2017 Sarwono MADRID SPAIN
The Development of The Alternative Dispute
Resolution in Indonesia
Prof .Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
Dr, Ir, MSC (Civ), MSBA (Bus), MH (Law), ACIArb (Arb), ACPE, IPU (PE).
FIDIC, International Accredited Trainer
FIDIC, Adjudicator
DRBF, Country Representative for Indonesia
BADAPSKI, Secretary General
University of Mercu Buana, Lecturer
sarwonohm2@yahoo.co.id & sarwonohm2@gmail.com
www.sarwonohm.com
Dispute Resolution Board Foundation. Moving projects forward since 1996.
Copyright © Dispute Resolution Board Foundation 2017
Copyright © Dispute Resolution Board Foundation 2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Dispute Resolution
(Through Litigation in Indonesia)
District Court
High Court
Supreme Court
Litigation
Decision
1st Judicial
Review
Arbitration
Dispute
2nd Judicial
Review
Mediation
Concilliation
nth Judicial
Review
Expert
Judgement
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on Indonesian Law No 18 Year 1999)
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
Recommendation
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on FIDIC General Conditions of Contract)
Dispute
Engineer
Determination
Dispute
Board
Litigation
Decision
Decision
Arbitration
Arbitration
Dispute
Dispute
Board
Mediation
Recommendation
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on Indonesian Law No 2 Year 2017)
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
Concilliation
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
FIDIC Conditions of Contract
Clause 3.5 Engineer Determination
Event
< 28 days
Notice of claim
Claim document
with suporting data
< 42 days, or as agreed
by parties
Clause 3.5
[Determination]
< 42 days, or as agreed by
parties
If the Contractor fails
to give notice of a
claim within such
period of 28 days, the
Time for Completion
shall not be extended,
the Contractor shall
not be entitled to
additional payment,
and the Employer
shall be discharged
from all liability in
connection with the
claim.
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
THE PRESIDENT AND COUNTRY REPRESENTATIVES OF DRBF
(Dewan Penyelesaian Sengketa Internasional)
Barcelona, Spain, September 2013
Founders of The Centre of Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution
for Construction of Indonesia
August 19, 2014, at The Office of The Minister of Public Works of Indonesia
Seating: Pof. Dr.Satya Arinanto, SH, MH; Ir. Agus Rahardjo,MSM; Prof.Dr.Ir. Wiratman Wangsadinata;
Dr.Ir. Djoko Kirmanto, Dip.HE; Abdul Rahman Saleh, SH, MH; Prof. Hilmahanto Juwana, SH, LLM, PhD;
Prof.Ir.Roesdiman Soegiarso, MSc, PhD; Irjen Pol (Purn) Prof.Dr.dr.Hadiman, Sp.KO, SH, MBA, MSc.
Standing: Dr.Ir.Sarwono Hardjomuljadi, MSc, MSBA, MH; Ir.Erie Heryadi, Dr.Amad Sudiro, SH, MH, MM;
Bintang Perbowo, SE, MM; Dr.Ir.Sudarto, MT; Ir.Hedianto Husaini, MSCE, MSi; Firman Wijaya, SH, MH
© Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
International Conference & Workshops
23 - 4 August
• Bali, Indonesia
Garuda Wisnu
Kencana
Tanah Lot Temple
Traditional Legong Dance
Traditional Kecak Dance
Uluwatu Temple
Kuta Beach
Sanur Beach
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
International Conference & Workshops
23 - 4 August
• Bali, Indonesia
Komodo Dragon Island
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
THANK YOU
Prof Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
Dr, Ir, MSC (Civ), MSBA (Bus), MH (Law), ACIArb (Arb), ACPE, IPU (PE).
FIDIC International Accredited Trainer
FIDIC Adjudicator
DRBF Country Representative for Indonesia
BADAPSKI Secretary General
University of Mercu Buana Lecturer
sarwonohm2@yahoo.co.id & sarwonohm2@gmail.com
www.sarwonohm.com
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
Resolution in Indonesia
Prof .Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
Dr, Ir, MSC (Civ), MSBA (Bus), MH (Law), ACIArb (Arb), ACPE, IPU (PE).
FIDIC, International Accredited Trainer
FIDIC, Adjudicator
DRBF, Country Representative for Indonesia
BADAPSKI, Secretary General
University of Mercu Buana, Lecturer
sarwonohm2@yahoo.co.id & sarwonohm2@gmail.com
www.sarwonohm.com
Dispute Resolution Board Foundation. Moving projects forward since 1996.
Copyright © Dispute Resolution Board Foundation 2017
Copyright © Dispute Resolution Board Foundation 2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Dispute Resolution
(Through Litigation in Indonesia)
District Court
High Court
Supreme Court
Litigation
Decision
1st Judicial
Review
Arbitration
Dispute
2nd Judicial
Review
Mediation
Concilliation
nth Judicial
Review
Expert
Judgement
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on Indonesian Law No 18 Year 1999)
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
Recommendation
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on FIDIC General Conditions of Contract)
Dispute
Engineer
Determination
Dispute
Board
Litigation
Decision
Decision
Arbitration
Arbitration
Dispute
Dispute
Board
Mediation
Recommendation
Dispute Resolution for Construction Services
(Based on Indonesian Law No 2 Year 2017)
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
Concilliation
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
FIDIC Conditions of Contract
Clause 3.5 Engineer Determination
Event
< 28 days
Notice of claim
Claim document
with suporting data
< 42 days, or as agreed
by parties
Clause 3.5
[Determination]
< 42 days, or as agreed by
parties
If the Contractor fails
to give notice of a
claim within such
period of 28 days, the
Time for Completion
shall not be extended,
the Contractor shall
not be entitled to
additional payment,
and the Employer
shall be discharged
from all liability in
connection with the
claim.
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
THE PRESIDENT AND COUNTRY REPRESENTATIVES OF DRBF
(Dewan Penyelesaian Sengketa Internasional)
Barcelona, Spain, September 2013
Founders of The Centre of Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution
for Construction of Indonesia
August 19, 2014, at The Office of The Minister of Public Works of Indonesia
Seating: Pof. Dr.Satya Arinanto, SH, MH; Ir. Agus Rahardjo,MSM; Prof.Dr.Ir. Wiratman Wangsadinata;
Dr.Ir. Djoko Kirmanto, Dip.HE; Abdul Rahman Saleh, SH, MH; Prof. Hilmahanto Juwana, SH, LLM, PhD;
Prof.Ir.Roesdiman Soegiarso, MSc, PhD; Irjen Pol (Purn) Prof.Dr.dr.Hadiman, Sp.KO, SH, MBA, MSc.
Standing: Dr.Ir.Sarwono Hardjomuljadi, MSc, MSBA, MH; Ir.Erie Heryadi, Dr.Amad Sudiro, SH, MH, MM;
Bintang Perbowo, SE, MM; Dr.Ir.Sudarto, MT; Ir.Hedianto Husaini, MSCE, MSi; Firman Wijaya, SH, MH
© Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
International Conference & Workshops
23 - 4 August
• Bali, Indonesia
Garuda Wisnu
Kencana
Tanah Lot Temple
Traditional Legong Dance
Traditional Kecak Dance
Uluwatu Temple
Kuta Beach
Sanur Beach
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
International Conference & Workshops
23 - 4 August
• Bali, Indonesia
Komodo Dragon Island
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017
DRBF International Conference & Workshops
24 - May
• Madrid, Spain
THANK YOU
Prof Sarwono Hardjomuljadi
Dr, Ir, MSC (Civ), MSBA (Bus), MH (Law), ACIArb (Arb), ACPE, IPU (PE).
FIDIC International Accredited Trainer
FIDIC Adjudicator
DRBF Country Representative for Indonesia
BADAPSKI Secretary General
University of Mercu Buana Lecturer
sarwonohm2@yahoo.co.id & sarwonohm2@gmail.com
www.sarwonohm.com
Copyright
Copyright ©
© Dispute
Dispute Resolution
Resolution Board
Board Foundation
Foundation 2017
2017