APRIL to MoF NeilFranklin

Responsible Peatland Management
Positive Outcomes for Carbon, Conservation,
Conservation,
Community and Economic Development
December 2009
Dr. Neil Franklin
Sustainability Director
Asia Pacific Resources International Ltd (APRIL)
NF Presentation to Gov Riau – Jan 2009

1

Challenges
• Some stakeholders hold negative view on all peatland development (due to
perceived carbon emissions liabilities) but this position ignores the
scientific basis for benefits of responsible forest management.
• Internationally, intensive plantation forest management in Indonesia still
suffers from poor reputation, while the sector itself is not fully recognized
as a means of sustainable development and Carbon emissions avoidance.

Opportunities

Responsible Peatland Management can deliver:
• Significant Social, Environmental and Economic benefits
• I tegrated

a age e t i support of peat Do e

o ser atio

• Positive image of Indonesia in addressing climate change
• Win-win solution based on Sustainable Development and REDD+

Mosaic Plantation Forest:
Planning Based on Micro & Macro Delineation with High Conservation Values

High
Conservation
Value Production
Forest

Protected by Mosaic

Plantation

Unproductive
Production
Forest

Managed and
Developed

Secondary
Production Forest

Managed and
Developed

Conservation Area
Acacia Plantation

Acacia Plantation


Vigorous plantation forest and mosaic landscape protect biodiversity, provide ecosystem services, and uplift
community well-being
3

Research for Sustainable Development
Science-Based Solutions for
Responsible Management of Peatlands.

Pioneering Research on Responsible
Peatland Management

APRIL’s “cie ce Based Management Support Project
• Independent team from Delft Hydraulics and world-leading
peatland, conservation and emissions experts
• US$ 1 Million; 3 year program, 2006-2009.
• Eco-Hydrological and HCVF spatial planning to optimise
plantations and minimise impact on conservation forests
• Develop SOPs for Responsible Peatland Management

5


Planning Guidelines for Peat Landscapes
• Key objective is to protect the important hydrology core
water source from external impacts by a narrow hydro
buffer and a wider pla tatio ri g that ha e well
managed water tables
• Peat Swamp Forest can be conserved only where its
wet condition is maintained. Landscape planning must
define how central core and all designated Conservation
areas will be protected from plantation drainage
impacts, including dealing with the ineviatable
subsidence of drained plantation lands
• Limit drainage impacts on conservation ideally by
conserving whole catchment areas, develop others:
minimum fragmentation (eco-hydrology principles)
• Plantation landscape water management is designed to
minimize subsidence & GHG emissions and maximize
lifespan of productive plantations.

Science Based Peat Management Project

APRIL in partnership with NGO and Academic stakeholders








Monitor water & gas stock & flux in large
acacia & jungle areas
Derive an annual water & Carbon balance
Construct a hydrology process model
Predict seasonal water surplus & deficits
Preemptive control adjustments to keep the
system at optimal water level
Understand the subsidence & Carbon release
process
interventions
oxidation

dewatering
consolidation

water inflow
Root decay

photosynthesis
Litter to humus

Ground water flows

Peat bulk density

Surface flows
Peat formation
Soil temp

Crop growth
Root respiration
water table


Deep ground water flows

Eco-Hydro Management
Water control for reduced carbon emissions

Eco-Hydro Ring Management
Carbon Protection and Peat Conservation

99

Eco-Hydrology Planning and Peatland Profile
• Central Dome or og plai porous /lo de sity peat, must conserve as water
source (upstream, deep peat).
• Mid-slopes with adequate peat density: hydro buffer to prevent drainage
impacts on the upslope central conservation core and Dome.
• Mid-lower slopes with adequate topographic gradient / peat porosity: acacia
plantation ring under best practice water management
• Lowest elevation riparian and seasonal flood plain: conserve high biodiversity
peat s a p forest i riparia orridor a d asi peat ater si ks hydrology

conservation function as well)
• Alluvial / mineralized peat fringe: high priority to conserve biodiversity but
largely occupied by community: promote sustainable livelihoods

10

Eco-Hydrology Buffers






Function: Buffer 0 cm water depth in Conservation Core from 50 cm water depth in
plantation
Location: on the slope edge of bog plain, not inside the zone flatter than 2.0 km
between 0.5 m contours. Where 1.5 km contour spacing, 1200 m wide buffer
Science data: buffers hold water gradient of 15cm / 400 m : 45 cm over 1200 m
Where flatter than 1.5 km contour spacing need the 1600 m buffer
Monthly monitoring of all hydro buffers for ground water levels, surface water control

& response SOP (sandbags), quarterly monitoring of subsidence

Integrated Forest Management for Conservation
Plantation buffer and
protected boundaries
Plantation
buffer

Water
management
zones

Teluk
Meranti
Village

Kerumutan
Nature
Reserve


No plantation buffer and
community encroachment

Comparison of Eco-Hydrology Plantation Forest
Ma age e t agai st Busi ess as Usual
Degraded forests exposed to
external factors

Managed Eco-hydrology Plantation
Forest
-

•Illegal logging

•No forest & land fire

•Encroachment

•Productive acacia plantation


•Uncontrolled drainag

•Managed water level

•Forest tree die-back

•Hydrologic buffers

• Forest & Land Fire

•Protected Conservation Areas

= 60 ton/ha/year CO2 emission

= 45-55% avoided emissions

Berdasarkan data: APRIL, Delft/SBMSP 2009; Swedish Env. Research Institute (IVL) Oct 2009

CONSERVATION

Statement on Sustainable Peatland
Management by SBMS Project Team

PRODUCTION

Al Hooijer (Delft Hydraulics, Holland),
Dr. Susan Page (Leicester University, UK),
Dr. Ruth Nussbaum (ProForest, UK).



The i depe de t tea supports AP‘IL s o
it e t to a age e t of
peatlands through the SBMS Project for Sustainable Peatland Management.



Forests and carbon sinks in peatland can only be sustainably managed if the
hydrological system is protected or rehabilitated. This is of importance for
conservation, and also vital for long-term economic production on peatland.



Degraded land contains low conservation value and is of marginal potential
for agriculture, but holds huge carbon deposits. Such land needs to be
properly managed to minimize forest loss, land fires & carbon emissions.



A new approach must be developed through the establishment of buffer
zones and water control infrastructure (to balance water requirements,
maximise production and minimise impact on intrinsic or adjacent
conservation landscapes).
June 2008

Practical Solutions
Kampar Peninsular: Using Plantations to Secure a
conservation landscape and reduce carbon emissions.

Current Degradation in Kampar Core
Hydrology is a Liability
Still intact forested Core
area, not impacted by
hydrology degradation

Based on 300 sample points
0-50 cm
> 50 cm (>100 tCO2/ha/yr)

Kampar Ring Plantation
Integrated Landscape Management Planning
Total concession area
of approx. 56,000 Ha
Plantations: 35,000 Ha
Conservation: 15,000 Ha

250,000 Ha of Deep Peat
Swamp Forest protected
within Plantation &
Community Ring

Community: 6,000 Ha

With Ring plantation
and optimised water
levels, current CO2
emissions can be
reduced by 50% (or
by 3 Million tons
CO2/year).

Estate Tasik Belat
(North Ring)
Estate Meranti (South
Ring)

Plantation Ring Plan – Meranti Estate
(Kampar Ring South)
Hydro buffer (for minimal impact
on adjacent natural forests)

Production (with hydro
management in canals)

Livelihood zone (for
community agriculture)

Conservation
(upstream deep peat)

Indigenous trees (also
Livelihood zone (for
community agriculture)

Hydro buffer (controlled
and raised water levels)

functions as hydro buffer to
river conservation areas)

Eco-Hydro Management
Water control for minimum impact conservation
boundaries and reduced carbon emissions

Controlled raising of water levels in
Eco-Hydro buffer zone between
planted and conservation areas

Water control
gates to
optimise at 5060cm in
plantations,
and 0-20cm in
conserv. areas

Investment in Forest Protection and Fire Prevention

Kampar Ring: Reduced Emissions
from Deforestation and Degradation
• Protective Ring of responsibly
managed plantations
• Reduced emissions impact
right across the landscape
• Protection of ecosystems and
biodiversity in core area
• Creation of several thousand
additional jobs
• Prevention of illegal logging
and opportunist settlers
• Collaborative management
• Avoided Emissions of 3 Million tons CO2
with stakeholders
/year with Ring
• Poverty alleviation and
• REDD Voluntary Market carbon credits
participation by local
up to US$15-20 Million /year
communities

Social and Economic Development
Ensuring that climate change commitments are
integrated with development objectives

Private Sector: Bridging the Social Gap
Active in social development and poverty
alleviation in order to raise the standards
and quality of living through the promotion
of the following community empowerment
programs:

- Integrated Farming System (80 villages;
3,000 families)

- Micro Small & Medium Business

Program (development of 1,200 people)
- Community Fiber Farming 30,000 Ha
(9,800 people in 32 villages)

- Social & Infrastructure Program

(education, free health services for 20,000
people every year, building of mosques,
schools, sports and cultural facilities)

- Vocational Training Program (689

trained persons) and Teacher Quality
Enhancement Training in several schools.

Case-Study PT RAPP: Economic Contribution


Generate employment opportunities and SME development towards alleviating poverty and
upgrading community well-being.
Based on results of 2006 University of Indonesia Faculty of Economics LPEM study:
Economic Impact Indicator – Riaupulp Actitivites, 1999 dan 2005

Riau
1999

Indicator

Pelalawan
2005
Value

Output (Rp billion)*)

6,347

(4.53)

17,400

(7.43)

2,773

(76.04)

9,315

(54.22)

Gross Domestic Product - Regional
(Rp billion**)

2,405

(2.89)

6,593

(4.74)

1,052

(72.29)

3,533

(51.54)

622

(4.25)

1.705

(6.97)

263

(69.03)

883

(49.22)

137,780

(8.00)

249,241

(9.39)

18,571

(13.48)

36,125

(14.49)

Employment Opportunities
(people)

(%)

2005
Value

(%)

Family Income
(Rp billion)

(%)

1999
Value

Value

(%)

*) Output: Market value of goods and services resulting from production activities to supply intermediate and end demands. Figures
in table represent economic output/revenue resulting from the presence of Riaupulp in Riau Province
**) Gross Domestic Product - Regional




Supporting local development through infrastructures (roads, bridges, ports) reaching
remote areas.
One of the largest export earners in Indonesia – up to US$ 1.5 billion/year, and capital
intensive within APRIL Indonesia with total assets of USD 5 billion.

Scaling-Up
National and global contribution of responsibly
managed forest and peatland resource

The Forests Dialogue 2009:

Co-Benefits of Managed Forests
• Consensus position of 200 of the
worlds forestry stakeholders
(Govt, Private, NGO, Community)
• Forests have a unique ability to
simultaneously reduce
greenhouse gas emissions,
capture carbon, & reduce the
vulnerability of people and
ecosystems to climate change.
• Sustainably managed forests
support livelihoods of millions of
rural people and deliver products,
ecosystem services and
biodiversity protection.

Potential Co-Benefits of Indonesian
Plantation Forestry
If Indonesian develops additional
9M Ha land (15% of production
forest) into HTI, Mosaic Plantation
Concept will result in:
– 2.1M Ha protected natural forest in
conservation areas
– 2.3M Ha land managed by villagers
for social development
– 4.6M Ha plantations
– 161M m3 of sustainable fiber/yr for
world market.
– 38 M Adt pulp production
Total carbon impact: net reduced emissions of 150 Mt CO2/year

Forestry as a Climate Change Solution


I the lo g ter , a sustainable forest management
strategy aimed at maintaining or increasing forest carbon
stocks, while producing an annual sustained yield of timber,
fiber or energy from the forest, will generate the largest
sustained mitigation benefit.
Source: IPCC 2007. Fourth Assessment Report.

SUMMARY
• A new science-based approach must be developed through the
establishment of buffer zones and water control infrastructure (to balance
water requirements, maximise production and minimise impact on intrinsic
or adjacent conservation landscapes). [Source SBMSP Project 2009].
• Sustainable Plantation Ring Management in Kampar is essential for
protecting the Kampar Peninsula Core peatland, reducing carbon emissions
by 50% (compared to present condition, reducing from 6 to 3 Million Tons
CO2/year) and achieving balanced social, environmental and economic
benefits in a Sustainable Development context

• Sustainable Peatland Management in Kampar Ring can become the model
for Government to showcase during COP XV UNFCCC summit , ith a WinWi solutio hi h i tegrates the atio al de elop e t a d li ate
change mitigation objectives.
• Positi e out o es fro la ds ape le el pla i g of I do esia s peatla ds
can provide maximum benefits to society – including environmental
protection, economic & social development and carbon (REDD+).
*Based on data: APRIL, Delft/SBMSP 2009; Swedish Env. Research Institute (IVL) Oct 2009

Acknowledgements of Best Practice
• Quality Management System (QMS) Certification
 Pulp Production
 Paper Production

• ISO Certification
 Paper Permanence

• GREEN Rating PROPER 2005-2006; 2006-2007; 2008-2009 by the
Ministry for Environment
 Program for Rating Environmental Management Performance
• OHSAS Certification
 Riaupulp Fiber Operations
 APRIL Mill Operations

• Runner-Up, Environmental Excellence Award –

HTI & HTR Development – Conservation and Community Aspects

• 1st Place – Best Practice, Social Programs Overall
• 1st Place – Best Practice Social Program (Social Category)
• Verification Statement, Acacia Chain of Custody

• Eco-label Certification
for Paper Products

• Environmental Management System (EMS) Certification
 Riaupulp Fiber Estates

• EMS Certification
 Integrated Paper Production

• Audit Certification, Occupational
Health and Safety Management
System

• Certification, Sustainable
Plantation Forest Management
System (LEI)

SUSTAINABLE FOREST MANAGEMENT

Balancing Carbon, Social, Environmental
and Economic Imperatives for Sustainable
Development in Indonesia
Thank you

31