152
5.3.4 Discussion and Conclusions
Our calibration experiment explored the EMG value of the SCM muscle related to
both neck support conditions, changes in head rotation angles and duration. The
first result shows that when the neck is under the support condition, both SCM
muscles showed a lower EMG value than under the without support condition. It
is shown that when the neck is supported, the SCM muscle stress is lower than
without support. Next, the mean rating of EMG values for a sitting person was
increasing over time for both SCM muscles. The result showed that the EMG
values for a sitting person in both neck support condition and without support
condition were increasing over time. In the third finding, the mean rating of EMG
value is increasing with the increase of head rotation angle. The finding is in line
with the studies by Ylinen et al. 2003, Bexander et al. 2005, Moon et al. 2003
and Lin and Huang 2008. Lastly, there is a significant difference between right
SCM muscle and left SCM muscle related to EMG value.
In this section, we describe the calibration experiment to determine the
difference of SCM muscle stress related to neck support conditions, time and
head rotation angles. To do this, we developed the head rotation angle
measurement apparatus with the support of the headset with laser beam and
MP150 Biopac Systems to measure the SCM muscle stress of four participants.
Based on the calibration experiment results, we concluded that the SCM muscle
stress showed a significant difference related to neck support conditions, time
and neck rotation angles. The right SCM muscle and left SCM muscle should be
evaluated differently based on both SCM muscle showing significant differences.
The main information gained from the calibration experiment is:
1 A
sitting person in support condition demonstrated significantly lower mean
ratings of SCM EMG value than under without support condition. 2
A sitting person in support and under without support condition presented
significantly higher mean ratings of SCM EMG value over the increase of
time.
153 3
A sitting person under support and under without support condition
showed higher mean ratings of SCM EMG value over the increase of head
rotation angles for both rotation directions.
The results from the calibration experiment act as important input to calibrate
our neck support design and validate our developed smart neck support system.
5.4
VALIDATION EXPERIMENT
In this subsection, a validation experiment is reported. The validation experiment
is to validate the developed smart neck support system SnS
2
in a simulated ‘real
life’ setting. The design knowledge about SnS
2
was acquired from literature review
findings as well as our survey results. Next, a functional prototype of SnS
2
was developed. The aim of SnS
2
is to support the passenger’s head and reduce passenger
neck muscle stress during air travel adaptively and autonomously. An aircraft
cabin simulator was utilised to conduct the validation experiment. The calibration
experiment was conducted to gain information to be used for the validation
experiment. The validation is an important process of SnS
2
. A similar
validation process is also described by Rauterberg 2006 and
Abrazhevich et al. 2009.
5.4.1 Research Question