Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 1
APPENDIX 1
Students' Mid Score at Class VIII State Junior High School 23
Padang
N0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
VIII 1
63
60
48
55
38
42
28
52
50
48
50
38
53
43
35
35
35
25
28
33
40
28
50
30
28
28
28
53
35
48
1227
79.16129
VIII 2
52
54
50
58
60
64
52
58
56
60
60
68
60
46
56
50
56
58
58
70
58
58
54
56
32
38
58
46
72
52
48
46
80
76
1920
109.7143
VIII 3
60
53
53
58
50
55
65
48
50
40
65
63
70
70
68
78
63
53
53
50
70
50
63
50
68
68
65
48
48
58
1695
113
APPENDIX 2
Analysis of SPSS for the English Midterm Class VIII State Junior High
School 23 Padang
Tests of Normality
VAR0
0002
Kolmogorov-Smirnova
Statistic
df
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
Statistic
df
Sig.
VAR00001 1
.108
30
.200*
.964
30
.381
2
.205
30
.002
.942
30
.106
3
.155
30
.063
.941
30
.095
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
*. This is a lower bound of the true significance.
Test of Homogeneity of Variance
Levene
Statistic
VAR00001
df1
df2
Sig.
Based on Mean
7.255
2
87
.001
Based on Median
6.547
2
87
.002
Based on Median and
with adjusted df
6.547
2
80.457
.002
Based on trimmed mean
7.507
2
87
.001
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 1
Normal Q-Q Plot Of VIII 3
Normal Q-Q plot of VIII 7
APPENDIX 3
Blue Print of Writing Test
of Test
Text
Recount text
Types
Written Test
Writing
Skill
Indicator
Topic
1. Students are able to
1. My Last Holiday
construct a text by
using content in writing
2. Students are able to
2. My Last Birthday
3. Visitmg the zoo
construct a text by
using organisation in
writing
3. Students are able to
construct a text by
using language use in
writing
4. Students are able to
construct a text by
using vocabulary in
writing
5. Students are able to
construct a text by
using mechanics in
writing
4. My Best or Worst
Experience
5. My lucky day
APPENDIX 4
WRITING TEST
RECOUNT TEXT
Choose One Tittle Below and Make
Recount Text on Your Paper
Minimal Five Lines!
1. My Last Holiday
2. My Last Birthday
3. Visiting The Zoo
4. My Best / WorstExperience
5. My Lucky Day
Name :
Class :
Result :
Content
:
Organization :
Vocabulary
:
Language Use :
Mechanic
:
APPENDIX 5
Pre-Test Scores of Experimental Class (Class VIII 3) in Term of Content,
Organization, Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanics.
No.
Name
1
AA
2
AIA
3
AJA
4
AF
5
AY
6
DH
7
EC
8
FF
9
FR
10
F
11
FN
12
FF
13
GY
14
GH
15
IDI
16
LA
17
MAF
18
MI
19
MR
20
MF
21
NM
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
18
12
11
12
3
56
16
9
9
9
2
45
15
10
9
10
2
46
18
12
12
10
2
54
16
11
11
11
2
51
17
12
12
11
3
55
17
9
10
9
2
47
18
11
11
10
2
52
17
10
10
9
2
48
16
9
10
10
2
47
17
12
12
11
3
55
18
11
10
10
2
51
17
11
10
9
2
49
17
10
10
9
2
48
16
10
10
11
2
49
17
10
10
10
2
49
17
10
10
11
2
50
17
10
10
12
3
52
17
12
12
11
2
54
18
12
11
12
3
56
17
10
10
10
2
49
No
Name
22
PC
23
PR
24
RA
25
RN
26
STA
27
SRA
28
SY
29
TN
30
YI
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
17
10
10
11
2
50
18
11
10
10
2
51
17
10
11
10
2
50
18
10
11
11
3
53
18
11
11
11
2
53
18
11
10
11
2
52
15
8
9
8
2
42
18
12
11
11
2
54
18
12
12
11
2
55
513
318
315
311
66
17,1
10,6
10,5
10,36667
2,2
1523
50,76
667
18
12
12
12
3
56
15
8
9
8
2
42
Pre-Test Scores of Control Class (Class VIII 1) in Term of Content,
Organization, Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanics.
No.
Name
1
AEP
2
AR
3
AP
4
AS
5
AC
6
AP
7
AKN
8
G
9
HP
10
HD
11
HR
12
IN
13
K
14
MM
15
MRA
16
MAR
17
MAF
18
N
19
RM
20
RS
21
RD
22
RF
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
17
10
10
11
2
50
15
10
10
10
2
47
17
11
11
10
2
51
18
12
11
12
2
55
15
10
10
10
2
47
18
12
12
11
2
55
17
10
10
11
2
50
15
10
10
10
2
47
17
11
11
11
2
52
13
9
10
9
2
43
17
10
10
11
2
50
18
11
12
11
2
54
15
10
10
10
2
47
14
9
9
10
2
44
14
9
9
9
2
43
16
9
9
10
2
46
16
10
10
10
2
48
17
14
10
10
3
54
17
10
10
11
2
50
16
10
10
10
2
48
14
9
9
10
2
44
16
10
10
10
2
48
No
Name
23
RJ
24
SJ
25
SW
26
SA
27
TP
28
TJF
29
WR
30
ZU
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
16
10
9
10
2
47
19
12
11
12
3
57
18
11
10
11
3
53
15
9
9
9
2
44
14
9
8
10
2
43
16
9
9
10
2
46
15
8
9
9
2
43
15
11
9
10
2
47
480
297
308
63
16
305
10,166
67
9,9
10,26667
2,1
1453
48,43
33
19
14
12
12
3
57
13
8
8
9
2
43
APPENDIX 6
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Pre-Test in
Experimental Class
Xi
42
45
1
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
1764
42
2025
45
1764
2025
2116
46
2116
46
1
1
47
2
2209
94
4418
48
2
2304
96
4608
49
4
2401
196
9604
50
3
2500
150
7500
51
3
2601
153
7803
2704
156
8112
2809
106
5618
52
∑
Fi
53
3
2
54
3
2916
162
8748
55
3
3025
165
9075
56
2
3136
112
6272
∑Xi2=32510
∑FiXi=1523
∑FiXi2=77663
∑Fi=30
xx =
∑ F1X1
1523
=
= 50.75
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = (1523) = 2319529
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(77663) − (2319529)
30(30 − 1)
S =
2329890 − 2319529
30(29)
S =
10361
= 11.90
870
S = √11.90 = 3.45
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Pre-Test In
Control Class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
43
4
1849
172
7396
44
1936
132
5808
46
3
2
2116
92
4232
47
6
2209
282
13254
48
3
2304
144
6912
50
4
2500
200
10000
51
1
2601
51
2601
52
1
2704
52
2704
53
1
2809
53
2809
54
2
2916
108
5832
55
2
3025
110
6050
57
1
3249
57
3249
∑
∑Fi=30
∑FiXi=1453
∑FiXi2=70847
∑Xi2=30218
xx =
∑ F1X1
1453
=
= 48.43
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 1453 = 2111209
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(70847) − (2111209)
30(30 − 1)
S =
2125410 − 2111209
30(29)
S =
14201
= 16.32
870
S = √16.23 = 4.04
APPENDIX 7
Post-test of Experimental Class (VIII 3)
Vocabulary, Language Use and Mechanic
No.
Name
1
AA
2
AIA
3
AJA
4
AF
5
AY
6
DH
7
EC
8
FF
9
FR
10
F
11
FN
12
FF
13
GY
14
GH
15
IDI
16
LA
17
MAF
18
MI
19
MR
20
MF
21
NM
in the Content, Oerganization,
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
24
16
15
19
4
78
20
13
14
17
3
67
23
15
15
19
3
75
23
16
15
18
3
75
23
15
15
18
3
74
23
15
14
18
3
73
22
12
13
16
3
66
23
16
16
17
3
75
23
16
17
17
3
76
23
14
14
17
2
70
22
15
13
16
2
68
23
15
15
16
3
72
22
15
15
17
3
72
23
15
14
18
3
73
23
16
16
18
3
76
22
16
14
18
2
72
21
14
13
17
2
67
22
14
13
17
2
68
20
14
15
18
3
70
24
16
17
19
3
79
23
15
16
18
2
74
No
Name
22
PC
23
PR
24
RA
25
RN
26
STA
27
SRA
28
SY
29
TN
30
YI
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
23
15
15
18
3
74
24
15
15
18
3
75
23
15
16
19
3
76
25
16
16
19
3
79
24
16
16
18
3
77
23
15
16
18
3
75
24
16
18
18
3
79
23
18
18
18
3
80
23
15
16
18
3
75
684
22,8
454
15,133
33
85
2,833
333
2210
73,66
667
25
18
18
19
4
84
20
12
13
16
2
66
455
532
15,166
67
17,73333
Post-Test score of Control Class (VIII 1) In term of Content, Organization,
Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanic.
No.
Name
1
AEP
2
AR
3
AP
4
AS
5
AC
6
AP
7
AKN
8
G
9
HP
10
HD
11
HR
12
IN
13
K
14
MM
15
MRA
16
MAR
17
MAF
18
N
19
RM
20
RS
21
RD
22
RF
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
22
14
14
18
3
71
22
13
13
17
3
68
22
13
12
17
2
66
21
13
13
16
2
65
20
13
12
14
2
61
21
14
13
16
3
67
22
14
13
16
3
68
19
15
15
16
2
67
15
12
13
15
2
57
16
13
13
15
2
59
15
12
12
16
2
57
22
15
14
18
3
72
23
16
15
18
3
75
22
13
13
16
2
66
21
14
14
16
2
67
17
13
13
17
2
62
20
13
13
16
2
64
22
14
14
17
3
70
21
13
12
16
2
64
21
13
13
16
2
65
22
13
12
16
2
65
20
13
13
16
2
64
23
RJ
24
SJ
25
SW
26
SA
27
TP
28
TJF
29
WR
30
ZU
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
21
14
13
16
2
66
23
14
15
17
3
72
23
15
15
17
3
73
21
13
13
17
2
66
20
13
14
18
3
68
20
14
15
17
3
69
22
14
13
16
2
67
23
14
14
18
3
72
619
20,633
33
407
13,566
67
72
2,4
1993
66,43
33
23
16
15
18
3
75
15
12
12
14
2
57
401
494
13,366
67
16,46667
APPENDIX 8
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Post-test in
Experimental class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
66
1
4356
66
4356
67
2
4489
134
8978
68
2
4624
136
9248
70
2
4900
140
9800
72
3
5184
216
15552
73
2
5329
146
10658
74
3
5476
222
16428
75
6
5625
450
33750
76
4
5776
304
23104
78
1
6084
78
6084
79
3
6241
237
18723
80
1
6400
80
6400
∑
∑Fi = 30
∑Xi2= 64484
∑FiXi=
2209
∑FiXi2=163
081
xx =
∑ F1X1
2209
=
= 73.63
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 2209 = 4879681
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(163081) − (4879681)
30(30 − 1)
S =
4892430 − 4879681
30(29)
S =
12749
= 14.65
870
S = √14.65 = 3.83
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Post-test in Control
Class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
57
2
3249
114
6498
59
1
3481
59
3481
61
1
3721
61
3721
62
1
3844
62
3844
64
3
4096
192
12288
65
3
4225
195
12675
66
4
4356
264
17424
67
4
4489
268
17956
68
3
4624
204
13872
69
1
4761
69
4761
70
1
4900
70
4900
71
1
5041
71
5041
72
3
5184
216
15552
73
1
5329
73
5329
75
1
5625
75
5625
∑
∑Fi = 30
∑Xi2= 66925
∑FiXi= 1993
∑FiXi2= 132967
x=
∑ F1X1
1993
=
= 66.43
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 1993 = 3972049
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(132967) − (3972049)
30(30 − 1)
S =
3989010 − 3972049
30(29)
S =
16961
= 19.49
870
S = √19.49 = 4.41
APPENDIX 9
Analysis of Post Test Score in Experimental Class and Control Class
X 1 = 73.63
n1 = 30
S1 = 3.8
S12 = 14.44
X 2 = 66.43
n2 = 30
S2 = 4.41
S22 = 19.4
s =
(n 1)s
+ (n 1)s
n + n − 2
(30 − 1)14.44 + (30 − 1)19.44
30 + 30 − 2
(30)14.44 + (30)19.44
58
s
s =
418.76 + 563.76
58
.
s =
=16.94
=√16.94
s = 4.11
X
t
s
1
X
2
1
1
n1
n2
73.63 66.43
4.11
1
30
301
7.2
4.11 0.07
7.2
4.11(0.07)
= 7 .2
1 . 069
t = 6.735
= 0.05
df n1 n 2 2
(30 30 2 )
= 58
t-Table = t (1- ) df
= t (1- 0.05) 58
= t (0.95) 58
= 2.000
t- Calculate = 6.732
t- Table
= 2.000
t- Calculate
> t- table
6.732>2.000
t- Calculate = 6.735
t- Table
= 2.000
t- Calculate > t- table
6.735 > 2.000
APPENDIX 10
Analysis of SPSS for Post Test of Experimental Class and Control Class
Case Processing Summary
Kelas
Cases
Valid
N
Nilai
Missing
Percent
N
Total
Percent
N
Percent
VIII 3
30
100.0%
0
.0%
30
100.0%
VIII 1
30
100.0%
0
.0%
30
100.0%
Tests of Normality
Kolmogorov-Smirnova
Kelas
Nilai
Statistic
df
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
Statistic
df
Sig.
VIII 3
.139
30
.141
.945
30
.127
VIII 1
.126
30
.200*
.962
30
.352
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
*. This is a lower bound of the true significance.
Test of Homogeneity of Variance
Levene
Statistic
Nilai
df1
df2
Sig.
Based on Mean
.115
1
58
.736
Based on Median
.184
1
58
.669
Based on Median and
with adjusted df
.184
1
56.942
.669
Based on trimmed mean
.129
1
58
.721
Descriptives
VAR00002
Kelas VIII 3
Statistic
Mean
95% Confidence Interval
(experimental) for Mean
73.63
Lower Bound
72.20
Upper Bound
75.06
5% Trimmed Mean
73.70
Median
74.50
Variance
14.654
Std. Deviation
VIII 1
.699
3.828
Minimum
66
Maximum
80
Range
14
Interquartile Range
(control)
Std. Error
4
Skewness
-.410
.427
Kurtosis
-.514
.833
Mean
66.40
.803
95% Confidence Interval
for Mean
Lower Bound
64.76
Upper Bound
68.04
5% Trimmed Mean
66.48
Median
66.50
Variance
19.352
Std. Deviation
4.399
Minimum
57
Maximum
75
Range
18
Interquartile Range
4
Skewness
-.324
.427
Kurtosis
.164
.833
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 3
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 1
APPENDIX 11
T-Table
APPENDIX 12
Students’ Answer Sheet of Post-Test at Experiment Class
APPENDIX 13
Hamburger graphic organizer
APPENDIX 14
DOCUMENTATION
Students' Mid Score at Class VIII State Junior High School 23
Padang
N0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
VIII 1
63
60
48
55
38
42
28
52
50
48
50
38
53
43
35
35
35
25
28
33
40
28
50
30
28
28
28
53
35
48
1227
79.16129
VIII 2
52
54
50
58
60
64
52
58
56
60
60
68
60
46
56
50
56
58
58
70
58
58
54
56
32
38
58
46
72
52
48
46
80
76
1920
109.7143
VIII 3
60
53
53
58
50
55
65
48
50
40
65
63
70
70
68
78
63
53
53
50
70
50
63
50
68
68
65
48
48
58
1695
113
APPENDIX 2
Analysis of SPSS for the English Midterm Class VIII State Junior High
School 23 Padang
Tests of Normality
VAR0
0002
Kolmogorov-Smirnova
Statistic
df
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
Statistic
df
Sig.
VAR00001 1
.108
30
.200*
.964
30
.381
2
.205
30
.002
.942
30
.106
3
.155
30
.063
.941
30
.095
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
*. This is a lower bound of the true significance.
Test of Homogeneity of Variance
Levene
Statistic
VAR00001
df1
df2
Sig.
Based on Mean
7.255
2
87
.001
Based on Median
6.547
2
87
.002
Based on Median and
with adjusted df
6.547
2
80.457
.002
Based on trimmed mean
7.507
2
87
.001
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 1
Normal Q-Q Plot Of VIII 3
Normal Q-Q plot of VIII 7
APPENDIX 3
Blue Print of Writing Test
of Test
Text
Recount text
Types
Written Test
Writing
Skill
Indicator
Topic
1. Students are able to
1. My Last Holiday
construct a text by
using content in writing
2. Students are able to
2. My Last Birthday
3. Visitmg the zoo
construct a text by
using organisation in
writing
3. Students are able to
construct a text by
using language use in
writing
4. Students are able to
construct a text by
using vocabulary in
writing
5. Students are able to
construct a text by
using mechanics in
writing
4. My Best or Worst
Experience
5. My lucky day
APPENDIX 4
WRITING TEST
RECOUNT TEXT
Choose One Tittle Below and Make
Recount Text on Your Paper
Minimal Five Lines!
1. My Last Holiday
2. My Last Birthday
3. Visiting The Zoo
4. My Best / WorstExperience
5. My Lucky Day
Name :
Class :
Result :
Content
:
Organization :
Vocabulary
:
Language Use :
Mechanic
:
APPENDIX 5
Pre-Test Scores of Experimental Class (Class VIII 3) in Term of Content,
Organization, Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanics.
No.
Name
1
AA
2
AIA
3
AJA
4
AF
5
AY
6
DH
7
EC
8
FF
9
FR
10
F
11
FN
12
FF
13
GY
14
GH
15
IDI
16
LA
17
MAF
18
MI
19
MR
20
MF
21
NM
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
18
12
11
12
3
56
16
9
9
9
2
45
15
10
9
10
2
46
18
12
12
10
2
54
16
11
11
11
2
51
17
12
12
11
3
55
17
9
10
9
2
47
18
11
11
10
2
52
17
10
10
9
2
48
16
9
10
10
2
47
17
12
12
11
3
55
18
11
10
10
2
51
17
11
10
9
2
49
17
10
10
9
2
48
16
10
10
11
2
49
17
10
10
10
2
49
17
10
10
11
2
50
17
10
10
12
3
52
17
12
12
11
2
54
18
12
11
12
3
56
17
10
10
10
2
49
No
Name
22
PC
23
PR
24
RA
25
RN
26
STA
27
SRA
28
SY
29
TN
30
YI
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
17
10
10
11
2
50
18
11
10
10
2
51
17
10
11
10
2
50
18
10
11
11
3
53
18
11
11
11
2
53
18
11
10
11
2
52
15
8
9
8
2
42
18
12
11
11
2
54
18
12
12
11
2
55
513
318
315
311
66
17,1
10,6
10,5
10,36667
2,2
1523
50,76
667
18
12
12
12
3
56
15
8
9
8
2
42
Pre-Test Scores of Control Class (Class VIII 1) in Term of Content,
Organization, Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanics.
No.
Name
1
AEP
2
AR
3
AP
4
AS
5
AC
6
AP
7
AKN
8
G
9
HP
10
HD
11
HR
12
IN
13
K
14
MM
15
MRA
16
MAR
17
MAF
18
N
19
RM
20
RS
21
RD
22
RF
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
17
10
10
11
2
50
15
10
10
10
2
47
17
11
11
10
2
51
18
12
11
12
2
55
15
10
10
10
2
47
18
12
12
11
2
55
17
10
10
11
2
50
15
10
10
10
2
47
17
11
11
11
2
52
13
9
10
9
2
43
17
10
10
11
2
50
18
11
12
11
2
54
15
10
10
10
2
47
14
9
9
10
2
44
14
9
9
9
2
43
16
9
9
10
2
46
16
10
10
10
2
48
17
14
10
10
3
54
17
10
10
11
2
50
16
10
10
10
2
48
14
9
9
10
2
44
16
10
10
10
2
48
No
Name
23
RJ
24
SJ
25
SW
26
SA
27
TP
28
TJF
29
WR
30
ZU
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
16
10
9
10
2
47
19
12
11
12
3
57
18
11
10
11
3
53
15
9
9
9
2
44
14
9
8
10
2
43
16
9
9
10
2
46
15
8
9
9
2
43
15
11
9
10
2
47
480
297
308
63
16
305
10,166
67
9,9
10,26667
2,1
1453
48,43
33
19
14
12
12
3
57
13
8
8
9
2
43
APPENDIX 6
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Pre-Test in
Experimental Class
Xi
42
45
1
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
1764
42
2025
45
1764
2025
2116
46
2116
46
1
1
47
2
2209
94
4418
48
2
2304
96
4608
49
4
2401
196
9604
50
3
2500
150
7500
51
3
2601
153
7803
2704
156
8112
2809
106
5618
52
∑
Fi
53
3
2
54
3
2916
162
8748
55
3
3025
165
9075
56
2
3136
112
6272
∑Xi2=32510
∑FiXi=1523
∑FiXi2=77663
∑Fi=30
xx =
∑ F1X1
1523
=
= 50.75
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = (1523) = 2319529
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(77663) − (2319529)
30(30 − 1)
S =
2329890 − 2319529
30(29)
S =
10361
= 11.90
870
S = √11.90 = 3.45
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Pre-Test In
Control Class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
43
4
1849
172
7396
44
1936
132
5808
46
3
2
2116
92
4232
47
6
2209
282
13254
48
3
2304
144
6912
50
4
2500
200
10000
51
1
2601
51
2601
52
1
2704
52
2704
53
1
2809
53
2809
54
2
2916
108
5832
55
2
3025
110
6050
57
1
3249
57
3249
∑
∑Fi=30
∑FiXi=1453
∑FiXi2=70847
∑Xi2=30218
xx =
∑ F1X1
1453
=
= 48.43
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 1453 = 2111209
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(70847) − (2111209)
30(30 − 1)
S =
2125410 − 2111209
30(29)
S =
14201
= 16.32
870
S = √16.23 = 4.04
APPENDIX 7
Post-test of Experimental Class (VIII 3)
Vocabulary, Language Use and Mechanic
No.
Name
1
AA
2
AIA
3
AJA
4
AF
5
AY
6
DH
7
EC
8
FF
9
FR
10
F
11
FN
12
FF
13
GY
14
GH
15
IDI
16
LA
17
MAF
18
MI
19
MR
20
MF
21
NM
in the Content, Oerganization,
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
24
16
15
19
4
78
20
13
14
17
3
67
23
15
15
19
3
75
23
16
15
18
3
75
23
15
15
18
3
74
23
15
14
18
3
73
22
12
13
16
3
66
23
16
16
17
3
75
23
16
17
17
3
76
23
14
14
17
2
70
22
15
13
16
2
68
23
15
15
16
3
72
22
15
15
17
3
72
23
15
14
18
3
73
23
16
16
18
3
76
22
16
14
18
2
72
21
14
13
17
2
67
22
14
13
17
2
68
20
14
15
18
3
70
24
16
17
19
3
79
23
15
16
18
2
74
No
Name
22
PC
23
PR
24
RA
25
RN
26
STA
27
SRA
28
SY
29
TN
30
YI
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
C
O
V
L
M
Total
23
15
15
18
3
74
24
15
15
18
3
75
23
15
16
19
3
76
25
16
16
19
3
79
24
16
16
18
3
77
23
15
16
18
3
75
24
16
18
18
3
79
23
18
18
18
3
80
23
15
16
18
3
75
684
22,8
454
15,133
33
85
2,833
333
2210
73,66
667
25
18
18
19
4
84
20
12
13
16
2
66
455
532
15,166
67
17,73333
Post-Test score of Control Class (VIII 1) In term of Content, Organization,
Vocabulary, Language Use, and Mechanic.
No.
Name
1
AEP
2
AR
3
AP
4
AS
5
AC
6
AP
7
AKN
8
G
9
HP
10
HD
11
HR
12
IN
13
K
14
MM
15
MRA
16
MAR
17
MAF
18
N
19
RM
20
RS
21
RD
22
RF
Components
Total
C
O
V
L
M
22
14
14
18
3
71
22
13
13
17
3
68
22
13
12
17
2
66
21
13
13
16
2
65
20
13
12
14
2
61
21
14
13
16
3
67
22
14
13
16
3
68
19
15
15
16
2
67
15
12
13
15
2
57
16
13
13
15
2
59
15
12
12
16
2
57
22
15
14
18
3
72
23
16
15
18
3
75
22
13
13
16
2
66
21
14
14
16
2
67
17
13
13
17
2
62
20
13
13
16
2
64
22
14
14
17
3
70
21
13
12
16
2
64
21
13
13
16
2
65
22
13
12
16
2
65
20
13
13
16
2
64
23
RJ
24
SJ
25
SW
26
SA
27
TP
28
TJF
29
WR
30
ZU
SUM
AVERAGE
MAX
MIN
21
14
13
16
2
66
23
14
15
17
3
72
23
15
15
17
3
73
21
13
13
17
2
66
20
13
14
18
3
68
20
14
15
17
3
69
22
14
13
16
2
67
23
14
14
18
3
72
619
20,633
33
407
13,566
67
72
2,4
1993
66,43
33
23
16
15
18
3
75
15
12
12
14
2
57
401
494
13,366
67
16,46667
APPENDIX 8
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Post-test in
Experimental class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
66
1
4356
66
4356
67
2
4489
134
8978
68
2
4624
136
9248
70
2
4900
140
9800
72
3
5184
216
15552
73
2
5329
146
10658
74
3
5476
222
16428
75
6
5625
450
33750
76
4
5776
304
23104
78
1
6084
78
6084
79
3
6241
237
18723
80
1
6400
80
6400
∑
∑Fi = 30
∑Xi2= 64484
∑FiXi=
2209
∑FiXi2=163
081
xx =
∑ F1X1
2209
=
= 73.63
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 2209 = 4879681
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(163081) − (4879681)
30(30 − 1)
S =
4892430 − 4879681
30(29)
S =
12749
= 14.65
870
S = √14.65 = 3.83
Calculation Process of Mean and Standard Deviation of Post-test in Control
Class
Xi
Fi
Xi2
FiXi
FiXi2
57
2
3249
114
6498
59
1
3481
59
3481
61
1
3721
61
3721
62
1
3844
62
3844
64
3
4096
192
12288
65
3
4225
195
12675
66
4
4356
264
17424
67
4
4489
268
17956
68
3
4624
204
13872
69
1
4761
69
4761
70
1
4900
70
4900
71
1
5041
71
5041
72
3
5184
216
15552
73
1
5329
73
5329
75
1
5625
75
5625
∑
∑Fi = 30
∑Xi2= 66925
∑FiXi= 1993
∑FiXi2= 132967
x=
∑ F1X1
1993
=
= 66.43
∑ F1
30
(F X ) = 1993 = 3972049
S =
S =
n ∑ F X − (∑ F X )
n (n − 1)
30(132967) − (3972049)
30(30 − 1)
S =
3989010 − 3972049
30(29)
S =
16961
= 19.49
870
S = √19.49 = 4.41
APPENDIX 9
Analysis of Post Test Score in Experimental Class and Control Class
X 1 = 73.63
n1 = 30
S1 = 3.8
S12 = 14.44
X 2 = 66.43
n2 = 30
S2 = 4.41
S22 = 19.4
s =
(n 1)s
+ (n 1)s
n + n − 2
(30 − 1)14.44 + (30 − 1)19.44
30 + 30 − 2
(30)14.44 + (30)19.44
58
s
s =
418.76 + 563.76
58
.
s =
=16.94
=√16.94
s = 4.11
X
t
s
1
X
2
1
1
n1
n2
73.63 66.43
4.11
1
30
301
7.2
4.11 0.07
7.2
4.11(0.07)
= 7 .2
1 . 069
t = 6.735
= 0.05
df n1 n 2 2
(30 30 2 )
= 58
t-Table = t (1- ) df
= t (1- 0.05) 58
= t (0.95) 58
= 2.000
t- Calculate = 6.732
t- Table
= 2.000
t- Calculate
> t- table
6.732>2.000
t- Calculate = 6.735
t- Table
= 2.000
t- Calculate > t- table
6.735 > 2.000
APPENDIX 10
Analysis of SPSS for Post Test of Experimental Class and Control Class
Case Processing Summary
Kelas
Cases
Valid
N
Nilai
Missing
Percent
N
Total
Percent
N
Percent
VIII 3
30
100.0%
0
.0%
30
100.0%
VIII 1
30
100.0%
0
.0%
30
100.0%
Tests of Normality
Kolmogorov-Smirnova
Kelas
Nilai
Statistic
df
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
Statistic
df
Sig.
VIII 3
.139
30
.141
.945
30
.127
VIII 1
.126
30
.200*
.962
30
.352
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
*. This is a lower bound of the true significance.
Test of Homogeneity of Variance
Levene
Statistic
Nilai
df1
df2
Sig.
Based on Mean
.115
1
58
.736
Based on Median
.184
1
58
.669
Based on Median and
with adjusted df
.184
1
56.942
.669
Based on trimmed mean
.129
1
58
.721
Descriptives
VAR00002
Kelas VIII 3
Statistic
Mean
95% Confidence Interval
(experimental) for Mean
73.63
Lower Bound
72.20
Upper Bound
75.06
5% Trimmed Mean
73.70
Median
74.50
Variance
14.654
Std. Deviation
VIII 1
.699
3.828
Minimum
66
Maximum
80
Range
14
Interquartile Range
(control)
Std. Error
4
Skewness
-.410
.427
Kurtosis
-.514
.833
Mean
66.40
.803
95% Confidence Interval
for Mean
Lower Bound
64.76
Upper Bound
68.04
5% Trimmed Mean
66.48
Median
66.50
Variance
19.352
Std. Deviation
4.399
Minimum
57
Maximum
75
Range
18
Interquartile Range
4
Skewness
-.324
.427
Kurtosis
.164
.833
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 3
Normal Q-Q Plot of VIII 1
APPENDIX 11
T-Table
APPENDIX 12
Students’ Answer Sheet of Post-Test at Experiment Class
APPENDIX 13
Hamburger graphic organizer
APPENDIX 14
DOCUMENTATION