Analisis dampak otonomi daerah terhadap kondisi ketimpangan pendapatan antar Kabupaten/Kota di Pulau Sumatera

! "#!

$

!
!

!
!
!
"

!
#

!

!
#
$%


!

!

&'
())*

+,,(

+,,- &

$%

#

$%
#

!


#

.
!

.

#

/

!

"
0

.
/

0


#

/

1
!

!

.

#

$%

.

$%
.

!

$%

#

#

#

!

!
!
#

0
.

#

!

!
#

#
"

%& '

&( ) " $ %

$ * $+ # * ,* - & .&#/%& )&% #
. ! &. #*& &, %
-/,/ "

#0 ,

-/,/ "


"
2

&

2

$

"

3

4

3 /(-(,+,*3

6

5


37 , %"$"$

. -

/,!"$"

*/,/ "

&*" . ,) ,

( . *&,

/*

"

&#
&,! . * ,


%

*&# 1

!
5

4

5

&

%

&

&

!


4
(8+ (*9 :*9

2

&
5

$
2

3

#
&
(8( 9-; 9:+

&#


&

!

5

! .
,* #

2

52< 2 2

=

%52 $1%52 $ /


8)
1


?

#

#
1

"

1
.

.

0

1

%

+,,;

/

#
#
#
(
(( ?

%

(+

(
&

(8

-

!

:

(- & .
(* $

:
?

:
9

+(

5

>

9

++

(+

+8

!

+-

(:
#

()

+* /

+,
+*

4
8(

+*
8((

#

>

8(+

&

8(8

5

8(-

8,
8+

8.

8:

8- /
8* >

"

88

8+
88

+*

89
?

89

8; 6

8)

8: &

8)

8:(

#

-,

! "#!

$

!
!

!
!
!
"

!
#

!

!
#
$%

!

!

&'
())*

+,,(

+,,- &

$%

#

$%
#

!

#

.
!

.

#

/

!

"
0

.
/

0

#

/

1
!

!

.

#

$%

.

$%
.
!

$%

#

#

#

!

!
!
#

0
.

#
!

!
#

#
"

%& '

&( ) " $ %

$ * $+ # * ,* - & .&#/%& )&% #
. ! &. #*& &, %
-/,/ "

#0 ,

-/,/ "

"
2

&

2

$

"

3

4

3 /(-(,+,*3

6

5

37 , %"$"$

. -

/,!"$"

*/,/ "

&*" . ,) ,

( . *&,

/*

"

&#
&,! . * ,

%

*&# 1

!
5

4

5

&

%

&

&

!

4
(8+ (*9 :*9

2

&
5

$
2

3

#
&
(8( 9-; 9:+

&#

&

!

5

! .
,* #

2

52< 2 2

=

%52 $1%52 $ /


8)
1

?

#

#
1

"

1
.

.

0

1

%

+,,;

/

#
#
#
(
(( ?

%

(+

(
&

(8

-

!

:

(- & .
(* $

:
?

:
9

+(

5

>

9

++

(+

+8

!

+-

(:
#

()

+* /

+,
+*

4
8(

+*
8((

#

>

8(+

&

8(8

5

8(-

8,
8+

8.

8:

8- /
8* >

"

88

8+
88

+*

89
?

89

8; 6

8)

8: &

8)

8:(

#

-,

8:+
8:8

'!

.

#

!

'!
&

-(
'! 4

-+
-8

-(

#

-8

-((

#

-(+

#

-8
%

-:
*+

*(

*+

*+

*+
**:

/
<

(

<

+

!

&

"

8(
8;

/
(

2
4

+

>
4

2

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;
>

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBB +(

8

&
>

BBBBBBBBBBB

-

++

6 " %

*

()::1()9(

++

>
?

())*1+,,(BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB +-

;

#

())*

-8

:

#

+,,(

--

9

#

+,,-

-;

)

#

%

())*

-:

(,

#

%

+,,(

-)

((

#

%

+,,-

*,

/
?

(

$%

/

%

&
*9

?

+

6

&
;,

?

8

6
&'

&
;+

?

-

/

#

?

*

/

#

;%

;;

* # &% - ,)

!

!

/

!
!
())* <

<

*

():*

0

0

<
!

#

!

#

1

!

< 0

())9
0
!

6 "
9,

!

<

.

1

%

())*
0

"
!

.

0

0
0

!

!

!

1

0
#
0

1
!
!
!
<

.

!

0

''
<

'' 2
():)

2

0

+*

'' 2

++

*

():-

()))

'' 2

*
''

()))
1

!
1
.

1

1

.

!
!

1
!
"
1

!

&

!

"

())9

!

0

1
!
"

%

!

!
.

.

"

0
()):

1

?

/
"

0

0
!

'' 2
++

()))

'' 2

+*

()))

1

"

1

&#

$ ,

$ %

0

1
0
0

!

1

1

!

"

!
!

"

0
$

%

$%
$%
0

!
0

$%

%

0
0

!

1+- 98
!

!

( )-

0
, ;(
$%

0

/

0

( 9)

!

%

!

.
0

!

%

.

!

+,,(
())81())9
$%
())8 /

!
(

(
4

2
>
!
())8
())())*
());
()):
())9

3

!

, )+8
, )89
, );+
, );;
, )9+
, );*
+,,(

!
0

#
.

1

3
(

!

#

C
+

%

#
C

4

0

, &,&%"*" ,

%

!
3

(

&

+

&

!

#

#

,5

* &,&%"*" ,

(

!

!

+

!

%

"
1
4

5

&

!

%

,) ",)- . &,&%"*" ,

#
())* +,,(
+,,-

())8

&/#" &#*

(

, -/,/ " 3"% +
"

!

"
!

"
/
!

.

!

1.
!

0
"
0

!

"

!
"

"

$0

())(
&

%

()9*
!

!

!
!

0

!

!

"

!

.

"
"

!
0

"

"

!

" !

"

"

"

"

$
> "

()*;

&

" ():,

&

"1 "
!
"1 "

.
!

?

1
"1 "

.
!

.

/
!

"1 "

"

0
0
!

D
.

"

!
!

#
.

"

.

= E.

?
.

?
&

?
&

!
!
0
.

!

1.
#
!
0

"

#

0

"
&

&

"

+,,(

.

.
!

!

!
!

!

!

"

D
.

.

.
!

/
<
!

4

1.

.

3

(

&

4
!

. !

!

.
!

+

&

.

&
&
!

!
!

>

" !
!
8

&
&

-

&
&

0

4
&

" +,,(

=E

4?
3

=

3 4

3
/ 2

(

3 F

"
!

?

3

!

3
/

3

2

3

&/#"

&*" . ,) ,

%

!
!

!

&

&

!

0 "

.. 0

.. 0 0

0

&

2

0
0

1

6

!

()),

"
!
0

1

0
.

@

()**
"

!

!

0

.
"

0
0

!

!
!
0
"
/
(

%
1"

.

!

2
())9

3

>

!

1

!
.

+

>

0

!

"

!
"
8

>

"

0 10
!

.

0

!

-

!

>

!

!
!

"

"

1

!
1

*

>

"

0

!

"

!
.

!

&

= @

+,,;

"

!

!
0

"

#
.

!

0

.

#
&

!

"
1
!

3

4

<

.
"
.
.

0

!

1.

.
"

4

/
!
%
!

.

!

.

.

!

!

!

0
.

0

4
!
!

!
!
4

"
!

%
!

!

0
.

G

G

.

1

!
4
4

.
!
!

.
"

.

! !

.

.

.

4
%

.

!
"
.
"

!

.
4

5
0

1
.

.

.
.

G

G

.
!

4

&("0 - ,

*/,/ "

&#
0

!
"

!

!
!
1

1

2

2

+*

/
++

()))

()))
"

0

10

! "

!

"
!

1

2

++

()))

"
! "
"

0

!

0
" !
"

"
!

"

!

"
$

.

"

.
0

!

! "

!
"

!
! "
!

"

%

%2

+,,8

/,$&.

/,6&#)&,$"
#

0

1

0

1
!
()9*
0

#

!

0
!

"
!

#
"

#

!

"
!

#

0

0
10 #
0 #
#

0

0

1

&

0

.

#

!

#

10 #

0

.
!

"

!

1
0

0
#

.
0 #

0

2
#

I10
.

#

#

0
%

H1
H10 #

!

0

! "

!

"

0
H10 #

!

!

0

.

0

!

#

"
"

&,&%"*" , &#!

%

'
>

/

DF"

()9;

.

():;1()9, '

/
$%

&

"

.

0
!

!

()9-1())8 /

());

!

!

"

!

!

())81())9

+,,(

$%

())8
/

!
+
+

4
'

():;
()::
():9
():)
()9,
()9()9*
()9;
()9:
()99
()9)
()),
())(
())+
())8
())())*
());
()):
())9
3'

>

2

J/
, -;8(

!

!

, -;,)
, -8-, *+-,
, --8*
, -9:*
, -:(, -;,,
, -*;:
, -;,)
, *;8+
, *89*
, *8)+
, *--+
, *-9)

/

()9;

!

, )+8
, )89
, );+
, );;
, )9+
, );*

());

!

!

0
6 "

/

!

"

+,,(

()); !

8

&

()9()9*
()9;
()9:
()99
()9)
()),
())(
())+
())8
3

6 "
, *;9,
, *8::
, *(::
, *(+,
, *,*, ;+,)
, ;,8, ;,-(
, ;(,9
, ;(*9

, +-;,
, +-*)
, +-:,
, +-;,
, +*+(
, +(*:
, ()8(
, (9(, (9;,
, (998
!

>
"
, ,*++
, ,-,9
, ,-+8
, ,8),
, ,-;,
, ,*,9
, ,*(*
, *9,,
, ,*)(
, ,;8+

, -89(
, -;+)
, --+,
, -:(,
, -*)*
, -;9(
, -*(;
, ---9
, -*,+
, --,(

?
, 8-8*
, 8*9+
, 8:9,
, 88+, -(+)
, -(98
, -,9;
, -*,:
, -**,
, -::*

());

&

()9*
6 "
.

>

&

%

()::1()9(

!
'

$%

/
!

"

$%

0
$%

!

/

"
!

-

6 " %
$%

()::
():9
():)
()9,
()9(
3&

, -;:
, 89,
, 89+
, 8::
, 8(;
()9*

()::1()9(

$%
, 8+8
, +*;
, +;)
, +:, +++

-- ;K
-9 -K
-+ ,K
8: ;K
-+ 8K

&

@

())*

!

!

"
.

1.

0
0

#

!

!

0

#

((

()981())8
1

!

"
"

"

!
.

"

.
!

1

!

!

()981())8

"
!

$%

$%

"
"

!

#
0

!

!

#

!
/

+,,())*1+,,(
.

>

/

!

$%
!

/

"

$%
0

/

$%

!

"
!

*
?

>
())*1+,,(
$%

())*
());
()):
())9
()))
+,,,
+,,(

$%

, 98:8
, 989,
, 98)(
, 98;)
, :)*(
, ::)8
, :;9,

3/

, --,, --))
, -9-;
, --+;
, -+,:
, -(;,
, -,;9

+,,-

%

!
!

!

#

-: -K
-; 8K
-+ +K
-: (K
-: (K
-; ;K
-: ,K

4

&# ,)-

4

/,$&.

& "-"# , &/#"*"$
/,6&#)&,$" 3"% +
#

0

1

0

1
!
()9*
#
#
!
"
&

%

())*

11
!

!

!

0

$ .
>

();*

!

"

#

>

"
#

.

"

#

#

0

!

0
!

"
#

!

#

!

!

#

"

"
0

0
10 #
0 #
#

0

0

1

&

0

.

#

!

#

10 #

0

.
!

"

!

1
0

0
#

2

.
0 #

#

0

I10

#

#

H1

0

.

H10 #

%

!

! "

!

"

0
H10 #

!

!

0

.

0

!

"
"

#

0

!

"

0
"
!
0

H10 #
0

6

0

#

0

.

#

0

.
"
!

"

!

.

0
0 #

0

H1

0
0

"

2

0 #

0

!

1

"

!

#

5D

0 #
0

0

#

2
0

!

2

2

1

0

1

#

0

0
!

!

0
#

1

#

10

4

#

#

#
1
" 2

1

1

&

#
.

!

.

#

1#

"
#
#

2

"

.
.

0

&
"
"

/

.

!

0

#

#

0

#

"
#

!

#

#

/

#

.
0

#

1#

0
#

#

1#

#
. !

#

#

1
1

!
&

"1 "

"

2

12

!
1

0

#

!

!
2

2

1

0

#
%

< 0

&

())9

#

6

2

1

5

'

.
-:
( :K

(99, '
-:

6
()8,1()), 0
$+

#

, )+ '
0

-

!

"

. 0

+(

((,

((
8

%

8

6

+ :)K
((

+,
(:

<

#

( )K

()*,1()),
4

&/#" &#*
&

(

,

/!&% /%/7

" +,,(

"

!

&

!

!

'

.

!

.
!

=E 4

?

!

.

=E 4
!

?L5

5

5.

?

4

3

#
!

0

1
!

.

!
!

!

.

!
!
3M E .
#

.

#

#

8

!
0

1 NO

O

M
N O

3

O

!

N

!

.

.

#

#
NO O

#
.

P

&

!

&
3&

" +,,(

( #

. -

&

0

, &-,/%/)"

!

!

/!&% /%/7
#

0

!
E.

!

.

.!

.

!

! !
O
!

"

!

!
"

!
.

!

!
!

.

.
#

!

!
!
.

0
1

.

.

!

!

!

=

!

!
!

!

!
4

4

!

.

.

&/#" &#*

&
(

.

E NO

O

0

&

QNE O

, ,!/)&,

'
"

1

!

!
"

"
'
.

=E

=
!

4

!

"
.
#
M

E

=QN
M

"
#

=

N

.
M= = E M

E

QN =

=E

!

RN
!
6

.

0
"

0

1

0
!
#
!
"
.

4

&,) - # ,

!

0

&*" . ,) ,
"

"

!
0
1

"

()9(

!
1

1

4

&# ,)-

& "-"# ,

/,$&.*

"

%

!

!

"
!

0

"

!

.
.
()9,1

!
()),1
!

!

"

!
0
!

"

"

!

!

0

6 "
1

2 +*

! "

2 ++

()))

1

()))

0
!

!
$%

!

0

<

+

#

!
5

!

&

6

$%

$

#

( #

&# ,)-

& "-"# ,

/,$&.*

%

44

&5","$"

.&# $"/, %

$%

!

(

*

"

.
$%
"

/
"

.
"
!

!

.

"

.
$%

!

$%

$%

$%

$%
1

"

$%

$%
!

"
+

8

6

!

"

! !

.

!
"
())8
!
())*

+,,(

+,,-

4

"./*&$"$
'
3

(

#

!

+
#

4

3 -* ! , /- $" &,&%"*" ,
6

+,,; "

0
+,,;
!
?

$%

0

!

!

!

0
#

4

&,"$ ! ,

(&#

*

6
$%
!
0
%
())* +,,(
+,,-

())8
&

48

(-

#

$%

&*/!& , %"$"$
0
.

0

.

0

.
.

.
#
#

#

&'(

#

$%

< !

())8 $

'

#

!
1

0

#
#

#

#
48

1#

, %"$"$

/,6&#)&,$"

&

$

+,,;

!

!

#

0
3
=

=

E O

=

O S BBBBBBBBBBBBBB +

3
=

=

=

3

$%

3

$%

3
3

.

3
3
6

T ,

!
0

#

#

!
())* +,,(
())8

"
'
$%

+,,-

$%

'

!

!

#

0

!

#

3
=

=

E O

=

(

O

U( O S

+

8

3
=

3

$%

=

3

$%

U(

3

=

3
(

3

.

+

3

.

3
3
'

#
.

(

+

6

T,

.
!

0
48

!
0

"

#

0" "),"5"- ,$" ,!"6"! 9 0" *:
'!

.

#

!
"

.
.

!

!

.

.

0
!

1

#
#

0
0
&

!

!

.

'

0

!

'

!

/,3

E,

/(3

,

.

3

!

#

1
!

0
"

.

.

#

0

#

!

.

" #
.

484

&,) 0" , &#

#

! .

/!&% &,! ) 9 0" :

'! 4

0

.

!

"

.

#

! 4 !
"
#

#
41

!

!

0
"

#

#

1#

.

;

, %"$"$

/,6&#)&,$"

, %"$"$

/,6&#)&,$" ($/% *

#

!

!

0

'

#

!

())*
;

#

F
D

=

;

)8

E , ((-())
$1 V ! E (- 8K
41
0 E (8 ,,

3?

())*
D .
( *+8;

5D .
, 8-9(

- 89

, ,,,

1, ,99+*

, ,+--9

18 ;(

, ,,(

$1 V E (* *K
41

0 E , ,,(

-

;
=
&

)*

=

)8

3

E ( *+ 1 , ,99+

0

=

)8

-

41
"

!

, ,,(

4 2

"
!

!

" #

0
$%

.

'

!
$%

1#

1
*
1
())* ())8

.
0

!
.

!

.

1

.

1
.

#

*

;

"

.
'

())8

())*
#

!

())*

.
0

.

$%

$%

6

.

,

0

#

#

%

!

1 , ,99+ T ,
0

#

#

!

+,,(

3

:

#

F
D

=

2
" #

!

:

/

+,,(

D .
8 99+(
1, (:888

)8

E , 8(++8*
$1 V ! E : 8K
41
0 E ; :(

3?

5D .
, )*()
, ,;;)+

- ,9
1+ *)

, ,,,
, ,(+

$1 V E 9 ;K
41

0 E , ,(+

-

%

:
3

=

,(

=

)8

E 8 99 1 , (:8

=

)8

BBBBBBBBB BBBB B *

$%

+,,(

, ,(+

"

41

! 4 2

"
!

#

1#

"

!

0
$%

'

.

!

!

.

1
1

.

.

+,,(

0

.

/

#

*

:

*

1

$%

'

.

" #

.
.

.

*

#
.

!

2

$%
0

1

!
6

+,,(

.

0
0

%

#

1, (:8 T ,
0

#

,
#

!

#

!

+,,-

9
9

#

F
D
U

D .
* :(8
1, +)(*,
$1 V E (+ *K

E , -+;-+:
$1 V ! E (( 8K
41
0 E(, (:
3?

+,,-

41

5D .
( 8,,
, ,)(8)

- 8)
18 ()

, ,,,
, ,,+

0 E , ,,+

-

%

9
3

=

,-

=

)8

E * :( 1 , +)+

0

)8

=

;

41
"

!

, ,,+

4 2

"
!

!

" #

0
$%

.

1
*

!

!
$%

!

+,,-

.

1
1

.

1

.

0

.

2
.
.

.

*

!

/

" #
$%

0

.
#

*

9

1#

'

#
.

!
6

+,,-

.

0
0

%

#

,
#

!

1, +)+ T ,
0

#
, %"$"$

/,6&#)&,$" &#$+ # *

'

#

!

#
!

&'

!

/

)
)

#

%

F

D .

D

( 8)((
1, ,99++
, ,(*(*

=
U(

)8

E , ((-8*+
$1 V ! E (- (K
41
0 E ; 9)
3?

())*
5D .
, 8:9, ,+-*(
, ,(;9-

8 ;9
18 ;,
, ),

, ,,,
, ,,(
, 8:(

$1 V E (; -K
41

0 E , ,,+

*

%

)
3

= )* =
&

)8

E ( 8) 1 , ,99+
0

=

)8

O , ,(*+

U(

:

41
"

! 4 2

, ,,+
"

!
!

" #

0
$%

.

1#

1
*

!

!

1

#
.

!

.

1

.
.

())8

.

"

/

$%
())*

.

*

!
$%

'

0

" #

$%
.

())*

#

*

)

!

.

1
2

.

())*

#
.

"

!
6

())*

.

0

,

0

#

%

!

#
1 , ,99+ T ,

0

#

.
0

#
, ,(*+ R ,

!

"

#
'
!

#

!

+,,(
"

"

/

(,
(,

#

F
D

%

D .

+,,(
5D .

= )8
U(
E
$1 V

! E

$1 V E

41

0E

41

3?

0 E

*

%

(,
3

= ,( =

)8

&

E 8 9: 1 , (:-

=

)8

O , ,,(*

0

U(

9

41
"

, ,-+

! 4 2

"
!

!

" #

0
$%

.

!

1#

1
*
!

1

#
.

!

.

1
1

2

.
.
.

(,
$%

*

.

.

!

+,,(

0
/

#
" #

$%
+,,(

())8

.

.

*

!

"

$%
'

+,,(

#

!

.

6

+,,(

.

0

,

0

#

%

#

!

1 , (:- T ,
0

#

.

#
, ,,(* R ,

0

!

"

#
'

#

!

+,,-

!
((
((

#

F
D

%

+,,-

D .
* *(,
1, +)(9+
, ,+8(+

= )8
U(
E , -+),-+
$1 V ! E (, +K
41
0 E * ,)
3?
*

5D .
( -()
, ,)();
, ,;+89

8 99
18 (:
, 8:

, ,,,
, ,,+
, :(+

$1 V E (+ :K
41

0 E , ,,)

%

((
3

= ,- =
&

)8

E * *( 1 , +)+
0

=

)8

O , ,+8(

U(

)

41
"

! 4 2

, ,,)
"

!
!

" #

0
$%

.

!

1#

1
*
!

1

#
.

!

.

1

.
.
.
.

.

/

$%

())8

+,,*

!

"
+,,-

#
.

!
6

+,,-

.

0

,

0

#

%

!

#
1 , +)+ T ,

0

#

.
0

0

" #

$%
'

+,,-

#

*

((
$%

!

.

1
2

.

#
, ,+8( R ,

#

!

"

;

&$" . % ,
(
0

#

/

.

1

0

$%

0
#

.

#

#
0

.

#
+

!

.
#

!

# ,
(

!
#

0
.

#

+

!

!
!

8

!

#
#

= / 4 / +,,;

%
0

"

())*
&
>
% %

%

!

>

% %

&

5

>

%

5

())81+,,%
6
())81+,,-

$

0

%

())81+,,-

'

())81+,,-

%

%

0
%

'

%

())81+,,- $

%

())81+,,- 6

%

$
%

6

())81+,,-

%

())81+,,- %

%

%

())81+,,- ?

%

?

+,,,1+,,-

&

%

%

%

%

%
%

$ 6
=

%

4 / ())* 4
&
%
+9

%

&

U

&0 < "1/

5
&
())*

()9*
5

())* $

5
2 - % 45 =

&

());

5

6

2 "

%

< 0

6<

?

())9 )
*

%

50

0

8- ( 3

)*1(+,
< !

())8 5

/

.

5

())9
5

/

6

>
%

6

+,,-

&
?

W

X

6

%

!

5

%

& ? ()), 5

0

$ ! "

6
%

+,,8
'

@

())* +
50
0 #

&

,

- $
D

D

" 2 < +,,(

&

<

6

&

.
F

3

F

5

6

Y ()9*
>

&

@

$0

0

? ())*
"
% %

!

5

%

0

$

"

6

/ > ())(
451' 6

$

6 "
% %

!

+,,; ,

1

5

#

5

$

5

%

?

8 &0 < "1/

"

2 "

=
()9*

&

?

451'

6
!

& Y ());

$
#

% %

6

5

!

'

&Y
$
6
6
5

>
D

+,,(
.
F
/

%

3
'2 4 $ >

()9; / "
*
*
F UUU F 2 8 ? 5&145' 6

6 < ();* / "
$0
Z
0
.
D
F (8 2 - / 81-*

50

.
0

#

."# ,
*
( . *&, -/* $&