Recommendations Many international and national organizations
Recommendations Many international and national organizations
strongly support the provision of pasteurized donor milk to LBW infants. In contrast, many developed country neonatal units preferen- tially provide artificial infant formula rather than donor human milk to LBW infants.
Donor human milk may be a feasible option in ability of donor banks. Equipment and train- many developing countries and should be con-
ing for heat treatment and milk banking may sidered as an important alternative to artificial
be difficult to obtain in some countries. The infant formula. Feasibility of providing donor
findings from this review support these rec- human milk is influenced by the amount that
ommendations.
can be expressed by mothers and the avail-
SUMMARY TABLE 2.1.3 Effects of donor human milk compared with formula feeding on infection or necrotising enterocolitis in LBW infants
Study, Design
Approximate proportion of
(Level of Inclusion participants with gestation age a Outcome Effect measure evidence)
Comparison groups
measure [95% CI]
McGuire & Birth weight
Possible RR 0.34 Anthony (174) <1850 g.
Unsupplemented term or
pre-term drip breastmilk only necrotising [0.12, 0.99] Meta-analysis Allocated to milk
enterocolitis of RCTs (LI)
(n=167) compared with
feeds as sole diet
standard or pre-term infant formula (n=176)
Confirmed RR 0.25 necrotising
[0.06, 0.98] enterocolitis
Schanler et al Gestation <30
If supply of own mother’s milk Septicaemia OR 1.04 (178 )
[0.53, 2.05] RCT (LII)
weeks. Mothers
was insufficient, infants were
who intended to
provided with at least
breastfeed.
50 ml/kg of supplemented
Confirmed RR 0.53
pasteurized donor milk
necrotising [0.14, 1.82]
(n=81) compared with pre-
enterocolitis
term formula (n=92) from birth to day 90.
a If gestational age was not available in the publication, infants with birth weight <1500 g are assumed to be <32 wk gestation, those weighing 1501–2000 g to be 32–36 wk gestation and those weighing 2001–2500 g to have a gestation of 37 weeks or more
32 OPTIMAL FEEDING OF LOW-BIRTH-WEIGHT INFANTS: TECHNICAL REVIEW
SUMMARY TABLE 2.1.4 Effects of donor human milk compared with formula feeding on neurodevelopment in LBW infants
Study, Design
Approximate proportion of
(Level of Inclusion participants with gestation age a Effect measure evidence)
Comparison groups
Outcome measure [95% CI]
Lucas et al Birth weight
Unsupplemented term Bayley psychomotor WMD 1.20 (16)
development index [-4.4, 6.8] RCT (LII)
<1850 g, received
drip breast milk
feed as sole diet
(n=62) compared
score at 18 months
with pre-term formula (n=52)
Bayley mental WMD 0.5 development index
[-6.2, 7.1] score at 18 months
Tyson et al Birth weight
Unsupplemented term Brazelton neonatal WMD -2.50 (177)
[-3.65, -1.35] RCT (LII)
<1500 g, received
drip breast milk
behavioural
feed as sole diet
(n=34) compared
assessment scale with pre-term formula (response to inanimate (n=42)
objects) at 37 weeks gestational age
Brazelton neonatal WMD -0.80 behavioural assess-
[-1.34, -0.26] ment scale (response to auditory and visual stimuli) at 37 weeks gestational age
Lucas et al Birth weight
Bayley psychomotor WMD 8.8 (16)
Standard infant
development index [3.3, 14.3] Cohort (LIII-2) feed as sole diet
<1850 g, received
formula only
score at 18 months non-random
(n=55) compared
with unsupplemented
comparison term drip breast milk Bayley mental WMD 2.1 within two
development index [-4.4, 8.7] RCTs
only (n=62)
score at 18 months a If gestational age was not available in the publication, infants with birth weight <1500 g are assumed to be <32 wk gestation, those weighing 1501–2000 g to be 32–36 wk gestation, and those weighing 2001–2500 g to have a gestation of 37 weeks or more.
SUMMARY TABLE 2.1.5 Effects of donor human milk compared with formula feeding on feed tolerance in LBW infants
Study, Design
Approximate proportion of
(Level of Inclusion participants with gestation age a Outcome Effect measure evidence)
Comparison groups
measure [95% CI]
Feed RR 0.30 al (18 )
Henderson et Birth weight
Unsupplemented term drip
<1600 g, received breast milk (n=58) compared intolerance [0.07, 1.37] Meta-analysis feed as sole diet
with standard infant formula by hospital of RCTs (LI)
discharge a If gestational age was not available in the publication, infants with birth weight <1500 g are assumed to be <32 wk gestation, those weighing 1501–2000 g to be 32–36 wk gestation, and those weighing 2001–2500 g to have a gestation of 37 weeks or more.
(n = 70)
33
RESULTS
34 OPTIMAL FEEDING OF LOW-BIRTH-WEIGHT INFANTS: TECHNICAL REVIEW