
:
€ €1s
T8.
68 " "
"
star]: -:- t::,:-:-:
r8
"d']rt3uM-aui^ac
]o alueldalle lBDos Surtlrpajd ul luauqletle areld jo Alrsuatur pue ltorJe^ ]o alor aql Surle8rlsa^u
gS
€8"""
M's[laH
sarllunuoddo'slureJlsuof,'sf,rlslrelleieqf,:lllluepr areld
68
"
e,o sualqoJd aql
ssalaopurM
Aroaql Bulleu-a3Eld ,o uorter8alul S'EIS
lueuuol^ua lelrslqd aql,o alor aql Sulddeu:a3eld,o llrluapr
"
t8'
8'alen:l lnodure^eqg
16" """ ""
I6
Jo
t^'elrMa']
Alrluopl oreld pue luauqtrellv areld ,IS
"
"'
.... .............. .
pa^!d;:
jo suorsuaurp oMl se Alr^rlle pue usllelol I rls
"
€6
Z6
SursnoH uopuol
pue eleld uaaMtaq drqsuorlelar aql ,to Ipnls asef V:a8ueql Jol SurlJoA Z tIS
-L'a)lel 1l 'uqn) 1w'uossueqof
.
."
.
91" " "
9L"""
"""
""
"
"'sarnseau
pu? susrueqf,au a^rleJolsal u! slqSrsur MaN:(t)
uoseas lalurM aq]8uunp Surlq8tl
Oll rooplnolo uorldalrad ,stuaptsau I IIS
sluauq,
ilqlfu
jE
E
'
q"JeaEt,^7r
Contents
GM
Speller,
S14.3 The
...........,94
role of neighbourhood attachment in people transactions with local flood risk......................... 95
Bonaiuto, M1; Bonnes, M1; De Dominicis, 51; Fornara,
Ross, C4
F2;
s!.il *ffiiffit
Ganucci Cancellieri, U3; Twigger-
..,............
:,r-, R-_-__.-,_--.
51.7_
p
Experience in ihe Noturol ond Buili Environmenl:
for Reseorch, Policy, ond Proclice
2 CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS
NTER NATIO
NAL ASSOC IATIO N
UNIVERSITY OF THE
,n,u.o,,ror@
Strathctyde
Glasgow
!vlll"il_Q9ll!
TJ\MS
I
IlI[}ffiuum
22. IAPS
CONFERENCE
Human Experience in the Naturaland Built Environment:
lmplications for Research policy & practice
Patron Karen Anderson, Architecture + Design Scotland
24 lune- 29 tune 2012
Strathclyde University
Glasgow, Scotland
Editors
Ombretta Romice
Edward Edgerton
Kevin Thwaites
ISBN: 978-0-94-764988-3
rM a3ue.raluoc eql jo slue^e lerceds Joqlo ]xeluoc estlce.ld pl-roM-lE3] e oi e:q ss::::
esrl..redxe qcJeosal Ourleru ,iq saLueq] eJoc slr loagar o] alqe ueoq seq ecue.retlc3 3-Mor,l jo eldurexe luellecxe ue sr
EelE eq]]o uorle.teue6at e:nin, eql ssncstp ol ,^,ac0se 3
ut (lrunLruoc uo]leC pue se.ueE leool eq] ]o sraqLuau.r qlrm raq1a6o1 osruedxo g6y1 0u:rc
Llcrqm IJoMleu uorleluesardey pue i{6o1oqdroy1 ueqJn or.l}}o OurleaLl lerceds e 6urpnlou
=
srqj oj elnquiuoc osle slue^e roqlo $rdol lo e6uer aql ssoJce ecrlcerd pue ,(cr1od qore3:=e6puq o1 Lxle o3uereluoo aql 6urlcellor,illecrlrcads uorlnquluoc 1o fuoOelec Mau
sra.:l
,(pn1s esec
'uorlrppe ur 'luasaJd ol peseald
oJe s.rasrue6ro oouaJaluoc.u_
'suotlelueserd reded 6re rerro 6ur.renrlep suorsses
^llercedso
Jeded B, pue srelsod 69 'ersodu,(s ,:Durpnlcur qlpeeJq pue,ilrlenb leuo6decxa,to eurure:Bord crlrluarcs e sluese.Ld srql ,ilan1ca :3
srtll
*
e
gt
'seprseq ojom qcnL! pue 'sluelr.ruo.Jl^ua crlenbe pue c-z
enlen lercos :slelrqel1 lernleu pue a1rlplrM qyM suorleloJ uelrnq luorle^rosuoo I6roua ::
lue^ele.r senssr lelueuuor^ue :luouJdole^ap 3rLlouoca pue uorleraueoer ueq.rn ol sesuoas3leluer.jJuoJr^ue pue lercos:e]n]3nrlserlur pue lueuraoeueu] leuolesue6ro uorlepocisuer) a:
seqceo:dde elqeurelsns :lueLudola^ep leluotuuolr^ue pue ecos ]c sa.ss -l ,crea -^*'-la
Jo alor eql :o] 6urtela: esoq] Ourpnlcur sauroq] eoue.reyo', t- --...= - :,. - -.','
L.uoJJ
acr1celdpuee6ueqcxee0pe|Moul't-]3leeSeJ1oa6uelepiME}ca|,e-i-*=-.-eq] ur suorsses llv burpuelsrepun 1eq1 ;o uorlecr;dde eq1 pue sppoM liric .-. ?--".eq1 ur ecuauedxa ueLrnq ]o aJnieu eq1 1o 6urpueislepun releerO 6utdolenep,Lo e:-:-::oql ur lsaJolur jo snsuesuoc 1eqo16 e 6urlerlsuouap 'palcerle a^eq seueq] a3usjaj-3:
pue
'ssauqci.l eq1 sesse.idxe slce4sqv Jo loo€ s -i
eLll q3il..u,^ lroar 10
^lrlenb
^lts.lo^tp
'u6tsep pue lueueoeueu-L 'lueLudo e^:a
pue elloe.ri
qlua pe6e6ue asoq] pue sreqc.reeser ueemlaq eOueqcxa 6ur1e1r1rce1 iq
^crlodpuE eoEil trrr'
ecue^pe ol slaas pue seoJe eseql urr]lrM r]oleosa.r ur luaLudole^ep pJoc€]
eouaroluoc aql 'sixeluoc plrom Ourdolenep pue podolo^ap Llloq ur suorlecrldLr.r JraL.l] Jelncrt-lec
ur 6u4cege: 'sueour srq] Ag 'luawabeuew pue uolleJuaaaldu pue :uo7eryeAo pue ubtse:
'6uuue1d\xoluoc pue lqdeLboe5:sea:E ureui oelL.l] uo sncoJ o] polr^ur oroM suorlnqrlL::
'luorxuor^Ue ]lrnq pue lernieu oql ur acuer]odxa uEu]nq ]o ouroql lle.la^o oq] L -:
"'
ecrlceld pue ,(crlod 'qcreesar ueamloq e6ueqcxe e6pelmoul Jo] uorjepuno] e se aln]oeltqs-.
adE"Jspuel pue uDrsap ueqrn '^6oloqclsd 1o lrorueure.r; {:eutldtcstptalut ue sassalcx:
pue slcegor srr-{j .(sa1remq1 urnay 16) plellJoqs 1o ,{lrsranruq pue (uolo6pf prempf
'(ectuog euarqurg rg) ep,{1eq1e4g 1o Altsta,rtL;11
rg) puellocg io iseM eL.ll jo
pasrue6ro Illurof ]ue^e^]rsra^run
eql
elrle.roqellqJ e sr ecueroluoc SdVl leuorleu:elul
oql
",ZZ
^q
']cedul lelueluuol^ue pue alersos
esrurldo o1 ,{olod pue ecrlce:d'qcJeosor 6urDprLq'e6ueqcxa pue uor}EcrunurL.uo3 oA}caga
6ur1e1r;rcel ur acuei:odlrr palelleredun seq ]r ocuonbosuoc ul suorleler ]uoL.lruoJrlue-ueL!n!
o1 6ur1e1er seere jo un.rlcads peo.rq e ssorce 6ur1urq1 ieotu. pue q3reosa.r snourouor.E
slr txorj seolnose: peluepece:dun pedolenep seq Ilrunururoc SdVl otl] sree^ I!rLl] JoAo -::
'plolJ or.ll ur asrpedxe pue uorlsJrldde
Jo seo]P olur alelsuer] ol seLxo3]no slr Jo+ pue suorl?-: -:
puoM-leoJ Jo sorlrunlJoddo pue suelqord xaldLum oql o] puodse.r puE ]ce[or o],{lr,:::
qSteeso] serrnbeJ JaAe ueLl] elour sorpnls .rnor^eqoq-lueLUUo.r,^ua jo ]rloueq lelercos e!:
6ursrwrxeyl pouJolur ;;e,r.,i;;en1nu aq o1 6ur1eu uorsrcep ,(cr1od pue actlcerd "to1 elqtsuodsa,
asoql pue saBrunL!ujoc qcJeeser roj ]ueirodu.r oJor.! uoeq lo^au seq ]r ]eq] suea',
seouallelp leluauruoJr^ue pue lercos polercosse slr puB ppoM 6utOueqc ,(lptder s,{epc_g
'qcreaseJ
lol
aJrlcerd pue i{crlod
suorlecrldu.r :luauuoJrAuf llrnE pue leJnleN aql ur ecueuedx3 ueurn;1
oroMrEol
J-
include a sustainability science Group meeting and an initial discussion
on
project on the therapeutic role of construction proiects
in communities.
a
research
we.would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has contributed
to what we are
confident will be a memorabre- and varuabre conference, and in particurar
to thant< ano pay
tribute to the contributions of our three distinguished keynote speakers, professors
ran
Bentley, Nabeel Hamdi and,,Gary Evans. rai Benfley wiil cross
scientific and design
traditions to address the idea that we shourd appry ecorogi'cat thinking
to tne oesig; ot human
settlemenis in an attempt to better understand how to mJke human hlabitats
that"have blnign
ecological impacts. Nabeer Hamdi dears with the changing nature of practrce
in the context
of some of the big issues impacting on people in thelnformal setflements ot
citi* in tne
south' including: the changing scope and purpose of practice; the rife and
organisation of
place; and the nature of professional interventions and the
changing roles and relationships
of practitroners to peopre and Frace. Gary Evans wiil focus on evid''enie revearing
tnai poverty
in childhood leads to physical and psychological difficulties throughout rite, irruitraiind
some
of the negative impacts of chirdhood poverty and their reratioriship to psychosociai ano
physical risk factors low-income children must confront.
lVe are delighted to wercome air participants to this conference at the University of
Stralhclyde, Glasgow, UK and we hope that the content of this book wiliLrr."trr
iriing tn"
conference and as
interests together.
a reference toor for research interests, bringing oeregates *iir-,
Ombretta Romice, Edward Edgerton and Kevin Thwaites
"nLr"o
!cc-cl
jo iool13S
uaen6
BUlllnes eua|f ro
ep,(1cq1e4g 1o Alrs:anru61
aclrrou Euejquo ro
)]eM * loueH
oou Auuef rO
,(ueLueg oqnrsl.re) 'r(6o1ouqcel 1o eln]tlsul eqnJSlre)
/'/\oqLUeU JaIIIU JO
^ltderOcaC
',{1rs.:e,riu1-g ,(.ley1
ftrs:enru61
ep,i1cq1er15 1o,(lrstenrup
epo4 orfuag
go.16
,{1rs:eirrupl Llllor{}co}S
u.roJlspJoN eue,.{
lo
seouorcs ay1 1o firs:earup uer6e,aarop
qploN EueloH
lo
ep^pqleJlS lo Itrsre^run
uoprcg
lo lrcunoC
4$eqen peqqn
1o [lrsrenru61
s-H{eltr€.Mlo
Li-rsrueqJn ueado.rn3
plegleqS
,{e.uny1
MesreM Jo ,{1rsJenrul ',i6o1oqc,(s3 1o ,(11nce3
e)p|n\al e-u€y{ro
se?uor3S lernllncuOy 1o ,{1rs.renru1 qsrpoms
6reqre-1 qeyr,;3o.16
,(lrsrenrul ellsecmaN
uelle) raled
-ro
,(ueu:eg'6rnqapOe6 lelrsre^run o)puanC-uoA-ollo
lesrE) ueuolJ Jord
qcreosou leluau_ruor]^US jo ejluaS
q3srqey unr6rs lord
zln-
e]eosr
Llr
rf
1o r{1rs.renrul lsenn
serpnlg leuor6eg '9 ueqrn roj arlueC ',(lrsrenrul
oley
ep,ilcq1er1g 1o,{1rs,lanr
u
61
uredg 'eunto3 ep apeprsranrun
puellocs Jo ]seM Jo ,t1rsra,rru6
epeue3
,i1r3
coqeno '^]rsro^run le^el
yn ueeproqv'elnlrlsul
uounH seurer eq1
,{1rs.renru61
loodra^'l
ulll Puuo3
rlleroH Esill
lo
uosraile pr^Eo ro
eirl^ el3ree oprecru
JoJd
uouo6p= slpp=
rc
serdse6 aloreC lo.rd
6rer3 r(uo116
uor.{c
rsj ro
erf eLloE elrslo^run
snrec addasnro 16
eLuo6'[1rs"renru6 ezuardeg
oinreuog ouriEr! JoJd
[1rsrenru61 ueMleH 'sUV eurg 1o [11nce3
rpeHlapqv elslv snlueur= ]ord
,(1e11
sqF.4f q.'I EI
lord
-pereqs
qlrm soleoalep burfur.rq
oLl] ourJnp lnlosn
aq
1o Alrs:enrup eL{}
llr,$
'qsa.r4ii trreEe. -cl F
)poq sqq lo }rEt-rc
a: E E &
le ouae+r@ srr[ c: s Ecol.FF I
a-E+"€:siL;-
-41
gr
pue leoosoqc^sd ol drtlsnoqepJ .rlEr.E f-€ ft-str
orJros OuqeJlsnllr 'e1r; poqBnorq sagpElup e6m-fl
Ipenod 1eq 6ur;eerre: aJuapha uo srEol pr s-er;
pLE srog
sdrLlsuorleleJ pue selor Bur6ueqtc
]o uorlesrueoro pue alrl eL$ :eJ[ced Jo
trg'
aF r t
&"rt! F-aq] ur sarllc ]o sluauialuos leuroJur s(1n u *ffi
Ef
]xeluoc oLll ur o9[oe]d Jo eJn]eu 6u6uap a.E :,,8, sE
a{
uorueq e,req ]eql slelrqeq uEurnLl aleur ol
frrr o.e&Eru
ru.6r
ueunLl ]o uOrsep eq1 og 6ur1urq1 1eo6qm
{-Et E-E
uorsep pue c!,uluorcs ssoJc llr,r IeBusA ^&
uel s.rosseloJd 'sre)eeds eloui{e1 peqsm6tr4sg :"8'f
Ied pue )iueL{} o} relnctped ut pue 'auelaJrrc
ore oM leqi ol peinquluoc sell oqr euol€,\€) )r-s: r I
i
.
t
--r
sur8rArrA
rrrlrntAoS llJlrNrfs ro rsll
'selllunululoJ
Llcteeser
e uo
u!
slc€h.l(t €rnt?Ed
uorssncsrp lEilur ue pue
o:gaa- :ro4
Co nte
Prof Petra Schweizer-Ries
University of Magdeburg
Dr lan Simkins
Experiential Landscape
Prof Chris Spencer
University of Sheffield
Mari Sundli-Tveit
The Norwegian University of Life Sciences
Dr Kevin Thwa tes
University of Sheffield
Dr Clare Twigger-Ross
Collingwood Environmental Planning Ltd
Prof David Uzzell
University of Surrey
Prof Catharine Ward-Thompson
Edinburgh College of Art
Patrick Devine Wright
University of Essex
nts
Contents
Practice in the lnformal Cities of Everyshere
Hamdi, N.,..-.................--...-...
Th€ Environment of Childh@d
Pffirty
Human Settlements as Natural Habitats:A
3:ntie,rMemorial Lecture-.
-_:::neJr lesearche: :. l::_,.: :: :- :':-:
--
Uzell, D..............-.-.---
],_.:::
:- ii:ricpologi, :ihncgr.ph, a
q.rrrL W-; Causen, C'.......-
Eya*Eti#
52. Case Studis of Post O€csFEDcy
52.1 Summer, Passiye Housing and
(eu.AG
i::-:--:
Se-cdl udJMlaq )d' >. :
ls,r.llrll
_oS
pue Bu
'
to,3
.
5.
. ?l-t : :'
:,
T9
95
suottestueSlo ut saSueql Surlerlrul .95
'uosslle) :zl^ 'uossueqof
'" ,'
19"
Surluilq
I
-
19:
l3,p.ro}a1ri1t
pareqs ut AStaua 3ur^eS
..
09"
"
"
"
U9
lrv'll^ll
oi
"
sa^loM pue sJeaq lo rea, ueunq ut sasuodsoJ lejnot^eqaq pue lelrSolotslqd 9.SS
"
",V
89
'11411
6s sla8euaal-ard
lrl^ 'uossueqol lrf'uosslre)l
qllaAlraqlpuror? :'.. :1: ::-:r -. :. :.
I
sa^loM pue sreaq lo real ueunq Bur8euen s ss
"
89
"
"
89 "
" "
l9
99
gS
tsJ:i
" """"
pue )leqpaal to alol aqf E 95
Uqeq e - sauttnot lltep Sur8ueql Aq lSiaua 8ur^es Z
" "
pue Surlq8rl uo rnor^eqaq pup sapnlrlle lenpt^.put ]o
19
89 "
...suotleztue8to ut slnot^eqaq
]uaDula-^8Jaue elouord
69
89 "
aq] ul ASlaua 3ut^es y
1'salqllen
IL "
ueunq alqeJeuln^ ur uolled!trqJed Fre u@=-..M
'e8an lu 'ell! l-ell'e9
rf'uosra]l uen irv'euafeH l.hlv'ls:oq1o1 1iH'sleels
Surllas leuollezrueSro ue ur rnorneqaq Surnes,{3taua uo
IL
01
1d
"
€V'l)Ill
"" ""
1rl'uasrapad 1zf'uosslJe) lrt^ 'uossueqof
]lom pue reaq uMorq ]o real ur llatqo paree, aql flSS
"
85'
"29'uossrrllr]'uoJlspues
8S
uapaas ui Apnls asel e a8ut8ueqt sa^loM spreMot sapntrtle arv E SS
"
|c"""
rd'sarqal lzff'e)sen l-hl'sqolef
"""',
--"""
: :. :
q'S e-Pf.
,.
ls
anle^ alrlplrM 01 Uau letlualod a^rprpald a^eq altlpltM pleao] suotltsodstp leuorloua oC
Mol ur qlleaH uo
Z
ES
slualu
of
u8rsaO 3ur^rl
a^rtrv pu.
-::.4 -: ::
:
:
Contents
59. Methodological lnnovations in Restoration Research (1): New insights jn restorative mechanisms and
59.lAttentionalrecovery:anoverviewofcognitivemeasures..........
Jahncke, H1; Hartig,
T2.........................
59.2 Human eeg responses to exact and statistical fractal
Hegerhell,
C1;
...........................76
............................76
patterns.........
Laike, T'; Tay or, R3; Kriller, M'z; Marcheschi,
E'z;
.....................7j
Boydston, C3...........................77
59.3 Does need for restoration direct us to nature? Testing vaewing patterns after emotional and cognittve
de Kort, YAWj Beute,
F....,..........
.....................................78
59.4 Green space and wellbeing: relationships between gender, patterns of salivary cortisol, self-reported
stress and levels ofgreen space in deprived urban communities in Scot1and..................................t....
.... .79
Roe, J1; Ward Thompson, C2; Asplnall, PA1; Brewer, Mr; Duff, 83; Mitchell, Ro; Clow, 45; Miller,
D6........................
................................7g
s9.5 No artificial ingredients added: Naturalness and the replenishment of ego-depletion by bright and
Beute, Fj de Kort,
YAW.......
................79
59.6 Virtual reality, restoration and aversive experiencesi distraction, relaxation and perceived control..80
Tanja-Dijkstra, K; Pahl, S; White, M; Andrade, I j May,
i.......,...
..,................80
510. Methodological Innovations in Restoration Research (2): New insights in restorative preferences and
S10.1 Links between enclosure and potential for restoration...........
Nordh,
H1;
Higerhdll,
.........
C'z..,....
510.2 A conjoint methodology
reldlionships wrth Breen spa(
for
.................81
...,...,......81
exploring place and activity preferences for stress regulation and
e............
............82
Roe, J1; Zuin, A'z; Ward Thompson, C']; Aspinall, PA1
......................
....,,..,....,82
510.3 Nearby outdoor recreation in Swiss peri-urban areas: Restorative needs and behaviours of dlfferent
Degenhardt, B1; Kienast,
F2;
lrngartinger,
C2;
Buchecker, M2..................................................,83
510.4 Creating a restorative staff room in an emergency department; the problems of a windowless
Payne, S1; Cain, Rr; Marsha , P1; Smith,
.12;
Squire, R2...................................................,..,,..,.,..83
S10.5 Community Gardening serving restoration and empowerment processes ........................................84
Martens/D..........................
................84
S11. New ways of lighting the streets at night: implications for practice and research ...................................85
13
EI
NI
olelsl
t6
e uo
llrunuuol
t6
"
1o osuas
""
" " '
€6
arou e spremol
luauqtrelle oleld
:sdrqsuorlelar atreld-aldoad
(Z)
""""
26"""""
....
.....
16
aal^ palellualailrp
88
"
""""""".'"'
€8
"
"""""
pue luauqleDe arPld
t
ETs
zll^ 'oSleplH :rl',zinu lrg'zapugulaH
:
pue uorleln8al
sluaudola^ap arnlnl auos pue
16
puP
06 "" " ,'
luauqrelle areld lo luauarnseau oqI
luauuoJr^ua lroM ujapou aqtr ur aleld lo alor oql :aleldlroM Jo asuas
.
(T)
" "
" " ""
"
""""
'
88"
'Al![qou ueq]n ueunq
g8
:€iA
'llluod
ur
1,U
€IS
:
"
"
-
ur
alroqr rolgp ]o olor aql
€ ZIS
"
S€urlsog1fd'^or]luau
.
61."" " "" " "'
6L
pdlrodJ,
aL
ZTS
....,.,,..,............,,.1 ,)n/usftu ue^ jV.suEEH
suraDed aze8 pue Atarxue:uortuaue ueutsapad uo lq8rl Surppaqs E TIS
1rU'aqll.n :E --:
...""
,la lo.ruo)
""
"
fuel le.
-
., .: :.:
pu?tr:s-:::- - :
,o ..:l-. I .
:
: :
:
-
a^rlruSol pue leuorloua raue sutatled
LL
lu r: :- :::
rl'uolsplo8:l - . ...
"suraljal :l::-
LL
"
:l
V'sueeH ll'>l/ss[lu ue^
'
.s8urlaal l+ales paJje SurtqBrl saop moH :slq8ll tuellluq pue slq8tu ]uetllug Z TIS
"
"
"
sarlp,osorlrleuosradaqlSurddenTzIS
seluenbasuo] pue'susrueqlal^ 'sasnel :lrl luauuor^ul-uosrad
""
6Z
61 "
- -:'
'
'.talltl,\1sV'moll
sura]]ed lesra^run :saqD lueu ]o ale] V Z ZTS
"
9g "
s8 " "
:.
08
puP lq8uq Aq uorlaldop-o8a
'auotquel lis 'olella)S lrv 'selnoN
""""
"
88
........................
98
S8 "" "
I
lrluapt areld pue luauqletrlv areld €1S
llrlenb-re uo sttralla Surllnsal aql pue suo!]oua Surleln8ar
rl 'ololser\
98
€IS
r'lu'lsJol :rl'Surllec 1z)l'sl^e]I lrCS'3ullso9 1il'l'uleqPJo
88
88' "
:
'
08 lolluo)pa'la)l-d--'
""
63
Z
M9'sue^llot^'qluarl
68
68
- : . .
:
€ €1s
T8.
68 " "
"
star]: -:- t::,:-:-:
r8
"d']rt3uM-aui^ac
]o alueldalle lBDos Surtlrpajd ul luauqletle areld jo Alrsuatur pue ltorJe^ ]o alor aql Surle8rlsa^u
gS
€8"""
M's[laH
sarllunuoddo'slureJlsuof,'sf,rlslrelleieqf,:lllluepr areld
68
"
e,o sualqoJd aql
ssalaopurM
Aroaql Bulleu-a3Eld ,o uorter8alul S'EIS
lueuuol^ua lelrslqd aql,o alor aql Sulddeu:a3eld,o llrluapr
"
t8'
8'alen:l lnodure^eqg
16" """ ""
I6
Jo
t^'elrMa']
Alrluopl oreld pue luauqtrellv areld ,IS
"
"'
.... .............. .
pa^!d;:
jo suorsuaurp oMl se Alr^rlle pue usllelol I rls
"
€6
Z6
SursnoH uopuol
pue eleld uaaMtaq drqsuorlelar aql ,to Ipnls asef V:a8ueql Jol SurlJoA Z tIS
-L'a)lel 1l 'uqn) 1w'uossueqof
.
."
.
91" " "
9L"""
"""
""
"
"'sarnseau
pu? susrueqf,au a^rleJolsal u! slqSrsur MaN:(t)
uoseas lalurM aq]8uunp Surlq8tl
Oll rooplnolo uorldalrad ,stuaptsau I IIS
sluauq,
ilqlfu
jE
E
'
q"JeaEt,^7r
Contents
GM
Speller,
S14.3 The
...........,94
role of neighbourhood attachment in people transactions with local flood risk......................... 95
Bonaiuto, M1; Bonnes, M1; De Dominicis, 51; Fornara,
Ross, C4
F2;
s!.il *ffiiffit
Ganucci Cancellieri, U3; Twigger-
..,............
:,r-, R-_-__.-,_--.
51.7_