S IPSE 1206305 Table of Content
CONTENTS
Page
SHEET OF LEGITIMATION ............................................................
i
DECLARATION ..................................................................................
ii
ABSTRACT ..........................................................................................
iii
ABSTRAK .............................................................................................
iv
PREFACE .............................................................................................
v
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ......................................................................
vi
CONTENTS ..........................................................................................
ix
LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................
xi
LIST OF FIGURES ..............................................................................
xiii
LIST OF APPENDICES ......................................................................
xiv
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1
A. Background .................................................................................
1
B. Research Problems .....................................................................
5
C. Research Objectives ...................................................................
5
D. Research Benefits .......................................................................
5
E. Organization Structure of Research Paper .................................
6
CHAPTER II DIORAMAS, STUDENTS’ CREATIVITY, AND
STUDENTS’ UNDERSTANDING
7
A. Dioramas .....................................................................................
7
B. Students’ Creativity ....................................................................
8
C. Students’ Understanding .............................................................
10
D. Ecosystem ...................................................................................
12
E. Relevant Research .......................................................................
19
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
CHAPTER III RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
21
A. Research Method and Research Design .....................................
21
B. Research Subject ........................................................................
22
C. Assumption .................................................................................
22
D. Hypothesis ..................................................................................
23
E. Research Procedures ...................................................................
23
F.
Instructional Tools ......................................................................
27
G. Research Instruments .................................................................
27
H. Instrument Analysis Results .......................................................
38
I.
40
Data Processing ..........................................................................
CHAPTER IV RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
47
A. Students’ Creativity in Creating Dioramas .................................
47
B. Students’ Understanding in Learning Ecosystem .......................
83
C. Correlation of Students’ Creativity and Understanding ..............
91
D. Profile of Students’ Response on Implementation of Dioramas
......................................................................................................
CHAPTER V CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
94
99
A. Conclusion .................................................................................
99
B. Recommendation .......................................................................
100
REFERENCES .....................................................................................
101
APPENDICES ......................................................................................
116
AUTOBIOGRAPHY ............................................................................
130
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Table 2.1 The Cognitive Processes Dimension ....................................
10
Table 2.2 Analysis of Core Competence and Basic Competence
on Ecosystem Topic .............................................................
13
Table 3.1 Pre-test and Post-test Design ................................................
21
Table 3.2 Research Instruments ............................................................
28
Table 3.3 Types of Validity Test ..........................................................
29
Table 3.4 Interpretation of Validity ......................................................
31
Table 3.5 Types of Reliability Test ......................................................
32
Table 3.6 Interpretation of Reliability ..................................................
34
Table 3.7 Difficulty Index ....................................................................
35
Table 3.8 Classification of Discriminating Power ...............................
36
Table 3.9 Recapitulation of Item Test for Students’ Understanding ....
39
Table 3.10 Categorized of Normalized Gain Value ...............................
42
Table 3.11 Interpretation of Correlation Coefficient ..............................
44
Table 3.12 Interpretation of Percentage ..................................................
45
Table 3.13 Scoring Guideline of Students’ Response .............................
45
Table 4.1 Percentage from Students’ Creativity Based on Creativity
Dimension in Experiment Class ............................................
48
Table 4.2 Percentage from Students’ Creativity Based on Creativity
Dimension in Control Class ...................................................
49
Table 4.3 Result of Percentage Students’ Creativity between
Experiment Class and Control Class ......................................
50
Table 4.4 Original Criteria in Experiment Class ....................................
52
Table 4.5 Original Criteria in Control Class ..........................................
53
Table 4.6 Surprising Criteria in Experiment Class .................................
55
Table 4.7 Surprising Criteria in Control Class .......................................
57
Table 4.8 Valuable Criteria in Experiment Class .................................... 59
Table 4.9 Valuable Criteria in Control Class .........................................
60
Table 4.10 Logic Criteria in Experiment Class .......................................
62
Table 4.11 Logic Criteria in Control Class .............................................
63
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
Table 4.12 Useful/Applicable Criteria in Experiment Class ...................
65
Table 4.13 Useful/Applicable Criteria in Control Class .........................
66
Table 4.14 Organism Criteria in Experiment Class ................................
69
Table 4.15 Organism Criteria in Control Class ......................................
70
Table 4.16 Completeness Criteria in Experiment Class .........................
71
Table 4.17 Completeness Criteria in Control Class ...............................
72
Table 4.18 Complexity Criteria in Experiment Class ............................
74
Table 4.19 Complexity Criteria in Control Class ..................................
75
Table 4.20 Understandable Criteria in Experiment Class ......................
76
Table 4.21 Understandable Criteria in Control Class ............................
77
Table 4.22 Artistic Criteria in Experiment Class ...................................
79
Table 4.23 Artistic Criteria in Control Class .........................................
81
Table 4.24 Blue Print of Objective Test (Pre Test and Post Test)
Based on Cognitive Level Domain .......................................
83
Table 4.25 Recapitulation of Students’ Pre Test and Post Test
Based on Cognitive Level Domain .......................................
84
Table 4.26 Result of Pre Test and Post Test Score Based on
Statistic in Experiment and Control Class .............................
87
Table 4.27 Result of Normality Test on Students’ Understanding .........
89
Table 4.28 Result of Homogenity Test on Students’ Understanding ......
89
Table 4.29 Result of Hypothesis Test on Students’ Understanding ........
90
Table 4.30 Correlation of Students’ Creativity and Understanding ........
93
Table 4.31 Recapitulation of Students’ Response ...................................
94
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
Figure 2.1 Ecosystem Dioramas .............................................................
7
Figure 2.2 An Antartic Marine Food Web ..............................................
18
Figure 2.3 Partial Food Web in Atlantic Coast .......................................
19
Figure 3.1 Research Plot .........................................................................
25
Figure 4.1 Percentage Based on Indicator in Novelty Dimension
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
51
Figure 4.2 Percentage Based on Indicator in Resolution Dimension
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
58
Figure 4.3 Percentage Based on Indicator in Elaboration and Synthesis
Dimension between Experiment and Control Class ..............
68
Figure 4.4 Students’ Understanding Based on Cognitive Domain
of Bloom’s Taxonomy in Pre Test and Post Test .................
85
Figure 4.5 Students’ Understanding Based on Normalized Gain Score in
Experiment and Control Class ..............................................
86
Figure 4.6 Students’ Impression Based on Percentage of Questionnaire
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
96
LIST OF APPENDICES
A. INSTRUCTIONAL TOOLS
Appendix A.1 Lesson Plan Experiment Class
Appendix A.2 Lesson Plan Control Class
Appendix A.3 Student’s Worksheet
Appendix A.4 Modul of Diorama
Appendix A.5 Project Design Sheet
Appendix A.6 Rubric of Presentation Scoring
Appendix A.7 Peer Assessment Sheet
Appendix A.8 Power Point Slide
B. RESEARCH INSTRUMENT
Appendix B.1 Rubric of Creativity
Appendix B.2 Instrument Test Before Validation
Appendix B.3 Instrument Test After Validation
Appendix B.4 Questionnaire of Students’ Impression
Appendix B.5 Observation Sheet
C. RESULTS OF RESEARCH DATA
Appendix C.1 Data Processing of Students’ Understanding Score
Appendix C.2 Recapitulation of Students’ Understanding Result
Appendix C.3 Recapitulation of Students’ Creativity Result
Appendix C.4 Data Processing of Students’ Impression Result
Appendix C.5 Data of Validation Result
D. DOCUMENTATION
Appendix D.1 Documentation in Class
Appendix D.2 Documentation of Students’ Product
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
Page
SHEET OF LEGITIMATION ............................................................
i
DECLARATION ..................................................................................
ii
ABSTRACT ..........................................................................................
iii
ABSTRAK .............................................................................................
iv
PREFACE .............................................................................................
v
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ......................................................................
vi
CONTENTS ..........................................................................................
ix
LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................
xi
LIST OF FIGURES ..............................................................................
xiii
LIST OF APPENDICES ......................................................................
xiv
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1
A. Background .................................................................................
1
B. Research Problems .....................................................................
5
C. Research Objectives ...................................................................
5
D. Research Benefits .......................................................................
5
E. Organization Structure of Research Paper .................................
6
CHAPTER II DIORAMAS, STUDENTS’ CREATIVITY, AND
STUDENTS’ UNDERSTANDING
7
A. Dioramas .....................................................................................
7
B. Students’ Creativity ....................................................................
8
C. Students’ Understanding .............................................................
10
D. Ecosystem ...................................................................................
12
E. Relevant Research .......................................................................
19
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
CHAPTER III RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
21
A. Research Method and Research Design .....................................
21
B. Research Subject ........................................................................
22
C. Assumption .................................................................................
22
D. Hypothesis ..................................................................................
23
E. Research Procedures ...................................................................
23
F.
Instructional Tools ......................................................................
27
G. Research Instruments .................................................................
27
H. Instrument Analysis Results .......................................................
38
I.
40
Data Processing ..........................................................................
CHAPTER IV RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
47
A. Students’ Creativity in Creating Dioramas .................................
47
B. Students’ Understanding in Learning Ecosystem .......................
83
C. Correlation of Students’ Creativity and Understanding ..............
91
D. Profile of Students’ Response on Implementation of Dioramas
......................................................................................................
CHAPTER V CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
94
99
A. Conclusion .................................................................................
99
B. Recommendation .......................................................................
100
REFERENCES .....................................................................................
101
APPENDICES ......................................................................................
116
AUTOBIOGRAPHY ............................................................................
130
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Table 2.1 The Cognitive Processes Dimension ....................................
10
Table 2.2 Analysis of Core Competence and Basic Competence
on Ecosystem Topic .............................................................
13
Table 3.1 Pre-test and Post-test Design ................................................
21
Table 3.2 Research Instruments ............................................................
28
Table 3.3 Types of Validity Test ..........................................................
29
Table 3.4 Interpretation of Validity ......................................................
31
Table 3.5 Types of Reliability Test ......................................................
32
Table 3.6 Interpretation of Reliability ..................................................
34
Table 3.7 Difficulty Index ....................................................................
35
Table 3.8 Classification of Discriminating Power ...............................
36
Table 3.9 Recapitulation of Item Test for Students’ Understanding ....
39
Table 3.10 Categorized of Normalized Gain Value ...............................
42
Table 3.11 Interpretation of Correlation Coefficient ..............................
44
Table 3.12 Interpretation of Percentage ..................................................
45
Table 3.13 Scoring Guideline of Students’ Response .............................
45
Table 4.1 Percentage from Students’ Creativity Based on Creativity
Dimension in Experiment Class ............................................
48
Table 4.2 Percentage from Students’ Creativity Based on Creativity
Dimension in Control Class ...................................................
49
Table 4.3 Result of Percentage Students’ Creativity between
Experiment Class and Control Class ......................................
50
Table 4.4 Original Criteria in Experiment Class ....................................
52
Table 4.5 Original Criteria in Control Class ..........................................
53
Table 4.6 Surprising Criteria in Experiment Class .................................
55
Table 4.7 Surprising Criteria in Control Class .......................................
57
Table 4.8 Valuable Criteria in Experiment Class .................................... 59
Table 4.9 Valuable Criteria in Control Class .........................................
60
Table 4.10 Logic Criteria in Experiment Class .......................................
62
Table 4.11 Logic Criteria in Control Class .............................................
63
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
Table 4.12 Useful/Applicable Criteria in Experiment Class ...................
65
Table 4.13 Useful/Applicable Criteria in Control Class .........................
66
Table 4.14 Organism Criteria in Experiment Class ................................
69
Table 4.15 Organism Criteria in Control Class ......................................
70
Table 4.16 Completeness Criteria in Experiment Class .........................
71
Table 4.17 Completeness Criteria in Control Class ...............................
72
Table 4.18 Complexity Criteria in Experiment Class ............................
74
Table 4.19 Complexity Criteria in Control Class ..................................
75
Table 4.20 Understandable Criteria in Experiment Class ......................
76
Table 4.21 Understandable Criteria in Control Class ............................
77
Table 4.22 Artistic Criteria in Experiment Class ...................................
79
Table 4.23 Artistic Criteria in Control Class .........................................
81
Table 4.24 Blue Print of Objective Test (Pre Test and Post Test)
Based on Cognitive Level Domain .......................................
83
Table 4.25 Recapitulation of Students’ Pre Test and Post Test
Based on Cognitive Level Domain .......................................
84
Table 4.26 Result of Pre Test and Post Test Score Based on
Statistic in Experiment and Control Class .............................
87
Table 4.27 Result of Normality Test on Students’ Understanding .........
89
Table 4.28 Result of Homogenity Test on Students’ Understanding ......
89
Table 4.29 Result of Hypothesis Test on Students’ Understanding ........
90
Table 4.30 Correlation of Students’ Creativity and Understanding ........
93
Table 4.31 Recapitulation of Students’ Response ...................................
94
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
Figure 2.1 Ecosystem Dioramas .............................................................
7
Figure 2.2 An Antartic Marine Food Web ..............................................
18
Figure 2.3 Partial Food Web in Atlantic Coast .......................................
19
Figure 3.1 Research Plot .........................................................................
25
Figure 4.1 Percentage Based on Indicator in Novelty Dimension
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
51
Figure 4.2 Percentage Based on Indicator in Resolution Dimension
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
58
Figure 4.3 Percentage Based on Indicator in Elaboration and Synthesis
Dimension between Experiment and Control Class ..............
68
Figure 4.4 Students’ Understanding Based on Cognitive Domain
of Bloom’s Taxonomy in Pre Test and Post Test .................
85
Figure 4.5 Students’ Understanding Based on Normalized Gain Score in
Experiment and Control Class ..............................................
86
Figure 4.6 Students’ Impression Based on Percentage of Questionnaire
between Experiment and Control Class .................................
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
96
LIST OF APPENDICES
A. INSTRUCTIONAL TOOLS
Appendix A.1 Lesson Plan Experiment Class
Appendix A.2 Lesson Plan Control Class
Appendix A.3 Student’s Worksheet
Appendix A.4 Modul of Diorama
Appendix A.5 Project Design Sheet
Appendix A.6 Rubric of Presentation Scoring
Appendix A.7 Peer Assessment Sheet
Appendix A.8 Power Point Slide
B. RESEARCH INSTRUMENT
Appendix B.1 Rubric of Creativity
Appendix B.2 Instrument Test Before Validation
Appendix B.3 Instrument Test After Validation
Appendix B.4 Questionnaire of Students’ Impression
Appendix B.5 Observation Sheet
C. RESULTS OF RESEARCH DATA
Appendix C.1 Data Processing of Students’ Understanding Score
Appendix C.2 Recapitulation of Students’ Understanding Result
Appendix C.3 Recapitulation of Students’ Creativity Result
Appendix C.4 Data Processing of Students’ Impression Result
Appendix C.5 Data of Validation Result
D. DOCUMENTATION
Appendix D.1 Documentation in Class
Appendix D.2 Documentation of Students’ Product
Finish Weny Arntanti, 2016
Keefektifan Diorama Pada Kreativitas Dan Pemahaman Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran
Ekosistem
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu