karl kautsky hitlerism and social democracy
1
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 2
!
" #"
$
%&&&
!
"
%
&
%
#
$
#
'" #
"
#
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 3
!
% &
# $
"
'
"
"
(
"
)
"
"
'
*
"
(
( +
(
"
*
+
(
(
"
"
(
,
-
(
.
(
)
(
/
(
"
" +
"
"
0
(
/
(
"
"
"
"
.
3
2
1
2
4
$
5
+
'
)
"
1
"
1 2
"
(
0
*
"
0
"
(
"
"
6
(
(
( +
(
Karl Kautsky
"
7
Halaman 4
(
8
) "
(
(
"
/
9
*
"
*
"
(
:
" )
#
3
6
)
"(
;
"
)
"
"
4
(
*
1
*
*
(
1
(
"
"
(
(
"
(
(
(
(
*
"
=
+
"
"
'
< /
"1
"
(
"
(
(
)
,
+
+ .
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 5
(
"
$
"
(
(
(
*
)
*
.(
.
$
( "
.
"
(
9 "
$
"
"
'
"
(
(
"
(
(
)
(
(
(
(
'
(
+
,
(
" )
9 "
"
(
)
)
(
"
(
"
/
"
)
( +
>
(
? !
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 6
@!@
)
(
@!@A
.
-
#
( (
@ )
"
"
=
8
.
(
"
"
@
"
,
"
.
"
)
?@
? ! )
.
" (
#
"
+
)
"
@!@ (
)
(
(
*
"
"
@
"
+
'
(
"
(
-
#
)
*
8
%
#
"
( ;
)
)
,
B
>
)
"
( +
"
)
)
-
#
)
$
-
"
)
"(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 7
#
#
)
@
*
(
(
*
$
(
#
:
)
(
(
(
,
"
(
6 (
(
"
(
-
+
"
(
(
)
5
+
>
'
? % =
"(
(
%& (
(
(
#
"
(
@
'
(
-
"
( +
'
#
(
(
#
+
(
?@
*
"
(
)
"
(
"
B
*
C
)
(
" 5
,
"
"
'
"
+
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 8
"
)
(
"
*
)
"
(
*
"
"
#
*
(
0
*
)
(
+
,
)
#
"
,
*
(
(
(
"
"
#
*
"
"
"D
6
(
"
"
"
2
(
,
(
"
6
7
*
" )
(
"
'
(
+
"
(
$
'
(
(
Karl Kautsky
*
:
Halaman 9
#
E
.
"
D
2
'
"
%
"
"(
*
(
9
"
"
G
0
%& &&& &&& (
" A ?F
(
.
( +
(
,
(
"
8
" @H
%@
"
D
" G?
' -
( +
(
!H
( +
" &
(
"
% !
"
8
'
"
( +
8
"
>
" (
" ' 0
$
"
"
%
2
(
'
+
(
A
6 (
(
1
)
(
( +
(
*
5
(
(
(
J
"
"
"
C
.
"
%& )
(
(
(
"
+
(
.
"
"
(
)
(
+
(
"
)
"
C
+
)
%&
8
"(
)
"(
+
" (
(
(
"
Karl Kautsky
*
'
%&
"
(
(
)
Halaman 14
+ (
$
+
2
"
8
#
(
"
,
)
"
(
"
9
+"
*
)
,
)
"
"
B
"(
%@
(
"
"
6
(
"
.
"
% &
" (
%
D
"
G
(
0
0
)
"
"
A
"
"
(
#
(
"
"
(
=
"
(
+
" "
(
(
'
"
"
+
9
"
B
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 15
"
+
.
"
.
"
)
"
(
"
"
@!@
"
*
-
"
.
"
(
' (
"
D
)
".
(
(
-
"
D
"
( +
"
" '
4 (
"
*
(
(
0
.
2
/
"1
"
0
.
3D $
(
4
0
1'
3
%
"
Karl Kautsky
/
(
0
(
"
*
" 5
0
'
)( "
Halaman 16
(
%@
#
(
%
&? ' (
(
"
(
"(
#
" %
"
9
( "
"(
"
"
"
.
"
"
$
(
(
"
"
"
"
(
6
(
" (
(
(
"
"
)
+
(
"(
$
)
" "
(
"
,
(
$
(
(
"
(
)
(
"
9
" (
+
(
"
(
(
(
(
"
+
Karl Kautsky
)
(
(
Halaman 17
+ (
"
I
( A
+
I
"
(
$
'
.
"
$
(
+
:
( "
(
(
9
"
(
$
)
"
"
"
)
>
(
"
5
"
2
(
(
( "
A
2
'
( +
(
"
(
>
2
,
"
+
(
)
>
"
%@@
G& (
%H&
GG! ' (
"
(
)
#
E
"(
9 "
(
" )
'
"
(
%@
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 18
#
6
>
#
" 5
E
"
8
(
%
#
>
'
"
$
#
(
6
(
(
%
6
" H
(
(
$
"7
(
(
(
"
"
(
"
'
(
(
(
:
"
'
9
"
"
)
(
(
(
(
(
9
>
"
K
(
(
2
(
"
(
*
,
#
=
+
(
"
"
,
"
(
Karl Kautsky
(
Halaman 19
+
+
9
" 2
"
(
(
$
"
' D
'
&
+
(
)
6
"
9
)
9
)
D
5
(
"
(
"
" )
"
)
(
(
(
"
(
"
$
(
8
"
(
(
"
"
"
(
"
(
)
(
;
"
"
"
"
+
( +
)
"
"
9
"
"
5
(
*
(
"
+
$
"
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 20
"
(
"
"
"
(
"( +
" ) "
"+
"
(
"
(
5
"
"
(
9
)
+
(
"
"
(
)
"
+
(
"
+
" "
(
"
)
"(
"
"
)
>
$
(
"
+
(
:
"
+
#
>
(
"
(
"
:
+
$
"
,
5
(
1 )
"
"
(
(
+
"
0
"
8
Karl Kautsky
)
3
4
"
)
2
(
*
"
"
.
*
"
;
0
0
=
0
(
%
*
(
"
2
G!
2
0
*
Halaman 21
( +
>
%@
'
#
0
?
(" (
" )
(
0
(
)
(
"
0
"
0
2
"
"
" (
*
"
(
.
"
"
(
*
"
"
0
&
"
"( +
"(
#
(
(
"
0
)
" '
(
(
0
" (
)
"
"
$
"
(
(
;
Karl Kautsky
6
+
"
,
Halaman 22
; 30
4
'
"
6
(
)
2
"
5
*
"
+
(
" )
*
(
" (
(
0
)
(
( +
(
"
"
2
"
+
"
#
)
(
%
/
'
%!
%!
"
"
'
?
! (
&? '
"
"
%@
/
7 &
0
9
(
(
(
$
(
3D $
(
4
(
(
)
0
(
"
*
(
0
"
9
0
(
+
"
(
(
(
(
Karl Kautsky
)
(
Halaman 23
0
I
"
"
(
"
"
( +
K
(
" (
"
"
'
(
+
"
(
"
"
"
( +
(
"
(
"
,
+
(
(
"
(
(
"
)
(
+
+
(
(
"
(
+
(
"
)
=
"
4
3
$
"
,
"
"
3
(
"
)
"
)
"
"
4
"
"
(
"
(
+ (
)
"
"
(
(
)
"
" - ""
(
) "
6
Karl Kautsky
.
)
C
Halaman 24
(
4 '
B
3
K
(
"
(
"
"
9
"
0
9 "
(
(
)
(
(
5
"
)
(
,
. +
(
8
"(
"
"
7
)
(
*
"
0
"
" )
(
"
*
(
(
"
)
(
(
+
"
A
A
"
( +
A
(
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
" "
Halaman 25
(
)
( "
(
(
+
)
0
"
"
+ (
+
(
35 (
4
(
(
(
(
"
"
"
0
(
$
5
"
" $
9
)
'
"
*
/
)
B
"
#
(
(
/
"
"
"
)
:
5
"
"
(
(
(
(
(
(
,
"
((
"
"
(
"
)
(
A
"
(
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 26
(
(
)
(
5
"(
" (
9
"
"
"
E
(
"
*
"
"
"
*
(
"
(
"
'
*
"
(
"
(
5
(
*
"
'
"
(
"
(
)
8
"
"
:
>
9
"
)
)
#
"
$
E
%G
+
"
"
6
0
Karl Kautsky
>
"
"
"
(
"(
#
5
Halaman 27
"
'
"
"
(
(
(
>
" :
(
+ +
"
"
(
+
(
"
"
9
0
(
(
+
"
0
(
(
"
(
"
=
(
"
'
"
(
(
"
"
"
(
)
+
(
3
$
4)
(
(
-
(
"
:
(
"
/
5
(
.
(
" (
(
(
"
+
"
"
)
3
*
4
2
"
'
(
3
4 5
(
"
3
; 3-
(
4 )
"
"
"(
"
* + 4
Karl Kautsky
=
3
Halaman 28
4(
6
7
/
"
"
" (
"
"
"
"
"
5
2
@?@ (
(
(
+7
( .
/
=
6
$
(
(
8
(
( +
(
I
"
(
)
"
(
B
(
(
"
'
(
(
(
"
(
"
(
"
" (
"
Karl Kautsky
' &
Halaman 29
&
(
(
( "
(
9
.
)
"
"
"
,
( (
"
(
2
(
.
"
(
.
"
(
>
,
"
6
(
7
"(
( -
'
"
(
"
(
6
7
(
0
(
/
(
=
8
>
(
"
0
+
0
(
)
"
0
(
8
+
"
7
( (
)
0 8
) "
$
0 8
(
"
Karl Kautsky
"
(
@ (
(
"
Halaman 30
"
; 3'
0 8
(
( (
(
(
4
)
; 3/
*
" (
(
+
+
0 8
(
"
L
"
74
'
"
(
,
0
"
$
"
(
"
(
3#
(
(
4
)
(
"
(
? !(
?@ :
"
" -
'
? %
(
(
(
"
=
(
'
(
"
(
"
(
/
(
+
" )
(
"
(
(
"
$
(
(
(
(
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 31
"
" (
"
+
)
+
(
"
(
"
)
(
(
"
"
"
8
" $,
"
. .
)
D
"
,
)
" '
(
"
(
/
+
(
" (
" (
"
(
.
6
"
+
(
+
'
(
"
"
"
+
" (
" 6
(
(
(
,
(
(
(
(
)
(
3
(
"
4
"
#
Karl Kautsky
(
"
K
Halaman 32
9
"
(
(
"
'
'
"(
8
"
(
'
(
" (
"
(
,
(
(
(
"
:
"
(
"
"
>
5
(
(
(
' (
"
(
" (
"
"
(
)
(
(
(
(
(
.
"
"
"
(
"
"
,
"
(
(
@ G
?@
(
*
'
(
(
(
-
5
(
#
(
? %
(
(
Karl Kautsky
(
(
(
Halaman 33
)
+
(
"
'
"
(
"
(
(
"
9 "
9
"
)
(
+
5
(
(
"
"
"
(
"
+
"
(
(
(
D
-
@?&
?
)
*
"
"
0
(
#
)
@
"
'
"
"
:
)
"
)
(
(
(
8
"
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
(
"
)
(
" =
#
.
(
*
6
7
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 34
'
(
(
(
"
+
=
"
0
$
'
,
(
(
"
0
"
(
"
"
)
? %. ? !
-
(
"
?@
" :
,
(
(
? % D
(
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
"
' (
(
=
.
(
>
( +
=
(
"
(
/
"
'
)
"
,
"
"
"
,
"(
(
"(
(
"
"
>
$
"
+
Karl Kautsky
.
Halaman 35
(
"
"
"
"
= "
.
)
"(
5
? %. ? !
5
(
(
"
,
"
"
'
5 +
"
" $
"
"
"
(
"
(
(
(
(
(
#
/
(
'
"
8
+
"
"
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
/
Halaman 36
"
"
(
>
"
"
D
6
6
"
)
+
(
"
/
"
(
(
+
$
.
"
)
"
9
"
)
"
$
$
"
"
"
$
"
(
B
"
)
(
"
"(
"
I
9
9
"
"
$
"
(
)
" (
(
5
)
$
"
"
" (
"
$
(
Karl Kautsky
:
(
(
Halaman 37
(
"
"
"
(
(
(
(
#
"
2
2
"
"
(
"
(
(
" +
)
"(
'
"
)
8
(
"
(
"
(
"
( ;
.
"
9
"
(
"
"
'
(
'
(
(
(
+
I
I
9
"
"
$
"
" )
"
(
)
(
"
" I
Karl Kautsky
"
(
'
Halaman 38
(
)
$
/
(
"
(
"
"
(
(
"
I'
:
"
"
)
(
"
(
"
$
)
"
/
.
+
) "
"
"
(
( +
+
4 )
(
+
( +
(
;3
"
"
"
+
"
"
$
"
"
"
)
(
"
"
"
,
+
(
"
=
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 39
"
"
'
"
#
??H
+
#
-
?@
"
"
"
" )
"
0
(
(
5
(
(
(
(
' "
$
(
(
8
"
" 6 (
"
"
$
(
(
"
1 K
#
"
(
-
(
(
.
"
"
(
.
(
-
??% (
(
(
"
)
(
+
"
(
-
"
)
(
(
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
0
>
Halaman 40
"
+
"
)
*
(
@ G
? %
@ !
"
#
(
:
"
5
/
(
>
(
-
+
"
@ &
"
"
"
? %. ? !
(
0
(
"
(
"
(
"
"
$
+
+
" '
( +
)
(
"
(
0
(
"
)
(
"
"
"
(
)
( +
)
7
(
"
D
"
(
B
"
@!@
5
>
"
A
J
+(
"
Karl Kautsky
'
"C
Halaman 41
" 0
'
@ &
+
"
+
"
"
(
)
"
(
)
"
( "
(
"
"
( +
D
7
>
@?
(
(
"
)
"
"
5
(
>
(
(
)
>
"
'
>
( +
H )
"
$
2
)
(
(
(
(
(
" "
2
' (
(
5
(
"
>
(
5
,
)
'
"
'
5
(
"
,
>
;
(
2
(
. (
"
"
$
$
Karl Kautsky
'
,
Halaman 42
(
"
"
"
(
(
(
"
G%@
/
+
(
"1
"
(
"
"
#
D
*
"
0
28
+
@
"
'
( +
?
=
(
"
"
( "
0
"
" )
(
" (
"
"
"
' (
(
"
0
=
D
D " % .%@ (
)
@
(
+
" %! @!@
>
(
(
%
D
% @!@
B
"
@?
(
"( + D "
8"
>
2
"
Karl Kautsky
)
"
Halaman 43
"
"
"
"
"
(
(
(
)
(
"(
"
$
"
=
"
(
"
"
8
(
9
( "
)
(
"
"
)
"
" (
$
(
9
"
(
"
"
" (
"
Karl Kautsky
)
*
!#
"
"
Halaman 44
+
(
(
(
=
(
$
"
$
(
$
5
(
(
"
"
"(
"
(
)
5
-
(
(
#
8
)
"
(
" (
"
"
(
(
"
" )
"
(
(
+
$
+
"
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 45
$
(
"
"
;
"
'
"
9
"
(
+
"
0
(
0
( $
.
(
/
"
'
(
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
'
=
(
(
"
"
"
"
(
(
"
+ ,
.
)
"
(
" "
"
(
)
"
"
""
(
@?
(
,
+
(
"
-
8
"
"
)
(
+ (
)
+
)
Karl Kautsky
"
(
+
(
"
"
+
+
I
Halaman 46
"
. (
8
)
+
8
)
I (
$
,
D
"
"
"
"
$
(
)
"
(
)
"
"
(
$
)
)
$
"
"
'
"
(
+
"
"
"
) "
8
(
(
)
(
"
( +
"
"
8
8
"
Karl Kautsky
(
Halaman 47
"
9
(
(
"(
(
"
(
+
"
"
(
(
(
( +
( +
"(
" )
)
' (
(
.
(
,
)
(
)
"
(
( +
" '
(
(
"
$
+
"
(
"
+
"
"
8
)
'
.
"
(
(
"
(
"
"
8
"
"
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 48
" "
5
"
(
"
"
""
(
(
)
"
(
" D $
:
'
(
(
(
,
"
,
)
(
'
"
"
(
(
(
" D $
(
(
(
" +
( +
"
$
(
(
(
'
"
+
(
(
(
@!@
( +
(
(
)
+(
,
0
"
( +
>
Karl Kautsky
D $
:
(
5
Halaman 49
(
( +
8
(
(
( +
"
( +
(
(
"
( +
8
A
,
"
(
( +
"
(
"
+
' (
.
+
"
(
(
( (
(
( +
( +
-
+
(
8
5
( +
+
)
"
"
(
(
(
"
"
(
8
"
"
(
+(
"
(
.
5"
"
(
"
8
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 50
"
(
(
)
"
> +
+
+
+ (
3"
(
E
(
)
(4
.
(
8
(
$
(
"
8
"
" (
(
( +
"
"
"
3"
9
"
(4
"
)
9
"
+
"
( (
)
$
(
"
)
(
( "
"
"
+
=
"
K
(
(
"
"
(
(
(
'
"
@ G
(
8
" :
(
)
9 "
'
.
"
(
)
(
"
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 51
(
(
2
(
(
"
$
(
" '
(
(
-
:
0
?&
'
"
? !
(
(
?&&. ? @ ? H
) + "A
)
>
(
(
(
? H. ?
(
#
(
(
(
(
( "
K
(
#
. ? G
(
+ ''
-
:
+
(
(
(
? @
(
(
? ?
?%&
(
(
(
"
(
?
) +
#
(
>
(
"
(
(
(
)
?!&. ?!@
?GH. ?H
)
>
>
(
(
?H@ (
#
.) +
??%
"
(
?H@. ??!
)
(
/
(
:
(
#
:
+
(
"
(
#
>
;
(
0
(
) +
(
??@. ?@%
?@?
(
(
Karl Kautsky
'
? %
)
(
(
" @ G
?&&
Halaman 52
:
(
@ G
(
( "
( A
(
6 (
(
"
@ G
!< ' :
(
(
(
"
@ G
@G!
(
@?@
! )
(
@G!
@?@ (
( (
5
(
(
(
D
I
2
(
#
.) +
(
@??.?@
) "
:
' :
(
"
( ;
'
(
(
@G
.>
(
@HH
.*
(
@?&.? ) "
(
8
"
0 .
"
(
@ G
!
(
"
(
:
(
' ' "
(
D " %& @G
%!
"
'
(
(
>
@HH
%H
" %% )
(
(
"
(
) .*
(
(
, +" )
(
%
@?& 5"
0
'''
"
+
(
"
*
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
(
"
Halaman 53
"
(
" 5
5
+
"
"
"
>
(
9 ".
$
"
(
(
" @? (
*
"
+
(
$
.
)
(
=
(
=
!
;
8 (
"
(
-
(
"
5
(
(
.
(
(
(
@?&.?
(
@ G
!
(
:
" 5
@ G
)
(
(
"
>
"
"
( +
(
(
"
(
(
+
"
(
+
(
"
( +
(
(
)
2
E
"
( "
"
,
"
(
3
(
" 4
"
(
"
Karl Kautsky
5
Halaman 54
"
(
'
=
/
"
/
(
"
( +
"
(
@
(
)
$
"
(
@ G
(
"
"
$
( +
! (
(
"
(
)
(
" (
(
(
.
.
(
!
Karl Kautsky
)
,
)
/
)
(
(
!
"
/
Halaman 55
(
"
"
(
"
(
"
"
$
"
"
"
"
"
(
)
(
"
,
"
"
"
(
"
"
(
"
"
D
:
(
"
"
(
" (
(
$
$
)
"
=
(
"
"
8
( +
(
(
(
"
(
8
(
(
'
(
'
"
"(
"
+
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 56
(
"
(
(
(
( +
"
(
( +
)
(
8
(
(
8
(
)
"
(
(
8
"
"
+
"
" ( +
"
,
"
"
(
" (
$
:
#
"
(
(
.
( +
/
8
(
"(
(
"
(
( A
2
(
(
:
"
(
,
" (
(
(
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 57
(
,
"
(
8
8
)
"
"
"
.
)
(
(
)
(
"
(
"
5
;
(
( +
"
(
2
"
(
(
( +
(
5
"
(
"
"(
"
"
:
"
"
"
9
'
(
(
3
"
"
8 (
4
$
=
"
"
5
"
(
(
"
D $
D $
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 58
'
"
( +
(
( +
"
(
"
.
"
.
(
+
9
(
"
:$
+
"
(
"
?
@
+
)
(
"
(
"
"
2
(
:
/
(
"
"
&G
@ &
? 5
(
(
"
*
(
" )
"
,
@!@
@?
(
"
.
.
(
(
(
+"
(
"
$
"
.
)
(
"
"
"
6
"(
.
"
"
.
"
Karl Kautsky
)
#
5
)
Halaman 59
+
5
(
(
(
"(
"
"
2
"
(
(
(
( +
)
0
(
$
"
(
"
'
(
+
5
+
(
"
+ "
D
+
5
"
"
+
"
(
5
$
+
"
" "
(
"
"
+(
( +
"
" "
"
.
(
0
"
"
(
"
D
" 5
"
'
"
; 35
(
0
Halaman 64
@
(
+
(
5
(
2
#
(
"
#
(
*
5
(
C
+
(
+
"
.
"
#
$
"
"
"
5
(
"
/
8
"
(
*
1
/
*
"
"
"
,
(
(
,
"
(
)
(
*
(
0 (
"
*
"
(
(
+*
"7
(
6
*
"
@
(
Karl Kautsky
*
Halaman 65
"
(
" 6
"
"
(
)
((
(
(
*
(
' (
*
"
"
"
(
"
>
)
"
.
"
(
(
(
(
0
(
"
" (
"
#
>
+
4
)
"
"
" (
3)
(
(
(
"
'
"
"
"
(
"
)
"
(
(
" (
(
" #
(
((
"
" "
( (
"
(
'
(
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 66
(
"
(
(
(
(
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
(
(
(
-
"
(
+
9
(
)
"
6 (
+
(
"
3
(
4
(
( +
(
"
"
:,
" (
8
0
"
"(
"
,
"
5
9
(
"
"
(
(
$
-
(
8
#
(
( ;3
"
" :,
"4
" -
+
"
8
(
+
(
=
(
"
,
(
"
8
)
( +
(
Karl Kautsky
"
"
"
Halaman 67
8
" "
A
"
)
"
(
6
(
(
,
"
"
"
"
0 8
)
(
"
"
"
"
3
(
4
+
" E
(
"
"
/
9
(
" "
"
)
*
6
( +
" )
(
(
/
(
"
/
(
"
+
(
6
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 2
!
" #"
$
%&&&
!
"
%
&
%
#
$
#
'" #
"
#
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 3
!
% &
# $
"
'
"
"
(
"
)
"
"
'
*
"
(
( +
(
"
*
+
(
(
"
"
(
,
-
(
.
(
)
(
/
(
"
" +
"
"
0
(
/
(
"
"
"
"
.
3
2
1
2
4
$
5
+
'
)
"
1
"
1 2
"
(
0
*
"
0
"
(
"
"
6
(
(
( +
(
Karl Kautsky
"
7
Halaman 4
(
8
) "
(
(
"
/
9
*
"
*
"
(
:
" )
#
3
6
)
"(
;
"
)
"
"
4
(
*
1
*
*
(
1
(
"
"
(
(
"
(
(
(
(
*
"
=
+
"
"
'
< /
"1
"
(
"
(
(
)
,
+
+ .
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 5
(
"
$
"
(
(
(
*
)
*
.(
.
$
( "
.
"
(
9 "
$
"
"
'
"
(
(
"
(
(
)
(
(
(
(
'
(
+
,
(
" )
9 "
"
(
)
)
(
"
(
"
/
"
)
( +
>
(
? !
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 6
@!@
)
(
@!@A
.
-
#
( (
@ )
"
"
=
8
.
(
"
"
@
"
,
"
.
"
)
?@
? ! )
.
" (
#
"
+
)
"
@!@ (
)
(
(
*
"
"
@
"
+
'
(
"
(
-
#
)
*
8
%
#
"
( ;
)
)
,
B
>
)
"
( +
"
)
)
-
#
)
$
-
"
)
"(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 7
#
#
)
@
*
(
(
*
$
(
#
:
)
(
(
(
,
"
(
6 (
(
"
(
-
+
"
(
(
)
5
+
>
'
? % =
"(
(
%& (
(
(
#
"
(
@
'
(
-
"
( +
'
#
(
(
#
+
(
?@
*
"
(
)
"
(
"
B
*
C
)
(
" 5
,
"
"
'
"
+
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 8
"
)
(
"
*
)
"
(
*
"
"
#
*
(
0
*
)
(
+
,
)
#
"
,
*
(
(
(
"
"
#
*
"
"
"D
6
(
"
"
"
2
(
,
(
"
6
7
*
" )
(
"
'
(
+
"
(
$
'
(
(
Karl Kautsky
*
:
Halaman 9
#
E
.
"
D
2
'
"
%
"
"(
*
(
9
"
"
G
0
%& &&& &&& (
" A ?F
(
.
( +
(
,
(
"
8
" @H
%@
"
D
" G?
' -
( +
(
!H
( +
" &
(
"
% !
"
8
'
"
( +
8
"
>
" (
" ' 0
$
"
"
%
2
(
'
+
(
A
6 (
(
1
)
(
( +
(
*
5
(
(
(
J
"
"
"
C
.
"
%& )
(
(
(
"
+
(
.
"
"
(
)
(
+
(
"
)
"
C
+
)
%&
8
"(
)
"(
+
" (
(
(
"
Karl Kautsky
*
'
%&
"
(
(
)
Halaman 14
+ (
$
+
2
"
8
#
(
"
,
)
"
(
"
9
+"
*
)
,
)
"
"
B
"(
%@
(
"
"
6
(
"
.
"
% &
" (
%
D
"
G
(
0
0
)
"
"
A
"
"
(
#
(
"
"
(
=
"
(
+
" "
(
(
'
"
"
+
9
"
B
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 15
"
+
.
"
.
"
)
"
(
"
"
@!@
"
*
-
"
.
"
(
' (
"
D
)
".
(
(
-
"
D
"
( +
"
" '
4 (
"
*
(
(
0
.
2
/
"1
"
0
.
3D $
(
4
0
1'
3
%
"
Karl Kautsky
/
(
0
(
"
*
" 5
0
'
)( "
Halaman 16
(
%@
#
(
%
&? ' (
(
"
(
"(
#
" %
"
9
( "
"(
"
"
"
.
"
"
$
(
(
"
"
"
"
(
6
(
" (
(
(
"
"
)
+
(
"(
$
)
" "
(
"
,
(
$
(
(
"
(
)
(
"
9
" (
+
(
"
(
(
(
(
"
+
Karl Kautsky
)
(
(
Halaman 17
+ (
"
I
( A
+
I
"
(
$
'
.
"
$
(
+
:
( "
(
(
9
"
(
$
)
"
"
"
)
>
(
"
5
"
2
(
(
( "
A
2
'
( +
(
"
(
>
2
,
"
+
(
)
>
"
%@@
G& (
%H&
GG! ' (
"
(
)
#
E
"(
9 "
(
" )
'
"
(
%@
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 18
#
6
>
#
" 5
E
"
8
(
%
#
>
'
"
$
#
(
6
(
(
%
6
" H
(
(
$
"7
(
(
(
"
"
(
"
'
(
(
(
:
"
'
9
"
"
)
(
(
(
(
(
9
>
"
K
(
(
2
(
"
(
*
,
#
=
+
(
"
"
,
"
(
Karl Kautsky
(
Halaman 19
+
+
9
" 2
"
(
(
$
"
' D
'
&
+
(
)
6
"
9
)
9
)
D
5
(
"
(
"
" )
"
)
(
(
(
"
(
"
$
(
8
"
(
(
"
"
"
(
"
(
)
(
;
"
"
"
"
+
( +
)
"
"
9
"
"
5
(
*
(
"
+
$
"
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 20
"
(
"
"
"
(
"( +
" ) "
"+
"
(
"
(
5
"
"
(
9
)
+
(
"
"
(
)
"
+
(
"
+
" "
(
"
)
"(
"
"
)
>
$
(
"
+
(
:
"
+
#
>
(
"
(
"
:
+
$
"
,
5
(
1 )
"
"
(
(
+
"
0
"
8
Karl Kautsky
)
3
4
"
)
2
(
*
"
"
.
*
"
;
0
0
=
0
(
%
*
(
"
2
G!
2
0
*
Halaman 21
( +
>
%@
'
#
0
?
(" (
" )
(
0
(
)
(
"
0
"
0
2
"
"
" (
*
"
(
.
"
"
(
*
"
"
0
&
"
"( +
"(
#
(
(
"
0
)
" '
(
(
0
" (
)
"
"
$
"
(
(
;
Karl Kautsky
6
+
"
,
Halaman 22
; 30
4
'
"
6
(
)
2
"
5
*
"
+
(
" )
*
(
" (
(
0
)
(
( +
(
"
"
2
"
+
"
#
)
(
%
/
'
%!
%!
"
"
'
?
! (
&? '
"
"
%@
/
7 &
0
9
(
(
(
$
(
3D $
(
4
(
(
)
0
(
"
*
(
0
"
9
0
(
+
"
(
(
(
(
Karl Kautsky
)
(
Halaman 23
0
I
"
"
(
"
"
( +
K
(
" (
"
"
'
(
+
"
(
"
"
"
( +
(
"
(
"
,
+
(
(
"
(
(
"
)
(
+
+
(
(
"
(
+
(
"
)
=
"
4
3
$
"
,
"
"
3
(
"
)
"
)
"
"
4
"
"
(
"
(
+ (
)
"
"
(
(
)
"
" - ""
(
) "
6
Karl Kautsky
.
)
C
Halaman 24
(
4 '
B
3
K
(
"
(
"
"
9
"
0
9 "
(
(
)
(
(
5
"
)
(
,
. +
(
8
"(
"
"
7
)
(
*
"
0
"
" )
(
"
*
(
(
"
)
(
(
+
"
A
A
"
( +
A
(
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
" "
Halaman 25
(
)
( "
(
(
+
)
0
"
"
+ (
+
(
35 (
4
(
(
(
(
"
"
"
0
(
$
5
"
" $
9
)
'
"
*
/
)
B
"
#
(
(
/
"
"
"
)
:
5
"
"
(
(
(
(
(
(
,
"
((
"
"
(
"
)
(
A
"
(
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 26
(
(
)
(
5
"(
" (
9
"
"
"
E
(
"
*
"
"
"
*
(
"
(
"
'
*
"
(
"
(
5
(
*
"
'
"
(
"
(
)
8
"
"
:
>
9
"
)
)
#
"
$
E
%G
+
"
"
6
0
Karl Kautsky
>
"
"
"
(
"(
#
5
Halaman 27
"
'
"
"
(
(
(
>
" :
(
+ +
"
"
(
+
(
"
"
9
0
(
(
+
"
0
(
(
"
(
"
=
(
"
'
"
(
(
"
"
"
(
)
+
(
3
$
4)
(
(
-
(
"
:
(
"
/
5
(
.
(
" (
(
(
"
+
"
"
)
3
*
4
2
"
'
(
3
4 5
(
"
3
; 3-
(
4 )
"
"
"(
"
* + 4
Karl Kautsky
=
3
Halaman 28
4(
6
7
/
"
"
" (
"
"
"
"
"
5
2
@?@ (
(
(
+7
( .
/
=
6
$
(
(
8
(
( +
(
I
"
(
)
"
(
B
(
(
"
'
(
(
(
"
(
"
(
"
" (
"
Karl Kautsky
' &
Halaman 29
&
(
(
( "
(
9
.
)
"
"
"
,
( (
"
(
2
(
.
"
(
.
"
(
>
,
"
6
(
7
"(
( -
'
"
(
"
(
6
7
(
0
(
/
(
=
8
>
(
"
0
+
0
(
)
"
0
(
8
+
"
7
( (
)
0 8
) "
$
0 8
(
"
Karl Kautsky
"
(
@ (
(
"
Halaman 30
"
; 3'
0 8
(
( (
(
(
4
)
; 3/
*
" (
(
+
+
0 8
(
"
L
"
74
'
"
(
,
0
"
$
"
(
"
(
3#
(
(
4
)
(
"
(
? !(
?@ :
"
" -
'
? %
(
(
(
"
=
(
'
(
"
(
"
(
/
(
+
" )
(
"
(
(
"
$
(
(
(
(
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 31
"
" (
"
+
)
+
(
"
(
"
)
(
(
"
"
"
8
" $,
"
. .
)
D
"
,
)
" '
(
"
(
/
+
(
" (
" (
"
(
.
6
"
+
(
+
'
(
"
"
"
+
" (
" 6
(
(
(
,
(
(
(
(
)
(
3
(
"
4
"
#
Karl Kautsky
(
"
K
Halaman 32
9
"
(
(
"
'
'
"(
8
"
(
'
(
" (
"
(
,
(
(
(
"
:
"
(
"
"
>
5
(
(
(
' (
"
(
" (
"
"
(
)
(
(
(
(
(
.
"
"
"
(
"
"
,
"
(
(
@ G
?@
(
*
'
(
(
(
-
5
(
#
(
? %
(
(
Karl Kautsky
(
(
(
Halaman 33
)
+
(
"
'
"
(
"
(
(
"
9 "
9
"
)
(
+
5
(
(
"
"
"
(
"
+
"
(
(
(
D
-
@?&
?
)
*
"
"
0
(
#
)
@
"
'
"
"
:
)
"
)
(
(
(
8
"
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
(
"
)
(
" =
#
.
(
*
6
7
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 34
'
(
(
(
"
+
=
"
0
$
'
,
(
(
"
0
"
(
"
"
)
? %. ? !
-
(
"
?@
" :
,
(
(
? % D
(
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
"
' (
(
=
.
(
>
( +
=
(
"
(
/
"
'
)
"
,
"
"
"
,
"(
(
"(
(
"
"
>
$
"
+
Karl Kautsky
.
Halaman 35
(
"
"
"
"
= "
.
)
"(
5
? %. ? !
5
(
(
"
,
"
"
'
5 +
"
" $
"
"
"
(
"
(
(
(
(
(
#
/
(
'
"
8
+
"
"
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
/
Halaman 36
"
"
(
>
"
"
D
6
6
"
)
+
(
"
/
"
(
(
+
$
.
"
)
"
9
"
)
"
$
$
"
"
"
$
"
(
B
"
)
(
"
"(
"
I
9
9
"
"
$
"
(
)
" (
(
5
)
$
"
"
" (
"
$
(
Karl Kautsky
:
(
(
Halaman 37
(
"
"
"
(
(
(
(
#
"
2
2
"
"
(
"
(
(
" +
)
"(
'
"
)
8
(
"
(
"
(
"
( ;
.
"
9
"
(
"
"
'
(
'
(
(
(
+
I
I
9
"
"
$
"
" )
"
(
)
(
"
" I
Karl Kautsky
"
(
'
Halaman 38
(
)
$
/
(
"
(
"
"
(
(
"
I'
:
"
"
)
(
"
(
"
$
)
"
/
.
+
) "
"
"
(
( +
+
4 )
(
+
( +
(
;3
"
"
"
+
"
"
$
"
"
"
)
(
"
"
"
,
+
(
"
=
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 39
"
"
'
"
#
??H
+
#
-
?@
"
"
"
" )
"
0
(
(
5
(
(
(
(
' "
$
(
(
8
"
" 6 (
"
"
$
(
(
"
1 K
#
"
(
-
(
(
.
"
"
(
.
(
-
??% (
(
(
"
)
(
+
"
(
-
"
)
(
(
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
0
>
Halaman 40
"
+
"
)
*
(
@ G
? %
@ !
"
#
(
:
"
5
/
(
>
(
-
+
"
@ &
"
"
"
? %. ? !
(
0
(
"
(
"
(
"
"
$
+
+
" '
( +
)
(
"
(
0
(
"
)
(
"
"
"
(
)
( +
)
7
(
"
D
"
(
B
"
@!@
5
>
"
A
J
+(
"
Karl Kautsky
'
"C
Halaman 41
" 0
'
@ &
+
"
+
"
"
(
)
"
(
)
"
( "
(
"
"
( +
D
7
>
@?
(
(
"
)
"
"
5
(
>
(
(
)
>
"
'
>
( +
H )
"
$
2
)
(
(
(
(
(
" "
2
' (
(
5
(
"
>
(
5
,
)
'
"
'
5
(
"
,
>
;
(
2
(
. (
"
"
$
$
Karl Kautsky
'
,
Halaman 42
(
"
"
"
(
(
(
"
G%@
/
+
(
"1
"
(
"
"
#
D
*
"
0
28
+
@
"
'
( +
?
=
(
"
"
( "
0
"
" )
(
" (
"
"
"
' (
(
"
0
=
D
D " % .%@ (
)
@
(
+
" %! @!@
>
(
(
%
D
% @!@
B
"
@?
(
"( + D "
8"
>
2
"
Karl Kautsky
)
"
Halaman 43
"
"
"
"
"
(
(
(
)
(
"(
"
$
"
=
"
(
"
"
8
(
9
( "
)
(
"
"
)
"
" (
$
(
9
"
(
"
"
" (
"
Karl Kautsky
)
*
!#
"
"
Halaman 44
+
(
(
(
=
(
$
"
$
(
$
5
(
(
"
"
"(
"
(
)
5
-
(
(
#
8
)
"
(
" (
"
"
(
(
"
" )
"
(
(
+
$
+
"
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 45
$
(
"
"
;
"
'
"
9
"
(
+
"
0
(
0
( $
.
(
/
"
'
(
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
'
=
(
(
"
"
"
"
(
(
"
+ ,
.
)
"
(
" "
"
(
)
"
"
""
(
@?
(
,
+
(
"
-
8
"
"
)
(
+ (
)
+
)
Karl Kautsky
"
(
+
(
"
"
+
+
I
Halaman 46
"
. (
8
)
+
8
)
I (
$
,
D
"
"
"
"
$
(
)
"
(
)
"
"
(
$
)
)
$
"
"
'
"
(
+
"
"
"
) "
8
(
(
)
(
"
( +
"
"
8
8
"
Karl Kautsky
(
Halaman 47
"
9
(
(
"(
(
"
(
+
"
"
(
(
(
( +
( +
"(
" )
)
' (
(
.
(
,
)
(
)
"
(
( +
" '
(
(
"
$
+
"
(
"
+
"
"
8
)
'
.
"
(
(
"
(
"
"
8
"
"
"
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 48
" "
5
"
(
"
"
""
(
(
)
"
(
" D $
:
'
(
(
(
,
"
,
)
(
'
"
"
(
(
(
" D $
(
(
(
" +
( +
"
$
(
(
(
'
"
+
(
(
(
@!@
( +
(
(
)
+(
,
0
"
( +
>
Karl Kautsky
D $
:
(
5
Halaman 49
(
( +
8
(
(
( +
"
( +
(
(
"
( +
8
A
,
"
(
( +
"
(
"
+
' (
.
+
"
(
(
( (
(
( +
( +
-
+
(
8
5
( +
+
)
"
"
(
(
(
"
"
(
8
"
"
(
+(
"
(
.
5"
"
(
"
8
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 50
"
(
(
)
"
> +
+
+
+ (
3"
(
E
(
)
(4
.
(
8
(
$
(
"
8
"
" (
(
( +
"
"
"
3"
9
"
(4
"
)
9
"
+
"
( (
)
$
(
"
)
(
( "
"
"
+
=
"
K
(
(
"
"
(
(
(
'
"
@ G
(
8
" :
(
)
9 "
'
.
"
(
)
(
"
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 51
(
(
2
(
(
"
$
(
" '
(
(
-
:
0
?&
'
"
? !
(
(
?&&. ? @ ? H
) + "A
)
>
(
(
(
? H. ?
(
#
(
(
(
(
( "
K
(
#
. ? G
(
+ ''
-
:
+
(
(
(
? @
(
(
? ?
?%&
(
(
(
"
(
?
) +
#
(
>
(
"
(
(
(
)
?!&. ?!@
?GH. ?H
)
>
>
(
(
?H@ (
#
.) +
??%
"
(
?H@. ??!
)
(
/
(
:
(
#
:
+
(
"
(
#
>
;
(
0
(
) +
(
??@. ?@%
?@?
(
(
Karl Kautsky
'
? %
)
(
(
" @ G
?&&
Halaman 52
:
(
@ G
(
( "
( A
(
6 (
(
"
@ G
!< ' :
(
(
(
"
@ G
@G!
(
@?@
! )
(
@G!
@?@ (
( (
5
(
(
(
D
I
2
(
#
.) +
(
@??.?@
) "
:
' :
(
"
( ;
'
(
(
@G
.>
(
@HH
.*
(
@?&.? ) "
(
8
"
0 .
"
(
@ G
!
(
"
(
:
(
' ' "
(
D " %& @G
%!
"
'
(
(
>
@HH
%H
" %% )
(
(
"
(
) .*
(
(
, +" )
(
%
@?& 5"
0
'''
"
+
(
"
*
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
(
"
Halaman 53
"
(
" 5
5
+
"
"
"
>
(
9 ".
$
"
(
(
" @? (
*
"
+
(
$
.
)
(
=
(
=
!
;
8 (
"
(
-
(
"
5
(
(
.
(
(
(
@?&.?
(
@ G
!
(
:
" 5
@ G
)
(
(
"
>
"
"
( +
(
(
"
(
(
+
"
(
+
(
"
( +
(
(
)
2
E
"
( "
"
,
"
(
3
(
" 4
"
(
"
Karl Kautsky
5
Halaman 54
"
(
'
=
/
"
/
(
"
( +
"
(
@
(
)
$
"
(
@ G
(
"
"
$
( +
! (
(
"
(
)
(
" (
(
(
.
.
(
!
Karl Kautsky
)
,
)
/
)
(
(
!
"
/
Halaman 55
(
"
"
(
"
(
"
"
$
"
"
"
"
"
(
)
(
"
,
"
"
"
(
"
"
(
"
"
D
:
(
"
"
(
" (
(
$
$
)
"
=
(
"
"
8
( +
(
(
(
"
(
8
(
(
'
(
'
"
"(
"
+
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 56
(
"
(
(
(
( +
"
(
( +
)
(
8
(
(
8
(
)
"
(
(
8
"
"
+
"
" ( +
"
,
"
"
(
" (
$
:
#
"
(
(
.
( +
/
8
(
"(
(
"
(
( A
2
(
(
:
"
(
,
" (
(
(
"
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 57
(
,
"
(
8
8
)
"
"
"
.
)
(
(
)
(
"
(
"
5
;
(
( +
"
(
2
"
(
(
( +
(
5
"
(
"
"(
"
"
:
"
"
"
9
'
(
(
3
"
"
8 (
4
$
=
"
"
5
"
(
(
"
D $
D $
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 58
'
"
( +
(
( +
"
(
"
.
"
.
(
+
9
(
"
:$
+
"
(
"
?
@
+
)
(
"
(
"
"
2
(
:
/
(
"
"
&G
@ &
? 5
(
(
"
*
(
" )
"
,
@!@
@?
(
"
.
.
(
(
(
+"
(
"
$
"
.
)
(
"
"
"
6
"(
.
"
"
.
"
Karl Kautsky
)
#
5
)
Halaman 59
+
5
(
(
(
"(
"
"
2
"
(
(
(
( +
)
0
(
$
"
(
"
'
(
+
5
+
(
"
+ "
D
+
5
"
"
+
"
(
5
$
+
"
" "
(
"
"
+(
( +
"
" "
"
.
(
0
"
"
(
"
D
" 5
"
'
"
; 35
(
0
Halaman 64
@
(
+
(
5
(
2
#
(
"
#
(
*
5
(
C
+
(
+
"
.
"
#
$
"
"
"
5
(
"
/
8
"
(
*
1
/
*
"
"
"
,
(
(
,
"
(
)
(
*
(
0 (
"
*
"
(
(
+*
"7
(
6
*
"
@
(
Karl Kautsky
*
Halaman 65
"
(
" 6
"
"
(
)
((
(
(
*
(
' (
*
"
"
"
(
"
>
)
"
.
"
(
(
(
(
0
(
"
" (
"
#
>
+
4
)
"
"
" (
3)
(
(
(
"
'
"
"
"
(
"
)
"
(
(
" (
(
" #
(
((
"
" "
( (
"
(
'
(
(
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 66
(
"
(
(
(
(
"
(
(
"
(
"
(
(
(
(
-
"
(
+
9
(
)
"
6 (
+
(
"
3
(
4
(
( +
(
"
"
:,
" (
8
0
"
"(
"
,
"
5
9
(
"
"
(
(
$
-
(
8
#
(
( ;3
"
" :,
"4
" -
+
"
8
(
+
(
=
(
"
,
(
"
8
)
( +
(
Karl Kautsky
"
"
"
Halaman 67
8
" "
A
"
)
"
(
6
(
(
,
"
"
"
"
0 8
)
(
"
"
"
"
3
(
4
+
" E
(
"
"
/
9
(
" "
"
)
*
6
( +
" )
(
(
/
(
"
/
(
"
+
(
6