5
CHAPTER II THEORETICAL REVIEW
A. Review of Related Studies
The  Best  Little  Girl  in  the  World
is  a  novel  by  Steven  Levenkron  which tells about a horrific story of a girl named Francesca Dietrich. The related studies
on  this  study  are  hard  to  find.  However,  there  are  some  studies  and  criticism which  are  related  to  this  study.  There  are  some  comments  related  to  this  book
which mostly focus on criticizing the story. The  study  from  Stella  Cecilia  on
The  Effect  of  Rebecca  Bloomwood’s
Compulsive Shopping Disorder
in the series of novels written by Sophie Kinsella, the writer uses the same approach as this study. The objective of this related study
is to find out the factors which influence of the  main character’s illness  named Compulsive  Shopping  Disorder  CSD.  There  are  three  problems  in  this  related
study. The first problem is the depiction of Rebecca Bloomwood in order to show her CSD. In the analysis, Rebecca is depicted as  someone who shows more than
four symptoms of CSD which means she suffers from CSD. The second problem is to discover the causal factor of Rebecca Bloomwood’s CSD. There are some
factors  which  influence  Rebecca  B loomwood’s  CSD.  Those  factors  are  family,
society, and media. The third problem is the effect of Rebecca Bloomwood’s CSD towards her relationship with other people. These people are Luke Brandon, Suze
Cleath-Stuart, Jess Bertram, and Elinor Sherman. PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
From  the  depiction  of  Rebecca  the  writer  of  this  study  finds  that  she suffered  from  a  psychological  illness  called  Compulsive  Shopping  Disorder
CSD. The writer finds that there are some reasons why Becky suffers from CSD. The first factor that most definitely
causes Becky’s CSD is caused by her family and  friends.  The  other  factors  are  caused  by  society  and  media  such  as
advertisements,  TV  programs  and  ‘sale’  promotions.  The  writer  concludes  that because of the main character’s obsession of shopping, she starts to have troubles
with people around her. Her relationship with some people close to her is harmed because of her disorder.
The study conducted by Cecilia uses the same approach as this thesis, which is the psychoanalytic  approach.  Another  similarity  is  about  the  way  of  the  two
researches  are  conducted.  This  thesis  is  conducted  by  analysing  the  intrinsic elements of the story and then moves on to the extrinsic elements. Both Cecilia’s
research and this thesis also analyse about person’s disorder. The difference between the study conducted by Cecilia and this thesis lies
on  the  way  Cecilia  tries  to  find  the  effect  of  character’s  disorder  towards  her relationship with other people. Another difference lies on the theory that is being
used.  Cecilia  uses  the  theory  about  consumerism  and  materialism.  This  thesis, however,  uses  the  Freudian  theory  of  defence  mechanism  to  reveal  character
development. The review of the book by Julius Fast says that one type of conflict in this
particular book is manwoman versus manwoman. This is shown when Francesca is forced to eat by her parents. Another type of conflict is manwoman versus self.