Indonesia gender policy brief 10 02 15
January 2015
Gender and forests in a changing landscape
Understanding women’s participation in
forestry in Indonesia
Policy brief
Photo by Ahmad Dhiaulhaq
Key messages
• AddressthelackofclarityontheconceptofgendermainstreamingamongplannersintheMinistry
ofForestry(MoF)throughcapacitydevelopmentopportunitiesandconsultationmeetingsorganized
bytheMinistryofWomen´sEmpowermentandChildProtection(MoWE).
• Invest in gender- and forestry-related research, including the collection of gender-disaggregated
data,andusetheindingstohelpraiseawarenessonthediversityofforest-dependentcommunities
andthedifferentneedsandprioritiesofmenandwomen.
• With the support and coordination of MoF, develop the capacity of gender working groups to
increasetheireffectivenessinmainstreaminggenderintopolicyplanning.
Background
As a signatory to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), the UN
Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, the
GovernmentofIndonesiahasundertakeninitiativesatpolicyandinstitutionallevelstopromotegenderequalityacrossall
sectors,includingforestry.TheNationalMedium-TermDevelopmentPlan2010-2014envisionsgendermainstreamingasa
developmentstrategytomakepoliciesandprogrammesmoreeffectiveforachievingequalityandinclusiveness(Kusumanto
2013).
ThePresidentialInstructionNo.9(2000)mandatesallgovernmentministriesandagenciestomainstreamgenderanalysisin
theplanning,implementationandmonitoringofdevelopmentpoliciesandprogrammes.Inthiscontext,theMoFadopted
technicalguidelinesfortheimplementationofgendermainstreamingdevelopedbytheMinistryofWomen´sEmpowerment
andChildProtection(MoWE);subsequentlytheMoFcreatedaworkinggroupforgendermainstreamingwithintheministry
in2003(MoF2010).
AtthesametimeMoWEintroducedtheGenderAnalysisPathway(GAP)toolforincorporationofgenderperspectivesin
developmentplanning.ThetoolwasdevelopedcollaborativelywiththeNationalDevelopmentPlanningAgency(BAPPENAS)1
withtechnicalsupportfromtheCanadianInternationalDevelopmentAgency(CIDA).DuetothejointeffortsofMoWE,
BAPPENASandtheMoF,inancialpolicyinstrumentswerealsodevelopedtostrengthengenderaccountabilityingovernment
agencies(Kusumanto2013).
However,forestgovernanceandtenuresystemsinIndonesiagivelimitedattentiontotheheterogeneityofcommunities,
speciically regarding gender, class, ethnicity and other socio-cultural aspects. Most of the work on forest tenure and
governancereforminIndonesiahasfocusedonhowtomanageconlictsbetweencustomarycommunityforestsystemsand
forestsunderstatecontrol.Whilethisthrustseekstochangeboththelegalframeworkanditsimplementation,aswellas
toaddressconlictmanagement,genderequalityprinciplesareseldomconsidered.Thus,gender-basedinjusticesinforest
governanceandtenure,mostlyexperiencedbywomen,haveyettobeaddressedadequately(SiscwatiandMahaningtyas
2012).
This brief discusses how gender perspectives are integrated in Indonesia’s forest policies and laws in terms of women’s
representation,participation,accesstoanddecision-makinginforestuseandmanagement.Thebriefalsohighlightsthe
keychallengesinmainstreaminggenderaspectsandoutlinesrecommendationstopromotegendermainstreamingfurther
intheforestrysector.
1
BAPPENASisresponsibleforgendermainstreaminginnationaldevelopmentplans;ithasamandatetosupportandmonitoritsimplementation.BAPPENAS
isalsoinvolvedintheformulationandreviewofsectoralplansandbudgetsandthusplaysakeyroleinensuringthattheyaregender-responsive.
Gender concerns in forest policies
ThetwokeypolicystrategiesforparticipatoryforestmanagementinIndonesiaarerelatedtosocialforestryandcommunity
forestry. Community forestry, as a policy strategy, began in 1995 with the objective of engaging communities in state
forest areas that had not been allocated as concessions or had no utilization permits. Since 2007, all forestry schemes
concerninglocalcommunities,whetherinsideoroutsideaforestestate,havebeenregulatedbyGovernmentRegulation
6/2007,althoughtheterm‘socialforestry’isnotexplicitlymentioned.SocialandcommunityforestryinIndonesiahasaimed
principallytorehabilitatedegradedforeststoenhancepeople’swelfare.
Theseparticipatorypoliciespresumecommunitiestobehomogenoussocialentitieswithcommoninterestsandpriorities;
theydonotconsiderthattheycomprisedifferentgroupswithdisparategenders,ethnicities,socialstatus,levelsofpower
and access to resources. Likewise, policies related to forest industries and trade do not acknowledge gender rights and
responsibilities, despite women’s signiicant contributions to Indonesia’s forest industries and small- and medium-size
enterprises(SMEs)(Box1),includingtheprocessingofnon-woodforestproducts(NWFPs)(Nansereko2011).
DespitethepromulgationofPresidentialInstructionNo.9(2000),ithasnotbeentranslatedintospeciicforestryregulations
orlawswhichwouldmakeitmandatoryforgovernmentministriesandagenciestomainstreamgenderintheplanning,
implementationandmonitoringofdevelopmentpoliciesandprogrammes.Forexample,thecommunityforestryregulations
andtheregulationsonissuanceofpermitsforharvestingNWFPsdonotincorporategenderconsiderations.
Hence,moreeffortsarerequiredtoaddressthefollowingkeychallengestomainstreamgenderissuesfurtherinIndonesia’s
forestpoliciesandpractices:
•
•
•
Poorunderstandingandlackofclarityontheconceptsofgenderandgendermainstreaminghavegeneratedconfusion
amongMoFoficials.
Members of the MoF’s gender mainstreaming working group have insuficient capacity to fulill their duties and
responsibilitiesastheylackskillsandexpertiseingendermainstreaming.
Duetomeagregender-relevantdataforinformingpolicy-makers,timelyidentiicationofneedsandpriorities,deining
policyoptions,developingprogrammeguidesandmonitoringpolicyimplementationaredificult.
Box 1. Women and forest enterprises
Overtime,community-basedtimberproductionhasgraduallyshiftedfromsubsistencetomarketproductionandhas
becomemoreintegratedintodomesticandexportmarkets.Timberbusinessactivitiesunderscoremen’straditional
rolesascashearnerswhilethoseofwomenarerelegatedtomerelymeetingsubsistenceneeds.
Ifthisperspectivecontinueswithinthechangingcontextofsubsistence-to-marketproduction,women,whoarethe
primaryusersandmanagersofNWFPs,willhavelimitedopportunitiestoproduceandsellproductsforthemarket.In
NWFP-processingindustries,mendominatefurniture-makinglargelyduetothesocially-andculturally-shapedgender
divisionoflabour,eventhoughwomenplaysigniicantrolesinwood-basedindustries.
The Indonesian furniture sector comprises more than 3 500 companies, of which most are SMEs that are familyownedandinwhichwomenareoftenunpaidworkers(Weidnitzeretal.2009;Purnomoetal.2011).Theproblem
isfurtherhighlightedina2009studybytheInternationalLabourOrganizationthatconcludedthattheproportionof
unpaidfemaleworkersinsocialandcommunityforestrywas69percent,whichwassubstantiallylargerthanunpaid
maleworkersat31percent(ILO2010).
Moving forward
Indonesiahasmadeprogressinintegratingwomen’sissuesintonationalprogrammesbyintroducinggendermainstreaming
asastrategyforinclusivityintheNationalMedium-TermDevelopmentPlan2010-2014.Thefollowingrecommendationswill
helpthegovernmenttoaddressremainingchallenges:
• Providecapacitydevelopmentopportunitiesandconsultationmeetings(organizedbytheMoWE)forforestryoficialson
theconceptofgendermainstreaminganditsimportancetosustainableforestmanagement.
• PromotecollaborationbetweentheMoF,MoWEandBAPPENAStosupporttheincorporationofgenderperspectivesin
researchandhumanresourcedevelopmentplanningbytheMoF.
• StrengthenthecapacitiesoftheMoF’sgendermainstreamingworkinggroupandimproveitsoutputthroughtraining
ongenderanalysisandgender-sensitivemonitoringandevaluationtobackstopitsrolesandresponsibilities.
• Hold dialogue and consultation meetings at national and subnational levels to promote understanding on the
heterogeneityofforestcommunitiesandtheinclusionofwomen’sconcernsintenurerightsandparticipatoryforest
policiesandprogrammes.
• Developagender-sensitivemonitoringandevaluationsystemthatincludescollection,useandanalysisofsector-wide
genderstatisticstoinformforestrypolicies.
References
InternationalLabourOrganization(ILO).2010.Labour conditions in forestry in Indonesia.Jakarta,ILO.
Kusumanto, T. 2013. Towards forests in Indonesia for the benefit of men and women: Capacity development needs
assessment for gender mainstreaming into forest policies.Jakarta,Indonesia.Unpublished.
MinistryofForestry(MoF).2010.ReformasiBirokrasi.Jakarta,MoF.
Nansereko,S.C.2011.Is gender relevant in enhancing economic competitiveness of forest industries? Exploring the woodfurniture value networks in Jepara, Central Java – Indonesia.DenmarkandBogor,Indonesia,DepartmentofForest
andLandscapePlanning,CopenhagenUniversityandCenterforInternationalForestryResearch.
Purnomo, H., Irawati, R.H., Fauzan, A.U. & Melati, M. 2011. Scenario-based actions to upgrade small-scale furniture
producersandtheirimpactsonwomeninCentralJava,Indonesia.International Forestry Review,13(2).
Siscwati,M.&Mahaningtyas,A.2012.Gender justice: forest tenure and forest governance in Indonesia. RightsandResources
InstituteBriefNo.3of4.Washington,DC.
Weidnitzer,E.,Sugarda,A.P.&Tambunan,T.T.H.2009.Furniture industry in Indonesia: The labour markets and gender impact
of the global economic slowdown on value chains.Jakarta,DeutscheGesellschaftfürTechnischeZusammenarbeit
GmbH,P.T.PaciicRekanprimaandUniversityofTrisakti.
Thisbriefispartofaprojectentitled‘MainstreamingGenderIssuesintoForestPoliciesofDevelopingAsia-PaciicForestryCommission
(APFC)MemberCountries’fundedbytheFoodandAgricultureOrganizationoftheUnitedNations(FAO)andimplementedbyRECOFTC
–TheCenterforPeopleandForests.Theobjectiveistopromotegenderequalityinnationalforestpolicies,includingstrengtheningthe
capacitiesofpolicy-makersandrelevantstakeholdersinmainstreaminggenderissuesinnationalforestpolicies.Formoreinformation,
see:http://www.recoftc.org/site/Gender/.
©FAOandRECOFTCJanuary2015
Bangkok,Thailand
All rights reserved. Reproduction of material in this brief for commercial purposes is prohibited without permission of the copyright
holders.TheviewsexpressedinthispublicationarenotnecessarilythoseofFAOandRECOFTC.
RECOFTC–TheCenterforPeopleandForests
P.O.Box1111
KasetsartPostOfice
Bangkok10903,Thailand
Tel+66(0)29405700
Fax+66(0)25614880
info@recoftc.org
www.recoftc.org
FAORegionalOficeforAsiaandthePaciic
39PhraAtitRoad
Bangkok10200,Thailand
Tel+66(0)26974000
Fax+66(0)26974445
FAO-RAP@fao.org
www.fao.org
Gender and forests in a changing landscape
Understanding women’s participation in
forestry in Indonesia
Policy brief
Photo by Ahmad Dhiaulhaq
Key messages
• AddressthelackofclarityontheconceptofgendermainstreamingamongplannersintheMinistry
ofForestry(MoF)throughcapacitydevelopmentopportunitiesandconsultationmeetingsorganized
bytheMinistryofWomen´sEmpowermentandChildProtection(MoWE).
• Invest in gender- and forestry-related research, including the collection of gender-disaggregated
data,andusetheindingstohelpraiseawarenessonthediversityofforest-dependentcommunities
andthedifferentneedsandprioritiesofmenandwomen.
• With the support and coordination of MoF, develop the capacity of gender working groups to
increasetheireffectivenessinmainstreaminggenderintopolicyplanning.
Background
As a signatory to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), the UN
Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, the
GovernmentofIndonesiahasundertakeninitiativesatpolicyandinstitutionallevelstopromotegenderequalityacrossall
sectors,includingforestry.TheNationalMedium-TermDevelopmentPlan2010-2014envisionsgendermainstreamingasa
developmentstrategytomakepoliciesandprogrammesmoreeffectiveforachievingequalityandinclusiveness(Kusumanto
2013).
ThePresidentialInstructionNo.9(2000)mandatesallgovernmentministriesandagenciestomainstreamgenderanalysisin
theplanning,implementationandmonitoringofdevelopmentpoliciesandprogrammes.Inthiscontext,theMoFadopted
technicalguidelinesfortheimplementationofgendermainstreamingdevelopedbytheMinistryofWomen´sEmpowerment
andChildProtection(MoWE);subsequentlytheMoFcreatedaworkinggroupforgendermainstreamingwithintheministry
in2003(MoF2010).
AtthesametimeMoWEintroducedtheGenderAnalysisPathway(GAP)toolforincorporationofgenderperspectivesin
developmentplanning.ThetoolwasdevelopedcollaborativelywiththeNationalDevelopmentPlanningAgency(BAPPENAS)1
withtechnicalsupportfromtheCanadianInternationalDevelopmentAgency(CIDA).DuetothejointeffortsofMoWE,
BAPPENASandtheMoF,inancialpolicyinstrumentswerealsodevelopedtostrengthengenderaccountabilityingovernment
agencies(Kusumanto2013).
However,forestgovernanceandtenuresystemsinIndonesiagivelimitedattentiontotheheterogeneityofcommunities,
speciically regarding gender, class, ethnicity and other socio-cultural aspects. Most of the work on forest tenure and
governancereforminIndonesiahasfocusedonhowtomanageconlictsbetweencustomarycommunityforestsystemsand
forestsunderstatecontrol.Whilethisthrustseekstochangeboththelegalframeworkanditsimplementation,aswellas
toaddressconlictmanagement,genderequalityprinciplesareseldomconsidered.Thus,gender-basedinjusticesinforest
governanceandtenure,mostlyexperiencedbywomen,haveyettobeaddressedadequately(SiscwatiandMahaningtyas
2012).
This brief discusses how gender perspectives are integrated in Indonesia’s forest policies and laws in terms of women’s
representation,participation,accesstoanddecision-makinginforestuseandmanagement.Thebriefalsohighlightsthe
keychallengesinmainstreaminggenderaspectsandoutlinesrecommendationstopromotegendermainstreamingfurther
intheforestrysector.
1
BAPPENASisresponsibleforgendermainstreaminginnationaldevelopmentplans;ithasamandatetosupportandmonitoritsimplementation.BAPPENAS
isalsoinvolvedintheformulationandreviewofsectoralplansandbudgetsandthusplaysakeyroleinensuringthattheyaregender-responsive.
Gender concerns in forest policies
ThetwokeypolicystrategiesforparticipatoryforestmanagementinIndonesiaarerelatedtosocialforestryandcommunity
forestry. Community forestry, as a policy strategy, began in 1995 with the objective of engaging communities in state
forest areas that had not been allocated as concessions or had no utilization permits. Since 2007, all forestry schemes
concerninglocalcommunities,whetherinsideoroutsideaforestestate,havebeenregulatedbyGovernmentRegulation
6/2007,althoughtheterm‘socialforestry’isnotexplicitlymentioned.SocialandcommunityforestryinIndonesiahasaimed
principallytorehabilitatedegradedforeststoenhancepeople’swelfare.
Theseparticipatorypoliciespresumecommunitiestobehomogenoussocialentitieswithcommoninterestsandpriorities;
theydonotconsiderthattheycomprisedifferentgroupswithdisparategenders,ethnicities,socialstatus,levelsofpower
and access to resources. Likewise, policies related to forest industries and trade do not acknowledge gender rights and
responsibilities, despite women’s signiicant contributions to Indonesia’s forest industries and small- and medium-size
enterprises(SMEs)(Box1),includingtheprocessingofnon-woodforestproducts(NWFPs)(Nansereko2011).
DespitethepromulgationofPresidentialInstructionNo.9(2000),ithasnotbeentranslatedintospeciicforestryregulations
orlawswhichwouldmakeitmandatoryforgovernmentministriesandagenciestomainstreamgenderintheplanning,
implementationandmonitoringofdevelopmentpoliciesandprogrammes.Forexample,thecommunityforestryregulations
andtheregulationsonissuanceofpermitsforharvestingNWFPsdonotincorporategenderconsiderations.
Hence,moreeffortsarerequiredtoaddressthefollowingkeychallengestomainstreamgenderissuesfurtherinIndonesia’s
forestpoliciesandpractices:
•
•
•
Poorunderstandingandlackofclarityontheconceptsofgenderandgendermainstreaminghavegeneratedconfusion
amongMoFoficials.
Members of the MoF’s gender mainstreaming working group have insuficient capacity to fulill their duties and
responsibilitiesastheylackskillsandexpertiseingendermainstreaming.
Duetomeagregender-relevantdataforinformingpolicy-makers,timelyidentiicationofneedsandpriorities,deining
policyoptions,developingprogrammeguidesandmonitoringpolicyimplementationaredificult.
Box 1. Women and forest enterprises
Overtime,community-basedtimberproductionhasgraduallyshiftedfromsubsistencetomarketproductionandhas
becomemoreintegratedintodomesticandexportmarkets.Timberbusinessactivitiesunderscoremen’straditional
rolesascashearnerswhilethoseofwomenarerelegatedtomerelymeetingsubsistenceneeds.
Ifthisperspectivecontinueswithinthechangingcontextofsubsistence-to-marketproduction,women,whoarethe
primaryusersandmanagersofNWFPs,willhavelimitedopportunitiestoproduceandsellproductsforthemarket.In
NWFP-processingindustries,mendominatefurniture-makinglargelyduetothesocially-andculturally-shapedgender
divisionoflabour,eventhoughwomenplaysigniicantrolesinwood-basedindustries.
The Indonesian furniture sector comprises more than 3 500 companies, of which most are SMEs that are familyownedandinwhichwomenareoftenunpaidworkers(Weidnitzeretal.2009;Purnomoetal.2011).Theproblem
isfurtherhighlightedina2009studybytheInternationalLabourOrganizationthatconcludedthattheproportionof
unpaidfemaleworkersinsocialandcommunityforestrywas69percent,whichwassubstantiallylargerthanunpaid
maleworkersat31percent(ILO2010).
Moving forward
Indonesiahasmadeprogressinintegratingwomen’sissuesintonationalprogrammesbyintroducinggendermainstreaming
asastrategyforinclusivityintheNationalMedium-TermDevelopmentPlan2010-2014.Thefollowingrecommendationswill
helpthegovernmenttoaddressremainingchallenges:
• Providecapacitydevelopmentopportunitiesandconsultationmeetings(organizedbytheMoWE)forforestryoficialson
theconceptofgendermainstreaminganditsimportancetosustainableforestmanagement.
• PromotecollaborationbetweentheMoF,MoWEandBAPPENAStosupporttheincorporationofgenderperspectivesin
researchandhumanresourcedevelopmentplanningbytheMoF.
• StrengthenthecapacitiesoftheMoF’sgendermainstreamingworkinggroupandimproveitsoutputthroughtraining
ongenderanalysisandgender-sensitivemonitoringandevaluationtobackstopitsrolesandresponsibilities.
• Hold dialogue and consultation meetings at national and subnational levels to promote understanding on the
heterogeneityofforestcommunitiesandtheinclusionofwomen’sconcernsintenurerightsandparticipatoryforest
policiesandprogrammes.
• Developagender-sensitivemonitoringandevaluationsystemthatincludescollection,useandanalysisofsector-wide
genderstatisticstoinformforestrypolicies.
References
InternationalLabourOrganization(ILO).2010.Labour conditions in forestry in Indonesia.Jakarta,ILO.
Kusumanto, T. 2013. Towards forests in Indonesia for the benefit of men and women: Capacity development needs
assessment for gender mainstreaming into forest policies.Jakarta,Indonesia.Unpublished.
MinistryofForestry(MoF).2010.ReformasiBirokrasi.Jakarta,MoF.
Nansereko,S.C.2011.Is gender relevant in enhancing economic competitiveness of forest industries? Exploring the woodfurniture value networks in Jepara, Central Java – Indonesia.DenmarkandBogor,Indonesia,DepartmentofForest
andLandscapePlanning,CopenhagenUniversityandCenterforInternationalForestryResearch.
Purnomo, H., Irawati, R.H., Fauzan, A.U. & Melati, M. 2011. Scenario-based actions to upgrade small-scale furniture
producersandtheirimpactsonwomeninCentralJava,Indonesia.International Forestry Review,13(2).
Siscwati,M.&Mahaningtyas,A.2012.Gender justice: forest tenure and forest governance in Indonesia. RightsandResources
InstituteBriefNo.3of4.Washington,DC.
Weidnitzer,E.,Sugarda,A.P.&Tambunan,T.T.H.2009.Furniture industry in Indonesia: The labour markets and gender impact
of the global economic slowdown on value chains.Jakarta,DeutscheGesellschaftfürTechnischeZusammenarbeit
GmbH,P.T.PaciicRekanprimaandUniversityofTrisakti.
Thisbriefispartofaprojectentitled‘MainstreamingGenderIssuesintoForestPoliciesofDevelopingAsia-PaciicForestryCommission
(APFC)MemberCountries’fundedbytheFoodandAgricultureOrganizationoftheUnitedNations(FAO)andimplementedbyRECOFTC
–TheCenterforPeopleandForests.Theobjectiveistopromotegenderequalityinnationalforestpolicies,includingstrengtheningthe
capacitiesofpolicy-makersandrelevantstakeholdersinmainstreaminggenderissuesinnationalforestpolicies.Formoreinformation,
see:http://www.recoftc.org/site/Gender/.
©FAOandRECOFTCJanuary2015
Bangkok,Thailand
All rights reserved. Reproduction of material in this brief for commercial purposes is prohibited without permission of the copyright
holders.TheviewsexpressedinthispublicationarenotnecessarilythoseofFAOandRECOFTC.
RECOFTC–TheCenterforPeopleandForests
P.O.Box1111
KasetsartPostOfice
Bangkok10903,Thailand
Tel+66(0)29405700
Fax+66(0)25614880
info@recoftc.org
www.recoftc.org
FAORegionalOficeforAsiaandthePaciic
39PhraAtitRoad
Bangkok10200,Thailand
Tel+66(0)26974000
Fax+66(0)26974445
FAO-RAP@fao.org
www.fao.org