Pengaruh kualitas teknologi informasi terhadap sistem e-filing dan implikasinya terhadap biaya kepatuhan : (survei pada wajib pajak badan terdaftar di KPP Madya Bandung)
147
!
"# #
$
%
&
% #
#
# #
+
' #
%
#' ()
*'
, -+
'
'
,'
('
'
$
0!
0
!
$ . / %%
0!
0
0
2 3
#
1
% #
,++(
,++)
,++
,+ (
!
"
#
$%
#
#&'
!
*
" # #% "
( # )
* ) %
%
#
(+ ,* )
# ",#,(
,& ( %
" #% #" *% - ",#,(
#
- % - ,(+ %
# ,# -
- - #
#
"
* ).
#
/0012034
5
/106
( #
!
"
#
( # #
) *
+#
$ %&
'
, #
-
# *
.
/
% - , (
# # ##
0
# ) *
+#
, #
1
#2 ( # #
(
) *
3 -
+#
( # #
+
0
+
) *
-
, #
(
'
4
(
+#
#
, #
(
#
+ 4
1556
v
'
7 ,
!
(
8 - 9
%
(
:
22
#
'
1
( # #
) *
+#
$) ,+9 &
;
+
6 !
2
%5 !
#2
!
!
)
!
%% !
-
%1
0
<
+
!
)
+
, 2#
!
+
!
#
#
%3 9
# *
%4
.
# *
%7
%8
# *
.
vi
#
, #
%:
.
.4
1556
#
2
# *
#
!
=
,
vii
15%3
/ 1%%56%4:
!
%
"
!
"
!
"
&
#
#
$
#
'
#
%
&
%
( )
"
&&
&
&&
"
viii
!
&
*
+
!
*
,
+
-
!
%
.
! "
&&
"&
&&
&
&&
%
&
& "
&&
%
&
%
, /
-
0
/
& /
1 " 0
#
&
*
+
%
1 " 0
,
"
"
&&
/
&
0
0 /
,
1 " 0
!
!
!%
"
!%
2 0&
!,
!,
34
!
&
!
5
30
&
!
/
4
%
$
7
,
%
4
%
5
%!
%
7 6
%
7
%
7
&0
,
6
%!
%,
4
%,
/
/
0
%%-
&0
ix
,
-
/
&
0
&
0
%
5
%
,#
5
&
,#
$
-
2 0&
-!
!
-!
2
!
8
4
!
7
-!
34
"
--
0&
!
$
!
7
$
-
!
2
7 6
!
2
7
$
5
!
$
4
0
5
&
0
6
4
"
&&
*9+
!
$
5
0
6
4 /
!
$
5
0
6
4
! ! $
6
*:+
1 " 0
##
! !
"
&&
&
0
#-
/
! ! <
!
,
*;+
/
0
1 " 0
#
4
!
"
&&
&
/
#-
!
%
"
%
/
/
0
1 " 0
,
0
!
x
xi
!
"
#
$
!
"
#
$
%
"
&
$
'
$
**
*!
# ++,
1# ) 1
1 * 1
** *
45'
&+
3
) " #
&
#
&'(&
- .+
+ **+* +
1 #1* 21
!
*
# ++
.
1#
,
., )
# )
+1# )
! .
"
+
$
+*
"
7
9
;
.
,
<
< =
.
6.#
2 5
## /
,>
:,
.)
4
"
) )
* 9
!
# ++
,
1.
1 1.
. $
! .. ( @
!
) (*'+&,/*+*0/&0/0+
! .
- + # 71 , .
* 8 *0 / 45'
( .
"
' .
$
)
/
'
"
$ * !
1
9
(
%
.
" ,1
.
0# 1 * 2,
122
#
7;
* (, * 3'45-*
.
$
5 $
- .+ * +* +
1#
1
? .
* 8 * &0 45'
$
@
1
#
'
> -
A ;
6
C !
* B
4
A "
( ?
-
6
! ?
.
/
.
7 6
0
?
A ;
.
"
$
* *
0 $5" D
7
, .
, >
5
@
'
.#
"
,
?
(5";6(
; .
# ++
/&11
1
0/1
1
$
#
- .+
+
1
1)
.
* +* +**+
,1
* 8 * & 45
1
*
#* '
.
1
1
5.
1> . $ 4 # #
; ;
- $
6.# - 6=
* 7
./
8 * 9+, 7 * &*
E < =
4
"
'
"$
> F
( ? * * 6=
(" ##
)
0# * && 1&/
**
$
== 1 #
@
:
+
.
.
+
+
**
" 67 1H -
92;
0001#
**
*
( !
" ,
/
& +
"
@
4
@
, .
#
/
6=
G
1
)
- .+
** 3
.
"
=
# )
.
G
;
*
# ++.
6
+
- .+
*
$ #* !
# ++
.1 , . 1# ) 1
* 8 * * 45'
3
?)
6
!
"
6D
.
45'
# < =
!
/
#
.#
*
123
-
$
/
.
4 )
?#
.
-
"7 !
1# ) 1- # 1
)
#
" .
6,, # <
,
7
9
9
" #
$ =
..
#
!G ;6
;(
#)
9
9
9
,
$ $ B
"
!
%
!
:
19
1
- 9
0
0 0
#
"
- G5"5
.
$
=1
%
0
%
.
#
1
# ++
1#
/
6
*
$
6= 5
@
4
&
.
*>
; )
*
!
.
1 .
45'
! $2#=
.
0C
.
< =
<
#
9 .
?
$
#
- .+
7
+
! .
+* / &+# ) 1 #
1
*0
* 8
/
2 "
$
=
%
5.
"
.#
.
5
=
"
,
-
71,
/
$
$
? 1
** 1* 0
5$
5
4
3,,
2
. 5
G
! ,,
##
7#
A: B
5. . @ %
2
!
5D
9
=
**
5
0
C
.#
$
-
3, 6 -
:
7G
0 @
=C
'
< =
&
?#
!
124
' .
!
9$
!
4
!
' - @
=
%
#
/
**
@
:#
?
/
!
6
)
B 4
$
1(
7
"
> .
#
D =
>
(
!
!
(
- G
# 7
? 6/
5 . ?
'
!
/
5
$
$ - .
6
125
6
" .
!
#
+ 1,
/
!
1# .
<
% $
** G -
/
-
6.#
,8
5 .-
0
4
- .+
+
/+
#
* $
9
$
&
/
.
>
* !
" B " C
#
.
.
"
0
$
- 9
"
/
/
.
.
-
(
!
"
C.
6 1 /+ ! +
.#
"
3
6 -
< =
(
$ "
B 1G
!
"
*
) .
6.#
# ++
#I
.#
00
(
$
(
4
0 0
&
> .
-
5, 7
< =
#
A"
C.
0
$?
!
?! > .
6 1 + !+
.
" 6
!
#
B " C
#
(
* 2*
&* (+ >
, 4
,, -
"
1#
"
,,
, -
#
1
$
2&//
$
H
, -
!
H -
-
,'
$
0
* - .$
64
4'
H
"
.
(
$-(
" ,
6"
7
7#
67#
--
$
@
"
, 8
A5 , .
@
*
/
8
$-
&*
" "
# ++
!
* 1
13
* /0 45'
>
"
)
)
G >
; .
,
-
)
(
!
>
;
2B *C ## 2&&01
/
# " E
- .
)
9 ,,
4
- 19
!
1 * !
##
;$
5 =
<
7
#
" ,
67 .
- = ;
/
0 0 *
-, 7
( < =
, > =
;
"
. *2 & > H
?
"
,
- @
.
:
"
$ 9
G -
;
-
*
@
*
:
'
0
<
$
%
*
5.
"
%
, %
)F
'
,
"
.
!
2
;
" #
#
** %
$
# )
# ++
1
1
)
1#
.
**8 * * 45'
> # .
"
1
.
' .
.#
"9
7 ;
,"
" .
"
'
#
1
45'
"
9
# ++
6,
?
.4
, .
:
5
0#
< =
,
+1 , .
*
. , 1
*2
!
/ 5.# .
6 - G
"
#
67#
- /
0
)
0# >
,
#
$
. ,
# ++
1 1
1
*
.# - +
15 1 .
. ;
G
+ .
;
0#
"
!
+
1;
;
+
5
- .+
.1
!
+
"
.
;
* +**+
;
#)
+ 0 &&&2 /+
> = .
8
;) .
#
5 ,
127
? 5
' .
+ 0 */+.
. , 1
/ #
* 8* /&
6
?
2
#* !
# 1
&* 45'
0
!
( *
$ - . ".
.
9
*$ '< =
/
ttabel pada taraf signifikan. Dimana t tabel untuk α =
0,05 sebesar 1,96.
!
!
"
119
120
!
#
!
$%
&
$%
(
)
'
!
!
"
&
'
"
121
$%
$%
$%
*
!
(
)
!
!
!
!
*
!
(
)
!
!
!
#
'
&
#
"
$%
"
&
(
)*
+#,
'
(
)
" #
'
(
*+
,
'
%!"
(
)
'
.
!
#
(
!
"
)
'
,
0 %1
$
%&
'
(
)
&!" /
1
2
!" 2
(
3
)
)
4
)'( *
(
,
'
(
)+*
),*
.
'
'
-
(
&!"
(
(
.
(
/
'
($!
'
(
(
'
(
)
5
($
(
(
.
!"
5
!"
#
$
%%& !
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
5
Page 1
)
4
!" 6
'
(
4
!"
/
'
(
5
($
6
*(-&&8(3"8
(
!" #
)
4
6
($
5
!"
5
'
/
0 !" #
(
7
3
($
(
($
5
<
!
63(
($
<
<
$
!
5
0 !"
'
(
4
!
,
.
$
#
#
92"
0
!"
)
'
(
4
:
0
2
. 4
'
(
!"
6
$
3
,
(
+
$
%%&!"
4
$4
-
4
+
-
"
4
'
!" (
4
4
#
(
$
((
"
4
2
(
(
"
!" #
'
"
(( #
'
)
#
$
!"
;
4
"
4
4
$
1 %!" $
(
4
(
4
$
, 4
4
,
"
)
4
4
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 2
#
4
$
1 %!
5
4
4
.
" ;
4
4
'
(( #
"
!
(
>, 4
4
"
" ;
'
4
, 4
#"
4
(
4
-4
4
-
(( #
"
"
!
!
4
4
(
!?"
)
5
4
5
4
4
" 6
"
4
-)
#. #/
' # #$
&
+#/ 1#/ 2 ! &
"
$
4
&+#/0 #
4
"
4
#
.=
!" #
-
!
4
3
>
!
!
4
!
4
!
?"
)
4
'
0!
)
4
! ,
$
#
!
5
@
4
"
3
A
A
3
!
!
6 4
!
4
9"
/
4
!
5
"
0!
!
)
4
"
!
!
"
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
)
)
)
#
!
4
Page 3
"
" +
" ,
0" -
6 4
!
(
!
# 4
!
0 !
$
7 (
6
$#
5
" -
($
(
($
" '
5
!
" (
"
5
!
!
63(
4
($
5
#
0!
"
%&%
!
4
?"
#
4
@
A
A
( #
#
$
#
%
"
#"
&
)
% %!
#
!
,
@(
>
#
-
'
)
6 4
)
'
(
?"
4
"
%&%!
"
. ,
($!
*
-
"
!
$
'
(
)
)
"
6
. (
'
$.#
(
)
4
*
$.#
'
.
>#
)
!" .
3
'
)
5
00 !
(
(
*
$.#!
4
($!
)
($
4
+
?"
)
)
. -
"
#
5
8
4
(
)
" .
4
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
#
"3
5
Page 4
>
"
?"
%
2-
!
"
)
4
4
>$
, 4
$
4
5) ! .& 1#/
C
4
4
& !1& &/&6
#/
"
4
4
4
4
;
"
/
.
4
'
4
(
#
A
A 3" .
.4
4
?"
7
6
A
1
7 "
)
(
(
"
#
4
4
4
#
6
+
4
4"
4
"$
#6"
.
,
1
!
+
4
4
)
>
4
#
(
4
"
-
0
"
(/ !" (
234"
+
#
9
3
@
B&!
>
@
'
)
)
.
+
"
%% !
'
#
4
(
(
4
($
(
4
"6
'
4
5
" #
"
63(
.
?"
((
4
6
)
4
.
,
4
D
E
($
)
)
4
4
"
4
"
)
"
2
B B!
)
.
+
4
4
-
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
0
"
Page 5
(/ !
" " 6 4
,
A
4)
0
"
1 &!
=
(/
5
"
-
0
"
,
4
5
E!"
2
5 " $
-
0
"
)
4
E!"
+
?"
#
,
#
A
=
4
1 !
(
(/ !
+
"
)
!
-
!" (
"
0
)
-
4
(/ !
4
4
"
+
)
+
)
!
B E
" 2
)
!
5
!"
4
4
"
5
5
-
+
,
5
4
4
+
4
"
#
A
4
0" "
"
F
7)
2# 6
&/&6
&
#2# #/
#/
1#/
(
'
(( #
!
#
2
2
A
" " (
)
"
5
+
"
4
(
"
,
F
#
'
)
(( #
!
#
4
"2
(
+
-4
'
(( #
4
"
4
" "(
"
)
((
5
4
)
)
#
#
"
7
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
1B
5
00
E
)
E!
E" 2
Page 6
) '
)
(
,
5
" $
E!
)
($
"
,
-
"
(
(
'
(( #
4
1%
E
" 2
"
)
'
)
(
5
)
5 +
%
2
E
5
"
'
(
5
)
E
5
)
"
!" 2
4
4
5
4
4
+
"
"
)
,
+
+
"
)
(/ !
-0" " "
6
)
1
5
E
" 2
"
(/ !
)
4
,
4
F
(
" #
+
5
"
-
'
(( #
4
+
!
+
" #
0
!
2
+
"
(
"0
+
"0"
)
5
2
!
)
5
+
!"
1 B E
" 2
)
'
+
#
"
3
#
(
+
+
"(
0 +
"
+
(
BB
4
E
" F
4
" 2
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
+
+
Page 7
+
+
+
+
0
4
+
,
#
0
-
4
"
"
4
+
$
4
, 4
+
"
" "
9
-
8
2
4
#
F
$
2
, 4
4
B0
" "
4
4 .
!
+
4
4
)
4
4
+
+
4
4
"
2
00"
-
+
- G
4
.
4
4
0 0E
1 BE
%1" .
4
5
4
4
+
4
4
,
4
+
-4
"
B10
4" .
4
4
+
4
"
"
5
8
#
& " .
F
& E
" " 2
4
- G
&E
!
4
+
-4
"
4
)
+
4
4
+
,
"
4
4
+
+
;
"
7
2
φ H
2
φ ≠
4
8
"
#
+
4
"1" 2
4
+
!
4
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
"B
Page 8
4
%&
)
%1!"
4
4
.
E
2
2
1
!
#
#
" 3
)
2
A
!
,
4
A
1& !
C
B! /
4
"
+
"
;
5
2
" 6
H
φ
5
"
2
φ
4
"
≠
2
"
)
"
& E" $
&
"&
%%
%1!"
'
E
2
2
"3
)
!
&E" .
& E
(
"
!
4
-4
1 BE
.
(
&!"
2
2
)
)
4
4
0 0E" $
1B
!
4
4
1 BE"
.
/
)
4
2
1 &!" 2
4
,
0 0E
!
1 BE
4
(
A )
!"
2
4
)
4
4
4
%
!
*+
!
2
4
B!
,
A
5
-
5
-
"
6
"
4
4
0!
0!"
+
A
B
)
-4
4
!
!
!
!" 2
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 9
9)
&
'6#/ 1#/ #+#/
!
)
! 6
4
3
(
4
" #
;
-
!
4
5
"
4
;
4
,$
"
!
)
,$
,$
"
#
"
5
'
2
(
'
"
(
" .
'
! '
(
(
6
4
"
3
;
'
1#% #+ '
4
.
.
"
,
4
.=
*
-
'
,$
4
!
4
'
(
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
,$
"
(
"
# #
$
I
(
(
.
%
-
9 " $ )
"
0"
( !
"
(
. "
(
"
&" 1
(
!
- ' !" 3
$
"
#
&"
"
" "
'
2
"
/
"
"
" ,
#
1 !
' !
3
88)))"
" " 85
8 5 8
J- 4
-
Page 10
.
K B
4
" 3
', "
.
) /
(
"
0
N
#
*
#
2
9
1"
,$
.
.
5
L4
4-.
$ J
$
9
4
; "
3
( #%
4
5
67 89 . J $ ; +
47 )
'
"
2
$
"
" 2
(
#
$, #
"
3
88)))"4
"5 8
8 8
"
" #
6
K
B ',
9
*" " @
) #"9"
%% "
"
(
" #, G
"
B - % "
6
"
" ,
,
%
- ' !
!
'
3
88)))"
) "5 8
800&
0&8
- 4
"
0C
K
', "
*+
9
"
$ -7 " # 5
'
5 "
"
$ J 9
5
9
5
#
*
5 *+
5
4
.
:
( # 3
&
;< : = .$.M ; +
4
7 )
'
.
"
5
#
,
4
$ 5
. 5
7 ):
"
A
A )
"
" .
(
(
'
(
$
(
" 3
; +
6
"
2
4
#" #"
B!" ( # "
( #
#
"
; +
;
#
(
"
2
3
)
"
"
$
" !
1
2
-( > 2
- ' !" $
( 5 N, ,(
;,"
2
*+ ,
"
1"
*
'
$
2
"
I
A
,
"
,
, ) " 3 44 (
"
"
9
5 9
C4 * 5
5 $ J
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
,
$
(
N
3
#
$
N
)
"
;
,
#
(
$ J
*."
1" "
$
*
)
,
0
"
"
(
+
6
"
63( 7
*(-&&8(3"8
"
$
9
(
5
*
!
(
(
.
. (!"
-/ "
7
C
.
#
"
"
J ( 5
$
* 5
5
. *
5 .
"
)
@
3
&
8 :
5"
+
$ 5
#
,
5
; +
"
= "
/
9
B" "
*
$
# 5
*
/
,
?
/
A
*
;
/
N
"
3
(" /
"
*
'
9
)
*
(" 3
"
(
"
@
"-(" 3
88)))"
J
"5 8 ) 8
8
08 -4
O
"&6 *
"
" 0 #
"
#6" .
,
6
2
= #
I
4 '
I
44
.
7
3
"
"N 5
44 5
4 5
#
"
.4 5
3
4
#
F " 1 !
" 1 B1
"
#
A
A "
"
*-N
4
$ J -.
5
(
"
3
$
1
"
&
= 9
",
"
"
%"
, 4
$ 5
N
#
" 7 )
6
$
#5A )-2 "
4
9
5 A ) # 2 ) 5 ("
%&%" )
( #
N 5 (
5
; "
"
" ' !
2
)
! @
I
A
,
"
-
"
-
Page 11
)
!
"
" 2
!
!
'
!
"
88)))"
4 -
$
"
" 85
8
- 4
"
K 0 ', "
'
"
"
5 N
4 $ J
17
2$
$
,
,
5 "
*J
(
%
"
"
" (
* 5
4
3
$4
"
(
,
"
88)))"
8
)
; +
7
"
6 ,
#
) "5
4 -
K &
', "
4
8
-
"
4
80 B&
- .
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 12
6#
0
+#/
5)3
0
7)3
1
7)3
8
2
#
:
#
9
10
&
B
B
0
B1
;55
3
!
"# #
$
%
&
% #
#
# #
+
' #
%
#' ()
*'
, -+
'
'
,'
('
'
$
0!
0
!
$ . / %%
0!
0
0
2 3
#
1
% #
,++(
,++)
,++
,+ (
!
"
#
$%
#
#&'
!
*
" # #% "
( # )
* ) %
%
#
(+ ,* )
# ",#,(
,& ( %
" #% #" *% - ",#,(
#
- % - ,(+ %
# ,# -
- - #
#
"
* ).
#
/0012034
5
/106
( #
!
"
#
( # #
) *
+#
$ %&
'
, #
-
# *
.
/
% - , (
# # ##
0
# ) *
+#
, #
1
#2 ( # #
(
) *
3 -
+#
( # #
+
0
+
) *
-
, #
(
'
4
(
+#
#
, #
(
#
+ 4
1556
v
'
7 ,
!
(
8 - 9
%
(
:
22
#
'
1
( # #
) *
+#
$) ,+9 &
;
+
6 !
2
%5 !
#2
!
!
)
!
%% !
-
%1
0
<
+
!
)
+
, 2#
!
+
!
#
#
%3 9
# *
%4
.
# *
%7
%8
# *
.
vi
#
, #
%:
.
.4
1556
#
2
# *
#
!
=
,
vii
15%3
/ 1%%56%4:
!
%
"
!
"
!
"
&
#
#
$
#
'
#
%
&
%
( )
"
&&
&
&&
"
viii
!
&
*
+
!
*
,
+
-
!
%
.
! "
&&
"&
&&
&
&&
%
&
& "
&&
%
&
%
, /
-
0
/
& /
1 " 0
#
&
*
+
%
1 " 0
,
"
"
&&
/
&
0
0 /
,
1 " 0
!
!
!%
"
!%
2 0&
!,
!,
34
!
&
!
5
30
&
!
/
4
%
$
7
,
%
4
%
5
%!
%
7 6
%
7
%
7
&0
,
6
%!
%,
4
%,
/
/
0
%%-
&0
ix
,
-
/
&
0
&
0
%
5
%
,#
5
&
,#
$
-
2 0&
-!
!
-!
2
!
8
4
!
7
-!
34
"
--
0&
!
$
!
7
$
-
!
2
7 6
!
2
7
$
5
!
$
4
0
5
&
0
6
4
"
&&
*9+
!
$
5
0
6
4 /
!
$
5
0
6
4
! ! $
6
*:+
1 " 0
##
! !
"
&&
&
0
#-
/
! ! <
!
,
*;+
/
0
1 " 0
#
4
!
"
&&
&
/
#-
!
%
"
%
/
/
0
1 " 0
,
0
!
x
xi
!
"
#
$
!
"
#
$
%
"
&
$
'
$
**
*!
# ++,
1# ) 1
1 * 1
** *
45'
&+
3
) " #
&
#
&'(&
- .+
+ **+* +
1 #1* 21
!
*
# ++
.
1#
,
., )
# )
+1# )
! .
"
+
$
+*
"
7
9
;
.
,
<
< =
.
6.#
2 5
## /
,>
:,
.)
4
"
) )
* 9
!
# ++
,
1.
1 1.
. $
! .. ( @
!
) (*'+&,/*+*0/&0/0+
! .
- + # 71 , .
* 8 *0 / 45'
( .
"
' .
$
)
/
'
"
$ * !
1
9
(
%
.
" ,1
.
0# 1 * 2,
122
#
7;
* (, * 3'45-*
.
$
5 $
- .+ * +* +
1#
1
? .
* 8 * &0 45'
$
@
1
#
'
> -
A ;
6
C !
* B
4
A "
( ?
-
6
! ?
.
/
.
7 6
0
?
A ;
.
"
$
* *
0 $5" D
7
, .
, >
5
@
'
.#
"
,
?
(5";6(
; .
# ++
/&11
1
0/1
1
$
#
- .+
+
1
1)
.
* +* +**+
,1
* 8 * & 45
1
*
#* '
.
1
1
5.
1> . $ 4 # #
; ;
- $
6.# - 6=
* 7
./
8 * 9+, 7 * &*
E < =
4
"
'
"$
> F
( ? * * 6=
(" ##
)
0# * && 1&/
**
$
== 1 #
@
:
+
.
.
+
+
**
" 67 1H -
92;
0001#
**
*
( !
" ,
/
& +
"
@
4
@
, .
#
/
6=
G
1
)
- .+
** 3
.
"
=
# )
.
G
;
*
# ++.
6
+
- .+
*
$ #* !
# ++
.1 , . 1# ) 1
* 8 * * 45'
3
?)
6
!
"
6D
.
45'
# < =
!
/
#
.#
*
123
-
$
/
.
4 )
?#
.
-
"7 !
1# ) 1- # 1
)
#
" .
6,, # <
,
7
9
9
" #
$ =
..
#
!G ;6
;(
#)
9
9
9
,
$ $ B
"
!
%
!
:
19
1
- 9
0
0 0
#
"
- G5"5
.
$
=1
%
0
%
.
#
1
# ++
1#
/
6
*
$
6= 5
@
4
&
.
*>
; )
*
!
.
1 .
45'
! $2#=
.
0C
.
< =
<
#
9 .
?
$
#
- .+
7
+
! .
+* / &+# ) 1 #
1
*0
* 8
/
2 "
$
=
%
5.
"
.#
.
5
=
"
,
-
71,
/
$
$
? 1
** 1* 0
5$
5
4
3,,
2
. 5
G
! ,,
##
7#
A: B
5. . @ %
2
!
5D
9
=
**
5
0
C
.#
$
-
3, 6 -
:
7G
0 @
=C
'
< =
&
?#
!
124
' .
!
9$
!
4
!
' - @
=
%
#
/
**
@
:#
?
/
!
6
)
B 4
$
1(
7
"
> .
#
D =
>
(
!
!
(
- G
# 7
? 6/
5 . ?
'
!
/
5
$
$ - .
6
125
6
" .
!
#
+ 1,
/
!
1# .
<
% $
** G -
/
-
6.#
,8
5 .-
0
4
- .+
+
/+
#
* $
9
$
&
/
.
>
* !
" B " C
#
.
.
"
0
$
- 9
"
/
/
.
.
-
(
!
"
C.
6 1 /+ ! +
.#
"
3
6 -
< =
(
$ "
B 1G
!
"
*
) .
6.#
# ++
#I
.#
00
(
$
(
4
0 0
&
> .
-
5, 7
< =
#
A"
C.
0
$?
!
?! > .
6 1 + !+
.
" 6
!
#
B " C
#
(
* 2*
&* (+ >
, 4
,, -
"
1#
"
,,
, -
#
1
$
2&//
$
H
, -
!
H -
-
,'
$
0
* - .$
64
4'
H
"
.
(
$-(
" ,
6"
7
7#
67#
--
$
@
"
, 8
A5 , .
@
*
/
8
$-
&*
" "
# ++
!
* 1
13
* /0 45'
>
"
)
)
G >
; .
,
-
)
(
!
>
;
2B *C ## 2&&01
/
# " E
- .
)
9 ,,
4
- 19
!
1 * !
##
;$
5 =
<
7
#
" ,
67 .
- = ;
/
0 0 *
-, 7
( < =
, > =
;
"
. *2 & > H
?
"
,
- @
.
:
"
$ 9
G -
;
-
*
@
*
:
'
0
<
$
%
*
5.
"
%
, %
)F
'
,
"
.
!
2
;
" #
#
** %
$
# )
# ++
1
1
)
1#
.
**8 * * 45'
> # .
"
1
.
' .
.#
"9
7 ;
,"
" .
"
'
#
1
45'
"
9
# ++
6,
?
.4
, .
:
5
0#
< =
,
+1 , .
*
. , 1
*2
!
/ 5.# .
6 - G
"
#
67#
- /
0
)
0# >
,
#
$
. ,
# ++
1 1
1
*
.# - +
15 1 .
. ;
G
+ .
;
0#
"
!
+
1;
;
+
5
- .+
.1
!
+
"
.
;
* +**+
;
#)
+ 0 &&&2 /+
> = .
8
;) .
#
5 ,
127
? 5
' .
+ 0 */+.
. , 1
/ #
* 8* /&
6
?
2
#* !
# 1
&* 45'
0
!
( *
$ - . ".
.
9
*$ '< =
/
ttabel pada taraf signifikan. Dimana t tabel untuk α =
0,05 sebesar 1,96.
!
!
"
119
120
!
#
!
$%
&
$%
(
)
'
!
!
"
&
'
"
121
$%
$%
$%
*
!
(
)
!
!
!
!
*
!
(
)
!
!
!
#
'
&
#
"
$%
"
&
(
)*
+#,
'
(
)
" #
'
(
*+
,
'
%!"
(
)
'
.
!
#
(
!
"
)
'
,
0 %1
$
%&
'
(
)
&!" /
1
2
!" 2
(
3
)
)
4
)'( *
(
,
'
(
)+*
),*
.
'
'
-
(
&!"
(
(
.
(
/
'
($!
'
(
(
'
(
)
5
($
(
(
.
!"
5
!"
#
$
%%& !
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
5
Page 1
)
4
!" 6
'
(
4
!"
/
'
(
5
($
6
*(-&&8(3"8
(
!" #
)
4
6
($
5
!"
5
'
/
0 !" #
(
7
3
($
(
($
5
<
!
63(
($
<
<
$
!
5
0 !"
'
(
4
!
,
.
$
#
#
92"
0
!"
)
'
(
4
:
0
2
. 4
'
(
!"
6
$
3
,
(
+
$
%%&!"
4
$4
-
4
+
-
"
4
'
!" (
4
4
#
(
$
((
"
4
2
(
(
"
!" #
'
"
(( #
'
)
#
$
!"
;
4
"
4
4
$
1 %!" $
(
4
(
4
$
, 4
4
,
"
)
4
4
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 2
#
4
$
1 %!
5
4
4
.
" ;
4
4
'
(( #
"
!
(
>, 4
4
"
" ;
'
4
, 4
#"
4
(
4
-4
4
-
(( #
"
"
!
!
4
4
(
!?"
)
5
4
5
4
4
" 6
"
4
-)
#. #/
' # #$
&
+#/ 1#/ 2 ! &
"
$
4
&+#/0 #
4
"
4
#
.=
!" #
-
!
4
3
>
!
!
4
!
4
!
?"
)
4
'
0!
)
4
! ,
$
#
!
5
@
4
"
3
A
A
3
!
!
6 4
!
4
9"
/
4
!
5
"
0!
!
)
4
"
!
!
"
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
)
)
)
#
!
4
Page 3
"
" +
" ,
0" -
6 4
!
(
!
# 4
!
0 !
$
7 (
6
$#
5
" -
($
(
($
" '
5
!
" (
"
5
!
!
63(
4
($
5
#
0!
"
%&%
!
4
?"
#
4
@
A
A
( #
#
$
#
%
"
#"
&
)
% %!
#
!
,
@(
>
#
-
'
)
6 4
)
'
(
?"
4
"
%&%!
"
. ,
($!
*
-
"
!
$
'
(
)
)
"
6
. (
'
$.#
(
)
4
*
$.#
'
.
>#
)
!" .
3
'
)
5
00 !
(
(
*
$.#!
4
($!
)
($
4
+
?"
)
)
. -
"
#
5
8
4
(
)
" .
4
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
#
"3
5
Page 4
>
"
?"
%
2-
!
"
)
4
4
>$
, 4
$
4
5) ! .& 1#/
C
4
4
& !1& &/&6
#/
"
4
4
4
4
;
"
/
.
4
'
4
(
#
A
A 3" .
.4
4
?"
7
6
A
1
7 "
)
(
(
"
#
4
4
4
#
6
+
4
4"
4
"$
#6"
.
,
1
!
+
4
4
)
>
4
#
(
4
"
-
0
"
(/ !" (
234"
+
#
9
3
@
B&!
>
@
'
)
)
.
+
"
%% !
'
#
4
(
(
4
($
(
4
"6
'
4
5
" #
"
63(
.
?"
((
4
6
)
4
.
,
4
D
E
($
)
)
4
4
"
4
"
)
"
2
B B!
)
.
+
4
4
-
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
0
"
Page 5
(/ !
" " 6 4
,
A
4)
0
"
1 &!
=
(/
5
"
-
0
"
,
4
5
E!"
2
5 " $
-
0
"
)
4
E!"
+
?"
#
,
#
A
=
4
1 !
(
(/ !
+
"
)
!
-
!" (
"
0
)
-
4
(/ !
4
4
"
+
)
+
)
!
B E
" 2
)
!
5
!"
4
4
"
5
5
-
+
,
5
4
4
+
4
"
#
A
4
0" "
"
F
7)
2# 6
&/&6
&
#2# #/
#/
1#/
(
'
(( #
!
#
2
2
A
" " (
)
"
5
+
"
4
(
"
,
F
#
'
)
(( #
!
#
4
"2
(
+
-4
'
(( #
4
"
4
" "(
"
)
((
5
4
)
)
#
#
"
7
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
1B
5
00
E
)
E!
E" 2
Page 6
) '
)
(
,
5
" $
E!
)
($
"
,
-
"
(
(
'
(( #
4
1%
E
" 2
"
)
'
)
(
5
)
5 +
%
2
E
5
"
'
(
5
)
E
5
)
"
!" 2
4
4
5
4
4
+
"
"
)
,
+
+
"
)
(/ !
-0" " "
6
)
1
5
E
" 2
"
(/ !
)
4
,
4
F
(
" #
+
5
"
-
'
(( #
4
+
!
+
" #
0
!
2
+
"
(
"0
+
"0"
)
5
2
!
)
5
+
!"
1 B E
" 2
)
'
+
#
"
3
#
(
+
+
"(
0 +
"
+
(
BB
4
E
" F
4
" 2
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
+
+
Page 7
+
+
+
+
0
4
+
,
#
0
-
4
"
"
4
+
$
4
, 4
+
"
" "
9
-
8
2
4
#
F
$
2
, 4
4
B0
" "
4
4 .
!
+
4
4
)
4
4
+
+
4
4
"
2
00"
-
+
- G
4
.
4
4
0 0E
1 BE
%1" .
4
5
4
4
+
4
4
,
4
+
-4
"
B10
4" .
4
4
+
4
"
"
5
8
#
& " .
F
& E
" " 2
4
- G
&E
!
4
+
-4
"
4
)
+
4
4
+
,
"
4
4
+
+
;
"
7
2
φ H
2
φ ≠
4
8
"
#
+
4
"1" 2
4
+
!
4
)
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
"B
Page 8
4
%&
)
%1!"
4
4
.
E
2
2
1
!
#
#
" 3
)
2
A
!
,
4
A
1& !
C
B! /
4
"
+
"
;
5
2
" 6
H
φ
5
"
2
φ
4
"
≠
2
"
)
"
& E" $
&
"&
%%
%1!"
'
E
2
2
"3
)
!
&E" .
& E
(
"
!
4
-4
1 BE
.
(
&!"
2
2
)
)
4
4
0 0E" $
1B
!
4
4
1 BE"
.
/
)
4
2
1 &!" 2
4
,
0 0E
!
1 BE
4
(
A )
!"
2
4
)
4
4
4
%
!
*+
!
2
4
B!
,
A
5
-
5
-
"
6
"
4
4
0!
0!"
+
A
B
)
-4
4
!
!
!
!" 2
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 9
9)
&
'6#/ 1#/ #+#/
!
)
! 6
4
3
(
4
" #
;
-
!
4
5
"
4
;
4
,$
"
!
)
,$
,$
"
#
"
5
'
2
(
'
"
(
" .
'
! '
(
(
6
4
"
3
;
'
1#% #+ '
4
.
.
"
,
4
.=
*
-
'
,$
4
!
4
'
(
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
,$
"
(
"
# #
$
I
(
(
.
%
-
9 " $ )
"
0"
( !
"
(
. "
(
"
&" 1
(
!
- ' !" 3
$
"
#
&"
"
" "
'
2
"
/
"
"
" ,
#
1 !
' !
3
88)))"
" " 85
8 5 8
J- 4
-
Page 10
.
K B
4
" 3
', "
.
) /
(
"
0
N
#
*
#
2
9
1"
,$
.
.
5
L4
4-.
$ J
$
9
4
; "
3
( #%
4
5
67 89 . J $ ; +
47 )
'
"
2
$
"
" 2
(
#
$, #
"
3
88)))"4
"5 8
8 8
"
" #
6
K
B ',
9
*" " @
) #"9"
%% "
"
(
" #, G
"
B - % "
6
"
" ,
,
%
- ' !
!
'
3
88)))"
) "5 8
800&
0&8
- 4
"
0C
K
', "
*+
9
"
$ -7 " # 5
'
5 "
"
$ J 9
5
9
5
#
*
5 *+
5
4
.
:
( # 3
&
;< : = .$.M ; +
4
7 )
'
.
"
5
#
,
4
$ 5
. 5
7 ):
"
A
A )
"
" .
(
(
'
(
$
(
" 3
; +
6
"
2
4
#" #"
B!" ( # "
( #
#
"
; +
;
#
(
"
2
3
)
"
"
$
" !
1
2
-( > 2
- ' !" $
( 5 N, ,(
;,"
2
*+ ,
"
1"
*
'
$
2
"
I
A
,
"
,
, ) " 3 44 (
"
"
9
5 9
C4 * 5
5 $ J
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
,
$
(
N
3
#
$
N
)
"
;
,
#
(
$ J
*."
1" "
$
*
)
,
0
"
"
(
+
6
"
63( 7
*(-&&8(3"8
"
$
9
(
5
*
!
(
(
.
. (!"
-/ "
7
C
.
#
"
"
J ( 5
$
* 5
5
. *
5 .
"
)
@
3
&
8 :
5"
+
$ 5
#
,
5
; +
"
= "
/
9
B" "
*
$
# 5
*
/
,
?
/
A
*
;
/
N
"
3
(" /
"
*
'
9
)
*
(" 3
"
(
"
@
"-(" 3
88)))"
J
"5 8 ) 8
8
08 -4
O
"&6 *
"
" 0 #
"
#6" .
,
6
2
= #
I
4 '
I
44
.
7
3
"
"N 5
44 5
4 5
#
"
.4 5
3
4
#
F " 1 !
" 1 B1
"
#
A
A "
"
*-N
4
$ J -.
5
(
"
3
$
1
"
&
= 9
",
"
"
%"
, 4
$ 5
N
#
" 7 )
6
$
#5A )-2 "
4
9
5 A ) # 2 ) 5 ("
%&%" )
( #
N 5 (
5
; "
"
" ' !
2
)
! @
I
A
,
"
-
"
-
Page 11
)
!
"
" 2
!
!
'
!
"
88)))"
4 -
$
"
" 85
8
- 4
"
K 0 ', "
'
"
"
5 N
4 $ J
17
2$
$
,
,
5 "
*J
(
%
"
"
" (
* 5
4
3
$4
"
(
,
"
88)))"
8
)
; +
7
"
6 ,
#
) "5
4 -
K &
', "
4
8
-
"
4
80 B&
- .
Universitas Komputer Indonesia
Page 12
6#
0
+#/
5)3
0
7)3
1
7)3
8
2
#
:
#
9
10
&
B
B
0
B1
;55
3