Review of Related Studies
Kakutani in her review states that there is a traumatic effect that causes Lisbon’s daughters to commit suicide. Kakutani says that the cause is Lisbon’s
daughters are feeling haunted by their ’s sister death. Kakutani, 199:54. This
thesis thinks that what Kakutani says is true but what makes them commit suicide is not only because of feeling scared, but there are also other factors. There is also
a research that is done by Adam Green entitled The Virgin Suicides Critical Analysis. Adam Green states that the cause of the Lisbon
’s daughters to commit suicide is because of supernatural factor. He states in his analysis that a suicide is
an extraordinary event. When someone takes their own life, especially in a tight- knit community, the support for that person’s family from the community takes
almost a supernatural form, as people with differences, and sometimes even feuds, who would never band together under normal circumstances, band together in
support. The weakness of Adam’s research, Adam still cannot answer some question. Such as
“Why?”, “Why would someone feel the need to take their own life?” “Why were their demons great enough to overpower all of the great
opportunities they would have had in life?” This thesis also thinks that Adam only focuses in the spiritual side. This thesis thinks that supernatural side is
something that is so extensive; it is why, this thesis wants to observe the basic cause of the decision to commit suicide which is more realistic.
This thesis also points out two reviews that observe character’s decision to
commit suicide. Nunung Marganingsih ’s research entitled “The Contribution of
Conflict toward Eustacia’s Decision to Commit Suicide in Thomas Hardy’s The Return of the Native, Marganingsih says that decision to commit suicide as the
contribution of the inner conflict and external conflict with other character in the novel Marganingsih: 1999: 52. In the novel, Eustacia is an all of person who
does not have parents and many friends. She is also an ambitious, arrogant, and unfaithful woman. These characteristics influenced her how to face the problem
and lead her to the conflict. Because of the conflict that she has and cannot be handled, she is depressed and drives her to commit suicide. In the novel The
Virgin Suicides, this thesis does not focus on the conflict that the characters experience, but this thesis focuses in psychological aspect. The position of conflict
is the trigger, not as the main focus. The other research by Lewi Yudianto entitled
Willy Loman’s Decision To Commit Su
icide in Arthur Miller’s Death of A Salesman, he states there that Willy Longman feels that he cannot be a good husband and father for his children
Yudianto: 1998: 48. It becomes a big problem and burdens him and affects his behavior and attitude in his daily life. He acts many stupid things and be a
temperament father. Because of his felling of failure with it all he commits suicide in the end of the story. In her research also, Yudianto states that depression is the
main cause of person to commit suicide because of self-destructive behavior, emotional, physical disturbance and withdrawal from socialization. This thesis
thinks that the difference between Yudianto’s theory and this thesis’ research is in the cause of depression.