Worksheet Uji Ranking Hedonik

  Perpustakaan Unika 7.

LAMPIRAN Lampiran 1. Kuesioner Uji Ranking Hedonik

Kuesioner Uji Ranking Hedonik

  Nama : Tanggal Uji : Produk : Tahu Kacang Hijau Atribut : overall rasa Instruksi

Di hadapan anda tersedia 4 sampel tahu kacang hijau. Cicipilah sampel secara berurutan

dari kiri ke kanan. Anda boleh mengulang sesering yang Anda perlukan. Setiap akan

mencicipi sampel yang berbeda berkumurlah dengan air tawar selama kurang lebih 30

detik. Berilah penilaian dengan kisaran nilai 1-4 Antar sampel tidak boleh memiliki

nilai yang sama. 1 = paling tidak suka 2 = tidak suka 3 = suka 4 = paling suka

  Kode sampel Ranking Nama : Tanggal Uji : Produk : Tahu Kacang Hijau Atribut : overall tekstur Instruksi

Di hadapan anda tersedia 4 sampel tahu kacang hijau. Tekanlah sampel secara berurutan

dari kiri ke kanan. Anda boleh mengulang sesering yang Anda perlukan. Berilah

penilaian dengan kisaran nilai 1-4. Antar sampel tidak boleh memiliki nilai yang sama. 1 = paling tidak suka 2 = tidak suka 3 = suka 4 = paling suka

  Kode sampel Ranking

  Perpustakaan Unika Nama : Tanggal Uji : Produk : Tahu Kacang Hijau Atribut : overall aroma Instruksi

Di hadapan anda tersedia 4 sampel tahu kacang hijau. Ciumlah sampel secara berurutan

dari kiri ke kanan. Anda boleh mengulang sesering yang Anda perlukan. Berilah

penilaian dengan kisaran nilai 1-4. Antar sampel tidak boleh memiliki nilai yang sama. 1 = paling tidak suka 2 = tidak suka 3 = suka 4 = paling suka

  Kode sampel Ranking Nama : Tanggal Uji : Produk : Tahu Kacang Hijau Atribut : overall warna Instruksi

Di hadapan anda tersedia 4 sampel tahu kacang hijau. Amatilah sampel secara berurutan

dari kiri ke kanan. Anda boleh mengulang sesering yang Anda perlukan. Berilah

penilaian dengan kisaran nilai 1-4. Antar sampel boleh memiliki nilai yang sama. 1 = paling tidak suka 2 = tidak suka 3 = suka 4 = paling suka

  Kode sampel Ranking

  Perpustakaan Unika

Lampiran 2. Worksheet Uji Ranking Hedonik

Worksheet Uji Ranking Hedonik

  Tanggal uji : 29 Oktober 2008 Jenis sampel : Tahu kacang substitusi kacang hijau Tujuan : Mengetahui tingkat kesukaan tahu substitusi kacang hijau dengan penggunaan dua jenis koagulan asam (asam asetat dan asam sitrat) Identifikasi Sampel A : Tahu substitusi kacang hijau dengan menggunakan koagulan asam sitrat B : Tahu substitusi kacang hijau dengan menggunakan koagulan asam asetat C : Tahu kontrol dengan menggunakan koagulan asam sitrat D : Tahu kontrol dengan menggunakan koagulan asam asetat Kode Kombinasi Penyajian no Kode no Kode 1, 22, 43 ACBD 14, 35 CADB 2, 23, 44 DACB 15, 36 CBAD 3, 24, 45 DCAB 16, 37 CBDA 4, 25, 46 ABCD 17, 38 CDAB 5, 26, 47 ACDB 18, 39 DABC 6, 27, 48 ABDC 19, 40 DCBA 7, 28, 49 BACD 20, 41 DBAC 8, 29, 50 BADC 21, 42 ADBC 9, 30 BDAC 10, 31 BDCA 11, 32 BCAD 12, 33 BCDA 13, 34 CABD

  Penyajian Panelis Kode sampel 1, 25, 49 2, 26 3, 27, 50 4, 28 5, 29 6, 30 7, 31 8, 32 9, 33 10, 34 11, 35 12, 36 13, 37 14, 38 15, 39 16, 40 17, 41 18, 42 19, 43 20, 44 21, 45 22, 46 23, 47 24, 48

  814 900 103 137 322 155 432 777 405 712 613 554 414 191 419 898 815 125 746 366 910 466 191 873 414 653 743 351 792 193 265 159 349 146 371 811 565 619 773 390 311 111 420 561 305 393 198 327 323 401 732 841 363 560 911 791 366 123 840 470 665 876 143 156 998 961 114 501 339 748 847 283 543 753 106 239 333 117 362 435 225 101 418 511 281 931 300 494 230 305 243 610 192 331 914 801

  Rekap Kode Sampel Kode Rekap A 814 155 613 414 815 910 653 193 371 390 420 327 401 560 840 156 114 748 239 362

  225 281 305 914 B 103 777 554 191 366 466 414 792 349 565 311 305 732 791 123 876 501 847 106 117 511 300 610 801

  C 900 432 712 419 125 873 743 159 811 773 111 393 323 363 366 665 998 283 753 435 418 931 243 331 D 137 322 405 898 746 191 351 265 146 619 561 198 841 911 470 143 961 339 543 333 101 494 230 192

  Perpustakaan Unika

  Lampiran 3. Standar Nasional Indonesia Standar Nasional Indonesia Tahu

Tabel 9. Syarat Mutu Tahu

  7.2

  Perpustakaan Unika

  Normal Putih normal/kuning normal Normal tidak berlendir dan tidak berjamur Maks. 1,0 Min. 9,0 Min. 0,5 Maks. 0,1 Sesuai SNI 01-0222-M dan Peraturan Men Kes No 722/Men.Kes/Per/IX/1998 Maks. 2,0 Maks. 30,0 Maks. 40,0 Maks. 40,0/250,0 Maks. 0,03 Maks. 1,0 Maks. 10 Negatif (Sumber: SNI 01-3142-1998)

  % (b/b) % (b/b) % (b/b) % (b/b) % (b/b) mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg APM/g /25g Normal

  9.2 Keadaan: Bau Rasa Warna Penampakan Abu Protein (N x 6,25) Lemak Serat kasar Bahan Tambahan Makanan Cemaran logam Timbal (Pb) Tembaga (Cu) Seng (Zn) Timah (Sn) Raksa (Hg) Cemaran arsen (As) Cemaran mikroba

  9.1

  9

  8

  7.5

  7.4

  7.3

  7.1

  No Jenis Uji Satuan Persyaratan

  7

  6

  5

  4

  3

  2

  1.4

  1.3

  1.2

  1.1

  1

Escherichia coli Salmonella

  Jenis Batch Kadar Air (%) Kadar Abu (%) Protein (%) Kalsium (mg/100 gr) Zat Besi (mg/100gr) Sitrat (55:45)

1 82,980 0,710 8,991 92,619 1,917

82,888 0,884 9,750 93,360 1,917

  83,745 0,759 8,699 92,435 1,826

2 83,785 0,873 9,925 91,926 1,509

83,313 0,792 9,925 92,435 1,450 83,260 0,884 9,575 91,693 1,475

  Cuka (55:45)

1 82,615 0,837 9,988 97,289 1,247

83,214 0,912 9,809 97,408 1,298 83,281 0,995 10,407 98,233 1,281

2 83,174 1,082 10,466 97,653 1,102

82,934 1,099 11,005 98,495 1,059 83,151 0,945 9,988 97,408 1,042

  Sitrat kontrol

1 74,491 1,049 11,104 141,466 2,194

74,056 1,024 11,282 140,247 2,587 74,631 1,091 11,992 142,241 2,384

2 75,398 1,010 11,282 144,447 2,587

74,351 0,901 11,548 142,241 2,461 74,875 1,182 11,015 141,608 2,182

  Cuka kontrol

1 73,400 0,974 13,997 147,315 2,651

72,956 0,929 12,317 148,306 2,704 73,730 1,161 12,224 143,777 2,265

2 73,933 1,214 13,530 145,096 2,278

73,275 1,134 12,690 142,457 1,785 72,837 0,930 13,063 145,447 2,411

  Ket: 55:45 = kacang hijau : kedelai Kontrol = 100% kedelai

  Perpustakaan Unika

Tabel 10. Hasil Penelitian Pengujian Kimia

  95% Confidence Interval for Mean

  N Mean Std.

  Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound

  Minimum Maximum k_air Sitrat 6 83,32850 ,374777 ,153002 82,93520 83,72180 82,888 83,785

  Cuka 6 83,06150 ,248081 ,101279 82,80115 83,32185 82,615 83,281 sitrat KNTRL 6 74,63367 ,463984 ,189421 74,14674 75,12059 74,056 75,398 cuka KNTRL 6 73,35517 ,426769 ,174228 72,90730 73,80303 72,837 73,933 Total 24 78,59471 4,736624 ,966859 76,59461 80,59481 72,837 83,785 k_abu Sitrat 6 ,81700 ,074232 ,030305 ,73910 ,89490 ,710 ,884

  Cuka 6 ,97833 ,101066 ,041260 ,87227 1,08440 ,837 1,099 sitrat KNTRL 6 1,04283 ,093032 ,037980 ,94520 1,14046 ,901 1,182 cuka KNTRL 6 1,05700 ,127119 ,051896 ,92360 1,19040 ,929 1,214 Total 24 ,97379 ,135207 ,027599 ,91670 1,03088 ,710 1,214 protein Sitrat 6 9,47750 ,515174 ,210319 8,93686 10,01814 8,699 9,925

  Cuka 6 10,27717 ,440152 ,179691 9,81526 10,73908 9,809 11,005 sitrat KNTRL 6 11,37050 ,355200 ,145010 10,99774 11,74326 11,015 11,992 cuka KNTRL 6 12,97017 ,698327 ,285091 12,23732 13,70302 12,224 13,997 Total 24 11,02383 1,421988 ,290262 10,42338 11,62429 8,699 13,997 kalsium Sitrat 6 92,41133 ,582368 ,237751 91,80018 93,02249 91,693 93,360

  Cuka 6 97,74767 ,498826 ,203645 97,22418 98,27115 97,289 98,495 sitrat KNTRL 6 142,04167 1,386029 ,565844 140,58712 143,49622 140,247 144,447 cuka KNTRL 6 145,39967 2,168044 ,885100 143,12444 147,67489 142,457 148,306 Total 24 119,40008 24,979195 5,098857 108,85229 129,94787 91,693 148,306

  Fe Sitrat 6 1,68233 ,227063 ,092698 1,44405 1,92062 1,450 1,917 Cuka 6 1,17150 ,116576 ,047592 1,04916 1,29384 1,042 1,298 sitrat KNTRL 6 2,39917 ,181036 ,073908 2,20918 2,58915 2,182 2,587 cuka KNTRL 6 2,34900 ,332044 ,135556 2,00054 2,69746 1,785 2,704 Total 24 1,90050 ,560048 ,114319 1,66401 2,13699 1,042 2,704

  Perpustakaan Unika

  Perpustakaan Unika

Air Tests of Normality

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. Kdr_air Sitrat (55:45)

  ,200 6 ,200(*) ,903 6 ,389 Cuka (55:45)

  ,308 6 ,079 ,841 6 ,134 Sitrat KONTROL

  ,169 6 ,200(*) ,971 6 ,899 Cuka KONTROL

  ,159 6 ,200(*) ,956 6 ,788 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction Duncan

  N Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  1

  2

  3

  1 cuka KNTRL 6 73,35517 sitrat KNTRL 6 74,63367 cuka 6 83,06150 sitrat 6 83,32850 Sig.

  1,000 1,000 ,246 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

Abu Tests of Normality

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. kdr_abu Sitrat (55:45)

  ,275 6 ,176 ,862 6 ,196 Cuka (55:45)

  ,181 6 ,200(*) ,953 6 ,763 Sitrat KONTROL

  ,195 6 ,200(*) ,977 6 ,936 Cuka KONTROL

  ,243 6 ,200(*) ,851 6 ,160 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction Duncan

  N Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  1

  2

  1 sitrat 6 ,81700 cuka 6 ,97833 sitrat KNTRL 6 1,04283 cuka KNTRL 6 1,05700

  Sig. 1,000 ,215 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. Sitrat (55:45)

  Perpustakaan Unika

Protein Tests of Normality

  ,256 6 ,200(*) ,837 6 ,123 Sitrat KONTROL

  ,265 6 ,200(*) ,898 6 ,365 protein Cuka KONTROL

  ,173 6 ,200(*) ,946 6 ,705 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction Duncan

  N Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  1

  2

  3

  4

  1 sitrat 6 9,47750 cuka 6 10,27717 sitrat KNTRL 6 11,37050 cuka KNTRL 6 12,97017 Sig.

  1,000 1,000 1,000 1,000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  ,242 6 ,200(*) ,856 6 ,176 Cuka (55:45)

Kalsium Tests of Normality

  ,276 6 ,170 ,921 6 ,511 Kalsium

  Cuka KONTROL ,158 6 ,200(*) ,974 6 ,919 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction Duncan

  N Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  1

  2

  3

  4

  1 sitrat 6 92,41133 cuka 6 97,74767 sitrat KNTRL 6 142,04167 cuka KNTRL 6 145,39967 Sig.

  1,000 1,000 1,000 1,000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  ,252 6 ,200(*) ,850 6 ,159 Sitrat KONTROL

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. Sitrat (55:45)

  ,194 6 ,200(*) ,946 6 ,705 Cuka (55:45)

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. Sitrat (55:45)

  ,277 6 ,165 ,794 6 ,051 Cuka (55:45)

  ,241 6 ,200(*) ,846 6 ,145 Sitrat KONTROL

  ,205 6 ,200(*) ,870 6 ,225 Fe

  Cuka KONTROL ,233 6 ,200(*) ,917 6 ,484 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction Duncan

  N Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  1

  2

  3

  1 cuka 6 1,17150 sitrat 6 1,68233 cuka KNTRL 6 2,34900 sitrat KNTRL 6 2,39917 Sig.

  1,000 1,000 ,707 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  Perpustakaan Unika

Zat Besi Tests of Normality

  Lampiran 5. Uji Statistik Fisik Tahu Substitusi Kacang Hijau

  Jenis Batch Hardness (N) Cohesiveness Fracture Force (gf) Sitrat (55:45)

1 0,479 0,145 53,585

0,462 0,124 52,842

  0,461 0,145 52,171

2 0,506 0,172 53,136

0,492 0,193 52,078 0,499 0,168 53,021

  Cuka (55:45)

1 0,498 0,148 56,112

0,500 0,145 55,765 0,482 0,144 56,937

2 0,515 0,190 55,704

0,570 0,173 56,318 0,563 0,185 56,420

  Sitrat kontrol

1 2,245 0,152 288,419

2,680 0,156 283,988 2,596 0,157 288,222

2 3,008 0,148 282,662

2,900 0,142 288,591 2,977 0,138 282,165

  Cuka kontrol

1 4,477 0,224 431,484

4,448 0,219 435,319 4,137 0,220 433,516

2 4,543 0,242 430,059

4,856 0,261 445,187 4,526 0,260 434,152

  Ket: 55:45 = kacang hijau : kedelai Kontrol = 100% kedelai

  Perpustakaan Unika

Tabel 11. Hasil Penelitian Pengujian Fisik

  Perpustakaan Unika

Descriptives Uji Fisik

  95% Confidence Interval for N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Mean Minimum Maximum

  Lower Upper Bound Upper Bound Lower Bound Bound Lower Bound Upper Bound Lower Bound Upper Bound

  Hardness Sitrat 6 ,48317 ,019010 ,007761 ,46322 ,50312 ,461 ,506 Cuka 6 ,52133 ,036582 ,014935 ,48294 ,55972 ,482 ,570 sitrat KNTRL 6 2,73433 ,290779 ,118710 2,42918 3,03949 2,245 3,008 cuka KNTRL 6 4,49783 ,229885 ,093850 4,25658 4,73908 4,137 4,856 Total 24 2,05917 1,722049 ,351512 1,33201 2,78632 ,461 4,856

  Cohesivness Sitrat 6 ,15783 ,024555 ,010025 ,13206 ,18360 ,124 ,193 Cuka 6 ,16417 ,021047 ,008592 ,14208 ,18625 ,144 ,190 sitrat KNTRL 6 ,14883 ,007653 ,003124 ,14080 ,15686 ,138 ,157 cuka KNTRL 6 ,23767 ,019541 ,007978 ,21716 ,25817 ,219 ,261 Total 24 ,17713 ,040361 ,008239 ,16008 ,19417 ,124 ,261 fracture Sitrat 6 52,80550 ,582489 ,237800 52,19421 53,41679 52,078 53,585

  Cuka 6 56,20933 ,457811 ,186901 55,72889 56,68978 55,704 56,937 sitrat KNTRL 6 285,67450 3,058236 1,248520 282,46508 288,88392 282,165 288,591 cuka KNTRL 6 434,95283 5,358367 2,187544 429,32957 440,57609 430,059 445,187 Total 24 207,41054 165,264566 33,734488 137,62544 277,19565 52,078 445,187

  54

  Tests of Normality

  1 sitrat 6 ,48317 cuka 6 ,52133 sitrat KNTRL 6 2,73433 cuka KNTRL 6 4,49783 Sig.

  ,207 1,000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  1 sitrat KNTRL 6 ,14883 sitrat 6 ,15783 cuka 6 ,16417 cuka KNTRL 6 ,23767 Sig.

  2

  1

  Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  Duncan N

  Cohessiveness

  ,727 1,000 1,000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  3

  Kolmogorov-Smirnov(a) Shapiro-Wilk jenis Statistic df Sig. Statistic df Sig. sitrat

  2

  1

  Subset for alpha = .05 jenis

  Duncan N

  Hardness

  ,306 6 ,082 ,821 6 ,091 * This is a lower bound of the true significance. a Lilliefors Significance Correction

  Cohesivness cuka KNTRL ,258 6 ,200(*) ,831 6 ,109 sitrat ,195 6 ,200(*) ,929 6 ,575 cuka ,167 6 ,200(*) ,944 6 ,695 sitrat KNTRL ,298 6 ,105 ,801 6 ,060 fracture cuka KNTRL

  Hardness cuka KNTRL ,255 6 ,200(*) ,921 6 ,512 sitrat ,199 6 ,200(*) ,966 6 ,867 cuka ,279 6 ,159 ,835 6 ,119 sitrat KNTRL ,160 6 ,200(*) ,930 6 ,577

  ,201 6 ,200(*) ,906 6 ,413 cuka ,235 6 ,200(*) ,867 6 ,213 sitrat KNTRL ,216 6 ,200(*) ,900 6 ,376

  Perpustakaan Unika

  Perpustakaan Unika Fracture Force

  Duncan N

  Subset for alpha = .05 Jenis

  1

  2

  3

  1 Sitrat 6 52,80550 Cuka 6 56,20933 sitrat KNTRL 6 285,67450 cuka KNTRL 6 434,95283 Sig.

  ,072 1,000 1,000 Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,000.

  Perpustakaan Unika Lampiran 6. Uji Statistik Sensoris Tahu Substitusi Kacang Hijau

Tabel 12. Hasil Pengujian Analisa Sensoris

  Variabel Jenis Ranking Frekuensi Jumlah Rata2 Warna Sitrat (55:45)

  4

  9 36 2,38 3 13 39 2 16 32 1 12 12

  Cuka (55:45) 4 7 28 2,08

  3

  9

  27 2 15 30 1 19 19 Sitrat kontrol 4 21 84 2,92 3 10 30 2 13 26

  1

  6

  6 Cuka kontrol 4 13 52 2,64 3 18 54

  2

  7

  14 1 12 12 Aroma Sitrat (55:45)

  4

  17 68 2,8 3 15 45

  2

  9

  18

  1

  9

  9 Cuka (55:45) 4 14 56 2,68 3 18 54

  2

  6

  12 1 12 12 Sitrat kontrol 4 7 28 2,22 3 12 36

  2 16 32 1 15 15 cuka kontrol 4 13 52 2,38

  3

  5

  15 2 20 40 1 12 12 Variabel Jenis Ranking Frekuensi Jumlah Rata2 Tekstur Sitrat (55:45)

  4

  17

  10

  1

  20

  10

  2

  51

  3

  3

  8 Cuka (55:45) 4 13 52 2,66

  8

  1

  22

  11

  2

  39

  10 sitrat kontrol 4 9 36 2,24

  11

  3

  27

  14 Ket: 4 = paling suka 3 = suka 2 = tidak suka 1 = paling tidak suka

  14

  1

  34

  17

  2

  9

  33

  3

  17 cuka kontrol 4 10 40 2,3

  17

  1

  26

  13

  2

  13

  

18

72 2,82

  

12

48 2,54

  9 Cuka (55:45) 4 9 36 2,12

  30

  15

  2

  21

  7

  3

  9

  19

  1

  34

  17

  2

  36

  12

  3

  1

  19 sitrat kontrol 4 7 28 2,56

  4

  3

  13 Rasa Sitrat (55:45)

  16 1 13

  8

  2

  24

  8

  9 cuka kontrol 4 21 84 2,74

  3

  9

  1

  22

  11

  2

  69

  23

  Perpustakaan Unika

  Perpustakaan Unika Test Statistics(a,b)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Chi-Square

  15,511 8,617 8,300 8,494 Df

  3

  3

  3

  3 Asymp. Sig. ,001 ,035 ,040 ,037 a Kruskal Wallis Test b Grouping Variable: jenis

Sitrat (55:45) Vs Cuka (55:45) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur Rasa Mann-Whitney U

  1043,000 1175,000 968,000 1168,500 Wilcoxon W

  2318,000 2450,000 2243,000 2443,500 Z

• 1,483 -,539 -2,017 -,582 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,138 ,590 ,044 ,560 a Grouping Variable: jenis

Sitrat (55:45) Vs sitrat kontrol (100% kedelai) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Mann-Whitney U

  903,500 880,000 1223,000 917,000 Wilcoxon W

  2178,500 2155,000 2498,000 2192,000 Z

• 2,476 -2,635 -,194 -2,372 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,013 ,008 ,846 ,018 a Grouping Variable: jenis

Sitrat (55:45) Vs Cuka kontrol (100% kedelai) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Mann-Whitney U

  1075,500 991,000 1121,500 951,000 Wilcoxon W

  2350,500 2266,000 2396,500 2226,000 Z

• 1,245 -1,850 -,919 -2,135 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,213 ,064 ,358 ,033 a Grouping Variable: jenis

Cuka (55:45) Vs sitrat kontrol (100% kedelai) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Mann-Whitney U

  737,000 955,000 942,000 985,000 Wilcoxon W

  2012,000 2230,000 2217,000 2260,000 Z

• 3,660 -2,105 -2,202 -1,889 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,000 ,035 ,028 ,059 a Grouping Variable: jenis

  Perpustakaan Unika

Cuka (55:45) Vs Cuka kontrol (100% kedelai) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Mann-Whitney U

  903,000 1066,000 909,000 1016,500 Wilcoxon W

  2178,000 2341,000 2184,000 2291,500 Z

• 2,478 -1,311 -2,445 -1,663 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,013 ,190 ,015 ,096 a Grouping Variable: jenis

Sitrat kontrol (100% kedelai) - Cuka kontrol (100% kedelai) Test Statistics(a)

  warna aroma tekstur rasa Mann-Whitney U

  1069,000 1160,500 1097,000 1207,000 Wilcoxon W

  2344,000 2435,500 2372,000 2482,000 Z

• 1,297 -,643 -1,093 -,308 Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

  ,195 ,520 ,274 ,758 a Grouping Variable: jenis