Hillside Forest Land as a Safety net For Local People in a Moutain Village in west Java : an Examination of differences in the Significance of National and Private Lands
F0 RM ULIR2
M O D E L i l . l . JU RN AL I LM I AH
I N TER N A S I ON A L
F O R M U L I R P E N I W I A N K A R YA I L M I A H
I N S TI TU T P E R TA N I A N
DOSEN
BOGOR
(REVI EWER 1 )
A.
I d e n t i t a s Ar t i k e l d a n Ju r n a l
1 . Ju d u l A r t i k e l
: Hi l l si d e f o r e s t l a n d a s a s a f e t y n e t f o r l o c a l p e o p l e i n a m o u n t a i n vi l l a ge i n
W e s t Ja v a : a n e x a m i n a t i o n o f d i f f e r e n c e s i n t h e s i g n i f i c a n c e o f n a t i o n a l a n d
2 . Penul i s
Pri va t e l and s
: Sit i Su gi a h M . M u g n i e s ya h
3 . H a l a m a n d a l a m Ju r n a l
: M a k o t o I n o u e , Yu u k i T s u r u d o m e , S i t i S u g i a h M . M u g n i e s y a h
4 . I d e n t i t a s Ju r n a l
a . N a m a Ju r n a l
ISSN On l i n e
: 95-101
: Jo u r n a l o f Fo r e s t R e s e a r c h
: 1341-6979
e. Penerb i t
: 1610-7403
No m o r / Vo l u m e
: 02/ 08
b. I SSN P r i n t
c.
d. Ed i s i ( B u l a n / Ta h u n ) : M e i
: T h e Ja p a n e s e Fo r e s t r y S o c i e t y
a n d S p i n g e r - Ve r l a g To k y o
f . Al am at Web si t e
Ju r n a l
2003
: http:/ / link.springer.com/ article
/ 1 0 . 1 0 0 7 3 6 2 Fsl 0 3 1 0 0 3 0 0 a i l t t p o go 1 •
B . H a s i l P e n i l a i a nzywvrlieaSRMC
Reviewer 1
Nilai
Maksimal
K o m p o n e n ya n g Dinilai
e. K e l e n g k a p a n u n s u r i si a r t i k e l ( 1 0 % )
4,00
f. Ru a n g l i n gk u p d a n k e d a l a m a n p e m b a h a s a n ( 3 0 % )
12,00
g. K e c u k u p a n d a n k e m u t a k h i r a n d a t a / i n f o r m a s i d a n
Nilai ya n g Di p ero l eh
tl.o
12,00
metodologi (3 0 %)
h. Kel engk ap an u n su r d a n k ual i t as p en erb i t a n j u rn a l (3 0 %)
Ni l a i To t a l ( 1 0 0 % )
12,00
40,00
C. D e s k r i p s i K u a l i t a s K a r y a l l m i a h
TuV&^* vr
S' z^ ' -
^ Ca" ^
1-^''^'=^^ .
ylM' ^ M lMJ
^l.JM.
Bogcr
J
^ -eniiai I ,
| l6/ jfe(^l^
Pro f . b / B i d r i a t n c S o e t a r t o , M A
Bidanglimu:p\ (i
i kAgrari a
Cwiiu ^
0
•- V
- t
•
1/ ,
F O R M U L I RwvutroljifeVTIC
3
M O D E L I L l . J U R N A L I L M I A H I N T E R N A S I O N A LzywvrlieaSRMC
\ :
,
!
F O R M U L I R P EN I L A I A N K A R YA I L M I A H
I N S TI TU T P E R TA N I A N
! I
DOSEN
BOGOR
{REVI EWER 2)
A.
I d e n t i t a s A r t i k e l d a n Ju r n a l
1 . Ju d u l A r t i k e l
: Hi l l si d e f o r e s t l a n d as a s a f e t y n e t f o r l o c a l p e o p l e i n a m o u n t a i n vi l l a ge i n
W e s t Ja v a : a n e x a m i n a t i o n o f d i f f e r e n c e s i n t h e s i g n i f i c a n c e o f n a t i o n a l a n d
Pri va t e lands
2 . Penul i s
: Sit i Su gi a h M . M u g n i e s ya h ,
3 . H a l a m a n d a l a m Ju r n a l
: M a k o t o I n o u e , Yu u k i Ts u r u d o m e , S i t i S u g i a h M . M u g n i e s y a h
4 . I d e n t i t a s Ju r n a l
a . N a m a Ju r n a l
b. ISSN P r i n t
ISSN On l i n e
: 95-101
: Jo u r n a l o f Fo r e s t R e s e a r c h
: 1341-6979
e. Pe n e r b i t
c.
: 1610-7403
No m o r / Vo l u m e
d . Ed i s i ( B u l a n / T a h u n )
a n d S p i n g e r - Ve r l a g To k y o
: 02/ 08
: Mei
: Th e Ja p a n e s e Fo r e s t r y S o c i e t y
f. A l a m a t W e b s i t e
2003
Ju r n a l
: ht t p:/ / link.springer.cprri/ ar_ t ic[e
/ 1 0 .1 0 0 7 %2 r5 l 0 3 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 f f p oGe 1
B, Ha s i l P e n i l a i a n / ? e v / e H ' e r 2
K o m p o n e n yang Dinilai
Nilai
Maksimal
Nilai ya n g Di p ero l eh
a . K e l e n g k a p a n u n s u r i si a r t i k e l ( 1 0 % )
4,00
b. R u a n g l i n g k u p d a n k e d a l a m a n p e m b a h a s a n ( 3 0 % )
12,00
/ /
12,00
//
12,00
//
c.
Kecukupan dan k em u t a k h i ra n data/ informasi dan
metodologi (3 0 %)
d. Kel engk ap an u n su r d a n kual i t as p en erb i t a n j u rn a l (3 0 %)
Ni l a i To t a l ( 1 0 0 % )
40,00
C. D e s k r i p s i K u a l i t a s K a r y a l l m i a h
F f o TTb r , Ir. U j a n g S u m a r w a n , M . S c
)
B I d a n g l l m u : Ri set K o n s u m e n d a n Pe r i l a k u K o n s u m e n
M O D E L i l . l . JU RN AL I LM I AH
I N TER N A S I ON A L
F O R M U L I R P E N I W I A N K A R YA I L M I A H
I N S TI TU T P E R TA N I A N
DOSEN
BOGOR
(REVI EWER 1 )
A.
I d e n t i t a s Ar t i k e l d a n Ju r n a l
1 . Ju d u l A r t i k e l
: Hi l l si d e f o r e s t l a n d a s a s a f e t y n e t f o r l o c a l p e o p l e i n a m o u n t a i n vi l l a ge i n
W e s t Ja v a : a n e x a m i n a t i o n o f d i f f e r e n c e s i n t h e s i g n i f i c a n c e o f n a t i o n a l a n d
2 . Penul i s
Pri va t e l and s
: Sit i Su gi a h M . M u g n i e s ya h
3 . H a l a m a n d a l a m Ju r n a l
: M a k o t o I n o u e , Yu u k i T s u r u d o m e , S i t i S u g i a h M . M u g n i e s y a h
4 . I d e n t i t a s Ju r n a l
a . N a m a Ju r n a l
ISSN On l i n e
: 95-101
: Jo u r n a l o f Fo r e s t R e s e a r c h
: 1341-6979
e. Penerb i t
: 1610-7403
No m o r / Vo l u m e
: 02/ 08
b. I SSN P r i n t
c.
d. Ed i s i ( B u l a n / Ta h u n ) : M e i
: T h e Ja p a n e s e Fo r e s t r y S o c i e t y
a n d S p i n g e r - Ve r l a g To k y o
f . Al am at Web si t e
Ju r n a l
2003
: http:/ / link.springer.com/ article
/ 1 0 . 1 0 0 7 3 6 2 Fsl 0 3 1 0 0 3 0 0 a i l t t p o go 1 •
B . H a s i l P e n i l a i a nzywvrlieaSRMC
Reviewer 1
Nilai
Maksimal
K o m p o n e n ya n g Dinilai
e. K e l e n g k a p a n u n s u r i si a r t i k e l ( 1 0 % )
4,00
f. Ru a n g l i n gk u p d a n k e d a l a m a n p e m b a h a s a n ( 3 0 % )
12,00
g. K e c u k u p a n d a n k e m u t a k h i r a n d a t a / i n f o r m a s i d a n
Nilai ya n g Di p ero l eh
tl.o
12,00
metodologi (3 0 %)
h. Kel engk ap an u n su r d a n k ual i t as p en erb i t a n j u rn a l (3 0 %)
Ni l a i To t a l ( 1 0 0 % )
12,00
40,00
C. D e s k r i p s i K u a l i t a s K a r y a l l m i a h
TuV&^* vr
S' z^ ' -
^ Ca" ^
1-^''^'=^^ .
ylM' ^ M lMJ
^l.JM.
Bogcr
J
^ -eniiai I ,
| l6/ jfe(^l^
Pro f . b / B i d r i a t n c S o e t a r t o , M A
Bidanglimu:p\ (i
i kAgrari a
Cwiiu ^
0
•- V
- t
•
1/ ,
F O R M U L I RwvutroljifeVTIC
3
M O D E L I L l . J U R N A L I L M I A H I N T E R N A S I O N A LzywvrlieaSRMC
\ :
,
!
F O R M U L I R P EN I L A I A N K A R YA I L M I A H
I N S TI TU T P E R TA N I A N
! I
DOSEN
BOGOR
{REVI EWER 2)
A.
I d e n t i t a s A r t i k e l d a n Ju r n a l
1 . Ju d u l A r t i k e l
: Hi l l si d e f o r e s t l a n d as a s a f e t y n e t f o r l o c a l p e o p l e i n a m o u n t a i n vi l l a ge i n
W e s t Ja v a : a n e x a m i n a t i o n o f d i f f e r e n c e s i n t h e s i g n i f i c a n c e o f n a t i o n a l a n d
Pri va t e lands
2 . Penul i s
: Sit i Su gi a h M . M u g n i e s ya h ,
3 . H a l a m a n d a l a m Ju r n a l
: M a k o t o I n o u e , Yu u k i Ts u r u d o m e , S i t i S u g i a h M . M u g n i e s y a h
4 . I d e n t i t a s Ju r n a l
a . N a m a Ju r n a l
b. ISSN P r i n t
ISSN On l i n e
: 95-101
: Jo u r n a l o f Fo r e s t R e s e a r c h
: 1341-6979
e. Pe n e r b i t
c.
: 1610-7403
No m o r / Vo l u m e
d . Ed i s i ( B u l a n / T a h u n )
a n d S p i n g e r - Ve r l a g To k y o
: 02/ 08
: Mei
: Th e Ja p a n e s e Fo r e s t r y S o c i e t y
f. A l a m a t W e b s i t e
2003
Ju r n a l
: ht t p:/ / link.springer.cprri/ ar_ t ic[e
/ 1 0 .1 0 0 7 %2 r5 l 0 3 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 f f p oGe 1
B, Ha s i l P e n i l a i a n / ? e v / e H ' e r 2
K o m p o n e n yang Dinilai
Nilai
Maksimal
Nilai ya n g Di p ero l eh
a . K e l e n g k a p a n u n s u r i si a r t i k e l ( 1 0 % )
4,00
b. R u a n g l i n g k u p d a n k e d a l a m a n p e m b a h a s a n ( 3 0 % )
12,00
/ /
12,00
//
12,00
//
c.
Kecukupan dan k em u t a k h i ra n data/ informasi dan
metodologi (3 0 %)
d. Kel engk ap an u n su r d a n kual i t as p en erb i t a n j u rn a l (3 0 %)
Ni l a i To t a l ( 1 0 0 % )
40,00
C. D e s k r i p s i K u a l i t a s K a r y a l l m i a h
F f o TTb r , Ir. U j a n g S u m a r w a n , M . S c
)
B I d a n g l l m u : Ri set K o n s u m e n d a n Pe r i l a k u K o n s u m e n