94
endix 2: Physical and Chemical Data of Water Criterion n
a i
Nove r 2007
sics Chemistry
App a.
Physical a d Chemical D ta Observation t me:
Phy
mbe
Turbidity olour TDS
Fe Mn Na NH4 Cl
SO4 NO2 NO3 C
pH CaCO3
No Point
ID Location
TCU mgl mgl mgl mgl mgl mgl mgl mgl mgl
NTU Standard Limit
Health Ministerial No. 907 15
100 6,5-
250 3 50 MENKESSKVII2002
5 8,5
500 0.3 0.1 20
1.5 250
1 SG28
Bp. Gufron, Ds.Kalidawir, Tglangin 3
1404 7.43
704.2 0.31
114 5
383.6 20.2
0.3 2
SG30 Bp.Rojih,Ds. Sentul, Tglangin
2688 7.28
1355.7 388
2.5 1356.2
89.6 1.4
2 3
uryati orong
0 1700 7.14 1291.7 1.2 0.16 100
72.9 SG32 B.S
,Renokenongo,P 3
2.1 724.1 0.01 0.4
4 SG34 Bp.
SafiI,Besuki,Porong 0 111
0.01 8
6 7.27 331.4
0 0 30 1.7 313.1 44.6
0.2 5 SG36
Pabrik Krupuk Bp.Hasan,Pejarakan,Jabon
2 0 588 7.45 305 0 0 102 0.3 65.8 18.7 0 0.1
6 SG39 B.Sri,Gedang,Porong
3 5 496 7.37 316.3
2.28 0.61 72 0.6 62.2 74.9 0 0.1
7 Jaga
5720 6.96
2397 2.52
5.2 1420
35.5 SG41
Pos Pintu KA Siring
3 14
3718.3 0.02
2 8 SG43
PT Candi
Oksigen,Siring 0 144
0 2 1
8 7.42 293.7
0.96 2.3 42 571.4 31.7
0.1 9 SG44
Bp.Suprayitno,Ketapang,Tgang 10 472 7.61 224.5 0 0 68 0.5 57.1 36.4 0 0.1
in 2
10 SG46 Bp.Abd Wahid,Beringin,Pamotan
0 1164 7.42 327.6 0 0 250 10 244.6 77.8 0.01 1.1
2 11
SB35 Jatim
yu 25
564 8.48
17.3 0.4
232 0.5
52. 13.6
PT Autocom,Wonoa
5 1
0.01 2.2
12 SB50 Sembura 0 309
08 295 0
n,Jatirejo 6 7.26 382.2
0 12 0 1321
0.2 13 AB116 Siring
12 8440 6.61 2108.9 21.08 0.17 3000 4.4 5623.4 205.5 0.02 0.4 400
15 AB117 Mindi 10 356 7.6 210.9 4.8
48 1.1 88.5 22.2 0 0.3
36 1
de Pond
15 22100 7.58
7 22.08 0
00 151.
4 AL31 Insi
8661. 56
180 15656 6
0.5 0.1 1
tanggul 46 10
161 6
00 80
0.03 10
170 13307.6
68 20
7.7 2628.
6 AL40
Titik
95
Physi Chemical
on time: Feb 2008
Phys C
b. cal and
Data Observati ruary
ics hemistry
Turbidity Colour TDS pH CaCO3
a 3
Fe Mn
N NH4
Cl SO4
NO2 NO
No Point
ID Location
NTU T mgl
mgl mgl
mgl mgl mgl
CU mgl
mgl mgl
Standard Limit Health
terial No. 907 02
5 15 1000
6,5- 8,5
500 0.3 0.1 200 1.5 250 250 3 50 Minis
MENKESSKVII20
1 Bp. Gufron, Ds.Kalid
3 1404
7.43 704.2
14 20
SG28 awir, Tglangin
0.31 1
5 383.6
.2 0.3
2 G3
Bp.R g
268 7
388 1356.2
89.6 1.4
S ojih,Ds. Sentul, Tglan in
2 8
7.28 1355.
2.5 3 SG32
B.Suryati,Renokenongo,Por 1291.7
1.2 0.16 100 2.1 724.1 72.9 0.01 0.4 ong
3 0 1700
7.14 4 SG34
Bp. SafiI,Besuki,Por
8 0 1116
7.29 391 0.6 8.3 627 9.56 1609.3 6.79
0.01 0.2 ong
5 SG36 Pabrik Krupuk
Bp.Hasan,Pejara 2 0
588 7.45
305 02
18 kan,Jabon
1 0.3
65.8 .7
0.1 6 SG39
B.Sri, 49
0.61 72 0 0.1
Gedang,Porong 3
5 6 7.37 316.3
2.28 0.6 62.2 74.9
7 SG41
Pos Jaga Pintu KA S 3
5720
7.2 3158 0.07 8.34 141.9 3.26 902.41 46.3
0.02 2 iring
8 SG43 PT
Candi Oksigen,Siring
1 0 1448
6.12 683 0.78 4.48 4105
8.51 7348.9 760.02
0 0.1 9 SG44
Bp.Suprayitno,K gangin
2 10 472
6.96 89.8 4.76
8.7 334.
20
etapang,T
0.17 15
2.8 48
.19
0.1 10 SG46 Bp.A
hid,Berin amotan
116
353
bd Wa
gin,P 2
4
6.8 69.5 0.02 0
0.99 416.14 45.27
0.01 1.1 11
SB35 yu
25 564
8.48 0.4
232 0.5
52.1 13.6
0.01 2.2
PT Jatim Autocom,Wonoa 5
17.3 12 SB50 Semburan,Jatirejo
0 3096
7.15 103.9 0.17 0.37 980 4.84 1245.85 136.57
0 0.2 13 AB116 Siring
400 12 8440 6.61 2108.9
21.08 0.17 3000 4.4 5623.4 205.5 0.02 0.4 1
Mindi 36 1
356 7.6
8 5
AB117 210.9
4.8 0 4 1.1 88.5 22.2 0 0.3
14 Inside
Pond 8661.7
22.08 0 5600 180 15656 151.6 0.5 0.1 15 22100
7.58 AL31
16 AL40
Titik t 10
16120 7.7
2628.6 6800
170 13307.6
80 0.03
10 anggul 46
Appendix 3: List of Expert
No. Name stitutio
In n
1 ra Badri
ronment ogy Researcher
Centre of Environm al Geo
andung Ind
Envi al
Ge ent
logy, B ol
2 Rimbawati Chief of
m Settlement Agency Dinas Pemukiman of Sidoarjo
Regen Progra
cy 3
ko Teg ibowo
asub Pokja anganan
nutupan S ran
BPLS ndo
Ha u W
h K
Pen Pe
embu 4
ien Widodo Disaster Technology Institute of Sepuluh Nopember,
Surab Am
Researcher aya
5 Public
A group of victim of Lapindo mud hazard
Appendix 4: Inpu
M of A iteria o
r the Hierarchy : Indra Badri
Subsidence ble
F ed Area
ater Priority
t PC ll Cr
ve 1.
Expert
Criteria Bub
lood W
Quality Subsidence 1
5 17 19 0.041
1 B
le 1 13 16
0.124 ubb
5 Flooded Area
1 1
0.240 7
3 4
Water Quality 4
0.596 9
6 1
CR = 0.093
Bubble Gas Methane H2S CO2 Priority
Methane 1 5 3 0.648
H2S 15 1 12 0.122
CO2 13 2 1 0.230
CR = 0.003
Subsidence Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 5 7 9 .648
Z 15 1 3 5
0. 2
211 Z
17 13 1 2 0.
3 088
Z 19 15 12 1
0. 4
052 CR = 0.044
Methane Z1 Z2 Z3
Z4 Priority
Z1 1 4 6
8 0.627
Z2 14 1 2 4
0.203 Z3
16 12 1 2 0.108
Z4 18 14 12 1
0.061 CR
= 0.017
96
H2S Z1 Z2 Z3
Z4 Priority
Z1 1 4 6
8 0.627
Z2 14 1
0.203 2 4
Z3 16 12 1 2
0.108 Z4
18 14 12 1 0.061
CR = 0.017 CO2
Z1 Z2 P
Z3 Z4 riority
Z1 1 4 6 8
0.627 Z2
14 1 2 4 .203
Z3 16 12 1 2
0.108 Z4
18 14 12 1 0.061
CR = 0.017
Flooded Area
1 2 3 4 ty Z
Z Z
Z Priori
Z1 1
5 7
9 0.648
Z2 15
1 1 3
5 0.21
Z3 17
13 1
2 0.088
Z4 19 15 12 1
0.052 CR = 0.044
Water Quality
Z1 2 3 4 ity Z
Z Z
Prior Z1
1 5 7 8 9
0.64 Z2
1 3 1 15
5 0.21
Z3 7 3 1
8 1
1 2
0.08 Z4
19 15 12 1 0.052 CR = 0.044
2.
Expert : Rimbawati
Subsidence Bubble
Flooded Area Water Quality
Priority Criteria
Subsidence 1 15 17 16 0.049
Bubble 5 1 15 13
0.141 Flooded Area
3 0.544
7 5
1 Water Quality
3 1
0.266 6
3 1
CR = 0.091
s Methane H2S CO2 Priority
Bubble Ga
Methane 1 2 3 0.525
H2S 12 1 3
0.33 4
CO2 13 13 1 0.142
CR = 0.046
Subsidence Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Pri ority
Z1 1 4 5 7
0.593 Z2
14 1 3 4 0.234
Z3 15 13 1 2
0.108 Z4
17 14 12 1 0.065
CR = 0.041
97
M 4
Priority ethane
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z Z1
1 4 6 8 0.596
Z2 14 1 4 5
0.248 Z3
16 14 1 3 05 0.1
Z4 18 15 13 1
2 0.05
C Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority R = 0.078
H2S Z1
1 5 6 7 0.611
Z2 15 1 3 5
0.222 Z3
16 13 19
1 3 Z4
17 1 1
0.055 5 3
1 CR = 0.089
CO2 Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 2 4 6 0.512
Z2 12 1 2 4
0.275 Z3
14 12 1 2 0.138
Z4 16 14 12 1
0.074 CR = 0.004
Flooded Area
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Z1 1
6 7
8 0.547
Z2 6 4 5
1 8
0.315 Z3
7 5 1 1
1 4
0.096 Z4
8 8 4 1
1 1
1 0.041
CR = 0.036
Water Quality
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Z1 1
5 6
8 0.617
Z2 1 4
15 5
0.237 Z3
6 4 1 1
1 2
0.091 Z4
8 5 2 1
1 1
1 0.055
CR = 0.076 3.
Expert : Handoko Teguh Wibowo Criteria
Subsidence ble
Flood Area ater Qu
Priority Bub
W ality
Su nce
9 0.548 bside
1 3
5 Bubble 13 1 4
7 0.285 Flood Area
15 14
1 5
0.126 Water Quality
19 17
15 1
.041 CR = 0.089
Bubble Gas Methane H2S CO2 Priority
Methane 1 4 6 0.685
H2S 14 1 3 0.221
CO2 16 13 1 0.093
CR = 0.047
98
Subsidence Z1 Z2 Z3 Z
Pr 4
iority Z
1 5 7 9 0.
1 645
Z 15 1 2 7
0. 2
212 Z
17 12 1 2 0.
3 094
Z 19 17 12 1
0. 4
050 CR = 0.061
Methane Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 3 5 7 0.558
Z2 13 1 3 5
0.263 Z3
15 13 1 3 0.122
Z4 17 15 13 1
0.057 CR
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 ority = 0.044
H2S
Pri Z1
1 2 4 6 512
0. Z2
12 1 2 4 0.275
Z3 14 12 1 2
0.138 Z4
16 14 12 1 0.074
CR Priority
= 0.004 CO2
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Z1
1 2 4 6 0.512
Z2 12 1 2 4
0.275 Z3
14 12 1 2 0.138
Z4 16 14 12 1
0.074 CR = 0.004
Flooded Area
1 2 4 ty Z
Z Z3
Z Priori
Z1 1 3 5 7
0.558 Z2
13 1 3 5 0.263
Z3 15 3
1 1
3 0.122
Z4 7 5 3
1 1
1 1
0.057 CR = 0.044
Water Quality
1 2 4
ty Z
Z Z3
Z Priori
Z1 1 3 5 7
0.558 Z2
13 1 3 5 0.263
Z3 5 3
1 1
1 3
0.122 Z4
7 5 3 1
1 1
1 0.057
CR = 0.044 .
Expert : Amien Widodo
a Subsidence
ble F
ed Area ater
Priority
4
Criteri Bub
lood W
Quality Subsidence 1
1 9
0.498 9
B le 1 5
0.373 ubb
1 5
Flooded Area 9
5 1
0.065 1
1 1
Water Quality 9
5 1
0.065 1
1 1
CR = 0.016
99
100
Methane H2S CO2 Pri Bubble
ority Methane 1
0.4 1 5 55
H2S 1 0.45
1 5 5 CO2 15
0.09 15 1
1 CR = 0.000
Subsidence Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 4 6 9 0.594
Z 14 1
2 4 6
0.251 Z
16 14 3
1 4 19 Z
19 16 14 4
1 0.044
CR = 0.094
Methane Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 4 6 9 0.594
Z2 14 1 4 6
0.251 Z3
16 14 1 4 19 Z4
19 16 14 1 0.044
CR = 0.094 H2S
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Z1 1
1 1 14
1 Z2
1 1 1
14 1
Z3 1 1 1 1
14 Z4
1 1 1 1 14
CR = Z3 Z4
Priority 0.000
CO2 Z1 Z2
Z1 1 1 1 1
14 Z2
1 1 1 1 14
Z3 1 1 1 1
14 Z4
1 1 1 1 14
C R = 0.000
Flooded Area Z1
Z3 Z4 Priority
Z2 Z1
1 4 6 9 0.594
Z2 14 1 4
6 0.251
Z3 16 14 1
4 19 Z4
19 16 1 1
0.044 4
CR = 0.094
Water Quality Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 4 6 9 0.594
Z2 14 1 4 6
0.251 Z3
16 14 1 4 19 Z4
19 16 14 1 0.044 CR = 0.094
5.
101
Expert : The Public victim of Lapindo mud hazard Criteria
le Ar
y Subsidence
Bubb Flooded
ea Water Quality
Priorit Su
ence 1 13 19 16 0.048
bsid B
08 ubble 3 1 0.2 0.25
0.1 Flooded Area
3 61
9 5
1 0.5
Water Qua 1
83 lity
6 4
13 0.2
CR = 0.047
Bu e
P bble
Methan H2S CO2 riority
Methane 1 5 8 0.723
H 15 1 4
0.206 2S
CO2 18 14 1 0.070
CR = 0.083
Subsidence
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Z1 1 4 5 7
1.266 Z2
14 1 3 5 0.767
Z3 15 13 1 2
0.276 Z4
17 15 12 1 0.139
CR = 0.086
Methane
Z1 Z2 Z3 4 Pri
y Z
orit Z1
1 4 7 9 0.607
Z2 14 1 3 7
0.234 Z3
17 13 1 0.
5 118
Z4 19 17 15 1
0.041 CR = 0.099
H2S Z1 Z2 Z3
Pri y
Z4 orit Z1
1 3 6 7 0.577
Z2 13 1 2 5
0.231 Z3
16 12 1 4 0.138
Z4 17 15 14 1
0.054 CR = 0.056
C
ri
O2 Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
P ority Z1
1 3 4 6 0.543
Z2 13 1 2 5
0.257 Z
14 12 1 2 0.131
3 Z4
16 15 12 1 .069 CR = 0.027
Flooded Area Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 5 7 9 0.516
Z2 15 4
0.34 7
8 1 Z3
17 17 0.10
1 6 7
Z 19 18 16 1
0.03 4
6 CR = 0.061
102
Water Quality Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 3 6 7 0.557
Z2 13 1 4 5
0.269 Z3
16 14 1 4 0.120
Z4 17 15 14 1
0.053 CR = 0.098
: Geometric Mean of Input PCM for All Criteria
Criteria Subsidence
Bubble Flooded Area
Water Quality Priority
Appendix 5
Subsidence 1 12 13 13 0.108
Bubble 2 1 12 12
0.187 Flooded Area
3 2
1 2
0.412 Water Quality
3 2
12 1
0.293
Bubble Methane H2S CO2 Priority
Methane 1 3 5 0.633
H2S 13 1 3 0.260
CO2 15 13 1 0.106
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Subsidence
Z1 1 4 6 8
0.611 Z2
14 1 3 5 0.235
Z3 16 13 1 2
0.097 Z4
18 15 12 1 0.057
Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4 Priority
Methane
Z1 1 4 6 8
0.606 Z2
14 1 3 5 0.232
Z3 16 13 1 3
0.110 Z4
18 15 13 1 0.052
H2S Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 3 4 5 0.542
Z2 13 1 2 3
0.233 Z3
14 12 1 2 0.140
Z4 15 13 12 1
0.085
CO2 Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 2 3 4 0.466
Z2 12 1 2 3
0.277 Z3
13 12 1 2 0.161
Z4 14 13 12 1
0.096
Appendix 6: Fuzzy AH
a.
b.
103
Flooded Area Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 5 6 8 0.601
Z2 15
1 4 6 0.240
Z3 16 14 1 4 0.113
Z4 18 16 14 1 0.046
Water Quality Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Priority Z1
1 4 6 8 0.596
Z2 14
1 4 5 0.248
Z3 16 14 1
3 0.105 Z4
18 15 13 1 0.052
P Performance of All Criteria over the Hierarchy at Several Alpha and Lambda Value
Fuzzy Weight of Criteria
Fuzzy Weight Criteria
Lower Middle Upper
Subsidence 0.046 0.105 0.351
Bubble 0.069 0.194 0.614
Flooded Area 0.111 0.387 1.228
Water Quality 0.090 0.315 0.965
Fuzzy Weight of Bubble Gases
Fuzzy Weight Bubble Gases
Lower Middle Upper
CH
4
0.224 0.605 1.522 H
2
S 0.099 0.291 0.819
CO
2
0.060 0.103 0.273
c. Fuzzy AHP Performance of Criteria at Alpha = 0.4