4. Data Observasi - Peran dewan komisaris PT Timah dalam menjalankan tugas pengawasan terhadap kasus penghentian hubungan ketenagakerjaan (PHK) bagi karyawan PT Timah ditinjau dari undang-undang nomor 40 tahun 2007 tentang perseroan terbatas (studi kasus

85

4. Data Observasi
Hasilwawancaradengan ibu Reny bagian humas PT Timah
Hasil wawancara dengan ibu Wilma Darwin sebagai sekretaris komisaris

rzl (6ui!,HioliE:taz

ra

a-o+

traL

u]lelcr uE {sruaa roru.y

F

urr rir3'..rr irfl I Oarqjar t[ a9,
-rsalrN
.!trrt LZLtt 'n,.!d!.-r6uLd r!

c,apuaf

!r

)jq-L (oi3srad) HY{,111

Id

oNr.u,r,

!

t090!002 )IIN
5NN'IY'CYII)H ANNf,tI

B-''

r

:;ri{#.-1^

seurnl I Su€plg lrJlrd:))

9l Oa snlsn6y

9l

-SuEurdl.I;ued
'tl,iul1slur

eururreieqcs uelemSradlp tedEP Intun
'u?eqesn-Iad

l

rolp Iul u!8uerel!){ lPlns uelllruaal

slrEliqaS - sEtunH ;uEp]fl Dped

{qJ

(orcsrad) qE{E!I

Id

rp etep uelrqure8uad uelrDi€latu qelal uulnlEuesreq 8ue{ reuoq Sueuaul
(ggO) Sunlnafl u]Sueg srllsJ.^Iun -lunlnll S"1F{EJ

nltlll

:

uEsrunl

YOCVXd IgY

:

erueN

um:{nH

: eaqeq

tllsmreuaul IuI ueSuecl

{qJ (oresr.d) HW &l Id

:

rsuelsul

el?de:

:

uetcqel

lY_I.-ti: \ \\Trl

:

etrreN

ueeqesnlod sgel3qes - seEnH A@Eg

D\]-lr

: ru qareqlp ue3o4 epusueq SueI

'N\1fir

.Lt-tlls

HVtruu(

L8

ei!elos

_._

ueP

6ue.rc qelepe suesltno, uernoc 4o66ue leoeqas

-

p{6ue!p ledep 6ue^ (e)
'spesltlloy

-.--

uallao uesnlrdal

ua

Eseplaq

ue{ulqau 'ljlluas-glpuss {epupaq

ledep )iep$ sgesluro) [BI'/I€O PpOAre de0ss uep
eloooue 6uelo (tues)

t

qpteu ueleduau

gep qlqal s€re Ulpal 6ue^ agestu.rcy ueflao Q)

-

Tl)tPu3q 6UeA ueBlepurFolepuruad

uarqelad ue6uop lenas qEFm[

-

6ue,( 'ue6ueloa$3d

lq&lelp lees Bped uEaB{sied lqnuauleu

ueftI+ u+usdaPll! $esluox |apuelp

srueq E)leur '6ue!o (e6s) e gep r{q3l qreslurcDl ue,hao epEtue qeumf

-

ellqBdv ieuEn slresluio)l IDIEM le6e€s latouElp ledep e)|alau eJque

sgeslutox leoeqas
!p EueJo€s ue{nuadlp e[qede uPp uepu€daFll

lqouelp

- E^ueiEquelp Euerca€ u"p euen sgss.lt[o)t leoeqac lslfuelp stitBJEuelp
- 6uBroos '6uero (eql) € eiu6ueJn)l-ouemlas pep Hplal qJequoy ue,$ao
0z t"sEd

qrequktx us^laq
eoles.red qap ue)llsEuoul$lo Hp q{e/,,

I

-a
p! lEtf;, tnJnq uep q lrunq eped pn$leuJrp eueuleoeqas leder qelesru
ledeJ qE€su

-

epEd

uqlexallp 6ue{ ulpuas]at leJns ujelep s{nUal

PJeces e^uuesele

ue8nqa^uau q![e,tl uepl6uesJaq 6ue,( 1u1 le,(e c p.inq uep q ]runq

-

Eped pnsxeuxp eueu.rP6eqes Pder llseq lq€oueiepueua''! Ieprl 6ue.(

suesluroy ue,ttao elo66ue nqe/uep ts1at16 ep66Le ledep'el EJ urepo
Ituox uPJ!\eo elo66ue ueo rsialC eto:'ale

*

epedal uqledueqp

uP4 '.{F€q B.t?^ Guesilloy t.tP.AcC

uT

T

sf*

e'csaE 8lp

{
I

(f)

I

98

--

lsxaro €to66ue qap luetuE4epuEp 'lEda lelesu uqirg,uqou"nIp
q![er !u! fesBd

e le..G

uepp pnsleu{p eueu!6e@s Pdel [s"H

-'lnqq€),!p lntun sgeslulol ua,h6o ep?dal E{Bdtx?^uaul !s{aJ!o uep
qrunFs

epedal ue)fldureslp uep lpeq fueit lsDPllO
- !s1|e{q Eo66up
qrunps qap tue6u4epuelp lpdel qq"stJ ueFp ue)Fuentlp
- Eo66ue
qfe/u ru F|sed

-

Z

lE/G uqep pflEqBufp EueufEoeqag lEda [ssH 'q

-uEqsrqndrp &rBI
|e|Ha{ uep (epe

exl'lqarE

qo66uP oqqdo

- &rpu€ssrp/umlnlaqepsal ueEelured Insetuat) uqele3lqlp 6uRA Pq

-

-1eq

;qraq 6uel pdeu qelesli lBnqlp srueq lqarlo ledeJ dellos

wqFo'e(lz)

'ledeu urelep uqjen|€M 6uEI erens qqujnf ue)lnlueuaur

--.-.---- ueJep 6un[qtp )lepg

uBp 8p€ )tPpS de66uep qes

&ir$ AIe,f o"ns(92]
pdeJ uesnlndgl

llsEq sEe qEjlre[ Aln66uqlaq yurlt t€p 8ru|!6uau |nqa$al F{arlc qo66ue
g)leuJ (u!Esqe) e.lgns

ue{€quoul ltpg !$(al!of elo66ue leq uqep-

-

'erens ueyenpouetu

-

- srueq teder uelep ![IEr !p 6ue^ nele llpeq 6oe^ lstajlo sloofue de0as(92)

nq"

et?ns ual.(equau,

'uerrenld{lp 6ue^ eJens qelunluep

--

us!6eq (enp led nles) % gep qlqat el€ns qalo.ladulaui uelnsn rqes qeles

-

e66ulqas E,(ueqJ6l aens qapjaduFul 6ueI uelnsn Enp depeqral 6ueln

usqlfl.lad uetnleup qeur 'ue4en1a4p 6ue,( aens qelunl !ep

- rcd Nes\ y, lep

-

uerOEq (Bnp

qrqal elens ueouap e^geuJalle nles ue$edepuetl Lunlaq

aens uelnounuJad lFeq

uep $euJalle enp

'e^u!lrle^1!p 6ue,{

I
I

lep qrqq uelnsfl Eq urelec(tz)

lslar€ elo66ue Irlun

eJens (rues)

L

ueqequlel uep elens (nles) ! uellenlaOua! letpa! Isla,la E;363Je ieaas(0z)

'es"lq lerfueqJal elens ueouap lql!€lp JEs.J€€r sreLu

I

ue)fllr4nqlp 6ue,( oueplq rp ue{qee)l n€qe/uep u€nqEa&Jad Dflllulau! .s

-

'l

urrP

-

:uB6uepun{u"pu ad uernplad tqnletrau lqun uau.quol lxlBr,eu .p

-'ue6uena)

Bsef seuolo epedol u?Ouena{ Ue0del

nslEflep ueunqEl uejodel uqleduBlfuauj uEq{ei ol Unuauaur

-

- )ieplr uEouBnay esef sEgolo

'q4 qapradusul

-uBp
-

I

lep usJ4epusd nEe ,updrFslad

6qe,( ueEqesrued ualqeqa/fuaur

qeuad .(c

:SdnU EpEdol s-ueqrucDl uer€O qoo5uE nEE Ep lqano

elo66ue leoeqas ueqe,'^q6un66ueIad uexEquJaul ,lEp[ qEurad

- nelp Sdnu qalo

eulalp lepg qeuad sgesluoy

u

tao Eo66ue

nele rpp lqaJrO qo66ue le6eqas eluuEqe/uE Aln66uqr6d.(q

-

:ueunqE SdnU

ue)pre6ouololuaur {ep$ q€uJad .(e
:leqefuou eul9las 6ue^ slEsluloy

--

uPrdao Elo66ue nele lep lqeJlo Bto66ue petueur qeurad

rypS -,

ep:ueouenol
roD{as ueouap uelrB)uoq 6uer( nelElrep ae6au ueouEnal ug)lloruau

-:-

-*--

6ue^ EuBptd

reprll uelDlel"r! euorel unlnqlp qeujod tepg

.e

:{!ed upwledulp ueeqesru€d
nlens uslqeqaluau qepsJaq uelEeIutp 6uBI suBslruo)l
ue^tao elo66ue nepluep FIaJIO eta66ue rpefueuJ qeured
lepq .Z

-:leqetualU

lllled uelete,tulp qeutad lepit

.l

eutElas upp ueloioueouod u_lnlaqas unqel (eL!rl) g L!elep .c
iuJnlnq uqenqiad

{!eq 6ue,{ sEU.r6aU! uep lerqll

ue)inIqa!

lpflp

deXsJ

FIrtr*tJaU

68

-

sdnu qap ua|suaq.!€qlp uep l€cttuelp sgeslurq{ uenao Eo66ue eled

E

{un}lerfr uEEule$aq

FlarO

lep[ sliesluox

-

e1o66ue

uelq8ue6ued ueou3p

ue^ aO B]o66ue

:6rrunq (€) lele

uqExoueouad (g)

[st5a)| p,(e

uBtep

pnsrytxlp euPruleoeqos uEeE^srad lqnusuau lep$ 6uer{ F{e{€ Eo66uB
upfl uEoSuad

uB)lnlepu, Inlun SdnU uetere66uap,{ueul qlferr uEoJss]ed

ldnn ot I

I

a)

|esed ue|ep

uenlualal uqqEpulouetx ue6uap lnq€srq uEqaabred s^u!{nuadjol leplr

-

lnqeFouaul leia4o nele B{uupl sUesluroy uE ,\aO ep66ue lees ,p[as

- unlnq euaE{ tqeq '6 (e) le^s

Eped

pnqeu{p Eueutroeqas uEerEisad

lqnuourau leF[ 6ue^ suesuroy us rso qo66ue uqE)IouEou€d (g)
'ue0uepun-6uepuruad

- ueiole.lad ue)Uesep€q ulel uePJef,$ad qras erq.ls€onl uE leueqetar
------:........dnln 6ue,( nuefl\ ue)lelpa^uaur
uep l,leoJ€sad
lnlun

tBdep

eqesn oueplq lp ;psslaur Ale{ uenqqaEuad pfrlura(rl 'uauafeu;u

-lsBrru oes qeEs uPousp uqe)lreq At"I;eqesruad

uEurafeua{ qqesEu

{ppspul leuaouar uEueqEuad'Fatpsp'seu6alu! uqoue+Uflla*rour
uearap ua){qEllp slresluro)

ue,!,14o

qo66ue uqe)ioueouad

- '!u! lesed (t) le^e Bped pnqeurlp eueuleoeqas ellaul lqnuarjau ulqas (9)

'qepaq

-

6uel E^uuq ue6uepun-ouepuruad gelqe.lad uelae,{sJad lqnuausul 6

---{rep

---

:nleuoq &re^ ueJn}erad u.Plep rn}etp eueul€6eqas uapuadapul

suesrluoy reoeqss ueleJe^g€d lqnuaul€ul

q(e

sele

uenluaFl lqnu€uraur srueq ulePs uapuadapul sussrulo>

!p

lnqasJal

)irqun

snsn{,

I

06

pped pnsxeu4p eupurle6Bqas uesEle euarot uesuaqreduad uesnlndaxz

-

,u€orasrad uenln] uEp ue8uguadal !,lep

t)

sdnu qqo.

ledal lelplp 6uer( e,(uu!el uesele uapesepreq SdnU qap uerqualaqlp

-

pdep sgesluroy uefl€O Eo66ue '(6) le^e eped pnsleulp eueuilB6eqas
sueslujo)l uefioo s1o66us ueBuaqJaqurod uesele oulduss !O(t, t)
'ui4?qe( eseu, W{ (ores) t, trqun SdnU qqo ltequs)t lg}i6uqp

-

tedep

fqasral

qrEslr.flo)l uerrtac Eo66ue 4qlBraq uE{eqel esErr

nqP :deFl 6ue,(

qqqas-

uqnq u4enp)t

I

ledunduroui 6uB^ ueIpe6uEd uesqnd ueouap lplBsJoq qqEg,(ulp O

-.-:ere63N
nele/rrep uEoftrsr"d ue)flouaui 6ue,( [EXepu0 u]epp lEquq (,

-l

Jpseo uB€06uV uEriluaFl nete/uEp

I

ueouspun{uepuruod uernplad uerqua|al uqeueqe|oulrlEpg (q
eq upouap e^us?6q ueleuesrleF(ll ledep

-

lep! (e

:ueselE qtqal nEe nles qelBs lqnua{laur

lnqasral slresluJoy uer{oo Eo66ue e.Ied B4['Jlqle€q e,(uuepqel
- esEur unlaqas nu&! {lDle,les lnqesal

-

lqarlo

e]o66ue uaorraqlaquau,

Irqun gqasJal sdnu leq t6uan6u6u lep$ ueEuop uep urep untreu

-- 'ppou JesEd ueJqeJad ue{leqreduraur uEouap 'pnslEu4p ualeqet

-

eseuJ

apouad (nles) [ r!Q{P eped uPunqe} SdnU uedrunuad ueouap ledues

nEe unqel (EuI) 9 nIB^ FqasJal sUEsltro)l ue,. oC eto66ue uEeqel eseul

-

epolad (nps) ! eped rlQler"q uep telbuelp (e)lera{!) q euerlrp SdnU
uetep ue)rqualrp 6ue,( le66uel lefas nleueq frqaslal uqexOue6uad(0 !)

-

--

SdnU r6eq le)lr6uau |nqas"l ueuolecuad uep n)efaq 6ue,( ueouepun

--6uepuruad

----

uejrUelod ueouep lensas ueuo|eouad sasoJd tnlel€u.r qeFlas

euJe,\ lJr,\O V UaS

ureqes 6ue6aurad qato ue{ftsnrp

tuei uqe3 uep

I6
gep plp ue4npunouau lauaq sgeslutql ue,{ao Eo06us ouaoas (e (6

-

r)

'irqasrel

--

ue6uo/rol !s!6uau ilnpn .ueEuoarrol rpetrar qEFlas peq (qnFdueHujas)
05 ]Equel oulted nuan uelep usleJeooua|aslp srueq SdnU

qeut

'susslrroy uE^€O Eo66us undoueJoos tefunduaul lEpll u€oJosJed

-- nEle 6uo.r\ol slEsluo, ue \aO elo66ue ueeqelqeqas nlens qalo elqedv{gr)
'ueoJasJod ueqaq sele sueslutox

ue \aO qelo lexouElp 6ue^ qrequq{ u",r €O spEaqes qqo rqueqlp

--

ledap

-

syes!u.to),1

ue \aC elussErq uE e.uepl

r1n1un

uep ,ir4ruos erlo:our

qqo Jqelp slesluJo) qp^\ao elo66ue eied erquelp e!a1 ue!6equred0f)

'nleljaq 6uei ueouepun

-------6uepuruad uelnpred uerrt(ia;a1 ue4lageduaur ueouap SdnU qqo

-

oexdqaup ertuqelunl uep stuol 6uer( UEEqef eumd ueunluesInseulal
seulsegueOuefunl upp ulnIejouo,.l uelsaqrp slJeslujoy !E/$aO Elo66uv(9!)
'e)i€taur

-

-

EJEqe !p oueJo€s qeps utisuogaqureu oueuarrlraq SdnU

lesBd (6r)

lele

Bped pnsleurlp eueuteoEqas uBepeaMel?t ptt
d

-

sUeO undneuJ

qetrl

,!ur

rlqec(9!)

€ua/el Inqul[ AleI ueounqnq lnseLUal .6utduJesel

sruntsleolrunuau lteq 'e50al leFJop u"6uap pduJes

e6Jenle)i uEOunqnq U tuelu 6uEJel!p tsleJo elo66ue ueOuap suequJoy

ueareg e7r66ue erEue uep sqes(uoy uelv1€C elo66ue EJed eJeluv(Fr)

---]euuoq

IBp! ueouap ueflJaqJequ.l"d ueledruauJ

H.i

lesecj (p uep (c

lrunq (6) lele eped pnslBuJlp eueulBoeqes Lesete eu€Je)i ue;.r3.r.l3qur6d(e
u,o

-

a***- u-"r,*o,

uaqlp uelnlouesJaq 6ue^ qelalils llquep 'lur tesed (. ueo (q i= ie)

r"x"

J

I

f

)

: eilqede

rurercq sueslu.lo) ue,uao qo66ue ueleq:f (02)

le,G q rllnq ulePp pnqeqp eueurlp8eqss SdnU ueeleoouaPlued

--

qres!"uoy uearpo
llseq uep e r0nq tuelep pnqetxlp Eueu{E6Bq6s

-

z

lEquel

pxeE/tseur

6uuPd uB6uena, esBf sElu€qo BpEdol uBr{edue,(uatu uep

"pedol

Feruoru! ueB)lnqr.,_i _dy

t/-2%

.

Z-,"a1/'

iV4t

r^-*ha' ---arJ5Z

ry"lr1

"41y'W,

,-Xm

W

-"f"il.y

9)-90't

,/^

.,Y"

NASOO

,.44

4:z

+"r1/

'4"T-,/
I's?r/y
-,. |\

h-

JyuYd

NvIffSUAd NyUVS

'v:ry.4/ 1/-to4

o\^ rcva!.
-\[ u*r,a.,r roo.{ \\ha*rr,^,i,1,:'}"[}r{;":.";
i:,,:,,:r::;',,"fi}:-r[l#-,
J
su,s",h ;^t(-"';iri,
._",-,,{,f \+,{ u
v["cN6 'r'r"
.
"*i i#rpa xi,/^"b,,ll
rnN$_t[ $\

ISdIUXS UIHXV

uEurE-I

^1]M
tZ009Zr(fl a0).[rtrI"-I!l,1a0092r.920092iOr/0)
uod.t.I
bunlrrso eliiurS uenptnde) rsurord r)i€ueg u.nrdnqul .)ntrtlnlen
Sunrtt;rg

1V3'NVI
)NIBI,I
NVSI'INNTC

SV}NI IJVSITNNiId NV}NISI{IS NTUYX
prsB qqn

"]{iueg

serrsraNun npedriJ sndu]rx

IAINXOH

SVI'INXYd

cN[lr']gs vx9NVn

-zo'J

SYJ.ISU!iAlNit

I

.dN/dIN

Surqurqrua4 uaso6
tnqelaEuapl

">.ry
Nltsoo dvuvd

??

/ )',r'
-,':-,a)'J^a 1

-vt Pr/

NVXTVSUSd

\tr"tt

\-.{i!

@$mvt{0

:--'--I a*
ISdIU}IS UIHXY SVSNI

NYSIIfl\]d I'

p{ rP qcn r. r_1

-=iuqlleg ?r6seg ulnetndi) rsii\!-i :r j=.: :e-Ea :-rf,
8r,rurraa eIimg ssusr: r::- ---::j:- -L5

WNXNH

D

SYI].]YVI

\r'll ll3B Y)C\\

B

.,

:-

. ..r-

uE{.rpJpuad tEdBAfU

ulelsl:
E.sruopuF

ere.A3N

qeltuetllqmlag:
€661 rereN

auleSv

It:

eSJe/[
snrqs

Iqe.I leSSueI

ryeJ-I{e-l: ururelex suef

ploJooqsf@prdrqv: llEql
899280// ggSo: uodeJal roEoN

,ggt€:
'Sunllres e)Fues 'q€8ueJ qSueg h.reg