Beating the Clock Strategic Management under the Threat of Direct Democracy (pages 38–48)

References

Acknowledgments

Backoff , Robert, Barton Wechsler, and Robert E. Crew, Jr. 1993. Th e Challenge of

Th is article benefi ted greatly from the constructive and insightful

Strategic Management in Local Government. Public Administration Quarterly

comments of three anonymous reviewers, as well as participants at

the 7th Transatlantic Dialogue on Strategic Management of Public

Bell Policy Center. 2010. Policy Brief: Preliminary Analysis of Amendment 61.

and Non-Profi t Organizations at Rutgers University–Newark.

November 17. http://bellpolicy.org/node/3501 [accessed October 8, 2012]. Brown, Trevor, and Matt Potoski. 2006. Contracting for Management: Assessing

Notes

Management Capacity under Alternative Service Delivery Arrangements. Journal 1. From the USC Initiative and Referendum Institute, IRI Report on Initiative

of Policy Analysis and Management 25(2): 323–46. Use, 1904–2009, September 2010, http://www.iandrinstitute.org/IRI%20

Bryson, John M., Frances S. Berry, and Kaifeng Yang. 2010. The State of Initiative%20Use%20(2010-1).pdf (accessed October 8, 2012).

Public Strategic Management Research: A Selective Literature Review and 2. Th is article focuses on public managers, but we acknowledge that management

Set of Future Directions. American Review of Public Administration 40(5): is a joint endeavor of appointed managers and elected offi cials in state and local

governments, so the fi ndings may be generalized to the broader group of deci- Budge, Ian. 1971. Correspondence: Agreement and the Stability of Democracy. sion makers across institutional settings.

Political Studies 19(3): 381–82.

3. For more comprehensive literature reviews on (1) direct democracy and initia- Denhardt, Robert B. 1985. Strategic Planning in State and Local Government. State tives and 2) strategic management, see Lupia and Matsusaka (2004) and Poister,

and Local Government Review 17(1): 174–79.

Pitts, and Edwards (2010), respectively. Dodge, William R., and Douglas C. Eadie. 1982. Strategic Planning: An Approach 4. Th ere is a lengthy literature describing responses (or lack thereof ) to threats—or

to Launching New Initiatives in an Era of Retrenchment. MIS Report 14(9): “cheap talk”—that are not deemed credible (see, e.g., Farrell and Rabin 1996;

Gibbons 1992). Eadie, Douglas C. 1983. Putting a Powerful Tool to Practical Use: Th e Application 5. Restrictions on issuing debt in Colorado may be further complicated by the

of Strategic Planning in the Public Sector. Public Administration Review 43(5): existence of home rule charters for many local governments and by the presence

of a Taxpayer Bill of Rights (TABOR), both of which may impose additional Elofson, Stan, Daniel A. Smith, Jennifer Berg, and Joey Lubinski. 2007. A Listing of restrictions.

Statewide Initiated and Referred Ballot Proposals in Colorado, 1912–2006. Issue 6. Combined, these two fi rms served as bond counsel for more than three-quarters

Brief no. 07-07, Colorado Legislative Council Staff . of all Colorado long-term municipal bonds issued during the study period.

Farrell, Joseph, and Matthew Rabin. 1996. Cheap Talk. Journal of Economic 7. Another way to conceptualize the “perceived threat” is by the pattern of fi nancial

Perspectives 10(3): 103–18.

support to the issue committee that led the opposition eff ort against the ballot Gardner-Smith, Brent. 2010. Amendments 60 and 61 Popular with Voters. Aspen items. Th

e number of campaign contributions to Coloradans for Responsible

Daily News, September 10.

Reform peaked in September 2010 as the election neared. Th

Gerber, Elisabeth R. 1996. Legislative Response to the Th reat of Popular Initiatives. of contributions peaked a couple of months earlier, in July, and more than 80

e dollar amount

American Journal of Political Science 40(1): 99–128. percent of all funds were received prior to the end of August. Th is is likely the

———. 1998. Pressuring Legislatures through the Use of Initiatives. In Citizens as time period when public managers were deciding whether to take the necessary

Legislators: Direct Democracy in the United States, edited by Shaun Bowler, Todd steps to issue debt prior to the November election.

Donovan, and Caroline J. Tolbert, 191–208. Columbus: Ohio State University 8. Another possible source of perceived credibility is the history of the initiative

Press.

process in Colorado, where there is an established record of not only using Gerber, Elisabeth R., Arthur Lupia, Mathew D. McCubbins, and D. Roderick direct democracy, but also using it to enact limits on the fi scal discretion of

Kiewiet. 2001. Stealing the Initiative: How State Government Responds to Direct government (see Elofson et al. 2007). Moreover, voters previously adopted

Democracy. New York: Prentice Hall.

TABOR, one of the most stringent state tax and expenditure limits (Martell Gibbons, Robert S. 1992. Game Th eory for Applied Economists. Princeton, NJ: and Teske 2007).

Princeton University Press.

9. Neighboring states are operationalized as those that are geographically adjacent Illescas, Carlos. 2010. Amendment 61 Has Special Districts Pre-emptively Seeking with Colorado: Arizona, Kansas, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah, and

Loans. Denver Post, October 10.

Wyoming. Jacob, Benoy, Becky Lipton, Victoria Hagens, and Bill Reimer. 2008. Rethinking 10. Our primary dependent variable of interest, the number of monthly bond issues

Local Autonomy: Perspectives from Four Rural Communities. Canadian Public in a state, is a count variable. In addition to reporting ordinary least squares

Administration 51(3): 407–27.

(OLS) results, which are favored for ease of interpretation and familiarity to Kutak Rock LLP. 2010. Colorado Debt and Tax Initiatives Analyzed Based on readers, we also report the results using negative binomial regression. Th e count

Existing TABOR Case Law. http://www.kutakrock.com/publications/publicfi - data method results are consistent with the direction and signifi cance of our

nance/ca051910.pdf [accessed October 8, 2012]. reported OLS estimates. A fi rst-diff erenced model, to account for the time-series

Levine, Charles H., Irene S. Rubin, and George G. Wolohojian. 1981. Th e Politics of nature of the data, is also estimated using the specifi cation reported in table 4,

Retrenchment: How Local Government Manages Fiscal Stress. Beverly Hills, CA: column A, with similar results.

Sage Publications.

Beating the Clock: Strategic Management under the Threat of Direct Democracy 47

Lupia, Arthur, and John G. Matsusaka. 2004. Direct Democracy: New Approaches View/D31CE0DA-5056-9125-630AA5F9B17C7CF0/ [accessed October 8, to Old Questions. Annual Review of Political Science 7: 463–82.

2012].

Maguire, Steven. 2010. Tax Credit Bonds: Overview and Analysis. Report no. R40523. Simonsen, Bill, and Larry Hill. 1998. Municipal Bond Issuance: Is Th ere Evidence of Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.

a Principal–Agent Problem? Public Budgeting and Finance 18(4): 71–100. Martell, Christine R., and Paul Teske. 2007. Fiscal Management Implications of

Smith, Daniel A. 2001. Homeward Bound? Micro-Level Legislative Responsiveness Colorado’s TABOR Bind. Public Administration Review 67(4): 673–87.

to Ballot Initiatives. State Politics and Policy Quarterly 1(1): 50–61. Matsusaka, John G. 1995. Fiscal Eff ects of the Voter Initiative: Evidence from the

Staley, Samuel R. 2001. Ballot Box Zoning, Transaction Costs, and Urban Growth. Last 30 Years. Journal of Political Economy 103(3): 587–62.

Journal of American Planning Association 67(1): 25–36. Mullins, Daniel R. 2004. Tax and Expenditure Limitations and the Fiscal Response

Streib, Gregory. 1992. Applying Strategic Decision Making in Local Government. of Local Government: Asymmetric Intra-Local Fiscal Eff ects. Public Budgeting

Public Productivity and Management Review 15(3): 341–55. and Finance 24(4): 111–47.

e Limits of Strategic Planning for Cities. Journal of Urban Poister, Th eodore H., and Gregory Streib. 1994. Municipal Management Tools from

Swanstrom, Todd. 1987. Th

Aff airs 9(2): 139–57.

1976 to 1993: An Overview and Update. Public Productivity and Management U.S. Census Bureau. 2008. 2007 Governments Integrated Directory (GID). http:// Review 18(2): 115–25.

harvester.census.gov/gid/gid_07/options.html [accessed October 8, 2012]. ———. 2005. Elements of Strategic Planning and Management in Municipal

Vogt, A. John. 2004. Capital Budgeting and Finance: A Guide for Local Governments. Government: Status after Two Decades. Public Administration Review 65(1):

Washington, DC: International City/County Management Association. 45–56.

Whorton, Joseph W., and John A. Worthley. 1981. A Perspective on the Challenge Poister, Th eodore H., David W. Pitts, and Lauren Hamilton Edwards. 2010. Strategic

of Public Management: Environmental Paradox and Organizational Culture. Management Research in the Public Sector: A Review, Synthesis, and Future

Academy of Management Review 6(3): 357–61.

Directions. American Review of Public Administration 40(5): 522–45. Williamson, Richard. 2010. Colorado Faces Debt, Tax Revolt: Issuers Rush Deals Robbins, Mark D., and Bill Simonsen. 2012. Do Debt Levels Infl uence State

e Bond Buyer, September 7, 1. Borrowing Costs? Public Administration Review 72(4): 498–505.

Before Election. Th

Ziblatt, Daniel. 2008. Why Some Cities Provide More Public Goods than Others: Sherman & Howard LLC. 2010. Proposition 101 and Amendments 60 and 61—

A Subnational Comparison of German Cities in 1912. Studies in Comparative What to Do in 2010? http://www.shermanhoward.com/NewsAndEvents/

International Development 43(3–4): 273–89.

48 Public Administration Review • January | February 2013