Impoliteness Strategies Used by Governor Candidates of DKI Jakarta in Governor Election Debate 2017
ISSN: 2548 - 4613 Vol. 3, December 2018 Vol. 3, December 2018
rd THE 3 ANNUAL INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR ON TRANSFORMATIVE EDUCATION EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP AND AISTEEL
ISSN: 2548 - 4613
2018 Education, Learning and Leadership Innovation
Supported and Coordinated by: Postgraduate School State University of Medan North Sumatera, Indonesia Organized by: Indexing By : PROCEEDINGS Emerald Garden Hotel, Medan - Indonesia 03-04 October 2018
rd
Proceedings of The 3 Annual International Seminar on
Transformative Education and Educational Leadership
(AISTEEL 2018)
“Education, Learning, and Leadership Innovation”
Emerald Garden Hotel, Medan City, North Sumatera, Indonesia October 3-4, 2018Editorial Board Editorial-in-Chief
Dr. Juniastel Rajagukguk, M.Si (State University of Medan, Unimed)
Deputy Editor
Dr. Saronom Silaban, M.Pd (State University of Medan, Unimed)
International Advisory Board / Scientific Committee
Prof. Dr. Kala Saravanamuthu (University of Newcastle, Australia) Prof. Arjen EJ Wals (University of Gothenburg, Sweden) Prof. Dr. Bornok Sinaga, M.Pd (Unimed, Indonesia) Prof. Dr. Aytekin Isman (Sakarya University, Turkey) Prof. Peter Charles Taylor, Ph.D., Med., B.Sc., Dip.Ed (Murdoch University, Australia) Prof. Dr. Mukhlas Samani, Ph.D (Indonesia) Prof. Dr. Jailani bin Md. Yunos (University Tun Hussein on Malaysia) Prof. Dr. Nurahimah Mohd. Yusuf (UTM, Malaysia) Assoc. Prof. Dr Pedro Isaias (University of Queensland, Australia) Assoc. Prof. Elisabeth Taylor, Ph.D (Murdoch University, Australia) Dr. Bambang Sumintono, M.Ed (Universiti Malaya, Malaysia) Dr. Isma Widyaty, M.Pd (UPI, Indonesia) Prof. Dr. Syahrul R, M.Pd (UNP, Indonesia) Prof. Amrin Saragih, MA., Ph.D (Unimed, Indonesia) Assoc. Prof. Ade Gafar Abdullah, M.Si (Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia) Eng. Asep Bayu Dani Nandiyanto (Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia) Prof. Dr. Hartono, M.Pd (Universitas Negeri Semarang) Please cite the proceeding as
“Proceeding of the First Annual International Seminar on
Transformative Education and Educational Leadership Vol. 3 ” with the following
abbreviation: Proc. Aist., 3rd
Proceedings of the 3 Annual International Seminar on Transformative Education
and Educational Leadership (AISTEEL 2018)
Preface
rd
The 3 Annual International Seminar on Transformative Education and Educational Leadership
(AISTEEL 2018) was held in Emerald Garden Hotel, Medan City-Indonesia on 3-4 October 2018.
This seminar is organized by Postgraduate School, Univesitas Negeri Medan and become a routine
agenda at Postgraduate program of Unimed now.The AISTEEL is realized this year with various presenters, lecturers, researchers and students from
universities both in and out of Indonesia participating in, the seminar with theme “Education, Learning and Leadership Innovation.”
The plenary speakers coming from various provinces in Indonesia have been present topics covering
multi disciplines. They have contributed many inspiring inputs on current trending educational
research topics all over the world. The expectation is that all potential lecturers and students have
shared their research findings for improving their teaching process and quality, and leadership.
The third AISTEEL presents a keynote speaker and 4 distinguised invited speakers from Australia,
Singapore, Taiwan, and Malaysia. In addition, presenters come from various Government and Private
Universities, Institutions, Academy, and Schools. Some of them are those who have sat and will sit in
the oral defence examination.
There are 326 articles submitted to committee, some of which are presented orally in parallel sessions,
and others are presented through posters. The articles have been reviewed by double blind reviewer
and 198 of them were accepted for published by Atlantis Press indexed by International Indexation.
Meanwhile 83 papers were published in online International Proceedings indexed by Google Scholar.
The Committees of AISTEEL invest great efforts in reviewing the papers submitted to the
conference and organizing the sessions to enable the participants to gain maximum benefit.
Grateful thanks to all of members of The 3rd Annual International Seminar on Transformative
Education and Educational Leadership (AISTEEL 2018) for their outstanding contributions. Thanks
also given to Universitas Negeri Medan for published this volume. The Editors Bornok Sinaga Rahmad Husein Juniastel Rajagukguk
Table of Contents
Titles and Authors pageDesign of Physical Practicum Tools on Rotational Dynamics Matter with Scientific Concept Fretty Doharni Ritonga; Nurdin Bukit; Betty M.Turnip...........................................
1 Analysis of the Leading Sector and Its Effect on the Economy in Pakpak Bharat Regency ....................................................................
Dinar Melani Hutajulu; M. Nasir; Arwansyah
6 Analyze the Characteristic and Factors Cause of Bullying Behaviours in Early Childhood Fadhilah Syam Nasution; Anita Yus; Aman Simaremare.........................................
12 Play Finger Painting in Creative Art Model to Help Smooth Motoric Development and Creativity of Group a in Kindergarten at Aek Loba Pekan Village Lola Wita Harahap; Sri Milfayetty; Rosmala Dewi.................................................
18 Maintenance of Gayonese Kinship Terms by Gayonese Minority Migrants in Jabodetabek
Desi Purnama Sari; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Berlin Sibarani.......................................
22 Effect of Functional Training and TRX Suspension Training on Body Composition member Golden Fitness and Spa
26 Rafliansyah; Nurhayati Simatupang; Albadi Sinulingga......................................... Interpersonal Metaphor Used in the Boss Baby Movie Khairuni Syafitri; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Anni Holila Pulungan.................................
29 Speech Act in Indonesia Lawyers Club: KPK vs Novanto Theresia Fransiska Sidabutar; Zainuddin; Busmin Gurning...................................
32 The Effect of Instructional Strategy and Style Ofthinking Secuential on Students Outcome MAN Medan Siti Aisyah Hanim; Tiur asih siburian; Darwin........................................................
36 The Effect of Cooperative Learning Models and Self Efficacy on Student Mathematics Learning Outcomes
39 Sabdo Puji Rahayu; Mukhtar; Keysar Panjaitan..................................................... Ideational Grammatical Metahpor in Reading Texts for Senior High School English Textbooks Diemam Ferzhawana; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Zainuddin............................................
43 Effect of Soft Modification on Student Learning Results PAB 13 Kwala Begumit Private Vocational School Iskandar Fahmi.........................................................................................................
47 Differences in Metacognitive Ability of Students Through Learning Realistic Mathematics Education and Problem Based Learning in Pangkalan Susu Senior High School
51 Chairi Mutia Lubis; Waminton Rajagukguk; Kms.M.Amin Fauzi........................... Development of Interactive Learning Media Projection of Working Drawing on Students of Class X TKR in SMK Markus 2 Medan Irwan Panggabean; R. Mursid; Samsidar Tanjung.................................................
56 Metaphor of Modality in Donald Trump’s Speech in United Nation General Assembly 2017 Nursyah Handaya; Siti Aisyah Ginting.....................................................................
60 Traditional Sport Of Silek Tuo In Minangkabau Community (a study of Silek tuo
Prima Nanda; Sabaruddin Yunis; Agung Sunarn.....................................................
Improved Student’s Generic Science Skills With The Application of Cooperative Learning Models Based on Batak Culture Rika Sari Indah Harahap; Derlina; Rahmatsyah; Sahyar; Bornok.........................
66 Management Development Athletes of Shorinji Kempo North Sumatra Region Arti Kurniaty Bangun................................................................................................
71 Efforts to Improve Learning Results Free Basketball Shot (Free Throw) Through The Application of Teaching Style Inclusion Bob Rahmat Manalu........................................... .....................................................
75 Development of Egosan Engineering Extension Models with Straight Sticking in Pencak Silat William Filipus; Amir Supriadi; Tarsyad Nugraha..................................................
77 The Development of Interactive Learning Media of Athletic on Physical Education in SMP Negeri 15 Medan Akhmad Khaidir; Budi Valianto; Tarsyad Nugraha.................................................
81 The Effect of Learning Model and Self-Reliance Learning toward Science Learning Outcomes Rohima; Mukhtar; Samsidar Tanjung......................................................................
84 The Effect of Learning Method and Kinesthetic Perception on The Learning Outcomes of Lay Up Basketball Saiful Adrian; N
88 urhayati Simatupang; Suprayitno………………………………….... Analysis Of Physical Education Teacher Management Skills In State Elementary School Sub-District Medan Tembung Syahrul Effendi Nasution; Amir Supriadi; Albadi Sinulingga..................................
91 Innovation Of The Speed Model Using Running With The Ball Techniques In Football
95 Julio Roberto; Amir Supriadi; Novita........................................... ........................... The Development of Penetration Drill Training Technique of Wrestling Sport Ihsan Idris Silalahi; Jan Bobby Nesra Barus...........................................................
99 Speech Function of Anies Baswedan’s Speech in Approval Ceremony as the Governor of Jakarta in the Period of 2017-2022 102 Ahmad Rifa’i Ritonga; Sumarsih........................................... .................................. Development of Web-Based Learning Media to Enhance Writing Capability of Biography Text of Student Class X SMA Rencus B. Sinabariba, Tiur Asi Siburian, Mutsyuhito Solin.................................... 105 Implementing the Teaching Supervision by Principals in Improving the Performance of Teachers in Aceh Besar Said Ashlan........................................... ........................................... ....................... 109 Female Principal Leadership Hendro Widodo; Hengkang Bara Saputra........................................... ................... 115 The Ways of Rohingya Teenagers in Medan Realized Their Language Attitude 120
I Wayan Dirgayasa; Rahmat Husein; Lonni NurIffah Nasution..............................
Metaphor in Umpasa of Saurmatua Toba Batak Ceremony Heppy Yersin Digita Purba; Rahmad Husein; Anni Holila Pulungan..................... 124 The Influence of Part Method, Whole Method and Determination Exercise Methods on Improving Exercise in the Sports Branch of Pencak Silat Single Art Category of College Students SPDKK (Art of Kencana Kwitang Self Defense) Deli Serdang Year 2018/2019 Mawar Sari........................................... ........................................... ....................... 127
Philosophy of Rakut Sitelu Desi Haryati Nianggolan.......................................................................................... Evaluation of Implementation of Sustainable Professional Development (PKB) for Junior High School Physical Education Teachers to Increase Professionalism in Tebing Tinggi City Mhd Fazar Afandi..................................................................................................... 135 Development of Innovative PJOK teaching materials on floor gymnastics materials to improve learning outcomes of Grade Students at Junior Hight School Bangun Saragih........................................................................................................ 138 The Influence of the Discovery Learning Model assisted with Image Media and Motivation Against Civics Learning Outcomes of Students in Class IV of Public Elementary Schools 055980 Aman Damai 2017/2018 Heryansyah Ginting; Dede Ruslan; Reh Bungana Br.Perangin-angin.................... 142 Development of science teaching materials based on Science Technology Society (STM) and its influence on learning outcomes of fourth grade students of MIN Medan Tembung Diah Hafizhotul Husna; Nuraini; Ramlan Silaban.................................................. 149 The Improvement of Cooperative Learning Model Application Skill in Numbered Head Together Through Clinical Supervision of Art Teacher in SDN 060886 Medan Baru Unita Vitta Omas Sianturi; Martua Manullang; Rosmala Dewi.............................. 154 Gold of North Sumatera Program Coach Performance Suyono; Hariadi; Supryetno..................................................................................... 159 Transitivity Systems Analysis of Bilingual Civic 3 Education Textbook for Grade
XII Jusup Sitepu; Anni Holila Pulungan; I Wayan Dirgeyasa Tangkas........................ 163 The Lecturer Performance Development of the STKIP Bina Bangsa Getsempena Banda Aceh Saiful Bahri............................................................................................................... 169 The Interference of Batak Mandailing Language to Indonesian (In The Interaction At The Seventh Grade Students Of Madrasah Tsanawiyah Swasta Al-Azhar Kabupaten Tapanuli Selatan Padang Sidimpuan) Siti Jahria Sitompul; Abdurrahman Adisaputera; Sumarsi...................................... 175 The Influence of Microbiology Dictionary and Microbiology Textbook Utilization in the Contextual Learning Framework on Biology Students Higher Order Thinking Skills
177 Kiki Rizqi Sahara; Hasruddin; Ashar Hasairin........................................................ The Differences of Learning Style and St udents’ Creativity to Students’ Achievement in Dribbling the Ball in Playing Football of Seventh Grade Students of SMP Ar
- – Rahman Percut
Muammar Afif Marpaung; Imran Akhmad; Rahma Dewi........................................ 180 Development of Gobag Sodor Game Model to Increase Interest in Elementary Students Siska Nova Undari.................................................................................................... 184 The Influence of Research-Based Learning with Portfolio Assessment on Science Process Skills in Microbiology Course for Biology Program Students Saudah Rahmayanti; Hasruddin; Tumiur Gultom.................................................... 187 The Influence of Teaching Style and Confident Against the Results of a Study of Shooting in the Game of Football (Experiment Studies the Self Check Style and
Tembung Sabilina) Muhammad Syaiful; Ramadhan Harahap................................................................ Development of Mirror Writing Teaching Materials Based on Class XI Media Literation of Lolomatua 1 State High School Yanida Bu'ulolo; Biner Ambarita; Marice.............................................................. 195 The Development of Teaching Materials for Technology- Assisted Procedure Text in Vocational High School Nova Andarini; Biner Ambarita; Malan Lubis......................................................... 197 Development of Adobe Flash Based Floor Gymnastics Media Learning on Health Sport Education Lesson Hardiansyah............................................................................................................... 201 The Effect of Learning Approach and Linguistic Competence Capability Reading The English Narative Text of Student SMA Negeri 6 Padangsidimpuan.
Sukriyah Batubara; Keysar Panjaitan........................................................... 206 ……….
Analysis Effect of Household Consumption, Investment and Labor to Economy Growth In Sumatera Utara Richna Handriyani; Arwansyah; Sahyar................................................................... 209 Idioms Translation Strategies in Pasung Jiwa Novel English Version Hariyanto; Amrin Saragih; Sumarsih........................................................................ 213 Code Mixing in Novel: A Case of Indonesian Literary Work Nurul Hidayanti Hasibuan; Amrin Saragih; Sumarsih............................................. 216 Logico-Semantic Relation in Presidential Debate Between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump
221 Annisa Risma Khairani Lubis; Della Fransiska Ginting; Jumino Suhadi................ Semiotic Meanings in Cigarette Advertisement Texts Rodearta Purba; Zainuddin; Amrin Saragih............................................................. 227 Modality as Hedging Device in the US Presidential Election Debate Roobby Hamdanur; Anni Holila Pulungan; Zainuddiin........................................... 232 The Improving Mathematical Communication Ability Through Realistic Mathematical Approach Based on Toba Batak Culture Aman Sanusi Siregar................................................................................................. 235 Speech Functions of Doctors and Patients on Medical Consultation Process Resti Citra Dewi; Anni Holila Pulungan, Sumarsih.................................................. 239 The Development of Venturimeter Instrumentation in Dynamic Fluid Zahrani Dalimunthe; Rahmatsyah; Derlina.............................................................. 243 Lexical Metaphors in Onang-onang of Bobby and Kahiyang Tortor Dance Siti Rahma Ritonga; Anni Holila Pulungan; Didik Santoso...................................... 246 The Discourse Markers in President Joko Widodo’s Speeches in KTT APEC China in 2015 Syahbuddin Nasution1; Busmin Gurning; I Wayan Dirgayasa Tangkas.................. 249 Preparation of Papers in Two-Column Format for AISTEEL Conference Proceedings
Translator’s Strategies in Transferring Cultural Values in Ratatouille
Film 254 Femy Septiani; Anni Holila Pulungan...................................................................... Lexical Metaphor In Printed Car Advertisements Misdiana; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Amrin Saragih.......................................................... 258 Political Discourse Analysis of Donald Trump Political Speech Elisa Silviani Siregar; Prof. Dr.Zainuddin, M.Hum; Prof.Dr. Sri MindaMurni, MS...................................................................................... ..................................... 263Nurliana Harahap; Mahendra Ginting Manik; Indah Listiana................................
Appraisal of Healthy Product Advertisement on Television Nurun Nazipah Harahap; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Rahmad Husein Napitupuluh.......... 274 Lexical Metaphor in Andrea Hirata’s “The Dreamer” Novel 277 Nurul Sa’adah; I Wy. Dirgeyasa; Siti Aisyah Ginting...............................................
Impoliteness Strategies Used by Governor Candidates of DKI Jakarta in Governor Election Debate 2017 Sri Minda Murni; Busmin Gurning
281 …….................................................................... Intertextuality in Travel Umroh Advertisement Afifah Nurul Khoirot Nasution; Anni Holila Pulungan; Eddy Setia......................... 287 Intertextuality on Oral Discourse in Sari Matua Batak Toba Ceremony Dyan Yosephin Hutagalung; Anni Holila Pulungan; Rahmad Husein..................... 290 The Effect of Mangosteen (Garcinia mangostana L.) Peel to Creatine Kinase Serum in Male Rats (Rattus norvegicus) with Fatigue from Swimming Rika Nailuvar Sinaga; Jumadin IP; Zulaini.............................................................. 293 Analysis of Technology Utilization to Measure The Throw Distance of The Ball on Hammer Throw Riki Prastian; Agung Sunarno; Sabaruddin Yunis Bangun....................................... 296 The Interactions of Social Stratification and Karonese Register in Giving Pedah Pedah Perjabun Elkana Putra Tarigan; Amrin Saragih; Siti Aisyah Ginting..................................... 300 Implementation Management Training Volleyball Club of Pertamina Year 2017 Reza Wibowo; Sanusi Hasibuan; Budi Valianto....................................................... 305 Lexical Metaphor in Printed Car Advertisements Misdiana; Siti Aisyah Ginting; Amrin Saragih.......................................................... 308 Improving Students’ Reading Comprehension Ability In Descriptive Text Through Flashcard Aisya Hartati.............................................................................................................. 309 The Role of Teacher’s Training Model and Technological Approach to the Improvement of Teachers’ Professionalis Intan Sufiah Batubara................................................................................................ 312 The Difficulties of Students at the Second Year of St.Thomas 3 Senior High School Medan in Translating English Idioms into Indonesian Fitri Susi Sinurat........................................................................................................ 315 The Effect Of Applying The Great Wind Blows Strategy On The Students’ Vocabulary Mastery
321 Gisca Irdayana Lubis................................................................................................. Attitude of Examiners in Thesis Convocation Mara Sutan Siregar................................................................................................... 325 Politeness Strategies in Mandailing Wedding Ceremony Nurun Nazipah Harahap; Fatma Raudah Siregar.................................................... 329
2548-4613 281
Impoliteness Strategies Used by Governor Candidates
of DKI Jakarta in Governor Election Debate 2017
English Applied Linguistics Study Program Universitas Negeri Medan
Medan, Indonesia yohanadeborasib51@gmail.com
Sri Minda Murni
English Applied Linguistics Study Program Universitas Negeri Medan
Medan, Indonesia
Busmin Gurning
English Applied Linguistics Study Program Universitas Negeri Medan
Medan, Indonesia
Abstract--This study aimed at exploring the impoliteness strategies in governor election debate 2017. The objectives of the study were to describe, to explain how types of impoliteness strategies used and to expose the reasons. This research applied descriptive qualitative method. The data were the utterances of the governor candidates in two different debate sessions which were analyzed by using Culpeper Impoliteness Theory. The findings revealed that there were three out of five impoliteness strategies found in both debates, namely bald on record impoliteness, positive impoliteness and negative impoliteness. The governor candidates used the bald on record in three realizations, positive impoliteness in seven realizations and negative impoliteness in three realizations. There are some reasons of using the impoliteness strategies, namely to vent negative feelings, to mock others, to show disagreement, to show power, and to clarify something. However, the main reason to use the impoliteness strategies was to show power. Moreover, it is also revealed that both two different types of impoliteness strategies and two different realizations were used at the same moment.
Keywords: election debate, governor candidates, impoliteness strategies
I. INTRODUCTION A good communication is one that comes from a speaker who can convey good messages to the audiences so that the audiences can understand or give a good feedback in order to create communication. Therefore, before performing a conversation, the speaker needs to consider several things, example of how social relations with the audiences, where the event occurs, and to what the conversation is done. In fact, the speaker task is to keep the conversation going well, is not jammed, not in vain, and the social relationship between the audiences of the conversation is not disturbed. Attitude of the speaker also becomes a factor in creating a good conversation which leads to the application of impoliteness as an important strategy that must be done by the participants in the communication and aims to maintain harmonious atmosphere Culpeper [1].
Beard [2] states study the language of politics is important because it helps the language users to understand how language is used by those who wish to gain power, those who wish to exercise power and those who wish to keep power. Moreover, language has a powerful tool in the hands of political leaders.In implementation of successful democratic rule in any country language of politics is essential. Aeyomoni and Akinkuolere [3] observe that language is the conveyer belt of power, it moves people to vote, debate.
Language is essential to politicians. Beard [2] elaborates the politician is a practitioner of the art of politics, essential to the working of human society. The language of politics provides the opportunity for politicians to explore the resources available through language to manipulate words to persuade them. Therefore, language could be regarded as the vehicle of politics. The governor candidates also politicians, because politics is the practice to influence of other people to achieved and exercise positions of governor. One activities perform by the politicians are done through the language like speech or debate. In recent years, political debates between governor candidates become one of interesting case to discuss they give lip service as it is a reality that must be ahead of the election, because basically they want to win at the time of the next election, so that they will give their best to get to the heart of society so that people would choose him to be a leader.
2548-4613 282
B. Impoliteness Strategies Culpeper makes a theory which explains an intended act to attack someone
2. Positive Impoliteness Positive impoliteness is a strategy directed to attack the hearer ’s positive face. Brown characterized positive face be desire to be liked, admired, ratified, and related to positively, nothing that one would threaten positive face by ignoring someone possible positive impoliteness realizations: 1)ignore, snub the other, 2)exclude the other from an activity, 3)dissasociate from the other, 4)be disinterested, unconcerned, unsympathetic, 5)use inappropriate identity markers, 6)use obsecure or secretive language, 7)seek disagreement, 8)make other feel uncomfortable, 9)use taboo words, and 10)call other names.
’s face or where the speaker does not have the power to (safely) utter an impolite utterance. He has categorized the realization of bald on record impoliteness into 1) direct, 2) clear, 3) unambiguous, and 4) concise way.
’s intention is to attack the hearer ’s face. A revised version of this strategy in Culpeper [1] takes into consideration that in this case there is a lot of face at stake and the speaker ’s intention is to attack the hearer
1. Bald on Record Impoliteness Bald on records impoliteness is performed in a direct, clear, unambiguous and concise way and the speaker
’ face.
’s strategies are more comprehensive as they consist of five strategies; meanwhile, Lachenict ’s strategies consist of four strategies. The impoliteness strategies which are made by Culpeper are: bald on record impoliteness, positive impoliteness, negative impoliteness, sacrasm or mock impoliteness, and withold impoliteness. These impoliteness strategies are a means of tracking the hearers
’s face. He calls his theory as the theory of impoliteness strategy. Compared to Lachenict ’s strategies, Culpeper
Culpeper [1] defines impoliteness as a situation where a speaker communicates face-attack intentionally, or when the hearer perceives and/or construct behaviour as intentionally face-attacking, or a combination of both. He further states that impoliteness comes about when: (1) the speaker communicates face attack intentionally, or (2) the hearer perceives and/ or constructs behavior as intentionally face tacking, or a combination of (1) and (2). In addition, there are some terms that refer to the same meaning with impoliteness; it is the term of rudeness. The term of impoliteness and rudeness have the same meaning in negative attitude. Lakoff [4] then asserts that rude behavior does not use the strategies of politeness when those strategies are hoped to do, in other ways that the utterance can be meant as deliberately and negatively argumentative.
Based on researcher's observation, the governor candidates of DKI Jakarta also utilized the impolite strategies to make other candidates feel uncomfortable. Impolite utterances of one candidate Anies Rasyid Baswedan (ARB) as can be seen in the following situation:
A. The Concept of Impoliteness The concept of impoliteness is the opposite of politeness. When one act politely, he is trying to get along with other people and try to ensure that the communication goes on smoothly. If for some reason one wants to be impolite towards other people he is deliberately attacking others with his speech or want to create a social interruption. People often express their feelings with impolite language that can cause conflict. They often cannot control their behavior or language when they communicate to others. They do not think about politeness strategy but they prefer to perform impoliteness strategy to express their feelings.
II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Culpeper [1] stated the positive impoliteness is the use of strategies to damage the addressee ’s positive wants, including ignore, make other feel uncomfortable, snub the other, use inappropriate identity makers and call other names. He tried to make the other candidate (BTP) feel uncomfortable because he asked about his previous promise for DKI Jakarta as the governor in his period. Related to the explanations above, the researcher is interested to analyze impoliteness utterance of governor candidates in governor election DKI Jakarta 2017 because when the candidates are debating, there are some rules that should be obeyed to make the hearers feel comfortable related to the language used by the candidates. Each candidates should be wise to choose the language especially about how to deliver opinion and how to respond the argument if they disagree with statements uttered by the other candidate. The candidates ’ language must have significant effects on the opponent. This research intends to describe the types of impoliteness strategies, to explain how those types of impoliteness strategies linguistically realized and to expose the reason why the impoliteness strategies linguistically used by the governor candidates in DKI Jakarta election debate 2017.
” is the positive impoliteness which realization call other names.
From the situation above, the utterance of “Firaun pencuri pun bisa dengan jujur menceritakannya.
”
ARB : “Firaun pencuri pun bisa dengan jujur menceritakannya.
3. Negative Impoliteness Negative impoliteness is a strategy used to attack the hearer ’s negative face. Negative face is the desire not to be imposed upon, nothing that negative face could be impinged upon by imposing on someone. The realizations are: 1)frighten, 2)condescend, scorn or ridicule, 3)invade the other ’s space,
2548-4613 4)explicitly associate the other with the negative aspect, 5)put the other indebtedness on record. Culpeper et al [1] add another
IV. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION strategy into this category, which is hindering or blocking the other physically or linguistically. After analyzing the data, the findings of this can be seen in the figure below:
4. Sarcasm or Mock Impoliteness Culpeper [1] stated that Sarcasm or mock impoliteness is Fig 1. Types of Impoliteness Strategies performed with the use of politeness strategies that are obviously insirece, and thus remain surface realizations. In this case, someone uses this strategy as following threatened face done by applying politeness strategies that actually just pretending.In addition, Culpeper
’s theory of sarcasm or mock impoliteness is close to Leech ’s [5] conception if irony “If you must cause offence, at least do so in a way which does not overtly conflict with the PP, but allows the hearer to arrive at the offensive point of your remark indirectly, by way of an implicature ”.
5. Withold Impoliteness Culpeper [1] explained that withhold impoliteness occurs In Figure 4.1 it is shown that the most frequently when someone prefers to keep silent when a polite act is hoped impoliteness strategies used was positive impoliteness, followed to be performed by the others. The realization of withhold by negative impoliteness and then bald on record. The researcher impoliteness are being silent and failing to thank. did not find sarcasm or mock impoliteness and withhold impoliteness.
C. Reasons of Using Impoliteness Strategies There are some functions of rudeness which relates to the Data 1: impoliteness according to Babee in Culpeper. They are: (1) to BTP :
“Pasangan ini ngomong kami hanya membangun
show disagreement, (2) to vent negative feelings, (3) to mock fisik, jembatan segala macam. Bukan. Karena kami others, (4) to clarify something and (5) to show power. ingin memperbaiki orang.
”
It can be seen from the data above, BTP wants to show his
III. METHODOLOGY rejection or ignorance of what candidate 1 says that he builds not only Jakarta but also the people because in the previous The study applied descriptive qualitative research design by statement candidate 1 only tells about the physical development describing the phenomena of language in society. In this case, of Jakarta. This strategy belongs to the positive impoliteness. the answers of the research problem in this study were answered by giving explanation or describing the impoliteness strategies of
Data 2: the utterances in governor candidates ’ interaction in detail.
ARB : “Ijinkan saya mengingatkan bahwa 5 tahun yang
Bogdan&Biklen [6] stated that the design used in the research
lalu pernah ada janji. Dan janji itu mengatakan akan
refers to the researcher ’s plan of how to proceed. The source of
dibangun kampung deret di pinggir-pinggir sungai. Di
data in this study was the governor candidates of governor
mana janji itu? Di mana kontrak politik itu? Kontrak
election debate of DKI Jakarta 2017. The data was the utterances
politik ditandatangani ”
in debates which were taken from videos and then transcribed into written text. There were twelve sections of debate from 13 The utterance of the ARB above can be categorized as
January 2017 until 10 February 2017, but in this research there negative impoliteness. It can be known from the question of were only five sections taken namely 13 January 2017
ARB asking or billing promises previously submitted by BTP (Pembangunan Demokrasi dan Pemerintahan yang Efektif), 27 but not yet realized until specified time.
January 2017 (Birokrasi, Pelayanan Publik, dan Penataan
Kawasan Perkotaan ) to be analyzed in this study. The data were
Data 3: then analyzed by applying Miles & Huberman ’s (2014) analysis
ARB : “Karena itu Pak Basuki, jangan hanya kerja-
model which considered three steps namely 1) data
kerja-kerja. Harus punya gagasan, harus punya kata-
condensation, 2)data display, and 3) conclusion drawing and
kata. Karena dua itu memberikan narasi. Dan Bung verification. Karno. Bung Karno mengatakan, banyak bicara
283
2548-4613 284
jelas, terukur. ”
AHY : “Inilah masalahnya. Pemimpin yang selalu
Bald on record impoliteness was used in 3 realizations.The realizations were direct, clear, and concise way. Data 9:
When the speaker speaks of weaknesses or what can be the object of dropping his opponent, he usually invades or always talks about his opponent's weakness to show that his opponent is not as strong as he is.The eviction system was one of the BTP's work programs while serving as governor of DKI Jakarta. In conveying his statement, AHY attacked the BTP ’s work program which he regarded as a program that could only hurt the people whose lives are difficult, not to improve the life of Jakarta residents. In other words, AHY attacks by scorning the BTP ’s work program in case of eviction.
”
AHY : ”Bapak punya alasan tentunya mengapa menggusur, tetapi bagaimana perasaan bapak sebagai pemimpin sekaligus pengambil kebijakan tersebut melihat warga yang hidupnya semakin sulit begitu semakin sulit? Dan akhirnya kehilangan segalanya.
Data 8:
Negative impoliteness was used in 3 realizations. They were condescend scorn or ridicule, invade the other ’s space, and explicitly associate other with negative aspect. The most dominant realization was invade the other's space.
When the speaker feels uninterested or displeased with the discussion of his interlocutor, he shows his disrespectful attitude.This statement comes out after the BTP responds to his work program that is considered only work without giving respect for the word. Then ARB directly interrupts that BTP words are not connected at all and are not interested in saying “Jawabannya ga nyambung sama sekali.”
”
bagaimana membangun manusia? Jawabannya ga nyambung sama sekali. Karena itu, karena itu
“Saya rasa sederhana. Pertanyaannya
Data 7: ARB :
When the speaker tries to distance himself from the conversation of others and feels not part of the other speaker's topic. The speaker also want to show that he is different from others or the intended of the speakers.In his statement BTP wants to show that he is not the same as ARB who has a style like a lecturer and who he thinks can only provide theory without giving action. He does not want to look the same as ARB by saying "Kalau kami? Kami tahu tujuannya.visinya
banyak bekerja. Bukan hanya banyak bekerja banyak bicara.
membangun, membangun manusia, tidak ada bangun benda matinya itu namanya apa tau gak? Itu namanya teori. Ngajar jadi dosen, di kampus, itu ya teori. Cuma ngomong saya mau bangun ini, mau bangun itu, bangun ini tapi ga ada action-nya. Kalau kami? Kami tahu tujuannya.Visinya jelas, terukur. Ya harus membangun, harus ada. Harus ada fisik supaya sumber manusia ini tercapai. Nah saya kira pasangan nomor 3 gayanya memang dosen kali ya. ”
Data 6: BTP : “Nah makanya kalau kita hanya mengatakan
The third candidate says that the vision and mission of the BTP is called a strategy, but the BTP ignores it and says it is not a strategy but a policy in their program. The BTP rejects the assumption of strategy and removes the word.
Kebijakan kami, apapun yang dipikirkan dIrancang, dianggarkan, harus membuat penuh otak perut dan dompet warga DKI. ”
dimaksud dari pasangan calon 3 itu bukan strategi, karena kalau strategi kami itu adalah transparansi, nontunai. Nah ini kami namakan kebijakan.
Data 5: BTP : “Di dalam visi misi program kami yang
The BTP in conveying his statements tries to demonstrate the achievements that he can carry out in his programs as a Jakarta government or boast of an improved human development index (HDI) and in that way he tries to make other candidates feel uncomfortable with his achievements.
”
”Dan apa lagi yang akan kami katakan, visi kami ini terukur dengan angka, apa angka itu, itu adalah indeks pembangunan manusia makanya jangan heran Jakarta nomor satu. Malahan kita terima empat piagam dari Bapenas.
BTP :
Related to the realizations of impoliteness strategies, there are many ways used in each strategy. Positive impoliteness was used in 7 realizations. The realizations were ignore and snub the other, dissasociate from other, be disinterested, use obsecure or secretive language, seek disagreement, make other feel uncomfortable, and call other names. The most dominant realization used was make other feel uncomfortable. Data 4:
From the data above, it can be seen that ARB wants to reply the question from the presenter and affirms to BTP that in building Jakarta it is necessary to use ideas not only working. Therefore, the utterance is concluded as bald on record which shows the impoliteness because ARB directly addressed the word "Pak Basuki" to BTP.
”
curiga dengan rakyatnya sendiri. Pertama tadi
2548-4613 285
”Di dalam visi misi program kami yang dimaksud dari pasangan calon 3 itu bukan strategi, karena kalau strategi kami itu adalah transparansi, nontunai. Nah ini kami namakan kebijakan. Kebijakan kami, apapun yang dipikirkan dirancang, dianggarkan, harus membuat penuh otak perut dan dompet warga DKI. Nah di sinilah perbedaannya. Pasangan ini (nomor 3) ngomong kami hanya membangun fisik, jembatan segalam macam. Bukan. Karena kami ingin memperbaiki orang. ”
Every governor candidate has the same right to speak up especially in clarifying something to be clear. ARB previous position as the Minister of Education made him giving an explanation that the purpose of his program is not only to build and improve the students' knowledge, but also their moral, faith and character.
”
Karakter moral artinya jujur, berkarakter: ikhlas, tuntas, beriman, tetapi karakter kinerja, kerja keras, kerja tuntas. Pendidikan bukan sekedar penyiapan ke pekerjaan.
ARB : ”Di sana tak ada moral, di sana tak ada karakter, di sana tak ada nilai. Justru yang mau kita bangun adalah iman, taqwa, akhlak, karena yang dibutuhkan bagi masyarakat Indonesia adalah pendidikan yang menumbuhkan karakter moral dan karakter kinerja.
In some occasions, the power between governor candidates seem different. This power struggle would occur to show the dominance of each speaker in their interaction.ARB used the parable of hooks, fish, and ponds in conveying opinions. If it can be seen from those, what is given by candidate number 1 and 2 will not be useful if he does not provide the pool. So he shows his strength or superiority over other candidates. Data 14:
”