THE PLIGHT OF BEING BLACK REFLECTED IN TATE TAYLOR’S THE HELP MOVIE (2011): The Plight Of Being Black Reflected In Tate Taylor’s The Help Movie (2011): A Marxist Approach.

THE PLIGHT OF BEING BLACK REFLECTED IN
TATE TAYLOR’S THE HELP MOVIE (2011):
A MARXIST APPROACH

RESEARCH PAPER

Submitted as a Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for Getting Bachelor Degree of Education
in English Department
by:
DINA MAULIDA
A320090255

SCHOOL OF TEACHER TRAINING AND EDUCATION
MUHAMMADIYAH UNIVERSITY OF SURAKARTA
2013

i

ii


iii

iv

MOTTO
“Beauty is not in the face; beauty is a light in the heart.”
(Kahlil Gibran)
“Do not think of todays failures, but of the success that may come tomorrow.”
(Helen Keller)
“Sesungguhnya Allah tidak akan mengubah nasib suatu kaum kecuali kaum itu
sendiri yang mengubah apa yang ada pada diri mereka.”
(QS Ar Ra’du : 11)

v

DEDICATION
With my deepest heart, as a final step to be a bachelor degree I
dedicate this research to:
 My Beloved Ibu and Ayah
 My Two Sister (Mb’dian and Dek Inna) and my One Brother

(Dek Addin).
 My special one in my heart.
 My best friends
 People who are willing to read this research paper

vi

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

Bismillahirrohmanirrohim,
Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarokatuh,
First of all, the writer wants to say Alhamdulillahirobbil’alamin and so
many thanks to Allah SWT who has given the writer guidance, blessing and helps
in the way to complete the research paper entitled THE PLIGHT OF BEING
BLACK REFLECTED IN TATE TAYLOR’S THE HELP MOVIE (2011): A
MARXIST APPROACH.
The writer realizes that this research paper can not be done without the
helps from the others who have given spirit and support to the writer in
completing the research paper. Therefore, in this occasion she would like to
express her special and deepest thanks to:

1.

Drs. H. Sofyan Anif, M. Si., as the dean of School Teacher Training and
Education of Muhammadiyah University of Surakarta, for approval to carry
out this research paper.

2.

Dr. Phil. Dewi Candraningrum, M. Ed., as the first consultant who has
given her guidance, support, suggestion, corrections and useful information
for completing this research paper tolerantly and earnestly.

3.

Drs. Abdillah Nugroho, M.Hum., as the second consultant who has given
her guidance, support, suggestion, corrections and useful information for
completing this research paper tolerantly and earnestly.

vii


4.

Titis Setyabudi S.S., as the chief of English Department in Muhammadiyah
University of Surakarta.

5.

All lecturers in English Department for teaching and giving knowledge, and
meaningful advices, so that the writer can comprehend about English well.

6.

Her lovely parents, Ayah and Ibu, who always give for loves, prayers,
supports and meaningful advice so that the writer can complete her research
paper fluently.

7.

Her lovely sister and brother, mb’ Dian, dek Inna and dek Addin, who
always give motivation for her in completing the research paper.


8.

Her lovely grandma, mbah Pat, who always gives prayers for her in
completing the research paper.

9.

Her lovely uncle and aunt, om Alul, tante Ana and many my lovely uncle
and aunt, who give motivation for her in finishing the research paper.

10.

Her special one in her heart, Dita Tri Sambodro, who always gives support
for her in finishing the research paper.

11.

Her beloved friends in Rumah Coklat’s boarding house: Oching, Kimbul,
dek Putri, dek Dzuzu, mb’ Sari, mb’ Ika, mb’ Mery, mb’ Amy, dek

Mir, dek Ririn, dek Nad, dek Tya, dek Jeje and others for the motivation,
jokes, and togetherness.

12.

Her beloved friends: Oching, bu Sus, Desy, mb’ Dhilla, mb’ Mia, mb’ Ely
for jokes and togetherness.

13.

Her friends in Gelas Plastik band : Amirul, Wisnu, Hafid, Mas Surya for
jokes and togetherness.

viii

ix

TABLE OF CONTENT

COVER ........................................................................................................ i

APPROVAL ................................................................................................ ii
ACCEPTANCE ........................................................................................... iii
TESTIMONY .............................................................................................. iv
MOTTO ....................................................................................................... v
DEDICATION ............................................................................................. vi
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ............................................................................ vii
TABLE OF CONTENT .............................................................................. x
LIST OF SCREEN CAPTURED ............................................................... xiv
LIST OF ABBREVIATION………………………………………………xvii
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................. xviii
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION………………………………………….1
A. Background of the Study .................................................. 1
B. Previous Study .................................................................. 7
C. Problem Statement ............................................................ 7
D. Objective of the Study ..................................................... 7
E. Limitation of the Study ..................................................... 8
F. Benefit of the Study .......................................................... 8
G. Research Method .............................................................. 8
H. Research Paper Organization .......................................... 10


x

CHAPTER II UNDERLYING THEORY …………………………………11
A. Notion of Marxism ...... .................................................... .11
B. Major Principle of Marxism ............................................. .12
1.

Dialectical Materialism................................................12

2.

Historical Materialism................................................ 13

3.

Class Struggle..............................................................13

4.

Revolution...................................................................14


5.

Alienation....................................................................14

C. Concept of Black................................................................15
1.

Notion of Black...........................................................15

2.

Aspects of Being Black...............................................17
a. Materialist Orientation.............................................17
b. Individualist Orientation.........................................18
c. Alien-Self Orientation.............................................18
d. Anti-Self Orientation...............................................18
e. Self-Destructive Orientation....................................18
f. Integration Orientation............................................18


D. Structural Elements of the Movie………………… ......... .21
1.

Narrative Elements..................................................... 21

2.

Technical Elements.....................................................23

E. Theoretical Application ………………………………….30
CHAPTER III SOCIAL BACKGROUND OF AMERICAN SOCIETY IN
THE EARLY TWENTY FIRST CENTURY….....… .......31
A. The Social Background of American Society in the Middle
twentieth Century..............................................................31

xi

a.

Social Aspect...........................................................31


b.

Economic Aspect....................................................34

c.

Political Aspect.......................................................36

d.

Cultural Aspect...................... ............................…37

e.

Religious Aspect ...................................................38

f.

Educational............................................................38

g.

Science and Technology Aspect............................41

B. Life of Tate Taylor.............................................................41
CHAPTER IV STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS..............................................45
A. Narrative Elements............................................................45
1. Character and Characterization.....................................45
2. Plot ...............................................................................56
3. Setting...........................................................................60
4. Point of View................................................................63
5. Theme...........................................................................64
B. Technical Elements..........................................................65
1. Mise-en-scene..............................................................65
2. Cinematography .........................................................74
3. Sound..........................................................................78
4. Editing ........................................................................79
C. Discussion .......................................................................81
CHAPTER V MARXIST ANALYSIS OF THE HELP MOVIE .............86
A. Marxist Analysis...............................................................86
1. Dialectical Materialism................................................87

xii

2. Historical Materialism..................................................90
3. Class Struggle .............................................................93
4. Revolution ...................................................................96
5. Alienation.....................................................................98
B. Concept of Being Black....................................................101
1. Materialist Orientation..................................................102
2. Individualist Orientation..............................................104
3. Alien-Self Orientation..................................................106
4. Anti-Self Orientation...................................................109
5. Self-Destructive Orientation........................................111
6. Integration Orientation.................................................112
C. Discussion........................................................................114
CHAPTER VI CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION.............................119
A. Conclusion.......................................................................119
B. Educational Implication...................................................120
C. Suggestion........................................................................121
BIBLIOGRAPHY
VIRTUAL REFERENCE
APPENDICES

xiii

LIST OF SCREEN CAPTURED
SC 1 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:04:25) Skeeter is driving.

46

SC 2 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:08) Skeeter’s Face

46

SC 3 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:01:23) Aibileen When Interviewed by Skeeter

48

SC 4 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:09:00) Aibileen as the Colored Maid in Elizabeth’s House

48

SC 5 (TH, 1st VCD, 00: 08:10) Minny as the Colored Maid in Hilly’s House

50

SC 6 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:50:18) Minny as the colored maid in Celia’s House

50

SC 7 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:11:04) Hilly’s Face

52

SC 8 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:30:34) Hilly’s Face

52

SC 9 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:14:15) Elizabeth’s face when there is meeting with friends.

54

SC 10 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:03:29) Elizabeth’s Face When facing Hilly’s Problem.

54

SC 11 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:06:45) Celia Foote While Having Lunch with Minny

55

SC 12 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:52:13) Celia wants to say thanks to Minny.

55

SC 13 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:01:49) Aibileen’s Kitchen

61

SC 14 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:24:44) Aibileen’s Kitchen

61

SC 15 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:04:50) The Jackson Journal

61

SC 16 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:04:50) The Jackson Journal

61

SC 17 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:23:31) Garden of Phelan’s House

61

SC 18 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:15:11) Garden of Phelan’s House

61

SC 19 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:14:50) Aibileen’s Living Room

62

SC 20 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:14:09) Aibileen’s Living Room

62

SC 21 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:48:00) Summer Season

62

SC 22 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:00:31) The Process of Writing in the Evening

63

SC 23 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:33:17) Rainy Season

63

xiv

SC 24 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:04:16) The Way to Jackson Journal

66

SC 25 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:04:16) Meeting of White People

66

SC 26 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:04) Restaurant

66

SC 27 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:10:57) Skeeter’s Complete Costume

70

SC 28 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:22:23) Skeeter’s Daily Costume

70

SC 29 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:08) Skeeter’s Dinner Costume

70

SC 30 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:31:05) Intensity or Brightness

71

SC 31 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:33:42) Intensity or Brightness

71

SC 32 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:38:02) Brown Color

72

SC 33 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:33:31) White Color

72

SC 34 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:11:04) The Frontal Light

73

SC 35 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:28:04) Top Lighting

73

SC 36 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:08) Side Lighting

73

SC 37 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:33:42) Sunshine

74

SC 38 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:06:35) Moonlight

74

SC 39 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:25:47) Photographic Qualities of the Shot

75

SC 40 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:25:52) Photographic Qualities of the Shot

75

SC 41 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:08) Straight Angle

76

SC 42 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:11:10) Low Angle

76

SC 43 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:31:11) High Angle

76

SC 44 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:20:10) Extreme Long Shot

77

SC 45 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:49:20) Long Shot

77

SC 46 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:15:07) Medium Long Shot

77

SC 47 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:08:39) Medium Shot

77

xv

SC 48 (TH, 2nd VCD, 00:03:29) Medium Close-Up

78

SC 49 (TH, 1st VCD, 01:03:44) Close-Up

78

SC 50 (TH, 1st VCD, 00:37:45) Extreme Close-Up

78

xvi

LIST OF ABBREVIATION

SC

: Screen Captured

TH

: The Help

VCD

: Video Compact Disc

xvii

ABSTRACT

DINA MAULIDA. A 320090255. THE PLIGHT OF BEING BLACK
REFLECTED IN TATE TAYLOR’S THE HELP MOVIE (2011): A
MARXIST APPROACH. RESEARCH PAPER. MUHAMMADIYAH
UNIVERSITY OF SURAKARTA.
In this study is primarily proposed to analyze how the plight of being
black reflected in Tate Taylor’s The Help movie (2011) viewed from Marxist
approach, and to analyze the movie based on its structural elements.
The writer uses Karl Marx’s Marxism theory to answer the problem of the
study. In analyzing The Help movie, the writer conducts the study by using a
descriptive qualitative study that it has data in the form of written or oral from
observing people or behavior and Marxist approach. There are two data source in
this study, primary and secondary data. The primary data source is the play of The
help movie itself and the secondary data source are the sources that relate to the
primary data, such as author’s biography, books or e-books, journal, internet or
any information relate the issue of this study “the plight of being black” and social
background of American society in the middle twentieth century. The data are
collected by using two kinds of technique, the first is note taking and the second is
image capturing.
The result of this study shows that there is plight of being black in
America at the 1960’s period. At the time the struggle to be equal for taking out
from segregation era is difficult to achieve. In The Help movie (2011), Tate
Taylor wants to show that this is the real life happened in America, and he wants
to tell that there is no separated treatment in human although each people have
different color, culture, ideology, and the like.

xviii