The significance of the title as revealed through the relationship of the main character in D.H. Lawrence's novel, sons and lovers - Widya Mandala Catholic University Surabaya Repository
CHAPTBRI
IIITRODUCTION
1.1
Background
of
In studyinE
access
to
becomes
way
of
(Lazar,
sources is
increases
country
vocabulary
opinions
ES
literature
course,
this
literary
literature
is
is not
students
work
written
There
a Eood
are
sone
enrichnent,
students'
The last
insiEht
learnt.
provides
and
Second,
8s
context
of
rich
reason,
as
encourages students
into
to
personal
express
and feelings.
throuElh
sone
the
cultural
One of the ways in expressing
that
languaEe
in the classroom (Co}1ie
the foreign
lit,erature
of
often
which provides
text
First,
grannar.
and
involvement,
their
One
n h o s e l a n E f u a E l ei s b e i n g
language enrichnent,
English
acqui.sition.
literature
1987:3-5).
Iinited
stimulating
1993:17).
this
have fairly
written
for
a literary
stinulatinEl
literature
and
inportance
reasons in using
the
"students
EnEIish,
prinary
SLater,
Study
spoken English,
acquisition"
English
the
analyzinEl a
an easy task.
opinions
literary
This
have difficulty
because
and feelings
they do not
in
can
work.
be
0f
seen
analyzinEl
the
understand
the
2
parts
inportant
comprehend
of the literary
what
they
encouraEles herself
Literature
classes.
economical
inaglery,
into
poetry
is
figurative
prose fiction
which presents
or narrative
one or a few najor
diffieulties
the
stories.
has
reasons.
length,
novel
other
as
1989:53).
nessage
implies
explore
a
means
fn
the
whether
of
event:
sharing
noveL,
implicitly
to the truth.
events
The last
narrative
forn
on
there
or
and
fictions,
which
creates
an
and dialogue.
"a
a novel because
novel
greatly
is
1967:!At).
Because of
in considerable
characters.
could be a social
The
which focuses
in studying
(LittIe,
the
sound.
fictional
includes
story
character"
of
on
novels
of all,
the noveL will
heavily
This
First
the relationship
a
lonEfest
i.s interested
eoncerned with
its
the
and
nore
problens
through description
The writer
sone
nuch
and deals with
Anong the forms of
imagined world
of
lives.
or
Elenres
is
by actors.
fiction
characters
in their
novel
which
writer
work.
three
language, rhythn
and is designed to be perforned
short
the
the use of words and relies
second is drana or play
is
Hence,
the literary
classified
first
in
read.
in analyzing
is
The
have
work or even they do not
Second,
people read
also
or explicitly
The nessaEleusually
"reading
to
experience"
is
depth
each
( Robert,
significant
stated
deals with
that
the
q
prob leEs
of
life.
inaginative
the
literature
favorite
and readers
(Kennedy, 1991:213).
"the
novel
the
is
(1967:1El1). Next,
main
problems,
also
in
character
and structure.
it,
such
as
Among nany elenents
hold
eharacter
story
eannot
problems
By
part
important
to
be
be
thene
developnent
conflict
the
can
be
of the character,
and
its
outcome
explored
is
a
no
characters.
understand
in the story
characters
elenents
there
the
we can a]so
chooses
a conflict,
because
by
many
conflict,
these
a story
own
writer
has
and thene because
I{ithout
her
the
setting,
the characters
Furthernore,
or
theme,
faced and solved
between
his
writer
said
relationship
how
the novel
in the story.
of
goes on,
the
analyzinEl the conflict,
characteristics
the
since
of novel,
severa]
a novel,
ends. Finally,
precious
elenents
conflict,
by analyzing
faces and solves
and how the story
Eets sonething
Little
for
anxious to know how the story
eharacter
two
of
recognised
the
more
as the najority
and
have
been
the
novelists
readers
of
for
ideas,
feels
for
one of the best vehicles
of moral and social
writer
has
In addition,
expression
centuries"
forns
in EnEllish, the novel
of both writers
hundred years"
says that
"anong
Third,
and
the
the
thenselves.
through
the nature
of the
(Perrine,
1966: 121)
the
central
In
4
conclusion,
analyzing
the thene cannot be separated
analyzinEl the conflict
In this
Lawrence
study,
as
and the character.
the writer
a novelist
at
working
that
time,
elasses .
remarkable
with
lloreover,
1996:562).
stories
Lawrence
Sons and Lovers
into
The
relations,
relation
good
(1913),
applying
his
theories
health,
that
Peacock
which is
in particular
nake
( 1911),
later
split
(L927).
the problens
hunan
poor
many poens,
and Honen in Love
deseribing
As Kettle
is
poor
of nan and wonan. Besides that,
in
output
his
The Hhite
The Sisters
the
and his
novels
of
of
life
besides novels,
Lawrence deals with
novelist
conflict
are
Rainbon (1915)
these novels,
Despite
in
condition
Lawrence's
and essays. The four
well-known
interested
the situation
unsettled
Lawrence nanages to produce,
short
is
the social
especially
considerinel his
(Drabble,
health
would take David Herbert
beeause she
Lawrence's works which deal
England
fron
In
hunan
of
to
Lawrence is
relationship
the
a
and
says,
"Lawrence sees human relationship
essentially
in
terms of a conflict
out of which a synthesis is possible
convey
but by no neans inevitable.
It is his ability
to
- which does indeed Eto
sense of eonflict
across
this
finest
his
deeper than a rational
level - which Aives
personal
their
unique
relationships
descriptions
of
(1976l.7O4)
force and insight".
The
writer
would
like
to analyze
Sons and Lovers
si,nce
in this
Eluise
of
says
that
noveI,
fiction
inportant
young
finest
his
"Sons
noveI,
Lawrence wants to describe
the work that
novelists
that
nasterpiece"
( 1385 : 7).
his
's
side
the working classes
soot
penury,
and
obj ects
of
of
Sons
simply present
nother
This
doninated
by their
Lovers
not as
h i m a m o n g [t h e
novel
's
father
mother's
up,
as
hunan
nor
with
women. In addition,
that
fate.
Through this
Lawrence hinself
as clearly
even
in his
life,
as
which
boys
has
so
when the boys
relationships
had
suffered
Lawrence describes
as possible.
has two roles
in their
century
of
that
satisfactory
novel,
is
However,
beings
a fanily
affection
they cannot forn
.
are displayed
of fun
depicts
it
Lawrence's
is
figures
but
so
a nan who has chosen
and rej ected his
novel
first
Sons--and-LayeRs.does
the readers with
grow
main character,
established
the
EngeI
Lawrence's
generati.on in the twentieth
identified.
roles
was
Furthernore,
in this
youth.
and
his Eleneration,
and
conpassion,
gleneration after
l{oreI's
childhood
Lovers
and
undeniable
not
own
in
PauI l'lorel,
as a son
PauL
the
and
as a 1over. Niven states,
"In Paul's case, he is not iust a son to his nother
roles
can be
and a lover
to Hiriam
and Clara; the
times alnost his mother's
reversed
as he becones at
the
both
other women a kind of
beau and seeks fron
maternalism" ( 1978:49).
substitute
This
idea becones the title
of Lawrence's novel
Sons and
I.overs.
1.2 Statenent
This
of
of
study
is
intended
the main eharacter
Sons
and Lovers.
main character,
a
the Problens
writer
Paul l{orel
problen
main
character
relationship
between
charaeters,
the writer
into
I{hat
is
does
P a uI
unsuccessful
1-3 Objectives
The
The
the
In analyzinE!
the
and
to elaborate
other
the main
questions:
between
Paul
l.loreI, as
l'loreI , as a lover , always exper ience
relationships
of
roles,
between
character
would like
as
nother?
with
his
the study
is
lovers
?
the Study
objective
relati-onshi.p
main
relationship
a son, and his
2 . lihy
the
the
life,
problem.
the main
characters?"
the followinEl
the
novel,
character's
the relationship
and other
entitled
has two roLes in his
to write
"l{hat is
is
of the
Fron the nain
would like
main
problen
of D.H Lawrence's novel
Based on the title
son and as a lover.
the
to analyze the relationship
between
of
the
main
to
character
analyze
and
the
other
.7
characters.
following
to
This
objective
the
as a son, and
2, to find
out
always
his
paul llorel,
why paul Horel,
as a lover,
mother ,
experiences
unsuccessful
relationships
with
lovers.
of
The writer
more
greatest
of his
hopes that
English
works deal with
study
of
is
Final Iy,
Catholic
of
especially
novels.
literature
students.
,
because
at
study
some
almost
contributi.on
the English
Departnent
hopefu l1y
to
of
Departnent
encouraEles other
of
l{idya
to write
a study on literary
In other
words, the
will
the
University.
the English
University
novelists
of
psychology natters.
literature
this
people nay
Lawrence as one
aimed to give
llandala Catholic
students
through her study,
about David Herbert
the teaching
I'lidya
the Study
psychological
. This
that
the
between
relationship
the reasons
1.4 Significance
know
into
objectives:
describe
his
can be elaborated
become nore
wrj.ter
Handala
works,
expects
interestinEl
to
1.5 Scope and Linitation
The writer
one
of
of this
the
Lawrence's
particularly
nother
his
the
1.6 Definition
this
lovers,
works
in
her study only
of
based
part
important
the whole story
To
limits
in the relationship
and
thene is
thesis
Sons
and
in
Lovers
anong Paul HoreI,
his
on the reason that
this
the novel
and
influences
of the novel.
of f,ey Teras
avoid nisunderstandinEf,
some key terns
used
in
study are defined.
1. A
Novel
"a
is
considerable
length,
is unfolded
by
2. A charaeter
all
the
story
the actions,
is
good
plot
having
speech and
another
with
force
"a reasonable of a hunan
and the bad traits
is usually
character
with
or
typically
narrative
of
that
thouElhts of
c h a r a e t e r s " . ( S o u k h a n o v , 1 9 9 6 r 1 2 3 9) .
the
a
prose
fictional
nust
face.
character,
an idea
action.
3. Conflict
concerned with
is
or
(Robert,
"a
clash
of being
a najor
This may involve
with
a difficult
g fe n e r a l
being,
with
hunan". A
problem
that
interaetion
situation,
circunstances
that
1989:56).
of
actions,
ideas,
desires
I
or
rrills".
The
nain
other
nan");
he
force
-
physical
nature,
against
environnent");
or
nay
be
in
sonle elenents
in
hinself"
conflict
enotional
The
his
or nora1.
1.7 Theoretical
There
is
says
literary
is
that
her child
1.8 Organization
This
( "man
nature
with
against
physical,
be
nay
nental,
1966:59).
theory
novel,
thesis
of
which
this
in
deals
case
other
"any study of
the
characters
will
Freud,
a nother's
controlling
nost
in
a
author's
psychological
quoted
as
role
of
characters.
an
a
include
Besides that,
life.
between
with
analyzinEl
with
t,hat when only
inevitably
aspects of
("nan
fate
relationship
writing
(1986:8).
Bee, inplies
she
own
a fundanental
his
analysis"
or
he nay be in conflict
work or the relationship
and
some external
Franework
the main character's
Guerin
wi.th
society
(Perrine,
analyzinEl Sons and Lovers
Iife
conflict
against
( "nan aElainst
person or Elroup of persons
some
).
nay be pitted
eharacter
is
the
by
present,
inportant
(1975:.275).
the Study
is divided
into
five
chapters.
Chapter
7g
one presents
of
the
the backElround of
problens,
signifieance
definition
orEanization
review
the objectives
of the study,
of
key
of
and
the study.
related
about the nethodology.
analysis
of
characters.
conclusion
the nain
Fina1ly,
of
the
statenent
study,
theoretical
franework
Chapter two
deals
literature
studies.
which
Chapter
Chapter four
character's
chapter
and sugEestion.
the
the
the seope and linitation,
terns,
of the reLated
theories
the study,
covers
three
diseusses
relationship
five
is dealing
the
and
with
a
related
concerns
about the
with
with
other
the
IIITRODUCTION
1.1
Background
of
In studyinE
access
to
becomes
way
of
(Lazar,
sources is
increases
country
vocabulary
opinions
ES
literature
course,
this
literary
literature
is
is not
students
work
written
There
a Eood
are
sone
enrichnent,
students'
The last
insiEht
learnt.
provides
and
Second,
8s
context
of
rich
reason,
as
encourages students
into
to
personal
express
and feelings.
throuElh
sone
the
cultural
One of the ways in expressing
that
languaEe
in the classroom (Co}1ie
the foreign
lit,erature
of
often
which provides
text
First,
grannar.
and
involvement,
their
One
n h o s e l a n E f u a E l ei s b e i n g
language enrichnent,
English
acqui.sition.
literature
1987:3-5).
Iinited
stimulating
1993:17).
this
have fairly
written
for
a literary
stinulatinEl
literature
and
inportance
reasons in using
the
"students
EnEIish,
prinary
SLater,
Study
spoken English,
acquisition"
English
the
analyzinEl a
an easy task.
opinions
literary
This
have difficulty
because
and feelings
they do not
in
can
work.
be
0f
seen
analyzinEl
the
understand
the
2
parts
inportant
comprehend
of the literary
what
they
encouraEles herself
Literature
classes.
economical
inaglery,
into
poetry
is
figurative
prose fiction
which presents
or narrative
one or a few najor
diffieulties
the
stories.
has
reasons.
length,
novel
other
as
1989:53).
nessage
implies
explore
a
means
fn
the
whether
of
event:
sharing
noveL,
implicitly
to the truth.
events
The last
narrative
forn
on
there
or
and
fictions,
which
creates
an
and dialogue.
"a
a novel because
novel
greatly
is
1967:!At).
Because of
in considerable
characters.
could be a social
The
which focuses
in studying
(LittIe,
the
sound.
fictional
includes
story
character"
of
on
novels
of all,
the noveL will
heavily
This
First
the relationship
a
lonEfest
i.s interested
eoncerned with
its
the
and
nore
problens
through description
The writer
sone
nuch
and deals with
Anong the forms of
imagined world
of
lives.
or
Elenres
is
by actors.
fiction
characters
in their
novel
which
writer
work.
three
language, rhythn
and is designed to be perforned
short
the
the use of words and relies
second is drana or play
is
Hence,
the literary
classified
first
in
read.
in analyzing
is
The
have
work or even they do not
Second,
people read
also
or explicitly
The nessaEleusually
"reading
to
experience"
is
depth
each
( Robert,
significant
stated
deals with
that
the
q
prob leEs
of
life.
inaginative
the
literature
favorite
and readers
(Kennedy, 1991:213).
"the
novel
the
is
(1967:1El1). Next,
main
problems,
also
in
character
and structure.
it,
such
as
Among nany elenents
hold
eharacter
story
eannot
problems
By
part
important
to
be
be
thene
developnent
conflict
the
can
be
of the character,
and
its
outcome
explored
is
a
no
characters.
understand
in the story
characters
elenents
there
the
we can a]so
chooses
a conflict,
because
by
many
conflict,
these
a story
own
writer
has
and thene because
I{ithout
her
the
setting,
the characters
Furthernore,
or
theme,
faced and solved
between
his
writer
said
relationship
how
the novel
in the story.
of
goes on,
the
analyzinEl the conflict,
characteristics
the
since
of novel,
severa]
a novel,
ends. Finally,
precious
elenents
conflict,
by analyzing
faces and solves
and how the story
Eets sonething
Little
for
anxious to know how the story
eharacter
two
of
recognised
the
more
as the najority
and
have
been
the
novelists
readers
of
for
ideas,
feels
for
one of the best vehicles
of moral and social
writer
has
In addition,
expression
centuries"
forns
in EnEllish, the novel
of both writers
hundred years"
says that
"anong
Third,
and
the
the
thenselves.
through
the nature
of the
(Perrine,
1966: 121)
the
central
In
4
conclusion,
analyzing
the thene cannot be separated
analyzinEl the conflict
In this
Lawrence
study,
as
and the character.
the writer
a novelist
at
working
that
time,
elasses .
remarkable
with
lloreover,
1996:562).
stories
Lawrence
Sons and Lovers
into
The
relations,
relation
good
(1913),
applying
his
theories
health,
that
Peacock
which is
in particular
nake
( 1911),
later
split
(L927).
the problens
hunan
poor
many poens,
and Honen in Love
deseribing
As Kettle
is
poor
of nan and wonan. Besides that,
in
output
his
The Hhite
The Sisters
the
and his
novels
of
of
life
besides novels,
Lawrence deals with
novelist
conflict
are
Rainbon (1915)
these novels,
Despite
in
condition
Lawrence's
and essays. The four
well-known
interested
the situation
unsettled
Lawrence nanages to produce,
short
is
the social
especially
considerinel his
(Drabble,
health
would take David Herbert
beeause she
Lawrence's works which deal
England
fron
In
hunan
of
to
Lawrence is
relationship
the
a
and
says,
"Lawrence sees human relationship
essentially
in
terms of a conflict
out of which a synthesis is possible
convey
but by no neans inevitable.
It is his ability
to
- which does indeed Eto
sense of eonflict
across
this
finest
his
deeper than a rational
level - which Aives
personal
their
unique
relationships
descriptions
of
(1976l.7O4)
force and insight".
The
writer
would
like
to analyze
Sons and Lovers
si,nce
in this
Eluise
of
says
that
noveI,
fiction
inportant
young
finest
his
"Sons
noveI,
Lawrence wants to describe
the work that
novelists
that
nasterpiece"
( 1385 : 7).
his
's
side
the working classes
soot
penury,
and
obj ects
of
of
Sons
simply present
nother
This
doninated
by their
Lovers
not as
h i m a m o n g [t h e
novel
's
father
mother's
up,
as
hunan
nor
with
women. In addition,
that
fate.
Through this
Lawrence hinself
as clearly
even
in his
life,
as
which
boys
has
so
when the boys
relationships
had
suffered
Lawrence describes
as possible.
has two roles
in their
century
of
that
satisfactory
novel,
is
However,
beings
a fanily
affection
they cannot forn
.
are displayed
of fun
depicts
it
Lawrence's
is
figures
but
so
a nan who has chosen
and rej ected his
novel
first
Sons--and-LayeRs.does
the readers with
grow
main character,
established
the
EngeI
Lawrence's
generati.on in the twentieth
identified.
roles
was
Furthernore,
in this
youth.
and
his Eleneration,
and
conpassion,
gleneration after
l{oreI's
childhood
Lovers
and
undeniable
not
own
in
PauI l'lorel,
as a son
PauL
the
and
as a 1over. Niven states,
"In Paul's case, he is not iust a son to his nother
roles
can be
and a lover
to Hiriam
and Clara; the
times alnost his mother's
reversed
as he becones at
the
both
other women a kind of
beau and seeks fron
maternalism" ( 1978:49).
substitute
This
idea becones the title
of Lawrence's novel
Sons and
I.overs.
1.2 Statenent
This
of
of
study
is
intended
the main eharacter
Sons
and Lovers.
main character,
a
the Problens
writer
Paul l{orel
problen
main
character
relationship
between
charaeters,
the writer
into
I{hat
is
does
P a uI
unsuccessful
1-3 Objectives
The
The
the
In analyzinE!
the
and
to elaborate
other
the main
questions:
between
Paul
l.loreI, as
l'loreI , as a lover , always exper ience
relationships
of
roles,
between
character
would like
as
nother?
with
his
the study
is
lovers
?
the Study
objective
relati-onshi.p
main
relationship
a son, and his
2 . lihy
the
the
life,
problem.
the main
characters?"
the followinEl
the
novel,
character's
the relationship
and other
entitled
has two roLes in his
to write
"l{hat is
is
of the
Fron the nain
would like
main
problen
of D.H Lawrence's novel
Based on the title
son and as a lover.
the
to analyze the relationship
between
of
the
main
to
character
analyze
and
the
other
.7
characters.
following
to
This
objective
the
as a son, and
2, to find
out
always
his
paul llorel,
why paul Horel,
as a lover,
mother ,
experiences
unsuccessful
relationships
with
lovers.
of
The writer
more
greatest
of his
hopes that
English
works deal with
study
of
is
Final Iy,
Catholic
of
especially
novels.
literature
students.
,
because
at
study
some
almost
contributi.on
the English
Departnent
hopefu l1y
to
of
Departnent
encouraEles other
of
l{idya
to write
a study on literary
In other
words, the
will
the
University.
the English
University
novelists
of
psychology natters.
literature
this
people nay
Lawrence as one
aimed to give
llandala Catholic
students
through her study,
about David Herbert
the teaching
I'lidya
the Study
psychological
. This
that
the
between
relationship
the reasons
1.4 Significance
know
into
objectives:
describe
his
can be elaborated
become nore
wrj.ter
Handala
works,
expects
interestinEl
to
1.5 Scope and Linitation
The writer
one
of
of this
the
Lawrence's
particularly
nother
his
the
1.6 Definition
this
lovers,
works
in
her study only
of
based
part
important
the whole story
To
limits
in the relationship
and
thene is
thesis
Sons
and
in
Lovers
anong Paul HoreI,
his
on the reason that
this
the novel
and
influences
of the novel.
of f,ey Teras
avoid nisunderstandinEf,
some key terns
used
in
study are defined.
1. A
Novel
"a
is
considerable
length,
is unfolded
by
2. A charaeter
all
the
story
the actions,
is
good
plot
having
speech and
another
with
force
"a reasonable of a hunan
and the bad traits
is usually
character
with
or
typically
narrative
of
that
thouElhts of
c h a r a e t e r s " . ( S o u k h a n o v , 1 9 9 6 r 1 2 3 9) .
the
a
prose
fictional
nust
face.
character,
an idea
action.
3. Conflict
concerned with
is
or
(Robert,
"a
clash
of being
a najor
This may involve
with
a difficult
g fe n e r a l
being,
with
hunan". A
problem
that
interaetion
situation,
circunstances
that
1989:56).
of
actions,
ideas,
desires
I
or
rrills".
The
nain
other
nan");
he
force
-
physical
nature,
against
environnent");
or
nay
be
in
sonle elenents
in
hinself"
conflict
enotional
The
his
or nora1.
1.7 Theoretical
There
is
says
literary
is
that
her child
1.8 Organization
This
( "man
nature
with
against
physical,
be
nay
nental,
1966:59).
theory
novel,
thesis
of
which
this
in
deals
case
other
"any study of
the
characters
will
Freud,
a nother's
controlling
nost
in
a
author's
psychological
quoted
as
role
of
characters.
an
a
include
Besides that,
life.
between
with
analyzinEl
with
t,hat when only
inevitably
aspects of
("nan
fate
relationship
writing
(1986:8).
Bee, inplies
she
own
a fundanental
his
analysis"
or
he nay be in conflict
work or the relationship
and
some external
Franework
the main character's
Guerin
wi.th
society
(Perrine,
analyzinEl Sons and Lovers
Iife
conflict
against
( "nan aElainst
person or Elroup of persons
some
).
nay be pitted
eharacter
is
the
by
present,
inportant
(1975:.275).
the Study
is divided
into
five
chapters.
Chapter
7g
one presents
of
the
the backElround of
problens,
signifieance
definition
orEanization
review
the objectives
of the study,
of
key
of
and
the study.
related
about the nethodology.
analysis
of
characters.
conclusion
the nain
Fina1ly,
of
the
statenent
study,
theoretical
franework
Chapter two
deals
literature
studies.
which
Chapter
Chapter four
character's
chapter
and sugEestion.
the
the
the seope and linitation,
terns,
of the reLated
theories
the study,
covers
three
diseusses
relationship
five
is dealing
the
and
with
a
related
concerns
about the
with
with
other
the