Pengaruh Buffle Cut Terhadap Unjuk Kerja Termal Dan Penurunan Tekanan Pada Alat Penukar Kalor Shell And Tube Susunan Tabung Segiempat
69
Lampiran 1. Data hasil pengujian
Tabel 1. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 11%
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas
air panas
udara
Udara
tekanan
udara
masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
o
o
o
o
m/s
( C)
( C)
( C)
( C)
2,6
80,1
76,7
31,6
61,1
18,3
3,1
80,1
76,7
31,6
61,2
27,2
3,6
80,1
76,8
31,6
61,3
35,6
4,1
80,1
76,8
31,6
62,2
47,2
4,6
80,1
76,9
31,6
62,2
58,5
5,1
80,1
76,9
31,6
62,3
64,3
Tabel 2. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 25,6 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
o
o
o
o
m/s
( C)
( C)
( C)
( C)
2,6
80,5
76,5
31,6
62,7
18,3
3,1
80,5
76,6
31,6
63,1
24,2
3,6
80,5
76,6
31,5
63,5
28,0
4,1
80,5
76,6
31,6
63,8
35,7
4,6
80,5
76,5
31,6
64,2
46,3
5,1
80,5
76,6
31,7
64,6
52,3
70
Tabel 3. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 38,88 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
keluar
m/s
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
2,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,8
15,5
3,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,2
21,7
3,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,4
26,0
4,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,8
34,8
4,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
63,2
42,7
5,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
63,6
51,7
Tabel 4. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 48,97 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
m/s
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
2,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,1
12,7
3,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,5
16,0
3,6
80,1
76,4
31,6
61,8
22,7
4,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,2
31,3
4,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,6
39,3
5,1
80,1
76,6
31,7
63,0
43,3
LAMPIRAN 3 : HASIL PERHITUNGAN HEAT TRANSFER
Hari/Tanggal : Senin / 1 Mei 2013
Jam
: 10:42:46
Vu
m/s
res
res1
res2
ho
W/m2oC
ho1
W/m2oC
ho2
W/m2oC
11
11
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
777.25755
410.12944
423.26396
435.71686
447.57222
458.89858
771.55696
407.10184
420.1394
432.50037
444.26822
455.51096
765.32339
403.79662
416.72833
428.98894
440.66124
451.81271
758.62144
138.26056
139.87331
147.36104
154.59909
161.61324
168.42484
137.24652
138.84075
146.27321
153.45783
160.4202
167.18151
136.13768
137.71352
145.08563
152.21192
159.11776
165.82418
134.94552
153.28165
155.39422
163.71121
171.75064
179.54114
187.51109
152.15744
154.24709
162.50268
170.48276
178.21576
186.12687
150.92813
152.99477
161.18334
169.09863
176.76884
184.61572
149.60645
71
Bc
Bc
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
400.24745
413.06549
425.21834
436.78805
447.8415
751.50078
396.48022
409.17762
421.21608
432.67689
443.6263
744.00148
392.5158
405.08623
417.00432
428.35054
439.19047
736.15695
388.3716
400.80931
412.60157
423.82799
434.55347
727.99584
384.06252
396.36224
136.50308
143.8104
150.87406
157.7192
164.36667
133.67888
135.21828
142.45682
149.45399
156.2347
162.81961
132.34488
133.86623
141.03239
147.95959
154.67251
161.19157
130.94948
132.45286
139.54336
146.39743
153.03947
159.4897
129.49776
130.98327
137.9951
151.65002
159.76662
167.61234
175.21513
182.99304
148.2022
150.22265
158.26285
166.03473
173.56596
181.27067
146.72327
148.72057
156.68038
164.37454
171.83047
179.45813
145.17627
147.15037
155.02614
162.63907
170.01628
177.56341
143.56683
145.5177
153.30608
72
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
408.02366
419.12552
429.732
719.54315
379.6016
391.75845
403.28443
414.25734
424.74062
710.8211
375.0004
387.0099
398.39616
409.23607
419.59228
701.84969
370.26933
382.12731
393.36993
404.07307
414.29863
692.64711
365.41786
377.12047
388.21578
398.77869
144.77312
151.34146
157.72013
127.99417
129.46188
136.39227
143.09156
149.58361
155.88819
126.44267
127.89266
134.73904
141.35713
147.77049
153.99865
124.84681
126.27914
133.03915
139.57374
145.90619
152.05578
123.20983
124.62457
131.296
137.74497
143.99445
160.83455
168.1299
175.5933
141.89989
143.8275
151.52542
158.96644
166.17706
173.55377
140.17983
142.08415
149.68876
157.03959
164.16281
171.4501
138.41059
140.29159
147.80026
155.05835
162.0917
169.28705
136.59577
138.45342
145.8637
153.02669
159.96789
73
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
22
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
15
10
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
137.70363
91.802416
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
100.98266
110.1629
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
19,052.50
22,351.03
14,180.37
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
15,857.28
17,442.17
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,125.77
22,866.14
26,826.29
17,101.53
17,101.53
19,125.77
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
19,125.77
20,932.95
408.87027
683.23006
360.45469
371.99836
382.94297
393.36241
403.31692
673.61399
355.38787
366.76927
377.56003
387.83301
397.64759
663.81329
350.22488
372.07493
391.87066
653.84143
653.84143
344.97273
356.02059
366.49511
376.46703
385.99398
339.63804
350.51504
150.06346
121.5347
122.93189
129.51271
135.8741
142.03869
148.02527
119.82417
121.20387
127.69218
133.96415
140.04209
145.94452
118.0808
119.44305
132.01795
143.82427
116.30698
116.30698
117.65182
123.94999
130.03814
135.93796
141.66741
115.83244
122.03321
167.06896
134.73864
136.57292
143.88256
150.94825
157.79518
164.7998
132.84228
134.65314
141.86003
148.82641
155.57709
162.48325
130.9095
132.41458
146.6643
159.77721
128.94296
128.94296
130.42883
137.70263
144.46485
151.01768
157.38111
128.41186
135.57318
74
22
23
23
23
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
25
26
26
26
26
26
26
26
27
27
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
360.82759
370.6453
380.02493
633.43415
334.227
355.07897
364.74026
373.97046
623.02199
328.74551
339.27369
349.2555
358.75834
367.83716
612.48529
323.19915
333.5497
343.36311
352.70563
361.63127
601.8342
317.59321
327.76422
337.40741
346.58788
355.35871
128.02722
133.8358
139.47665
112.67688
113.98703
125.98752
131.70356
137.25454
110.82474
112.11758
118.11949
123.92126
129.54356
135.0035
108.95044
110.22601
116.12666
121.83055
127.35799
132.72581
107.0558
108.31412
114.11242
119.71738
125.14894
130.42366
142.23083
148.68233
154.94735
124.6539
126.36603
139.96484
146.31356
152.47877
122.60489
124.29357
130.94469
137.66934
143.91394
149.97804
120.53136
122.19657
128.73548
135.34669
141.48593
147.44772
118.43533
120.07705
126.50254
132.99907
139.03183
144.89021
75
27
27
27
28
28
28
28
28
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
30
30
30
30
30
31
31
31
31
31
31
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
591.07838
311.93269
321.92243
331.39375
340.41059
349.0251
580.22695
306.22237
316.02923
325.32717
334.17895
342.63575
569.28858
300.46675
310.08928
319.21246
327.89786
336.19572
558.27145
294.67007
304.10696
313.05413
321.57198
329.70975
547.18322
288.83634
105.14253
106.38362
112.07858
117.58364
122.91839
128.0991
103.21225
104.43614
110.02684
115.43112
120.66822
125.75408
101.2665
102.4732
107.95882
113.26152
118.40019
123.39046
99.306748
100.49626
105.87605
111.07646
116.11598
121.00999
97.334347
98.506689
116.31868
117.9369
124.24787
130.62861
136.55384
142.30781
114.18322
115.77792
121.97336
128.23729
134.05405
139.70268
112.03065
113.60181
119.6808
125.55675
131.53443
137.07689
109.86259
111.41017
117.37189
123.13448
128.99684
134.43237
107.68053
109.20453
76
32
32
32
32
32
32
33
33
33
33
33
33
34
34
34
34
34
34
35
35
35
35
35
35
36
36
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
298.08641
306.85644
315.20566
323.18232
536.03111
282.96929
292.03147
300.62336
308.80298
316.61762
524.82178
277.0724
285.94573
294.35857
302.36773
310.01951
513.56139
271.14885
279.83247
288.06546
295.90339
303.39159
502.2555
265.20154
273.69469
281.7471
103.77997
108.87742
113.81718
118.61429
95.35058
96.505752
101.67192
106.66583
111.50524
116.20492
93.356636
94.494636
99.553147
104.44298
109.18155
113.78328
91.353608
92.474429
97.424793
102.21009
106.84735
111.3507
89.342489
90.446117
95.287901
99.968235
115.04822
120.69672
126.44302
131.77095
105.4859
106.98629
112.71128
118.24505
123.87462
129.09432
103.28001
104.75677
110.36245
115.7809
121.29316
126.40408
101.06406
102.51717
108.003
113.30561
118.70002
123.70168
98.839173
100.26858
105.63409
110.82039
77
36
36
36
36
37
37
37
37
37
37
38
38
38
38
38
38
39
39
39
39
39
39
40
40
40
40
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,243.58
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,107.21
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
289.41312
296.73707
490.90912
259.23304
267.53505
275.40623
282.89972
290.05884
253.24559
261.35586
269.04524
276.36565
283.35942
468.11158
247.24109
262.66613
269.81297
276.64092
456.66702
241.22103
248.9462
256.27048
263.24331
269.905
445.19506
235.18649
104.50378
108.90836
87.31219
88.410579
93.143396
97.718397
102.15187
106.45732
86.368581
90.992085
95.461419
99.792493
103.9985
83.257461
84.306527
93.19801
97.426394
101.53268
81.221953
82.253751
86.655623
90.928736
95.054163
99.060462
79.181571
80.196037
116.09649
120.98844
96.796202
98.01198
103.25674
108.32632
113.23879
118.26553
95.748221
100.87184
105.82433
110.62334
115.53398
92.104641
93.460378
103.31522
108.00044
112.79465
89.852834
91.184715
96.269379
100.7996
105.37074
110.04821
87.595636
88.903579
78
40
40
41
41
41
41
41
41
42
42
42
42
42
43
43
43
43
43
44
44
44
44
44
44
45
45
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
17,586.92
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
21,214.05
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,963.47
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,174.13
242.7184
249.85945
256.65784
263.15288
433.697
229.13809
236.47631
243.43371
250.05726
256.38526
422.17321
223.076
230.22008
236.99341
243.44173
249.60232
410.62311
216.99983
223.94932
230.53816
236.81084
242.80362
399.04501
210.90865
217.66307
224.06696
84.487789
88.654003
92.676226
96.582301
77.136547
78.133601
82.314981
86.356753
90.292832
94.098452
75.086948
76.066494
80.13725
84.072093
87.904039
91.608977
73.032667
73.994586
77.954463
81.782129
85.509699
89.113722
70.973408
71.91756
75.766284
79.486507
93.65945
98.277931
102.73472
107.29518
85.333301
86.617207
91.25077
95.936388
100.09264
104.53582
83.065906
84.325657
88.836633
93.398289
97.444586
101.77021
80.793331
82.028786
86.416892
90.854296
94.79038
98.798931
78.515249
79.72624
83.991172
88.113469
79
45
45
45
45
46
46
46
46
46
46
47
47
47
47
47
47
48
48
48
48
48
48
49
49
49
49
49
49
49
14
15
15
128.52338
137.70363
137.70363
20,688.65
22,351.03
22,351.03
24,956.76
26,963.47
26,963.47
230.16356
235.98813
235.98813
83.109444
86.612303
86.612303
92.129617
96.025648
96.025648
80
LAMPIRAN 3 : HASIL PERHITUNGAN HEAT TRANSFER
Hari/Tanggal : Senin / 6 Mei 2013
Jam
: 10:42:46
Bc% Vu Ntu
Ntu1
Ntu2
m/s
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
5,21034
4,42086
4,46531
4,50574
4,54277
4,57689
5,20267
4,41034
4,45491
4,49545
4,53259
4,56681
5,19418
4,39873
4,44343
4,4841
4,52135
4,55569
5,18493
2,68616
2,70556
2,78527
2,86035
2,93013
2,99347
2,67477
2,69407
2,77371
2,84872
2,91846
2,98178
2,66223
2,68143
2,761
2,83594
2,90563
2,96892
2,64866
2,85335
2,87331
2,95569
3,02987
3,10028
3,16725
2,84176
2,86164
2,94397
3,01813
3,08851
3,1555
2,82899
2,8488
2,93107
3,00521
3,07557
3,14256
2,81515
efektifitas1 efektifitas2 a1 a2 a3 a4
0,905054
0,898355
0,913728
0,925641
0,935031
0,942549
0,904845
0,897973
0,913368
0,925305
0,934716
0,942256
0,904612
0,897549
0,912969
0,924931
0,934367
0,94193
0,904358
0,773181
0,79475
0,816935
0,835699
0,851613
0,865091
0,772251
0,793792
0,815999
0,834791
0,850738
0,864251
0,77122
0,792732
0,814963
0,833786
0,849769
0,863321
0,770096
0,819829
0,83723
0,855624
0,870794
0,883616
0,894582
0,818927
0,836326
0,854758
0,869971
0,882835
0,893844
0,817927
0,835324
0,8538
0,869058
0,881969
0,893025
0,816836
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
81
11
11
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
efektifitas
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
4,38612
4,43096
4,47176
4,50914
4,5436
5,17496
4,37257
4,41756
4,4585
4,49602
4,5306
5,16429
4,35812
4,40327
4,44436
4,48202
4,51673
5,15295
4,34281
4,38812
4,42937
4,46717
4,50203
5,14094
4,32665
4,37214
2,66777
2,74725
2,82211
2,89174
2,95501
2,63413
2,65315
2,73254
2,80731
2,87688
2,94012
2,6187
2,63765
2,71693
2,7916
2,86109
2,9243
2,60243
2,6213
2,70046
2,77503
2,84444
2,90761
2,58535
2,60415
2,68318
2,83491
2,91711
2,99122
3,06156
3,12855
2,80034
2,82005
2,90217
2,97625
3,04655
3,11355
2,7846
2,80428
2,88631
2,96035
3,03061
3,09761
2,76799
2,78763
2,86958
2,94357
3,01378
3,08269
2,75054
2,77016
2,852
0,897086
0,912533
0,924523
0,933986
0,941574
0,904083
0,896585
0,912061
0,924081
0,933574
0,941189
0,903788
0,896049
0,911555
0,923607
0,93313
0,940775
0,903473
0,895476
0,911015
0,9231
0,932657
0,940333
0,903137
0,894868
0,910441
0,791578
0,813833
0,83269
0,848712
0,862305
0,768884
0,790333
0,812615
0,831508
0,847571
0,861209
0,767586
0,789001
0,811311
0,830242
0,846349
0,860033
0,766205
0,787584
0,809923
0,828893
0,845046
0,858781
0,764741
0,786083
0,808452
0,834231
0,852754
0,868062
0,881023
0,89213
0,815657
0,833052
0,851625
0,866987
0,880002
0,891163
0,814395
0,83179
0,850415
0,865834
0,878906
0,890125
0,81305
0,830445
0,849126
0,864605
0,877736
0,889134
0,811624
0,829019
0,847759
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
82
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
4,41355
4,45151
4,48651
5,12828
4,30967
4,35534
4,39692
4,43503
4,47019
5,11497
4,29188
4,33773
4,37948
4,41776
4,45307
5,10101
4,27328
4,31932
4,36125
4,3997
4,43517
5,08639
4,25389
4,30012
4,34223
4,38086
2,75764
2,82696
2,89175
2,56749
2,58622
2,66512
2,73945
2,80867
2,87339
2,54888
2,56755
2,6463
2,7205
2,78961
2,85424
2,52955
2,54817
2,62675
2,7008
2,76979
2,83433
2,50951
2,52807
2,60648
2,68037
2,74924
2,92594
2,99611
3,06498
2,73229
2,7519
2,83362
2,9075
2,97761
3,04644
2,71327
2,73286
2,81446
2,88827
2,95831
3,0271
2,6935
2,71308
2,79454
2,86827
2,93824
3,00697
2,67299
2,69398
2,77388
2,84753
2,91741
0,922562
0,932154
0,939862
0,902783
0,894224
0,909833
0,921992
0,93162
0,939362
0,902408
0,893544
0,90919
0,921389
0,931055
0,938834
0,902012
0,892828
0,908513
0,920753
0,930459
0,938276
0,901596
0,892075
0,907801
0,920083
0,929832
0,827464
0,843665
0,857565
0,763196
0,784498
0,806899
0,825953
0,842204
0,856158
0,761569
0,782831
0,805263
0,824361
0,840665
0,854675
0,759861
0,781079
0,803544
0,822688
0,839045
0,853114
0,75807
0,779244
0,801742
0,820933
0,837345
0,8633
0,876495
0,887957
0,810118
0,827513
0,846313
0,86192
0,875181
0,886711
0,808531
0,825926
0,844789
0,860463
0,873793
0,885394
0,806862
0,824257
0,843185
0,85893
0,872332
0,884007
0,805112
0,822611
0,841502
0,85732
0,870796
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
83
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
22
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
15
10
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
4,41649
5,07111
4,23369
4,28012
4,32242
4,36122
4,39703
5,05517
4,2127
4,25932
4,30181
4,3408
4,37679
5,03856
4,1909
4,28042
4,35575
5,02126
5,02126
4,1683
4,21534
4,25822
4,29758
4,33392
4,14489
4,19214
2,81368
2,48879
2,5073
2,58552
2,65924
2,72797
2,7923
2,46739
2,48586
2,56388
2,63741
2,70599
2,7702
2,44534
2,46376
2,6149
2,7474
2,42377
2,42377
2,44102
2,51859
2,59172
2,65997
2,7239
2,41765
2,49498
2,98608
2,65176
2,67273
2,7525
2,82762
2,89584
2,96444
2,62984
2,65078
2,7304
2,80539
2,87353
2,94205
2,60723
2,62486
2,78245
2,91553
2,58394
2,58394
2,60156
2,68412
2,75881
2,82677
2,8917
2,5776
2,65996
0,937688
0,901159
0,891284
0,907052
0,919379
0,929171
0,937069
0,900701
0,890454
0,906266
0,918639
0,928477
0,936418
0,90022
0,889585
0,917863
0,935735
0,899716
0,899716
0,888674
0,904578
0,917049
0,926984
0,935017
0,887721
0,903673
0,851474
0,756197
0,777323
0,799855
0,819094
0,835563
0,849753
0,75424
0,775317
0,797883
0,81717
0,833697
0,847952
0,752196
0,773222
0,815159
0,846066
0,750148
0,750148
0,771037
0,793672
0,813059
0,829708
0,844095
0,768761
0,791431
0,882547
0,803278
0,820776
0,839736
0,855741
0,869183
0,881013
0,80136
0,818856
0,837888
0,853971
0,867492
0,879405
0,799357
0,816534
0,852117
0,877453
0,797265
0,797265
0,814436
0,833935
0,850178
0,863867
0,875684
0,812247
0,831826
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
84
22
23
23
23
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
25
26
26
26
26
26
26
26
27
27
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
4,23522
4,27477
4,3113
4,98456
4,12066
4,2114
4,25115
4,28786
4,96513
4,0956
4,14327
4,18676
4,2267
4,2636
4,94495
4,06971
4,11759
4,16129
4,20142
4,23851
4,92401
4,04297
4,09106
4,13496
4,1753
4,21257
2,56788
2,63594
2,69972
2,37644
2,39366
2,54338
2,61124
2,67486
2,35185
2,36905
2,44583
2,51824
2,58589
2,64932
2,32666
2,34384
2,42033
2,49246
2,55988
2,62312
2,30086
2,31803
2,3953
2,46605
2,53322
2,59626
2,73447
2,80232
2,86715
2,53213
2,55298
2,70945
2,77718
2,84189
2,50687
2,52771
2,60633
2,68375
2,75135
2,81593
2,48098
2,5018
2,58018
2,65737
2,72483
2,78927
2,45559
2,47526
2,55338
2,63032
2,69905
2,76191
0,916196
0,926182
0,934264
0,898636
0,886724
0,915303
0,925342
0,933474
0,898058
0,885682
0,901736
0,914367
0,924461
0,932645
0,897453
0,884592
0,900699
0,913388
0,923538
0,931777
0,896821
0,883454
0,899615
0,912363
0,922572
0,930867
0,810869
0,82758
0,842036
0,745616
0,766391
0,808585
0,825359
0,839886
0,743211
0,763925
0,786663
0,806206
0,823044
0,837642
0,740709
0,76136
0,784132
0,803727
0,820631
0,835302
0,738109
0,758693
0,781591
0,801146
0,818116
0,832862
0,848153
0,861928
0,873831
0,792483
0,809964
0,846037
0,859902
0,871894
0,790111
0,807585
0,82701
0,843829
0,857785
0,869869
0,787641
0,805108
0,824613
0,841524
0,855575
0,867752
0,785163
0,802528
0,822114
0,839121
0,853377
0,865541
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
85
27
27
27
28
28
28
28
28
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
30
30
30
30
30
31
31
31
31
31
31
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
4,90229
4,01536
4,06367
4,10777
4,14831
4,18578
4,87976
3,98688
4,0354
4,07971
4,12044
4,1581
4,85641
3,95751
4,00624
4,05075
4,09168
4,12953
4,8322
3,92722
3,97616
4,02088
4,06201
4,10005
4,80711
3,89601
2,27448
2,29163
2,36853
2,43901
2,50592
2,56874
2,2475
2,26465
2,34117
2,41134
2,47798
2,54056
2,21995
2,23708
2,3132
2,38306
2,4494
2,51173
2,19182
2,20894
2,28463
2,35416
2,42019
2,48225
2,16313
2,18023
2,4284
2,44808
2,52715
2,60261
2,67113
2,73385
2,40058
2,42028
2,49902
2,57423
2,64253
2,7051
2,37214
2,39186
2,47025
2,54191
2,61325
2,67566
2,34308
2,36282
2,44084
2,51222
2,58329
2,64552
2,31341
2,33316
0,89616
0,882264
0,898482
0,91129
0,92156
0,929912
0,895469
0,881021
0,897296
0,910167
0,920499
0,928912
0,894746
0,879722
0,896056
0,908991
0,919388
0,927864
0,89399
0,878364
0,894759
0,90776
0,918224
0,926764
0,893199
0,876945
0,735407
0,755921
0,77885
0,79846
0,815497
0,830318
0,732599
0,75304
0,776001
0,795664
0,812769
0,827667
0,729683
0,750048
0,773038
0,792756
0,809928
0,824903
0,726653
0,746939
0,769959
0,789729
0,80697
0,822024
0,723508
0,743709
0,782487
0,799843
0,819613
0,836615
0,850968
0,863231
0,779704
0,797048
0,816901
0,834001
0,848454
0,860819
0,776809
0,79414
0,814076
0,830948
0,84583
0,858299
0,773799
0,791115
0,811134
0,828103
0,843093
0,855668
0,770668
0,787967
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
86
32
32
32
32
32
32
33
33
33
33
33
33
34
34
34
34
34
34
35
35
35
35
35
35
36
36
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
3,94516
3,99007
4,0314
4,06963
4,7811
3,86385
3,9132
3,95831
3,99983
4,03825
4,75415
3,83072
3,88027
3,92558
3,96728
4,00589
4,72621
3,7966
3,84633
3,89183
3,93373
3,97252
4,69725
3,76145
3,81137
3,85705
2,25547
2,32464
2,39034
2,45212
2,13386
2,15095
2,22572
2,29452
2,35986
2,42133
2,10403
2,1211
2,19538
2,26378
2,32875
2,3899
2,07363
2,09069
2,16445
2,23242
2,29701
2,35781
2,04267
2,05972
2,13293
2,20046
2,4108
2,48188
2,55266
2,61602
2,28313
2,30289
2,38011
2,45088
2,52134
2,58445
2,25223
2,27296
2,34879
2,42032
2,48935
2,55219
2,22071
2,24143
2,31682
2,38796
2,45667
2,51922
2,18859
2,20928
2,28421
2,35493
0,893402
0,906471
0,917004
0,92561
0,892371
0,875461
0,891982
0,905121
0,915725
0,9244
0,891505
0,87391
0,890495
0,903706
0,914383
0,92313
0,890597
0,872286
0,888938
0,902223
0,912975
0,921795
0,889646
0,870586
0,887306
0,900667
0,766757
0,786581
0,80389
0,819024
0,72024
0,740355
0,763429
0,783305
0,800683
0,815897
0,716847
0,73687
0,759969
0,779897
0,797344
0,812637
0,713322
0,73325
0,756371
0,77635
0,793865
0,80924
0,70966
0,729488
0,752629
0,772658
0,80807
0,825138
0,840237
0,853028
0,767412
0,784691
0,804879
0,822046
0,837257
0,850157
0,764026
0,781373
0,801555
0,818923
0,834146
0,847158
0,760504
0,777826
0,798092
0,81556
0,830899
0,844024
0,756839
0,774132
0,794484
0,812053
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
87
36
36
36
36
37
37
37
37
37
37
38
38
38
38
38
38
39
39
39
39
39
39
40
40
40
40
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
3,89913
3,9381
4,66723
3,72524
3,77535
3,82121
3,86347
3,90262
3,68795
3,73823
3,78427
3,8267
3,86602
4,60379
3,64954
3,74618
3,78878
3,82827
4,57026
3,60996
3,66055
3,70692
3,74967
3,78932
4,53546
3,56918
2,26462
2,32506
2,01096
2,02817
2,10081
2,16874
2,2316
2,29165
1,99606
2,0681
2,13551
2,19793
2,25757
1,9462
1,96314
2,10164
2,1636
2,22282
1,91296
1,92987
2,0006
2,06713
2,12861
2,18737
1,87913
1,89601
2,4233
2,48554
2,15865
2,17652
2,25096
2,32123
2,386
2,45114
2,14312
2,21705
2,28685
2,35125
2,41601
2,08903
2,10883
2,25178
2,31679
2,38014
2,05437
2,07417
2,15086
2,21602
2,28056
2,34353
2,01907
2,03885
0,911497
0,920393
0,888648
0,868806
0,885595
0,899035
0,909945
0,918919
0,866941
0,883801
0,89732
0,908312
0,917367
0,886501
0,864984
0,895517
0,906594
0,915733
0,885345
0,86293
0,879936
0,893621
0,904785
0,91401
0,884129
0,860773
0,790241
0,805697
0,706405
0,725577
0,748737
0,768902
0,786465
0,802002
0,721511
0,744687
0,764897
0,782528
0,798146
0,698323
0,717755
0,760724
0,778422
0,794121
0,694035
0,713349
0,736502
0,756374
0,774137
0,789916
0,689571
0,708761
0,827509
0,840748
0,753864
0,770287
0,790723
0,808393
0,823612
0,837323
0,766282
0,786802
0,804572
0,819904
0,83374
0,745448
0,762497
0,800582
0,816127
0,82999
0,741134
0,758143
0,779267
0,796413
0,812072
0,826063
0,736635
0,7536
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
88
40
40
41
41
41
41
41
41
42
42
42
42
42
43
43
43
43
43
44
44
44
44
44
44
45
45
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
3,61991
3,66642
3,70933
3,74913
4,49929
3,52713
3,57799
3,62464
3,66769
3,70763
4,46169
3,48376
3,53474
3,58151
3,62469
3,66477
4,42256
3,439
3,49008
3,53697
3,58027
3,62047
4,38181
3,39279
3,44395
3,49093
1,96605
2,03197
2,09294
2,15122
1,8447
1,86216
1,93087
1,99587
2,05658
2,11435
1,80966
1,82706
1,89504
1,95937
2,02025
2,07674
1,77398
1,79131
1,85853
1,92216
1,98241
2,03836
1,73766
1,75491
1,82133
1,88422
2,11184
2,17953
2,24359
2,30614
1,9831
2,00287
2,07518
2,14508
2,20585
2,26796
1,94645
1,96689
2,03781
2,10709
2,16734
2,22989
1,9091
1,92948
1,99969
2,06909
2,12801
2,18712
1,87103
1,89135
1,9608
2,02648
0,877853
0,891624
0,902878
0,912191
0,882847
0,858503
0,875659
0,889519
0,900865
0,91027
0,881494
0,856113
0,873346
0,887296
0,898737
0,908238
0,880065
0,853593
0,870905
0,884947
0,896486
0,906084
0,878553
0,850931
0,868323
0,882459
0,73192
0,751835
0,769663
0,785522
0,684921
0,704047
0,727142
0,747473
0,764988
0,780926
0,680072
0,69906
0,722155
0,74252
0,760183
0,776114
0,675012
0,693854
0,716945
0,73734
0,755063
0,771072
0,669725
0,688415
0,711496
0,731917
0,77441
0,792054
0,807826
0,821948
0,731941
0,748858
0,769744
0,788193
0,803379
0,817632
0,727039
0,74398
0,764864
0,78342
0,798716
0,813198
0,721915
0,738797
0,759754
0,778504
0,793822
0,808085
0,716553
0,733369
0,754398
0,772832
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
89
45
45
45
45
46
46
46
46
46
46
47
47
47
47
47
47
48
48
48
48
48
48
49
49
49
49
49
49
49
14
15
15
3,53434
3,57466
3,57466
1,9438
1,99919
1,99919
2,08784
2,1464
2,1464
0,894099
0,903798
0,903798
0,749698
0,765783
0,765783
0,788679
0,803068
0,803068
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
90
Cmin2
Cmax
Cmax1
Cmax2
c
c11
c12
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
91
Cmin1
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
92
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
93
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
69.24993
79.90376
53.26918
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
66.3789
77.0665
50.4261
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.63418
79.25409
92.01475
60.1976
60.1976
66.63418
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
66.63418
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.6058
0.52503
0.78754
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.62987
0.54252
0.82923
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.52773
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62776
0.52773
0.45449
0.69488
0.69488
0.62776
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.62776
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
94
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
58.59609
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
55.8178
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
66.63418
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
0.71595
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.74913
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.62776
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52773
95
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52773
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45455
96
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.8178
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.38709
66.63418
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.74913
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69278
0.62783
97
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
72.91907
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.15762
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.68457
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.74913
0.68457
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.68244
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.68244
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.57365
0.52788
0.4886
0.45455
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.4886
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.57185
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.57194
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
98
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
79.90376
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
77.0665
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.48777
85.60221
92.01475
92.01475
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.52503
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.54252
0.69297
0.62587
0.57194
0.52616
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52616
0.48866
0.4546
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52623
0.48866
0.4546
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52631
0.48866
0.4546
0.4546
99
Ureq
W/m2oC
U1
W/m2oC
Ureq1
W/m2oC
U2
W/m2oC
Ureq2
W/m2oC
U3
W/m2oC
Cmin
180.30504
152.9847
154.52293
155.92205
157.20354
158.38436
180.03967
152.62059
154.16297
155.566
156.85119
158.03551
179.74587
152.21888
153.7658
155.1731
156.46233
157.65048
179.4257
151.78254
153.33433
154.74624
156.03982
180.30504
152.9847
154.52293
155.92205
157.20354
158.38436
180.03967
152.62059
154.16297
155.566
156.85119
158.03551
179.74587
152.21888
153.7658
155.1731
156.46233
157.65048
179.4257
151.78254
153.33433
154.74624
156.03982
92.641218
93.321668
96.059652
98.64884
101.05565
103.22756
92.248468
92.92514
95.660823
98.247879
100.65312
102.82449
91.816186
92.489382
95.222449
97.80708
100.21051
102.38122
91.348112
92.018095
94.748226
97.330138
99.731521
92.641218
93.321668
96.059652
98.64884
101.05565
103.22756
92.248468
92.92514
95.660823
98.247879
100.65312
102.82449
91.816186
92.489382
95.222449
97.80708
100.21051
102.38122
91.348112
92.018095
94.748226
97.330138
99.731521
98.4547
99.131569
101.97375
104.52055
106.94929
109.24665
98.054512
98.728746
101.56911
104.11531
106.54337
108.84107
97.61388
98.285898
101.12418
103.66963
106.09688
108.39487
97.136572
97.806738
100.64266
103.1872
105.61347
98.4547
99.131569
101.97375
104.52055
106.94929
109.24665
98.054512
98.728746
101.56911
104.11531
106.54337
108.84107
97.61388
98.285898
101.12418
103.66963
106.09688
108.39487
97.136572
97.806738
100.64266
103.1872
105.61347
98.455789
99.132675
101.97492
104.52178
106.95058
109.248
98.055592
98.729843
101.57028
104.11653
106.54466
108.84242
97.61495
98.286985
101.12534
103.67084
106.09815
108.39621
97.137631
97.807815
100.64381
103.1884
105.61473
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
100
U
W/m2oC
157.2321
179.08056
151.31365
152.87063
154.28742
155.58563
156.78231
178.7114
150.81371
152.37615
153.7981
155.10119
156.3025
178.31887
150.28382
151.85196
153.27931
154.58752
155.79369
177.90341
149.72478
151.29887
152.73184
154.04538
155.25661
177.46528
101.90143
90.846993
91.513995
94.240862
96.819755
99.218847
101.3878
90.314942
90.979165
93.702434
96.277998
98.674541
100.84237
89.753636
90.415262
93.134582
95.706497
98.100221
100.26673
89.164441
89.82363
92.538638
95.106569
97.497191
99.731841
88.548489
101.90143
90.846993
91.513995
94.240862
96.819755
99.218847
101.3878
90.314942
90.979165
93.702434
96.277998
98.674541
100.84237
89.753636
90.415262
93.134582
95.706497
98.100221
100.26673
89.164441
89.82363
92.538638
95.106569
97.497191
99.731841
88.548489
107.9117
96.625346
97.293982
100.12726
102.6707
105.09582
107.39419
96.082314
96.749703
99.580033
102.12219
104.54597
106.84437
95.509143
96.17554
99.002607
101.54326
103.96549
106.3425
94.907184
95.572816
98.396288
100.93519
103.35565
105.73151
94.277547
107.9117
96.625346
97.293982
100.12726
102.6707
105.09582
107.39419
96.082314
96.749703
99.580033
102.12219
104.54597
106.84437
95.509143
96.17554
99.002607
101.54326
103.96549
106.3425
94.907184
95.572816
98.396288
100.93519
103.35565
105.73151
94.277547
107.91302
96.626394
97.295047
100.12839
102.6719
105.09708
107.3955
96.08335
96.750756
99.581151
102.12337
104.54721
106.84566
95.510167
96.17658
99.003712
101.54442
103.96671
106.34379
94.908194
95.573843
98.39738
100.93634
103.35686
105.73278
94.278544
41.952
41.
Lampiran 1. Data hasil pengujian
Tabel 1. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 11%
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas
air panas
udara
Udara
tekanan
udara
masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
o
o
o
o
m/s
( C)
( C)
( C)
( C)
2,6
80,1
76,7
31,6
61,1
18,3
3,1
80,1
76,7
31,6
61,2
27,2
3,6
80,1
76,8
31,6
61,3
35,6
4,1
80,1
76,8
31,6
62,2
47,2
4,6
80,1
76,9
31,6
62,2
58,5
5,1
80,1
76,9
31,6
62,3
64,3
Tabel 2. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 25,6 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
o
o
o
o
m/s
( C)
( C)
( C)
( C)
2,6
80,5
76,5
31,6
62,7
18,3
3,1
80,5
76,6
31,6
63,1
24,2
3,6
80,5
76,6
31,5
63,5
28,0
4,1
80,5
76,6
31,6
63,8
35,7
4,6
80,5
76,5
31,6
64,2
46,3
5,1
80,5
76,6
31,7
64,6
52,3
70
Tabel 3. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 38,88 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
keluar
m/s
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
2,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,8
15,5
3,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,2
21,7
3,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,4
26,0
4,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,8
34,8
4,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
63,2
42,7
5,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
63,6
51,7
Tabel 4. Hasil penelitian untuk baffle cut 48,97 %
Laju Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Temperatur Penurunan
aliran air panas air panas udara
Udara
tekanan
udara masuk
keluar
masuk
Keluar
mm H2O
m/s
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
(oC)
2,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,1
12,7
3,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
61,5
16,0
3,6
80,1
76,4
31,6
61,8
22,7
4,1
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,2
31,3
4,6
80,1
76,6
31,6
62,6
39,3
5,1
80,1
76,6
31,7
63,0
43,3
LAMPIRAN 3 : HASIL PERHITUNGAN HEAT TRANSFER
Hari/Tanggal : Senin / 1 Mei 2013
Jam
: 10:42:46
Vu
m/s
res
res1
res2
ho
W/m2oC
ho1
W/m2oC
ho2
W/m2oC
11
11
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
777.25755
410.12944
423.26396
435.71686
447.57222
458.89858
771.55696
407.10184
420.1394
432.50037
444.26822
455.51096
765.32339
403.79662
416.72833
428.98894
440.66124
451.81271
758.62144
138.26056
139.87331
147.36104
154.59909
161.61324
168.42484
137.24652
138.84075
146.27321
153.45783
160.4202
167.18151
136.13768
137.71352
145.08563
152.21192
159.11776
165.82418
134.94552
153.28165
155.39422
163.71121
171.75064
179.54114
187.51109
152.15744
154.24709
162.50268
170.48276
178.21576
186.12687
150.92813
152.99477
161.18334
169.09863
176.76884
184.61572
149.60645
71
Bc
Bc
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
400.24745
413.06549
425.21834
436.78805
447.8415
751.50078
396.48022
409.17762
421.21608
432.67689
443.6263
744.00148
392.5158
405.08623
417.00432
428.35054
439.19047
736.15695
388.3716
400.80931
412.60157
423.82799
434.55347
727.99584
384.06252
396.36224
136.50308
143.8104
150.87406
157.7192
164.36667
133.67888
135.21828
142.45682
149.45399
156.2347
162.81961
132.34488
133.86623
141.03239
147.95959
154.67251
161.19157
130.94948
132.45286
139.54336
146.39743
153.03947
159.4897
129.49776
130.98327
137.9951
151.65002
159.76662
167.61234
175.21513
182.99304
148.2022
150.22265
158.26285
166.03473
173.56596
181.27067
146.72327
148.72057
156.68038
164.37454
171.83047
179.45813
145.17627
147.15037
155.02614
162.63907
170.01628
177.56341
143.56683
145.5177
153.30608
72
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
408.02366
419.12552
429.732
719.54315
379.6016
391.75845
403.28443
414.25734
424.74062
710.8211
375.0004
387.0099
398.39616
409.23607
419.59228
701.84969
370.26933
382.12731
393.36993
404.07307
414.29863
692.64711
365.41786
377.12047
388.21578
398.77869
144.77312
151.34146
157.72013
127.99417
129.46188
136.39227
143.09156
149.58361
155.88819
126.44267
127.89266
134.73904
141.35713
147.77049
153.99865
124.84681
126.27914
133.03915
139.57374
145.90619
152.05578
123.20983
124.62457
131.296
137.74497
143.99445
160.83455
168.1299
175.5933
141.89989
143.8275
151.52542
158.96644
166.17706
173.55377
140.17983
142.08415
149.68876
157.03959
164.16281
171.4501
138.41059
140.29159
147.80026
155.05835
162.0917
169.28705
136.59577
138.45342
145.8637
153.02669
159.96789
73
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
22
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
15
10
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
137.70363
91.802416
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
100.98266
110.1629
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
19,052.50
22,351.03
14,180.37
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
15,857.28
17,442.17
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,030.40
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,690.50
17,101.53
19,125.77
22,866.14
26,826.29
17,101.53
17,101.53
19,125.77
20,932.95
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
19,125.77
20,932.95
408.87027
683.23006
360.45469
371.99836
382.94297
393.36241
403.31692
673.61399
355.38787
366.76927
377.56003
387.83301
397.64759
663.81329
350.22488
372.07493
391.87066
653.84143
653.84143
344.97273
356.02059
366.49511
376.46703
385.99398
339.63804
350.51504
150.06346
121.5347
122.93189
129.51271
135.8741
142.03869
148.02527
119.82417
121.20387
127.69218
133.96415
140.04209
145.94452
118.0808
119.44305
132.01795
143.82427
116.30698
116.30698
117.65182
123.94999
130.03814
135.93796
141.66741
115.83244
122.03321
167.06896
134.73864
136.57292
143.88256
150.94825
157.79518
164.7998
132.84228
134.65314
141.86003
148.82641
155.57709
162.48325
130.9095
132.41458
146.6643
159.77721
128.94296
128.94296
130.42883
137.70263
144.46485
151.01768
157.38111
128.41186
135.57318
74
22
23
23
23
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
25
26
26
26
26
26
26
26
27
27
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
360.82759
370.6453
380.02493
633.43415
334.227
355.07897
364.74026
373.97046
623.02199
328.74551
339.27369
349.2555
358.75834
367.83716
612.48529
323.19915
333.5497
343.36311
352.70563
361.63127
601.8342
317.59321
327.76422
337.40741
346.58788
355.35871
128.02722
133.8358
139.47665
112.67688
113.98703
125.98752
131.70356
137.25454
110.82474
112.11758
118.11949
123.92126
129.54356
135.0035
108.95044
110.22601
116.12666
121.83055
127.35799
132.72581
107.0558
108.31412
114.11242
119.71738
125.14894
130.42366
142.23083
148.68233
154.94735
124.6539
126.36603
139.96484
146.31356
152.47877
122.60489
124.29357
130.94469
137.66934
143.91394
149.97804
120.53136
122.19657
128.73548
135.34669
141.48593
147.44772
118.43533
120.07705
126.50254
132.99907
139.03183
144.89021
75
27
27
27
28
28
28
28
28
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
30
30
30
30
30
31
31
31
31
31
31
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,866.14
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
591.07838
311.93269
321.92243
331.39375
340.41059
349.0251
580.22695
306.22237
316.02923
325.32717
334.17895
342.63575
569.28858
300.46675
310.08928
319.21246
327.89786
336.19572
558.27145
294.67007
304.10696
313.05413
321.57198
329.70975
547.18322
288.83634
105.14253
106.38362
112.07858
117.58364
122.91839
128.0991
103.21225
104.43614
110.02684
115.43112
120.66822
125.75408
101.2665
102.4732
107.95882
113.26152
118.40019
123.39046
99.306748
100.49626
105.87605
111.07646
116.11598
121.00999
97.334347
98.506689
116.31868
117.9369
124.24787
130.62861
136.55384
142.30781
114.18322
115.77792
121.97336
128.23729
134.05405
139.70268
112.03065
113.60181
119.6808
125.55675
131.53443
137.07689
109.86259
111.41017
117.37189
123.13448
128.99684
134.43237
107.68053
109.20453
76
32
32
32
32
32
32
33
33
33
33
33
33
34
34
34
34
34
34
35
35
35
35
35
35
36
36
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,180.37
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,186.80
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
298.08641
306.85644
315.20566
323.18232
536.03111
282.96929
292.03147
300.62336
308.80298
316.61762
524.82178
277.0724
285.94573
294.35857
302.36773
310.01951
513.56139
271.14885
279.83247
288.06546
295.90339
303.39159
502.2555
265.20154
273.69469
281.7471
103.77997
108.87742
113.81718
118.61429
95.35058
96.505752
101.67192
106.66583
111.50524
116.20492
93.356636
94.494636
99.553147
104.44298
109.18155
113.78328
91.353608
92.474429
97.424793
102.21009
106.84735
111.3507
89.342489
90.446117
95.287901
99.968235
115.04822
120.69672
126.44302
131.77095
105.4859
106.98629
112.71128
118.24505
123.87462
129.09432
103.28001
104.75677
110.36245
115.7809
121.29316
126.40408
101.06406
102.51717
108.003
113.30561
118.70002
123.70168
98.839173
100.26858
105.63409
110.82039
77
36
36
36
36
37
37
37
37
37
37
38
38
38
38
38
38
39
39
39
39
39
39
40
40
40
40
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
15,857.28
17,442.17
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
24,830.43
26,826.29
17,243.58
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
19,125.77
21,038.38
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,107.21
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
289.41312
296.73707
490.90912
259.23304
267.53505
275.40623
282.89972
290.05884
253.24559
261.35586
269.04524
276.36565
283.35942
468.11158
247.24109
262.66613
269.81297
276.64092
456.66702
241.22103
248.9462
256.27048
263.24331
269.905
445.19506
235.18649
104.50378
108.90836
87.31219
88.410579
93.143396
97.718397
102.15187
106.45732
86.368581
90.992085
95.461419
99.792493
103.9985
83.257461
84.306527
93.19801
97.426394
101.53268
81.221953
82.253751
86.655623
90.928736
95.054163
99.060462
79.181571
80.196037
116.09649
120.98844
96.796202
98.01198
103.25674
108.32632
113.23879
118.26553
95.748221
100.87184
105.82433
110.62334
115.53398
92.104641
93.460378
103.31522
108.00044
112.79465
89.852834
91.184715
96.269379
100.7996
105.37074
110.04821
87.595636
88.903579
78
40
40
41
41
41
41
41
41
42
42
42
42
42
43
43
43
43
43
44
44
44
44
44
44
45
45
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
128.52338
137.70363
91.802416
100.98266
110.1629
119.34314
17,586.92
19,052.50
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
20,688.65
22,351.03
14,297.46
15,988.65
17,586.92
19,210.89
21,214.05
22,981.89
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,826.29
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,056.83
24,956.76
26,963.47
17,329.99
19,285.18
21,214.05
23,174.13
242.7184
249.85945
256.65784
263.15288
433.697
229.13809
236.47631
243.43371
250.05726
256.38526
422.17321
223.076
230.22008
236.99341
243.44173
249.60232
410.62311
216.99983
223.94932
230.53816
236.81084
242.80362
399.04501
210.90865
217.66307
224.06696
84.487789
88.654003
92.676226
96.582301
77.136547
78.133601
82.314981
86.356753
90.292832
94.098452
75.086948
76.066494
80.13725
84.072093
87.904039
91.608977
73.032667
73.994586
77.954463
81.782129
85.509699
89.113722
70.973408
71.91756
75.766284
79.486507
93.65945
98.277931
102.73472
107.29518
85.333301
86.617207
91.25077
95.936388
100.09264
104.53582
83.065906
84.325657
88.836633
93.398289
97.444586
101.77021
80.793331
82.028786
86.416892
90.854296
94.79038
98.798931
78.515249
79.72624
83.991172
88.113469
79
45
45
45
45
46
46
46
46
46
46
47
47
47
47
47
47
48
48
48
48
48
48
49
49
49
49
49
49
49
14
15
15
128.52338
137.70363
137.70363
20,688.65
22,351.03
22,351.03
24,956.76
26,963.47
26,963.47
230.16356
235.98813
235.98813
83.109444
86.612303
86.612303
92.129617
96.025648
96.025648
80
LAMPIRAN 3 : HASIL PERHITUNGAN HEAT TRANSFER
Hari/Tanggal : Senin / 6 Mei 2013
Jam
: 10:42:46
Bc% Vu Ntu
Ntu1
Ntu2
m/s
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
5,21034
4,42086
4,46531
4,50574
4,54277
4,57689
5,20267
4,41034
4,45491
4,49545
4,53259
4,56681
5,19418
4,39873
4,44343
4,4841
4,52135
4,55569
5,18493
2,68616
2,70556
2,78527
2,86035
2,93013
2,99347
2,67477
2,69407
2,77371
2,84872
2,91846
2,98178
2,66223
2,68143
2,761
2,83594
2,90563
2,96892
2,64866
2,85335
2,87331
2,95569
3,02987
3,10028
3,16725
2,84176
2,86164
2,94397
3,01813
3,08851
3,1555
2,82899
2,8488
2,93107
3,00521
3,07557
3,14256
2,81515
efektifitas1 efektifitas2 a1 a2 a3 a4
0,905054
0,898355
0,913728
0,925641
0,935031
0,942549
0,904845
0,897973
0,913368
0,925305
0,934716
0,942256
0,904612
0,897549
0,912969
0,924931
0,934367
0,94193
0,904358
0,773181
0,79475
0,816935
0,835699
0,851613
0,865091
0,772251
0,793792
0,815999
0,834791
0,850738
0,864251
0,77122
0,792732
0,814963
0,833786
0,849769
0,863321
0,770096
0,819829
0,83723
0,855624
0,870794
0,883616
0,894582
0,818927
0,836326
0,854758
0,869971
0,882835
0,893844
0,817927
0,835324
0,8538
0,869058
0,881969
0,893025
0,816836
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
81
11
11
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
efektifitas
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
4,38612
4,43096
4,47176
4,50914
4,5436
5,17496
4,37257
4,41756
4,4585
4,49602
4,5306
5,16429
4,35812
4,40327
4,44436
4,48202
4,51673
5,15295
4,34281
4,38812
4,42937
4,46717
4,50203
5,14094
4,32665
4,37214
2,66777
2,74725
2,82211
2,89174
2,95501
2,63413
2,65315
2,73254
2,80731
2,87688
2,94012
2,6187
2,63765
2,71693
2,7916
2,86109
2,9243
2,60243
2,6213
2,70046
2,77503
2,84444
2,90761
2,58535
2,60415
2,68318
2,83491
2,91711
2,99122
3,06156
3,12855
2,80034
2,82005
2,90217
2,97625
3,04655
3,11355
2,7846
2,80428
2,88631
2,96035
3,03061
3,09761
2,76799
2,78763
2,86958
2,94357
3,01378
3,08269
2,75054
2,77016
2,852
0,897086
0,912533
0,924523
0,933986
0,941574
0,904083
0,896585
0,912061
0,924081
0,933574
0,941189
0,903788
0,896049
0,911555
0,923607
0,93313
0,940775
0,903473
0,895476
0,911015
0,9231
0,932657
0,940333
0,903137
0,894868
0,910441
0,791578
0,813833
0,83269
0,848712
0,862305
0,768884
0,790333
0,812615
0,831508
0,847571
0,861209
0,767586
0,789001
0,811311
0,830242
0,846349
0,860033
0,766205
0,787584
0,809923
0,828893
0,845046
0,858781
0,764741
0,786083
0,808452
0,834231
0,852754
0,868062
0,881023
0,89213
0,815657
0,833052
0,851625
0,866987
0,880002
0,891163
0,814395
0,83179
0,850415
0,865834
0,878906
0,890125
0,81305
0,830445
0,849126
0,864605
0,877736
0,889134
0,811624
0,829019
0,847759
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
82
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
4,41355
4,45151
4,48651
5,12828
4,30967
4,35534
4,39692
4,43503
4,47019
5,11497
4,29188
4,33773
4,37948
4,41776
4,45307
5,10101
4,27328
4,31932
4,36125
4,3997
4,43517
5,08639
4,25389
4,30012
4,34223
4,38086
2,75764
2,82696
2,89175
2,56749
2,58622
2,66512
2,73945
2,80867
2,87339
2,54888
2,56755
2,6463
2,7205
2,78961
2,85424
2,52955
2,54817
2,62675
2,7008
2,76979
2,83433
2,50951
2,52807
2,60648
2,68037
2,74924
2,92594
2,99611
3,06498
2,73229
2,7519
2,83362
2,9075
2,97761
3,04644
2,71327
2,73286
2,81446
2,88827
2,95831
3,0271
2,6935
2,71308
2,79454
2,86827
2,93824
3,00697
2,67299
2,69398
2,77388
2,84753
2,91741
0,922562
0,932154
0,939862
0,902783
0,894224
0,909833
0,921992
0,93162
0,939362
0,902408
0,893544
0,90919
0,921389
0,931055
0,938834
0,902012
0,892828
0,908513
0,920753
0,930459
0,938276
0,901596
0,892075
0,907801
0,920083
0,929832
0,827464
0,843665
0,857565
0,763196
0,784498
0,806899
0,825953
0,842204
0,856158
0,761569
0,782831
0,805263
0,824361
0,840665
0,854675
0,759861
0,781079
0,803544
0,822688
0,839045
0,853114
0,75807
0,779244
0,801742
0,820933
0,837345
0,8633
0,876495
0,887957
0,810118
0,827513
0,846313
0,86192
0,875181
0,886711
0,808531
0,825926
0,844789
0,860463
0,873793
0,885394
0,806862
0,824257
0,843185
0,85893
0,872332
0,884007
0,805112
0,822611
0,841502
0,85732
0,870796
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
83
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
22
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
15
10
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
4,41649
5,07111
4,23369
4,28012
4,32242
4,36122
4,39703
5,05517
4,2127
4,25932
4,30181
4,3408
4,37679
5,03856
4,1909
4,28042
4,35575
5,02126
5,02126
4,1683
4,21534
4,25822
4,29758
4,33392
4,14489
4,19214
2,81368
2,48879
2,5073
2,58552
2,65924
2,72797
2,7923
2,46739
2,48586
2,56388
2,63741
2,70599
2,7702
2,44534
2,46376
2,6149
2,7474
2,42377
2,42377
2,44102
2,51859
2,59172
2,65997
2,7239
2,41765
2,49498
2,98608
2,65176
2,67273
2,7525
2,82762
2,89584
2,96444
2,62984
2,65078
2,7304
2,80539
2,87353
2,94205
2,60723
2,62486
2,78245
2,91553
2,58394
2,58394
2,60156
2,68412
2,75881
2,82677
2,8917
2,5776
2,65996
0,937688
0,901159
0,891284
0,907052
0,919379
0,929171
0,937069
0,900701
0,890454
0,906266
0,918639
0,928477
0,936418
0,90022
0,889585
0,917863
0,935735
0,899716
0,899716
0,888674
0,904578
0,917049
0,926984
0,935017
0,887721
0,903673
0,851474
0,756197
0,777323
0,799855
0,819094
0,835563
0,849753
0,75424
0,775317
0,797883
0,81717
0,833697
0,847952
0,752196
0,773222
0,815159
0,846066
0,750148
0,750148
0,771037
0,793672
0,813059
0,829708
0,844095
0,768761
0,791431
0,882547
0,803278
0,820776
0,839736
0,855741
0,869183
0,881013
0,80136
0,818856
0,837888
0,853971
0,867492
0,879405
0,799357
0,816534
0,852117
0,877453
0,797265
0,797265
0,814436
0,833935
0,850178
0,863867
0,875684
0,812247
0,831826
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
84
22
23
23
23
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
25
26
26
26
26
26
26
26
27
27
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
4,23522
4,27477
4,3113
4,98456
4,12066
4,2114
4,25115
4,28786
4,96513
4,0956
4,14327
4,18676
4,2267
4,2636
4,94495
4,06971
4,11759
4,16129
4,20142
4,23851
4,92401
4,04297
4,09106
4,13496
4,1753
4,21257
2,56788
2,63594
2,69972
2,37644
2,39366
2,54338
2,61124
2,67486
2,35185
2,36905
2,44583
2,51824
2,58589
2,64932
2,32666
2,34384
2,42033
2,49246
2,55988
2,62312
2,30086
2,31803
2,3953
2,46605
2,53322
2,59626
2,73447
2,80232
2,86715
2,53213
2,55298
2,70945
2,77718
2,84189
2,50687
2,52771
2,60633
2,68375
2,75135
2,81593
2,48098
2,5018
2,58018
2,65737
2,72483
2,78927
2,45559
2,47526
2,55338
2,63032
2,69905
2,76191
0,916196
0,926182
0,934264
0,898636
0,886724
0,915303
0,925342
0,933474
0,898058
0,885682
0,901736
0,914367
0,924461
0,932645
0,897453
0,884592
0,900699
0,913388
0,923538
0,931777
0,896821
0,883454
0,899615
0,912363
0,922572
0,930867
0,810869
0,82758
0,842036
0,745616
0,766391
0,808585
0,825359
0,839886
0,743211
0,763925
0,786663
0,806206
0,823044
0,837642
0,740709
0,76136
0,784132
0,803727
0,820631
0,835302
0,738109
0,758693
0,781591
0,801146
0,818116
0,832862
0,848153
0,861928
0,873831
0,792483
0,809964
0,846037
0,859902
0,871894
0,790111
0,807585
0,82701
0,843829
0,857785
0,869869
0,787641
0,805108
0,824613
0,841524
0,855575
0,867752
0,785163
0,802528
0,822114
0,839121
0,853377
0,865541
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
85
27
27
27
28
28
28
28
28
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
30
30
30
30
30
31
31
31
31
31
31
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
4,90229
4,01536
4,06367
4,10777
4,14831
4,18578
4,87976
3,98688
4,0354
4,07971
4,12044
4,1581
4,85641
3,95751
4,00624
4,05075
4,09168
4,12953
4,8322
3,92722
3,97616
4,02088
4,06201
4,10005
4,80711
3,89601
2,27448
2,29163
2,36853
2,43901
2,50592
2,56874
2,2475
2,26465
2,34117
2,41134
2,47798
2,54056
2,21995
2,23708
2,3132
2,38306
2,4494
2,51173
2,19182
2,20894
2,28463
2,35416
2,42019
2,48225
2,16313
2,18023
2,4284
2,44808
2,52715
2,60261
2,67113
2,73385
2,40058
2,42028
2,49902
2,57423
2,64253
2,7051
2,37214
2,39186
2,47025
2,54191
2,61325
2,67566
2,34308
2,36282
2,44084
2,51222
2,58329
2,64552
2,31341
2,33316
0,89616
0,882264
0,898482
0,91129
0,92156
0,929912
0,895469
0,881021
0,897296
0,910167
0,920499
0,928912
0,894746
0,879722
0,896056
0,908991
0,919388
0,927864
0,89399
0,878364
0,894759
0,90776
0,918224
0,926764
0,893199
0,876945
0,735407
0,755921
0,77885
0,79846
0,815497
0,830318
0,732599
0,75304
0,776001
0,795664
0,812769
0,827667
0,729683
0,750048
0,773038
0,792756
0,809928
0,824903
0,726653
0,746939
0,769959
0,789729
0,80697
0,822024
0,723508
0,743709
0,782487
0,799843
0,819613
0,836615
0,850968
0,863231
0,779704
0,797048
0,816901
0,834001
0,848454
0,860819
0,776809
0,79414
0,814076
0,830948
0,84583
0,858299
0,773799
0,791115
0,811134
0,828103
0,843093
0,855668
0,770668
0,787967
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
86
32
32
32
32
32
32
33
33
33
33
33
33
34
34
34
34
34
34
35
35
35
35
35
35
36
36
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
3,94516
3,99007
4,0314
4,06963
4,7811
3,86385
3,9132
3,95831
3,99983
4,03825
4,75415
3,83072
3,88027
3,92558
3,96728
4,00589
4,72621
3,7966
3,84633
3,89183
3,93373
3,97252
4,69725
3,76145
3,81137
3,85705
2,25547
2,32464
2,39034
2,45212
2,13386
2,15095
2,22572
2,29452
2,35986
2,42133
2,10403
2,1211
2,19538
2,26378
2,32875
2,3899
2,07363
2,09069
2,16445
2,23242
2,29701
2,35781
2,04267
2,05972
2,13293
2,20046
2,4108
2,48188
2,55266
2,61602
2,28313
2,30289
2,38011
2,45088
2,52134
2,58445
2,25223
2,27296
2,34879
2,42032
2,48935
2,55219
2,22071
2,24143
2,31682
2,38796
2,45667
2,51922
2,18859
2,20928
2,28421
2,35493
0,893402
0,906471
0,917004
0,92561
0,892371
0,875461
0,891982
0,905121
0,915725
0,9244
0,891505
0,87391
0,890495
0,903706
0,914383
0,92313
0,890597
0,872286
0,888938
0,902223
0,912975
0,921795
0,889646
0,870586
0,887306
0,900667
0,766757
0,786581
0,80389
0,819024
0,72024
0,740355
0,763429
0,783305
0,800683
0,815897
0,716847
0,73687
0,759969
0,779897
0,797344
0,812637
0,713322
0,73325
0,756371
0,77635
0,793865
0,80924
0,70966
0,729488
0,752629
0,772658
0,80807
0,825138
0,840237
0,853028
0,767412
0,784691
0,804879
0,822046
0,837257
0,850157
0,764026
0,781373
0,801555
0,818923
0,834146
0,847158
0,760504
0,777826
0,798092
0,81556
0,830899
0,844024
0,756839
0,774132
0,794484
0,812053
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
87
36
36
36
36
37
37
37
37
37
37
38
38
38
38
38
38
39
39
39
39
39
39
40
40
40
40
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
3,89913
3,9381
4,66723
3,72524
3,77535
3,82121
3,86347
3,90262
3,68795
3,73823
3,78427
3,8267
3,86602
4,60379
3,64954
3,74618
3,78878
3,82827
4,57026
3,60996
3,66055
3,70692
3,74967
3,78932
4,53546
3,56918
2,26462
2,32506
2,01096
2,02817
2,10081
2,16874
2,2316
2,29165
1,99606
2,0681
2,13551
2,19793
2,25757
1,9462
1,96314
2,10164
2,1636
2,22282
1,91296
1,92987
2,0006
2,06713
2,12861
2,18737
1,87913
1,89601
2,4233
2,48554
2,15865
2,17652
2,25096
2,32123
2,386
2,45114
2,14312
2,21705
2,28685
2,35125
2,41601
2,08903
2,10883
2,25178
2,31679
2,38014
2,05437
2,07417
2,15086
2,21602
2,28056
2,34353
2,01907
2,03885
0,911497
0,920393
0,888648
0,868806
0,885595
0,899035
0,909945
0,918919
0,866941
0,883801
0,89732
0,908312
0,917367
0,886501
0,864984
0,895517
0,906594
0,915733
0,885345
0,86293
0,879936
0,893621
0,904785
0,91401
0,884129
0,860773
0,790241
0,805697
0,706405
0,725577
0,748737
0,768902
0,786465
0,802002
0,721511
0,744687
0,764897
0,782528
0,798146
0,698323
0,717755
0,760724
0,778422
0,794121
0,694035
0,713349
0,736502
0,756374
0,774137
0,789916
0,689571
0,708761
0,827509
0,840748
0,753864
0,770287
0,790723
0,808393
0,823612
0,837323
0,766282
0,786802
0,804572
0,819904
0,83374
0,745448
0,762497
0,800582
0,816127
0,82999
0,741134
0,758143
0,779267
0,796413
0,812072
0,826063
0,736635
0,7536
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
88
40
40
41
41
41
41
41
41
42
42
42
42
42
43
43
43
43
43
44
44
44
44
44
44
45
45
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
14
15
10
11
12
13
3,61991
3,66642
3,70933
3,74913
4,49929
3,52713
3,57799
3,62464
3,66769
3,70763
4,46169
3,48376
3,53474
3,58151
3,62469
3,66477
4,42256
3,439
3,49008
3,53697
3,58027
3,62047
4,38181
3,39279
3,44395
3,49093
1,96605
2,03197
2,09294
2,15122
1,8447
1,86216
1,93087
1,99587
2,05658
2,11435
1,80966
1,82706
1,89504
1,95937
2,02025
2,07674
1,77398
1,79131
1,85853
1,92216
1,98241
2,03836
1,73766
1,75491
1,82133
1,88422
2,11184
2,17953
2,24359
2,30614
1,9831
2,00287
2,07518
2,14508
2,20585
2,26796
1,94645
1,96689
2,03781
2,10709
2,16734
2,22989
1,9091
1,92948
1,99969
2,06909
2,12801
2,18712
1,87103
1,89135
1,9608
2,02648
0,877853
0,891624
0,902878
0,912191
0,882847
0,858503
0,875659
0,889519
0,900865
0,91027
0,881494
0,856113
0,873346
0,887296
0,898737
0,908238
0,880065
0,853593
0,870905
0,884947
0,896486
0,906084
0,878553
0,850931
0,868323
0,882459
0,73192
0,751835
0,769663
0,785522
0,684921
0,704047
0,727142
0,747473
0,764988
0,780926
0,680072
0,69906
0,722155
0,74252
0,760183
0,776114
0,675012
0,693854
0,716945
0,73734
0,755063
0,771072
0,669725
0,688415
0,711496
0,731917
0,77441
0,792054
0,807826
0,821948
0,731941
0,748858
0,769744
0,788193
0,803379
0,817632
0,727039
0,74398
0,764864
0,78342
0,798716
0,813198
0,721915
0,738797
0,759754
0,778504
0,793822
0,808085
0,716553
0,733369
0,754398
0,772832
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
89
45
45
45
45
46
46
46
46
46
46
47
47
47
47
47
47
48
48
48
48
48
48
49
49
49
49
49
49
49
14
15
15
3,53434
3,57466
3,57466
1,9438
1,99919
1,99919
2,08784
2,1464
2,1464
0,894099
0,903798
0,903798
0,749698
0,765783
0,765783
0,788679
0,803068
0,803068
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
90
Cmin2
Cmax
Cmax1
Cmax2
c
c11
c12
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
91
Cmin1
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54245
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45437
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
92
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62758
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
0.52767
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
93
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
69.24993
79.90376
53.26918
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
66.3789
77.0665
50.4261
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.64455
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.02908
60.1976
66.63418
79.25409
92.01475
60.1976
60.1976
66.63418
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
66.63418
72.93042
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.6058
0.52503
0.78754
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82914
0.74913
0.62987
0.54252
0.82923
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.52773
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62766
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45442
0.69488
0.62776
0.52773
0.45449
0.69488
0.69488
0.62776
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.62776
0.57349
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
94
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
58.59609
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
55.8178
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
66.63418
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
0.71595
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.74913
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68448
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.62776
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69499
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48846
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57358
0.52773
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52773
95
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.82
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.25409
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52773
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45449
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45455
96
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.4261
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.8178
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.18824
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.61554
92.01475
60.38709
66.63418
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82923
0.74913
0.68457
0.62987
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.74913
0.69507
0.62776
0.57365
0.52782
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69507
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.48852
0.45455
0.69278
0.62783
97
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
55.8178
61.0825
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.3789
71.7069
77.0665
72.91907
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
66.63418
72.91907
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.15762
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.24175
85.60221
92.01475
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.68457
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.74913
0.68457
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.68244
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.7468
0.68244
0.62994
0.58307
0.54252
0.57365
0.52788
0.4886
0.45455
0.62783
0.57365
0.52788
0.4886
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.57185
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62587
0.57194
0.52788
0.48866
0.45455
98
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.82
41.81
41.81
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.84
41.83
41.83
41.83
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
53.26918
58.59609
63.92301
69.24993
74.57685
79.90376
79.90376
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
50.5848
55.9923
61.2728
66.585
71.7069
77.0665
77.0665
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.50014
85.60221
92.01475
60.3777
66.84248
73.14623
79.48777
85.60221
92.01475
92.01475
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.78754
0.71595
0.65628
0.6058
0.56253
0.52503
0.52503
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58307
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.82663
0.74689
0.68244
0.62799
0.58314
0.54252
0.54252
0.69297
0.62587
0.57194
0.52616
0.48866
0.45455
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52616
0.48866
0.4546
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52623
0.48866
0.4546
0.69297
0.62595
0.57194
0.52631
0.48866
0.4546
0.4546
99
Ureq
W/m2oC
U1
W/m2oC
Ureq1
W/m2oC
U2
W/m2oC
Ureq2
W/m2oC
U3
W/m2oC
Cmin
180.30504
152.9847
154.52293
155.92205
157.20354
158.38436
180.03967
152.62059
154.16297
155.566
156.85119
158.03551
179.74587
152.21888
153.7658
155.1731
156.46233
157.65048
179.4257
151.78254
153.33433
154.74624
156.03982
180.30504
152.9847
154.52293
155.92205
157.20354
158.38436
180.03967
152.62059
154.16297
155.566
156.85119
158.03551
179.74587
152.21888
153.7658
155.1731
156.46233
157.65048
179.4257
151.78254
153.33433
154.74624
156.03982
92.641218
93.321668
96.059652
98.64884
101.05565
103.22756
92.248468
92.92514
95.660823
98.247879
100.65312
102.82449
91.816186
92.489382
95.222449
97.80708
100.21051
102.38122
91.348112
92.018095
94.748226
97.330138
99.731521
92.641218
93.321668
96.059652
98.64884
101.05565
103.22756
92.248468
92.92514
95.660823
98.247879
100.65312
102.82449
91.816186
92.489382
95.222449
97.80708
100.21051
102.38122
91.348112
92.018095
94.748226
97.330138
99.731521
98.4547
99.131569
101.97375
104.52055
106.94929
109.24665
98.054512
98.728746
101.56911
104.11531
106.54337
108.84107
97.61388
98.285898
101.12418
103.66963
106.09688
108.39487
97.136572
97.806738
100.64266
103.1872
105.61347
98.4547
99.131569
101.97375
104.52055
106.94929
109.24665
98.054512
98.728746
101.56911
104.11531
106.54337
108.84107
97.61388
98.285898
101.12418
103.66963
106.09688
108.39487
97.136572
97.806738
100.64266
103.1872
105.61347
98.455789
99.132675
101.97492
104.52178
106.95058
109.248
98.055592
98.729843
101.57028
104.11653
106.54466
108.84242
97.61495
98.286985
101.12534
103.67084
106.09815
108.39621
97.137631
97.807815
100.64381
103.1884
105.61473
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
41.952
100
U
W/m2oC
157.2321
179.08056
151.31365
152.87063
154.28742
155.58563
156.78231
178.7114
150.81371
152.37615
153.7981
155.10119
156.3025
178.31887
150.28382
151.85196
153.27931
154.58752
155.79369
177.90341
149.72478
151.29887
152.73184
154.04538
155.25661
177.46528
101.90143
90.846993
91.513995
94.240862
96.819755
99.218847
101.3878
90.314942
90.979165
93.702434
96.277998
98.674541
100.84237
89.753636
90.415262
93.134582
95.706497
98.100221
100.26673
89.164441
89.82363
92.538638
95.106569
97.497191
99.731841
88.548489
101.90143
90.846993
91.513995
94.240862
96.819755
99.218847
101.3878
90.314942
90.979165
93.702434
96.277998
98.674541
100.84237
89.753636
90.415262
93.134582
95.706497
98.100221
100.26673
89.164441
89.82363
92.538638
95.106569
97.497191
99.731841
88.548489
107.9117
96.625346
97.293982
100.12726
102.6707
105.09582
107.39419
96.082314
96.749703
99.580033
102.12219
104.54597
106.84437
95.509143
96.17554
99.002607
101.54326
103.96549
106.3425
94.907184
95.572816
98.396288
100.93519
103.35565
105.73151
94.277547
107.9117
96.625346
97.293982
100.12726
102.6707
105.09582
107.39419
96.082314
96.749703
99.580033
102.12219
104.54597
106.84437
95.509143
96.17554
99.002607
101.54326
103.96549
106.3425
94.907184
95.572816
98.396288
100.93519
103.35565
105.73151
94.277547
107.91302
96.626394
97.295047
100.12839
102.6719
105.09708
107.3955
96.08335
96.750756
99.581151
102.12337
104.54721
106.84566
95.510167
96.17658
99.003712
101.54442
103.96671
106.34379
94.908194
95.573843
98.39738
100.93634
103.35686
105.73278
94.278544
41.952
41.