karl kautsky marxism and bolshevism
1
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 2
!
" #"
$
%&&&
!
!
# $
%
"
$ ! !
&
Karl Kautsky
!"
#
' (
!
+
Halaman 3
# $%
)
*
"
")
( $
( $
")
"
$
)
*
,
-- .
*
/
0
1
( $
)
) "
( $
,
-"
( $
$
" ( $
/
)
/
2
)
3
1
4
4 *
6
( $
$
( $
2
( $
2
( $
*
/ *
#
5
"
)
0
)
/ *
)
--%
"
2
7
)
4
) "
.
) "
7
4
2
)
*
#
)
( $
%8
Karl Kautsky
, .
1
1
Halaman 4
( $
"
*
)
( $
)
-- )
( $: "
1
. /
9 ( 9"
/ $
6
( $
--
.
"
)
)
( $
")
)
)
"
, )
)
"
*
)
)
)
" "
"
"
"
)
' "
"
"
.
/
"
"
4
"
3
"
$"
3
( $
*
1
,
(
;
"
,
<
( $
$
";
= ( $
) )
"
( $
)
"
) ,
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 5
)
1
"
"
)
( $
)
"
( $
( $
>
2
( $
)
6
#
(
*
( $
/
( $
*( $
/
. "
( $
"
"
)
?
( $
"
1
)
"
"
)
)
)
"
?
"
)
"
)
)
.
"
$
"
1
)
( $
1
)
"
) " *
*
1
.
*
".
)
)
( $
( $
.
)
@
( $
)
.
"
)
( $
) *
")
)
*
"
( $
)
)
Karl Kautsky
( $
Halaman 6
)
)
*
( $
)
)
"
)
)
"
"
"
A
"
)
( $
, B
)
"
C
"
( $
"
1 ( $
)
*
1
D
( $
)
)
)
"
"
"
)
( $
" ( $
)
B "
.
"
)
)
( $
)
1
( $
)
( $
"
*
.
,
"
$
1
"
"
"
" 1
"
)
$
"
!
/
)
.
Karl Kautsky
"
* (
A
) )
( $
1
1 *
)
Halaman 7
"
)
"
B
*
)
)
*
)"
*
*
)
)
"
"
*
:
#
)
"( $
)
" ( $
"
"
*
"
( $
( $
"
)
"
,
)
" ( $ )
"
1
),( $
-!!
#
3/ B
"
"
9
6
3
)
1
"
( $
E
@
#
"
B
"
)
'
( $
3
*
*)
"
3/
"
$
" 1
B
( $
1
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 8
"
)
)
( $
)
#
)
1
F
F
$
3
B
" *
B
/
3
)
* /
"
( $
)
*
)
"
@
"
7
"
)
"
)
* ))
)
( $ >
"
*
')
4
)
E
/"
<
"
*
< )=
=
( $
"
1
$
*
( $
F
"
)
)
( $:
( $
)
.
"
3
Karl Kautsky
.
Halaman 16
9
$
3
)
)
)
2
"
)
.
( $
( $: "
9 )
9
"3
6
"
"
- &
)
"
"
)
"
?
)
)
"
/
"
))
)
*
" 1
")
)
"
"
)
"
"
1
1
)
*
)
;
;
, )
/
3
"
I
)
)
)
"
"
)
1
"
3
"
1
"
)
3
")
"
)
Karl Kautsky
, )
"
Halaman 17
3
"
"
)
,
'
B
"
1
"
*
1
"
)
.
L
:
L
)
"
C
"
)
" )
)
"
1
"
)
I
"
"
"
, #
"
( $
)
@
)
@
1
1
"
/
"
*
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 25
#
) 7?
1
"
"
"
)
"
"
*
1
"
)
"
)
"
":
?
1
)
1
/
*
"
?
)
1
)
"
)
"
"
"
6
)
"
)
1
1
)
) *
$
"
$
"
)
" I
"
7
"
"
*
"
,
"
"
"
" ,
#
"
)
*
3
"
"
)
"
"
)
"
)
/
"
"
"
"
"
?
?
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 26
$
C
"
/
@
I
*
)
"
"
@
D
"
)
A )
"
"
@
"
"3
) "
)
"
"
" 9
*
"
"
"
"
"
$
"
)
( $ $
"
"
A
,
"
"
( $ $
"
/
)
)
B
,
"
"
"
$
/
*
*
)
"
)
)
B
1
)
"
)
3
*
"
) *
")
?
1
)
Karl Kautsky
1
?
9
"
I
@
F
"
"
2
@
"
Halaman 27
2
)
"
)
"
"
)
/
"
)
)
1
) "
)
7
>
)
"
@
@
)
"
)
)
)
) * )
/
"
$
)
)
6
B
*
)
)
"
"
"
)
)
"
1
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 28
(!
1
)
"
B
" 1
3
"
5
)
,
)
"
"
)
1
"
)
)
% 1
/
:
C
'
*
)
)
"
"
)
"
1
)
)
,
)
" ) *
"
6
"
"
?
)
"
"
)
"
"
) "
)
B
,
"
"
"
"
,
) "
"
*
"
)
"
)
"
"
"
)
B
"
)
)
"
Karl Kautsky
,
B
)
Halaman 29
"
"
"
) "
$
" )
9 )
*
) "
"
"
"
$
"
)
)
B
>
B
)
,
"
"
"
)
/
$
B
" )
"
"
,
)
)
/
B
"
*
)
" )
)
)
"
)
1
,
"
) *
?
1
)
"
"
) *
)
) *
"
"
"
)
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 30
)
) *
"
1
) *
?
"
?
1 "
1
$
?
"
" 6
"
)
"
6
"
" .
"
$
"
,
) *
@
) *
"
"
B
B
)
)
)
"
"
)
1
)
"
"
"
)
)
)
1
*
)
")
)
"
)
1
"
3
"
"
@
"
"
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
@
) "
*
)
,
)
Halaman 31
" ,
)
"
D' "
/
)
?
<
=
"
) *
(
) *
'
"
"
"
)
)
)
?
*
)
"
"
,
"
)
@
"
"
)
/
"
1
"
)
)
)
"
*
"
"
)
?
)
) "
?
"
"
"
"
*
"
"
@
9
"
)
") "
"
" $
/
@
"
)
" "
'
)
F
)
)
)
)
@
Karl Kautsky
1
$
Halaman 32
)
"
"
"
( $
"
"
*
"
$
"
"
"
?
)
"
1
*
)
"
*
)
1
")
$
" @
)
)
1
"
)
" )
"
"
"
)
"
@
*
"
$
F
)
"
)
'
" )
" "
"
F
"
,
,
*
F
")
%&
)
"
* )
)
"
"
)
, )
&J
+
@
"
) *
" @
$
?
"
#
2
)
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 33
"
)
"
"
'
, )
$
*
)
)
)
@
*
)
)
) "
C
"
)
"
@
"
"
)
" ,
*
/
"
" ,
B
)
7
/
'
/
5
"
" ,
"
F
"
) "
B
#
1
/
"
)
)
'
)
"
<
,
,
"
=) * 1
,
@
"
*
I
*
)
"
7
*)
)
)
@
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 34
"3
.
"
)
. "
"
"
)
"
)
)
"
( $
) *
/
.
)
)
)
?
) "
"
)
@ *
)
)
(
)
)
"
D,
")
)
"D
6
)
)
( $
*
@
)
( $
"
)
"
"
)
)
)
1
*
( $
)
)
?
1
#
( $
$
"
)
)
)
"
1
@
"
"
*
"
"4 *
,
)
3#
*
"
#
( $
?
" "
)
) *
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 35
) *
"
"
"
$
"
*
?
3
I
)
)
"
#
" B
?
$
)
) "
/
*
"
3
'
" "
"( $
)
"
)
*
(
)
1
@
)
@ A
#
1
#
/
*
;
#
1
(
*
)
1
/
3
"
/
F
*
)
4
(
:
)
)
9
7?
?
)
*
"
"
* )
( $
?
"
)
,
"
)
B
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 36
"
)
"
"
1
(
)
*
*
*
"
3#
*
)
1 "
?
* )
"
1
$
*
@
"
*
/
)
*
1
" F
@
7
"
1
F
.
1
"
"
F
7
3( $
)
)
1
/
*
)
#
F
@
F
"
#
?
*)
D 6
*)
"
)
"
3
"
)
$
"
F
)
"
)
"
)
*
1
/
*
$
/
*
" #
Karl Kautsky
#
.
1
Halaman 37
$
@
"
)
* )
"
1
/
/
$
*
$
F
)
1
/
#
*
)
)
)
)
*
@
$
.
)
1
*
#
)
)
1
)
)
"
- 9
#
@
)
"
#
)
)
,
)
)
#
*
)
*
,
1
"
)
)
$
" 1
?
" )
)
/
"
"
"
"
$
"
" ,
"
"
Karl Kautsky
@
)
)
Halaman 38
#
/
= )
)
"
*
) *
" )
"
)
)
"
<
)
"
"
%
"
#
<
"7
@
>
=)
*
))
9
)
%!
*
/
B
>
" , )
"
>
"
$
)
$
>
, )
"
:
"
)
)
)
)
,
)
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 39
/
)
*
( $:
/
)
"
"
"
)
)
%)
?
1
?
6
)
"
3E
" , )
"
@
4
$
"
I
)
"
$
"
"
"
#
?
"
$
F
' "
)
3
1
"
)
)
#
"
)
)
)
1
"
" )
)
1
/
"
" )
*
) *
1 "
$
"
"
,
)
1 "
"
.
7
) *
,
)
#
)
)
3
) *
" #
:
)
B
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 2
!
" #"
$
%&&&
!
!
# $
%
"
$ ! !
&
Karl Kautsky
!"
#
' (
!
+
Halaman 3
# $%
)
*
"
")
( $
( $
")
"
$
)
*
,
-- .
*
/
0
1
( $
)
) "
( $
,
-"
( $
$
" ( $
/
)
/
2
)
3
1
4
4 *
6
( $
$
( $
2
( $
2
( $
*
/ *
#
5
"
)
0
)
/ *
)
--%
"
2
7
)
4
) "
.
) "
7
4
2
)
*
#
)
( $
%8
Karl Kautsky
, .
1
1
Halaman 4
( $
"
*
)
( $
)
-- )
( $: "
1
. /
9 ( 9"
/ $
6
( $
--
.
"
)
)
( $
")
)
)
"
, )
)
"
*
)
)
)
" "
"
"
"
)
' "
"
"
.
/
"
"
4
"
3
"
$"
3
( $
*
1
,
(
;
"
,
<
( $
$
";
= ( $
) )
"
( $
)
"
) ,
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 5
)
1
"
"
)
( $
)
"
( $
( $
>
2
( $
)
6
#
(
*
( $
/
( $
*( $
/
. "
( $
"
"
)
?
( $
"
1
)
"
"
)
)
)
"
?
"
)
"
)
)
.
"
$
"
1
)
( $
1
)
"
) " *
*
1
.
*
".
)
)
( $
( $
.
)
@
( $
)
.
"
)
( $
) *
")
)
*
"
( $
)
)
Karl Kautsky
( $
Halaman 6
)
)
*
( $
)
)
"
)
)
"
"
"
A
"
)
( $
, B
)
"
C
"
( $
"
1 ( $
)
*
1
D
( $
)
)
)
"
"
"
)
( $
" ( $
)
B "
.
"
)
)
( $
)
1
( $
)
( $
"
*
.
,
"
$
1
"
"
"
" 1
"
)
$
"
!
/
)
.
Karl Kautsky
"
* (
A
) )
( $
1
1 *
)
Halaman 7
"
)
"
B
*
)
)
*
)"
*
*
)
)
"
"
*
:
#
)
"( $
)
" ( $
"
"
*
"
( $
( $
"
)
"
,
)
" ( $ )
"
1
),( $
-!!
#
3/ B
"
"
9
6
3
)
1
"
( $
E
@
#
"
B
"
)
'
( $
3
*
*)
"
3/
"
$
" 1
B
( $
1
Karl Kautsky
"
Halaman 8
"
)
)
( $
)
#
)
1
F
F
$
3
B
" *
B
/
3
)
* /
"
( $
)
*
)
"
@
"
7
"
)
"
)
* ))
)
( $ >
"
*
')
4
)
E
/"
<
"
*
< )=
=
( $
"
1
$
*
( $
F
"
)
)
( $:
( $
)
.
"
3
Karl Kautsky
.
Halaman 16
9
$
3
)
)
)
2
"
)
.
( $
( $: "
9 )
9
"3
6
"
"
- &
)
"
"
)
"
?
)
)
"
/
"
))
)
*
" 1
")
)
"
"
)
"
"
1
1
)
*
)
;
;
, )
/
3
"
I
)
)
)
"
"
)
1
"
3
"
1
"
)
3
")
"
)
Karl Kautsky
, )
"
Halaman 17
3
"
"
)
,
'
B
"
1
"
*
1
"
)
.
L
:
L
)
"
C
"
)
" )
)
"
1
"
)
I
"
"
"
, #
"
( $
)
@
)
@
1
1
"
/
"
*
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 25
#
) 7?
1
"
"
"
)
"
"
*
1
"
)
"
)
"
":
?
1
)
1
/
*
"
?
)
1
)
"
)
"
"
"
6
)
"
)
1
1
)
) *
$
"
$
"
)
" I
"
7
"
"
*
"
,
"
"
"
" ,
#
"
)
*
3
"
"
)
"
"
)
"
)
/
"
"
"
"
"
?
?
Karl Kautsky
)
Halaman 26
$
C
"
/
@
I
*
)
"
"
@
D
"
)
A )
"
"
@
"
"3
) "
)
"
"
" 9
*
"
"
"
"
"
$
"
)
( $ $
"
"
A
,
"
"
( $ $
"
/
)
)
B
,
"
"
"
$
/
*
*
)
"
)
)
B
1
)
"
)
3
*
"
) *
")
?
1
)
Karl Kautsky
1
?
9
"
I
@
F
"
"
2
@
"
Halaman 27
2
)
"
)
"
"
)
/
"
)
)
1
) "
)
7
>
)
"
@
@
)
"
)
)
)
) * )
/
"
$
)
)
6
B
*
)
)
"
"
"
)
)
"
1
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 28
(!
1
)
"
B
" 1
3
"
5
)
,
)
"
"
)
1
"
)
)
% 1
/
:
C
'
*
)
)
"
"
)
"
1
)
)
,
)
" ) *
"
6
"
"
?
)
"
"
)
"
"
) "
)
B
,
"
"
"
"
,
) "
"
*
"
)
"
)
"
"
"
)
B
"
)
)
"
Karl Kautsky
,
B
)
Halaman 29
"
"
"
) "
$
" )
9 )
*
) "
"
"
"
$
"
)
)
B
>
B
)
,
"
"
"
)
/
$
B
" )
"
"
,
)
)
/
B
"
*
)
" )
)
)
"
)
1
,
"
) *
?
1
)
"
"
) *
)
) *
"
"
"
)
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 30
)
) *
"
1
) *
?
"
?
1 "
1
$
?
"
" 6
"
)
"
6
"
" .
"
$
"
,
) *
@
) *
"
"
B
B
)
)
)
"
"
)
1
)
"
"
"
)
)
)
1
*
)
")
)
"
)
1
"
3
"
"
@
"
"
"
"
"
"
Karl Kautsky
@
) "
*
)
,
)
Halaman 31
" ,
)
"
D' "
/
)
?
<
=
"
) *
(
) *
'
"
"
"
)
)
)
?
*
)
"
"
,
"
)
@
"
"
)
/
"
1
"
)
)
)
"
*
"
"
)
?
)
) "
?
"
"
"
"
*
"
"
@
9
"
)
") "
"
" $
/
@
"
)
" "
'
)
F
)
)
)
)
@
Karl Kautsky
1
$
Halaman 32
)
"
"
"
( $
"
"
*
"
$
"
"
"
?
)
"
1
*
)
"
*
)
1
")
$
" @
)
)
1
"
)
" )
"
"
"
)
"
@
*
"
$
F
)
"
)
'
" )
" "
"
F
"
,
,
*
F
")
%&
)
"
* )
)
"
"
)
, )
&J
+
@
"
) *
" @
$
?
"
#
2
)
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 33
"
)
"
"
'
, )
$
*
)
)
)
@
*
)
)
) "
C
"
)
"
@
"
"
)
" ,
*
/
"
" ,
B
)
7
/
'
/
5
"
" ,
"
F
"
) "
B
#
1
/
"
)
)
'
)
"
<
,
,
"
=) * 1
,
@
"
*
I
*
)
"
7
*)
)
)
@
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 34
"3
.
"
)
. "
"
"
)
"
)
)
"
( $
) *
/
.
)
)
)
?
) "
"
)
@ *
)
)
(
)
)
"
D,
")
)
"D
6
)
)
( $
*
@
)
( $
"
)
"
"
)
)
)
1
*
( $
)
)
?
1
#
( $
$
"
)
)
)
"
1
@
"
"
*
"
"4 *
,
)
3#
*
"
#
( $
?
" "
)
) *
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 35
) *
"
"
"
$
"
*
?
3
I
)
)
"
#
" B
?
$
)
) "
/
*
"
3
'
" "
"( $
)
"
)
*
(
)
1
@
)
@ A
#
1
#
/
*
;
#
1
(
*
)
1
/
3
"
/
F
*
)
4
(
:
)
)
9
7?
?
)
*
"
"
* )
( $
?
"
)
,
"
)
B
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 36
"
)
"
"
1
(
)
*
*
*
"
3#
*
)
1 "
?
* )
"
1
$
*
@
"
*
/
)
*
1
" F
@
7
"
1
F
.
1
"
"
F
7
3( $
)
)
1
/
*
)
#
F
@
F
"
#
?
*)
D 6
*)
"
)
"
3
"
)
$
"
F
)
"
)
"
)
*
1
/
*
$
/
*
" #
Karl Kautsky
#
.
1
Halaman 37
$
@
"
)
* )
"
1
/
/
$
*
$
F
)
1
/
#
*
)
)
)
)
*
@
$
.
)
1
*
#
)
)
1
)
)
"
- 9
#
@
)
"
#
)
)
,
)
)
#
*
)
*
,
1
"
)
)
$
" 1
?
" )
)
/
"
"
"
"
$
"
" ,
"
"
Karl Kautsky
@
)
)
Halaman 38
#
/
= )
)
"
*
) *
" )
"
)
)
"
<
)
"
"
%
"
#
<
"7
@
>
=)
*
))
9
)
%!
*
/
B
>
" , )
"
>
"
$
)
$
>
, )
"
:
"
)
)
)
)
,
)
"
Karl Kautsky
Halaman 39
/
)
*
( $:
/
)
"
"
"
)
)
%)
?
1
?
6
)
"
3E
" , )
"
@
4
$
"
I
)
"
$
"
"
"
#
?
"
$
F
' "
)
3
1
"
)
)
#
"
)
)
)
1
"
" )
)
1
/
"
" )
*
) *
1 "
$
"
"
,
)
1 "
"
.
7
) *
,
)
#
)
)
3
) *
" #
:
)
B
"