Dependent Variable: Log monthly hours of PT
Dependent Variable: Log monthly hours of PT
1 Tobit
Variables OLS
Characteristics Gender
school ranking 1 st quintile
School ranking 2 nd quintile
School ranking 4 th quintile
School ranking 5 th quintile
Family Log monthly income
Average years of
parents’ schooling
Number of children
School Private (=1)
Student-teacher ratio
School size: 300-500 rd
School size: 500 or more rd
High school under
Equalization Policy (=1)
Special Purpose
High school (=1)
Contextual effect Proportion of classmates
receiving PT service
Price Log hourly price of PT
Metropolitan cities
Constant 4.6137*** -5.8062*** 2.6856***
Lambda( λ )
Rho ( ρ )
-- 0.7429
Observations 2,515 3,562 3,601 2 R 2 / Pseudo R
Note. 1. Standard error in parentheses are adjusted for clustering on schools. 2. Standard errors in parentheses are adjusted for clustering on schools.
***p<.01 , **p<.05, * p<.1
TABLE 5. Conditional Moments Tests Results Dependent Variable: Log monthly expenditure on PT
Test Moment Restrictions t-statistics Omitted Variables 2 E( PRED ) = 0 44.37
3 E( PRED ) = 0 45.46
2 Heteroscedasticity 2 E ( Z
1 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 30.19
2 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 22.36
3 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 16.78
4 y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 10.74
5 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 7.69 E ( Z 6 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − 2 σ ˆ )) = 0 52.06
E ( Z 7 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 51.45
8 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 47.63
9 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 25.60 E ( Z 10 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 35.00
11 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 23.23 E ( Z 12 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 51.36 E ( Z 13 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 47.47
14 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 10.25 E ( Z ( E ( u 2 | y ) − 15 2 σ ˆ )) = 0 53.36
16 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 35.79 E ( Z 17 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 18.07
Non-normality 3 E ( E ( u | y )) = 0 7.39 4 4 E ( E ( u | y ) − 3 σ ) = 0 5.58
i β ) × η ˆ ), PRED = ( x i β ˆ ) × η ˆ ), η is the gener ized residuals. al Note 2. Absolute values
2 ' ˆ 2 3 ' Note 3 1. PR ED = ( x
Note 3. Z
1 =Gende r, Z 2 = school ranking 1 quintile, Z 3 = School ranking 2 quintile, Z 4 =Sch ool ranking 4 quintile, Z
5 = School ranking 5 quintile, Z 6 =Log monthly income, Z 7 =Average years of parents’ schooling, Z 8 =Number of children, Z 9 =Private school, Z =School size:300 -500 3 rd 10 grade, Z 11 = School size:500 or more 3 rd grade, Z 12 = Teacher-student ra o, Z ti 13 =High scho ol unde r Equalization Policy, Z 14 =Special Purpose High School, Z 15 =Proportion of classmates recei ving PT service, Z 16 = Seoul, Z 17 = Metropolitan cities
th
TABLE 6. Conditional Moments Tests Results Dependent Variable: Log monthly hours of PT
Test Moment Restrictions t-statistics
2 Omitted Variables E( PRED ) = 0 0.01 3 E( PRED ) = 0 5.81
Heteroscedasticity E ( Z ( E ( u 1 2 | y ) − 2 σ ˆ )) = 0 10.19 E ( Z ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 2 σ )) = 0 10.48
E ( Z 3 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 9.87
4 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 5.99
5 ( E ( u | y ) − σ )) = 0 1.35
6 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 19.39
7 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 20.09 E ( Z ( E ( u 8 2 | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 18.11
E ( Z 9 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 10.34
10 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 14.40 E ( Z E 11 2 ( ( u | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 10.51
12 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 19.15
13 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 19.31
E ( Z 14 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − ˆ 2 σ )) = 0 2.83
15 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 22.20 E ( Z 16 ( E ( u 2 | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 18.63
17 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ 2 )) = 0 4.05
18 ( E ( u | y ) − σ ˆ )) = 0 18.05
Non-normality 3 E ( E ( u | y )) = 0 9.15 4 4 E ( E ( u | y ) − 3 σ ) = 0 13.14
i β ) × η ), PRED = ( x i β ˆ ) × η ˆ ), η is the generalized residuals. Note 2. Absolute values
Note 3 1. PR ED = ( x
Note3. Z =
st
1 Gender, Z 2 =school ranking 1 th quintile, Z 3 = School ran ing 2 k nd quintile, Z 4 =Scho ol ranking 4 th quintile, Z 5 =School ranking 5 quintile, Z 6 =Log monthly income, Z 7 =Aver age yea rs of parents’
rd grade, Z 11 = School size:500 or more 3 rd
schooling, Z 8 =Number of children, Z 9 =Private school, Z =School size:300
10 -500 3 grade, Z 12 =Student-teacher ra tio, Z 13 =High school u nde r Equalization Policy, Z 14 =Special Purpose High School, Z 15 =Proportion of classmates receiving PT service, Z 16 =
Seoul, Z 17 =Metropolitan cities, Z 18 =Price of PT
33