The class begins by reading a passage in
37 oral communication
3. the ALM‟s activities includes
dialogue memorization, repetition drill, single-slot substitution drill,
chain drill, transformation drill, minimal
pairs, complete
the dialogue and grammar games;
The activities of the GTM includes reading and translating difficult
classical Latin or Greek literary passages early on in the learning,
reading comprehension questions, cognates,
synonymsantonyms, deductive application of rule, fill-
in-the-blank, memorization, use words in sentences, composition
based upon some aspect of the reading passage and elaborate
explanations on the topic that is learned
4. The ALM is more or less the same
but learners are treated as organisms that can be directed by skilled
training techniques to produce correct responses
The roles of learners in the GTM is that they are imbeciles and
therefore they just have to follow the instructions given and just
receive what is being given by the teachers
5. Teachers in ALM are also central
and active
where they
are dominating. They are like orchestra
leaders where they provides models for learners to follow, controls
direction and pace of the class, and also
conducting, guiding,
and controlling the students behavior in
the target language Teachers‟ roles in the GTM are
like tyrants or fascists where they have all the authority and that
student should get the correct answer although not all users of
this method are like that. It remains popular as it required few
specialized skills on the part of the teachers because tests of grammar
rules and translations are easy to
38 construct and can be objectively
scored 6.
ALM uses tapes and visuals where the language labs are often used
The materials used in the GTM are books and journals.
7. ALM only permitted very little use
of the mother tongue The native language are used in
teaching using the GTM 8.
The ALM counters by stressing the importance of communications
The learning in the GTM are quite tedious and little motivation are
given to go beyond grammar analogies, translations and rote
exercises 9.
The GTM can be defined as learning „the‟ language, not how to use the
language The ALM focuses on intensive
oral learning with little use of reading and writing