S TB 1000465 Table of content
DAFTAR ISI
PERNYATAAN .................................................................................................... i
ABSTRAK .............................................................................................................ii
KATA PENGANTAR ...........................................................................................iv
UCAPAN TERIMAKASIH .................................................................................. v
DAFTAR ISI ........................................................................................................ vii
DAFTAR TABEL .................................................................................................ix
DAFTAR GAMBAR............................................................................................. x
DAFTAR LAMPIRAN .........................................................................................xi
BAB I PENDAHULUAN .............................................................................. 1
A. Latar Belakang Masalah ................................................................ 1
B. Identifikasi Masalah...................................................................... 3
C. Batasan Masalah ............................................................................ 3
D. Rumusan Masalah.......................................................................... 4
E. Tujuan Penelitian ........................................................................... 4
F. Manfaat Penelitian …………………………………………..….. 4
G. Struktur Organisasi Penulisan ……...…………………….…….. 5
BAB II KAJIAN PUSTAKA ........................................................................... 6
A. Konsep Efektivitas ......................................................................... 6
1. Pengertian Efektivitas ................................................................ 6
2. Ukuran Efektivitas ..................................................................... 7
3. Pendekatan Terhadap Efektivitas .............................................. 9
4. Masalah dalam Pengukuran Efektivitas .................................. 10
B. Penilaian Model Presentasi .......................................................... 11
1. Pengertian Penilaian ................................................................ 11
2. Fungsi, Tujuan dan Jenis Penilaian ......................................... 13
3. Presentasi yang Efektivitas ...................................................... 14
2. Penilaian Model Presentasi...................................................... 15
C. Evaluasi........................................................................................ 15
1. Tujuan Evaluasi dan Kegunaannya ......................................... 16
2. Standar Evaluasi ...................................................................... 17
3. Sistem Evaluasi Praktik Industri di DPTS ............................... 17
D. Penelitian yang Relevan .............................................................. 24
F. Asumsi ......................................................................................... 25
BAB III METODE PENELITIAN ................................................................. 27
A. Metode Penelitian ........................................................................ 27
B. Lokasi, Populasi Dan Sampel ...................................................... 28
C. Variabel Penelitian ....................................................................... 30
D. Definisi Operasional .................................................................... 30
E. Metode dan Instrumen Pengumpulan Data .................................. 31
F. Kisi-Kisi Instrumen Penelitian..................................................... 34
G. Prosedur Penelitian ...................................................................... 35
H. Pengujian Instrumen Penelitian ................................................... 36
1. Uji Validitas ………………………………………………. 36
2. Uji Reliabilitas ……………………………………………. 37
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
I. Teknik Analisi Data Penelitian ..................................................... 43
BAB IV HASIL PENELITIAN DAN PEMBAHASAN ................................. 47
A. Deskripsi Penelitian ........................................................................ 47
B. Analisis Data Penelitian ................................................................. 49
1. Aspek Penilaian Laporan ........................................................... 50
2. Aspek Ujian (Presentasi) ............................................................ 55
3. Data Persentase Peraspek .......................................................... 60
C. Pembahasan Hasil Penelitian …………………………………….. 65
BAB V KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN ........................................................ 71
A. Kesimpulan ................................................................................... 71
B. Saran.............................................................................................. 72
C. Rekomendasi ................................................................................. 72
DAFTAR PUSTAKA
LAMPIRAN-LAMPIRAN
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR TABEL
Tabel
2.1 Rentang Skala Penilaian PI DPTS.............................................................. 23
2.2 Rentang Skala Penilaian UPI...................................................................... 24
3.1 Populasi Penelitian ..................................................................................... 28
3.2 Sampel Penelitian ....................................................................................... 29
3.3 Alternatif Jawaban Sakala Likert ............................................................... 32
3.4 Kisi-Kisi Angket Tertutup .......................................................................... 34
3.5 Kisi-Kisi Angket Terbuka .......................................................................... 34
3.6 Interpretasi Nilai r....................................................................................... 39
3.7 Hasil Validitas Angket Sesudah uji Coba .................................................. 40
3.8 Rekapitulasi hasil validasi angket terbuka ................................................. 41
3.9 Kriteria Pedoman Penafsiran Persentase Indikator .................................... 45
3.10 Kriteria Persentase Peraspek ...................................................................... 45
4.1 Rekapitulasi Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden ...................................... 48
4.2 Pernyataan Indikator Kelengkapan Isi Laporan ......................................... 49
4.3 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Teori ............................................................. 50
4.4 Pernyataan Indikator Analisis Kajian Praktik Industri ............................... 51
4.5 Pernyataan Indikator Bahasa ...................................................................... 52
4.6 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Faktual .......................................................... 53
4.7 Pernyataan Indikator Kesimpulan dan Saran ............................................. 54
4.8 Pernyataan Indikator Kemampuan Mempertahankan Laporan.................. 55
4.9 Pernyataan Indikator Sikap Ilmiah ............................................................. 56
4.10 Pernyataan Indikator Tilikan Komprehensif .............................................. 57
4.11 Pernyataan Indikator Penampilan ............................................................... 58
4.12 Pernyataan Indikator Penyajian .................................................................. 59
4.13 Rekapitulasi Jawaban Untuk Penilaian Laporan. ....................................... 60
4.14 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Perindikator............................................. 62
4.15 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator Presentasi................................. 62
4.16 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator .................................................. 63
4.17 Rekapitulasi jawaban keseluruhan respon mahasiswa tentang efektivitas
penilaian praktik industri dengan model presentasi…………………
64
4.18 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Mahasiswa PI ......................... 66
4.19 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Mahasiswa PI ......................... 67
4.20 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Pembimbing PI....................... 68
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR GAMBAR
Gambar
3.1 Prosedur Penelitian ...................................................................................... 35
4.1 Diagram Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden ............................................. 48
4.2 Pernyataan Indikator Kelengkapan Isi Laporan ......................................... 49
4.3 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Teori ............................................................. 50
4.4 Pernyataan Indikator Analisis Kajian Praktik Industri ............................... 51
4.5 Pernyataan Indikator Bahasa ...................................................................... 52
4.6 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Faktual .......................................................... 53
4.7 Pernyataan Indikator Kesimpulan dan Saran ............................................. 54
4.8 Pernyataan Indikator Kemampuan Mempertahankan Laporan.................. 55
4.9 Pernyataan Indikator Sikap Ilmiah ............................................................. 56
4.10 Pernyataan Indikator Tilikan Komprehensif .............................................. 57
4.11 Pernyataan Indikator Penampilan ............................................................... 58
4.12 Pernyataan Indikator Penyajian .................................................................. 59
4.13 Rekapitulasi Jawaban Untuk Penilaian Laporan. ....................................... 60
4.14 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator Presentasi................................. 62
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1
Daftar Peserta Seminar Praktik Industri
Form Penilaian Praktik Industri
Lampiran 2
Hasil Uji Validilitas
Hasil Uji Reabilitas
Lampiran 3
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket tertutup
Kecendrungan Jawaban Responde Terhadap Variabel Efektivitas Penilaian
Model Presentasi Laporan Hasil Praktik Industri.
Diagram Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden
Distribusi Data Angket Aspek Penilaian laporan
Diagram Jawaban Responden Aspek Penilaian laporan
Distribusi Data Angket Aspek Penilaian Ujian/presentasi
Diagram Jawaban Responden Aspek Ujian/presentasi
Hasil Persentase Keseluruhan Jawaban Responden
Diagram Keseluruhan Jawaban Responden
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Mahasiswa
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Dosen Pembimbing
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Pembimbing Lapangan
Lampiran 4
Surat Keputusan Penunjukkan Dosen Pembimbing
Lembar Bimbingan
Judgement Expert
Berita Acara Seminar dan Sidang
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
PERNYATAAN .................................................................................................... i
ABSTRAK .............................................................................................................ii
KATA PENGANTAR ...........................................................................................iv
UCAPAN TERIMAKASIH .................................................................................. v
DAFTAR ISI ........................................................................................................ vii
DAFTAR TABEL .................................................................................................ix
DAFTAR GAMBAR............................................................................................. x
DAFTAR LAMPIRAN .........................................................................................xi
BAB I PENDAHULUAN .............................................................................. 1
A. Latar Belakang Masalah ................................................................ 1
B. Identifikasi Masalah...................................................................... 3
C. Batasan Masalah ............................................................................ 3
D. Rumusan Masalah.......................................................................... 4
E. Tujuan Penelitian ........................................................................... 4
F. Manfaat Penelitian …………………………………………..….. 4
G. Struktur Organisasi Penulisan ……...…………………….…….. 5
BAB II KAJIAN PUSTAKA ........................................................................... 6
A. Konsep Efektivitas ......................................................................... 6
1. Pengertian Efektivitas ................................................................ 6
2. Ukuran Efektivitas ..................................................................... 7
3. Pendekatan Terhadap Efektivitas .............................................. 9
4. Masalah dalam Pengukuran Efektivitas .................................. 10
B. Penilaian Model Presentasi .......................................................... 11
1. Pengertian Penilaian ................................................................ 11
2. Fungsi, Tujuan dan Jenis Penilaian ......................................... 13
3. Presentasi yang Efektivitas ...................................................... 14
2. Penilaian Model Presentasi...................................................... 15
C. Evaluasi........................................................................................ 15
1. Tujuan Evaluasi dan Kegunaannya ......................................... 16
2. Standar Evaluasi ...................................................................... 17
3. Sistem Evaluasi Praktik Industri di DPTS ............................... 17
D. Penelitian yang Relevan .............................................................. 24
F. Asumsi ......................................................................................... 25
BAB III METODE PENELITIAN ................................................................. 27
A. Metode Penelitian ........................................................................ 27
B. Lokasi, Populasi Dan Sampel ...................................................... 28
C. Variabel Penelitian ....................................................................... 30
D. Definisi Operasional .................................................................... 30
E. Metode dan Instrumen Pengumpulan Data .................................. 31
F. Kisi-Kisi Instrumen Penelitian..................................................... 34
G. Prosedur Penelitian ...................................................................... 35
H. Pengujian Instrumen Penelitian ................................................... 36
1. Uji Validitas ………………………………………………. 36
2. Uji Reliabilitas ……………………………………………. 37
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
I. Teknik Analisi Data Penelitian ..................................................... 43
BAB IV HASIL PENELITIAN DAN PEMBAHASAN ................................. 47
A. Deskripsi Penelitian ........................................................................ 47
B. Analisis Data Penelitian ................................................................. 49
1. Aspek Penilaian Laporan ........................................................... 50
2. Aspek Ujian (Presentasi) ............................................................ 55
3. Data Persentase Peraspek .......................................................... 60
C. Pembahasan Hasil Penelitian …………………………………….. 65
BAB V KESIMPULAN DAN SARAN ........................................................ 71
A. Kesimpulan ................................................................................... 71
B. Saran.............................................................................................. 72
C. Rekomendasi ................................................................................. 72
DAFTAR PUSTAKA
LAMPIRAN-LAMPIRAN
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR TABEL
Tabel
2.1 Rentang Skala Penilaian PI DPTS.............................................................. 23
2.2 Rentang Skala Penilaian UPI...................................................................... 24
3.1 Populasi Penelitian ..................................................................................... 28
3.2 Sampel Penelitian ....................................................................................... 29
3.3 Alternatif Jawaban Sakala Likert ............................................................... 32
3.4 Kisi-Kisi Angket Tertutup .......................................................................... 34
3.5 Kisi-Kisi Angket Terbuka .......................................................................... 34
3.6 Interpretasi Nilai r....................................................................................... 39
3.7 Hasil Validitas Angket Sesudah uji Coba .................................................. 40
3.8 Rekapitulasi hasil validasi angket terbuka ................................................. 41
3.9 Kriteria Pedoman Penafsiran Persentase Indikator .................................... 45
3.10 Kriteria Persentase Peraspek ...................................................................... 45
4.1 Rekapitulasi Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden ...................................... 48
4.2 Pernyataan Indikator Kelengkapan Isi Laporan ......................................... 49
4.3 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Teori ............................................................. 50
4.4 Pernyataan Indikator Analisis Kajian Praktik Industri ............................... 51
4.5 Pernyataan Indikator Bahasa ...................................................................... 52
4.6 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Faktual .......................................................... 53
4.7 Pernyataan Indikator Kesimpulan dan Saran ............................................. 54
4.8 Pernyataan Indikator Kemampuan Mempertahankan Laporan.................. 55
4.9 Pernyataan Indikator Sikap Ilmiah ............................................................. 56
4.10 Pernyataan Indikator Tilikan Komprehensif .............................................. 57
4.11 Pernyataan Indikator Penampilan ............................................................... 58
4.12 Pernyataan Indikator Penyajian .................................................................. 59
4.13 Rekapitulasi Jawaban Untuk Penilaian Laporan. ....................................... 60
4.14 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Perindikator............................................. 62
4.15 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator Presentasi................................. 62
4.16 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator .................................................. 63
4.17 Rekapitulasi jawaban keseluruhan respon mahasiswa tentang efektivitas
penilaian praktik industri dengan model presentasi…………………
64
4.18 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Mahasiswa PI ......................... 66
4.19 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Mahasiswa PI ......................... 67
4.20 Rekapitulasi Hasil Angket Terbuka Untuk Pembimbing PI....................... 68
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR GAMBAR
Gambar
3.1 Prosedur Penelitian ...................................................................................... 35
4.1 Diagram Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden ............................................. 48
4.2 Pernyataan Indikator Kelengkapan Isi Laporan ......................................... 49
4.3 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Teori ............................................................. 50
4.4 Pernyataan Indikator Analisis Kajian Praktik Industri ............................... 51
4.5 Pernyataan Indikator Bahasa ...................................................................... 52
4.6 Pernyataan Indikator Kajian Faktual .......................................................... 53
4.7 Pernyataan Indikator Kesimpulan dan Saran ............................................. 54
4.8 Pernyataan Indikator Kemampuan Mempertahankan Laporan.................. 55
4.9 Pernyataan Indikator Sikap Ilmiah ............................................................. 56
4.10 Pernyataan Indikator Tilikan Komprehensif .............................................. 57
4.11 Pernyataan Indikator Penampilan ............................................................... 58
4.12 Pernyataan Indikator Penyajian .................................................................. 59
4.13 Rekapitulasi Jawaban Untuk Penilaian Laporan. ....................................... 60
4.14 Pedoman Penafsiran Presentase Indikator Presentasi................................. 62
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu
DAFTAR LAMPIRAN
Lampiran 1
Daftar Peserta Seminar Praktik Industri
Form Penilaian Praktik Industri
Lampiran 2
Hasil Uji Validilitas
Hasil Uji Reabilitas
Lampiran 3
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket tertutup
Kecendrungan Jawaban Responde Terhadap Variabel Efektivitas Penilaian
Model Presentasi Laporan Hasil Praktik Industri.
Diagram Kecendrungan Jawaban Responden
Distribusi Data Angket Aspek Penilaian laporan
Diagram Jawaban Responden Aspek Penilaian laporan
Distribusi Data Angket Aspek Penilaian Ujian/presentasi
Diagram Jawaban Responden Aspek Ujian/presentasi
Hasil Persentase Keseluruhan Jawaban Responden
Diagram Keseluruhan Jawaban Responden
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Mahasiswa
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Dosen Pembimbing
Rekapitulasi Jawaban Responden Angket Terbuka Pembimbing Lapangan
Lampiran 4
Surat Keputusan Penunjukkan Dosen Pembimbing
Lembar Bimbingan
Judgement Expert
Berita Acara Seminar dan Sidang
Diyo Atma Triputra, 2015
EFEKTIVITAS PENILAIAN MOD EL PRESENTASI LAPORAN HASIL PRAKTIK IND USTRI D I DPTS
FPTK UPI
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia | repository.upi.edu | perpustakaan.upi.edu