71
ANSWER KEY
POSITIVE ELLIPTICAL 1. A
2. C 3. A
4. A 5. A
6. A 7. B
8. A 9. A
10. A
NEGATIVE ELLIPTICAL 11. D
12. B 13. C
14. A 15. D
16. D 17. D
18. D 19. D
20. B
OPPOSITE ELLIPTICAL 21. A
22. D 23. A
24. C 25. B
26. D
72
27. A 28. A
29. C 30. A
Questionnaire items for learners
: 1.
Did you learn the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences ? a.
Yes b.
No c.
I did know 2.
Is the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences learned with excercises ? a.
Yes b.
No c.
I do not know 3.
Do you think the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences is difficult to understand ?
a. Difficult to understand
b. Easy to understand
c. I do not know
4. If there, what are the difficult to understand the elliptical construction or elliptical
sentences ? a.
The patterns kinds of elliptical sententences b.
The vocabularies understanding meaning c.
Nothing
73 5.
Can you understand when the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences given in one meeting ?
a. Yes
b. No
c. I do not know
The table
No Items
Answers percentage
Explanation
A B
C 1
Did you learn the elliptical construction or elliptical
sentences ? 66,7
25 8,3
Choosing A greater than B and
C
2 Is the elliptical construction or
elliptical sentences learned with excercises ?
8,3 66,7
25 Choosing B greater
than A and C
3 Do you think the elliptical
construction or elliptical sentences is difficult to
understand ? 83,3
6,7 10
Choosing A greater than B and
C
4 If there, what are the difficult to
understand the elliptical construction or elliptical
sentences ? 26,7
63,3 10
Choosing B greater than A and C
5 Can you understand when the
elliptical construction or 5
83,3 11,7 Choosing B greater
than A and C
74 elliptical sentences given in one
meeting ?
Processed from Questionnaire
62
REFERENCES
Achirani. 2011. An Error Analysis Of The Use Of Using Present Tense Made By Students of Second Year Junior High School Of Madrasah Tsanawiyah Al
Wasliyah 16 Perbaungan.Medan Apriyanti, Erah. 2009. Solusi Taktis UN. Depok : Media Pusindo
Azar, Betty Schrampfer. 1989. English Grammar. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Inc. Arikunto, Suharsimi. 1993. Prosedur Penelitian: Suatu Pendekatan Praktek. Jakarta:
Rineka Cipta Biber, Douglas. 2002. Student Grammar of Spoken and Written English. England:
Longman Group Ltd. Carrol, John B. 1993. Human Cognitives Abilities. Rowley: Cambridge University
Press. Depdikbud. 1983. Dirjen Pendidikan Dasar dan Menengah. Jakarta: Balai Pustaka.
Dewa Brata, Paidi. 2007. Strategi Sukses UAN. Yogyakarta: Penerbit Andi. Djayanti, Asfani. 2012. An Error Analysis of the Use of Simple Sentence Made by the
Ninth Grade Students of SMP Negeri 2 Pancur Batu. Medan: Faculty of Cultural Studies USU.
Dwi W, Elan. 2005. Modern English Grammar. Yogyakarta: PustakaPelajar. Ellis, Rod. 1985. Understanding Second Language Acquisition . Hong Kong :
Oxford University Press Gardner and Lambert .1972. Attitudes , Motivation, and Second Language Learning.
London : Ontorio University Press L. Blommfield. 1995. Language Bahasa. Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama
63 Lado, Robert. 1961. Language Testing: The Construction and Use of Foreign
Language Tests. London : Longman Group Limited. Larsen, Diane F. 1986. Techniques and Principles in Language Teaching. New
York: Oxford University Press. Nawawi, H. 1993. Metode Penelitian Bidang Sosial. Yogyakarta: Gajah Mada
University Press Nurkancana, Wayan and P. P. N. Sumartana. 1986. Evaluasi Pendidikan. Surabaya:
Usaha Nasional. Oller, John W. 1979. Language Test at School. London: Longman Group Ltd.
Prambandari. 2008. An Analysis On Primary School Students’ Ability To Use Personal Pronouns: A Case Study On The Sixth Year Students Of SDN NO.
101878 Tg. Moraw. Medan Richard, J.C. 1974. Error Analysis Prespective on Second Language Acquisition.
London: Longman Group.----------------. 1985. Longman Dictionary of Applied Linguistic. Burnt Mill: Longman.
Robbins, Stephen P. 2007. Perilaku Organisasi Organizational Behaviour. Jakarta : Penerbit Salemba Empat.
Schneider, Edgar W. 2011. English Around The World : An Introduction. New York: Cambridge University Press
Setiawan Djuharie, Otong. 2002. Bimbingan Pemantapan BAHASA INGGRIS. Bandung: YramaWidya.
Sudijono, Anas. 1991. Pengantar Statistik Pendidikan. Rajawali Pers. Jakarta. Trask, R. L. 1999. Languange the Basic. London: Routledges
Wikipedia. online, http:en.wikipedia.orgwikiData:modified on May 23, 2015
36 subjects. Next, the researcher prepared a multiple choice test before being taught and
then the researcher taught the subject of elliptical in front of the class. And after that, did the test again after being taught . And the last, the researcher used descriptive
method to describe all the point that involved by each learners. Then the researcher made the result test of the learners. The researcher combined the result of learners
test before and after being taught.
3.2 Population and Sample
The word “population” might mean differently in different situation or context. Based on The Oxford Advance Learner’s Dictionary 1974 : 649, it
explains that, “ population is the member of the people living in a place, country, etc or a special section of them.” According the quotation above, the population of a
country is people, but the population of a research can be people, social phenomena, language, and any other things, which may be relevant to the study. In this case,
population is a group of individual or item to be studied. Sample was used as an object to represent the population. It was impossible
for the researcher to take all population to be the object of this thesis. Therefore, the researcher took some learners as samples and informants. The sample of this thesis is
grade IX of “Bimbel Medica” learners on Jl.Iskandar Muda no 19A Medan.
3.3 The Techniques of Collecting Data
In order to collect the data, the researcher did some steps. first, researcher collected the data by using observation and test. These two steps have their own
advantages. By doing observation the researcher knew about the learners problems in elliptical sentences. By giving the test, the researcher got the data based on their
37 ability in mastering English elliptical construction. In fact, if someone do a research
without using any technique of collecting the data, it will be impossible to complete the analysis.
3.4 Data Collection Procedure
According to Wikipedia, “Data is a set of values of qualitative or quantitative variables; restated, pieces of data are individual pieces of information. Data is
measured, collected and reported, and analyzed, where upon it can be visualized using graphs or images.” It means that data is instrument for researcher to measure,
reported and analyzed to be information in answering questions of problem and making conclusion and suggestion.
Based on the explanation above, library research was done to find the theory of ability and grammar in compiling information of data related of literature. Then,
field research was done when collecting data from “Bimbel Medica” for analyzing the learners’ ability.
In analyzing the problem, some baseline data was needed that represent learner’s ability by giving them a grammar test. It was done by the grade IX of
“Bimbel Medica” learners by giving them 30 questions of multiple choice. In scoring the test, it was given one point for one question. So, there are 30 questions which are
conducted in 60 minutes. It was enough because Lado 1961:20 says, “We must test in one hour what has been learned in a month or a year or five years”.
Then, the researcher arranged the test as follows : 1. Test on the use of positive elliptical, number 1-10 in multiple choice
2. Test on the use of negative elliptical , number 11-20 in multiple choice
38 3. Test on the use of opposite ellipitical, number 21-30 in multiple choice
In this research, the test had been given to them which should be filled by thirty learners who were selected at random. After doing the test, the answer-sheets
were collected.
3.5 Technique of Data Analysis
After collecting the baseline data, several steps were used to analyze the data
as follow :
1. First, scoring the pre test and post test with use the formula of Nurkancana and
Sumartana 1986 as follow :
N =
�′ � .�
. 100 N :
The outcomes of the learners’ answer
X’ : The result of correct answer
X : The number of learners
Y : The number of question
In finding the average level of learners competency, the researcher categorizes the score into five levels, they are as follows:
Excellent 90-100
Very Good 80-89
Good 70-79
Bad 60-69
Very Bad 0-59
39 2.
Then, the list of data was reconstituted the composition of list from the highest to the smallest score. It was needed to tabulate the scores of each student firstly. In
scoring the test, the researcher used the formula of Nurkancana and Sumartana 1986 as follow :
� =
R N
In which: X = Individual score
R = The number of correct answers N = Number of questions
3. Then, it is needed to find the percentage of number of learners get score
≥ 60, number of learners get score 60 and also to find the percentage of the
classification of the learners’ ability in answering the test will be calculated by using some formulas of Sudijono 1991:41 as follows:
First, find out the mean score of the learners’ ability in mastering English elliptical sentences, it was calculated by using this following formula:
� �
=
∑� � ∑�
In which: �� = The average level of the learners
∑ �� = The total of score ∑ � = The total of learners
40 After that, find the percentage of the classification of the learners’ ability in
answering the test will be calculated by using the formula
P=
� �
x 100 In which:
P = percentage f = number of frequency
n = Total numbers of respondents 4.
To categorize the level of the learners’ ability of mastering English elliptical
construction, the following scale is used:
Table 3.1 Learners’ Score Range in “Bimbel Medica”
Adapted from KKM Minimum
Standard Scores of English
subject Categories
Score
Excellent 90-100
Very Good 80-89
Good 70-79
Bad 60-69
Very Bad 0-59
41
CHAPTER IV ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
4.1 Data Analysis
As it had mentioned in the third chapter, the researcher carry on the field research. In this analysis, the data was collected from grade IX of “Bimbel Medica” learners at Jl.
Iskandar Muda no.19A Medan. Researcher had taken 30 learners randomly from three classes. Each class consisted of 10 learners. In testing their ability, researcher gave 30
questions.
The researcher gave a multiple choice test, which was focused on elliptical sentences. This test consisted of 30 questions, each of elliptical sentences had certain
42 questions; for positive elliptical, it had ten questions of multiple choice test, negative
elliptical had ten questions of multiple choice test and opposite elliptical had ten questions of multiple choice test. The researcher put the questions at random as it can
be seen below.
Table 4.1 Elliptical Sentences function and each questions
No Type of Elliptical
Sentences Multiple Choice
Number of Items
1 Positive elliptical
1-10 10
2 Negative elliptical
11-20 10
3
Opposite elliptical 21-30
10
First, it was needed to tabulate the scores of learners’ data. In scoring the test, the researcher used the formula of Nurkancana and Sumartana 1986
technique of data analysis : The formula:
N =
X ′
X .Y
x 100
N : the outcomes of the learners’ answer
X’: the result of correct answer
X : the number of learners
Y : the number of question
43 In finding the average level of learners competency, the researcher categorize the
score into five levels, they are as follows:
Excellent 91-100
Very Good 80-89
Good 71-79
Bad 60-70
Very Bad 0-59
Table 4.2 The Result of Positive Elliptical Construction Pre Test Number of question
A B
C D
True answer
1 25
A 2
5 2
23 C
3 22
3 5
A 4
26 3
1 A
5 19
6 2
3 A
6 20
2 A
7 3
15 2
7 B
8 18
2 6
2 A
9 14
2 3
A 10
24 A
44 N
1
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student X . number of question Y
x 100 =
206 30 .10
x 100 = 68,7
Table 4.3 The Result of Positive Elliptical Construction Post Test Number of question
A B
C D
True answer
1 30
A 2
2 2
26 C
3 23
3 4
A 4
25 3
1 A
5 24
1 2
3 A
6 24
2 1
3 A
7 3
23 2
B 8
21 2
6 1
A 9
25 2
3 A
10 30
A
N
2
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student X . number of question Y
x 100 =
251 30 .10
x 100 = 83,7
So, ��
avarage
=
�� + �2 2
=
68,7 + 83,7 2
45
=
76 rounded From the table and the result above, researcher had known that most of the learners
could answer positive elliptical construction questions correctly. The score is 76, it means that the ability of the learners in mastering positive construction question is
“good”. Table 4.4 The Result of Negative Elliptical Construction Pre Test
Number of question A
B C
D True
answer 11
9 3
3 15
D 12
1 24
3 2
B 13
4 2
22 2
C 14
13 16
1 A
15 13
2 3
12 D
16 8
5 3
14 D
17 24
D 18
22 D
19 2
22 D
20 25
B
N
1
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student Y . number of question Y
x 100 =
193 30 .10
x 100 = 64,3
Table 4.5 The Result of Negative Elliptical Construction Post Test
46
Number of question A
B C
D True
answer 11
5 25
D 12
27 B
13 6
2 20
2 C
14 24
1 5
A 15
8 2
23 D
16 8
5 3
22 D
17 3
2 25
D 18
2 3
25 D
19 2
27 D
20 28
B
N
2
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student Y . number of question Y
x 100 =
247 30 .10
x 100 = 82,3
So, ��
avarage
=
�� + �2 2
=
64,3 + 82,3 2
=
73 rounded From the table and the result above, researcher had been known that most of
the learners can answer negative elliptical construction questions correctly. The score is 73, it means that the ability of the learners in mastering negative elliptical
construction question is “good”.
47
Table 4.6 The Result of Opposite Elliptical Construction Pre Test
Number of question A
B C
D True
answer 21
30 A
22 2
2 2
24 D
23 22
2 3
3 A
24 7
3 23
C 25
13 12
3 2
B 26
8 5
3 14
D 27
24 1
5 A
28 23
4 3
A 29
22 8
C 30
30 A
N
2
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student X . number of question Y
x 100 =
224 30 .10
x 100 = 74,7
Table 4.7 The Result of Opposite Elliptical Construction Post Test
Number of question A
B C
D True
answer 21
30 A
22 1
2 27
D 23
28 2
3 3
A 24
30 C
48
25 26
2 2
B 26
1 3
26 D
27 28
1 1
A 28
30 A
29 20
10 C
30 30
A
N
2
=
result of correct answer X ′
number of student X . number of question Y
x 100 =
275 30 .10
x 100 = 91,7
So, ��
avarage
=
�� + �2 2
=
74,7 + 91,7 2
=
83 rounded From the table and the result above, researcher had known most of the learners
who can answer the opposite elliptical construction questions correctly. The score is 83, it means that the ability of the learners in mastering opposite elliptical
construction question is “very good”. Moreover, researcher can said that the learners
find it more easier in answer opposite elliptical construction question than other type of questions.
For the purpose, it is first needed to tabulate the scores of each student firstly. In scoring the test, the researcher used the formula of Nurkancana and Sumartana
1986 as follows : X = R x 100
49
N
In which: X = Individual score
R = The number of correct answers N = Number of questions
Table 4.8 are arranged based on the result of scoring the test and on the highest to the smallest to distribute learners’ scores in sequence as follows.
Table 4.8 The Highest to the Smallest Scores
No. Name of the Learners
Total the Correct SCORE
X Pre Test
Post Test average
1. Delima Pardede
30 30
30 100
2. Jewel Mendagi
30 30
30 100
3. Joyce Bintang
27 30
28.5 95
4. Ega Malinda
26 30
28 93
5. Yolanda A S
25 30
27.5 91
6. Afri Damayanti
24 30
27 90
7. Jesica Ziliwu
24 29
26.5 88
8. Galang Topan P
23 28
25.5 85
9. Devi Ratu A
22 28
25 83
10. Andi Kurnia
24 26
25 83
11. Syaiful Fathah
24 26
25 83
12. Syarifah Fauziah
24 26
25 83
13. T. Rahmad Putra
23 26
24.5 82
14 Ester Juliana P
23 25
24 80
50 15
Daniel T B Panjaitan 23
25 24
80 16
Albert Sam Owen 22
25 23.5
78 17
Hesron 22
25 23.5
78 18
Harten 21
25 23
76 19
Monica S P 21
25 23
76 20
Gabriel Peluhisa G 20
24 22
73 21
Vania I A Pelawi 20
24 22
73 22
Andrean Purba 19
24 21.5
72 23
Ade Jeremy Munthe 18
24 21
70 24
Ruspita Sari 18
22 20
68 25
Swandi Pakpahan 17
22 19.5
65 26
Ramona Octavia 17
22 19,5
65 27
Jumpa Agung 17
21 19
63 28
Rizki Adimanatap R 17
20 18,5
62 29
Kristian Abraham 15
18 16.5
55 30
Gidion I Silalahi 14
16 15
50 31
TOTAL 672
756 714
� � = 2340
The scores of the learners were converted to percentages by dividing the total correct answer with the number of all items and multiplied by 100 that is:
Outcomes of the scoreN =
total of correct answer X ′
number of student X . number of question Y
x 100
=
714 30 .30
x 100
51 = 79,3
The percentage of the whole score is 79,3. This percentage implies that the learners are able to answer elliptical Construction question.
4.2 Research Findings
After analyzing the data, table 4.9 described the ability of grade IX “Bimbel Medica” learners in mastering elliptical sentences in the multiple choice test with
tabulating their grade and the percentage.
Table 4.9 The learners’ Score in Using Elliptical Sentence No
Score for each student X
Frequency x
Fx
1 100
2 200
2 95
1 95
3 93
1 93
4 91
1 91
5 90
1 90
6 88
1 88
7 85
1 85
8 83
4 332
9 82
1 82
10 80
2 160
11 78
2 156
12 76
2 152
52 13
73 2
146 14
72 1
72 15
70 1
70 16
68 1
68 17
65 2
130 18
63 1
63 19
62 1
62 20
55 1
55 21
50 1
50
TOTAL ∑f = 30
∑f x = 2340
Based on the table 4.9, it was found that the frequency was 30 and total score was 2340. Then, to find out the mean score of the learners’ ability in using elliptical
sentences, it was calculated by using this following formula:
� �
=
∑� � ∑�
� �
=
2340 30
=78 The average level of the learners’ competency is 78, Therefore the
competency of grade IX “Bimbel Medica” Jl. Iskandar Muda No 19A medan in
mastering elliptical Construction can be categories into “Good.”
Then, it is needed to find the percentage of number of learners get score ≥ 60,
number of learners get score 60 and also to find the percentage of the classification
53 of the learners’ ability in answering the test will be calculated by using the formula
of Sudijono 1991:41 as follows: P=
� �
x 100
Then, the researcher tabulate the classification of learners’ score based on Minimum Standard Scores of English subject that can be seen at Table 4.10.
Table 4.10 The Result of Learners’ Score in Mastering English Elliptical Construction
Classification Frequency
Percentage Level of
Ability Range
Excellent 90-100
6 20
Very Good 80-89
9 30
Good 70-79
8 26,6
Bad 60-69
5 16,7
Very Bad 0-59
2 6,7
Total 30
100
From the table 4.10, it shows that 6 learners 20 of the respondents have
excellent ability, 9 learners 30 of the respondents have very good ability, 8
learners 26,6 of the respondents have good ability, 5 learners 16,7 of the respondents have bad ability and 2 learners 6,7 of the respondents have very
bad ability .
54 Based on classification criteria Table4.10 above, then reassembled each
learners ability level as in table 4.11 as follows.
Table 4.11 The Learners’ Level of Ability in Mastering English Elliptical Construction
No Name
Total Score
X Level of Ability
1 Delima Pardede
30 100
Excellent
2 Jewel Mendagi
30 100
Excellent
3 Joyce Bintang
28.5 95
Excellent
4 Ega Malinda
28 93
Excellent
5 Yolanda A S
27.5 91
Excellent
6 Afri Damayanti
27 90
Excellent
7 Jesica Ziliwu
26.5 88
Very good
8 Galang Topan P
25.5 85
Very good
9 Devi Ratu A
25 83
Very good
10 Andi Kurnia
25 83
Very good
11 Syaiful Fathah
25 83
Very good
12 Syarifah Fauziah
25 83
Very good
13 T. Rahmad Putra
24.5 82
Very good
14 Ester Juliana P
24 80
Very good
15 Daniel T B Panjaitan
24 80
Very good
16 Albert Sam Owen
23.5 78
Good
17 Hesron
23.5 78
Good
55 18
Harten 23
76 Good
19 Monica S P
23 76
Good
20 Gabriel Peluhisa G
22 73
Good
21 Vania I A Pelawi
22 73
Good
22 Andrean Purba
21.5 72
Good
23 Ade Jeremy Munthe
21 70
Good
24 Ruspita Sari
20 68
Bad
25 Swandi Pakpahan
19.5 65
Bad
26 Ramona Octavia
19,5 65
Bad
27 Jumpa Agung
19 63
Bad
28 Rizki Adimanatap R
18,5 62
Bad
29 Kristian Abraham
16.5 55
Very bad
30 Gidion I Silalahi
15 50
Very bad
Total 2340
Mean 78
From the Table 4.12, it can be reviewed that the distribution of learners’ ability could be concluded as follows:
Table 4.12 Chart of Learners’ Ability in Mastering English Elliptical Construction
56 According to the chart above, it was found that the ability of grade IX
“Bimbel Medica” learners , could be stated as follows: •
6 learners 20 the respondents have excellent ability in mastering English elliptical construction
• 9 learners 30 the respondents have very good ability in mastering
English elliptical construction •
8 learners 26,6 the respondents have good ability in mastering English elliptical construction
• 5 learners 16,7 the respondents have bad ability in mastering
English elliptical construction •
2 learners 6,7 the respondents have very bad ability in mastering English elliptical construction
Based on the data analysis, it was found that the ability of grade IX “Bimbel Medica” learners in mastering English elliptical construction
76
,6 of the grade IX “Bimbel Medica” learners have high capability in mastering
20 30
26,6
16,7
6,7 5
10 15
20 25
30 35
Percentage excellent ability
very good ability good ability
bad ability very bad ability
57 English Elliptical Construction. 23,4 out of the grade IX “Bimbel Medica”
learners have standard capability in mastering English elliptical construction. Moreover, researcher could say that the result of process teaching and
learning English as a second language in mastering English elliptical
construction was “Good” based on the result of the data analysis.
Finally, the researcher could find the problems of grade IX “Bimbel Medica” learners in mastering English elliptical construction or elliptical
sentences by distributing questionnaire with some items are as follows : 1.
Did you learn the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences ? a.
Yes b.
No c.
I did know 2.
Is the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences learned with excercises ?
a. Yes
b. No
c. I do not know
3. Do you think the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences is
difficult to understand ? a.
Difficult to understand b.
Easy to understand c.
I do not know 4.
If there, what are the difficult to understand the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences ?
a. The patterns kinds of elliptical sententences
58 b.
The vocabularies understanding meaning c.
Nothing 5.
Can you understand when the elliptical construction or elliptical sentences given in one meeting ?
a. Yes
b. No
c. I do not know
Table 4.13 The Result of Quistionnaire Items No
Items Answers
percentage Explanation
A B
C 1
Did you learn the Elliptical construction or elliptical
sentences ? 66,7
25 8,3
Choosing A greater than B and
C
2 Is the Elliptical construction or
elliptical sentences learned with excercises ?
8,3 66,7
25 Choosing B greater
than A and C
3 Do you think the elliptical
construction or elliptical sentences is difficult to
understand ? 83,3
6,7 10
Choosing A greater than B and
C
4 If there, what are the difficult to
understand the elliptical 26,7
63,3 10
Choosing B greater than A and C
59 construction or elliptical
sentences ?
5 Can you understand when the
elliptical construction or elliptical sentences given in one
meeting ? 5
83,3 11,7 Choosing B greater
than A and C
Processed from Questionnaire
60
CHAPTER V CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
5.1 Conclusions
After having analyzed the data thoroughly, researcher would like to draw some conclusions, they are:
a. From the test that the researcher have given to the Medica learners, the average
score of the grade IX learners is 78 . Accordingly, it can be said that the ability of grade IX Medica learners in mastering English elliptical construction
is “Good”. The result of the test also shows that the process of teaching and
learning English grammar is good too at “Bimbel Medica” Jl. Iskandar Muda Medan. Majority of the learners understand about elliptical construction well, it
is around 76,6 b.
The problems of the learners are lack of vocabularies, they do not understand about the kinds of elliptical construction and how to use it in English sentence,
especially in conversation.
5.2 Suggestions
Having seen the result of the study, the researcher would like to offer some suggestions as follows.
a. Researcher expects English tutor in “Bimbel Medica” should improve their
English teaching process especially about English grammar. b.
The grade IX “Bimbel Medica” learners should be encouraged to study English more seriously because it is very important for their future.
61 c.
The learners should do more practices and familiarize themselves with examinations, so that they could get more good result in UN ujian nasional
especially for English subject. d.
The learners should be diligent enough to read various English texts, in order to improve and enrich their English vocabulary and English grammar.
8
CHAPTER II REVIEW OF LITERATURE
This research is based on some linguistic theories proposed by some prominent linguists. As the researcher have researched, there has not been any
previous analysis about elliptical construction. In relation to review of the related literature, the following books and websites are consulted as the secondary sources to
find out some supportive data and information : Understanding Second Language Acquisition 1985 by Rod Ellis that
contains about how to understand second language acquisition in describing theory of SLA and giving examples to research. In this book, it is found that in acquiring
SLA has also meant acquiring the grammar of SLA, so that learner should be able to develop grammatical knowledge. This basic explanation help me in providing this
research. Techniques and Principles in Language Teaching 1986 by Diane Larsen
Freeman. Diane Larsen Freeman’s book contains some methods in language teaching and giving some techniques in learners about the learning of English. In this
book, the direct method is found that become the basic methods of learning English, especially in course design.
Bimbingan Pemantapan BAHASA INGGRIS 2002 by Otong Setiawan Djuharie describes about the kind of grammar with the explanation and also
exercises to help learners in understanding grammar. It is used to construct a questionnaire in testing learners’ ability.
An Error Analysis of the Use of Simple Sentence Made by the Ninth Grade Students of SMP Negeri 2 Pancur Batu a thesis by Djayanti 2012 . Those studies
also have been one of the references to make further analysis on this investigating.
9 An Analysis on Primary School Students’ Ability to Use Personal Pronouns:
A Case Study on The Sixth Year Students of SDN No. 101878 Tg. Morawa by Prambandari 2008, is another research that describes about the students’ ability in
uses personal pronouns. The writer assumed that in general there are is still many language problems especially grammatical problems.
An Error Analysis of The Use of Using Present Tense Made By Students of Second Year Junior High School of Madrasah Tsanawiyah Al Wasliyah 16
Perbaungan a thesis by Achirani 2011 describe about testing learners to find out about errors in grammar. Those researches have become a reference to make a
further analysis in my study.
2.1 Ability
According to Oxford Dictionary 2000:2, “Ability is the fact that somebodysomething is able to do something.”It means that someone measure from
what shehe could do something with the ability shehe has. If someone has ability then shehe is considered to be doing something effectively or its contrary. Such
thing can be obtained by way of learning and practicing continuously. According to Robbins 2007:58 capability consists of two factors, namely:
1. Intellectual ability that the skills needed to perform a variety of mental activity-thinking, reasoning and problem solving.
2. Physical ability is the ability to perform tasks that require stamina, skill, strength,and similar characteristics.
Carroll 1993 an influental psychologist in the field of educational linguistics divided the four ability components are as follows :
10 1.
Phonetic coding ability is ability to perceive distinct sounds, associate a symbol with that sound and retain that association.
2. Grammatical memory is ability to recognize the grammatical function of a
lexical element word, phrase, etc in a sentence without explicit training in grammar.
3. Associative memory is ability to learn associations between words in foreign
language and their meanings and retain that association. 4.
Inductive learning ability is ability to infer or induce rules governing the structure of a language.
2.1.1 Factors of Ability
According to Ellis 1985, there are several factors which may affect a persons ability in learning a foreign language :
1. Personal Factors are divided into three parts as follows :
a Group dynamics
Differences inabilitylevel of different learners in understanding a foreign language that trigger competitiveness among learners. This competition encourages
students to be able to master a foreign language with active learning in the classroom or even suppress the learners a sense of mistrust in studying a foreign language.
b Attitudes to the teacher and course material
The role of the teacher in the class in applying the teaching style to the student and teaching materials are used by learners also affect learners ability to
learn a foreign language. Mostly student prefer to use their own learning paths, such
11 as student-student interaction in the class or democratic teaching style. Learners also
prefer to use a variety of materials than a coursebook. c
Individual learning techniques Some learners push themselves to be able to use a foreign language by using
their own learning techniques, such as preparing and memorizing vocabulary lists, looking dictionary, learning word in context means learners pick up some vocabulary
from paragraph that usually used in context, and practising vocabulary means use vocabulary in a sentence, conversation, playing games, etc.
2. General Factors are divided into :
a Age
Ellis 1985 says, “...children are better language learners than adults.”It means that the level of language acquisition at childhood better than adult hood.
Because they lack of ability in language learning. Although there are adults who are able to learn the language.
b Intelligence and aptitude
Intelligence and aptitude influence the ability in learning L2. Learner who has high level in intelligence and aptitude is able to understand the use of L2 rapidly
especially in formal teaching method in some skills such as reading comprehension, dictation, and free writing, but much less of in naturalistic SLA Second Language
Acquisition. c
Cognitive style Cognitive style is a term to use the manner in which people perceive,
conceptualize, organize, and recall information. It talk about the process in receiving
12 the information understanding of SLA. How the learners able to understand the
foreign language and use practically, such as in communication and testing. d
Attitude and Motivation Gardner and Lambert 1972 define ‘motivation’ in terms of the L2 learner’s
overall goal or orientation, and ‘attitude’ as the persistence shown by the learner in striving for a goal. If the learners have more or less motivation in learning L2, it will
be shown in their attitude. Gardner and Lambert divide motivation into integrative and instumental. Integrative motivation occurs for learner who want to maintain their
mother tongue when they learn a L2. It means they naturally learn L2 in acquiring some knowledge. Instrumental motivation occurs for learners who want to learning
L2 for functional, such as passing an examination, furthering career opportunities or facilitating study of other subjects.
e Personality
Personality refers to personal traits. In pshycology, personality is divided into : -
Extroversion and Introversion : Extrovert learn L2 rapidly than introvert because they have more contact with others. The more we have contact with
other individual, the more we can use language practically and become habitual.
- Social skills : there are seven social styles but only ‘talkativeness’ and
responsiveness’ which could make easier in learning L2 rapidly because they have interact with others in using L2 practically.
13 -
Inhibition : Inhibition is negative factor that determine the way of the learners in taking risk while learning L2 and turn leads to increased self-consciousness
of learners in learning L2.
2.2 Grade IX
In Indonesia, grade IX is the third grade in Junior High School. learners are typically 14 or 15 years old. They also learn about English especially grammar. In
“Bimbel Medica”, there are some classes of grade IX that have been divided as randomized controlled trial, because grade IX learners come from different schools.
2.3 Elliptical Construction
In this chapter, the writer would like to discuss about elliptical construction or elliptical sentence. There are some definitions about what is elliptical construction.
An elliptical clause a form of elliptical construction is a clause in which some words have been omitted. www. Ensiclopedia.com. In the grammar of a sentence,
an elliptical construction is a construction that lacks an element that is, nevertheless, recoverable or inferable from the context. The elliptical construction is a sequence of
words in which some words have been omitted. Because of the logic or pattern of the entire sentence, it is easy to infer what the missing words are.
An elliptical sentence does not mean a sentence with an ellipsis in it. An ellipsis is three periods, symbolizing missing information. This form most often
appears when using only part of a direct quote. An elliptical sentence refers to sentences with information missing. This form does not require an ellipsis. These
sentences are grammatically correct only if the necessary information to understand the sentence has been supplied previously or is clear from the context of the
sentence.
14 Actually elliptical construction is not only using in writing but it’s also often be
used in dialogue to shorten what is being said. For examples :
1. Tony : “ I want to go home, and you ?” Rony : “me too”.
2. Ria : “I like ice cream very much”. Yuni : “so do I”.
3. X : “ My uncle went to Bandung last week”. Y: “ So did my father”
4. Riri : “I had bought a new motorcycle last year”. Yuyun : “I had too”.
5. Rika : “ I don’t want to stay here”. Feni: “ Neither do I”.
6. X: “My mother can’t speak Frence, and how about yours?” Y: “ My mother doesn’t either”.
7.Rio : “ My father doesn’t watch tv in the morning”. Ria : “ My mother doesn’t either”.
8.Rika : “ She has found a lovely dress”. Mira : “ But I haven’t”.
9. X : “ She has not a good boy friend”. Y : “ But I have ”.
10. Rio : “ I can drive a motor cycle to around the world”. Ria : “ But I can’t”.
There are three kinds of the elleptical contruction that will be discussed in this thesis :
15 1. Positive elliptical construction
2. Negative elliptical construction 3. Opposite elliptical construction
2.3.1. Positive Elliptical
Positive elliptical is used in positive sentence to combine two positive sentences inwhere the sentence has the same verb and object. To make the two
sentences simply the learners can put conjunction and add with word ‘So’ and ‘Too’. For example:
- Mira goes to school everyday. - Rina goes to school everyday.
• The two sentences can be combine into :
- Mira goes to school everyday and so does Rina, or - Mira goes to school and Rina does too.
The important part that is must be carefully is about To be or auxiliary verb because It is always changes based on the tenses.
Explanation: From the example above ‘Mira goes to school everyday’ is as main clause and ‘so does Rina’ or ‘Rina does too’ is as next statement.
The example of elliptical construction in some tenses The pattern is :
S + V + O + and so + to be auxiliary verb + S Or
S + V + O, + and + S + to be Auxiliary + too Explanation:
S = subject
16 V = verb
O = object
A. Elliptical Construction in Simple Present Tense
1. I buy a new book. She buys a new book. •
I buy a new book and so does she, or •
I buy a new book , and she does too. 2. She studies English in“Bimbel Medica”.
He studies English in “Bimbel Medica”. •
She studies English in “Bimbel Medica” and so does he, or •
She studies English in “Bimbel Medica”, and he does too. 3. They are smart learners in Indonesia. We are smart learners in Indonesia.
• They are smart learners in Indonesia and so are we, or
• They are smart student in Indonesia, and we are too.
B. Elliptical Construction in Past Tense
1. She went to Bandung last month. He went to Bandung last month. •
She went to Bandung and so did he, or •
She went to Bandung, and he did too. . My mother cooked some cakes yesterday.
My aunty cooked some cakes yesterday. •
My mother cooked some cakes yesterday and so did my aunty, or 3. They saw the movie together in twenty one last nigth.
We saw the movie together in twenty one last night. •
They saw the movie together in twenty one last night and so did we, or •
They saw the movie together in twenty one last night, and we did too.
C. Elliptical Construction in Present Continuous Tense
17 1. I am thinking about this problem now.
You are thinking about this problem now. •
I am thinking about this problem now and so are you, or •
I am thinking about this problem now, and you are too. 2. They are watching TV today. We are watching TV today.
• They are watching TV today and so are we, or
• They are watching TV today, and we are too.
3. She is preparing some books for presentation at this time. He is preparing some books for presentation at this time.
• She is preparing some books for presentation at this time and so is he, or
• She is preparing some books for presentation at this time, and he is too.
D. Elliptic Construction in Past Continuous Tense
1. I was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month. He was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month.
• I was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month and so was he, or
• I was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month, and he was too.
2. Mia was reading that novel yesterday. Nini was reading that novel yesterday.
• Mia was reading that novel yesterday and so was she, or
• Mia was reading that novel yesterday, and she was too.
3. They were playing basketball together. We were playing basketball together. •
They were playing basketball together and so were we, or •
They were playing basketball together, and we were too.
18
E. Elliptic Construction in Present Future
1. I will cut the tree tomorow. He will cut the tree tomorow.
• I will cut the tree tomorow and so will he, or
• I will cut the tree tomorow, and he will too.
2. Reza will come to your house at sevent o’clock. Nila will come to your house at sevent o’clock.
• Reza will come to your house at sevent o’clock and so will she, or
• Reza will come to your house at sevent o’clock, and she will too.
3. They will breakfast with me tomorow morning. You will breakfast with me tomorow morning.
• They will breakfast with me tomorow morning and so will you, or
• They will breakfast with me tomorow morning, and you will too.
F. Elliptic Construction in Past Future Tense
1. I would say sorry to you. She would say sorry to you. •
I would say sorry to you and so would she, or •
I would say sorry to you, and she would too. 2. She would bring a new magazine yesterday.
He would bring a new magazine yesterday. •
She would bring a new magazine yesterday and so would he, or •
She would bring a new magazine yesterday, and he would too. 3. They would give a doll for you. We would give a doll for you.
• They would give a doll for you and so would we, or
• They would give a doll for you, and we would too.
19
G. Elliptic Construction with Modal Auxiliary Verb
1. I can swim well. She can swim well. •
I can swim well and so can she, or •
I can swim well, and she can too. 2. We might go to the office. I might go to the office.
• We might go to the office and so might I, or
• We might go to the office, and I might too.
3. You should take a medicine. She should take a medicine. •
You should take a medicine and so should she, or •
You should take a medicine, and she should too. 4. You must pay me more. Hari must pay me more.
• You must pay me more and so must he, or
• You must pay me more, and he must too.
5. Lia has to study hard. Ali has to study hard. •
Lia has to study hard and so have to him, or •
Lia has to study hard, and he has to too.
2.3. 2. Negative Elliptical
Negative elliptical is used in negative sentence to combine two negative sentences in where the sentence has the same verb and object. To make the two
sentences simply the learners can put conjunction and add with word ‘Neither’ and ‘Either’.
For examples: - Mira doesn’t go to school today.
- Rina doesn’t go to school today.
20 The two sentence we can combine become :
- Mira doesn’t go to school today and neither does Rina. Or - Mira doesn’t go to school today and Rina doesn’t either.
In elliptical construction the important part that is must be carefully is about To be or auxiliary verb because It is always changes based on the tenses.
Explanation: From the example above Mira doesn’t go to school today is as main clause and neither does Rina or Rina doesn’t either is as next statement.
The example of elliptical construction in some tenses The pattern is :
S + V + O, + and + neither + to be auxiliary verb + S Or
S + V + O, + and + S + to be Auxiliary + not + either Explanation:
S = subject V = verb
O = object
A.Elliptical Construction in Simple Present Tense
1. She doesn’t study English in that course. He doesn’t study English in that course.
• She doesn’t study English in that course, and neither does he. Or
• She doesn’t study English in that course, and he doesn’t either.
2. They are not smart learners in this school. We are not smart learners in this school.
• They are not smart learners in this school, and neither are we. Or
• They are smart student in this schooland, and we aren’t either.
21 3. Nobody cares about my problem. Nobody cares about your problem.
• Nobody cares about my problem, and neither do you. Or
• Nobody cares about my problem, and you don’t either.
B.Elliptical Construction in Past Tense
1. She seldom went to Bandung last month. He seldom went to Bandung last month.
• She seldom went to Bandung last month, and neither did he. Or
• She seldom went to Bandung last month, and he didn’t either.
2. They didn’t see the movie together in twenty one last nigth. We didn’t see the movie together in twenty one last night.
• They didn’t see the movie together in twenty one last night,
and neither did we. Or •
They didn’t see the movie together in twenty one last night, and we didn’t either.
3. Mira never made a beautiful dress yesterday. Gusni never made a beautiful dress yesterday.
• Mira never made a beautiful dress yesterday, and neither did Gusni. Or
• Mira never made a beautiful dress yesterday, and Gusni didn’t either.
C. Elliptical Construction in Present Continuous Tense
1. I am not thinking about this problem now. You are not thinking about this problem now.
• I am not thinking about this problem now, and neither are you. Or
• I am not thinking about this problem now, and you aren’t either.
2. They are not watching TV today. We are not watching TV today. •
They are not watching TV today, and neither are we. Or
22 •
They are not watching TV today, and we aren’t either. 3. You are rarely cleaning my house now.
She is rarely cleaning my house now. •
You are rarely cleaning my house now, and neither is she. Or •
You are rarely cleaning my house now, and she isn’t either.
D. Elliptical Construction in Past Continuous Tense
1. Noone was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month. He was not climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month.
• Noone was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month, and neither was he.Or
• Noone was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month, and he wasn’t either.
2. Mia was not reading that novel yesterday. Nini was not reading that novel yesterday.
• Mia was not reading that novel yesterday, and neither was she. Or
• Mia was not reading that novel yesterday, and she wasn’t either.
3. They were not playing basketball together. We were not playing basketball together.
• They were not playing basketball together, and neither were we. Or
• They were not playing basketball together, and we weren’t either.
E. Elliptic Construction in Present Future
1. I will not cut the tree tomorow. He will not cut the tree tomorow. •
I will not cut the tree tomorow, and neither will he. Or •
I will not cut the tree tomorow, and he won’t either. 2. Reza will not come to your house at sevent o’clock.
Nila will not come to your house at sevent o’clock.
23 •
Reza will not come to your house at sevent o’clock, and neither will she. Or
• Reza will not come to your house at sevent o’clock, and she won’t either.
3. They will not breakfast with me tomorow morning. You will not breakfast with me tomorow morning.
• They will not breakfast with me tomorow morning, and neither will you.
Or •
They will breakfast with me tomorow morning, and you won’t either.
F. Elliptical Construction in Past Future Tense
1. I would not say sorry to you. She would not say sorry to you. •
I would not say sorry to you, and neither would she. Or •
I would not say sorry to you, and she wouldn’t either. 2. She would not bring a new magazine last day.
He would not bring a new magazine last day. •
She would not bring a new magazine last day, and neither would he. Or •
She would not bring a new magazine last day, and he wouldn’t either. 3. They would not give a doll for you. We would not give a dool for you.
• They would not give a doll for you, and neither would we. Or
• They would not give a doll for you, and we wouldn’t either.
G. Elliptical Construction with Modal Auxiliary Verb
1. I never can swim well. She never can swim well. •
I never can swim well, and neither can she. Or •
I never can swim well, and she can’t either. 2. We might not go to the office.
24 I might not go to the office.
• We might not go to the office, and neither might I. Or
• We might not go to the office, and I might not too.
3. You should not go at the mid night. She should not go at the mid night. •
You should not go at the mid night, and neither should she. Or •
You should not go at the mid night, and she shouldn’t either. 4. You must not smoke here. Hari must not smoke here.
• You must not smoke here, and neither must he. Or
• You must not smoke here, and he mustn’t either.
5. Lia has not to study hard. Ali has not to study hard. •
Lia has not to study hard, and neither has to he. Or •
Lia has not to study hard, and he has not to either.
2.3.3. Opposite Elliptical
Opposite elliptical is used in two sentences that have contras meaning. Opposite entence use to combine two sentences in where the sentence has different
verb but has it bject. If the first sentence has positive meaning, so the second sentence has negative one. In opposite elliptical the learners used conjunction “and +
but” to combine that two sentences which have contras meaning. For example:
- Mira go to school today. -
Rina doesn’t go to school today. The two sentence we can combine become :
- Mira go to school today, but Rina doesn’t. In elliptical construction the important part that is must be carefully is about To
be or auxiliary verb because It is always changes based on the tenses.
25 Explanation: From the example above Mira go to school today is as main
clause, but Rina doesn’t is as next statement. The example of elliptical construction in some tenses
The pattern is: S + V + O, + BUT + S + to be auxiliary
+ - - + Explanation :
S = subject V = verb
O = object + = positive sentence
- = negative sentence
A. Elliptical construction in Simple present tense
1. I am not buy a new book. She buys a new book. •
I am not buy a new book, but she does. 2. She doesn’t study English in that course. He studies English in that course.
• She doesn’t study English in that course, but he does.
3. They are smart learners in this school. We are not smart learners in this school.
• They are smart learners in this school, but we aren’t.
B. Elliptical Construction in Past Tense
1. She didn’t go to Bandung last month. He went to Bandung last month. •
She didn’t go to Bandung last month, but he was. 2. My mother cooked some cakes yesterday.
26 My aunty didn’t cook some cakes yesterday.
• My mother didn’t cook some cakes yesterday, but my aunty did.
3. They saw the movie together in twenty one last nigth. We didn’t see the movie together in twenty one last night.
• They saw the movie together in twenty one last night, but we did.
C. Elliptical Construction in Present Continious Tense
1. I am not thinking about this problem now. You are thinking about this problem now.
• I am not thinking about this problem now, but you are. Or
2. She is preparing some books for presentation at this time. He is not preparing some books for presentation at this time.
• She is preparing some books for presentation at this time, but he isn’t.
3. You are rarely cleaning my house now. She is cleaning my house now. You are rarely cleaning my house now, but she is.
D. Elliptical Construction in Past Continuous Tense
1. I was not climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month. He was climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month.
• I was not climbing Sriwijaya mountain last month, but he was.
2. Mia was not reading that novel yesterday. Nini was reading that novel yesterday.
• Mia was not reading that novel yesterday, but she was.
3. They were playing basketball together. We were not playing basketball together.
• They were playing basketball together, but we weren’t.
E. Elliptical Construction in Present Future
27 1. I will not cut the tree tomorow. He will cut the tree tomorow.
• I will not cut the tree tomorow, but he will.
2. Reza will come to your house at sevent o’clock. Nila will not come to your house at sevent o’clock.
• Reza will come to your house at sevent o’clock, but she won’t.
3. They will breakfast with me tomorow morning. You will not breakfast with me tomorow morning.
• They will breakfast with me tomorow morning, but you won’t.
F. Elliptical Construction in Past Future Tense
1. I would not say sorry to you. She would say sorry to you. •
I would not say sorry to you, but she would . 2. She would not bring a new magazine last day.
He would bring a new magazine last day. •
She would not bring a new magazine last day, but he would. 3. They would give a doll for you. We would not give a dool for you.
• They would give a doll for you, but we would.
G. Elliptical Construction with Modal Auxiliary Verb
1. You could not smoke here. He could smoke here. •
You could not smoke here, but he could. 2. They may to see your mother. She may not to see your mother.
• They may to see your mother, but she may not.
3. You should not go at the mid night. She should go at the mid night. •
You should not go at the mid night, but she should. 4. You must not smoke here. Hari must smoke here.
• You must not smoke here, but he must.
28 5. Lia has not to study hard. Ali has to study hard.
• Lia has not to study hard, but he has to.
2.3.4. The Summary Of Elliptical Construction 1. If in the sentence use to be \ auxiliary, so we use it in next statement.
2. Nothing to be \ auxiliary is used, if verb 1 is used do or does depend on subject sentence. Verb 2 is used did.
3. There is “have” + noun is used do in next statement. 4. There is “has” + to infinitive is used does in next statement.
5. There is “had” + object is used did in next statement. 6. If the elliptical sentence use negative word such as, not, rarely, never,
nothing,nobody, no one, seldom, etc . It means the sentence is negative
sentence. Therefore, we use negative elliptical in next statement.
7. If in the sentence use modal, so we use it in next statement. 2.4
Test
According to Ellis 1985:112, the purpose of test is to measure the abilities of learners to discriminate the meaningful sounds of language, to associate sounds
with written symbols, and to identify the grammatical regularities of a language. Through the test, learners can know how good their ability in learning foreign
languages, especially in understanding grammar of elliptical sentences in order to learners can improve their performance to become expert.
Lado 1961:19 states, “.... the test taker is understood as a social being whose subjectivity is a function of subject positions realized in the test itself. From
this perspective, tests become technologies of subjectivity. The act as mechanism
29 both for the definition of subject positions and for the recognition of subjects. Tests
create the identities that they measure.”Testing need to be carried out as evidence of student learning outcomes in schools. The test taker sperform tests to examine and
determine the extent to which the student has the ability to understand grammar of elliptical sentence. The test will produce the identity of the tested person by knowing
the grouping results in a standardized test that is applicable in school. As stated by Depdikbud, Dirjen Dikti, 19831994, PPS, 15 with its
quidelines “To determine whether learners are regarded successful, at least 75 must get score 60 or more if less then 75 learners get this score, they are considered to
have failed”. Then the results of the test compared to the Department of Education
standarization. 2.4.1
Kinds of Test
According to Lado 1961:32, there are 5 type of tests as follows :
1. Translation