1
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1.1 Research Background
Many investors choose stocks that have first caught their attention. Barber and Odean 2008 and Da et al. 2009 said that attention is a scarce resource.
Attention is the cognitive process of selectively concentrating on one aspect of the environment while ignoring other things Anderson, 2004 as cited in Chen and Yu
2013. Odean 1999 explains that investors limiting their search of stock that have recently caught their attention to manage the problem from the huge of
alternatives. So, when investors have a lot of alternatives, attractive alternatives are more to be considered and chosen. And the way investor limiting their search
is depend on their preferences. Investors have to make a decision to where and when they invest their
resources by considering the risk, expected return and which securities they choose. Basically, when we want to choose a stock, we can consider about two
analyses, which is fundamental and technical analysis. According to Liaw 2004 Fundamental analysis examines financial statements that published by the
company and economic fundamentals to determine value of securities and its growth prospect. McMillan, et al. 2011 define that technical analysis is study of
market trends or patterns that comes from price and volume data which is often graphically displayed. It doesn’t required detail knowledge of the financial
instrument. Investors have to get enough information to do the two analyses.
1.1 Research Bac c
kg kground
Many ny investors choose
s stoc
oc ks
ks t
t ha
ha t
t ha
ha ve
ve first caught thei
eir r
attention. Barber and Od
Od ean 2008 a
a n
nd D D
a a et al. 2009 said
d tha
ha t
t at
at te
te n
ntion is a sca a
rc rc
e resource. At
At t
tention is is t
t he
he c c
ogniti i
ve ve
p ro
cess of se le
ctivel y
co nc
nc en
e tratin
ng g on
on o
one aspec ect of the
enviro o
nm nm
en en
t wh h
il il
e ig
no ring other thi
ng s Anderson,
2 00
4 as
s c
c ited
d in
n Ch Chen
e and
d Yu 20
13 13
. Ode e
an 1999 ex
pl ains that in
ve stors limi
ti ng their s
ea r
rch of of
s s
to to
ck tha at
ha ha
ve ve
rec c
en tl
y caught their att
ention to
mana ge
the problem fro m
m the e
hu hu
ge g
of f
alternat at
iv es. So,
wh en
investors h
av e
a lo
t of
alterna ti
ve s,
attractiv e
e alternativ
v es
es are mo
o re to be considered
an d
ch os
en. And th
e wa y investor limiting
their se search
h is dep
pen en
d on t
he ir
p p
re re
fe fe
re re
nc nc
es es.
Investors have to make a d
d e
ecis s
io io
n to where and when they invest t
th thei
ei r
re reso
s ur
urce c
s by considering the risk, y
expected return and which sec ec
ur ur
i itie
ies s
th th
ey ch
choo oose. Ba
B i
sica ll
lly, w w
he he
n n we wan
nt t to
to c c
ho ho
os ose a stoc
k k,
w we
e can cons
i ider a
a bo
bo ut
ut two analys
ys es
es ,
, whic
c h
h is
is f
fundamental a a
nd n
technic ical analysis. A
A cc
cc or
or di
d ng
g to
o Li
Liaw 2004 Fundamental analysis examine
e s financia
l l statements that published by the
company and economic fundame mentals to
determine value of securities and its d
growth prospect. McMillan, et al. 2 2011
1 define that technical analysis is study of market trends or patterns that comes
f from price and volume data which is often
2 Individual investor will rationally use all of the available relevant information to
buy stocks that they might to buy. This makes adequate and reliable financial information important in financial decision. According to Rose, Peter S. and
Marquis, Milton H. 2008 there are four groups of information sources that relied by the investors, which are debt security prices and yields, stock prices and
dividend yields, information on security issuers, and general economic and financial conditions across the entire economy and financial systems.
Nowadays, the advance information technology is growing rapidly, especially for the internet development. People can easily get information and
data from the internet about what they search, and update their current information to understand what happen around them. This is also give impact for
investor behavior. In this modern era, Rose, Peter S. and Marquis, Milton H. 2008 explain
that the information revolution providing financial services to the public involves the analysis, storage, and transfer of financial information. Digitized
communication through the internet make investors equipped with powerful new tools such as advance gadgets or smart phones to easily getting information
resources, monitoring their investment in 24 hours and helps them in decision making.
Investors engage with advance gadget when they access information. They can easily get information about stocks that they want to buy, company
performance, annual report and everything that publish in the internet to do analysis before they decide to make investment. According to Liaw 2004
information important in fin n
an an
i cial decision.
n Ac A
cording to Rose, Peter S. and Marquis, Milton H.
. 2
2008 there are four groups of infor orma
m tion sources that relied
by the inves es
t tors, which are de
de bt
t s
s ec
ec ur
ur it
it y
y pr
pr ic
i es and yields,
s stock prices and
dividend nd yields, inf
fo orma
ma t
tion on security issuers rs
, an an
d general ec
c on
o omic and
fin nancial co
co nd
nd it
it io
io ns acr
r os
os s th
e entire e co
nomy a nd
d f
f in
in ancial
l s sys
ys te
te m
ms. No
No wa
da da
y ys
, th e
advance information technology is grow
ow in
ing g
rapi pidl
d y,
es s
pe pe
i cially f
f or
the interne t
developm en
t. People ca
n easily g et
t infor
rma ma
t tion an
nd da
da ta
ta fro
o m
the internet a bo
ut wha t
they sea
rc h, and updat
e thei
ir r cu
cur rrent
inform m
atio n to und
erstan d what
hap pe
n arou
nd them.
T his is also gi
v ve impact fo
fo r
r invest
or behavior.
In In
t his mo
de rn
n e
e ra
ra, Ro
Ro se
se ,
, Peter S. and
d M
M ar
ar qu
qu is
is, Milt
on H
. 2 00
008 8 expla
la in
in th
t at the information revolution prov
v id
id in
ng g financial services to the public inv
v ol
ol ve
ve s
th the
e an
an alysis, storage, and transfer of financial information
on .
Di Di
gi git
tiz zed
co comm
mmun i
icat i
ion h
thro o
ug ug
h h
th the intern
rnet et m
mak ak
e e
in investors
s eq
eq ui
uipp p
d ed w
i it
h h powe
we rf
rful ul
new tools
su su
ch as ad ad
v vance gadgets
or o
smart t phones to eas
s il
il y
y ge
g tting
g in
information resources, monitoring their inve
estment in 24
2 hours and helps them in decision
making. Investors engage with advanc
nce ga adget when they access information. They
can easily get information about s s
tocks that they want to buy company
3 millions of customers conduct their banking, stock, bond, and trading using online
systems. By presenting bills, and delivering account statements, research report and other materials online, companies cut operating cost and improve efficiency.
According to Da et al. 2011 abnormal return, abnormal turnover, media reports, and advertising expenditure are the indirect proxies of investors’
attention. Information about list firm that reported in the media cannot give guarantee that the investor receives attention, except the investor read it.
Investors’ attention can be seen from the search activity that did by the investor. When the investors try to find information or search all the information about that
stock, it means the investor give attention to that stock. This study is using Google search volume index as a direct proxy of
investors’ attention. It can be access in Google Trends. Google Trends is a tool that provides the volume of queries on many kinds of industries that will helpful
to predict the subsequent data release Choi Hyunyoung and Varian Hall, 2009. The previous researcher, Bank et al. 2011 said that there is relation
between the increasing of internet search volume with the trading activity, stock liquidity and return. When the internet search volume increase, the stock liquidity
and the stock return will also increase for the short run. Stock will be more liquid when the demand and the supply is high or having high trading activity.
According to Da et al. 2009 The reason that this study using Google search volume as a direct proxy of investors’ attention is the popularity of Google
among the internet users as the search engine sources to collect information and also the capability of Google search volume index to capture public attention
and other materials online, co o
mp mpanies cut op
p er
er at
a ing cost and improve efficiency.
According to to
D Da et al. 2011 abnormal return,
a a
bn b
ormal turnover, media reports, and
d advertising expen
en di
di tu
u re
re a
a re
re the
he indirect prox
xie i
s of investors’ attentio
o n.
Information on a
abo bo
ut list firm that repo o
rt rt
ed ed
i i
n the media ca
c nnot give
gu u
a arantee th
tha at
t the inv
nv e
es to
r receives attention,
ex ex
cept t
the he
i in
nvestor re
r ad it.
Invest st
or ors’
s’ a
atten n
ti ti
on c
an be seen from
th e search activ
it y
th hat
at did
d b
b y
y th
the e
inve e
st s
or. Wh
Wh en
t the i
i n
nv estors try to
fi nd informa
ti on or sear
ch all the inf
or m
mation on
a ab
bout tha hat
st stoc
oc k
k, it m
m ea
ns the investor give
atten tion
to th at
sto ck.
Th is study
is us
ing Go og
le sea
rch vo
lume ind
ex as a di
re e
ct proxy o
f invest
or s’ attention. It can
be ac ce
ss in Go og
le T rends. Google Tr
en nds is a
a too ol
that p pro
ro vi
de s
th e vo
lu lu
me me
o o
f f
qu qu
er e
ies on many y
ki ki
nd nd
s s
of of
i i
nd ustr
ie s th
at t
w w
i ill help
p fu
fu l
l to
t predict the subsequent data release
se Ch
Ch oi Hyunyoung and Varian Hall, 2009
09 .
. The previous researcher, Bank et al. 2011 said that ther
er e
e i
is r r
el elat
at i
ion be
betw tween
h the
i increa
si sing
ng o
o f
f intern et
et s
s ea
ea rc
rch h
v volume w
w it
ith h
th the
t tr
d ad
i ing activi
vi ty
ty ,
, stock
liquid id
it it
y y
an d
re e
tu tu
rn rn. When the int
t er
e net sear
arch volume incr r
ea ea
se se
, ,
the st st
oc oc
k k liquidity
and the stock return will also inc crease for th
he short run. Stock will be more liquid when the demand and the supply
i i
s high or r
having high trading activity. According to Da et al. 20
09 T
The reason that this study using Google search volume as a direct proxy of inv
v estors’ attention is the popularity of Google
4 which is not capture by news. Google search volume captures the attention of
individual investor or retail investor who has limited sources of information. Usually, the institutional investor has more detail source of information.
Cited from Antaranews, APJII Asosiasi Penyelenggara Jasa Internet Indonesia stated that Internet users in Indonesia keep increasing
http:www.antaranews.com. In the year 2013 it reach 71,19 million users or increase until 13 compare to the year 2012 that reach until 63 million users.
According to web sources of techcircle.in, internet users in India reach about 150 million people, and India has become the 3
rd
largest internet population in the world after China http:techcircle.vccircle.com.
The reasons that researcher interesting to study on these two countries, Indonesia and India because both of them are have some similarities. Indonesia
and India are emerging market that become members of G20 http:internasional.kompas.com and the growth of internet users in these two
countries are similar https:www.google.compublicdata. Below is the graph of Indonesia and India internet users.
Usually, the institutional inves es
to tor has more
d d
et et
ai a
l source of information. Cited from
m A
Antaranews, APJII Asosiasi Pen nye
ye lenggara Jasa Internet
Indonesia stated that Int
t e
erne ne
t t
us us
er er
s s
in i
Indonesia k
k eep increasing
http: w
www.antarane ews
ws.c .
om o
. In the year 201 3
3 it
it r rea
ac ch 71,19 mil
lli li
on users or in
n c
crease u u
nt ntil
il 1 1
3 3
com m
p pa
re to the ye ar
2012 th
h at
at r
r ea
e ch u
unt ntil
il 6
6 3
3 millio
on n
users. Acco
rd rdin
in g
g t to w
w eb
eb sou
rc es of techcirc
le .in, internet us
er s
in I
I ndia rea
each ch a
a bout
t 150
mi mi
ll ll
io i
n peo ople
, and Indi a
has become the 3
rd
lar ge
st internet p
popula lati
tion o
in th he
wo wo
rl rl
d af f
t ter Ch
ina http:tech ci
rcle.v cc
ir cle.co
m .
Th e reason
s th
at resea rc
he r
inte re
st in
g to stu
dy o
n these
tw wo countrie
es s,
Indone e
sia and India becaus e bo
th of them
a re h
ave some similaritie s
s. Indon onesia
ia and
In I
di a are
em em
er er
gi gi
ng ng
market th h
at at
b b
ec ec
om om
e me mb
er s
s of
G G
20 20
h ttp:internasional.kompas.com an
an d
d th
th e growth of internet users in these
e tw two
co coun
un tr
tr ie
ie s are similar https:www.google.compublicdata. Below is
s t
t he
he g g
ra raph
ph of
In Indo
donesia an d
d I
In di
dia a
in inte
te r
rnet users s
.
5
Figure 1 Development of Internet users in Indonesia and India
in the year 1990-2012
Sources :https:www.google.compublicdata
Figure 2 Pattern of internet users in Indonesia:
Sources: HarianTI http:harianti.com So
So ur
u ce
s s
:h ttps
: www.google.
co mpubl
ic data
Fi gu
re 2
Pa ttern
of interne
t user
s in Indonesia:
6 From data above that cited from HarianTI, it can be seen that 78,49
internet users in Indonesia use the internet to find news and information, 77.81 use to find information about goods and services and 37,67 use to access the
others financial facility http:harianti.com. It is interesting to examine the usage of internet in term of investment in
those countries, the correlation between the internet usage through Google search engine to find information of stock, company profile, annual report and any
subject that support investors to get more knowledge to do investment.
1.2 Problem Statements