Ya Sudah, Bebaskan Saja.
Pikiran Rakyat
,--- .= - = - - = - - = ~ ~ ~ ~
'-'--"
o
o
S e n in
2
18
O P e b
3
19
S e la s a
4
5
•
o
R a b u
7
22
6
21
20
O M a r
A
8
23
O M ei
O A p r
K a m is
o
S a b tu
10
11 ~13
25
26
27
24
O J U /1
o
O J llm a t
9
O J u l
TSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
O Sep
O A g s
M i/1 g g u
14
15
29
3
28
.O k t
O N o v
0
16
31
O D e s
,,'/'
,I
Pakar Hukum Tata Negara, Indra Perwira
Ya
EPUTUSAN
K
S u d a h , B e b a s l~ a n
Saja
b e b a s P e n g a d ila n T ip ik o r B a n -
d u n g m e ru p a k a n k e p u tu s a n y a n g o b je k tif,
ra s io n a l, d a n p e n u h p e rtim b a n g a n .
K e p u tu s a n b e b a s d a la m
p a k a n p e rs o a la n
d i P e n g a d ila n
s u a tu p e ra d ila n ju g a m e ru -
y a n g w a ja r. T id a k s e m u a te rd a k w a
T ip ik o r h a ru s d ih u k u m ,
" A d a b e b e ra p a p e rtim b a n g a n y a n g d ia m b il m a je lis
h a k im u n tu k m e m v o n is b e b a s te rd a k w a . M u n g k in
s a la h s a tu n y a tu n tu ta n ja k s a
tid a k m e m e n u h i u n s u r
p id a n a n y a a ta u ju g a m u n g k in d ia tid a k b e rs a la h . S e b a g a i o ra n g h u k u m , k ita h a ru s m e m b e rik a n
pem aham an
k e p a d a m a s y a ra k a t, b a h w a
tid a k s e m u a o ra n g y a n g d ia d ili d i p e n g a d ila n itu b e r s a la h ," k a ta P a k a r
H ukum
T a ta N e g a ra U n iv e rs ita s P a -
d ja d ja ra n
In d ra P e rw ira , S e la s a
(1 1 /1 0 ).
In d ra m e n g a ta k a n , v o n is b e b a s y a n g
d ip u tu s m a je lis h a k im P e n g a d ila n
T ip ik o r te rh a d a p M o c h ta r M o h a m a d d a n B u p a ti S u b a n g E e p
"
H id a y a b e b e ra p a w a k tu la lu
te rs a n g k a . P rin s ip h u k u m
d ik a re n a k a n a s u m s ija k s a k e p a -
le b ih b a ik m e m b e b a s k a n
d a k e d u a te rs a n g k a itu tid a k
o ra n g b e rs a la h
c u k u p , " S e la in itu , d a k w a a n n y a
m enghukum
ju g a b is a m e n g a d a -a d a , s e h in g -
tid a k b e r s a la h ," u c a p n y a .
g a tid a k te r b u k ti," k a ta n y a .
K e p u tu s a n
b u k tik a n
itu ju g a m e m -
b a h w a le m b a g a
p e n g a d ila n
T ip ik o r te la h
m a n d iri s e h in g g a b e ra n i
m e n g a m b il k e p u tu s a n b e b a s .
" K a la u a la t b u k ti k u ra n g , d a k -
itu
10
k e tim b a n g
s a tu o ra n g y a n g
In d ra m e n ila i, la n g k a h k e ja k s a a n y a n g a k a n m e n g a ju k a n
kasasi ke M ahkam ah A gung
tid a k te p a t, " J P U (J a k s a P e n u n tu t U m u m ) s u d a h g a g a l k a re n a
te rs a n g k a d iv o n is b e b a s . S e k a ra n g m a u k a s a s i k e M A , itu s a -
w a a n tid a k b e n a r, m a je lis
m a d e n g a n J P U m e le m p a rk a n
h a k im b is a m e m v o n is b e b a s
ta n g g u n g ja w a b
k e le m b a g a
y a r ig le b ih tin g g i," u c a p n y a .
O le h k a re n a itu , In d ra
m enyayangkan
la n g k a h y a n g
d ia m b il k e ja k s a a n
d a la m k a -
s u s k o ru p s i in i. " S a y a s e la lu
m e m a n ta u
d u a k a s u s p e ja b a t
in i, K a la u m e m a n g s u d a h d iv o n is b e b a s , y a s u d a h , b e b a s k a n s a ja ," k a ta n y a . ( M ir a d in
S y a h b a n a /" P R " )* * *
K lip in g
H um as
U npad
2011
.- - - - -
,--- .= - = - - = - - = ~ ~ ~ ~
'-'--"
o
o
S e n in
2
18
O P e b
3
19
S e la s a
4
5
•
o
R a b u
7
22
6
21
20
O M a r
A
8
23
O M ei
O A p r
K a m is
o
S a b tu
10
11 ~13
25
26
27
24
O J U /1
o
O J llm a t
9
O J u l
TSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
O Sep
O A g s
M i/1 g g u
14
15
29
3
28
.O k t
O N o v
0
16
31
O D e s
,,'/'
,I
Pakar Hukum Tata Negara, Indra Perwira
Ya
EPUTUSAN
K
S u d a h , B e b a s l~ a n
Saja
b e b a s P e n g a d ila n T ip ik o r B a n -
d u n g m e ru p a k a n k e p u tu s a n y a n g o b je k tif,
ra s io n a l, d a n p e n u h p e rtim b a n g a n .
K e p u tu s a n b e b a s d a la m
p a k a n p e rs o a la n
d i P e n g a d ila n
s u a tu p e ra d ila n ju g a m e ru -
y a n g w a ja r. T id a k s e m u a te rd a k w a
T ip ik o r h a ru s d ih u k u m ,
" A d a b e b e ra p a p e rtim b a n g a n y a n g d ia m b il m a je lis
h a k im u n tu k m e m v o n is b e b a s te rd a k w a . M u n g k in
s a la h s a tu n y a tu n tu ta n ja k s a
tid a k m e m e n u h i u n s u r
p id a n a n y a a ta u ju g a m u n g k in d ia tid a k b e rs a la h . S e b a g a i o ra n g h u k u m , k ita h a ru s m e m b e rik a n
pem aham an
k e p a d a m a s y a ra k a t, b a h w a
tid a k s e m u a o ra n g y a n g d ia d ili d i p e n g a d ila n itu b e r s a la h ," k a ta P a k a r
H ukum
T a ta N e g a ra U n iv e rs ita s P a -
d ja d ja ra n
In d ra P e rw ira , S e la s a
(1 1 /1 0 ).
In d ra m e n g a ta k a n , v o n is b e b a s y a n g
d ip u tu s m a je lis h a k im P e n g a d ila n
T ip ik o r te rh a d a p M o c h ta r M o h a m a d d a n B u p a ti S u b a n g E e p
"
H id a y a b e b e ra p a w a k tu la lu
te rs a n g k a . P rin s ip h u k u m
d ik a re n a k a n a s u m s ija k s a k e p a -
le b ih b a ik m e m b e b a s k a n
d a k e d u a te rs a n g k a itu tid a k
o ra n g b e rs a la h
c u k u p , " S e la in itu , d a k w a a n n y a
m enghukum
ju g a b is a m e n g a d a -a d a , s e h in g -
tid a k b e r s a la h ," u c a p n y a .
g a tid a k te r b u k ti," k a ta n y a .
K e p u tu s a n
b u k tik a n
itu ju g a m e m -
b a h w a le m b a g a
p e n g a d ila n
T ip ik o r te la h
m a n d iri s e h in g g a b e ra n i
m e n g a m b il k e p u tu s a n b e b a s .
" K a la u a la t b u k ti k u ra n g , d a k -
itu
10
k e tim b a n g
s a tu o ra n g y a n g
In d ra m e n ila i, la n g k a h k e ja k s a a n y a n g a k a n m e n g a ju k a n
kasasi ke M ahkam ah A gung
tid a k te p a t, " J P U (J a k s a P e n u n tu t U m u m ) s u d a h g a g a l k a re n a
te rs a n g k a d iv o n is b e b a s . S e k a ra n g m a u k a s a s i k e M A , itu s a -
w a a n tid a k b e n a r, m a je lis
m a d e n g a n J P U m e le m p a rk a n
h a k im b is a m e m v o n is b e b a s
ta n g g u n g ja w a b
k e le m b a g a
y a r ig le b ih tin g g i," u c a p n y a .
O le h k a re n a itu , In d ra
m enyayangkan
la n g k a h y a n g
d ia m b il k e ja k s a a n
d a la m k a -
s u s k o ru p s i in i. " S a y a s e la lu
m e m a n ta u
d u a k a s u s p e ja b a t
in i, K a la u m e m a n g s u d a h d iv o n is b e b a s , y a s u d a h , b e b a s k a n s a ja ," k a ta n y a . ( M ir a d in
S y a h b a n a /" P R " )* * *
K lip in g
H um as
U npad
2011
.- - - - -