Efisiensi Beberapa Substrat dalam Pengujian Viabilitas Benih Berukuran Besar dan Kecil
! !
" #$
+ , -'
!
( #
) *
1!
"!
/0
$
"#
3
&
.
"#
2
%
1
%&
+% , %, 4
# /
21
'
-
*
.
! %
/ 3 4 #
"##$
,
+
%
.
+
/&
#
'
+
$
) *"
!
!
)
'
(
%'
!
# //01% '
25 67 1% ,
%'
%.
!
'
!&
"##' (
-
01 -
)
.
/&
" 2 $
.
*
3
,
/&
4##5
6#5
(
675
*'5
/&
01
"
/&
$
"
8
(
$
)
.
#
$ 31 5676 3
#
##
#
# 8 *
)!.
*
@
%
(8
8
9
#
).!
##
#
#
#
9:! (
8
% 2110+ !
$
#
# #
# 8
8
8
#
( 1+
*
(
% 2112+
' 3" (211?+
# 8
*
#
##
#
$
8
% 211/;
9
%
?1 ><
( 770+%
#
9
#
52 ><
#
(2110+
#
8 # #
#
8
7 2> #
7> 6< " .
#
(
-
#
+%
%
#
-
A
#
"
#
(2115+
*
# 8
8
"
#
$
8
(2110+
#
#
9:!
# 72
#
75<
#
>
8
##
8
# 8
#
'
>2
+ !
6
?%
#
#
/
0
( ..I+
!
..I
(
8 %
775+
( 775+%
% 8
(
(! +
5
/%
#
#
#
*
A
#
##
8
#
##
*
##
).!
9
"
,
,
:
,
,
5 3 1 3 8 9:1
2
%
# 8
( +
*
# 8
*
3
#
## !
9
B
'
# %
2115 (
211> (
'
"
##
,
,
:
+
+
4
,
,
#
8 #
% 211>+%
211/+
( 8 # 1? C 1
( 8 #1
(
(
##
?8
D 1/
(
% 211>; 3
%
#
J ?
B+ *
(251 5 L 1 65 #+
#
(
B+*
.
(60 7
L 1 5> #+%
28
(
E /1
#9 111
+
(? .
B+ *
'4 /5
(2 7 L 1 1 #+
# 8 (9
B+ *
.
# (?> / L 1 2 #+
5
%
##
#
# 2
&
8
(
#%
+
8
(2% 6% 5
?
9
+ ,
#
1%
#
# 2?
# 8
*
#
4$
2/ 611:
/7 71<
#
(! +
* # ('A+ ' 3" (211?+% * #
8
! 8 # #
# 8
6
?%
#
?
> '
*#
#
#
1<
M(FN1 ?+
2110+
% (2+
##
#
%
+
>8
C 1/
E 1?
+
# (
(B +
4 F + *
$
%
(/
B+ *
:
%
(9
B+ *
:
%
(;
B+ *
G
#
# (9
.
B+ *
#
#
(
(B + + * %
(/
B+ *
A
%
# 8 (9
B+
* H %
(<
(B + - + * H %
(
B+ *
%
(=
B+ *
G
#
#
(
B+ *
#
#
#%
%
9:!
$A %
#
#
# 66 2 #% 61 5/ #% 66 67 #% 21 /5 # (
+
##
8
%
#
8
%
#
1
#
#
##
2?
# 8
*
#
)8
.
!#
#
().! +
! #
5
9
71 3$ 8
5
3
4
,
:
,
,
3
%
# 8
(! +
#
#
( 11 /
>7 /
>6 2
?/ 0
#
1 >2
1 7>
1 ?7
1 71
1 67
#
#
.
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
(? /
06 2
?0 5
#
1 />
1 7>
1 ?7
1 7/
1 55
00 0
77 /
>0 1
02 5
/? /
(#+
1 //
1 7?
1 /1
1 71
1 5?
#
#
#
>1 0
57 /
/7 2
// 1
21
1 5/
1 6/
1 6?
1/
1 1>
%
8
#
# 8
8
8 #
#
#
#
(3
#
2+
8
8
!
#
#
#
4
> 8
..I
#%
#
8
8
##
#
!
8
#
# 8
()!.+
8
11<
#
#
8
$
##
#
(2110+
#
11<
##
#%
06 6<
#
#
*
#
$A
%
8
#
!
#
#
#
#
2
%
&
$
$
#
(2110+
*
8
##
#
#
+
# 8
%
#
#
8
%
$
8
#
#
8 #
#
#
8
8
#
> <
..I
#
8
8
%
3
#
# 8
%
#
%
#
##
#
##
$A
#
#
##
%
!
(?> #9
+
# (7 2> # 9
..I
#
#
# (5/ ? #9
+
##
/
3
2
$
# 8
*
8
#
,
I
-
#
$A
!
#
.
.
.
$
B
G
#
0> /
05 5
7 2
72 0
06 /
// 1
7> 2
8
#
.
.
.
$
B
G
#
.
1 25
1 6
1/
10
1 1/
1 5
1 6/
8
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
8 #
#
#
#
#
# 8
*
#
8
!
?><
.
!
*
$
$A
> <
11<
..I
8
01<
21<
!
.
##
9
0/<
#
(!
#
..I
..I
#
$A
#
#
.
#
#
#
#
8
!
%
$A
#
#
%
# 8
,
% 8
#
8
6+ )
#
##
.
!
#
%
# 8
#
(
2
(
#
#
#
(2112+% 8
8
+ 4
2
#
#
:
#9
.
+%
#
#
#
(L? #9
#
#
+
(L / #9
(L 7
+
2110+ #
#
(60 7
(
(211?+% 8
#
.
5 C ?
?
#
##
#
8
,
,
# ? 2
7> 2
70 2
7> 1
7> 1
70 2
7/ 0
-
#
62 0
>2
7/
?5 5
62 5
56 2
-
#
76 0
7 1
76 5
7> 2
75 5
7/ 1
.
#
>1 0
?5 0
?/ 1
.
.
#
#
#
#
>1
/5 5
/2 5
8
7? 2
7/ 5
7/ /
7/ /
70 1
7/ 5
#
#
8 !-43 ?<
8
8
##
2
8
3
5 '
8
8
'
*#
5
8
#
8
8
+
8 #
# 5
5
?
8
#
(
# ?
# 2% 6% 5
#?
%
#
%
#
#
#
#
#
5
#
#
#
?
#
#
#
#
9
#
5
##
?
,
#
# 8
#
*#
#
(
+
##
*#
#
# 8
#
8 %
L ?1<
98
*# %
#
#?
! %
#
*
##
# 8
*
# 8
*
#
#
*#
#
#
#
8
(
#
#
%
#
8
%
8
%
#
# #
( 77>+
'A
8
%
#
#
# ?
##
#
# 8
#
5
8
#
#
%
8
#6
$
# 8 *
#
#
%5
*#
#
8
#
('A+%
#
#
%
.
#
#9
#
# 8
?
#6
5
#
6
# 2
+ )
8
#
8 %8
*#
,
8 #
#
%
6% 5
#?
%
?
# (3
8
#
#
?+
*#
8
##
(
#%
%
*#
#
775+ '
!
*#
# 8
*#
!
8
#
*
'
3
5
#
#
#
,
.
8
8
8
*#
,
2
(
5
6
( /
55 1
>5 0
>0 0
>0 1
06 /
>/ 0
0 2
0/ 5
-
#
10 5
60 2
60 1
105 2
50 /
5 0
105 5
/1 1
?1 1
07 /
01 1
>1 1
.
-
#
1> 1
1> 1
1> 1
172
1> 1
1 772
-
#
?2 0
1> 1
71
0/ 5
// 1
>5 /
.
.
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
+
!
#
3
6 715
1 772
57/
5 >7?
6 200
2 /05
0/ /
0? 0
07 5
71 5
71 1
72 2
8
#
8
M (F N 1 ?+
#
# 8
# 8
#%
*
#
).!
?
#
#
8
##
#
+
#
8
#
#
8
#
# 8
).!
*
#
*#
.
,
,
#
#
(
+
*#
-
#
2C?
2C?
2C?
6C?
5C?
6C?
-
#
5% (?+
?
?
(?+
-
#
2C?
-
#
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
, # #
.
.
.
#3
#$8
#
#
#
(
6C?
5C?
5C?
#% ?
+
&
:
!
)
# 8
-
8$67 3
*
#
#
8
#
(
#+%
# 8
%
8
#
#
#
%
#
% B% &:
8 % 4
#
## % 0/<
8
*
#
5
##
2
8 %
G
#
8
#
*
2
5
#
0 (5+ 26> 252
:
% "
(
#
'
# %
#
"3
211>Q
2110+
# !
21 I *
(
##
+
% $
*
*
# % 2/ - 211?
% 211>
(B
, "#
% B 2112 3
G
%,
3
#
3
? C?" ?1
3
#% ? C ? 6 3
3
#
"
211?
#3
%
% :BB G
#
.
5
4
#
'
3
#
2110+
.
#
-
% IB% $:
2115 '
99
A#
Q 8
6Q
%
9 7769276
G
3
% ) 211/
#
O$
#P (&
I &
6 (2+ 61? 621
770
%#
' 3" 211? '
:
? 3
:
?
'
%
#
8
#
#
1 +9 ; $6 9 )
%I %4: A "
#
F %
70>
775 .
,
,
*
, "#
"#
% !A
4% $ ! )
211>
'
*#
GI
8
#
#%
" .
211/
# 8
*
&
$A ?><
# 8
27(6+ 2> 2>7
#
65( + ?? /
01<
#
% #
'
##
#
#
77>
*
).!
#
##
11<
% .
+
21(2+ 62/ 62>
#
% 2110
# 8
*
8 ).!
"#
?
3 4 8
&:%' $
3
% ! 2110
(<
$
B
#
!
B 3
+
#
6/( + 05 7
*#
8
)8 !
'
! !
" #$
+ , -'
!
( #
) *
1!
"!
/0
$
"#
3
&
.
"#
2
%
1
%&
+% , %, 4
# /
21
'
-
*
.
! %
/ 3 4 #
"##$
,
+
%
.
+
/&
#
'
+
$
) *"
!
!
)
'
(
%'
!
# //01% '
25 67 1% ,
%'
%.
!
'
!&
"##' (
-
01 -
)
.
/&
" 2 $
.
*
3
,
/&
4##5
6#5
(
675
*'5
/&
01
"
/&
$
"
8
(
$
)
.
#
$ 31 5676 3
#
##
#
# 8 *
)!.
*
@
%
(8
8
9
#
).!
##
#
#
#
9:! (
8
% 2110+ !
$
#
# #
# 8
8
8
#
( 1+
*
(
% 2112+
' 3" (211?+
# 8
*
#
##
#
$
8
% 211/;
9
%
?1 ><
( 770+%
#
9
#
52 ><
#
(2110+
#
8 # #
#
8
7 2> #
7> 6< " .
#
(
-
#
+%
%
#
-
A
#
"
#
(2115+
*
" #$
+ , -'
!
( #
) *
1!
"!
/0
$
"#
3
&
.
"#
2
%
1
%&
+% , %, 4
# /
21
'
-
*
.
! %
/ 3 4 #
"##$
,
+
%
.
+
/&
#
'
+
$
) *"
!
!
)
'
(
%'
!
# //01% '
25 67 1% ,
%'
%.
!
'
!&
"##' (
-
01 -
)
.
/&
" 2 $
.
*
3
,
/&
4##5
6#5
(
675
*'5
/&
01
"
/&
$
"
8
(
$
)
.
#
$ 31 5676 3
#
##
#
# 8 *
)!.
*
@
%
(8
8
9
#
).!
##
#
#
#
9:! (
8
% 2110+ !
$
#
# #
# 8
8
8
#
( 1+
*
(
% 2112+
' 3" (211?+
# 8
*
#
##
#
$
8
% 211/;
9
%
?1 ><
( 770+%
#
9
#
52 ><
#
(2110+
#
8 # #
#
8
7 2> #
7> 6< " .
#
(
-
#
+%
%
#
-
A
#
"
#
(2115+
*
# 8
8
"
#
$
8
(2110+
#
#
9:!
# 72
#
75<
#
>
8
##
8
# 8
#
'
>2
+ !
6
?%
#
#
/
0
( ..I+
!
..I
(
8 %
775+
( 775+%
% 8
(
(! +
5
/%
#
#
#
*
A
#
##
8
#
##
*
##
).!
9
"
,
,
:
,
,
5 3 1 3 8 9:1
2
%
# 8
( +
*
# 8
*
3
#
## !
9
B
'
# %
2115 (
211> (
'
"
##
,
,
:
+
+
4
,
,
#
8 #
% 211>+%
211/+
( 8 # 1? C 1
( 8 #1
(
(
##
?8
D 1/
(
% 211>; 3
%
#
J ?
B+ *
(251 5 L 1 65 #+
#
(
B+*
.
(60 7
L 1 5> #+%
28
(
E /1
#9 111
+
(? .
B+ *
'4 /5
(2 7 L 1 1 #+
# 8 (9
B+ *
.
# (?> / L 1 2 #+
5
%
##
#
# 2
&
8
(
#%
+
8
(2% 6% 5
?
9
+ ,
#
1%
#
# 2?
# 8
*
#
4$
2/ 611:
/7 71<
#
(! +
* # ('A+ ' 3" (211?+% * #
8
! 8 # #
# 8
6
?%
#
?
> '
*#
#
#
1<
M(FN1 ?+
2110+
% (2+
##
#
%
+
>8
C 1/
E 1?
+
# (
(B +
4 F + *
$
%
(/
B+ *
:
%
(9
B+ *
:
%
(;
B+ *
G
#
# (9
.
B+ *
#
#
(
(B + + * %
(/
B+ *
A
%
# 8 (9
B+
* H %
(<
(B + - + * H %
(
B+ *
%
(=
B+ *
G
#
#
(
B+ *
#
#
#%
%
9:!
$A %
#
#
# 66 2 #% 61 5/ #% 66 67 #% 21 /5 # (
+
##
8
%
#
8
%
#
1
#
#
##
2?
# 8
*
#
)8
.
!#
#
().! +
! #
5
9
71 3$ 8
5
3
4
,
:
,
,
3
%
# 8
(! +
#
#
( 11 /
>7 /
>6 2
?/ 0
#
1 >2
1 7>
1 ?7
1 71
1 67
#
#
.
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
(? /
06 2
?0 5
#
1 />
1 7>
1 ?7
1 7/
1 55
00 0
77 /
>0 1
02 5
/? /
(#+
1 //
1 7?
1 /1
1 71
1 5?
#
#
#
>1 0
57 /
/7 2
// 1
21
1 5/
1 6/
1 6?
1/
1 1>
%
8
#
# 8
8
8 #
#
#
#
(3
#
2+
8
8
!
#
#
#
4
> 8
..I
#%
#
8
8
##
#
!
8
#
# 8
()!.+
8
11<
#
#
8
$
##
#
(2110+
#
11<
##
#%
06 6<
#
#
*
#
$A
%
8
#
!
#
#
#
#
2
%
&
$
$
#
(2110+
*
8
##
#
#
+
# 8
%
#
#
8
%
$
8
#
#
8 #
#
#
8
8
#
> <
..I
#
8
8
%
3
#
# 8
%
#
%
#
##
#
##
$A
#
#
##
%
!
(?> #9
+
# (7 2> # 9
..I
#
#
# (5/ ? #9
+
##
/
3
2
$
# 8
*
8
#
,
I
-
#
$A
!
#
.
.
.
$
B
G
#
0> /
05 5
7 2
72 0
06 /
// 1
7> 2
8
#
.
.
.
$
B
G
#
.
1 25
1 6
1/
10
1 1/
1 5
1 6/
8
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
8 #
#
#
#
#
# 8
*
#
8
!
?><
.
!
*
$
$A
> <
11<
..I
8
01<
21<
!
.
##
9
0/<
#
(!
#
..I
..I
#
$A
#
#
.
#
#
#
#
8
!
%
$A
#
#
%
# 8
,
% 8
#
8
6+ )
#
##
.
!
#
%
# 8
#
(
2
(
#
#
#
(2112+% 8
8
+ 4
2
#
#
:
#9
.
+%
#
#
#
(L? #9
#
#
+
(L / #9
(L 7
+
2110+ #
#
(60 7
(
(211?+% 8
#
.
5 C ?
?
#
##
#
8
,
,
# ? 2
7> 2
70 2
7> 1
7> 1
70 2
7/ 0
-
#
62 0
>2
7/
?5 5
62 5
56 2
-
#
76 0
7 1
76 5
7> 2
75 5
7/ 1
.
#
>1 0
?5 0
?/ 1
.
.
#
#
#
#
>1
/5 5
/2 5
8
7? 2
7/ 5
7/ /
7/ /
70 1
7/ 5
#
#
8 !-43 ?<
8
8
##
2
8
3
5 '
8
8
'
*#
5
8
#
8
8
+
8 #
# 5
5
?
8
#
(
# ?
# 2% 6% 5
#?
%
#
%
#
#
#
#
#
5
#
#
#
?
#
#
#
#
9
#
5
##
?
,
#
# 8
#
*#
#
(
+
##
*#
#
# 8
#
8 %
L ?1<
98
*# %
#
#?
! %
#
*
##
# 8
*
# 8
*
#
#
*#
#
#
#
8
(
#
#
%
#
8
%
8
%
#
# #
( 77>+
'A
8
%
#
#
# ?
##
#
# 8
#
5
8
#
#
%
8
#6
$
# 8 *
#
#
%5
*#
#
8
#
('A+%
#
#
%
.
#
#9
#
# 8
?
#6
5
#
6
# 2
+ )
8
#
8 %8
*#
,
8 #
#
%
6% 5
#?
%
?
# (3
8
#
#
?+
*#
8
##
(
#%
%
*#
#
775+ '
!
*#
# 8
*#
!
8
#
*
'
3
5
#
#
#
,
.
8
8
8
*#
,
2
(
5
6
( /
55 1
>5 0
>0 0
>0 1
06 /
>/ 0
0 2
0/ 5
-
#
10 5
60 2
60 1
105 2
50 /
5 0
105 5
/1 1
?1 1
07 /
01 1
>1 1
.
-
#
1> 1
1> 1
1> 1
172
1> 1
1 772
-
#
?2 0
1> 1
71
0/ 5
// 1
>5 /
.
.
#
#
#
!-43 ?<
+
!
#
3
6 715
1 772
57/
5 >7?
6 200
2 /05
0/ /
0? 0
07 5
71 5
71 1
72 2
8
#
8
M (F N 1 ?+
#
# 8
# 8
#%
*
#
).!
?
#
#
8
##
#
+
#
8
#
#
8
#
# 8
).!
*
#
*#
.
,
,
#
#
(
+
*#
-
#
2C?
2C?
2C?
6C?
5C?
6C?
-
#
5% (?+
?
?
(?+
-
#
2C?
-
#
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
2C?
, # #
.
.
.
#3
#$8
#
#
#
(
6C?
5C?
5C?
#% ?
+
&
:
!
)
# 8
-
8$67 3
*
#
#
8
#
(
#+%
# 8
%
8
#
#
#
%
#
% B% &:
8 % 4
#
## % 0/<
8
*
#
5
##
2
8 %
G
#
8
#
*
2
5
#
0 (5+ 26> 252
:
% "
(
#
'
# %
#
"3
211>Q
2110+
# !
21 I *
(
##
+
% $
*
*
# % 2/ - 211?
% 211>
(B
, "#
% B 2112 3
G
%,
3
#
3
? C?" ?1
3
#% ? C ? 6 3
3
#
"
211?
#3
%
% :BB G
#
.
5
4
#
'
3
#
2110+
.
#
-
% IB% $:
2115 '
99
A#
Q 8
6Q
%
9 7769276
G
3
% ) 211/
#
O$
#P (&
I &
6 (2+ 61? 621
770
%#
' 3" 211? '
:
? 3
:
?
'
%
#
8
#
#
1 +9 ; $6 9 )
%I %4: A "
#
F %
70>
775 .
,
,
*
, "#
"#
% !A
4% $ ! )
211>
'
*#
GI
8
#
#%
" .
211/
# 8
*
&
$A ?><
# 8
27(6+ 2> 2>7
#
65( + ?? /
01<
#
% #
'
##
#
#
77>
*
).!
#
##
11<
% .
+
21(2+ 62/ 62>
#
% 2110
# 8
*
8 ).!
"#
?
3 4 8
&:%' $
3
% ! 2110
(<
$
B
#
!
B 3
+
#
6/( + 05 7
*#
8
)8 !
'
! !
" #$
+ , -'
!
( #
) *
1!
"!
/0
$
"#
3
&
.
"#
2
%
1
%&
+% , %, 4
# /
21
'
-
*
.
! %
/ 3 4 #
"##$
,
+
%
.
+
/&
#
'
+
$
) *"
!
!
)
'
(
%'
!
# //01% '
25 67 1% ,
%'
%.
!
'
!&
"##' (
-
01 -
)
.
/&
" 2 $
.
*
3
,
/&
4##5
6#5
(
675
*'5
/&
01
"
/&
$
"
8
(
$
)
.
#
$ 31 5676 3
#
##
#
# 8 *
)!.
*
@
%
(8
8
9
#
).!
##
#
#
#
9:! (
8
% 2110+ !
$
#
# #
# 8
8
8
#
( 1+
*
(
% 2112+
' 3" (211?+
# 8
*
#
##
#
$
8
% 211/;
9
%
?1 ><
( 770+%
#
9
#
52 ><
#
(2110+
#
8 # #
#
8
7 2> #
7> 6< " .
#
(
-
#
+%
%
#
-
A
#
"
#
(2115+
*