Lampiran 1 Gambar Editor Input Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
DAFTAR LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1
Gambar Editor Input Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 2
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
107
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 3
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 4
Gambar Editor Input Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
108
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 5
Gambar Hasil Momen–Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 6
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
109
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 7
Gambar Editor Input Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 8
Gambar Hasil Momen – Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
110
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 9
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 10
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230
dengan Response-2000
111
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 11
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response2000
Lampiran 12
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response-2000
112
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 13
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100
dengan Response-2000
Lampiran 14
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response2000
113
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 15
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response-2000
Lampiran 16
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan
Response-2000
114
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 17
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response2000
Lampiran 18
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Response-2000
115
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 19
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT
116
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 20
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT
117
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 21
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT
118
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 22
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT
119
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 23
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT
120
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 24
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT
121
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 25
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–CURVATURE DENGAN CUMBIA
Curvature
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
No
Moment
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
EI Effektif
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
0.009
0.00760
0.08968
11.800
482.060
528.240
1.096
63428.947
0.009
0.00799
0.07544
9.442
624.690
672.900
1.077
78183.980
0.258
0.016
0.00772
0.16105
20.861
488.470
639.000
1.308
63273.316
Ultimate/Yield
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.016
0.00768
0.13986
18.211
485.820
618.720
1.274
63257.813
5
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.015
0.00772
0.22738
29.453
489.370
696.910
1.424
63389.896
6
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.016
0.00769
0.14967
19.463
486.700
628.770
1.292
63289.987
Lampiran 26
TABEL
HASIL
RESPONSE–2000
PERHITUNGAN
MOMEN–CURVATURE
Curvature
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
4
5
6
No
DENGAN
Moment
EI Effektif
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
Ultimate/Yield
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
0.009
0.00766
0.07543
9.848
421.866
467.149
1.107
55073.890
0.009
0.00796
0.07543
9.476
529.475
597.304
1.128
66516.960
0.258
0.009
0.00775
0.13144
16.960
428.468
495.249
1.156
55286.194
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.009
0.00763
0.11765
15.419
425.862
474.449
1.114
55814.155
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.009
0.00776
0.19322
24.899
429.361
505.649
1.178
55330.026
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.009
0.00768
0.12575
16.374
426.760
487.849
1.143
55567.708
Lampiran 27
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–CURVATURE DENGAN XTRACT
Curvature
No
1
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
Moment
EI Effektif
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
Ultimate/Yield
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
0.003
0.00590
0.07061
11.968
363.010
470.600
1.296
61527.119
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
0.005
0.00608
0.06326
10.405
462.800
607.600
1.313
76118.421
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
0.258
0.005
0.00600
0.07027
11.712
368.120
475.500
1.292
61353.333
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.004
0.00598
0.07020
11.739
365.200
474.700
1.300
61070.234
5
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.005
0.00605
0.07146
11.812
369.600
477.300
1.291
61090.909
6
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.005
0.00595
0.07132
11.987
366.460
475.600
1.298
61589.916
122
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 28
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN CUMBIA
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
8802.190
0
-1630.080
0
690.620
3435.330
386.520
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
9552.730
0
-2445.120
0
801.570
3435.330
531.480
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
8789.760
0
-1630.080
0
703.790
3435.330
400.230
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
8792.580
0
-1630.080
0
699.510
3817.040
400.330
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
8781.340
0
-1630.080
0
718.210
3817.040
402.500
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
8791.580
0
-1630.080
0
703.440
3435.330
399.410
0
Lampiran 29
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN RESPONSE-2000
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
9137.303
0
-2222.641
0
628.615
2747.194
373.058
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
9784.070
0
-3309.718
0
729.569
2707.314
514.578
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
9087.300
0
-2222.641
0
600.910
2747.194
390.158
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
9097.700
0
-2222.641
0
599.510
2747.194
390.050
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
9077.500
0
-2222.641
0
618.610
2747.194
385.058
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
9097.800
0
-2222.641
0
600.410
2747.194
383.058
0
Lampiran 30
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN XTRACT
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
9544.000
0
-1624.000
0
650.500
3236.000
349.400
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
10290.000
0
-2436.000
0
749.000
3278.000
504.900
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
9673.000
0
-1624.000
0
651.400
3237.000
369.500
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
9658.000
0
-1624.000
0
650.300
3237.000
369.500
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
9698.000
0
-1624.000
0
671.600
3238.000
359.500
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
9663.000
0
-1624.000
0
661.300
3237.000
355.500
0
123
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 31
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.004311
0.005648
0.004443
0.004379
0.004428
0.004436
3
0.039175
0.035054
0.067307
0.059042
0.093240
0.062865
Base Force (kN)
4
0.045964
0.040824
0.074274
0.064907
0.100201
0.069736
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297.736
390.021
306.814
302.392
305.787
306.329
3
308.619
404.611
343.965
339.514
362.162
341.360
4
305.475
400.601
340.625
336.176
358.441
338.079
Lampiran 32
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.004211
0.005490
0.004211
0.004211
0.004211
0.004211
3
0.033542
0.034981
0.055217
0.049880
0.079126
0.053015
Base Force (kN)
4
0.041718
0.041551
0.063393
0.058056
0.087301
0.061191
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290.777
379.097
290.777
290.777
290.777
290.777
3
300.372
399.732
300.372
300.372
300.372
300.372
4
297.395
395.729
297.395
297.395
297.396
297.395
Lampiran 33
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.003982
0.005364
0.003985
0.003984
0.003985
0.003984
3
0.031658
0.030592
0.031537
0.031508
0.032001
0.031944
Base Force (kN)
4
0.041250
0.037495
0.041349
0.041287
0.041864
0.041749
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274.999
370.416
275.164
275.150
275.179
275.150
3
299.165
421.978
299.910
299.775
300.119
299.957
4
296.130
417.751
296.896
296.761
297.107
296.938
124
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 34
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA Lsp Jarak 25 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,003071
0,004022
0,003164
0,003119
0,003154
0,003159
3
0,037889
0,033368
0,065874
0,057627
0,091731
0,061443
Base Force (kN)
4
0,038976
0,034299
0,067041
0,058591
0,092828
0,062606
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297,736
390,021
306,814
302,392
305,787
306,329
3
308,619
404,611
343,965
339,52
362,162
341,36
4
304,153
398,768
338,993
334,611
356,928
336,425
Lampiran 35
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Lsp Jarak 25
cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002999
0,00391
0,003509
0,002999
0,002999
0,002999
3
0,03229
0,033315
0,054493
0,048628
0,077874
0,051763
Base Force (kN)
4
0,033644
0,034369
0,056155
0,049982
0,079228
0,053117
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290,777
379,097
290,777
290,777
290,777
290,777
3
300,372
399,732
300,372
300,372
300,372
300,372
4
296,03
393,965
296,662
296,03
296,03
296,03
Lampiran 36
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT Lsp Jarak 25 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002836
0,00382
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
3
0,030412
0,028834
0,030288
0,030259
0,03075
0,030694
Base Force (kN)
4
0,031968
0,02994
0,031896
0,031861
0,03237
0,032299
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274,999
370,416
275,164
275,15
275,179
275,15
3
299,165
421,978
299,91
299,775
300,119
299,957
4
294,842
415,893
295,576
295,443
295,782
295,622
125
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 37
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA Lsp Jarak 50 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,003071
0,004022
0,003164
0,003119
0,003154
0,003159
3
0,037889
0,033368
0,065874
0,057627
0,091731
0,061443
Base Force (kN)
4
0,040108
0,03529
0,06826
0,059605
0,09398
0,06382
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297,736
390,021
306,814
302,392
305,787
306,329
3
308,619
404,611
343,965
339,52
362,162
341,36
4
304,153
398,768
338,993
334,611
356,928
336,425
Lampiran 38
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Lsp Jarak 50
cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002999
0,00391
0,003852
0,002999
0,002999
0,002999
3
0,03229
0,033315
0,054846
0,048628
0,077874
0,051763
Base Force (kN)
4
0,035043
0,035483
0,057913
0,051381
0,080627
0,054516
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290,777
379,097
290,777
290,777
290,777
290,777
3
300,372
399,732
300,372
300,372
300,372
300,372
4
296,03
393,965
296,991
296,03
296,03
296,03
Lampiran 39
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT Lsp Jarak 50 cm
No
1
2
3
4
q5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002836
0,00382
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
3
0,030412
0,028834
0,030288
0,030259
0,03075
0,030694
Base Force (kN)
4
0,033569
0,03111
0,03355
0,033508
0,034034
0,033949
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274,999
370,416
275,164
275,15
275,179
275,15
3
299,165
421,978
299,91
299,775
300,119
299,957
4
294,842
415,893
295,576
295,443
295,782
295,622
126
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 40
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS Lsp Jarak 57,4 cm
No
1
2
3
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
CUMBIA
Response-2000
XTRACT
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
2
0,004443
0,002999
0,002838
3
0,067307
0,053965
0,030288
Base Force (kN)
4
0,070103
0,057132
0,034039
1
0
0
0
2
306,814
290,777
275,164
3
343,965
300,372
299,91
4
340,424
296,03
295,576
Lampiran 41
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSISLsp Jarak 60 cm
No
1
2
3
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
CUMBIA
Response-2000
XTRACT
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
2
0,003429
0,002999
0,002838
3
0,092057
0,077874
0,03075
Base Force (kN)
4
0,094544
0,081186
0,034699
1
0
0
0
2
305,787
290,777
275,179
3
362,162
300,372
300,118
4
357,348
296,03
295,782
Lampiran 42
TABEL LATERAL FORCE-DISPLACEMENT RESPONSE ENVELOPESHASIL
EKSPERIMENTAL CHUNG dkk. (2008)
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,018
0,015
0,015
0,015
0,015
0,015
3
0,04
0,024
0,030
0,030
0,057
0,057
Base Force (kN)
4
0,090
0,077
0,105
0,105
0,105
0,105
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
283
260
270
270
315
315
3
315
275
290
290
365
365
4
190
135
180
180
250
250
127
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 43
GAMBAR HASIL MOMEN CURVATURE SECARA MANUAL DENGAN
MICROSOFT EXCEL
Nilai-nilai momen-kurvatur dapat diperkirakan secara perhitungan manual.
Untuk kurvatur pada keadaan leleh φy dapat diperkirakan dengan menggunakan
persamaan usulan Park dan Paulay (1974) yang dimodifikasi oleh Kunnath dkk. (1992);
n f /E
φ y = 1.05 + (C 2 − 0.05) 0 y s
3 d (1 − k )
dimana;
C2 =
0.45
At f y
0.84 +
'
bdf c
;
n0 =
N
bdf c'
(
)
;
128
Universitas Sumatera Utara
2
A f
Ad f 1
A f 1
Af
Af
Af
1
k = t y' + c y'
− t y' + c y'
+ t y' + c 2c 'y
2
bdf c bd f c ε y / ε 0 bdf c bdf c 2ε y / ε 0
bdf c bdf c 4(ε y / ε 0 )
Kurvatur ultimate dapat diperkirakan dengan menganggap kolom berperilaku
sama dengan elemen balok sebagaimana persamaan yang diusulkan olehPark dan
Paulay (1976);
φu =
0.85 f c'bβ1ε c
At f y − Ac f y
Momen lentur pada keadaan leleh (My) dapat diperkirakan dengan persamaan
berikut Park dkk. (1987);
d
0.75
'
2
M y = 0.5 f c bd 1 + c −
εy
d
1+
ε0
εc
ε0
0.7
0.75
+
ε
1+ y
ε0
0.75
N
bdf ' + 2 −
εy
c
1+
ε0
εc
ε0
0 .7
εc
ε0
0.7
At f y
bdf ' ...........
c
d Ac f y
α
− 2 c
c
d bdf c'
dimana;
d
α c = 1 − c
d
ε y dc
−
ε0 d
Sedangkan momen lentur pada keadaan runtuh atau batas (Mu) dapat
diperkirakan dengan persamaan berikut (Park dkk., 1987);
N
Af
My
M u = 1.24 − 0.15 t y' − 0.5
'
bdf
bdf
c
c
129
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 44
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE CUMBIA
SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Curvature
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
0.00760
0.00799
0.00772
0.00768
0.00772
0.00769
0.08968
0.07544
0.16105
0.13986
0.22738
0.14967
0.00570
0.00599
0.00579
0.00576
0.00579
0.00577
0.06726
0.05658
0.12079
0.10490
0.17054
0.11225
Lampiran 45
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE RESPONSE2000 SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
Curvature
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
0.00766
0.00796
0.00775
0.00763
0.00776
0.00768
0.07543
0.07543
0.13144
0.11765
0.19322
0.12575
0.00575
0.00597
0.00581
0.00572
0.00582
0.00576
0.05657
0.05657
0.09858
0.08824
0.14492
0.09431
Lampiran 46
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE XTRACT
SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Curvature
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
0.00590
0.00608
0.00600
0.00598
0.00605
0.00595
0.07061
0.06326
0.07027
0.07020
0.07146
0.07132
0.00443
0.00456
0.00450
0.00449
0.00454
0.00446
0.05296
0.04745
0.05270
0.05265
0.05360
0.05349
130
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 1
Gambar Editor Input Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 2
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
107
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 3
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 4
Gambar Editor Input Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
108
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 5
Gambar Hasil Momen–Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 6
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia
109
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 7
Gambar Editor Input Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 8
Gambar Hasil Momen – Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
110
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 9
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia
Lampiran 10
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230
dengan Response-2000
111
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 11
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response2000
Lampiran 12
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response-2000
112
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 13
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100
dengan Response-2000
Lampiran 14
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response2000
113
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 15
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response-2000
Lampiran 16
Gambar Penampang dan Geometric Properties Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan
Response-2000
114
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 17
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response2000
Lampiran 18
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Response-2000
115
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 19
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT
116
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 20
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT
117
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 21
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT
118
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 22
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT
119
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 23
Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT
120
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 24
Gambar Hasil Momen – Axial Specimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT
121
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 25
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–CURVATURE DENGAN CUMBIA
Curvature
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
No
Moment
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
EI Effektif
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
0.009
0.00760
0.08968
11.800
482.060
528.240
1.096
63428.947
0.009
0.00799
0.07544
9.442
624.690
672.900
1.077
78183.980
0.258
0.016
0.00772
0.16105
20.861
488.470
639.000
1.308
63273.316
Ultimate/Yield
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.016
0.00768
0.13986
18.211
485.820
618.720
1.274
63257.813
5
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.015
0.00772
0.22738
29.453
489.370
696.910
1.424
63389.896
6
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.016
0.00769
0.14967
19.463
486.700
628.770
1.292
63289.987
Lampiran 26
TABEL
HASIL
RESPONSE–2000
PERHITUNGAN
MOMEN–CURVATURE
Curvature
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
4
5
6
No
DENGAN
Moment
EI Effektif
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
Ultimate/Yield
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
0.009
0.00766
0.07543
9.848
421.866
467.149
1.107
55073.890
0.009
0.00796
0.07543
9.476
529.475
597.304
1.128
66516.960
0.258
0.009
0.00775
0.13144
16.960
428.468
495.249
1.156
55286.194
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.009
0.00763
0.11765
15.419
425.862
474.449
1.114
55814.155
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.009
0.00776
0.19322
24.899
429.361
505.649
1.178
55330.026
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.009
0.00768
0.12575
16.374
426.760
487.849
1.143
55567.708
Lampiran 27
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–CURVATURE DENGAN XTRACT
Curvature
No
1
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
Hinge
Length
(m)
Bi-Factor
DN-SP00-R0-230
0.258
Moment
EI Effektif
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
Ultimate/Yield
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
Ultimate/Yield
Yield
Moment/Yield
Curvature
0.003
0.00590
0.07061
11.968
363.010
470.600
1.296
61527.119
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
0.258
0.005
0.00608
0.06326
10.405
462.800
607.600
1.313
76118.421
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
0.258
0.005
0.00600
0.07027
11.712
368.120
475.500
1.292
61353.333
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
0.258
0.004
0.00598
0.07020
11.739
365.200
474.700
1.300
61070.234
5
US-SP00-R0-50
0.258
0.005
0.00605
0.07146
11.812
369.600
477.300
1.291
61090.909
6
US-SP00-R0-93
0.258
0.005
0.00595
0.07132
11.987
366.460
475.600
1.298
61589.916
122
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 28
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN CUMBIA
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
8802.190
0
-1630.080
0
690.620
3435.330
386.520
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
9552.730
0
-2445.120
0
801.570
3435.330
531.480
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
8789.760
0
-1630.080
0
703.790
3435.330
400.230
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
8792.580
0
-1630.080
0
699.510
3817.040
400.330
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
8781.340
0
-1630.080
0
718.210
3817.040
402.500
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
8791.580
0
-1630.080
0
703.440
3435.330
399.410
0
Lampiran 29
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN RESPONSE-2000
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
9137.303
0
-2222.641
0
628.615
2747.194
373.058
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
9784.070
0
-3309.718
0
729.569
2707.314
514.578
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
9087.300
0
-2222.641
0
600.910
2747.194
390.158
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
9097.700
0
-2222.641
0
599.510
2747.194
390.050
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
9077.500
0
-2222.641
0
618.610
2747.194
385.058
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
9097.800
0
-2222.641
0
600.410
2747.194
383.058
0
Lampiran 30
TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN–AXIAL DENGAN XTRACT
Max. Compression Load
No
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
Max. Tension Load
Maximum Moment
Moment (Mxx) at P = 0
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
M3
(kN-m)
M3
(kN-m)
P at Max. Moment
(kN)
M3
(kN-m)
P (kN)
1
DN-SP00-R0-230
9544.000
0
-1624.000
0
650.500
3236.000
349.400
0
2
DN-SP50-R0-230
10290.000
0
-2436.000
0
749.000
3278.000
504.900
0
3
DL-SP00-R0-82
9673.000
0
-1624.000
0
651.400
3237.000
369.500
0
4
DL-SP00-R0-100
9658.000
0
-1624.000
0
650.300
3237.000
369.500
0
5
US-SP00-R0-50
9698.000
0
-1624.000
0
671.600
3238.000
359.500
0
6
US-SP00-R0-93
9663.000
0
-1624.000
0
661.300
3237.000
355.500
0
123
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 31
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.004311
0.005648
0.004443
0.004379
0.004428
0.004436
3
0.039175
0.035054
0.067307
0.059042
0.093240
0.062865
Base Force (kN)
4
0.045964
0.040824
0.074274
0.064907
0.100201
0.069736
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297.736
390.021
306.814
302.392
305.787
306.329
3
308.619
404.611
343.965
339.514
362.162
341.360
4
305.475
400.601
340.625
336.176
358.441
338.079
Lampiran 32
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.004211
0.005490
0.004211
0.004211
0.004211
0.004211
3
0.033542
0.034981
0.055217
0.049880
0.079126
0.053015
Base Force (kN)
4
0.041718
0.041551
0.063393
0.058056
0.087301
0.061191
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290.777
379.097
290.777
290.777
290.777
290.777
3
300.372
399.732
300.372
300.372
300.372
300.372
4
297.395
395.729
297.395
297.395
297.396
297.395
Lampiran 33
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0.003982
0.005364
0.003985
0.003984
0.003985
0.003984
3
0.031658
0.030592
0.031537
0.031508
0.032001
0.031944
Base Force (kN)
4
0.041250
0.037495
0.041349
0.041287
0.041864
0.041749
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274.999
370.416
275.164
275.150
275.179
275.150
3
299.165
421.978
299.910
299.775
300.119
299.957
4
296.130
417.751
296.896
296.761
297.107
296.938
124
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 34
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA Lsp Jarak 25 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,003071
0,004022
0,003164
0,003119
0,003154
0,003159
3
0,037889
0,033368
0,065874
0,057627
0,091731
0,061443
Base Force (kN)
4
0,038976
0,034299
0,067041
0,058591
0,092828
0,062606
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297,736
390,021
306,814
302,392
305,787
306,329
3
308,619
404,611
343,965
339,52
362,162
341,36
4
304,153
398,768
338,993
334,611
356,928
336,425
Lampiran 35
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Lsp Jarak 25
cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002999
0,00391
0,003509
0,002999
0,002999
0,002999
3
0,03229
0,033315
0,054493
0,048628
0,077874
0,051763
Base Force (kN)
4
0,033644
0,034369
0,056155
0,049982
0,079228
0,053117
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290,777
379,097
290,777
290,777
290,777
290,777
3
300,372
399,732
300,372
300,372
300,372
300,372
4
296,03
393,965
296,662
296,03
296,03
296,03
Lampiran 36
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT Lsp Jarak 25 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002836
0,00382
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
3
0,030412
0,028834
0,030288
0,030259
0,03075
0,030694
Base Force (kN)
4
0,031968
0,02994
0,031896
0,031861
0,03237
0,032299
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274,999
370,416
275,164
275,15
275,179
275,15
3
299,165
421,978
299,91
299,775
300,119
299,957
4
294,842
415,893
295,576
295,443
295,782
295,622
125
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 37
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA Lsp Jarak 50 cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,003071
0,004022
0,003164
0,003119
0,003154
0,003159
3
0,037889
0,033368
0,065874
0,057627
0,091731
0,061443
Base Force (kN)
4
0,040108
0,03529
0,06826
0,059605
0,09398
0,06382
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
297,736
390,021
306,814
302,392
305,787
306,329
3
308,619
404,611
343,965
339,52
362,162
341,36
4
304,153
398,768
338,993
334,611
356,928
336,425
Lampiran 38
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Lsp Jarak 50
cm
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002999
0,00391
0,003852
0,002999
0,002999
0,002999
3
0,03229
0,033315
0,054846
0,048628
0,077874
0,051763
Base Force (kN)
4
0,035043
0,035483
0,057913
0,051381
0,080627
0,054516
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
290,777
379,097
290,777
290,777
290,777
290,777
3
300,372
399,732
300,372
300,372
300,372
300,372
4
296,03
393,965
296,991
296,03
296,03
296,03
Lampiran 39
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT Lsp Jarak 50 cm
No
1
2
3
4
q5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,002836
0,00382
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
0,002838
3
0,030412
0,028834
0,030288
0,030259
0,03075
0,030694
Base Force (kN)
4
0,033569
0,03111
0,03355
0,033508
0,034034
0,033949
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
274,999
370,416
275,164
275,15
275,179
275,15
3
299,165
421,978
299,91
299,775
300,119
299,957
4
294,842
415,893
295,576
295,443
295,782
295,622
126
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 40
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS Lsp Jarak 57,4 cm
No
1
2
3
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
CUMBIA
Response-2000
XTRACT
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
2
0,004443
0,002999
0,002838
3
0,067307
0,053965
0,030288
Base Force (kN)
4
0,070103
0,057132
0,034039
1
0
0
0
2
306,814
290,777
275,164
3
343,965
300,372
299,91
4
340,424
296,03
295,576
Lampiran 41
TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSISLsp Jarak 60 cm
No
1
2
3
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
CUMBIA
Response-2000
XTRACT
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
2
0,003429
0,002999
0,002838
3
0,092057
0,077874
0,03075
Base Force (kN)
4
0,094544
0,081186
0,034699
1
0
0
0
2
305,787
290,777
275,179
3
362,162
300,372
300,118
4
357,348
296,03
295,782
Lampiran 42
TABEL LATERAL FORCE-DISPLACEMENT RESPONSE ENVELOPESHASIL
EKSPERIMENTAL CHUNG dkk. (2008)
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of
Test Specimen
DN-SP00-R0-230
DN-SP50-R0-230
DL-SP00-R0-82
DL-SP00-R0-100
US-SP00-R0-50
US-SP00-R0-93
Displacement (m)
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0,018
0,015
0,015
0,015
0,015
0,015
3
0,04
0,024
0,030
0,030
0,057
0,057
Base Force (kN)
4
0,090
0,077
0,105
0,105
0,105
0,105
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
283
260
270
270
315
315
3
315
275
290
290
365
365
4
190
135
180
180
250
250
127
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 43
GAMBAR HASIL MOMEN CURVATURE SECARA MANUAL DENGAN
MICROSOFT EXCEL
Nilai-nilai momen-kurvatur dapat diperkirakan secara perhitungan manual.
Untuk kurvatur pada keadaan leleh φy dapat diperkirakan dengan menggunakan
persamaan usulan Park dan Paulay (1974) yang dimodifikasi oleh Kunnath dkk. (1992);
n f /E
φ y = 1.05 + (C 2 − 0.05) 0 y s
3 d (1 − k )
dimana;
C2 =
0.45
At f y
0.84 +
'
bdf c
;
n0 =
N
bdf c'
(
)
;
128
Universitas Sumatera Utara
2
A f
Ad f 1
A f 1
Af
Af
Af
1
k = t y' + c y'
− t y' + c y'
+ t y' + c 2c 'y
2
bdf c bd f c ε y / ε 0 bdf c bdf c 2ε y / ε 0
bdf c bdf c 4(ε y / ε 0 )
Kurvatur ultimate dapat diperkirakan dengan menganggap kolom berperilaku
sama dengan elemen balok sebagaimana persamaan yang diusulkan olehPark dan
Paulay (1976);
φu =
0.85 f c'bβ1ε c
At f y − Ac f y
Momen lentur pada keadaan leleh (My) dapat diperkirakan dengan persamaan
berikut Park dkk. (1987);
d
0.75
'
2
M y = 0.5 f c bd 1 + c −
εy
d
1+
ε0
εc
ε0
0.7
0.75
+
ε
1+ y
ε0
0.75
N
bdf ' + 2 −
εy
c
1+
ε0
εc
ε0
0 .7
εc
ε0
0.7
At f y
bdf ' ...........
c
d Ac f y
α
− 2 c
c
d bdf c'
dimana;
d
α c = 1 − c
d
ε y dc
−
ε0 d
Sedangkan momen lentur pada keadaan runtuh atau batas (Mu) dapat
diperkirakan dengan persamaan berikut (Park dkk., 1987);
N
Af
My
M u = 1.24 − 0.15 t y' − 0.5
'
bdf
bdf
c
c
129
Universitas Sumatera Utara
Lampiran 44
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE CUMBIA
SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Curvature
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
0.00760
0.00799
0.00772
0.00768
0.00772
0.00769
0.08968
0.07544
0.16105
0.13986
0.22738
0.14967
0.00570
0.00599
0.00579
0.00576
0.00579
0.00577
0.06726
0.05658
0.12079
0.10490
0.17054
0.11225
Lampiran 45
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE RESPONSE2000 SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
Curvature
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
0.00766
0.00796
0.00775
0.00763
0.00776
0.00768
0.07543
0.07543
0.13144
0.11765
0.19322
0.12575
0.00575
0.00597
0.00581
0.00572
0.00582
0.00576
0.05657
0.05657
0.09858
0.08824
0.14492
0.09431
Lampiran 46
TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE XTRACT
SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
Characteristics of Test
Specimen
DN_SP00_R0_230
DN_SP50_R0_230
DL_SP00_R0_82
DL_SP00_R0_100
US_SP00_R0_50
US_SP00_R0_93
Curvature
Displacement
First Yield
(1/m)
Ultimate
(1/m)
First Yield
(kN-m)
Ultimate
(kN-m)
0.00590
0.00608
0.00600
0.00598
0.00605
0.00595
0.07061
0.06326
0.07027
0.07020
0.07146
0.07132
0.00443
0.00456
0.00450
0.00449
0.00454
0.00446
0.05296
0.04745
0.05270
0.05265
0.05360
0.05349
130
Universitas Sumatera Utara