1
Maranatha Christian University
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Study
Having learned English −including English pronunciation− for several years, many undergraduate Indonesian students of English as a foreign language EFL seem
to stay unable to produce standard English sounds. This reality can be observed in the pronunciation of the senior students of the English Department in the research site. As
they have been learning English pronunciation for at least three years since their first semester in the English Department, they are expected to pronounce English words
appropriately. However, many of them seem not to be aware with their sub-standard pronunciation. As a matter of fact, besides having gained knowledge and skills of
English pronunciation in the Pronunciation class, the students have learned things relevant to pronunciation, such as when practicing speaking in conversation classes.
Although learning English pronunciation is not the same as learning English speaking in the conversation classes, pronunciation is evidently a part of speaking. The
lecturers in conversation classes must have helped improve the students’ English pronunciation by correcting their sub-standard pronunciation when they are speaking.
Thus, these students seem to have no reason to maintain their sub-standard English pronunciation. The fact that the senior students still cannot demonstrate their standard
2
Maranatha Christian University
English pronunciation correctly leads to an opinion that these students will go on having this problem even after they have graduated.
The sub-standard English pronunciation of the English Department students is interesting to investigate because this poor fact is against the purpose of the teaching
and learning English at the English Department. The Pronunciation class and other related classes are meant to provide students with knowledge and skills that can
support their oral English communication. Having sufficient skills in English pronunciation will make graduates more appreciated in the job market as it becomes a
general knowledge that almost all companies require their applicants to be fluent in oral English. Besides, fluency in oral English may also make them communicate more
easily with foreigners, particularly when they study abroad. Since the English Department students are chosen to be the data source of this study, they are not only
expected just to be fluent in oral English communication but also to have good English pronunciation.
I choose this particular topic because I am concerned with the fact that many senior students in the English Department still produce sub-standard English sounds.
Students with the Indonesian mother tongue are chosen to be the data source of this
study because the study is expected to be more feasible than the one using students with a vernacular mother tongue as respondents. In fact, I do not master any
vernacular language and the literature of vernacular languages is also rare. In second language L2 learning, there is a strong assumption that most of the
difficulties faced by an L2 learner are imposed by his or her first language Ellis 6. It is assumed that where there are differences between the first language L1 and the
second language L2, the learner’s L1 knowledge will interfere with the L2, and where the L1 and L2 are similar, the L1 will actively support the L2 learning. This
3
Maranatha Christian University
process is called language transfer. There are two kinds of language transfer, positive transfer and negative transfer interference.
The interference of the Indonesian sound production system may cause pronunciation problems for the Indonesian speakers when they try to produce English
sounds. Some English sounds, especially those that are similar to Indonesian sounds and that are absent in Indonesian sound production system, may be problematic to the
Indonesian speakers. The absent sounds include allophone differences, absent phonemes and different concepts of long and short vowels in English and Indonesian.
Therefore, I attempt to find out the difficulties that the students have in producing English sounds with phonological accuracy according to the Received Pronunciation
RP standard, as described in Daniel Jones’ English Pronouncing Dictionary 17
th
Edition. RP is also called the Queens or Kings English, Oxford English, or BBC
English, which is used by people speaking Standard British English. RP refers to a form of pronunciation, rather than a dialect, which is known as the use of a particular
variety of vocabulary and grammar as well as pronunciation. Anyone using the RP will typically speak Standard British English Burrel 27.
In the research site, I have not been the first to choose pronunciation as the topic of a study. However, apart from investigating the students’ sub-standard English
pronunciation, I also attempt to reveal the students’ motivation in improving their pronunciation. So far, in this university, there have been only two students who have
conducted a study concerning problems in producing standard English sounds. The first study is not quite relevant with this one because it focuses on examining the
Chinese speakers’ errors in pronouncing English sounds. The second is relevant with
4
Maranatha Christian University
this study except that it did not discuss how motivation had influenced the student’s sub-standard English pronunciation like what I am doing now.
My study belongs to applied linguistics, specifically second language acquisition, and the analyses are descriptive. The first theory applied in this study is
concerned with English and Indonesian sound systems. I attempt to find out how Indonesian sound system has interfered with the production of the students’ sub-
standard English pronunciation. I use RP as the standard English pronunciation because in the research site, the pronunciation classes are based on RP. I use all of the
English sounds to test the students’ pronunciation; however, only the most problematic sub-standard English sounds, which are produced by more than 40
2 of the students, will be discussed in this thesis because I think it has already been considered as problematic if more than two out of five students fail to produce the
English sounds. This study deals with individual sounds, so individual English words are used to test the students’ pronunciation.
Another theory that I use in this study is the theory of motivation in learning SLA. I choose this theory because it has been widely accepted by both teachers and
researchers as one of the key factors that influence the success of second or foreign language learning. Motivation is a component that can change comparatively fast and
can be altered by the learner himself according to the learner’s goal of learning a second language. Therefore, a more motivated learner will put more efforts in his or
her studies. He will be open to do extra work in order to improve his language skills, spend more time for studying the language and even deal with the subject on a
subconscious level. However, learner’s motivation can be influenced by many factors. These factors can influence the students’ accomplishment in learning English
5
Maranatha Christian University
pronunciation. In this study, I intend to find out the motivation factors that may have contributed to the production of the students’ sub-standard English sounds.
I choose five seventh semester students of the English Department of Maranatha Christian University as the respondents of this study, particularly because
they have the Indonesian mother tongue. I choose only five students because students with the Indonesian mother tongue are much fewer than those with a vernacular
mother tongue. This study is expected to contribute to the teaching of standard English
pronunciation not only in the English Department of Maranatha Christian University but also in general English classes in Indonesia. I hope this study will also provide
necessary information about Indonesian students’ difficulties in pronouncing English sounds appropriately. Moreover, the findings of this study can be used by English
teachers in Indonesia as a springboard for improving their methods of teaching standard English pronunciation. By putting more emphasis on the problematic English
sounds, teachers may help the students improve their sub-standard English pronunciation. Besides, this study can inspire other students to conduct studies on
similar topics. Words: 1106
1.2 Statement of the Problem