Ranking employee against other employees of the same organization : In
196 CASE STUDIES
Level 1 Level 2
Level 3 Levels 1, 2 Items Plus . . .
Level 4 Level 3 Plus
Technical Expertise
Demonstrates basic
engineering skills.
Work is of good quality.
Works on tasks of low
to medium complexity,
based on specifications
developed by others.
Working technical knowledge in one
technical area. Work employs
company - wide BKMs.
Shows consistent growth
improvement in areas of
contribution.
Works on tasks of low to
medium complexity,
based on specifications
developed by others.
Regarded as an expert in area of
contribution. Work has high
quality consistent with the complexity
and risk of assignment.
Work either extends or employs
company - wide BKMs.
Shows consistent growth
improvement in area of expertise and its
application.
Needs minimal assistance on
medium to complex tasks.
Regarded as an expert in several
technical areas. Understands risks
and manages them effectively.
Exhibits initiative independence in
finding ways to ramp up in new
technical areas.
Comfortable with medium to
high complexity projects.
Teamwork and Leadership
Viewed by peers as
a positive team player;
demonstrates a professional
attitude.
Gives credit where credit is
due. Viewed by
peers as a positive
team player; demonstrates
a professional attitude.
Displays a willingness to
volunteer for projects outside
job scope.
Gives credit where credit
is due. Viewed by peers
as an excellent role model for
communication, teamwork, and
leadership skills.
Shifts between leader and follower
as needed. Sets clear
expectations and requirements
for team. Networks
effectively to share methods
and information to uncoversolve
issues.
Openly shares and accepts ideas.
Viewed by manager as more
of a peer than a subordinate.
Builds credibility and consensus
both within team and external to
team.
Identifies problems and
solves them.
Business Understanding
Understands high level of
how his work impacts the
whole project. Understands
how hisher work and that
of hisher immediate
work group fits business
goals. Independently
adapts hisher work and that
of hisher immediate
work group based on a solid
understanding of business goals.
Identifies, quantifies, and
flags problems at a team level.
Proactively generates
possible solutions to problems
including cost benefit analyses;
drives solutions across the project.