Perbandingan Performansi Internet Berbasis Code Division Multiple Acces Pada Sistem Internet Mobile
33
LAMPIRAN B
HASIL PENGUJIAN
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
1
11/11/14
2
12/11/14
3
13/11/14
4
14/11/14
5
15/11/14
6
16/11/14
7
17/11/14
8
18/11/14
9
19/11/14
10
20/11/14
11
21/11/14
Jam
10:43
15:03
8:02
16:48
10:33
13:22
10:19
15:20
9:32
14:32
13:34
17:26
9:07
15:59
8:58
15:25
11:24
19:00
10:19
18:00
9:41
17:58
Min
Maks
Ratarata
2094
2002
2002
2003
2043
2138
2027
2000
2525
2039
2069
2004
2011
2044
2024
2002
2000
2115
2037
2017
2003
2010
6538
6404
6057
7276
6304
5938
5368
6786
5950
6408
6184
6352
5863
6081
5132
6004
5983
5171
5483
6561
5734
5711
4630
4286
4762
4814
4272
4487
4118
4433
5328
4399
4276
4274
4139
4605
3935
4224
3887
4055
3800
4525
4283
4231
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
10:38
15:25:13
8:58:50
16:44:35
10:25:48
17:13:18
10:16:05
15:16:53
9:33:05
14:16:34
8:40:30
17:22:45
9:02:18
15:55:49
8:55:46
15:21:50
11:00:52
18:54:04
10:05:30
17:42:30
9:36:45
17:51:20
10:39
15:25:52
8:59:30
16:45:15
10:26:45
17:14:05
10:17
15:17:32
9:33:50
14:17:20
8:41:15
17:23:45
9:03:00
15:56:25
8:56:40
15:22:50
11:01:52
18:55:27
10:06:55
17:43:33
9:37:25
17:52:30
60
39
40
40
57
47
55
39
45
46
45
60
42
36
54
60
60
83
85
63
40
70
479778
738120
719667
719667
505030
612483
523394
738120
639704
625798
639704
479778
685397
799630
533087
479778
479778
346828
338667
456932
719667
411238
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
10:11:03
15:28:25
8:00:33
16:45:50
10:28:10
17:14:43
10:17:55
15:19:00
9:35:45
14:19:00
8:44:55
17:24:30
9:04:04
15:57:49
8:57:10
15:24:43
11:20:40
18:36:05
10:09:03
17:43:50
9:39:09
17:53:28
10:11:38
15:29:04
8:01:04
16:46:50
10:30:40
17:48.0
10:18
15:20:00
9:35:50
14:27:46
8:47:22
17:25:25
9:05:50
15:58:10
8:57:43
15:25:11
11:22:15
18:58:19
10:13:37
17:45:25
9:39:55
17:57:00
35 822477
39 738120
31 928603
60 479778
150 191911
185 155604
35 822477
60 479778
5 5757338
526
54728
147 195828
55 523394
106 271573
21 1370795
33 872324
28 1028096
95 303018
1334
21579
274 105061
95 303018
46 625798
212 135786
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
315
320
313
261
313
287
335
273
310
269
274
279
263
265
274
267
904
975
996
1000
989
909
976
1000
881
994
999
978
986
907
950
987
264
265
260
267
260
994
991
999
998
992
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
381
369
36
452
543 182
366
604
48
394 15703 9126
457
546 169
425
371 253
438
250
37
469 6914 3994
366 3379 1068
369 3846 2558
406
304 203
435
254
71
422
285
96
339
112
3
392
232
26
381
424
36
10
34
8
58
31
68
15
58
32
67
67
28
34
3
11
8
337
483
346
395
416
8
53
57
22
57
573
48
247 130
4123 2357
493 106
764 438
Universitas Sumatera Utara
34
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
12
22/11/14
13
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
16
26/11/14
17
27/11/14
18
28/11/14
19
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
01/12/14
22
02/12/14
23
03/12/14
24
04/12/14
25
05/12/14
Jam
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
8:29 2003 5961 4311 8:18:49 8:20:25
17:39 2025 4189 3042 17:30:23 17:31:35
9:43 2003 5651 3879 9:36:06 9:37:20
17:39 2001 5414 4010 17:35:27 17:36:07
10:06 2071 5832 4341 9:56:44 9:58:10
17:07 2202 5892 4404 17:03:30 17:04:35
9:12 3481 5144 4660 9:07:42 9:08:40
14:33 2001 6407 4167 14:34:39 14:35:55
9:03 2005 6255 4384 8:59:35 9:01:00
16:11 2004 6384 4149 14:06:50 16:07:50
9:34 1999 6653 4762 9:31:46 9:33:05
15:59 2087 5062 3897 15:56:21 15:57:10
10:24 2017 4939 3747 10:18:06 10:19:04
16:29 2010 6167 4334 16:25:46 16:26:30
8:55 2014 5962 4506 8:51:58 8:52:45
18:40 2006 5882 3967 18:35:36 18:36:22
9:35 2021 5547 4280 9:24:14 9:25:05
15:23 2059 5115 3982 15:12:03 15:14:25
10:31 2042 6008 4892 10:19:35 10:21:30
19:14 2019 5879 4228 18:13:56 18:15:05
10:03 2071 4922 3756 8:33:50 8:34:35
16:30 2004 5634 4270 17:20:57 17:21:47
8:36 16984 42520 35474 8:33:50 8:34:35
17:24 2016 6004 4391 17:20:57 17:21:47
9:23 2037 5828 4273 9:06:21 9:07:01
16:59 2027 6329 4317 16:55:43 16:56:35
10:38:24 10:39:37
10:48
19:20 2039 5249 3806 19:16:04 19:17:02
96
72
74
40
86
65
58
76
85
7260
79
49
58
44
47
46
51
142
115
69
45
50
45
50
40
52
73
58
299861
399815
389009
719667
334729
442872
496322
378772
338667
3965
364388
587483
496322
654243
612483
625798
564445
202723
250319
417198
639704
575734
639704
575734
719667
553590
394338
496322
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
8:21:23
17:32:48
9:38:52
17:37:06
9:59:50
17:05:50
9:09:20
14:36:35
9:01:50
16:08:38
9:33:52
15:57:50
10:20:39
16:27:15
8:53:15
18:37:35
9:32:30
15:20:43
10:22:35
19:21:37
8:35:03
17:22:30
8:35:03
17:22:30
9:07:54
16:57:13
10:41:00
19:17:59
8:23:26
17:37:39
9:41:43
17:38:28
10:02:10
17:06:20
9:09:49
14:39:22
9:02:28
16:08:56
9:35:50
15:58:35
10:23:35
16:27:50
8:53:50
18:38:26
9:33:39
15:23:04
10:25:01
19:22:18
8:35:35
17:23:25
8:35:47
17:23:25
9:20:37
16:57:59
10:45:22
19:18:09
123 234038
291
98923
171 168343
82 351057
140 205619
30 959556
29 992644
167 172375
38 757544
18 1599260
118 243955
45 639704
176 163561
35 822477
35 822477
51 564445
69 417198
141 204161
146 197169
41 702114
32 899584
55 523394
44 654243
55 523394
763
37728
46 625798
262 109873
10 2878669
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
267
312
267
261
269
263
260
288
269
263
257
285
265
264
260
268
264
260
274
258
268
267
263
267
262
259
264
268
996
984
986
994
968
995
999
991
994
999
994
892
983
993
978
997
995
977
995
963
998
997
997
998
978
994
996
990
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
401
830 386
533
729 520
369 3239 2325
416
502 203
418
701 348
413
245
41
363
271
52
580
186 104
352 4067 2532
483 4864 3346
324 15586 4889
390
136
46
437
467 277
361 2615 1838
378
279
57
445
494 295
342 2974 1641
346
990 438
428
78
42
343
217 107
421
821 389
465
117
14
415
227
30
449
485 211
459 1331 1182
376 3190 2230
572
794 651
430
460 113
47
71
73
40
50
17
19
56
62
69
31
34
59
70
20
60
55
44
54
49
47
12
13
44
89
70
82
25
Universitas Sumatera Utara
35
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
26
06/12/14
27
07/12/14
28
08/12/14
29
09/12/14
30
10/12/14
Jam
Min
Maks
9:34
18:05
10:54
17:55
10:13
18:19
18:09
2110
2041
2129
2020
3005
2017
2005
5959
5518
6568
11:29
18:17
2014
2030
5109
5199
5129
5034
5194
5752
Ratarata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
9:29:20
17:58:52
10:04:36
18:13:12
10:04:36
18:13:12
11:19:10
18:13:57
4027 11:19:10
4174 18:13:57
4944
4121
4328
4316
4406
4262
4526
9:31:20
18:02:20
10:08:50
18:14:25
10:08:50
18:14:25
11:20:20
18:15:06
11:20:20
18:15:06
120
208
254
73
254
73
70
69
70
69
239889
138398
113333
394338
113333
394338
411238
417198
411238
417198
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
9:37:37
18:03:21
10:17:55
18:15:58
10:17:55
18:15:58
11:27:40
18:21:02
11:27:40
18:21:02
9:40:40
18:04:40
10:21:13
18:18:14
10:21:13
18:18:14
11:28:05
18:22:52
11:28:05
18:22:52
183 157304
79 364388
198 145387
136 211667
198 145387
136 211667
25 1151468
110 261697
25 1151468
110 261697
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
273
286
274
255
251
269
268
271
260
262
538
410
243
309
215
472
1698
323
437
247
987
927
983
974
557
989
984
985
981
998
362
445
471
345
235
390
331
400
344
377
245
237
104
56
0
218
317
71
34
45
46
58
43
18
0
46
19
22
8
18
Universitas Sumatera Utara
36
Tabel 2: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam tidak sibuk
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
1
11/11/14
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
12/11/14
13/11/14
14/11/14
15/11/14
16/11/14
17/11/14
18/11/14
19/11/14
20/11/14
21/11/14
22/11/14
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
Jam
Packet Loss
Durasi
Through
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Sent
Lost
Lost
(%)
12:07:24
132
218081
314
998
381
786
68
9
9:35:57
9:42:40
403
71431
272
996
400
4363
2692
62
719667
12:30:21
12:31:00
39
738120
316
1000
393
568
111
20
71
405446
20:42:30
20:42:53
23
1251595
320
970
423
484
127
26
12:33:50
105
274159
12:34:44
12:37:10
146
197169
319
988
456
410
274
67
21:49:15
55
523394
21:50:17
22:00:00
583
49377
283
808
423
57
7
12
13:12:28
13:13:15
47
612483
13:14:15
13:19:00
285
101006
318
970
400
258
87
31
4365
22:13:15
22:14:30
75
383823
22:15:15
22:18:08
173
166397
325
969
459
682
232
34
5101
4040
12:38:26
12:39:15
49
587483
12:40:05
12:41:02
57
505030
310
983
419
294
128
44
2001
5304
3986
21:54
21:55:00
45
639704
21:56:00
21:57:50
110
261697
316
968
441
719
212
29
12:53
3935
4907
4300
12:58:33
13:28:00
1767
16291
13:30:20
13:32:30
130
221436
270
996
351
2825
2115
75
23:11
2000
4954
2945
22:58:00
22:59:20
80
359834
22:05:35
22:08:00
145
198529
278
993
497
622
309
50
13:21
2015
5540
4207
13:14:12
13:14:52
40
719667
13:16:15
13:17:16
61
471913
268
442
301
89
1
1
22:41
2025
5232
4761
22:31:00
22:32:00
60
479778
22:43:07
22:43:45
38
757544
266
995
383
389
222
57
12:19
2085
5711
4441
12:15:05
12:15:50
45
639704
12:16:16
12:16:40
24
1199445
268
976
401
262
25
10
22:21
2032
5153
4084
22:17:32
22:18:24
52
553590
22:19:27
22:19:42
15
1919113
271
994
363
341
91
27
13:54
2007
5353
4101
13:51:29
13:52:25
56
514048
13:39:50
13:41:30
100
287867
266
997
438
921
267
29
21:13
2005
6465
3951
21:04:59
21:06:00
61
471913
21:08:41
21:11:37
176
163561
257
1000
409
2286
1414
62
13:54
2014
6580
4261
13:46:20
13:47:20
60
479778
13:49:54
13:52:02
128
224896
259
977
386
2580
1900
74
22:25
2001
6276
3827
22:16:27
22:18:13
106
271573
22:22:31
22:23:29
58
496322
264
1000
396
3400
2617
77
13:23
2001
6095
4187
13:16:26
13:17:09
43
669458
13:19:52
13:26:39
407
70729
270
999
409
2616
2011
77
21:29
2000
6607
4287
21:24:03
21:24:05
2
14393344
21:25:43
21:27:53
130
221436
258
996
365
3317
2042
62
14:21
2004
5097
3962
13:10:15
13:13:50
215
133892
13:17:20
13:30:06
766
37581
275
994
469
2678
2208
82
21:57
2000
6028
4508
21:49:59
21:51:49
110
261697
21:53:03
21:56:40
217
132658
271
985
372
3359
2535
75
13:17
2001
6172
3903
13:10:37
13:11:22
45
639704
13:13:50
13:14:30
40
719667
261
990
414
4008
3134
78
22:02
2007
6609
4188
21:53:57
21:56:30
153
188148
21:57:55
22:00:45
170
169333
271
984
496
607
416
69
12:43
2055
6023
4953
12:41:31
12:42:40
69
417198
12:53:48
12:54:50
62
464301
265
997
349
428
62
14
1:05
1999
5233
2504
22:20:40
23:39:30
4730
6086
23:53:30
24:30:00
2190
13145
13:17
2009
4595
3576
13:10:22
13:13:14
172
167364
13:14:20
13:16:23
123
234038
291
994
440
569
285
50
Min
Maks
12:53
3544
5257
21:33
2008
12:33
Rata-rata
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi (s)
4709
12:12:12
12:13:22
70
6157
4003
21:33:42
21:34:55
3478
5161
4706
12:28:41
20:46
2009
5001
4009
12:38
2091
5337
22:02
4143
6116
13:15
2100
22:24
Through
put
Delay
Mulai
Akhir
411238
12:05:12
73
394338
12:29:21
40
20:40
20:41:11
3932
12:32:05
5277
21:48:20
5927
4576
2055
5709
12:41
2044
22:05
Universitas Sumatera Utara
37
20:42
2434
4940
4450
20:37:10
Tanggal
16
26/11/14
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
27/11/14
28/11/14
29/11/14
30/11/14
01/12/14
02/12/14
03/12/14
04/12/14
05/12/14
Jam
08/12/14
09/12/14
2878669
20:39:00
20:40:00
60
479778
71
134
Delay
91
0
0
Packet Loss
Through
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Sent
Lost
Lost
(%)
12:14:40
45
639704
277
990
360
21:59:10
132
218081
259
977
419
251
39
16
328
204
62
13:29:32
13:29:50
18
1599260
264
982
387
443
34
8
237907
20:16:38
20:17:20
42
685397
259
1000
364
615
221
36
50
575734
13:15:48
13:17:04
76
378772
261
989
381
496
246
50
22:18:08
139
207098
22:19:46
22:25:39
353
81549
259
999
380
3641
2692
74
12:03:53
12:05:00
67
429652
12:06:21
12:07:18
57
505030
257
996
378
312
82
26
3467
22:02:08
22:03:43
95
303018
22:07:00
22:24:09
1029
27975
273
977
380
1976
1704
86
5833
4285
12:35:34
12:37:00
86
334729
12:38:25
6511
4259
22:31:34
22:33
86
334729
22:35:29
12:39:25
60
479778
264
999
403
906
533
59
22:47:55
746
38588
272
1000
359
5123
3844
75
2061
5644
4238
12:59:33
13:00:19
46
625798
13:01:57
13:02:46
49
587483
272
991
447
461
164
36
22:48
2005
4827
3595
22:35:22
22:36:21
59
487910
22:38:08
22:47:06
538
53507
267
998
410
1591
1226
77
13:47
2011
6147
4401
13:56:39
13:57:33
54
533087
13:58:48
13:59:58
70
411238
291
948
437
1244
1208
97
23:23
2011
6147
4471
23:08:09
23:10:22
133
216441
23:12:15
23:22:22
607
47425
262
1000
336
4699
2302
49
14:01
2064
5262
4488
13:56:39
13:57:33
54
533087
13:58:48
13:59:58
70
411238
252
981
357
371
147
40
23:23
2002
6386
3706
23:08:09
23:10:22
133
216441
23:12:15
23:22:22
607
47425
262
999
442
4474
2517
56
13:06
2003
23:11
2014
5901
4114
12:55:07
12:55:55
48
599723
12:57:03
13:04:29
446
64544
266
995
437
910
627
69
6415
4156
23:03:48
23:04:55
67
429652
23:05:35
23:08:23
168
171349
276
997
489
4326
2609
60
13:33
2026
5943
4085
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
263
988
390
243
80
33
21:53
2075
6333
4743
21:48:54
21:49:55
61
471913
21:50:30
21:51:50
80
359834
262
993
391
503
275
55
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
Maks
12:15
2031
5881
22:00
2020
5764
13:32
2223
20:18
Rata-rata
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi (s)
4621
12:12:38
12:13:25
47
4327
21:05:34
21:56:20
3046
5024
3977
13:27:43
13:28:30
2002
5888
4883
20:13:36
13:21
2004
6301
4950
22:27
2007
6266
12:08
2003
22:25
Through
put
515
Durasi
Min
Mulai
Akhir
612483
12:13:55
9451
21:56:58
47
612483
20:15:37
121
13:13:40
13:14:30
4276
22:15:49
5260
4086
2014
4909
12:40
2000
22:39
2008
13:03
06/12/14
07/12/14
10
Tabel 2: Hasil pengujian menggunakanprovider A pada jam tidak sibuk
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
20:37:20
22:53
2027
5146
4401
22:45:13
22:46:03
50
575734
22:52:16
22:53:30
74
389009
271
978
330
260
68
26
13:23
2010
6366
4231
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
264
996
373
3675
2169
59
21:04
2013
6111
4166
21:50:29
21:51:19
50
575734
21:51:03
21:55:22
259
111146
256
998
469
615
180
29
12:50
2105
5229
4246
12:44:32
12:45:23
51
564445
12:46:41
12:48:53
132
218081
257
986
412
479
167
35
21:56
2015
5862
4239
21:50:29
21:51:19
50
575734
21:51:03
21:55:22
259
111146
274
999
436
634
382
60
23:20
1999
6581
3889
13:09:14
13:09:58
44
654243
13:10:52
13:13:37
165
174465
267
991
460
477
223
47
Universitas Sumatera Utara
38
30
10/12/14
13:14
2012
5123
3684
22:06:32
22:07:22
50
575734
22:08
22:10:02
122
235956
260
999
413
3458
2581
74
13:09:14
13:09:58
44
654243
13:10:52
13:13:37
165
174465
267
991
460
477
223
47
22:06:32
22:07:22
50
575734
22:08:00
22:10:02
122
235956
273
994
435
444
212
48
Universitas Sumatera Utara
39
Tabel 3: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam sibuk
No
Tanggal
Jam
Bandwidth (Bps)
RataMin Maks
rata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
2154
2003
2002
2126
6536
6404
6274
7197
10:03:00 10:27:00
4426
4317 15:03:00 15:25:00
4583 8:19:54 8:49:03
6005 15:56:40 16:26:00
1440
19991
2
11/11/14 10:31
14:28
8:57
12/11/14
16:29
1320
1749
1760
21808
16459
16356
3
13/11/14 11:05
2030
6664
4794
10:36:05 10:57:20
1275
22578
14:21:39 14:50:00
1701
16923
1
4
5
14/11/14 11:22
14:20
2014
2000
6014
6662
10:36:05 10:57:20
3740
4269 14:21:39 14:50:00
1275
22578
1701
16923
15/11/14 10:18
2000
6675
4386
9:42:20 10:00:00
1060
27157
15:31:00 15:59:00
1680
17135
Throughput saat download
Delay
Through
RataMulai
Akhir
Durasi
Min Maks
rata
put
10:32:00
10:30:00
120 239889 287
AM
998
363
15:30:10 3:39:10 PM
540
53309 278
997
503
8:53:49 8:56:30 AM
161 178799 271
998
382
16:27:07 4:27:35 PM
28 1028096 269
284
326
11:01:30
10:58:58
152 189386 276
AM
989
415
14:54:20 2:55:35 PM
75 383823
11:01:30
AM
10:58:58
152 189386 265
951
369
14:54:20 2:55:35 PM
75 383823 273 1000
474
10:11:00
AM
10:05:15
345
83440 268
996
501
15:00:00 3:02:15 PM
135 213235
258
998
413
267
998
415
9:50:27 9:51:13 AM
46 625798 261
988
531
14:39:15 2:40:49 PM
94 306241 262
947
414
9:43:50 9:49:30 AM
340
84667 267
991
337
15:11:00 3:14:40 PM
220 130849 279
988
507
8
9:03
17:19
9:52
17/11/14
16:42
9:59
18/11/14
15:14
2011
2004
2009
2003
1999
2002
6486
6352
6229
6081
6299
5174
4554
4136
4113 9:16:46 9:47:50
4208 16:02:40 16:32:30
4558 9:01:13 9:29:30
3674 14:36:18 15:07:17
1864
1790
1697
1859
15444
16082
16963
15485
9
19/11/14
16:40
2016
6446
4548 18:03:32 18:33:09
1777
16200 18:36:06
10
20/11/14
9:58
17:34
2000
2017
6385
6561
8:30:27 9:00:04
3902
4450 16:52:56 17:19:35
1777
16200
1599
11:33:49
18003 17:27:15
2000
2010
2003
2022
2003
2001
6329
5848
5961
5998
5651
6289
9:49:03 10:13:20
3997
4189 18:06:46 18:35:20
4303 8:36:04 9:02:13
3546 17:44:51 18:15:03
3820 8:53:07 9:18:28
4013 17:45:15 18:12:18
1457
19758
13
21/11/14 10:27
18:48
9:07
22/11/14
18:28
9:28
23/11/14
18:19
1714
1569
1812
1521
1623
16795
18347
15887
18926
17737
14
24/11/14
2009
6524
4301
10:10:35 10:36:00
1525
18877
6
7
11
12
16/11/14
11:32
10:23:37
18:42:32
9:04:36
18:21:10
9:24:30
18:16:50
11:29:30
6:37:09 PM
11:42:08
AM
5:31:27 PM
10:25:34
AM
6:46:35 PM
9:05:35 AM
6:25:47 PM
9:27:10 AM
6:17:25 PM
11:35:00
AM
63
456932
268
997
353
499
252
57689
114233
268
264
999
998
401
374
117
143
59
277
160
35
246040
201306
487910
103923
179917
822477
267
260
267
274
269
261
998
993
996
996
904
996
482
406
404
450
336
449
330
87232
269
1000
480
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
366
181
49
554
3815
1917
243
2426
1693
44
64
88
2521
1635
65
462
311
67
3361
1903
57
2250
1638
73
1088
1558
2228
2389
3844
2249
2504
425
1130
2079
2130
1776
2112
1938
39
73
93
89
46
94
77
3734
2748
74
2597
2083
80
3202
2132
67
3632
3016
3613
2368
2842
2865
2226
3002
1834
2173
79
74
83
77
76
5763
2320
40
Universitas Sumatera Utara
40
15
25/11/14
17:54
9:50
2002
2023
5892
6246
4005 17:12:15 17:47:15
3699 9:17:38 9:46:00
15:29:25 16:23:00
2100
1702
3215
13708 17:44:40
16913 9:49:05
8954 14:27:12
5:48:23 PM
9:51:10 AM
2:27:51 PM
223
125
39
129088
230294
738120
282
272
272
973
947
994
563
539
350
2478
1985
3953
2068
1915
2986
83
96
76
Tabel 3: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
No
Tanggal
16
26/11/14
17
18
Jam
8:40
15:25
9:24
27/11/14
16:41
19
28/11/14 11:37
16:20
9:45
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
01/12/14 11:03
19:00
22
02/12/14 10:11
17:33
9:24
03/12/14
14:45
23
9:20
18:21
24
04/12/14 10:21
16:48
25
05/12/14
20:00
26
27
06/12/14 10:10
17:45
18:53
07/12/14
Bandwidth (Bps)
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Delay
Packet Loss
Durasi
Through
Through
RataRataLost
Mulai
Akhir
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
Min Maks
Min Maks
Sent Lost
rata
rata
(%)
(s)
put
put
2041 6255 4348 8:00:55 8:31:10
1816
15852 8:37:55 8:39:37 AM
102 282222 263
999
517 2717 2094 77
2004 6394 4026 14:47:39 15:05:55
1096
26265 15:11:50 3:13:05 PM
75 383823 257
994
320 2301 1352 59
1999 6653 4782 8:45:22 9:16:16
1854
15527 9:20:30 9:22:10 AM
100 287867 285
991
499 15004 4627 31
2005 5062 3710 16:06:30 16:37:00
1830
15730 16:39:29 4:40:35 PM
66 436162 265
998
489 2589 2265 87
11:35:50
10:53:59 11:23:11
1752
16431
4598 3419 74
AM
2004 6241 3937
11:32:08
222 129670 264
993
356
2010 6167 4209 13:49:15 16:12:48
8613
3342 16:14:52 4:19:10 PM
258 111576 276
983
406 2112 1603 76
2013 5962 4276 8:58:30 9:30:00
1890
15231 9:47:12 9:51:23 AM
251 114688
2915 2230 77
17:21:59 17:47:55
1556
18500 18:53:19 6:59:40 PM
381
75556 275
995
360
2103 5547 4378 8:50:29 9:10:38
1209
23810 9:14:21 9:18:30 AM
249 115609 260
997
400 2059 1422 69
1999 6141 4174 17:49:02 18:10:38
1296
22212 18:12:23 6:16:55 PM
252 114233 264
995
395 5024 3441 68
11:02:13
10:41:43 10:55:25
822
35020
1964 1139 58
AM
1999 6138 4144
10:57:46
267 107815 263
969
352
2019 5741 4210 18:20:34 18:52:50
1936
14869 18:55:33 6:58:54 PM
201 143217 278
979
343 2536 1924 76
10:54:35
10:12:18 10:45:30
1992
14451
352
110
31
AM
2071 5025 4014
10:49:23
312
92265 281
994
373
17848 42800 34704 16:49:00 17:19:20
1820
15817 17:31:30 5:35:30 PM
240 119945 283
51
1
2
993
434
15688 51752 35034 8:49:05 9:15:40
1595
18048 9:20:03 9:28:23 AM
500
57573
2463 1693 69
2014 6338 4556 14:05:55 14:31:40
1545
18632 14:33:57 2:42:55 PM
538
53507 262
991
363 2920 1788 61
10:19:58
9:35:52 10:04:20
1708
16854
4824 3211 67
AM
2016 6356 4357
10:10:58
540
53309 279
994
382
2049 6329 4271 16:12:17 16:39:23
1626
17704 16:41:40 4:46:01 PM
261 110294
2528 1933 76
11:06:20
10:57:13 11:30:10
1977
14561
AM
11:02:58
202 142508 266
990
408
2039 6507 4002 18:24:07 18:52:39
1712
16815 18:54:56 6:58:17 PM
201 143217 384
935
603 2780 2028 73
11:12:15
10:10:49 10:17:30
401
71787
374
325
87
2017 4196 2679
11:08:00
255 112889 396
AM
997
610
2013 4082 2523 17:32:40 17:37:25
285
101006 17:44:07 5:48:56 PM
289
99608
1737 1217 70
277
369
314
17:52:04 18:10:10
1086
26507 18:54:38 6:58:10 PM
212 135786
192
185
96
Universitas Sumatera Utara
41
28
29
30
9:26
18:51
9:07
09/12/14
18:50
2053
2136
2518
2316
5593
5339
5707
5613
3996 8:52:11 9:23:55
4084 18:27:02 18:46:34
4584 8:30:56 8:53:02
4265 18:15:31 18:46:20
1904
1172
1326
1849
15119 9:28:45
24562 18:49:03
21709 9:01:10
15569 18:49:23
10/12/14 10:53
18:56
2195
2213
5873
6490
10:28:33 10:48:55
4205
4287 18:25:21 18:53:02
1222
23557
08/12/14
1661
11:06:43
17331 19:01:21
9:32:30 AM
6:50:25 PM
9:05:34 AM
6:52:50 PM
11:10:30
AM
7:05:45 PM
225
82
264
207
127941
351057
109040
139066
268
278
285
261
941
959
989
963
351
330
337
332
227
264
126814
109040
259
917
339
1492
2753
2139
1258
1400
1966
84
51
92
2077
1385
67
1863
1681
90
Universitas Sumatera Utara
42
Tabel 4: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam tidak sibuk
No
Tanggal
Jam
Bandwidth (Bps)
RataMin Maks
rata
1
11/11/14
2
12/11/14
13:54
20:33
12:47
2003
2118
2002
6404
4930
5754
4449
3732
4309
13:51
2036
4937
3054
3
13/11/14
4
5
12:20:10
20:36:12
12:48:10
21:00:50
13:31:00
12:47:10
21:01:01
12:58:10
21:30:32
14:01:20
1620
1489
600
1782
1820
17770
19333
47978
16154
15817
22:30:17
13:31:00
22:59:50
14:01:20
1773
1820
16236
15817
14/11/14
16/11/14
7
17/11/14
Throughput saat download
Through
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
put
12:51:21
12:49:11
130
221436
PM
21:19:50 9:21:52 PM
122
235956
13:45:30 1:46:37 PM
67
429652
21:34:35 9:38:30 PM
235
122497
14:02:03 2:08:20 PM
377
76357
11:05:44
PM
23:03:45
119
241905
14:02:03 2:08:20 PM
377
76357
11:05:44
PM
23:03:45
119
241905
14:00:00 2:02:15 PM
135
213235
10:34:46
22:31:18
208
138398
PM
23:08
14:05
2015
2321
6515
5942
4220
4549
22:30:17
13:31:00
22:59:50
13:59:00
1773
1680
16236
17135
22:39
2001
5322
3791
22:09:00
22:26:27
1047
27494
23:42
13:59
2000
2015
5862
5540
3209
4234
13:19:30
13:58:00
2310
12462
13:06:05
23:06
13:37
2025
2013
66518
6450
4587
2029
22:43:40
12:36:40
23:00:00
12:50:45
980
845
29374
34067
23:04:12
13:42:12
22:55
14:22
20:58
13:43
2032
2072
2005
2072
6148
6374
6465
6580
3955
4024
3840
4270
22:24:42
13:58:11
20:35:39
13:14:27
22:49:18
14:17:49
20:52:25
13:37:30
1476
1178
1006
1383
19503
24437
28615
20815
22:51:00
14:21:33
20:54:35
13:33:49
22:12
13:13
21:14
2001
2007
2000
6276
5832
6274
3913
3823
4217
21:42
2013
6028
4305
21:30:05
12:43:40
20:35:17
13:38:21
21:09:16
22:00:14
13:09:13
21:01:30
14:07:13
21:35:25
1809
1533
1573
1732
1569
15913
18778
18301
16620
18347
22:05:36
13:11:43
21:05:05
13:11:27
21:37:52
15/11/14
6
8
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
18/11/14
9
19/11/14
10
20/11/14
11
21/11/14
12
22/11/14
1:10:30 PM
11:05:40
PM
1:42:40 PM
10:53:30
PM
2:22:27 PM
8:56:38 PM
1:42:08 PM
10:08:30
PM
1:12:38 PM
9:06:56 PM
1:13:59 PM
9:41:03 PM
Delay
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
Min
Maks
Ratarata
284
272
266
277
914
994
994
1000
996
914
496
353
388
424
914
248
814
1436
1297
123
79
285
334
437
122
32
35
23
36
99
276
796
346
120
22
18
279
274
988
994
485
353
3283
2247
2418
1801
74
80
286
997
532
1825
12561
69
457
997
408
340
1654
2232
1650
1954
100
88
265
108629
344
267
88
28
327121
1028096
73
992
272
4519
2983
66
150
54
123
499
191911
533087
234038
57689
64
268
257
259
999
978
1000
967
318
369
458
372
1882
491
1430
1908
1557
392
1112
1530
83
80
78
80
174
55
111
152
191
165441
523394
259340
189386
150716
264
277
258
275
271
1000
998
969
994
985
410
374
348
487
381
2638
2061
2447
2322
2457
2315
1735
1773
2040
2072
88
84
72
88
84
Universitas Sumatera Utara
43
13
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
12:51
22:48
2004
2021
6172
6609
4016
4337
12:13:53
21:14:29
12:42:50
21:40:00
1737
1531
16573
18803
12:47:01
21:42:45
12:29
2009
6634
4284
12:12:32
12:27:00
868
33164
12:28:38
4178
4138
0:21:40
13:29:25
20:51:20
0:43:51
14:23:00
21:18:30
1331
3215
1630
21628
8954
17661
0:46:00
13:27:12
21:20:05
14:26
20:50
2001
2026
6250
6384
12:48:46
PM
9:46:20 PM
12:31:48
PM
12:47:25
AM
1:27:51 PM
9:21:45 PM
105
215
274159
133892
281
966
396
2495
2103
84
190
151509
266
997
502
1079
975
90
85
39
100
338667
738120
287867
334
264
59
969
992
972
567
357
164
1638
1499
92
534
131
25
Tabel 4: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam tidak sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
Jam
13:15
16
Throughput saat download
Through
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
2005
6160
4224
12:21:19
12:52:00
1841
15636
13:12:20
22:29:00
13:59:00
20:47:40
14:02:40
1560
1300
1410
1945
18453
22144
20416
14800
22:35:49
14:03:20
20:50:06
14:05:26
26/11/14
17
27/11/14
18
28/11/14
19
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
13:36
20:56
14:10
2050
2002
2004
5024
6468
6659
3884
4454
4648
22:03:00
13:37:20
20:24:10
13:30:15
22:11
2160
6145
4325
21:33:11
22:00:41
1650
17446
22:05:41
12:53
20:01
13:36
2003
2034
2000
6180
6191
6511
3889
4217
4719
12:16:58
19:21:59
12:47:10
19:47:55
1812
1556
15887
18500
12:53:13
19:53:19
22:25
13:54
2048
2005
6511
5644
4354
4033
21:46:50
13:19:23
22:13:27
13:46:00
1597
1597
18025
18025
22:17:19
13:48:35
23:37
2005
6258
4356
22:51:30
23:20:12
1722
16717
23:45:10
10:24:26
PM
1:53:59 PM
11:49:20
PM
21:57
2049
6474
4474
21:12:49
13:05:55
21:40:02
13:31:40
1633
1545
17628
18632
21:47:35
13:33:57
9:58:40 PM
1:42:55 PM
01/12/14
22
02/12/14
23
03/12/14
1:12:30 PM
10:36:00
PM
2:04:24 PM
8:55:10 PM
2:08:58 PM
10:09:12
PM
12:58:05
PM
7:59:40 PM
Delay
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
10
2878669
269
959
353
3366
2301
68
11
64
304
212
2616972
449792
94693
135786
264
259
261
982
1000
989
418
422
386
662
2848
3369
116
1979
2487
18
69
74
211
136430
271
987
364
2713
1976
73
292
381
98585
75556
294
271
254
994
997
999
395
358
330
2608
3436
4211
2190
2440
894
84
71
21
427
324
67416
88848
272
272
954
999
338
474
4312
3464
3243
2112
75
61
250
115147
263
988
319
2867
1720
60
665
538
43288
53507
262
250
949
1000
336
426
3229
2064
64
Universitas Sumatera Utara
44
24
25
26
6362
6388
3423
4556
22:15:17
13:07:59
22:38:42
13:32:10
1405
1451
20489
19839
22:40:42
13:36:57
22:58
13:07
2026
2026
6415
5618
4198
3912
22:07:56
12:57:13
22:57:04
13:30:10
2948
1977
9765
14561
22:42:27
13:02:58
22:04
14:26
2072
2135
5952
6304
3797
4221
22:06:38
13:39:00
22:25:35
14:11:20
1137
1940
25318
14838
22:32:23
13:21:43
22:32
13:07
21:52
13:44
2015
2614
2009
2005
6196
6366
6111
5905
3827
5045
4100
2970
21:57:23
12:35:30
21:16:15
13:01:40
22:27:15
12:54:12
21:45:25
13:36:00
1792
1122
1750
2060
16064
25657
16450
13974
22:31:18
12:57:02
21:47:47
13:40:00
22:44
2015
6349
4308
21:04:20
22:36:39
5539
5197
22:38:32
23:12
13:49
1999
2012
6581
6539
3545
3966
22:27:55
13:23:13
22:56:09
13:43:24
1694
2071
16993
13900
23:00:44
13:44:57
23:04
2015
6319
4307
22:29:31
23:01:00
1889
15239
23:11:27
05/12/14
06/12/14
07/12/14
28
08/12/14
30
2002
2014
04/12/14
27
29
22:51
14:45
09/12/14
10/12/14
10:49:44
PM
1:42:55 PM
10:57:04
PM
1:06:20 PM
10:36:32
PM
1:24:45 PM
10:36:28
PM
1:02:05 PM
9:51:38 PM
1:42:32 PM
10:43:15
PM
11:11:06
PM
1:48:23 PM
11:14:53
PM
542
358
53112
80410
261
250
999
1000
443
426
2595
2920
1280
1788
49
61
877
202
32824
142508
276
262
985
999
481
471
3581
3697
2216
2864
62
77
249
182
115609
158169
260
263
998
989
363
343
420
2950
34
2146
8
73
310
303
231
152
92860
95006
124618
189386
268
265
256
268
1000
986
1000
952
407
376
503
411
2429
2596
3452
364
1928
1900
2383
134
79
73
59
37
283
101720
274
999
465
3509
2603
74
622
206
46281
139741
260
261
999
992
424
487
3014
2502
2411
1895
80
76
206
139741
262
1000
435
3578
1905
53
Universitas Sumatera Utara
LAMPIRAN B
HASIL PENGUJIAN
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
1
11/11/14
2
12/11/14
3
13/11/14
4
14/11/14
5
15/11/14
6
16/11/14
7
17/11/14
8
18/11/14
9
19/11/14
10
20/11/14
11
21/11/14
Jam
10:43
15:03
8:02
16:48
10:33
13:22
10:19
15:20
9:32
14:32
13:34
17:26
9:07
15:59
8:58
15:25
11:24
19:00
10:19
18:00
9:41
17:58
Min
Maks
Ratarata
2094
2002
2002
2003
2043
2138
2027
2000
2525
2039
2069
2004
2011
2044
2024
2002
2000
2115
2037
2017
2003
2010
6538
6404
6057
7276
6304
5938
5368
6786
5950
6408
6184
6352
5863
6081
5132
6004
5983
5171
5483
6561
5734
5711
4630
4286
4762
4814
4272
4487
4118
4433
5328
4399
4276
4274
4139
4605
3935
4224
3887
4055
3800
4525
4283
4231
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
10:38
15:25:13
8:58:50
16:44:35
10:25:48
17:13:18
10:16:05
15:16:53
9:33:05
14:16:34
8:40:30
17:22:45
9:02:18
15:55:49
8:55:46
15:21:50
11:00:52
18:54:04
10:05:30
17:42:30
9:36:45
17:51:20
10:39
15:25:52
8:59:30
16:45:15
10:26:45
17:14:05
10:17
15:17:32
9:33:50
14:17:20
8:41:15
17:23:45
9:03:00
15:56:25
8:56:40
15:22:50
11:01:52
18:55:27
10:06:55
17:43:33
9:37:25
17:52:30
60
39
40
40
57
47
55
39
45
46
45
60
42
36
54
60
60
83
85
63
40
70
479778
738120
719667
719667
505030
612483
523394
738120
639704
625798
639704
479778
685397
799630
533087
479778
479778
346828
338667
456932
719667
411238
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
10:11:03
15:28:25
8:00:33
16:45:50
10:28:10
17:14:43
10:17:55
15:19:00
9:35:45
14:19:00
8:44:55
17:24:30
9:04:04
15:57:49
8:57:10
15:24:43
11:20:40
18:36:05
10:09:03
17:43:50
9:39:09
17:53:28
10:11:38
15:29:04
8:01:04
16:46:50
10:30:40
17:48.0
10:18
15:20:00
9:35:50
14:27:46
8:47:22
17:25:25
9:05:50
15:58:10
8:57:43
15:25:11
11:22:15
18:58:19
10:13:37
17:45:25
9:39:55
17:57:00
35 822477
39 738120
31 928603
60 479778
150 191911
185 155604
35 822477
60 479778
5 5757338
526
54728
147 195828
55 523394
106 271573
21 1370795
33 872324
28 1028096
95 303018
1334
21579
274 105061
95 303018
46 625798
212 135786
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
315
320
313
261
313
287
335
273
310
269
274
279
263
265
274
267
904
975
996
1000
989
909
976
1000
881
994
999
978
986
907
950
987
264
265
260
267
260
994
991
999
998
992
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
381
369
36
452
543 182
366
604
48
394 15703 9126
457
546 169
425
371 253
438
250
37
469 6914 3994
366 3379 1068
369 3846 2558
406
304 203
435
254
71
422
285
96
339
112
3
392
232
26
381
424
36
10
34
8
58
31
68
15
58
32
67
67
28
34
3
11
8
337
483
346
395
416
8
53
57
22
57
573
48
247 130
4123 2357
493 106
764 438
Universitas Sumatera Utara
34
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
12
22/11/14
13
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
16
26/11/14
17
27/11/14
18
28/11/14
19
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
01/12/14
22
02/12/14
23
03/12/14
24
04/12/14
25
05/12/14
Jam
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
8:29 2003 5961 4311 8:18:49 8:20:25
17:39 2025 4189 3042 17:30:23 17:31:35
9:43 2003 5651 3879 9:36:06 9:37:20
17:39 2001 5414 4010 17:35:27 17:36:07
10:06 2071 5832 4341 9:56:44 9:58:10
17:07 2202 5892 4404 17:03:30 17:04:35
9:12 3481 5144 4660 9:07:42 9:08:40
14:33 2001 6407 4167 14:34:39 14:35:55
9:03 2005 6255 4384 8:59:35 9:01:00
16:11 2004 6384 4149 14:06:50 16:07:50
9:34 1999 6653 4762 9:31:46 9:33:05
15:59 2087 5062 3897 15:56:21 15:57:10
10:24 2017 4939 3747 10:18:06 10:19:04
16:29 2010 6167 4334 16:25:46 16:26:30
8:55 2014 5962 4506 8:51:58 8:52:45
18:40 2006 5882 3967 18:35:36 18:36:22
9:35 2021 5547 4280 9:24:14 9:25:05
15:23 2059 5115 3982 15:12:03 15:14:25
10:31 2042 6008 4892 10:19:35 10:21:30
19:14 2019 5879 4228 18:13:56 18:15:05
10:03 2071 4922 3756 8:33:50 8:34:35
16:30 2004 5634 4270 17:20:57 17:21:47
8:36 16984 42520 35474 8:33:50 8:34:35
17:24 2016 6004 4391 17:20:57 17:21:47
9:23 2037 5828 4273 9:06:21 9:07:01
16:59 2027 6329 4317 16:55:43 16:56:35
10:38:24 10:39:37
10:48
19:20 2039 5249 3806 19:16:04 19:17:02
96
72
74
40
86
65
58
76
85
7260
79
49
58
44
47
46
51
142
115
69
45
50
45
50
40
52
73
58
299861
399815
389009
719667
334729
442872
496322
378772
338667
3965
364388
587483
496322
654243
612483
625798
564445
202723
250319
417198
639704
575734
639704
575734
719667
553590
394338
496322
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
8:21:23
17:32:48
9:38:52
17:37:06
9:59:50
17:05:50
9:09:20
14:36:35
9:01:50
16:08:38
9:33:52
15:57:50
10:20:39
16:27:15
8:53:15
18:37:35
9:32:30
15:20:43
10:22:35
19:21:37
8:35:03
17:22:30
8:35:03
17:22:30
9:07:54
16:57:13
10:41:00
19:17:59
8:23:26
17:37:39
9:41:43
17:38:28
10:02:10
17:06:20
9:09:49
14:39:22
9:02:28
16:08:56
9:35:50
15:58:35
10:23:35
16:27:50
8:53:50
18:38:26
9:33:39
15:23:04
10:25:01
19:22:18
8:35:35
17:23:25
8:35:47
17:23:25
9:20:37
16:57:59
10:45:22
19:18:09
123 234038
291
98923
171 168343
82 351057
140 205619
30 959556
29 992644
167 172375
38 757544
18 1599260
118 243955
45 639704
176 163561
35 822477
35 822477
51 564445
69 417198
141 204161
146 197169
41 702114
32 899584
55 523394
44 654243
55 523394
763
37728
46 625798
262 109873
10 2878669
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
267
312
267
261
269
263
260
288
269
263
257
285
265
264
260
268
264
260
274
258
268
267
263
267
262
259
264
268
996
984
986
994
968
995
999
991
994
999
994
892
983
993
978
997
995
977
995
963
998
997
997
998
978
994
996
990
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
401
830 386
533
729 520
369 3239 2325
416
502 203
418
701 348
413
245
41
363
271
52
580
186 104
352 4067 2532
483 4864 3346
324 15586 4889
390
136
46
437
467 277
361 2615 1838
378
279
57
445
494 295
342 2974 1641
346
990 438
428
78
42
343
217 107
421
821 389
465
117
14
415
227
30
449
485 211
459 1331 1182
376 3190 2230
572
794 651
430
460 113
47
71
73
40
50
17
19
56
62
69
31
34
59
70
20
60
55
44
54
49
47
12
13
44
89
70
82
25
Universitas Sumatera Utara
35
Tabel 1: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
26
06/12/14
27
07/12/14
28
08/12/14
29
09/12/14
30
10/12/14
Jam
Min
Maks
9:34
18:05
10:54
17:55
10:13
18:19
18:09
2110
2041
2129
2020
3005
2017
2005
5959
5518
6568
11:29
18:17
2014
2030
5109
5199
5129
5034
5194
5752
Ratarata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
9:29:20
17:58:52
10:04:36
18:13:12
10:04:36
18:13:12
11:19:10
18:13:57
4027 11:19:10
4174 18:13:57
4944
4121
4328
4316
4406
4262
4526
9:31:20
18:02:20
10:08:50
18:14:25
10:08:50
18:14:25
11:20:20
18:15:06
11:20:20
18:15:06
120
208
254
73
254
73
70
69
70
69
239889
138398
113333
394338
113333
394338
411238
417198
411238
417198
Throughput saat download
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
9:37:37
18:03:21
10:17:55
18:15:58
10:17:55
18:15:58
11:27:40
18:21:02
11:27:40
18:21:02
9:40:40
18:04:40
10:21:13
18:18:14
10:21:13
18:18:14
11:28:05
18:22:52
11:28:05
18:22:52
183 157304
79 364388
198 145387
136 211667
198 145387
136 211667
25 1151468
110 261697
25 1151468
110 261697
Delay
RataMin Maks
rata
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
273
286
274
255
251
269
268
271
260
262
538
410
243
309
215
472
1698
323
437
247
987
927
983
974
557
989
984
985
981
998
362
445
471
345
235
390
331
400
344
377
245
237
104
56
0
218
317
71
34
45
46
58
43
18
0
46
19
22
8
18
Universitas Sumatera Utara
36
Tabel 2: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider A pada jam tidak sibuk
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
1
11/11/14
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
12/11/14
13/11/14
14/11/14
15/11/14
16/11/14
17/11/14
18/11/14
19/11/14
20/11/14
21/11/14
22/11/14
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
Jam
Packet Loss
Durasi
Through
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Sent
Lost
Lost
(%)
12:07:24
132
218081
314
998
381
786
68
9
9:35:57
9:42:40
403
71431
272
996
400
4363
2692
62
719667
12:30:21
12:31:00
39
738120
316
1000
393
568
111
20
71
405446
20:42:30
20:42:53
23
1251595
320
970
423
484
127
26
12:33:50
105
274159
12:34:44
12:37:10
146
197169
319
988
456
410
274
67
21:49:15
55
523394
21:50:17
22:00:00
583
49377
283
808
423
57
7
12
13:12:28
13:13:15
47
612483
13:14:15
13:19:00
285
101006
318
970
400
258
87
31
4365
22:13:15
22:14:30
75
383823
22:15:15
22:18:08
173
166397
325
969
459
682
232
34
5101
4040
12:38:26
12:39:15
49
587483
12:40:05
12:41:02
57
505030
310
983
419
294
128
44
2001
5304
3986
21:54
21:55:00
45
639704
21:56:00
21:57:50
110
261697
316
968
441
719
212
29
12:53
3935
4907
4300
12:58:33
13:28:00
1767
16291
13:30:20
13:32:30
130
221436
270
996
351
2825
2115
75
23:11
2000
4954
2945
22:58:00
22:59:20
80
359834
22:05:35
22:08:00
145
198529
278
993
497
622
309
50
13:21
2015
5540
4207
13:14:12
13:14:52
40
719667
13:16:15
13:17:16
61
471913
268
442
301
89
1
1
22:41
2025
5232
4761
22:31:00
22:32:00
60
479778
22:43:07
22:43:45
38
757544
266
995
383
389
222
57
12:19
2085
5711
4441
12:15:05
12:15:50
45
639704
12:16:16
12:16:40
24
1199445
268
976
401
262
25
10
22:21
2032
5153
4084
22:17:32
22:18:24
52
553590
22:19:27
22:19:42
15
1919113
271
994
363
341
91
27
13:54
2007
5353
4101
13:51:29
13:52:25
56
514048
13:39:50
13:41:30
100
287867
266
997
438
921
267
29
21:13
2005
6465
3951
21:04:59
21:06:00
61
471913
21:08:41
21:11:37
176
163561
257
1000
409
2286
1414
62
13:54
2014
6580
4261
13:46:20
13:47:20
60
479778
13:49:54
13:52:02
128
224896
259
977
386
2580
1900
74
22:25
2001
6276
3827
22:16:27
22:18:13
106
271573
22:22:31
22:23:29
58
496322
264
1000
396
3400
2617
77
13:23
2001
6095
4187
13:16:26
13:17:09
43
669458
13:19:52
13:26:39
407
70729
270
999
409
2616
2011
77
21:29
2000
6607
4287
21:24:03
21:24:05
2
14393344
21:25:43
21:27:53
130
221436
258
996
365
3317
2042
62
14:21
2004
5097
3962
13:10:15
13:13:50
215
133892
13:17:20
13:30:06
766
37581
275
994
469
2678
2208
82
21:57
2000
6028
4508
21:49:59
21:51:49
110
261697
21:53:03
21:56:40
217
132658
271
985
372
3359
2535
75
13:17
2001
6172
3903
13:10:37
13:11:22
45
639704
13:13:50
13:14:30
40
719667
261
990
414
4008
3134
78
22:02
2007
6609
4188
21:53:57
21:56:30
153
188148
21:57:55
22:00:45
170
169333
271
984
496
607
416
69
12:43
2055
6023
4953
12:41:31
12:42:40
69
417198
12:53:48
12:54:50
62
464301
265
997
349
428
62
14
1:05
1999
5233
2504
22:20:40
23:39:30
4730
6086
23:53:30
24:30:00
2190
13145
13:17
2009
4595
3576
13:10:22
13:13:14
172
167364
13:14:20
13:16:23
123
234038
291
994
440
569
285
50
Min
Maks
12:53
3544
5257
21:33
2008
12:33
Rata-rata
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi (s)
4709
12:12:12
12:13:22
70
6157
4003
21:33:42
21:34:55
3478
5161
4706
12:28:41
20:46
2009
5001
4009
12:38
2091
5337
22:02
4143
6116
13:15
2100
22:24
Through
put
Delay
Mulai
Akhir
411238
12:05:12
73
394338
12:29:21
40
20:40
20:41:11
3932
12:32:05
5277
21:48:20
5927
4576
2055
5709
12:41
2044
22:05
Universitas Sumatera Utara
37
20:42
2434
4940
4450
20:37:10
Tanggal
16
26/11/14
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
27/11/14
28/11/14
29/11/14
30/11/14
01/12/14
02/12/14
03/12/14
04/12/14
05/12/14
Jam
08/12/14
09/12/14
2878669
20:39:00
20:40:00
60
479778
71
134
Delay
91
0
0
Packet Loss
Through
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Sent
Lost
Lost
(%)
12:14:40
45
639704
277
990
360
21:59:10
132
218081
259
977
419
251
39
16
328
204
62
13:29:32
13:29:50
18
1599260
264
982
387
443
34
8
237907
20:16:38
20:17:20
42
685397
259
1000
364
615
221
36
50
575734
13:15:48
13:17:04
76
378772
261
989
381
496
246
50
22:18:08
139
207098
22:19:46
22:25:39
353
81549
259
999
380
3641
2692
74
12:03:53
12:05:00
67
429652
12:06:21
12:07:18
57
505030
257
996
378
312
82
26
3467
22:02:08
22:03:43
95
303018
22:07:00
22:24:09
1029
27975
273
977
380
1976
1704
86
5833
4285
12:35:34
12:37:00
86
334729
12:38:25
6511
4259
22:31:34
22:33
86
334729
22:35:29
12:39:25
60
479778
264
999
403
906
533
59
22:47:55
746
38588
272
1000
359
5123
3844
75
2061
5644
4238
12:59:33
13:00:19
46
625798
13:01:57
13:02:46
49
587483
272
991
447
461
164
36
22:48
2005
4827
3595
22:35:22
22:36:21
59
487910
22:38:08
22:47:06
538
53507
267
998
410
1591
1226
77
13:47
2011
6147
4401
13:56:39
13:57:33
54
533087
13:58:48
13:59:58
70
411238
291
948
437
1244
1208
97
23:23
2011
6147
4471
23:08:09
23:10:22
133
216441
23:12:15
23:22:22
607
47425
262
1000
336
4699
2302
49
14:01
2064
5262
4488
13:56:39
13:57:33
54
533087
13:58:48
13:59:58
70
411238
252
981
357
371
147
40
23:23
2002
6386
3706
23:08:09
23:10:22
133
216441
23:12:15
23:22:22
607
47425
262
999
442
4474
2517
56
13:06
2003
23:11
2014
5901
4114
12:55:07
12:55:55
48
599723
12:57:03
13:04:29
446
64544
266
995
437
910
627
69
6415
4156
23:03:48
23:04:55
67
429652
23:05:35
23:08:23
168
171349
276
997
489
4326
2609
60
13:33
2026
5943
4085
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
263
988
390
243
80
33
21:53
2075
6333
4743
21:48:54
21:49:55
61
471913
21:50:30
21:51:50
80
359834
262
993
391
503
275
55
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
Maks
12:15
2031
5881
22:00
2020
5764
13:32
2223
20:18
Rata-rata
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi (s)
4621
12:12:38
12:13:25
47
4327
21:05:34
21:56:20
3046
5024
3977
13:27:43
13:28:30
2002
5888
4883
20:13:36
13:21
2004
6301
4950
22:27
2007
6266
12:08
2003
22:25
Through
put
515
Durasi
Min
Mulai
Akhir
612483
12:13:55
9451
21:56:58
47
612483
20:15:37
121
13:13:40
13:14:30
4276
22:15:49
5260
4086
2014
4909
12:40
2000
22:39
2008
13:03
06/12/14
07/12/14
10
Tabel 2: Hasil pengujian menggunakanprovider A pada jam tidak sibuk
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
20:37:20
22:53
2027
5146
4401
22:45:13
22:46:03
50
575734
22:52:16
22:53:30
74
389009
271
978
330
260
68
26
13:23
2010
6366
4231
13:27:42
13:28:35
53
543145
13:29:30
13:32:31
181
159042
264
996
373
3675
2169
59
21:04
2013
6111
4166
21:50:29
21:51:19
50
575734
21:51:03
21:55:22
259
111146
256
998
469
615
180
29
12:50
2105
5229
4246
12:44:32
12:45:23
51
564445
12:46:41
12:48:53
132
218081
257
986
412
479
167
35
21:56
2015
5862
4239
21:50:29
21:51:19
50
575734
21:51:03
21:55:22
259
111146
274
999
436
634
382
60
23:20
1999
6581
3889
13:09:14
13:09:58
44
654243
13:10:52
13:13:37
165
174465
267
991
460
477
223
47
Universitas Sumatera Utara
38
30
10/12/14
13:14
2012
5123
3684
22:06:32
22:07:22
50
575734
22:08
22:10:02
122
235956
260
999
413
3458
2581
74
13:09:14
13:09:58
44
654243
13:10:52
13:13:37
165
174465
267
991
460
477
223
47
22:06:32
22:07:22
50
575734
22:08:00
22:10:02
122
235956
273
994
435
444
212
48
Universitas Sumatera Utara
39
Tabel 3: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam sibuk
No
Tanggal
Jam
Bandwidth (Bps)
RataMin Maks
rata
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
2154
2003
2002
2126
6536
6404
6274
7197
10:03:00 10:27:00
4426
4317 15:03:00 15:25:00
4583 8:19:54 8:49:03
6005 15:56:40 16:26:00
1440
19991
2
11/11/14 10:31
14:28
8:57
12/11/14
16:29
1320
1749
1760
21808
16459
16356
3
13/11/14 11:05
2030
6664
4794
10:36:05 10:57:20
1275
22578
14:21:39 14:50:00
1701
16923
1
4
5
14/11/14 11:22
14:20
2014
2000
6014
6662
10:36:05 10:57:20
3740
4269 14:21:39 14:50:00
1275
22578
1701
16923
15/11/14 10:18
2000
6675
4386
9:42:20 10:00:00
1060
27157
15:31:00 15:59:00
1680
17135
Throughput saat download
Delay
Through
RataMulai
Akhir
Durasi
Min Maks
rata
put
10:32:00
10:30:00
120 239889 287
AM
998
363
15:30:10 3:39:10 PM
540
53309 278
997
503
8:53:49 8:56:30 AM
161 178799 271
998
382
16:27:07 4:27:35 PM
28 1028096 269
284
326
11:01:30
10:58:58
152 189386 276
AM
989
415
14:54:20 2:55:35 PM
75 383823
11:01:30
AM
10:58:58
152 189386 265
951
369
14:54:20 2:55:35 PM
75 383823 273 1000
474
10:11:00
AM
10:05:15
345
83440 268
996
501
15:00:00 3:02:15 PM
135 213235
258
998
413
267
998
415
9:50:27 9:51:13 AM
46 625798 261
988
531
14:39:15 2:40:49 PM
94 306241 262
947
414
9:43:50 9:49:30 AM
340
84667 267
991
337
15:11:00 3:14:40 PM
220 130849 279
988
507
8
9:03
17:19
9:52
17/11/14
16:42
9:59
18/11/14
15:14
2011
2004
2009
2003
1999
2002
6486
6352
6229
6081
6299
5174
4554
4136
4113 9:16:46 9:47:50
4208 16:02:40 16:32:30
4558 9:01:13 9:29:30
3674 14:36:18 15:07:17
1864
1790
1697
1859
15444
16082
16963
15485
9
19/11/14
16:40
2016
6446
4548 18:03:32 18:33:09
1777
16200 18:36:06
10
20/11/14
9:58
17:34
2000
2017
6385
6561
8:30:27 9:00:04
3902
4450 16:52:56 17:19:35
1777
16200
1599
11:33:49
18003 17:27:15
2000
2010
2003
2022
2003
2001
6329
5848
5961
5998
5651
6289
9:49:03 10:13:20
3997
4189 18:06:46 18:35:20
4303 8:36:04 9:02:13
3546 17:44:51 18:15:03
3820 8:53:07 9:18:28
4013 17:45:15 18:12:18
1457
19758
13
21/11/14 10:27
18:48
9:07
22/11/14
18:28
9:28
23/11/14
18:19
1714
1569
1812
1521
1623
16795
18347
15887
18926
17737
14
24/11/14
2009
6524
4301
10:10:35 10:36:00
1525
18877
6
7
11
12
16/11/14
11:32
10:23:37
18:42:32
9:04:36
18:21:10
9:24:30
18:16:50
11:29:30
6:37:09 PM
11:42:08
AM
5:31:27 PM
10:25:34
AM
6:46:35 PM
9:05:35 AM
6:25:47 PM
9:27:10 AM
6:17:25 PM
11:35:00
AM
63
456932
268
997
353
499
252
57689
114233
268
264
999
998
401
374
117
143
59
277
160
35
246040
201306
487910
103923
179917
822477
267
260
267
274
269
261
998
993
996
996
904
996
482
406
404
450
336
449
330
87232
269
1000
480
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
366
181
49
554
3815
1917
243
2426
1693
44
64
88
2521
1635
65
462
311
67
3361
1903
57
2250
1638
73
1088
1558
2228
2389
3844
2249
2504
425
1130
2079
2130
1776
2112
1938
39
73
93
89
46
94
77
3734
2748
74
2597
2083
80
3202
2132
67
3632
3016
3613
2368
2842
2865
2226
3002
1834
2173
79
74
83
77
76
5763
2320
40
Universitas Sumatera Utara
40
15
25/11/14
17:54
9:50
2002
2023
5892
6246
4005 17:12:15 17:47:15
3699 9:17:38 9:46:00
15:29:25 16:23:00
2100
1702
3215
13708 17:44:40
16913 9:49:05
8954 14:27:12
5:48:23 PM
9:51:10 AM
2:27:51 PM
223
125
39
129088
230294
738120
282
272
272
973
947
994
563
539
350
2478
1985
3953
2068
1915
2986
83
96
76
Tabel 3: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam sibuk (lanjutan)
No
Tanggal
16
26/11/14
17
18
Jam
8:40
15:25
9:24
27/11/14
16:41
19
28/11/14 11:37
16:20
9:45
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
01/12/14 11:03
19:00
22
02/12/14 10:11
17:33
9:24
03/12/14
14:45
23
9:20
18:21
24
04/12/14 10:21
16:48
25
05/12/14
20:00
26
27
06/12/14 10:10
17:45
18:53
07/12/14
Bandwidth (Bps)
Throughput saat upload
Throughput saat download
Delay
Packet Loss
Durasi
Through
Through
RataRataLost
Mulai
Akhir
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
Min Maks
Min Maks
Sent Lost
rata
rata
(%)
(s)
put
put
2041 6255 4348 8:00:55 8:31:10
1816
15852 8:37:55 8:39:37 AM
102 282222 263
999
517 2717 2094 77
2004 6394 4026 14:47:39 15:05:55
1096
26265 15:11:50 3:13:05 PM
75 383823 257
994
320 2301 1352 59
1999 6653 4782 8:45:22 9:16:16
1854
15527 9:20:30 9:22:10 AM
100 287867 285
991
499 15004 4627 31
2005 5062 3710 16:06:30 16:37:00
1830
15730 16:39:29 4:40:35 PM
66 436162 265
998
489 2589 2265 87
11:35:50
10:53:59 11:23:11
1752
16431
4598 3419 74
AM
2004 6241 3937
11:32:08
222 129670 264
993
356
2010 6167 4209 13:49:15 16:12:48
8613
3342 16:14:52 4:19:10 PM
258 111576 276
983
406 2112 1603 76
2013 5962 4276 8:58:30 9:30:00
1890
15231 9:47:12 9:51:23 AM
251 114688
2915 2230 77
17:21:59 17:47:55
1556
18500 18:53:19 6:59:40 PM
381
75556 275
995
360
2103 5547 4378 8:50:29 9:10:38
1209
23810 9:14:21 9:18:30 AM
249 115609 260
997
400 2059 1422 69
1999 6141 4174 17:49:02 18:10:38
1296
22212 18:12:23 6:16:55 PM
252 114233 264
995
395 5024 3441 68
11:02:13
10:41:43 10:55:25
822
35020
1964 1139 58
AM
1999 6138 4144
10:57:46
267 107815 263
969
352
2019 5741 4210 18:20:34 18:52:50
1936
14869 18:55:33 6:58:54 PM
201 143217 278
979
343 2536 1924 76
10:54:35
10:12:18 10:45:30
1992
14451
352
110
31
AM
2071 5025 4014
10:49:23
312
92265 281
994
373
17848 42800 34704 16:49:00 17:19:20
1820
15817 17:31:30 5:35:30 PM
240 119945 283
51
1
2
993
434
15688 51752 35034 8:49:05 9:15:40
1595
18048 9:20:03 9:28:23 AM
500
57573
2463 1693 69
2014 6338 4556 14:05:55 14:31:40
1545
18632 14:33:57 2:42:55 PM
538
53507 262
991
363 2920 1788 61
10:19:58
9:35:52 10:04:20
1708
16854
4824 3211 67
AM
2016 6356 4357
10:10:58
540
53309 279
994
382
2049 6329 4271 16:12:17 16:39:23
1626
17704 16:41:40 4:46:01 PM
261 110294
2528 1933 76
11:06:20
10:57:13 11:30:10
1977
14561
AM
11:02:58
202 142508 266
990
408
2039 6507 4002 18:24:07 18:52:39
1712
16815 18:54:56 6:58:17 PM
201 143217 384
935
603 2780 2028 73
11:12:15
10:10:49 10:17:30
401
71787
374
325
87
2017 4196 2679
11:08:00
255 112889 396
AM
997
610
2013 4082 2523 17:32:40 17:37:25
285
101006 17:44:07 5:48:56 PM
289
99608
1737 1217 70
277
369
314
17:52:04 18:10:10
1086
26507 18:54:38 6:58:10 PM
212 135786
192
185
96
Universitas Sumatera Utara
41
28
29
30
9:26
18:51
9:07
09/12/14
18:50
2053
2136
2518
2316
5593
5339
5707
5613
3996 8:52:11 9:23:55
4084 18:27:02 18:46:34
4584 8:30:56 8:53:02
4265 18:15:31 18:46:20
1904
1172
1326
1849
15119 9:28:45
24562 18:49:03
21709 9:01:10
15569 18:49:23
10/12/14 10:53
18:56
2195
2213
5873
6490
10:28:33 10:48:55
4205
4287 18:25:21 18:53:02
1222
23557
08/12/14
1661
11:06:43
17331 19:01:21
9:32:30 AM
6:50:25 PM
9:05:34 AM
6:52:50 PM
11:10:30
AM
7:05:45 PM
225
82
264
207
127941
351057
109040
139066
268
278
285
261
941
959
989
963
351
330
337
332
227
264
126814
109040
259
917
339
1492
2753
2139
1258
1400
1966
84
51
92
2077
1385
67
1863
1681
90
Universitas Sumatera Utara
42
Tabel 4: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam tidak sibuk
No
Tanggal
Jam
Bandwidth (Bps)
RataMin Maks
rata
1
11/11/14
2
12/11/14
13:54
20:33
12:47
2003
2118
2002
6404
4930
5754
4449
3732
4309
13:51
2036
4937
3054
3
13/11/14
4
5
12:20:10
20:36:12
12:48:10
21:00:50
13:31:00
12:47:10
21:01:01
12:58:10
21:30:32
14:01:20
1620
1489
600
1782
1820
17770
19333
47978
16154
15817
22:30:17
13:31:00
22:59:50
14:01:20
1773
1820
16236
15817
14/11/14
16/11/14
7
17/11/14
Throughput saat download
Through
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
put
12:51:21
12:49:11
130
221436
PM
21:19:50 9:21:52 PM
122
235956
13:45:30 1:46:37 PM
67
429652
21:34:35 9:38:30 PM
235
122497
14:02:03 2:08:20 PM
377
76357
11:05:44
PM
23:03:45
119
241905
14:02:03 2:08:20 PM
377
76357
11:05:44
PM
23:03:45
119
241905
14:00:00 2:02:15 PM
135
213235
10:34:46
22:31:18
208
138398
PM
23:08
14:05
2015
2321
6515
5942
4220
4549
22:30:17
13:31:00
22:59:50
13:59:00
1773
1680
16236
17135
22:39
2001
5322
3791
22:09:00
22:26:27
1047
27494
23:42
13:59
2000
2015
5862
5540
3209
4234
13:19:30
13:58:00
2310
12462
13:06:05
23:06
13:37
2025
2013
66518
6450
4587
2029
22:43:40
12:36:40
23:00:00
12:50:45
980
845
29374
34067
23:04:12
13:42:12
22:55
14:22
20:58
13:43
2032
2072
2005
2072
6148
6374
6465
6580
3955
4024
3840
4270
22:24:42
13:58:11
20:35:39
13:14:27
22:49:18
14:17:49
20:52:25
13:37:30
1476
1178
1006
1383
19503
24437
28615
20815
22:51:00
14:21:33
20:54:35
13:33:49
22:12
13:13
21:14
2001
2007
2000
6276
5832
6274
3913
3823
4217
21:42
2013
6028
4305
21:30:05
12:43:40
20:35:17
13:38:21
21:09:16
22:00:14
13:09:13
21:01:30
14:07:13
21:35:25
1809
1533
1573
1732
1569
15913
18778
18301
16620
18347
22:05:36
13:11:43
21:05:05
13:11:27
21:37:52
15/11/14
6
8
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
18/11/14
9
19/11/14
10
20/11/14
11
21/11/14
12
22/11/14
1:10:30 PM
11:05:40
PM
1:42:40 PM
10:53:30
PM
2:22:27 PM
8:56:38 PM
1:42:08 PM
10:08:30
PM
1:12:38 PM
9:06:56 PM
1:13:59 PM
9:41:03 PM
Delay
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
Min
Maks
Ratarata
284
272
266
277
914
994
994
1000
996
914
496
353
388
424
914
248
814
1436
1297
123
79
285
334
437
122
32
35
23
36
99
276
796
346
120
22
18
279
274
988
994
485
353
3283
2247
2418
1801
74
80
286
997
532
1825
12561
69
457
997
408
340
1654
2232
1650
1954
100
88
265
108629
344
267
88
28
327121
1028096
73
992
272
4519
2983
66
150
54
123
499
191911
533087
234038
57689
64
268
257
259
999
978
1000
967
318
369
458
372
1882
491
1430
1908
1557
392
1112
1530
83
80
78
80
174
55
111
152
191
165441
523394
259340
189386
150716
264
277
258
275
271
1000
998
969
994
985
410
374
348
487
381
2638
2061
2447
2322
2457
2315
1735
1773
2040
2072
88
84
72
88
84
Universitas Sumatera Utara
43
13
23/11/14
14
24/11/14
15
25/11/14
12:51
22:48
2004
2021
6172
6609
4016
4337
12:13:53
21:14:29
12:42:50
21:40:00
1737
1531
16573
18803
12:47:01
21:42:45
12:29
2009
6634
4284
12:12:32
12:27:00
868
33164
12:28:38
4178
4138
0:21:40
13:29:25
20:51:20
0:43:51
14:23:00
21:18:30
1331
3215
1630
21628
8954
17661
0:46:00
13:27:12
21:20:05
14:26
20:50
2001
2026
6250
6384
12:48:46
PM
9:46:20 PM
12:31:48
PM
12:47:25
AM
1:27:51 PM
9:21:45 PM
105
215
274159
133892
281
966
396
2495
2103
84
190
151509
266
997
502
1079
975
90
85
39
100
338667
738120
287867
334
264
59
969
992
972
567
357
164
1638
1499
92
534
131
25
Tabel 4: Hasil pengujian menggunakan provider B pada jam tidak sibuk (lanjutan)
Bandwidth (Bps)
No
Tanggal
Jam
13:15
16
Throughput saat download
Through
Mulai
Akhir
Durasi
put
Min
Maks
Ratarata
2005
6160
4224
12:21:19
12:52:00
1841
15636
13:12:20
22:29:00
13:59:00
20:47:40
14:02:40
1560
1300
1410
1945
18453
22144
20416
14800
22:35:49
14:03:20
20:50:06
14:05:26
26/11/14
17
27/11/14
18
28/11/14
19
29/11/14
20
30/11/14
21
Throughput saat upload
Durasi Through
Mulai
Akhir
(s)
put
13:36
20:56
14:10
2050
2002
2004
5024
6468
6659
3884
4454
4648
22:03:00
13:37:20
20:24:10
13:30:15
22:11
2160
6145
4325
21:33:11
22:00:41
1650
17446
22:05:41
12:53
20:01
13:36
2003
2034
2000
6180
6191
6511
3889
4217
4719
12:16:58
19:21:59
12:47:10
19:47:55
1812
1556
15887
18500
12:53:13
19:53:19
22:25
13:54
2048
2005
6511
5644
4354
4033
21:46:50
13:19:23
22:13:27
13:46:00
1597
1597
18025
18025
22:17:19
13:48:35
23:37
2005
6258
4356
22:51:30
23:20:12
1722
16717
23:45:10
10:24:26
PM
1:53:59 PM
11:49:20
PM
21:57
2049
6474
4474
21:12:49
13:05:55
21:40:02
13:31:40
1633
1545
17628
18632
21:47:35
13:33:57
9:58:40 PM
1:42:55 PM
01/12/14
22
02/12/14
23
03/12/14
1:12:30 PM
10:36:00
PM
2:04:24 PM
8:55:10 PM
2:08:58 PM
10:09:12
PM
12:58:05
PM
7:59:40 PM
Delay
Min
Maks
Ratarata
Packet Loss
Lost
Sent Lost
(%)
10
2878669
269
959
353
3366
2301
68
11
64
304
212
2616972
449792
94693
135786
264
259
261
982
1000
989
418
422
386
662
2848
3369
116
1979
2487
18
69
74
211
136430
271
987
364
2713
1976
73
292
381
98585
75556
294
271
254
994
997
999
395
358
330
2608
3436
4211
2190
2440
894
84
71
21
427
324
67416
88848
272
272
954
999
338
474
4312
3464
3243
2112
75
61
250
115147
263
988
319
2867
1720
60
665
538
43288
53507
262
250
949
1000
336
426
3229
2064
64
Universitas Sumatera Utara
44
24
25
26
6362
6388
3423
4556
22:15:17
13:07:59
22:38:42
13:32:10
1405
1451
20489
19839
22:40:42
13:36:57
22:58
13:07
2026
2026
6415
5618
4198
3912
22:07:56
12:57:13
22:57:04
13:30:10
2948
1977
9765
14561
22:42:27
13:02:58
22:04
14:26
2072
2135
5952
6304
3797
4221
22:06:38
13:39:00
22:25:35
14:11:20
1137
1940
25318
14838
22:32:23
13:21:43
22:32
13:07
21:52
13:44
2015
2614
2009
2005
6196
6366
6111
5905
3827
5045
4100
2970
21:57:23
12:35:30
21:16:15
13:01:40
22:27:15
12:54:12
21:45:25
13:36:00
1792
1122
1750
2060
16064
25657
16450
13974
22:31:18
12:57:02
21:47:47
13:40:00
22:44
2015
6349
4308
21:04:20
22:36:39
5539
5197
22:38:32
23:12
13:49
1999
2012
6581
6539
3545
3966
22:27:55
13:23:13
22:56:09
13:43:24
1694
2071
16993
13900
23:00:44
13:44:57
23:04
2015
6319
4307
22:29:31
23:01:00
1889
15239
23:11:27
05/12/14
06/12/14
07/12/14
28
08/12/14
30
2002
2014
04/12/14
27
29
22:51
14:45
09/12/14
10/12/14
10:49:44
PM
1:42:55 PM
10:57:04
PM
1:06:20 PM
10:36:32
PM
1:24:45 PM
10:36:28
PM
1:02:05 PM
9:51:38 PM
1:42:32 PM
10:43:15
PM
11:11:06
PM
1:48:23 PM
11:14:53
PM
542
358
53112
80410
261
250
999
1000
443
426
2595
2920
1280
1788
49
61
877
202
32824
142508
276
262
985
999
481
471
3581
3697
2216
2864
62
77
249
182
115609
158169
260
263
998
989
363
343
420
2950
34
2146
8
73
310
303
231
152
92860
95006
124618
189386
268
265
256
268
1000
986
1000
952
407
376
503
411
2429
2596
3452
364
1928
1900
2383
134
79
73
59
37
283
101720
274
999
465
3509
2603
74
622
206
46281
139741
260
261
999
992
424
487
3014
2502
2411
1895
80
76
206
139741
262
1000
435
3578
1905
53
Universitas Sumatera Utara